Odyssey Marine Exploration, Inc. v. The Unidentified Shipwrecked Vessel

Filing 178

RESPONSE to motion re 131 MOTION to dismiss Amended Complaint or for summary judgment of Kindom of Spain filed by Santiago de Alvear, Emilio de Alvear, Maria Eugenia Solveyra, Alejandro Julian Pera Barthe', Agustina Solveyra, Ignacio Solveyra. (McLaughlin, John)

Odyssey Marine Exploration, Inc. v. The Unidentified Shipwrecked Vessel

Doc. 178

fk=qeb=rkfqba=pq^qbp=afpqof`q=`lroq= jfaaib=afpqof`q=lc=cilofa^= q^jm^=afsfpflk=
= = =

fk=^ajfo^iqv=

lavppbv=j^ofkb=bumilo^qflkI=fk`K= =
=

mδ~αεναΡΡI=

=

`fsfi=^`qflk=

= == qeb=rkfabkqfcfbaI=pefmtob`hba== sbppbiI=αΡ=~εσI=ανλ=~ιι~κΙδI=ν~ΕβδΙI== ~ιιμκνΙε~εΕΙλ=~εΗ=Ε~κΦη=δηΕ~νΙΗ=οανάαε=~== ΡαξΙ=γαδΙ=κ~Ηαμλ=ηΡ=νάΙ=ΕΙενΙκ=ιηαεν=ΕηJ= ηκΗαε~νΙλ=ικηξαΗΙΗ=νη=νάΙ=`ημκν=μεΗΙκ=λΙ~δI=
=

`~λΙ=kηK=UWlTJ`sJMMSNQJpajJj^m=

== ==
= = = = =

= =

aΙΡΙεΗ~ενI= fε=oΙγ=

^εΗ= qάΙ=hαεΦΗηγ=ηΡ=pι~αε=~εΗ=νάΙ=oΙιμΔδαΕ=ηΡ=mΙκμI= == ^εΗ= dηες~δη=ΗΙ=^δα~Φ~=EνάΙ=`ημεν=ηΡ=p~ε=gμ~ε=ΗΙ=iμκαΦ~εΕάηFI= ^Φμλναε=ΗΙ=^δα~Φ~=EνάΙ=ΕμκκΙεν=j~κθμΙλ=ΗΙ=wΙδ~Η~=ΗΙ=δ~= cμΙενΙFI=dηες~δη=^δξ~κΙς=ΗΙδ=sαδδ~κI=gΦε~Εαη=ΗΙ= `ηδγΙε~κΙλ=EνάΙ=NNνά=`ημεν=ηΡ=mηδΙεναεηλFI=^δΔΙκνη=bγαδαη= qάαΙλλΙεI=bεκαθμΙν~=mαν~=aμνάμκΔμκμI=cδηκ~=iΙηεηκ=mΙκ~δΙλ= `~δΗΙκηε=ΗΙ=`ηδγΙε~κΙλI=cΙδαιΙ=sησΙλνI=^ΗΙδ~=^κγαΗ~=ΗΙ= fςΕμΙ=_~ςηI=`~κηδ~=a~ακΙ~μρ=hαελβσI=bδΙηεηκ~=a~ακΙ~μρ= hαελβσI=j~ναδΗΙ=a~ακΙ~μρ=hαελβσI=gμδαη=sΙΦ~=bμκ~λθμαεI= δεΙς=j~κθμΙς=lληκαηI=g~ξαΙκ=Ηη=dησΙεΙΕάΙ=EνάΙ=ΕμκκΙεν= `ημεν=ηΡ=dμ~θμα=~εΗ=j~κθμΙλ=ΗΙ=sαδδ~ΡμΙενΙFI=
= =

=

`δ~αγ~ενλX=

^εΗ== p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=bγαδαη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI= j~κ~=bμΦΙεα~=pηδξΙσκ~I=^δΙΰ~εΗκη=gμδ~ε=mΙκ~=_~κνά¨I= ^Φμλναε~=pηδξΙσκ~I=~εΗ=fΦε~Εαη=pηδξΙσκ~= = == = `δ~αγ~ενλK= ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||L=
=

abp`bka^kq=`i^fj^kqpI=p^kqf^dl=ab=^isb^oI=bjfifl=ab=^isb^oI=j^oπ^= brdbkf^=plisbvo^I=^ibg^kaol=griπ^k=mbo^=_^oqe°I=^drpqfk^=plisbvo^I= ^ka=fdk^`fl=plisbvo^I=obpmlkpb=ql=qeb=hfkdalj=lc=pm^fkΫp=jlqflk=ql= afpjfpp=lo=clo=prjj^ov=gradjbkq=

Dockets.Justia.com

=

= `δ~αγ~ενλI=p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=bγαδαη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=j~κ~=bμΦΙεα~=pηδξΙσκ~I=^δΙΰ~εΗκη=

gμδ~ε=mΙκ~=_~κνά¨I=^Φμλναε~=pηδξΙσκ~I=~εΗ=fΦε~Εαη=pηδξΙσκ~I=ΰηαε=αε=νάΙ=κΙλιηελΙ=ΡαδΙΗ=ηε= ΔΙά~δΡ=ηΡ=νάΙ=Εδ~αγ~ενλI=dηες~δη=ΗΙ=^δα~Φ~I=Ιν=~δK=νη=pι~αεΫλ=jηναηε=νη=aαλγαλλ=ηκ=Ρηκ= pμγγ~κσ=gμΗΦγΙενK==tανά=νάΙ=ΙρΕΙιναηε=ηΡ=pι~αε=~εΗ=mΙκμI=~δδ=ηνάΙκ=Εδ~αγ~ενλ=~κΙ= ΗΙλΕΙεΗ~ενλ=ηΡ=ικαξ~νΙ=αεΗαξαΗμ~δλ=οάηλΙ=ΦηηΗλ=οΙκΙ=λάαιιΙΗ=~Δη~κΗ=νάΙ=jΙκΕΙΗΙλK==fν= ΗηΙλ=εην=~ιιΙ~κ=νη=ΔΙ=ΗαλιμνΙΗ=Δσ=pι~αε=νά~ν=νάΙ=jΙκΕΙΗΙλ=ο~λ=Ε~κκσαεΦ=ικαξ~νΙδσ=ηοεΙΗ= Ε~κΦη=οάΙε=λάΙ=λ~εβ=αε=NUMQK==lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ=bριδηκ~ναηεI=fεΕK=ά~λ=εην=Δσ=νάΙακ=λ~δξ~ΦΙ= ΙΡΡηκνλ=κΙΕηξΙκΙΗ=νάΙ=ξΙλλΙδ=jΙκΕΙΗΙλ=Δμν=~=ιηκναηε=ηΡ=νάΙ=ικαξ~νΙδσ=ηοεΙΗ=Ε~κΦη=Ε~κκαΙΗ=ηε= νάΙ=jΙκΕΙΗΙλ=ΡημεΗ=λνκΙοε=ηε=νάΙ=^νδ~εναΕ=λΙ~ΔΙΗK=== fν=αλ=νάΙ=ΕηενΙεναηε=ηΡ=`δ~αγ~ενλI=p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=Ιν=~δKI=νά~ν=νάαλ=`ημκν=εηο=ά~λ= ~δδ=ΕηεΕΙκεΙΗ=ι~κναΙλ=νη=νάαλ=γ~ννΙκ=ΔΙΡηκΙ=αν=~εΗ=αλ=αε=νάΙ=ΔΙλν=ιηλαναηε=νη=ΗΙνΙκγαεΙ=νάΙ= καΦάνλ=ηΡ=νάΙ=ξ~καημλ=Εδ~αγ~ενλ=~εΗ=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ=bριδηκ~ναηεI=fεΕK==`δ~αγ~ενλ=~κΙ= ικΙι~κΙΗ=νη=ηΡΡΙκ=ικηηΡ=νη=νάαλ=`ημκν=νά~ν=~=ιηκναηε=ηΡ=νάΙ=ΕηγγΙκΕα~δ=Ε~κΦη=νά~ν=ο~λ= κΙΕηξΙκΙΗ=Δσ=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ=bριδηκ~ναηεI=fεΕK=ο~λ=ηοεΙΗ=Δσ=aαΙΦη=ΗΙ=^δΙξΙ~κ=~εΗ=νά~ν= p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=Ιν=~δK=~κΙ=νάΙ=δ~οΡμδ=ΗΙλΕΙεΗ~ενλ=ηΡ=aαΙΦη=ΗΙ=^δΙξΙ~κK= = qάΙ=aΙλΕΙεΗ~ενλ=`δ~αγ~ενλI=p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=bγαδαη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=j~κ~=bμΦΙεα~=

pηδξΙσκ~I=^δΙΰ~εΗκη=gμδ~ε=mΙκ~=_~κνά¨I=^Φμλναε~=pηδξΙσκ~I=~εΗ=fΦε~Εαη=pηδξΙσκ~=κΙλιΙΕνΡμδδσ= κΙθμΙλν=νά~ν=νάαλ=`ημκν=κΙν~αε=ΰμκαλΗαΕναηε=ηξΙκ=νάΙ=ι~κναΙλ=~εΗ=νά~ν=p~ενα~Φη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI= bγαδαη=ΗΙ=^δξΙ~κI=j~κ~=bμΦΙεα~=pηδξΙσκ~I=^δΙΰ~εΗκη=gμδ~ε=mΙκ~=_~κνά¨I=^Φμλναε~=pηδξΙσκ~I= ~εΗ=fΦε~Εαη=pηδξΙσκ~=ΔΙ=~ΗΰμΗαΕ~νΙΗ=νάΙ=ηοεΙκλ=ηΡ=λιΙΕαΡαΕ=ιηκναηελ=ηΡ=νάΙ=ικαξ~νΙδσ=ηοεΙΗ= Ε~κΦη=Ε~κκαΙΗ=~Δη~κΗ=νάΙ=jΙκΕΙΗΙλ=~εΗ=νά~ν=νάαλ=`ημκν=ΗΙΕκΙΙ=νάΙακ=λιΙΕαΡαΕ=ΙενανδΙγΙεν=νη= νάΙ=κΙΕηξΙκΙΗ=ΕηαελI=δΙλλ=~=λ~δξ~ΦΙ=~ο~κΗ=νη=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ=bριδηκ~ναηεI=fεΕK= =

`boqfcf`^qb=lc=`ljmif^k`b= = mμκλμ~εν= νη= iηΕ~δ= oμδΙ= PKMNI= μεΗΙκλαΦεΙΗ= ΕημελΙδ= ΕΙκναΡαΙλ= νά~ν= άΙ= ά~λ= ΕηεΡΙκκΙΗ=

οανά=`ημελΙδ=Ρηκ=νάΙ=hαεΦΗηγ=ηΡ=pι~αε=αε=~=ΦηηΗ=Ρ~ανά=ΙΡΡηκν=νη=κΙληδξΙ=αλλμΙλ=κ~αλΙΗ=αε=νάαλ= oΙλιηελΙK= = hαεΦΗηγ= ηΡ= pι~αε= ηιιηλΙλ= aΙλΕΙεΗ~εν= `δ~αγ~ενλI= p~ενα~Φη= ΗΙ= ^δξΙ~κI= bγαδαη= ΗΙ= ^δξΙ~κI= j~κ~= bμΦΙεα~= pηδξΙσκ~I= ^δΙΰ~εΗκη= gμδ~ε= mΙκ~= _~κνά¨I= ^Φμλναε~= pηδξΙσκ~I= ~εΗ= fΦε~Εαη=pηδξΙσκ~I=ΡαδαεΦ=ηΡ=νάαλ=oΙλιηελΙK= = = = = = = = = = = = a~νΙΗ=νάΙ=Vνά=Η~σ=ηΡ=cΙΔκμ~κσ=OMMVK= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = oΙλιΙΕνΡμδδσ=λμΔγαννΙΗI= LλLgηάε=jΕi~μΦάδαε= glek=jΕi^rdeifk= t~ΦεΙκI=s~μΦά~ε=C=jΕi~μΦάδαεI=mK^K= SMN=_~σλάηκΙ=_δξΗKI=pμανΙ=VNM= q~γι~I=cδηκαΗ~===PPSMS= UNPLOORJQMMMX=UNPLOORJQMNM=EΡ~ρF= cδηκαΗ~=_~κ=kηK=NVPRUT= bJγ~αδW===gηάε]ο~ΦεΙκδ~οKΕηγ=

`boqfcf`^qb=lc=pbosf`b= = f= ebob_v= `boqfcv= νά~ν= ηε= cΙΔκμ~κσ= NOI= OMMVI= f= ΙδΙΕνκηεαΕ~δδσ= ΡαδΙΗ= νάΙ= ΡηκΙΦηαεΦ= οανά= νάΙ= `δΙκβ= ηΡ= νάΙ= `ημκν= Δσ= μλαεΦ= νάΙ= `jLb`c= λσλνΙγ= οάαΕά= οαδδ= λΙεΗ= ~= εηναΕΙ= ηΡ= ΙδΙΕνκηεαΕ=ΡαδαεΦ=νη=νάΙ=ΡηδδηοαεΦW=== = gΙΡΡκΙσ=^εΗΙκλΙεI=bλθμακΙ= = = = g~γΙλ=dηηδΗI=bλθμακΙ= a~ξαΗ=_~εβΙκI=bλθμακΙ= = = = `ηξαεΦνηε=C=_μκδαεΦI=iim= hΙανά=pβηκΙοαΕςI=bλθμακΙ= = = = NOMN=mΙεελσδξ~εα~=^ξΙKI=kt= _μλά=oηλλI=mK^K= = = = = t~λάαεΦνηεI=a`==OMMMQJOQMN= mKlK=_ηρ=PVNP== = = = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=hαεΦΗηγ=ηΡ=pι~αε= q~γι~I=ci==PPSMNJPVNP= = = = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=hαεΦΗηγ=ηΡ=pι~αε= = = = = hK=oμλλΙδδ=i~jηννΙI=bλθμακΙ== = = jΙδαεΗ~=gK=j~Ε`ηεεΙδδI=bλθμακΙ= _ΙξΙκαΗΦΙ=C=aα~γηεΗI=m`= = = = lΫ_καΙε=_ηοΙκI=mK^K= NPRMN=f=pνK=ktI=pμανΙ=TMM= = = = RNN=tK=_~σ=pνKI=pμανΙ=PPM= t~λάαεΦνηεI=a`==OMMMRJPPNN= = = q~γι~I=ci==PPSMSJPRPP= ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ= = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ= = bκαΕ=`K=qάαΙδI=bλθμακΙ= = = = j~κδηο=sK=tάανΙI=bλθμακΙ= ^δδΙε=hK=ξηε=pιαΙΦΙδΡΙδΗI=bλθμακΙ= = = iΙοαλ=C=tάανΙI=mi`= _~εβΙκ=iηιΙς=d~λλδΙκI=mK^K= = = = mKlK=_ηρ=NMRM= RMN=bK=hΙεεΙΗσ=_δξΗKI=pμανΙ=NRMM= = = q~δδ~ά~λλΙΙI=ci==POPMO= = = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=`δ~αγ~ενI=bδλ~=tάανδηΕβ= q~γι~I=ci==PPSMO= = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=lΗσλλΙσ=j~καεΙ= = = = = j~κβ=j~εΙσI=bλθμακΙ= = = = qαγηνάσ=pάμλν~I=bλθμακΙ= j~εΙσ=cακγ= = = = = = mάΙδιλ=aμεΔ~κI=iim= TNN=iημαλα~ε~I=pμανΙ=PNMM= = = = NMM=pK=^λάδΙσ=aκKI=pμανΙ=NVMM= eημλνηεI=qu==TTMMOJOTNN= = = = q~γι~I=ci==PPSMOJRPNR= ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=oΙιμΔδαΕ=ηΡ=mΙκμ= = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=oΙιμΔδαΕ=ηΡ=mΙκμ= = a~ξαΗ=mK=eηκ~εI=bλθμακΙ= = = = dμσ=bK=_μκεΙννΙI=gκKI=bλθμακΙ= eηκ~ε=C=t~δδ~ΕΙI=iim= = = = dμσ=bK=_μκεΙννΙI=gκKI=mK^K= SMU=tάανΙάΙ~Η=pνK= = = = = PMOM=kK=pά~εεηε=i~βΙλ=aκK= hΙσ=tΙλνI=ci==PPMQM= = = = = q~δδ~ά~λλΙΙI=ci==POPMV= ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=`δ~αγ~ενλ= = = = ^ννηκεΙσ=Ρηκ=`δ~αγ~ενλ= = = f= ά~ξΙ= ικηξαΗΙΗ= ΕηιαΙλ= ηΡ= νάΙ= ΡηκΙΦηαεΦ= νη= gηλΙιά= ^K= oηΗκαΦμΙςI= mκη= pΙLrεκΙικΙλΙενΙΗ= m~κνσI= QSNN= pK= rεαξΙκλανσ= aκKI= a~ξαΙI= ciI= PPPOUJPUNTI= νάαλ= NOνά= Η~σ= ηΡ= cΙΔκμ~κσI=OMMVK= = = = = = = = = LλL=gηάε=jΕi~μΦάδαε= = = = = = = = glek=jΕi^rdeifk= = = = = = = = t~ΦεΙκI=s~μΦά~ε=C=jΕi~μΦάδαεI=mK^K= = = = = = = = SMN=_~σλάηκΙ=_δξΗKI=pμανΙ=VNM= = = = = = = = q~γι~I=cδηκαΗ~===PPSMS= = = = = = = = UNPLOORJQMMMX=UNPLOORJQMNM=EΡ~ρF= = = = = = = = ^ννηκεΙσλ=Ρηκ=`δ~αγ~ενλ== = = = = = = = cδηκαΗ~=_~κ=kηK=NVPRUT= = = = = = = = bJγ~αδW===gηάε]ο~ΦεΙκδ~οKΕηγ=