Lee v. Greenspoon Marder, P.A.

Filing 83

ORDER granting final approval of class settlement agreement. Signed by Magistrate Judge John J. O'Sullivan on 3/5/2012. (mkr)

Download PDF
UN I TED STATES DISTRICT CO UR T SO UTH ERN DISTRICT O F FLO RI A D CA SE NO . 10- 61184-O ' lvan : cvSuli I CONSENTI YO UNG LEE,on behal ofhi sel f m f and al ot I herssi iarl s t ed, m l y i uat Pl ntf , ai if G REEN SPO O N M AR DER,P. . A, a Fl da Prof onalAs aton,and ori essi soci i LA RRY C O RM AN,i vi l ndi dualy, Def endant . s O R DER G M N TING FINAL APPRO VA L O F CLA SS SETTLEM EN T A GR EEM EN T On Nove b 29,201l t s Co tpr lm i a iy a ov t e Cl s Se te e Agr e e t m er , hi ur e i n r l ppr ed h a s tlm nt e m n (d re t' an c riid a cls f p pos of stlme .Do t# 79 (i t e men' d e tfe Ag ) a s or ur es ete nt cke i DE ' .The ' ) A gr entcont pl es dam ages t Pl ntf and t cl m em ber paym entoft coss of cl eem em at o ai if he ass s, he t ass a m i sr ton,r s bl ltg ton co t ,a r s bl a t ne f es The Co ti i or ed t t d nit a i ea ona e ii a i s s nd ea ona e tor y e . ur s nf m ha ac ualnotce w as sent by Fi t Cl s,l ,t t r part cl adm i sr or vi fr t cl m ai t t i rs as nc. he hid- y ass nitat , a i s - ass l o on hu e f t f (44)cls membes Fory- e ( )notce wer rt ne b t Unie e ndrd ory-our 1 as r. t on 41 i s e eur d y he td Stt Posa Seviewihnofr r n a es fve( noiesweert ne byt Unie Stts aes tl r c t o wadig ddrs; i 5) tc r eur d he td ae Pos a Se vi e wih a f wa di a e s a d r m a l b Fis Cl s ,l Fis Cl s ,l r c i d t l r c t or r ng ddr s n e ied y r t a s nc. r t a s nc. e e ve n o jcin , o rq et fre cu in . u s l o b t sd src ie n n a welOfte 1 4 o be to s n r e u ss o x lso s Co n e f r oh ie e ev d o c s l. h 4 cl m em ber ,103 cl sm em ber r ai t r vet rrz rat s e oft cl sf ass s as s em n o ecei hei w a har he as und. On M ar 5,201 t Cour hel a f r ch 2, he t d ainesshearng t whi Cl m em ber i udi any i o ch ass s, ncl ng wihobe ton ,weei td.Th Cour, ngf l ad s di t prmies hee yor r: t jci s r nvie e tbei uly vie n he e s , rb des The Cour fnds t t pr si f notce t t cl s s if t t i hat he ovi ons or i o he as ats y he r r ent ofFed.R.Ci P.23 and due pr equiem s v. ocess. 2. The Cour fnds t t setl ent i f r and r onabl and her t i hat he tem s ai eas e, eby a ove t Ac p e OferofJ ppr s he ce t d f udgm e t n. 3. Dee nts lpa t ea h Cls memb who di no optou,o j tt fnda hal y o c as er d t t bec o e l e hi -orhe s ffom te s tlme a who c nbe lcae ac ec i t a xcud m rel r h ete nt nd a o t d, h k n he moun o $9l51 tf . , rpr e i t i pr r a s r of t $9, 79 Cls Fu v d f t fve ( da aher e esntng her o at hae he 425. a s nd, oi ory-i 45) ys is nc . W ihi t ry ( day oft sOr er De e an s al pr d Fis Cls ,l c. t ac c s ua e t n hit 30) s hi d , f nd t h l ovie rt a s n wih he k i te a n h moun of $ 425, r r e tng t Cls Fund,f pr r t ditiuto t e c ca s t 9, 79, ep es n i he a s or o a a srb in o a h ls me rasd ci d i dit y a e.Cls me e c c s lb maie wihi sxy (0) mbe esrbe mme ael bov as mb r he ks hal e ld t n it 6 days oft s Or ,Pl ntf ' counselw iladm i ser t c pr aw ar w hi w ilbe sent t t hi der ai ifs l nit he y es d, ch l o he N atonalConsum er Law Cent . i er W ihi t ry (0) d ys of t s Or r Dee nts lpr de Pli ips t n hit 3 a hi de, fnda hal ovi antf c ns ScotD. nswih a c e i t a ntof$3, 00 f pa ntofPl ntf' saut y ou el t Owe t h ck n he mou 000. or yme ai ifs t t or d ge ( , 0. )a rc nii ofhi s vi sa teca srprs ttve( 000. ) ama s $l00 00 nd e og ton s er ce s h ls e eenai $2, 00 . 5. Pur uantt t Agr ent Pl ntf i deemed t pr lng and s s o he eem , ai if s he evaii uccess ul f p t s el f pur e of a a r of c t a d a l n y f es Th Co t h a i d a ary ol y or pos s n wa d os s n tor e e . e ur as pple nd c i r d t f cor lsed i J ns n v.Ga Hi hwa Expr s l , F. 71 71 1 ( t Ci. onsde e he a t s it n oh o . z y es . nc.488 2d 4, 7- 9 5 h r 1 4) a d fn t tt fei tei tn c ei r s bl ihi t ry( da oft sOr r 97 1 n ids ha he e n h nsa t as s eaona e.W t n hit 30) ys hi de, De e n s l pr vie Pl n ipsco e Sc tD.Owe wihac c i t e a ntof$46,88. f nda t ha l o d aitf uns l ot ns t he k n h mou 1 00 (osso $177 pl atr yf sof$ 41 00 . c t f , 3 us tone ee 44, 5. ) 1TheEl event Cicui i Bonnerv. Ci ofPrc d, F. 1 h r tn t y ihar 661 2d 206,1 ( lhCi.1 )( 207 1 t r 981 en ba c)a tdaspe ed tde sonsoft f me Fit Cic trndee prort Ocobe 1 1 . n , dope rc en cii he or r fh rui e rd i o t r , 981 2 6. Def endant s l pay t coss of cl adm i sr i diecty t t hal he t ass ni taton r l o he adm i sr or a l t fve days i advance of t ser ces necesst i any such cos s.Pl ntf s nitat t eas i n he vi iatng t ai if counsels lbe r hal esponsi e f diectng t cl adm i s r or bl or r i he ass nitat . The Cour fndst Agr entt be f r adequat and r t s he eem o ai, e, easonabl and m ade es i good f t n aih, 8. The Cour rti j rs ci ove te i epr ai e oreme t a t eans uiditon r h ntr etton, nf c n nd i pl ent i of t A gr ent and of t s O r m em aton he eem hi der. Upon t pe f m a e of a l t n of t s he r or nc l e ms hi Or ,i udi t adm i s r i of t c pr awar afer t checks ar voi t pa i shal der ncl ng he nit aton he y es d t he e d, he rtes l f e a s i a i advi ng t s Courtt al t m shave been per or 5l tpulton si hi hat l er f med,r eques i dim isaloft tng s s he caewi prj c s t eudie. h D O NE A ND O R DER ED i Cham ber atM i i Fl d t s5t day ofM ar 2012. n s am , ori hi h ch, z ; JO J.O ' LLI S VAN UN I D STA ES M A G I T STRATE J DGE U 3

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?