Lee v. Greenspoon Marder, P.A.

Filing 83

ORDER granting final approval of class settlement agreement. Signed by Magistrate Judge John J. O'Sullivan on 3/5/2012. (mkr)

UN I
TED STATES DISTRICT CO UR T
SO UTH ERN DISTRICT O F FLO RI A
D
CA SE NO . 10- 61184-O ' lvan
: cvSuli

I
CONSENTI
YO UNG LEE,on behal ofhi sel
f
m f
and al ot
I herssi iarl s t ed,
m l y i uat
Pl ntf ,
ai if

G REEN SPO O N M AR DER,P. .
A,
a Fl da Prof onalAs aton,and
ori
essi
soci i
LA RRY C O RM AN,i vi l
ndi dualy,
Def
endant .
s

O R DER G M N TING FINAL APPRO VA L
O F CLA SS SETTLEM EN T A GR EEM EN T

On Nove b 29,201l t s Co tpr lm i a iy a ov t e Cl s Se te e Agr e e t
m er
, hi ur e i n r l ppr ed h a s tlm nt e m n

(d re t' an c riid a cls f p pos of stlme .Do t# 79 (i
t e men' d e tfe
Ag
)
a s or ur es ete nt cke
i
DE

' .The
'
)

A gr entcont pl es dam ages t Pl ntf and t cl m em ber paym entoft coss of cl
eem
em at
o ai if
he ass
s,
he t
ass

a m i sr ton,r s bl ltg ton co t ,a r s bl a t ne f es The Co ti i or ed t t
d nit a i ea ona e ii a i
s s nd ea ona e tor y e .
ur s nf m
ha
ac ualnotce w as sent by Fi t Cl s,l ,t t r part cl adm i sr or vi fr t cl m ai t
t
i
rs as nc. he hid- y ass
nitat , a i s - ass l o

on hu e f t f (44)cls membes Fory- e ( )notce wer rt ne b t Unie
e ndrd ory-our 1
as
r. t on 41 i s e eur d y he td
Stt Posa Seviewihnofr r n a es fve( noiesweert ne byt Unie Stts
aes tl r c t
o wadig ddrs; i 5) tc
r eur d he td ae
Pos a Se vi e wih a f wa di a e s a d r m a l b Fis Cl s ,l Fis Cl s ,l r c i d
t l r c t or r ng ddr s n e ied y r t a s nc. r t a s nc. e e ve

n o jcin , o rq et fre cu in . u s l o b t sd src ie n n a welOfte 1 4
o be to s n r e u ss o x lso s Co n e f r oh ie e ev d o c s l. h 4
cl m em ber ,103 cl sm em ber r ai t r vet rrz rat s e oft cl sf
ass
s
as
s em n o ecei hei w a har
he as und.
On M ar 5,201 t Cour hel a f r
ch
2, he
t d ainesshearng t whi Cl m em ber i udi any
i o
ch ass
s, ncl ng

wihobe ton ,weei td.Th Cour, ngf l ad s di t prmies hee yor r:
t jci s r nvie e
tbei uly vie n he e s , rb des

The Cour fnds t t pr si f notce t t cl s s if t
t i
hat he ovi ons or i o he as ats y he
r r ent ofFed.R.Ci P.23 and due pr
equiem s
v.
ocess.
2.

The Cour fnds t t setl ent i f r and r onabl and her
t i
hat he tem
s ai
eas
e,
eby

a ove t Ac p e OferofJ
ppr s he ce t d f
udgm e t
n.

3.

Dee nts lpa t ea h Cls memb who di no optou,o j tt
fnda hal y o c as
er
d t
t bec o

e l e hi -orhe s ffom te s tlme a who c nbe lcae ac ec i t a
xcud m
rel r h ete nt nd
a
o t d, h k n he moun o $9l51
tf . ,

rpr e i t i pr r a s r of t $9, 79 Cls Fu v d f t fve ( da aher
e esntng her o at hae he 425.
a s nd, oi ory-i 45) ys
is nc . W ihi t ry ( day oft sOr er De e an s al pr d Fis Cls ,l c. t ac c
s ua e t n hit 30) s hi d , f nd t h l ovie rt a s n wih he k
i te a
n h moun of $ 425, r r e tng t Cls Fund,f pr r t ditiuto t e c ca s
t
9, 79, ep es n i he a s
or o a a srb in o a h ls

me rasd ci d i dit y a e.Cls me e c c s lb maie wihi sxy (0)
mbe
esrbe mme ael bov as mb r he ks hal e ld t n it 6
days oft s Or ,Pl ntf ' counselw iladm i ser t c pr aw ar w hi w ilbe sent t t
hi der ai ifs
l
nit he y es
d, ch l
o he
N atonalConsum er Law Cent .
i
er

W ihi t ry (0) d ys of t s Or r Dee nts lpr de Pli ips
t n hit 3 a
hi de, fnda hal ovi antf
c ns ScotD. nswih a c e i t a ntof$3, 00 f pa ntofPl ntf' saut y
ou el t Owe
t h ck n he mou
000. or yme
ai ifs t t or

d ge ( , 0. )a rc nii ofhi s vi sa teca srprs ttve( 000. )
ama s $l00 00 nd e og ton s er ce s h ls e eenai $2, 00 .
5.

Pur uantt t Agr ent Pl ntf i deemed t pr lng and s
s
o he eem , ai if s
he evaii
uccess ul
f

p t s el f pur e of a a r of c t a d a l n y f es Th Co t h a i d a
ary ol y or pos s
n wa d
os s n tor e e . e ur as pple nd

c i r d t f cor lsed i J ns n v.Ga Hi hwa Expr s l , F. 71 71 1 ( t Ci.
onsde e he a t s it n oh o
. z y
es . nc.488 2d 4, 7- 9 5 h r

1 4) a d fn t tt fei tei tn c ei r s bl ihi t ry( da oft sOr r
97 1 n ids ha he e n h nsa t as s eaona e.W t n hit 30) ys hi de,
De e n s l pr vie Pl n ipsco e Sc tD.Owe wihac c i t e a ntof$46,88.
f nda t ha l o d aitf
uns l ot
ns t he k n h mou
1 00

(osso $177 pl atr yf sof$ 41 00 .
c t f , 3 us tone ee 44, 5. )

1TheEl
event Cicui i Bonnerv. Ci ofPrc d, F. 1
h r tn
t
y
ihar 661 2d 206,1 ( lhCi.1 )(
207 1 t r 981 en

ba c)a tdaspe ed tde sonsoft f me Fit Cic trndee prort Ocobe 1 1 .
n , dope
rc en cii
he or r fh rui e rd i o t r , 981
2

6.

Def
endant s l pay t coss of cl adm i sr i diecty t t
hal
he
t
ass
ni taton r l o he

adm i sr or a l t fve days i advance of t ser ces necesst i any such cos s.Pl ntf s
nitat t eas i
n
he vi
iatng
t ai if
counsels lbe r
hal esponsi e f diectng t cl adm i s r or
bl or r i he ass
nitat .
The Cour fndst Agr entt be f r adequat and r
t s he eem
o
ai,
e,
easonabl and m ade
es
i good f t
n
aih,
8.

The Cour rti j rs ci ove te i epr ai e oreme t a
t eans uiditon r h ntr etton, nf c n nd

i pl ent i of t A gr ent and of t s O r
m em aton
he
eem
hi der. Upon t pe f m a e of a l t n of t s
he r or nc
l e ms hi
Or ,i udi t adm i s r i of t c pr awar afer t checks ar voi t pa i shal
der ncl ng he
nit aton he y es
d t he
e d, he rtes
l
f e a s i a i advi ng t s Courtt al t m shave been per or
5l tpulton
si hi
hat l er
f med,r
eques i dim isaloft
tng s s
he

caewi prj c
s t eudie.
h
D O NE A ND O R DER ED i Cham ber atM i i Fl d t s5t day ofM ar 2012.
n
s
am , ori hi h
ch,
z
;

JO
J.O ' LLI
S
VAN
UN I D STA ES M A G I
T
STRATE J DGE
U

3