Twinstar Partners, LLC v. Diamond Aircraft Industries, Inc.
Filing
104
ORDER denying 77 79 Motions to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 6/25/2014. (mmd)
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
Cas N um ber 11e
: 61684- l - O RE NO
C V M
TW I
NSTAR PARTNERS, LLC ,
,
Pl i if
antf,
VS.
DI OND AI
AM
RCRAFT I
NDUSTRI , I C. et
ES N ,
al
.
De e nt .
f nda s
O RD ER DEN Y I G M O TI N S TO D I I
N
O
SM SS
At su i temo in t d s s aeF d rl l o Cii P o e u e9 b ' rq rme t o
is e n h to s o imis r e ea Ru e f v l r c d r ( )s e uie n t
pla fa wihpari ulrt a Fede a Rul ofCi lPr edur 1 sr a i ba k pr son. A t
e d r ud t
tc a iy nd
rl e
vi oc e 5' elton c ovi i
or la gume ,c
a r
nt ouns lf De e ntDi
e or f nda
amond Aicr f I tis I ( a
r a t ndusre , nc Dimond Ca da a
na ) nd
Di mond Aic a tSal U. A . ( a ndU. A. rprs ntdt ti viw of her c ntflngfr
a
r r f es S. Dimo
S. ) e e e e ha n e t e e i o
s mma yj d me tteCo r n e n t e ieteRul 9 b is e .Th Co r i o nc u to n
u r u g n h u t e d o d cd h
e ( ) s u s e u tn pe o r f u d
tepla ig s fiin l c mp idwihRul 9b a da ple t er lto b c d crn t tn t e
h e dn s u fce ty o le t e () n p id h eain a k o tie o i d h
saut oflm ia i di notba Pli tf ss tfom goi f wa d ag ns Di mond U .S. .
t t e i ttons d
r a n if ui r
ng or r ai t a
A.
THI CAUSE ca be or t Cour u Dim ondU .S. ' Motont Dimis( E.
S
me f e he
t pon a
A.S i o s s D. No.
77)fldonFe uar 14. 4a DimondCana sMotont Dimis( E.No. fldon
,ie
br v 201 nd a
da' i o s s D.
79) ie
Fe uar 14.
br y 2014.
TH E CO URT has consdered t m otons, t r s
i
he
i
he e pons ,or lar e ,a t pe tne
es a gum nt nd he ri nt
pori nsoft r or a bei ot r s f l a s d i t pr m ie , i i
to
he ec d, nd ng he wie uly dvie n he e s s t s
ADJUDGED t tt m o i a e DENI
ha he tons r
ED
.
1 Bac ound
. kzr
Pl i if Tw i t r Pa t r , LLC i a Arz c por ton t tpur has d t Dim ond
a ntf , nsa r ne s
s n i ona or a i ha
c e wo a
1 A42 Tw i St a r r f , m a a ur d b Def nda , Dim ond Aic a t I ti Gm bl
7
n ar i c a t
nuf ct e y
e nt a
r r f ndusres
l
(s a n Au ti '. Dimo d Au ti ma u a t rd t ar rf a d et e d lv rd t m o
i mo d sra' a n sra n fcu e he ica t n ih r ei ee he r
Di
)
s ppedt m f a s
hi
he or s embl t Def nda Dim ondAic a tl usre ,
y o e nt a
r r f nd tis
Ic (ç a ndCa a a'i
n . ç mo
Di
nd' n
)
On a i Ca da.Thet r De e nti Dim ondAicr f Saes U. A.s imo dU. A.)t
t ro, na
hid f nda s a
r a t l , S. (r a n S. ',he
'
c
ompa t ti t s d wih de o ng a U .S.m ar f t aicr t l is Thid Amende
ny ha s a ke
t velpi
ket or he r af. n t
r
d
Compli , aitf alege t Di mond e ii alo r t dunde t s m eowne s p a f r a
ant Pl n if l s he a
nttes l pe a e
r he n
r hi nd o m l
e utvea ho iy, t Chrsin Dre s r ng sm ula ousy a t ChifExe tveOfi rf
xec i ut rt wih ita is e vi i t ne l s he e
cu i
fce or
Di mondAusra DimondCa da,a DimondU. A. Pl i ifsa e i hea nde c
a
ti, a
na nd n
S. . antf tt s nt me d ompli
ant
t t amondU. A . ltl ornoa s t a o r t sa a a ntora tr e ofDi
ha Di
S. has ite
s es nd pe a e s n ge
le - go
amond Ca da
na
a D i m ond Aus r a
nd a
ti .
l Dec mbe 2006, antf e e edac r ct t U SAERO , LLC, non- ry di ti or
n
e r
Pl i if nt r
onta wih
a
pa t s rbut
i Arz t pur has t fr t1A42ar r f. Pli ifpur ha e t s cond1A42 ar r f i M a
n iona,o c e he is 7
ic a t antf c s d he e
7
ic a t n y
2007 fom Gavi Fl ng Se vi e I , non- ryditi ori Se tl, W as ng on.Thear a t
r
l n yi
r c , nc.a
pa t srbut n a te
hi t
icr f
a is i t sc e we e e pped wih t n t bo di s le nest twe e m a a t ed by t
t s ue n hi as r qui
t wi ur
e e ngi ha r
nuf c ur
he
Ge nc
nna ompa Thil tAica Engi sGmbl C$ '.TAE a t Dimond e iisae
ny eer r rh
ne
- TAE'
l
)
nd he a
ntte r
s pa a e unr aed e ii s Dim ond i t l TAE e nesi s
e r t , elt ntte . a
nsaled
ngi n ome ofisar r t The engi
t ic af.
nes
we ewa r nt onl by TAE.Dim ond s ii lyexc ude t TAE e ne fom iswa r nt .
r ra ed y
a
pecfca l
l d he
ngi s r t r a y
On o a
r boutA prl24,
i
2008 - m o et n ayea a t rTw i t rPa t r , LLC c r c e t pur has
r ha
r fe
ns a rne s
onta t d o c e
t aic af - TAE entr i o apr e ng i Ge ma t ti aki t aba upt y i t Unie
he r r t
e ed nt
oce di n r ny ha s n o
nkr c n he t d
St t ,a iswa r nte we e voi d. Pli ifs ekst r c r fom De e nt t da a s
aes nd t ra i s r
de
a ntf e
o e ove r
f nda s he m ge
Pl i ifs f r due t t l soft e newa y.
antf ufe ed
o he os
he ngi
nunt
Ast t fr taic af,Pli if sm e r , J f M cElr h,
o he is r r t a ntf
mbe s e f
fes EdnaLa , and Andr w La
ke
e
ke
a tnd t USAERO de we ke s i Sc tdal, A rzona.Dur ngt w e ke M r Fa l y
te ed he
mo e nd how n ots e i
i he e nd . re
,
ofUSAERO e pli d t t m t tr soft TAE wa r nt . Upon de i r oft fr taic a t
x a ne o he he e m
he
ra y
lve y he s r r f
i Lo on, a i Dim ond Ca da' Aic af Delve y Ce e M ana rc im e t tnnsof
n nd Ontro, a
na s r r t i r ntr
ge onfr d he e
t e newar nt M r Slnge l pr dedM r La wih aLi iedW a r nt doc e whi h
he ngi
ra y. . i rand ovi
.
ke t
m t
ra y um nt c
,
sae t tt TAE engi wer c r by a wa r nt f t ye r pa t a a l
tt d ha he
nes e ove ed
ra y or wo a s rs nd nd abor pl
us
,
pr a e ove 2, fi hthour or1 ye s M r Slngera al o pr ded aco of heTAE Te m s
or t d r 400 lg
s 2 ar . . i l nd s ovi
py t
r
ofGua a e oft Li ie Pr Ra a M anuf c ur r s Gua a e f t Ce ur on 1.7.
r nt e he m t d o t
at e'
r nt e or he nt i
Ast t s cond ar r t M r M c fes a M r La ta e t London,Ont rot t ke
o he e
ic af, . Elr h nd . ke r veld o
ai o a
delvey.W hiei Ont ro, antf alege t tDim o Ca
i l
l n a i Pli if l s ha a nd nadae pl se anedt t m t
m oyee xpl i o he he
tr oft TAE wa r nt Dimond Ca dae oye J r m iAusi c i dt M r M c fes
e ms he
ra y. a
na mpl e e e
tn onfnne o . Elr h
a M r La t tonc t aic a te nesr c a oxi t l 1000 fi hthour ,t y w oul
nd . ke ha
e he r r f ngi ea hed ppr ma ey ,
lg
s he
d
be abl t r pl ce t e nes f ne 2.01 engi sf a pr a e cos bas on num be offi
e o e a he ngi
or w
, ne or or t d t ed
r lght
hour on t e ne a t tm e ofr pl c e . Anot runi ntfed Di mond Cana e oye
s he ngi s t he i
e a em nt
he
de ii
a
da mpl e
a s pr vi dM r M c fes andM r La wih a he Li td W a r nt doc e , whi h s a e
lo o de
. Elr h
. ke t not r mie
ra y um nt c t t d
t tt TAE e neswe ecove e by awa r nt f t ye r pa t a lbor pl pr r t d ove
ha he
ngi
r
rd
ra y or wo a s rs nd a , us o a e
r
2, fihthour or 1 yea s
400 lg
s 2 r.
Pl i ifs Thid Amende Compli i bas on is r la e on r pr s nt i ns by
antf
r
d
ant s ed
t ei nc
e e e ato
Di ond' e pl ee or ag t r ga di t TA E w a r y. Pl ntf ' t o c
am
s m oy s
en s e r ng he
r ant
ai i f s w ount a e f
s r or
fa e m ir pr s ntton a fa c c
r udul nt se e e a i nd r udulnt once l e .
am nt
I .Le St
I eal andar
d
dro s v ve a m oton t di m i s pli if mus do mor t n m e ey sa e l al
t
' ur i
i o s s , antfs
t
e ha
r l tt eg
conc us ons 'i t dpl i i f m us ça l ges es cii f t bas sf hos c us onsorf c
l i , ns ea a ntf s t s le om pe fc ac ual i ort e oncl i
'
ae
dimis loft i cl ms' J k onv Belsout Te e omm ., 37 F. 1
s s a her ai . ' ac s . l h l c
2 3d 250,1 ( 1hCi. 4)
263 1 t r 200 .
W he r lngon amotont dimis acou t us viw t compl i i t lgh mos f vor bl t
n ui
i o s s,
r m t e he
ant n he i t t a a e o
t pl i ifa a e t pl i ifswel- e dedf c sast e. SeeStJos ph' Hos Inc.v.H os
he antf nd cc pt he antf
lpla
a t nz
. e s p.,
p.
Cop. fzm. 7 5 F.d 9 8 9 3 ( lh Ci.1 8 ) Th stn t ho ve, doesnotappl t l l
r o q , 9 2 4 , 5 1 t r 9 6 . i e e, we r
y o ega
c uso . SeeAs rjtv.I al 1 S.Ct 1937,1 ( ) Mor over tg hie lga
oncl ins
hc o
qb , 29
.
949 2009
e , fwq l e l
.
co usons ca pr de t fa e k of a c
ncl i
n ovi he r m wor
ompl nt t y mus be s
ai , he
t
uppo td by f c ua
re
at l
alg to s'I a 1 0.Th s 'fa t a alg to smus b e u ht r iearg torle a o e
le ai n . d t 95
'
o e ' jcu l le ain
g
t e no g o as ih t eif b v
t s c ai l ve on t a s
he pe ultve e l he s umpton t taloft c
i ha 1 he ompli ' ale to a e tu .' BelAt.
ants l ga i ns r r e ' l l
Cor v Twombl 550 U. . 5 5 ( ) I s tt c
p. .
y,
S 44, 45 2007 . n hor, he ompl ntmus notme ey al a
ai
t
r l lege
mic
s onduc , m us de onsr t t tt pl a ri e ildt r i . Se I ,1 S. . t1 .
t but t m ta e ha he e de s ntte o elef e qbal 29 Ct a 950
1 1 L e A nal i
1 . gal
ys s
A .St ut ofLi i a i
at e
m t t ons
Thepa tesa e t tt i ta a tonwasfld durng t a i bl sa ut oflmia i .
ri gr e ha he nii l c i
ie
i he pplca e tt e i t tons
Thequesi ort Cour i whe he heThidAmende Compli t whih a dDi
tonf he
ts t rt
r
d
a n , c dde amondU. A .
S. ,
r a e ba k t t orgi l m pl nt Fe r Rul of viPr dur 1 c ()C) pple andunder
el t s c o he i na co ai . deal e Ci l oce e 5() 1( a is
t sr ec am sr l t ba k i:
hi ul l i e ae c f
( t a ndme c nge t pa t ort na ng oft pa t
C) he me
nt ha s he ry he mi
he ry
a ns whom acli i as e td, i Rul 1 c( )B)i s tsida
gai t
a m s s re f e 5()1( s aife nd
i, t nt pei pr de byRul 4( f s r ngt s
fwihi he rod ovi d
e m) or e vi he ummons
a c
nd ompl nt t pa t t be br ghti by a e e :
ai , he ry o
ou n
m ndm nt
()r eve s h noi oft a ton t t i wilnotbe
i ec i d uc tce he ci ha t l
prj c i dee ngont meis a
eudied n fndi
he rt; nd
(i kne o s dhavekno t tt aci woul ha
i) w r houl
wn ha he ton
d ve
be n br
e ough aga ns i,bu f a m it ke c
t i t t t or
sa
once ni t
r ng he
pr
operpary' i iy.
t s dentt
TheSupr Cour hashedt t hepr ri r f rwhe he apli ifha s tsi dRul
eme
t
l ha t ope nquiy o
t r antf s ai fe
e
1 () 1( i wh t h d f n a t e o s o dh v k o d rn t tmel tf rs r ieo
5c ()C) s a t e e e d n kn w r h ul a e n wn u ig he i i o e vc f
mi
t c pli a s mons Kr ps iv
he om a nt nd um
.
u k .Cosa Cr i r , S. . ,560 U. 538, 541( 0) The
t oc e e p A.
S.
201 .
Co te ai d t tt f us on a def nda ' k w ldge goe t t he r oft pur e of
ur xpl ne ha he oc
e nts no e
s o he a t he pos
alwigr lto b c . I b ln e j sief rpan if wiht eitr sso ad f n a twh i
lo n eai n a k t aa c s u tc o litfs t h n ee t f ee d n o s
rg f l e il or pos . I , U. a 550. rtngf heCour,J tc Sot a
ihtuly nttedt e e d 560 S. t
W ii ort
t us ie om yore ane
xpl i d
i Kr ps it ta ' li ifm i know t tt pr pe tvedef nte ssbutnone hels har
n u k ha ' antf ght
p
ha he os c i
enda xit
t e s bor
amiunde sa nga
s r tndi bout ssausorr ei t e nt gi ngrs t t c am a is a s m a
hi t t
ol n he ve s vi ie o he l i t s ue nd he y
,
m it ke y c
sa nl hoos t s a dif r ntde e ntbas d o t tm ii e son.' 1 , U. a 5 .
e o ue fe e
f nda
e n ha smpr s i ' d 560 S. t 49
Prort Kr ps ,heElvent Cic te m i d t r l tonbac pr sonsofRul 1 and
i o u kit
e h r ui xa ne he e ai
k ovii
e 5
hel t ys ul bes wha lbe al c tued. Po r v Grfi1 8F.d 1 2 ,1 2 ( 1hCi.
d he ho d ome t i r ly onsr
wes . a f 4 3 2 3 2 6 1 t r
1 .l saed Rul 1 doe no s
998) t tt
e 5 s t uppor i eai ba i
t s lton ck n
r
c es wher t ne y a d
as
e he wl dde
. . .
de e nt we ekno t t pl i ifbef et r ngoft sa ut oflm iai a whe e t
f nda s r
wn o he antf or he unni
he tt e i t tons nd
r he
pot tal e nt s ul no ne e s rl ha knownt t abs nta m i t ke by t pl i i f t
en i def nda s ho d t c s a iy ve
ha , e
sa
he a ntf hey
,
woul havebee s d.' I Sl pur eofRul 1 c)i t pemi a
d
n ue ' d k-he pos
e 5( s o r t mende c ai st r ae
d ompl nt o elt
bac t orgi lflngsf saut oflm iai nspu os whe t a nde compl i i c r tng
k o i na ii or t t e i t to
m es n he me d
ant s oreci
am it kea tt i ntt oft def nda .'1 t n t mos lbe a i e pr t tonoft itke'
sa bou he de iy he e nt ' d. d
Eve he
t i r l nt r e a i
m sa
ca ti udeadelber t de i i no t s aparywhos i ntt ai ifkne fom t out e .''
nno ncl
i ae c son t o ue
t
e de iypl ntf w r he s t
1 1 F. a 1 (uoi Wel v HBO drCo.81 F S p 1 61 1 6 ( D. .1 9 :.
d, 48 3d t 227 q tng ls .
, 3 u p. 5 , 5 7 N. Ga 9 2
.
Pl ntf c ede i kne Di
ai if onc s t w amond U .S. exit butas e t t ti di no know how
A. sed,
s rs ha t d t
D i m o U . A . asi ve i t f a entac i t untlt de ii ofis Pr i ntPe e
a nd S. w nvol d n he r udul
tviy i he pos ton t es de
tr
M aur on Sept ber27, 201 De e nt a guet tPl ntfs c
er
em
3. f nda s r
ha ai if ' ouns ha t ke t de ii n
el d a n he posto
ofPe e M a e i as pa aeunr l td c ei Se e
t r ur r n e r t e ae as n pt mber2011. Thepa tesa e t tPl ntf a s
ri gr e ha ai if lo
ha ac es t t FAA doc e s fl d on J y 22,201 t ts
d c s o he
um nt , ie
ul
0 ha howe t e se ofDim ond
d he xit nce
a
U. A. nd isr ei ta f ri tteoft ar r f t Unie St t spur s r a orditi or
S. a t ol n r ns e rng il he ic a to t d a e
cha e s nd/ srbut s
.
The da e offlng oft FAA doc e swa i a s pa a e c e a
t
ii
he
um nt s n e r t as nd
prort t e r ton ofa
i o he xpia i
sa u eoflmia i .Se M as ar Avi i v Dimo dAic a t n u .Ca eNo 1 - 0 5 - Vtt t
i t tons e
c o aton . a n r rj l d s, s . 0 6 5 6 CI
M ORENO,Dimond Ca da' M oton t Dimisa Exhi tO t ough HH ( D .Fl J y 22,
a
na s i o s s t bi hr
S
a. ul
.
2 0.
01 )
Event h Pl ntf ' c
houg ai ifs ouns lm a ha known t oug t i wor i as
e y ve
hr h her k n e
par e cas t
at e hat
t pa te we e r l t , t Cour c r i
he ri s r e aed he
t amot mput t tknowldge t t Pli ifi t s ca e
e ha
e
o he a ntf n hi s
,
es cily i lg ofKr ps isve y lbe a i e r tton ofRul 1 sr a i ba pr son.l
pe a l n i ht
u k ' r i r l nt m ea i
e 5' elton ck ovii
n
t sca e, hePl ntf l r d oft r l tons p a ong t va i Def nda sa t Se e
hi s t
ai if eane
he e a i hi m
he rous e nt t he pt mber
201 de ii ofPee M a e andpr
3 poston
tr ur r
omptym ove t a e t c
l
d o m nd he ompli . M or ove , heFAA
ant
e rt
doc nt s
ume s howi tteta f rs e i ufi i t o t i own, o s
ng il r nse e m ns fcen , n her
t uppor afndi t tPl i if
t i ng ha antf
delbe a eychos not os Di
i rtl
e t ue nmondU .S. . A ccor ngl , t Cour de e t motont dim is
A .
di y he
t ni s he i o s s
tndi t r lton bac docrnea ist alow t a e
i ng he ea i
k ti pple o l he m ndmen i t sca e
t n hi s .
D ON E AN D O RDERED i O pe Cour a M i m i Fl r da t s
n
n
t t a , o i , hi
da ofJ , 201
y
une
4.
.e
,;
F
'X
FED
O .M OREN O
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co e pr de t
pis ovi d o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor
-
6-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?