Perret et al v. Wyndham Vacation Resorts, Inc. et al

Filing 67

ORDER denying 45 Motion to Remand. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 2/21/2012. (ls)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
C as N o.11- e
CV 61904-SEI SI O N TO N
TZ/ M
HA RRY PERR ET a
nd
M ELI
NDA PERRET,ndi dualy,
i vi l
an on be fofalt esm iary st t d,
d
hal
l hos i l l iua e

Pl n if ,
aitf s
V S.

W Y ND HA M V A CA TI RESO RTS,l C . etal,
ON
N ,
.

Defnda s
e nt.
/

O R DER D EN Y I G M O TI N TO R EM A N D
N
O

THI CAUS i beo et Co r o Plitfs Moi nt Re nd( 45 . Th s
S
E s f r he u t n an if' to o ma DE- 1 i
put tvec a sa ton wa fld i t Cicui Cour oft Se e t J calCicui i a f
ai l s c i
s ie n he r t
t he venten h udi i r t n nd or
Br wa d Count Fl rda.De e
o r
y, o i
f ndan sr
t emove t aci t t sCour bas d on t Cl s
d he ton o hi
t e
he a s

Aci Far s Ac (
ton ine s t CAFA) Pli if'Ame dComplitaiesoutoft s l a
. antfs
nde
an rs
he ae nd
m a ge e toftmes r va ton pr ri i Fl rda.Pl ntfsa s tt tt s l
na m n
i ha e cai
ope tes n o i
ai if s er ha he ae

ta a tonswe em il di a de e i andt tt m a e e c t as e s d b
r ns ci
r sea ng nd c ptve
ha he nag m nt oss s s e y
De e nt a e e es i a unr as bl Pli if s e r m a bec us t amounti
f nda s r xc sve nd e ona e. antfs e k e nd a e he
n
c r ve s ha no be me a be us cas szehasnotbee e tbls l Bec us t
onto r y s t en t nd ca e l s i
n sa ihed.
a e he

a u ti c n r v ryr q ie n f r u idcinu d rCAFA i f cal a pae t rm t e
mo n n o to es e urme t o j rs ito n e
s a il p rn fo h
y
alegai oft Am e d Compl i ,t M oton t Rema i deni
l tons he
nde
ant he
i o
nd s
ed.
1 Fac sA le d i C o pl i and O t D ocum e s
.
t l ge n m a nt
her
nt

Deenda W y m Va ai Res t,nc.( y m)ad ts ,s l a ma ge
f nt ndha
c ton ors I W ndha
veries els, nd na s
l antfsc e t tDe e nt ha s ifed t mi maldi r iy a m o et n
pl i if onc de ha f nda s ve atsi he ni
ve st nd r ha
l cl s m e be sr qui e ent ofCA FA .
00 a s m r e r m s

tme haepr risi Fl i Dee ntFaishaeVa tonOwne sAsocai ( ishae
i s r ope te n orda. fnda
r r cai
r s iton Far r)
i t tuse f t be ii resoft W yndha Tr t whih c it oft owne sof
s he r t e or he nefc a i
he
m us, c onsss he
r

tmes r pr peri owne by W yndha . antfsg r ly al get tDef nda swe e
i ha e o tes
d
m Pl i if ene a l le ha
e nt r
de e i a m iladi i t i s ea m a ge e oftm e har pr ri . Spe fcal
c ptve nd se ng n her al nd na m nt i s e ope tes
ci ly,

Pli if'Ame
antfs
ndedCo antalge sxc ussofa i ( )e tbl r i agans bot
mpli le s i a e cton: 1 quia e elef i t h

Dee d ns ( )b e c o fd cayd t a ans F is a e ( )be c offd cayd t a ans
fn a t; 2 ra h f iu ir uy g i t ar h r ; 3 r a h i u ir uy g i t
W yndha ( vi ai ofFl i ' De ptvea Unfi TrdePrcie Ac (
m;4) olton
ordas ce i nd ar a a tc s t FDUTPA)

a ans Wy d a ( ) r a ho c n rc a an t t Dee d n s a d ()fa db W y d n
g i t n h m; 5 b e c f o ta t g i s boh fn a t; n 6 r u y n h m.
Pli if pr y f da es i l ng i e e ta dig g m e ofi quia ea
antfs a or mag , nc udi nt r s nd s or e nt ne t bl nd
unc c ona epr isi t whe e or clus sofCount 1, 1, 1 .The s e
ons i bl oft n he
rf e a e
s I 11 and V
y ek

c mp n aoyd ma e , pe il a g s a dp eud me titrs i Co n V a dsmpy
o e s tr a g s s ca d ma e , n rj g n n ee tn u t n i l
da esi l ng i e es i CountVI
mag ncudi ntr t n
.
De e nt r
f nda s emove t sa ton fom sae c r ba e on t a lga i i t c
d hi c i r t t ou t s d he le tons n he ompli
ant

a d sv r l e lrto .Th Ame d dCo an , aa rp 1 , le e t tS th a u t f
n e e a d caains e
n e mplit p r ga h 0 alg s ha ç l e mo n o
l
ea h i vi lca m i contove s e e $1 000. e usveofi t r s a coss' l
c ndi dua li n
r r y xce ds 5, 00, xcl i
n e e t nd t . t
'
f t ral ge ,i pa ag a 26,ha i ai if a e i or e a bele t tpot ntaly
urhe le s n r r ph t t d ntfs r nf m d nd ive ha
pl
e il
t a ofFl i a a non- ordinsha pur ha e tmes r va a i nsfom
hous nds
ordins nd
Fl i a
ve c s d i ha e c to r
W yndha .
m'
'

TheAme d Compl i de i t c a sas
nde
ant fnes he l s :
Al r s d sofFl i and non-e i nt ofFl i who,whiei Fl i pur ha e
l e i ent
orda
r sde s
orda
l n orda, c s d
tm e ha evac tonsf W yndha ' pr rist ta e l a e i Fl i a who ar
i s r
a i or
m s ope te ha r oc t d n orda nd
e
m em be s oft t s f whom Fa r r ac sast Tr t
r
he nzt or
isha e t
he us ee.
De e nt r move t a ton prm a iy ba e on t a lga i i t Am e
f nda s e
d he c i
i rl s d he le tons n he
nded Compl nt
ai .

Pl ntfss e t r nd t a ton b a eDe e n sha no de i t l esabls d t tt
ai if e k o ema he c i ec us f nda t ve t fniey t ihe ha he

amounti c tove s e ee $5, 0
n on r r y xc ds 000,00.
II D i si
. scus on

Un e CAF ad src c u t a j rs ito o e aca sa to i whiht ea u i
d r A, itit o r h s uidcin v r ls cin n c h mo ntn
contoves exc edst s orvaueof$5, 000.28U. C.j 1 2( ( .Addii ly,t
r ry e he um
l
000,
S.
33 d)2)
tonal he

p o osdp an ifca smu te c e 1 0me es 2 U. C. 1 3 ( ()B)2Net e p ry
r p e litf ls s x e d 0 mb r. 8 S. j 3 2d)5 ( . ih r a t
diputst tt b den i on Def nda st e tbls t tt er r m e sofCAFA hasbe
s e ha he ur
s
e nt o sa ih ha hes equie nt
en

me.Se Ltwdyv Al
t e p z . abamaPowe Co.48 F. 11 1 ( 1h Ci.2007)(ttngt t
r , 3 3d 84, 207 1 t r
sai hathe

rmo i gpat b asteb r e o e tbihn tedsrc c u ts u id ci n .Th De e a t
e v n ry e r h u d n f sa ls ig h itit o r'j rs ito ) e fnd ns
mus pr t a ounti c r r y a t sz oft pr e cls b apr ponde a of
t ove he m
n ontove s nd he i e he opos d a s y
e
r nce
t e de e.1 a 1
he vi nc d. t 208. Pl ntf sdo notdiput t tt c a sszewile e 1 m e r .
ai if
s e ha he l s i
l xce d 00 mbe s
Howeve ,t y do diput De e nt 'esi eoft cls szea i i us d t ca c a et
r he
s e f nda s tmat
he a s i s t s e o l ult he
am ounti c r r y.
n ontove s

Thea o i c r r yca be fci l a r ntfom t pl di is f t ve whe
m unt n ontove s n a aly ppa e r he ea ng tel, k n
e
n

t c
he ompli doesnotcli a s cii a
a nt
a m pe fc mountofda
mage . Roe v M ihelnNorhAme ia,
s'
'
. c i
t
rc

I c, 3F.d 1 5 ,1 61( 1hCi. 01 )(n en lq otto o te & ctto o te )
n .61 3 0 8 0 1 t r 2 0 itr a u ain mi d iain mitd .
t
Unders h cr m sa es a diti c t a ma t e onabl de tons r as bl
uc icu t nc , srct our m y ke i as
r
e duc i , e ona e
i e enc s orot rr a ona e e r poltonsfo t pladi t de e mi wheheri i
nf r e ,
he e s bl xta a i r m he e ngs o t r ne
t ts

fcilya rntt tac ei rmova e. I a 1 - (ntr lquotton o te & ct in
a al ppae ha as s e bl ' d t 06162 i ena
'
ai mitd iato
omitd)
te .

z e to 1 3 ( )c n an oh r u idcin l r rq iie t tas mu t eme i o d r
s cin 3 2 d o tis te j rs ito a p ee u st s ha lo s b t n r e
t r
o emove ac s fom saecour.Howeve ,t ea enota is e he e.
a e r tt
t
r hos r
t su r
3

I t s c s ,t a ounti c r r y i f i ly a r ntf om t A m e d Com pl i .
n hi a e he m
n ont ove s s ac a l ppa e r he
nde
a nt

Pa a a 1 oft Ame dCompli saes i pat(ll a
r grph 0 he nde
ant tt ,n r,ithe mountofe h i vi cli
ac ndi dual am

i c nr ves e c e $1 ,0 0 , x lsv o itr s a dc ss' ( mp a i a d d .Th
n o to ry x e ds 50 0.0 e cu ie f n ee t n o t. e h ss d e ) e
'
Am e d Compli f t rsae ,a pa a a 26,' antfsa ei onne and bei vet t
nde
ant urhe t ts t r gr ph ç i if r nf
Pl
d
le ha
po e ilyt a ofFl i a a non- ordi nsha pur ha ed tm e ha e va atonsfom
t ntal hous nds
ordins nd
Fl i a
ve c s i s r c i r

W yn m . Thus $1 000 i da
dha '
'
, 5, n mage pe i vi lcl m tmes1 orm or i vi
s r ndi dua ai i
000,
e, ndi dual
cas me be s i $1 000, i dn a s welove t $5 00 000 tle hol f CAFA
l s m r s 5, 000 n m ge , l r he , 0, lr s d or

j rs cin.
u idito 3
Pl i if ar t tt al ga in i pa ag a 1 r ga di t a ountoft c am swa
antfs gue ha he le to n r r ph 0 e r ng he m
he l i
s
m e ntonl t r f rt t ca msoft name Pli if a whe r a t gehe wih ot r
a
y o e e o he li
he
d a ntfs nd
n e d o t r t he
al g i nsde onsr t t tt alegai we e o ym e ntt s tsy sat cr ui co t e i
le ato
m ta e ha he l tons r nl a o ai f t e ic t ur pl ad ng

a dj rs ito r q ie n s Co tayt P an if'a srin ,ha i n twh thealg to s
n u id cin e urme t. nrr o litfs se t s t t s o a t le ain
o
s y.Pl ntfs a gum e i f rhe unde mi byt f tt ,e s wher i t Amende
a
ai if ' r
nt s u t r
r ned he ac hat l e
e n he
d
Compl i ,Pl ntfss cii al r e t t hena e Pli if 'and S opos d Cl s
ant ai if pe fc ly ef r o ç
t
m d antf s'
i
pr e as

Re e e atves't , akng i c e rt tPl i if kne ho t a di i f c ,ditnguih
pr s nt i ,'hus m i t l a ha antfs w w o, nd d n a t si s
bewe t na e Pl n if andt pl ntf cas . Pli tf sdi notma s h aditnc i i
t en he m d aitfs
he ai if l s a n if d
ke uc
si ton n
3 hi cac a i i c e v tvebe a et Am e d Compl ntsaest tea h
' s lulton s ons r a i
F
c us he
nde
ai t t ha c

i vi lca m e e $1 000 a t Am e
ndi dua li xce ds 5, nd he
ndedCompli c ansfves pa a ecount
a nt ont i i e r t
s
s e ngm o y da ges Thus e h c a smemberal ge y ha fve s r t c am swih e c
e ki
ne ma .
, ac l s
le dl s i epa a e l i
t ah

cai worh$1 000.Thus e hca sme rhascli wihda ge t ai $75, ( x
l m t 5,
, ac ls mbe
ams t ma s otlng 000 5
$1 000 andt r aemor t n 1 cls me r.
5, ) hee r
e ha 000 a s mbes
Furhe m or e i t Cour r dpar gr ph 10asa yi onl t t na e
t r e, ven f he
t ea
a a
ppl ng y o he m d
Pli if ,t Ame d Compli a s a lgest t na
antfs he
nde
ant lo le hat he med Pli tf s c am sa et ca o
a n if ' l i r ypi l f
t cl m s oft cl s m e be s Thus i or rt m e tt t pi alt r r m e oft c a s
he ai
he a s m r .
, n de o e he y c iy equie nt he l s

a gi n t na ur oft cl ms t cons r tve $l 000 a o toft na e Pl n if '
nd ve he t e he ai , he
e vai
5, m un he m d aitf s
a lge da a ss d besm ia t t a
le d m ge houl
i lr o he mountoft da a soft o he cl smembe s
he m ge
he t r as
r.

Thi t woul m e n t tt n o ti co r ry e e t $5, 000 r uie e
s oo
d a ha he m un n ntove s xc eds he 000, eq r m nt

( 5, x 1000=$1 000, .
$1 000 ,
5, 000)
4

pa a r ph 1 Ba e on t Am e d Compli t t a o i c r r y i f cily a r nt
r g a 0. s d he
nde
a n , he m unt n ontove s s a a l ppa e .

Eve i t Cour we e t a ce Pl i if 'a g e t tt amounti c tove s i
n f he
t r o c pt antfs r um nt ha he
n on r ry s
no f c al a e fo t Am e d Compli ,Def nda shavesilesa ihe
t a i ly ppar nt r m he
nde
ant
e nt
tl t bls d

j rs it n. anif ag eta teca ssz alg to i teAme d d Co liti n t
u idci Plitfs r u h t h ls ie l ai n n h
o
e
n e mpan s o
s fce t esabls cls szea t r y,c c ae t a ounti c r r y.Ac di t
ufi int o t ih a s i nd, he eb alul t he m
n ontove s
cor ng o
Pli if ,Def nt 'da aa tsi
antfs
enda s t nd e tmony,s it d wih t Re ova notc ,do notce l
ubm te t he m l i e
lary
esabls c a sszebe aus t dat us d di no m ac t c a sde i ton.Howe r i
t ih l s i
c e he a e d t th he l s fnii
ve , n
r pons t Pl ntfs M oton t Re a De e nt s it d addii ldaaand t tmony.
es e o ai if ' i o m nd, f nda s ubm te
tona t
esi
Pl ntfshav notpr ded a e de t r
ai if
e
ovi
ny vi nce o ebutDe e
f ndant e de ebutha i t d,
s' vi nc
ve, nsea

ag e ta Dee d n s e ie ei i u fce t oe tbls u idito Th Co r fnd
r u d h t fn a t' vd nc s ns fiin t sa ihj rs cin. e u t i s
ot r s De e nt ha pr e e da aa t si onyi c tngt t43, 0 c r we e
he wie. f nda s ve es nt d t nd e tm
ndia i ha 21 ontads r
sgne i Fl i durng t cas pe i d. W hie Def nda sc d notdefniey saet tt s
i d n orda i he l s ro 4
l
e nt oul
i t l tt ha he e
co r twe e sg i Fl i ,t y esabls d t tt y wer sgne t s m eda a t y we e
ntac r i ned n orda he t ihe ha he
e i d he n
y s he
r

c e tda Dee d nt' lrd slsc ne a dta t o ewhemigmao iyo De e d n s
rae t fn a s F o ia ae e tr n h t he v r l n j rt f fn a t'
busnes i f c t f ceta a i ns
i s s a e-o-a r ns cto .Thus De e
, f ndan sha esa ihed b apr ponde a eof
t ve tbls
y
e
r nc
t e de et tt cls szee e dst r quie e sofCAFA a i f ct e e ds 1
he vi nc ha he a s i xc e he e r m nt
nd, n a , xc e 000

cas me be s Ba ed on t br d al ga i i pa ag a 1 oft Am e d Compli t t
l s m r. s
he oa le tons n r r ph 0 he
nde
a n ,he

4 ai if a guet tma oft e c r c sdo notm e tt cl sde ton be a et y
pl ntfs r
ha ny hes onta t
e he as fnii
c us he
a e f S pg a s' De e nt r s nd t tupg ade f l wihi t cls dei ton. TheCour
r or l r de .' f nda s e po ha
u
r s al t n he a s tnii
t
fndst ta t spoi i tmei ne no a es t sis bec us e n i upg ade do notf l
i ha t hi nt n i t ed t ddr s hi s ue a e ve f r s
al
wihi t ca sde i to De e nt ha pr s e evi ncet t40% oft i busne si fr t
t n he ls fnii n, f nda s ve e entd de
ha
her i s s is
tmepur ha e s Thus t swoul mea t t1 284 c r c sttPli tfs i t r e a i oft
i
c sr .
, hi
d
n ha 7,
onta t i a n if ' n e pr t ton he
d i ton oft cas . Thi woul silcr a eac a ss t intt m e tt amounti
efnii
he l s
s
d tl e t l s ufk e o e he
n
co r ry r quie e tofCAFA bas d on t al ga i oft Am e d Co pl nti t
ntove s e r m n
e
he le tons he
nde
m ai f he

i vi lcli swe e onl t s lamountof$290 ea h.
ndi dua am
r y he mal
c
5

a
mounti c r r y r quieme ofCAFA ha be n m e .
n ontove s e r nt
s e
t5

Ac o dn l h vngc n iee t emo in,heDee d n s o o i o ( 5 ! a d
c r igy, a i o sd r d h to t
fn a t' pp st n DE- 7 , n
i
Plitfs rpy ( 6 ) a df r h ra o s t o t a o e i i h r b
anif' e l DE- 4 , n o t e e s ns e f rh b v ,t s ee y
ORDERED t t anif' oi nt Re n g 45 i DENI
ha Pli tfs M to o ma d DE- ) s
ED.

DONEAND ORDERE i Mimi d Co ny t i 4 1 a o F bur, 0 2
D n a - e u t hs
Da
y f eray 2 1 .
,

*

PATRI A A . I
CI
T
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Copi sf ni hed t
e ur s
o:
Al c
l ouns ofr cor
el e d

s Cou ta s fndsi t li t tPl i if ha no si aed t tt a o toft i
The r l o i t elng ha antfs ve t tpult ha he m un
he r

da esdo note e $5, 000.
mag
xce d 000,
6