Perret et al v. Wyndham Vacation Resorts, Inc. et al
Filing
68
ORDER granting 14 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim; denying 14 Motion for More Definite Statement. Plaintiffs may file a second amended complaint by 3/19/12. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 3/5/12. (tp)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Cas No.11 CV- 904-SEI SI ONTON
e
- 61
TZ/ M
HARRY PERRET a
nd
M ELW DA PERRET,i vi l
ndi dualy,
a on be l ofa1t e sm ia l st t d,
nd
haf 1 hos i l ry iua e
Pl ntfs
ai if ,
VS.
W YNDHAM VACATI RESORTS,I , al,
ON
NC.et .
De e nt .
f nda s
/
ORDER GM NTI G M OTI TO DSI I
N
ON
M SS
THI CAUSE i bef r t Cour ont t Def nda s'M otont Dim is ori t
S
s o e he
t he wo e nt
i o s s , n he
Al r ai , o aM o eDei ieSae n E 1 ) Plitfs r s o e( 5 )1 n
t n tve fr
e
r fnt ttme t DE-4 , anif' e p ns DE- 8 ,a d
i
ie n he r t
he
Dee d n s r py( 6 j Thi put tvecl ssacton wasfld i t Cicui Courtoft
fn a t' e l DE- 5 . s ai a
Se nt nt J c a Cic ti a d f Br wa d Co y, orda.De e nt r m ove t a ton
ve ee h udii l r ui n n or o r unt Fl i
f nda s e
d he c i
t t sCou tba e on t Cl sAci Faine sAc . Pl i if 'A me d Compl i a iesout
o hi
r s d he as ton r s t antf s
nde
ant rs
oft s l a m a eme oftmes r va ton pr risi Fl i Pl n if as e t ha t
he a e nd nag nt i ha e cai
ope te n orda. aitfs s r t t he
s l ta a i we em iladi a dec ptvea t tt m a ge e cossa s s d by
a e r ns ctons r se ng nd e i nd ha he na m nt t s es e
De enda sa e e es i a unr as bl De e nt s ekst dim isa1c soft
f nt r xc sve nd e ona e. f nda s e
o s s 1 ount he
Ame d Compli f rf iur t sa eaca eo a ton upon whih r i c n begr nt or i
nde
ant o al e o t t
us f c i
c elef a
a ed , n
t at m a i De e nt s e am or de t sae e . Be a e Pli if ha f ie t
he le tve, f nda s e k
e fnie t tm nt c us antf s ve al d o
l Cour not st tPli if 'r s e i l saCe tfcae ofGood Faih
'
rhe
t e ha antfs e pons ncude
rii t
t
Conf r nc ,whih sae t tt
et e
c tt s ha d r i ne c
unde sg d ouns lf pl i if c e r wih couns f
e or antfs onf red t
el or
def nt,a i aut i d t r pr entt de e nt a eet t is nceoft r le
enda s nd s horze o e es hat f nda s gr o he s ua
he ei f
pli if r que ther i Thi i c e ry no a a c a e sa e e .TheCour c utonsPl i if '
antfs e s en. s s l a l t n c ur t t t m nt
ta i
antfs
couns t m a s ea lf ur s
el o ke ur 1 ut e ubmisonsa c aey s tf t t cr um sanc oft i flng.
si
c ur t l e orh he ic t es her ii
a uaey pl d t rc am s De e nt 'moton t dim isi g a ed wih la f rPli if
deq t l ea hei l i , f nda s
i o s s s r nt
t e ve o antfs
t r plad c it ntwih t die tonsi t sOr r
o e e onsse
t he r c i n hi de .
Fac s A le d i C om pl i
t l ge n
a nt
Dee d n W y ha Va ainReo t,n . Wy h m)a vets s s ls a dma a e
fn a t nd m c to s rs I c ( nd a d rie , el, n n g s
tme h r p o e t si F o ia Dee d n Far h r Va ainOwn r As o ito ( is ae
i s ae r p ri n l rd . fn a t is a e c to
e
e s s cain Far h r)
i t tuse f t be fcire oft W yndha Tr t whih c it oft owne sof
s he r t e or he ne i a i s he
m us , c onsss he
r
tm e ha epr risowne by W y ham . ai if ge r lyaleget tDe enda swe e
i s r ope te
d
nd
Pl ntfs ne al l ha f nt r
de e i a mil a ng i t rs e a ma ge toftm es r pr pe tes Spe fc l
c ptve nd se di n hei al nd na men
i ha e o ri . cii aly,
Plitfs Ame d dCo litalg ssx c usso a t n: 1 e utb erle a an t o h
anif ' n e mp an l e i a e f ci ( ) q ia l eif g is b t
e
o
Dee d n s ( )b e c o fd cayd t a ans F is r ; 3 b e c offd cayd t a an t
fn a t; 2 ra h f iu ir uy g i t ar hae ( ) r a h i u ir uy g i s
W y ha ()voaino Flrd ' De e t a Un arTrd P a tc sAc ( DUTP
nd m;4 ilto f o ias c pi nd fi a e r cie t F
ve
A)
a an tW y d m; 5 b e c o c nrd a an tb t Dee a t; n ( )fa db W y d a
g i s n ha ( ) ra h f o ta g i s oh fnd ns a d 6 ru y n h m.
TheAm e
nded Compl i a l ge t tDe e nt madem il a ng r pr s n a i a
ant le s ha f nda s
se di e e e t tons nd
omisonsprort and d i t s eoft tm e ha e whih m ir pr e e t a t lnaur
si
i o
urng he al he i s r s, c s e es ntd he c ua t e,
i ntt a fna i land lgalc e nce oft s ea t r s c i rght , i tons
de iy, nd i nc a
e
ons que s he al nd he e pe tve i s oblga i ,
a dute oft pa te a ii fom t s l Def nda scha a t rze t tans c i a a
nd is he ri s rsng r he ae. e nt
r e e i d he r a ton s
smpl purha eofatm e har va to butt pur has i bundl d wihi a c
i e c s
i s e cai n
he c e s
e t n ompl x a
e nd
c usng s tofta a tonswhi h r lt t fna il mana men ,m ant na
onf i e
r ns c i
c e ae o i nca ,
ge t i e nce,r t a ot r
tus, nd he
l alr ltons psa o i a i nsunde tke by t pur has ra s l r Bym ir pr e i
eg e a i hi nd blg to
ra n he c e nd ele .
se es ntng
t naur oft ta a tons Def nda si e Pl ntfst e e i o fna i l one ous
he t e he r ns c i , e nt nduc d ai if o nt r nt i ncaly r
r l tons ps
e a i hi .
Thes etans tona t lyivol smuli eta a tons ( )t purhaea s l ofa
al r aci cual n ve
tpl r ns ci : 1 he c s nd ae
2
fa to a fesmpeitr s i r a e tt ;2 t eta se o tefesmpeitrs t a
rcin l e i l ne et n e l sae () h rn fr f h e i l n eet o
W yn m co r l tus;()a a sg ntoft nt't t purhasrwhihca betade
dha ntoled r t 3 n s inme
' s'o he c e c n r d
poi
f rv c to tmea c ranW y d a o e p o e t s ( )a a re n b p rh srt e g g
o a ain i t e ti n h m wn d r p ri ; 4 n g e me t y u c a e o n a e
e
W y d a c nr le p o e t ma a e sa dt p yte fe ; 5 a a re n t pa mo tl
n h m-o to ld r p ry n g r n o a h m e s () n g e me t o y nhy
man e a c fe t W y d a p o e t ma a es a ( )arln us me t rwav rb t e
itn n e e s o n h m r p ry n g r; nd 6 eiq ih n o ie y h
pur ha e oft rg t feey s l t i tm e ha ei e es wihoutgvi W yndham t fr t
c s r he i ht o r l el her i s r nt r t t
i ng
he is
rgh o r f a on a tans c i n. Pli if a lget tt s a ee t e i ty i pos
i t f e us l ny r a to z antfs le ha he e gr men s xplcil m e
upon Def nda sva i fducir d i a o i tons3 Pl i if a s ale t tFl i 1w
e nt rous i a y utes nd blga i . antfs lo l ge ha orda a
i o e fd ca yd te o Dee d ns s e i al, o iaSauej5 .01
mp s s i u ir u is n fn a t, p cfc ly Fl rd tt t 012 .
Afert cl i oft ta a tons De e nt begi c lc i t f sa c t
t he osng he r ns c i , f nda s
n ole tng he ee nd oss
a s a e wih t tmes r ownerhi Pl i if a s tt tt ef esa c t a e s
s ocit d t he i ha e
s p. antfs s er ha hes e nd oss r o
e c si , n e s n bl, ndu r ltdt Dee d n s a t a c ssa de pe s sa t u j ty
x e sve u ra o a e a n eae o f n a t' cu l o t n x n e s o nusl
e rc De e
n i h f ndan sa i pos a e r me derme on Pli if
t nd m e n xte
ti nt
antfs.
Pl i if i r a eeve ypro al ga i i o e c c
antfs nco por t
r i r le ton nt a h ountoft Ame d Compli .
he
nde
ant
I a ton t t pr ce nga l a i ,CountIoft A me d Com pl ntal ge t tPli tf s
n ddii o he e di leg tons
he
nde
ai le s ha a n if
wi s fe irp r beh r i Dee d nsaen te j ie fo c ni igt s ltmeh rs
l u f r re a a l a m f f n a t r o n on d r m o t n o el i s a e
l
nu
z ai if havenotatac d t a e nt t t Ame d Compl nta t Amende
pl ntfs
t he he gr eme s o he
nde
ai nd he
d
Compl i doe no s to whi h pa tese e e i t whih a r e t .Toac e t goa of
ant s t e ut c ri nt r d n o c g e men s
hi ve he l
Rue 1o t eFe ea Rue o Cii P o e u e t j s, p e y a d ie p n ier s l t no
l f h d r l ls f vl r c d r ,he u t s e d , n n x e sv e o ui f
o
ev yaci n, a nded c
er to any me
ompl i mus a t h t c r t a is a Pl ntfsm us
ant t tac he ontacs t s ue nd ai if
t
i ntf t pr sonsoft c r t on whi h t i cli sr s .
de iy he ovii
he ontacs
c her am e t
3 pr ousynot d, ai if ha notat c d t ag ee nt t t Ame ed
As evi l e Pl ntfs ve
ta he he r me s o he
nd
Co pl nt TheAm e
m ai .
nded Com pl ntalo doe nots tou a lng
ai s
s
e t ny a uagefom t ag e ment
r he r e
s
t ti
ha mpos a fduc ay d y o Fa r e.Pli tf sha s tf t asngl c a eofoneoft
es i i r ut n ishar
a n if ve e orh i e l us
he
a e m e s whih t y a lgei pos afd a y dut on W yndham .
gr e nt , c he le m e
ucir
y
u igterc re tmeho sa di Dee d n saen te j i e fo c ni un t i os
sn h i u rn t d n f fn a t r o no n d r m o tn ig o mp e
8.1 ( )a
i lt d mana me a mant na f es Co n 1 alg st a Flrd Stt t j71 1 1 1()
nfa e
ge nt nd i e nce e . u t 1 le e h t o i a aue
pr de t ofi r a die or ofc
ovi s hat fce s nd r ct s ondomi um a s a i ha afducir r l tons p t
ni s ocitons ve i a y e ai hi o
owne sa t tFar r ha b e c isfducir dute t Pl ntfs4 Countl1a lgest t
r nd ha isha e s r a hed t i a y is o ai if .
l le
ha
W y d a h dafd cayd t , ru n t t a re n sa dF o iaS au ej7 .32 () t
n h m a i u ir u y pu s a t o he g e me t n l rd ttt 21 1 ()a ,o
Pli if and t W y
antfs
hat ndha br a he t dut CountI a lgest W y ha adve ts a
m e c d hat y.
V le hat nd m
ries nd
s lstmes r sbym a ng a tr tvem ir pr e ai a omisonsofm aera i onua i
el i ha e
ki fi ma i
s e es nt tons nd
si
t il nf
ton
r r ng t vaue oft tmes r a ot rpe tnentde a l andt ts h a t c tt e a
ega di he l
he i ha es nd he ri
t is
ha uc c s onsiut n
t arm eho ofco pe ii unc cona e a t a un ara de e i pr c i . Coun V
mf i t d
m tton, ons i bl c, nd f i nd c ptve a tce
t
a lgest De e
le hat f ndan sbr a he t ag e ment byf ii t pe f m t rm a ge e a
t e c d he r e
s alng o ror hei na m nt nd
tuse r ponsbiii a a s h, vevi ae t i i d c na o goo f ih a f i
r t e es i ltes nd, s uc ha
ol td he mple ove nt f d at nd a r
de lng. Fi ly,CountV1a lge t tW yndha ma knowi y f le sae e sabou t
a i s na l
le s ha
m de
ngl a s t tm nt
t he
pr ia lt a val oft tm e ha es t tW yndha kne t tPl n if woul r s bl
oft biiy nd ue he i s r ,ha
m
w ha aitfs
d ea ona y
r y o t mir pr s nt i ns a t tPl ntfsr i on t em ir pr en a i by e erng
el n he se e e ato , nd ha ai if eled hes se es t tons nt i
i o t a e m e s whih t y woul notot r s ha e e ed i o.
nt he gr e nt , c he
d
he wie ve ntr nt
l.
I
M oto To Dim isSt
in
s s andar
d
Thepur e ofamoton t dim isfl purua t Fe r lRul ofCi lPr d e
pos
i o s s ied s nt o de a
e
vi oce ur
1 b)6 i t t tt fcils fce ofac ant Ther epemisdimis lofac ant
2( ( ) s o es he a a ufiincy
ompli .
ul r t s sa
ompli
t tf ist sae acli upon whih r le ca begr nt d. l s d ber ad aongsde Fe r l
ha al o t t
am
c e if n
a e t houl
e l i
de a
4 Am e d Co antdoe notal get tFar r wasan ofi rordiecorofa
The
nde
mpli
s
le ha isha e
fce
r t
ny
c
ondom i um as oc a i
ni
s i ton.
s Ame d Compl ntdo no s touta y s cii c r tpr sonsa lge y
The
nde
ai es t e
n pe fc ontac ovii
le dl
vi a e by De e nt.
olt d
f nda s
4
Rul ofCi lPr e e8()2) whi r quiesat ho'a pli saeme oft cai s ng
e
vi oc dur a ( , ch e r t l nd an tt nt he l m howi
s t
t a t pe d ri e tte t r le . Al ug ac mp an c alng db aRue 1 ( )6 moi n
h the la e s n ild o eif' t h o lit h l e y l 2 b ( ) to
' ho
e
t dimi sdoesnotne d de al d f c ua al gai ,apl ntf i siloblga e t pr det
o s s
e t ie a t l le tons
ai if s tl i t d o ovi he
f c ua tg ou ' f hi e il me t r le ,a ac us yort o m ul cr ia i oft
a t l tr nds' or s ntte nt o e if nd oncl or
d r ai ect ton he
f
ee
lment ofac eofa ton wilnotdo. Be l l i Cor v Twombl 550U . 544,555
s
aus
ci
l
' l Atantc p. .
'
y,
S.
(
2007)
.
W h n ac mpan i c l ng du d rRue 1 ( )6 , c u t lp e u t a al
e o lit s hal e n e l 2 b ( ) a o r wi r s me h t 1
e
l
we lpl de a lga i a et u a vi w t pladi i t lghtm os f vo a et t
l- ea d le tons r r e nd e he e ngs n he i
t a r bl o he
panif Ame ia UntdL# I s Co v Ma tn z 4 0F.d 1 4 ,1 6 ( 1hCi. 0 7 .
litf. rc n i
e
n . . . rie , 8 3 0 3 0 6 1 t r 2 0 )
Howe r onc a c tide ii spla ngst t bec us t y a eno m or t n c l i ,a e
ve , e our çi ntfe e di ha, a e he r
e ha onc usons r
note il t t a s
ntted o he s umpto oftut ' i mus deer i whe he t we lpld f c sS t t a
i n r h, t t t m ne
'
t r he l- e a t s ae
s
cai t r le t ti pl usbl o isf ce' As r .j v I b l 1 9 S. .1 3 ,1 4 ( 0 9 .
l m o ei f ha s a i e n t a . hc o t . q a s 2 Ct 9 7 9 9 2 0 )
'
c mplitc no ys l v a1 ( )6 moint ds s i i c n an fcu l le ain ta ae
o an a nl uwi e 2 b ( ) to o imis f t o tis a t a alg to s h t r
t nough t r i earg t r le a ve t s cultvel ve ,ont a s ptont ta 1 he
s
e
o a s i ht o ei f bo he pe a i e l
he s um i ha l t
ga t a)alg to i t ec mpan aetu . T mby, 5 U. a 5 5.Ho v r awelp e
fcu l l ains n h o li t r r e' wo l 5 0 S. t 5
e
'
we e , l ld
-
c mplits r v samoint ds s ' v n i i srk sasv j g ta a t a p o fo t e e
o an u vie
to o imis d e f t tie a vy ud e h t cu l r o f h s
e
f t i i o bl a tha ar cove y i ver r mot a unlkey.' Twombl 550 U . a
acs s mpr ba e, nd t t e
r s y e e nd i l ''
y,
S. t
556.
1 1 D i c s on
1 . s us i
De en nt ha m ove t dim isalc soft Am e d Com pl ntunde Rul
f da s ve
d o s s l ount he
nde
ai
r e
1 b ()a dt efa dc u t f rfiu et c mp ywi Fe e a Rul o Ci i P o e u e9 b .
2()6 n h r u o n s o alr o o l t d rl e f vl r c d r ( )
h
De e nt alo s ek t dim ist Ame ed Compl i bec us i i as t pl di l t
f nda s s e o s s he
nd
ant a e t s ho gun ea ng. n he
5
aler tve,Def nda ss e a mor defniesa e e ast Coun sI, 1,a V. The Co twil
t nai
e nt e k
e i t t t m nt o
t I 11 nd
ur l
a e st c am si t s
ddr s he l i n he ame o de a t pa tesha i t rpa r .
r r s he ri ve n hei pe s
W. Co n V o Br a ho nr c i Dimis d
u t f r e c fco ta t s s s e
Dee t movet dimisPli if bra h ofc r c cli f t e r s :( )
fndans
o s s antfs' e c
onta t am or hr e eaons 1
Pl i if di no at ch ac oft c r c sa is t t Am e d Com pl nt a r quie
antfs d t ta
opy he onta t t s ue o he
nde
ai , s e r d
b Fl i Rul o Ci lPr ce e1.30() ( t Amende Compl n doesnotstoutan
y orda e f vi o dur 1 a ; 2) he
d
ait
e
y
s cfcc rcua pr sonst tDeenda t ha br c a ()t eli i l a
pe ii onta t l ovii ha f ns ve ea hed; nd 3 he am ncudes n
al gai n t tDe e nt ha br a he t i i d c na ofg f ih a f i de lng
le to ha f nda s ve e c d he mple ove nt ood at nd a r a i
wihouts ciyi how De e nt ha br c t co r c s Pl i if r pond t tt
t
pe f ng
f nda s ve ea hed he nta t . antfs es
ha he
Fe r lRulsofCi lPr e e d no r quiet t a t h t c r c st t Am e d
de a
e
vi oc dur o t e r hem o tac he onta t o he
nde
Co anta t tt Ame d Compl i ha a qua ey pld abr c oft c
mpli nd ha he
nde
ant s de t l e
ea h he ovena tof
n
g f t a f rdeai 6
ood aih nd ai lng.
Unde Fl rdal w t Cd y o good f t m us r lt t t peror nc ofa e e s
r o i a he lut f
aih
t ea e o he f ma e n xpr s
tnn oft c r c a i nota a ta a i pende t m ofa c r twhi h ma be
e
he onta t nd s
n bsr ct nd nde
nt er
ontac
c
y
a s re a as c ofbr a h whe a1 ot rtr sha be pe f m e purua t t con r c
s e td s our e
ec
n l he e m
ve en ror d s nt o he ta t
rq rme t. Hopi lCop.fAme iav Flrd M e ia Ce tr I .71 S 2 5 3, 7
e uie ns' s t r o
'
a
rc . o ia dc l n e, nc, 0 o. d 7 5 5
( a. hDCA 1 .Thecove ntofgood f t ofe c si oplywhe unde t pa tes
F1 4t
998)
na
aih tn ome nt a
n, r he ri '
c r c ,i pa t hast powe t m a a dic e i r de i i wiho de i d sa ds'
onta t t
one ry
he
r o ke s r tona y c son t ut fne tndar .
'
Pu l S pe M a k t,I c v Wi e Cop o lwa e 8 6 S 2 6 2, 5( 1 . dDCA
b i u r r es n . . l r r fDea r , 7 o. d 5 65 F a 2
x
d
2004)
.
Coun V oft Am e d Compli a lgest tDe e
t
he
nde
ant le ha f ndant as e s d e s i f es
s s s e xce sve e ,
Y a e on Pli if r pons t t moton,i a ar t tt onl br ac ofc r c
sd
a ntfs' es e o he i t ppe s ha he y e h onta t
al ge by Pl i if i abr a h oft cove nto goodf ih a f i de lng.
le d
antfs s e c
he
na f
at nd a r a i
6
ove sae t a t lma ke val ofs r ce ,a c r i e e ton f
r t td he c ua r t ue e vi s nd ha ged nt r s
undst tdo note s.
ha
xit
Th Ame e Co lit o d sn fcu ld tist s p o the ea j cia c n lso sa t
e nd d mp an prvie o a t a eal o u p r t s d e tv l o cu in s o
% e sve' nd S' r t t d.'M or ove ,t Am e d Co pl ntdoe nots toutwhih oft
d s i 'a çove sa e '
exc
'
e r he
nde
m ai
s
e
c
he
m uli ec r c sbet e t pa tes lta o whih pr sonsoft eco r c s ga
tpl onta t we n he ri ,e l ne c ovii
hos nta t , ve
De e
f ndan st dicr ton t do t s t ngs Norha Pl i if pld how De e n sf ie t
t he s ei o he e hi .
ve antfs e
f nda t a ld o
c ry ou i g f t a pa tc arpr vii ofacon r c .W ihoutt si or a i Pli tfs
a r t n ood aih
ri ul o son
ta t t
hi nf m ton, a n if
ha no saed ac e ofa ton f br ac oft co na ofg f ih.Cons que l Coun
ve t t t
aus
c i or e h he ve nt ood at
e nty,
t
V i dimi s d wih lavet r e d,i t r a ef t t s
s s se t e
o epla f he e r acs o uppor t s alegai .
t he e l tons
#.Pl it ' a dCl m,Co n V i Dimis d
ants Fr u ai u t L s s s e
Def nda sm ovet dim isCo tV1oft Am e
e nt
o s s un
he
nded Compl i be us i doe no
ant ca e t s t
c ywiht pa tc aiyr qurme t ofFe rlRul ofCi lPr dur 9b) l r pons
ompl t he riulrt e ie n s dea e
vi oce e ( . n es e,
Pl i if c e t tt y ha notpl t da e, i a pl c oft a l edl fa en
antfs onc de ha he ve
ed he t tme, nd a e he leg y r udul t
rpr e ai ma byDee nt, ,i t d,aser t tt yc nme tt Rul 9(
e esnttons de
fnda s but nsea s tha he a e he e b)
pl di r quie nt by o he mea . Pli if a guet tt pl di r quieme sa e
ea ng e r me s
t r ns antfs r
ha he ea ng e r nt r
' eaxe ' n t f le i or ton i dis m i t dt ough sa r ze co port do
' l d'whe he a s nf ma i s s e na e hr
r
t nda di d r ae cume s
nt ,
whe t De e ntha a mos e usveknowl
n he f nda
s l t xcl i
edgeofa c r ove t f c ua i or a i
nd ontol r he a t l nf m ton
unde l ngt fa orwhe t fa en ta a to a enume ousa t pl c overa
ryi he r uds
n he r udul t r ns ci ns r
r
nd ake a e
n
e e d pe i oftme.
xt nde rod i
Asag n r l ue, l 9b ma b s tsi di ac mp an st f rh:t1 p e ieywh t
e ea r l Rue () y e aite f o lit e s o t $ ) r cs l a
(
saeme soromisonsweema i whihdoc nt oror rpr enttons ( t tmea
tt nt
si
r de n c ume s al e es ai ;2) he i nd
plc o ea hs hsae n a t peronr ponsbl f ma ng( ,nt ca eofomisons
a e f c uc ttme t nd he s es i e or ki or i he s
si ,
notma ng t m;( t contntofs hsae t a t ma ri whiht ymildt
ki ) he 3) he e
uc ttmens nd he nne n c he se he
7
pli if a ( wha t defnda o ai dasaco eque eoft faud.'Fi hatI sor
antf; nd 4) t he e nt bt ne
ns nc he r ' nd*r nvet
Gr u v Fidörat o 6 8F.d1 8 1 9 ( 1hCi. 0 1; e as Srl / v BleCr s d
o p . n h . m, 5 3 2 2, 2 6 1 t r 2 1 ) s e lo ttc . u o s r
c
).
ç
Bl eS il o o ia I c, 1 F.d 1 6 1 71( 1h Ci. 9 7 .Qui smpl Plitfsh v
u hed fFlrd , n .l 6 3 3 4, 3 1 t r 1 9 ) t i y, an if a e
e
notpld CountVlwih t r quie s c fct NorhavePli if pl t rfa cli
e
t he e r d pe ii iy.
antf s ed hei r ud a m
t ough t t elxe ' equie e t on whih t y r l
hr
he ' a d'r r m n s
r
c he ey.
Fis,Pl i if ha notpl i t Am e d Co aitt tDe e nt us d
rt antf s ve
ed n he
nde
mpl n ha f nda s e
sa r ze c por t doc e s c
tnda di d or a e um nt .Se ond, antfs Amende Com pli doesnota lget t
Pl i if '
d
a nt
le ha
De enda t ha e l i c r ove t f cua i o m a i unde l ngt fa l f c , he
f n s d xcusve ontol r he a t l nf r ton
ryi he r ud. n a t t
Amt d Com pli alege , n ac us ym a r t tPl ntfsr ei d m il di
nde
a nt l s i oncl or nne ,ha ai if ec ve sea ng
i or ton a docume s t ,g v ng Pli if a ce st t ale dl faud e ma e i s
nf mai nd
nt ,hus i i
antfs c s o he l ge y r ulnt t ral,
whi h woul e bl Pl ntfst pl a t a l ed fa wih t r quie s cii t Fi ly,
c
d na e ai if o e d he leg r ud t he e r d pe fciy. na l
Pli if do notaleget tt y t k pa t nnume ousfa e tta a tonswih De e nt
a ntfs
l ha he oo r i
r
r udul n r ns c i
t f nda s.
Th ,
us noneoft r s f t S e a d' sa r a y he e. Furhe , he e i no hi i t
he ea ons or he l l xe ' t nda ds ppl r
r
t r t r s t ng n he
pla ngst ti c t t tPli tfsc no s tf rht faud e r pr en a i ma b
e di ha ndia es ha a n if an t e o t he r ulnt e es t tons de y
Def nda s t tm eandplceofs h saeme s who m a t sa e e t t t m , heco e
e nt ,he i
a
uc t t nt ,
de he t t m n s o he t
nt nt
oft saeme s how t saeme sm il Pl i if ,a wha De e nt o ane a ar s t
he t t nt ,
he t t nt sed antfs nd
t f nda s bt i d s e ul
o t fa Cons que l Pli tfsha f l t sa eaca eofa i n f fa a
f he r ud.
e nty, a n if ve aied o tt
us
cto or r ud nd
De enda s moton t dimisi gr n ed a t CountV1 antfsm a r e t i fa c am
f nt ' i o s s s a t s o
.Pli if y eplad he r r ud l i
i t yca s tout( )prciel wha sae t o omisonswe emadei whihdoc nt or
f he n e
1 e s y t ttmens r si
r
n c ume s
or rpr e ai ;( t tmea plc ofea hs hsae
al e esnttons 2) he i nd a e
c uc ttmenta t pes r s i ef
nd he ron e ponsbl or
ma ng( r i t c s ofomisons notma ng t m;( t c en ofs h sae nt a
ki o ,n he a e
si ,
ki ) he 3) he ont t uc ttme s nd
t ma ri whiht mildt pl ntf;a ( wha t dee ntobti d a a
he nne n c hey se he ai if nd 4) t he fnda
ane s
8
c e nc oft f aud.
ons que e he r
C.Pl it '
an p FDUT Cli Co n fqi Dimis d
PA am, u t ) s s s e
De e d n smo et d s s PlitfsFDUTPA cam be a s ( )i d e n tc mpy
fn a t v o imis an if
li c u e: 1 t o s o o l
wi t epe dn rq ie nso Rue9() ( )i d e no s tsytepla igsa d r sst
t h la ig e u rme t f l b ; 2 t o s t aif h e dn tn a d e
h
frh i I a Twombl a ( t da ge algai aei uf in t s ti a
o t n qbal nd
yk nd 3) he ma s le tons r ns sce t o usan
FDUTPA cli .Pli tf s FDUTPA cai i cla l ba e on fa a t cli a l est t
am
a n if '
l m s e ry s d r ud, s he am leg ha
W y d a ç u p s f l a ds se tc lyg d lafr tv mir p e e tto sa d (
n h m s r o eul n y tmaial ma e fimai e se rs n ai n n 1
p
y
o isonsofm aerali or ai n.
m si
t i nf m to '
'
Ru e9b sae t t$inalgngfa o mitk , pat mus saewihp riu ai
l () tts ha 1 ) le i rud r sa e a ry t tt t a t lrt
(
c y
t c r umsa e c tt i fa orm itke. Ther e doe no sa et ti onl ap i t
he ic tnc s onsiutng r ud
sa '
'
ul
s t t t ha t y ples o
c am sf fa i s ysi a i t al gai offa W hienota lc am sunde FDUTPA
l i or r ud; t a t pples o le tons r ud.
l
l li
r
wilbebas d on fa Pli if 'cai i. Cons quen l Pli if 'FDUTPA cli mus be
l
e
r ud, antfs l m s7
e
ty, a ntfs
am
t
pla wih pa tc art a m us me tt s pla ng sa r ass to a
e d t riul iy nd
t e he ame e di t nda d e ut bovei t
n he
dic son oft faud c am ,whi h i doe not Acc di y,hemoton t dim isi gr nt d as
s us i
he r
li
c t s . or ngl t
i o s s s a e
t Co I wih la t r plad.
o unt V t e ve o e e
D. Cou t f rEq ia l Rei sDimis d
n I o ut be le
fi s s e
Dee d n smo et ds s Co n 1f rd caao ya dij n t rle be a e( )i
fn a t v o imis u t o e lrt r n nu ci eif c us 1 t
ve
c nest c t i oo ( i doe nots tce l ale e ilmtntt de aaor r i ;
ombi wo ouns nt ne; 2) t s ufiinty lge ntte
o clrt y elef
a d( )i d e no alg t er q ii ee n sf re tte n t ij nci rle .Plitfs
n 3 t o s t le e h e u st lme t o n ilme to nu t eif an if'
e
ve
Q heCo tr c z st tt r i a s i i t sditi tove whehe ac am unde
ur e ogni e ha he e s plt n hi src r t r l i
r
FDUTPA mu t e t ep e dngrq rme t o Ru e9 b .Co r Lld - r e ov
s me t h la i e uie n s f l ( ) mpa e a o ca r n .
Gui Cor ,2011W L 705403,*5( D. a. 1 (e rngt taFDUTPA cli bepl d
dant p.
S. Fl 201 ) rquii ha
am
ea
i ac or ncewihRul 9( )wih CosaKerne I er i Re ors I .201 W L
n c da
t e b) t t z r nt natonal s t, nc, 1
251
9244,* ( D. a. 1 ( tngt s i i a hort a hol ngt tFDUTPA cli d
2 S. Fl 201 ) noi he plt n ut iy nd di ha
ams o
notha t compl wih Rul 9b) ye,fndi i uf intalgai ofmir e e ai )
ve o
y t e ( , t i ng ns sce le tons
seprs nttons.
9
cli f requiabl r ifdoe no s f t t l ga ba i f t cli .I t i opposton t t
am o
t e ele
s t et orh he e l ss or he am n her
ii o he
m o i t dimis Pli if sa et tt ca m f de a a or r le i bas ont Fl rda
ton o s s , antf s t t ha he li or clr t y ei f s ed he o i
De lrt r J dg n Ac a dF
caao y u me t t n DUTPA a dta t ecam f rij n tv r le i b sdo
n h t h li o n u cie eif s a e n
FDUTPA.Howe r t r i not ng i t Am e
ve ,he e s hi n he
nded Co pl ntt ti ca e t tt esa ut
m ai ha ndi t s ha hes tt es
aet elg l ssf rP an if'cam f rd ca ao yo ij ci rle .
r h e a ba i o litfs li o e lrt r r nun t eif
ve
Pl i if s k adeca ai n t tDefnda t s l pr tc a e fa e t
antfs ee
lr to ha
e n s aes aci es r r udul n ,
u c nsi n be a die utbl.Dee da t mo et d s s tecam frd caao yj g n
n o co a l, n n q i e fn ns v o imis h li o e lrtr ud me t
a
be a et c am a ie fom t s conduc t tf m st bassofPl i if 'br a h of
c us he l i rs s r he ame
t ha or he i
antfs e c
c r c cli a t de l r t y r le i nota ia eunde t Fede alDe l r t r J
onta t am nd hus c a aor ei f s
va lbl
r he
r
c a a o y udgmen
t
Ac . Pl i if r s
t antfs e pondbyar ui t tt i Am e d Compl n i bas on t Fl rda
g ng ha her
nde
ait s ed he o i
De l rt y J m e Ac ,nott f de ala t a on FDUTPA,whih per tdeca a or r le
c a aor udg nt t
he e r c , nd
c
mi lr t y ei f
des t t a ia lt ofot rr le .Howe r not ng i t Am e
pie he va lbiiy
he ei f
ve , hi n he
nded Compli i caes
ant ndi t
t tt Fl i Deca aor J m e Ac a FDUTPA a et ba i ofPl i if 'de l aor
ha he orda
lr t y udg nt t nd
r he s s
antfs car t y
j d me tcam.I fc, litfsha epe as p rt FDUTPA cam, u t V, ihd e
u g n li n a t P an if v ld e aae
li Co n I wh c o s
nots ek de lr t y r i .Gi t l c ofclrt Coun If de l r t yr le i dimis d
e
ca aor elef ven he a k
a iys
t or c a a or ei f s s s e
wih l vet r pl d.H o ve , c us Pl i if a ei f r lc t ha notpr vi l
t ea o e ea
we r be a e antfs r n ede a our and d
e ousy
asere a ca m unde Fl i sDe lr t y J
s td li
r orda' ca aor udgme Ac ,t Fede a Deca aor J
nt t he
r l lr t y udgme
nt
Ac mus bet ba i f a cai SeeGTE Die t e Publs ng Cor v Trme Ame ia,
t t he ss or ny l m
r coris
ihi
p. . i n
rc
I c, 7F.d 1 6 ,1 6 ( 1hCi. 9 )(ttn t tt fd r l caao yJ g n Ac i
n .6 3 5 3 5 7 1 t r 1 95 saig ha he e ea De lrt r ud me t t s
pr du a)
oce r l.
Dee da t mo et d s s tecam f rij n tv r l f c u ePli if h v n t
fn ns v o imis h li o nu cie ei be a s antfs a e o
e
pldt ee n st d mo taearg t oij n t r le a dPlitfsha eno alg dt e
e he lme t o e nsrt ih t nu ci eif n an if v t le e h
ve
10
lc o a a e u t r me ya lw.Pli t f rs o dt thercam f rij n tv r le i
a k f n d q ae e d t a
ani s e p n ha t i li o n u cie eif s
f
br
oughtpu s ntt FDUTPA. Howe r not ngi t Amende Com pli i c est .
r ua o
ve , hi n he
d
a nt ndiat hat
Furhe ,Coun ldoesnota qua ey a l ea c am underFDUTPA t twoul pe m i Pl ntfs
t r
t
de t l leg l i
ha
d r t ai if
t o ti ij n tv r le .Co s q e ty Co n 1i ds se i ise trt wih u prj d c .
o b an nu cie eif n e u n l, u t s imis d n t n iey to t eu ie
E.Pl it ' ai f rBr a ho d car Dîy Co ns1 a dS/ Ar Dimis d
an p Cl ms o e c fFiu i y f , u t 1 n
/
e s se
De e nt a guet tPl ntfs br ac offducir dut c am ss d bedim is
f nda s r ha ai if ' e h i a y y l i houl
s s ed
be a et y a eba r byt ec
c us he r red he onomi l snze t t extntt tt cai sa e ba e on
c os l, o he e ha he l m r s d
dutest ta ief o ac r c ua r l tons p.l r s ns Pli if a s r t tt e
i ha rs r m onta t l e ai hi n e po e, antfs s e t ha he conomi
c
l sl l doesnotbarwel- t bls d ca e ofa ton i t r , uc asbr c offduca ydut
os ' e
u
lesa ihe us s c i n o t s h
ea hes i ir
y,
t e nom i l sr e doe no ba i t ntona t t, ndt e nomi l sr e doe no ba
he co
c os ul
s t r n e i l ors a he co
c os ul
s t r
c us sofa ton whe et dut i c eaedby sa ut o no con r t s ur es Howe r t
a e
ci
r he y s r t
tt e r n- tacual o c .
ve ,he
Ame
nded Co pl nti no c e ra t t ba i oft a lge td ir dut pa tc ary i lg
m ai s t l a s o he s s he le d i uca y y, ri ul l n i ht
ofPl i if 'i or a i ofa1 pr ce ng aleg i nsi o e c c
antfs nc por ton
1 e di l ato nt a h ountoft Am e d
ht
nde
Compli . Be a et bassf t c am si notce ,Def nda s m oton i gr nt wih
ant c us he i or he l i s
lar
e nt ' i s a ed t
l a t r pl d t ba i ofDef nda s fduca y dute a t f cua ba i f t br c of
e ve o e ea he ss
e nt ' i ir
i s nd he a t l ss or he ea h
t edutes H o
hos
i . weve , o t e en t tPl n if 'c am sa ebas d on a br ac ofa c r c ,
r t he xt t ha aitf s l i r
e
e h ny onta t
t camsaeds se wi p eu ie
he li r imis d t rj dc .
h
F.Pl n p ' n e Co an i Dimis da aSh tu Pla n
ait Ame d d mpl its s s e s og n e dig
Fi ly,Pl i if 'Am e d Compli ti ape f c e m pl ofs gun pl di I
na l antfs
nde
a n s re t xa e hot
ea ng. t
i om or t se r al ga i byr e e i o e h s e ntc am f r le .See Wa rv.
nc
a e ve y le ton ef r nce nt ac ubs que l i or e if
gne
Fis Horz nPhar eutc Cor , F. 1 1 ( t Ci.2006) Asars tiii
rt io
mac ial p.464 3d 273, 279 11h r
.
e ul,tt s
vit lyi sbl t know whihal ai offc aei e dt s
rual mposi e o
c leg tons a t r ntnde o uppor whihcli s f
t c amt) or
11
r le . An e s nv Ditit a do r se so nr l o ia Co nt Co lg , 7F.d
eif' d r o . src Bo r fT u te fce ta Flrd mmu i le e 7 3
'
y
364,366( 1hCi.1 ) Bec us i i i sbl t prpel rs
1 t r 996 . a e t s mposi e o o ry e pondt s as t
o uch hogun
pl a ng, ai if 'Ame d Compl i i dimi s d wih la t r pl d i a or nc wih
e di Pl ntfs
nde
ant s s s e t e ve o e ea n cc da e t
t r toft sor r
he es hi de .
Ac r ngl i i he e
co di y, t s r by
ORDERED t tDef nt 'M oto t Dim is ori t Ale nai f aM or
ha
enda s
i n o s s , n he tr tve, or
e
Dei t Sttme t( 1 1i GRANTED i p r a dDENI i p r.
fni ae n DE-4 s
e
n at n
ED n a t
a TheM otont Dimisi GRANTED.Pl ntfsma fl as c a
)
i o s s s
ai if y ie e ond mende c ant
d ompli
i a or ncewih t sOr rby M ar h 19, 2. The Co tc utonsPli if t e ur t t
n cc da
t hi de
c
201
ur a i
a ntfs o ns e ha
t c am ss touti t rs c a e d c
he l i e
n hei e ond m nde ompl i c
ant ompl wih t sor a ha as
y t hi der nd ve ound
f t la l albass
acua nd eg
i.
b)TheM otonfraM or Dei t Sttme i DENI asmoo.
i o
e fnie ae nt s
ED
t
DONEAND ORDERED i MimiDa eCo ny t i X d yo Mac , 01
n a - d u t, hs
a f rh 2 2.
h.
.
*
PA T C1 A EI
A
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Copi f nihedt
es ur s
o:
Al c
l ouns lofr cor
e
e d
12
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?