Beaver et al v. Inkmart LLC et al

Filing 106

ORDER denying 62 Motion to Stay; denying 62 Motion to Compel Signed by Judge Donald M. Middlebrooks on 9/4/2012. (sw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.1 60028- I
2M DDLEBROO KS& M NNO N
ROBERT E.
BEAVER, J ,e Jl,
R. f .
Pli if ,
antfs
m KM ART,LLC , eta1,
.
De e nt.
f nda s
/

ORDER DENYI PLAI FFS'M OTI TO STAY PRO CEEDI
NG
NTI
ON
NGS
AND COM PEL ARBI
TRATI
ON
THI CAUSE c esbef e t Cour on Pli tfsRobt tE.
S
om
or he
t
a n if
r

Be ve,J.Cd ve' a
a r r Bea r' nd
)

I a tof Ne Engand, LLC' (Ne Engl ' (ol tvey
nkm r
w
l
Sd w
ç
and' c l i l , ç ai if' Moton t Sty
) ec
ç ntfs'
pl
) i o a

P o e dn s a d Co lAr irto (ç to ' ( 6 ) tl Jul 24 2012. Def ndant
r ce ig n
mpe b tain l in' DE 2 , ied y
Mo )
e
,
l
nkmar,LLC ttnkmaf' fl isRes e( 74)onAugus 7, 2012,t whih Pl i if fld
t
t
l l l ied t pons DE
t
o c antfs ie
aRe y( 8 )o Au us 1 ,2 2.TheCo r h srv e dt er c r a d i f ly advied i
pl DE 7 n g t 7 01
u t a e iwe h e o d n s u l
s n
t pr s .
he emies

1 BACKGROUND
.
Thi diput ars sfom a Fr nc s Agr e e be we n Pl ntf Be ve and De e
s s e ie r
a hie
e m nt t e ai if a r
f ndan
t
I a tr r ng t pur ha e a m ant na e ofa I
nkm r ega di he c s nd i e nc
n nkmar Fr nc s
t a hie

.

Afe t Fr nc s
tr he a hie

Agr me wa sgned a e utd, Be rcli t the cn t r alze t ts r loft
ee nt s i
nd xec e
ave a ms ha
me o e i ha eve a
he
pr ie a dicl ur t t I
om s s nd s os es ha nkma ta lge y ma t hi
r le dl
de o
m wer m a dii nuousy, a
e de snge
l nd
I a tf ie t c
nkm r al d o ompl wih t dicos er quieme si t Fr nc s Dicos eDoc l e
y t he s l ur e r nt n he a hie s l ur
lm nt
.

W ihi t Fr nc s Ag ee e wasa a bir ton c a e
t n he a hie r m nt
n r ta i l us

,

1

pr di i r l va pa t
ovi ng, n e e nt r :

' he pa te agr e t s i ny clin,c r r y or diput a i i outofor
T
ris e o ubm ta
a r ontove s
s e rsng

rgreem t t i Age me ttnd a tc me t)o t e r lto s i c e td b t s
eaig
A ltn o h s r e n a ta h n s r h eain hp r ae y hi
by Fr ne ttn a yn nd n ste eo icu ig bu no lm ied t , a ca m
a n a d n me me t h r t) n l dn , t t i t o ny li

c s e ora oft c r lng prnc pas
hie , ny he ontoli
i i l
, orpe s
r onscli ng on be f
a mi
hal
of Fr nc s e or t contoli prncpas c e ni t e r i o
a hie
he
r lng i i l, onc r ng he nty nt
pe f
ro
he
, t
m nc
r he e m na i
he
ee nt
b r a e unde ort t r i ton oft Agr me , or a ot rag e m e
ny he r e nt
ewe n Fr nc s oris a sla e a Fr hiee a cl i a i t a pa t or
t e a hior t f it s nd anc s , ny a m ga ns
s
pr e ofi er die t , e oye or ag
es nt fc , r c or mpl e
ent of Fr nc s i udi t e
a hior ncl ng hos
,
oc ur i s e nt t t t r i ton of t s Agr e e s
c rng ubs que o he e m na i
hi
e m nt h
s cfc l s tf t her n and i Secton 20
pe iial e orh ei
y
al, e c pta
lg x e s
l
n
i
.6. ber f re t Ar ta i
2, e e r d o bir ton.''

( e DE 12a j2 5a ) Th e se c a dvaii o t i ca ei n ti d s
Se
- t 0.( ). e xitn e n ldt f h s lus s o n ip
y
u e ( eDE 7
t . Se
4
a 3) (ç ihe pa t ha dipue t vai t of t abirton pr son i te Fr nchi e
t t t r ry s s td he ldiy he r tai ovii n h a s
Ne
Ag e m e o t a i biiy oft FAA i t s a to .
r e nt r he pplca lt
he
n hi c i n

'. Th Pa t s sg e t e F a c ie
'
) e ri in d h rn hs
e

A gr e e on A ugus 11 201 a Be ve pad t l kma tt $200
e m nt
t ,
0, nd a r i o n r he

000 r r d ofhi under
equie
m

,

t ec nrc. ( eDE 5 a ! 2 , 6
h o ta t Se
2 t! 52)
.

On Ja r 6,201 , Plitfsfld terCo an ( 1 a an tDee a t Ik r
nua y
2 anif ie h i mplit DE ) g i s fnd ns n ma t
,

LLC, e Pa a C$ r s' J e Sulv n (t 1 v n', and M aser Fr hie l t nt l
Drw r s Paa ', o l a $ l a '
)
i
Su i )
t
anc s nvesme s nc.
,

Ci F1) algn camsi c n rc a d tr, undert l wsofFl i , Connectcut M ai and
M ', l ig li n o ta t n o t
' e
he a
orda
i , ne,
t Unie Stt . On Fe 'a y 1 201 ,
he td a es
bl r 5, 2 Plitfstld aM oin frClr sDe a l ( 1 )
u
an if ie
to o ek' fut DE 4

a i tM FI a t Clr e ee aClr sDeful ( 1 )t ne da On Aprl9,201 I
gans
, nd he ek ntrd ek' a t DE 5 he xt y
i
2,
a c p e Plitfs Noieo Vo u tr Dimisl( 3 )a t De e d n S lia o
c e td an if ' tc f l na y s sa DE 9 s o fn a t u l n
v
nl (
y. See
DE 4 )
0.
.

Folowi De e nt Pa a 'M o in t Dimis P ru n t Rue 1 ( ( )( 2 )11
l ng f nda
rs
to o s s u s a t o l 2b)2 DE 0 ,

d s se wih u p eu ie te cams a ans De e d n Paa o Jme 6,2012, alowi
imisd t o t rj dc h li g i t fn a t rs n t
l ng
Pl i if tn da t fl a Am e
antfs e ys o ie n
nded Compli .
ant

( eDE 45) Alo onJme6,201 1g a ed
Se
. s
t
2, r nt
I k r' Moton t DimisPl ntfs Compli ( 22) a alwe Pli if t n da t
n ma ts
i o s s ai if'
ant DE 2 nd lo d antfs e ys o

1Pli if fldaRe pons ( 26)t ( 20)onM ar h 12,2012.
antfs ie
s e DE
o DE
c
anif fldaRepo e( 3 )t ( 2 o M ac 1 , 2012.
itfs ie
s ns DE 2 o DE 2) n rh 6

2Pl

rpe d ( e DE 4 ) nmyOr e , bas d ont choi ofl w pr si n i t Pari s'cont
e la . S e
6 .l
dr e
he
ce a ovi o n he te

r ,
act

I ba r d t Pl n if fom a s ri cli s unde t l
r e he aitfs r
s e tng am
r he
a of Cor e tc a M ane, a
ws
m c iut nd
i
nd
dim is d t r mai ng c am sf f iur t c pl wih F
s s e he e ni l i or a l e o om y t

e ea Rueo Cii P o e u e9 b
d rl l f vl rc d r ()
.

L e i..
s e d)
On J 15, 2, l r ne Plitfs Un p s dM oi nf rEx e in o Ti ( 48
une 201 g a td an if ' o po e
to o tnso f me DE )
t fl t r Am e d Compli . ( e DE 49) Fol ng t deay
o ie hei
nde
a nt Se
. l
owi he l , Pl i if fld t r
antfs ie hei

Ame d d Co an ( 5 )a ans I k r a d MFIo J e25 2012. Ahert flng oft
n e mplit DE 2 g i t n mat n
n un ,
he ii
he
Amende Compli t I a ttl a M oton t Dim is Am e
d
a n , nkm r ied
i o s s
nd

e Compl n ( 5 on J y
d
ait DE 4) ul
1 201 a aM oton f SummayJ
0, 2, nd
i or
r udgme ( 56)o J y 1 , 2012. Fi ly on J y 24,
nt DE
n ul 7
3 nal
ul
,

201 Pl i if fl t i t ntM oton t St Pr e ngs
2, antfs ied he nsa
i o ay oc edi

a dCo e Ar i ain ( 6 )4
n mp l bt to DE 2 .
r

1 . DI
I SCUSSI
ON

W hie sae 1w gove ns t i e r t ton a f ma i ofar tai a e ment
l tt a
r he nt m e ai nd or ton
bir ton gr e
s

,

t
he

e or a lt of s a ee e s i gover d by f de all . Empl yers Ins
nf ce biiy
uch gr m nt s
ne
e r aw
o
o Wa s u v
f ua .
BrghtM et S ci te , I ' 251 F. 1 6,
i
al pe alis nc ,
3d 31
.

1 (11h Ci.2001 . The Fe r Ar tai
322 t r
)
deal bir ton
Act(C ' pr dest tabirton agee sis lbe vai, ir vocabl and enfor abl
$
FAA' ovi ha r tai r ment thal
)
ld re
e,
ce e
,

s ve upon s h gr
a
uc oundsa e s a lw o i e t f t r vocai ofa c
s xit t a r n quiy or he e
ton
ny o
n r c .' 9 U. C.
ta t'
S.

j 2 fl e r l o t c u t i t 'io o sy e f r e a re n st abi ae''Hemipherx
. ç' oe f he o rs s o rg r u l n o c g e me t o r t t '
rh
r
s
.

Biph ma,I . v Johanne bur Cons . I s,553 F. 1
o ar
nc .
s g
ol nv .
3d 351

,

1 6 ( 1h Ci. 0 8 ( u tn
3 6 1 t r 2 0 ) q oig

De Witr Re ds I v.Byr 470 U .
an te ynol , nc.
d,

S.21 ,2 ( 9 5 ) Th F h we e ,to sn t
3 21 1 8 ). e AA, o v r t e o
d

3Pl i if r ponde t t M o i t Dimison Aug t1
antfs es
d o he ton o s s
us , 201 a t M o i f Slmm a y
J
2 nd he ton or l r
udgm v on Augus 1 , 201 ( eDEs72, 6)
nt
t0
4
2. Se
7 .
OnM a c 7, 2, a sr t J
r h 201 M gita e udgeAnn E. Vi cis daPr tilSc dulngOr r(
t
una sue
era he i de DE

25 prquii a
her hi ,ha t ri ie l era motons nd m a a
es
1 w ,eo rng, mongot t ngs t t hePa t fl a1pr til i a me or nd of
a ) ri
rt J y 1 201
o ul 6, 2.

r r pari t a bir t whe t y ha nota e d t d
equit tes o r ta e
n he ve
gr e o
o s nordoesi pr ntpa te who do
o,
t eve
ri s
a e t a bir t fom e udi ce t i cli fom t s ope oft
gr e o r ta e r
xcl ng ran a ms r he c
h
erar ta i n a e m e .''
i bir to gr e nt

V l If . cs, n . . .o n . fLea dStn o dl Uni. 489U .
o t n o S i.I c v ## fl s o l n a f r r v ,
r
S
.

Am.Ex e sFi . Advior ,I .v M akar wiz,
pr s n
s s nc .
e c

.

46 ,4 8( 9 9 ; c o d
8 7 1 8 )a c r

1 2F.d 9 6 9 0( 1hCi. 9 7 .
2 3 3 , 4 1t r19 )

W he consde i a m oton t c
n
i rng
i o ompe a bir ton, t FA A die s t tt moton be
l r ta i he
r ct ha he
i
g antd i a diti tc ti s tsi d t tt pa te a e t a bir t t eunde l ng i s
r e f src our s aife ha he ris gr ed o r ta e h
ryi s ue

.

See

9U. C. 3; c o dFl. a. 6 20 ()(t p ryt a a r e n o pr v so f rar taton
S. j a c r a Stt j 8 .3 1 1 a t o n g e me t r o iin o bir i
A
s be tt ti 1w camig te n ge to r f s lo a oh rpa t te eot c mpy t er wih
u j c o h s a li n h e lc r e u a f n t e ry h r t o o l h e t
m a m a a i a i t t c tf an or rdiec i t pa test pr e wih a bir ton i
y ke pplc ton o he our or
de r tng he ri o oce d t r tai n
ac or nce wih t t r s t r of' . ll e r l o t e c u t i t tio o l e f re
c da
t he e m he e . ' t- oe f h o rs s o rg r usy n o c
) -h

a e m e st a bir t '' e s r Biphar , I .v Johanne r Cons . I s,553 F.
gr e nt o r ta e.'H miphe x o
ma nc .
sbu g
ol nv .
3d

1 6 ( 1h Ci.2 0 )( u t g De n Witr Re od , I .v.#yr#,470 U. 213,221
3 6 1 t r 0 8 q oi
n a te yn ls nc
S
( 9 5) l rve n a moin t c mp labtai n c u t mus c n ie t re f co s ( )
1 8 ). n e iwig
to o o e r irto , o rs t o sd r h e a tr : 1
.

whehe a vai wrte a ee ntt ar tae e ss
t r
ld it n gr me o bir t xit ,

( )wh t e a a bta l is e it,a d
2 eh r n r i be sue x ss n
r

()wh te terg tt a btaewa wav d See,e. ,M ercur Tel Gr p, Inc.v.Empre e
3 eh r h ih o r i t s ie
r
g.
y co ou
s
.

de Te e ommuniacone de Bo a S A.E. P. 67 F.Supp.
lc
c i s
got
S. , 0
.

2d 1
350,1 ( D.Fl.2009)
354 S. a
;

Se r v US Ho Cop. e a1 7 0 S 2d 633,636 ( 1. 1 99) tl e pat rssi
fet . . me r , t . 5 o
,
F a 9 . s- ry e it
-h
ng
.

a bir ton be s t bur n ofpr ng t tt c am s a i s
r tai
ar he de
ovi ha he l i t s u
e a e uns t bl f a bir to .''
r
uia e or r tai n
G r e Tr e Fi
e n e nanci Cor . v Randol 531 U .
al p .
ph,
S.7 ,9 ( 0 ) Fu t r wh n i d u t
9 2 20 0 . rhe, e n o b ,

q tons ofa bir biiy s ul be r ol d i f vorofar tai n. Se M os s H Cone M e '
uesi
r ta lt ho d
es ve n a
bir to
e
e
ml
Ho pialv. e c y Consr Cor ,460 U . .
s t M r ur
t.
p.
S

1 2 - 5( 9 3 .
, 42 1 8 )

Appl ng t sa r s t f t a
yi he t nda ds e orh bove t t i tnt ca e t Pa tes do no diput
o he nsa
s he ri
t s e
,
whehe a vai wrte a e m e t ar tae e ss nor do t y diput wheher a bir bl
t r
ld it n gr e nt o bir t xit
he s e
t
r ta e
,

4

is e e it(lme t o ea dt ) ( eDE 62 a 4- ;DE 74a 3,4) Atis her i whet r
su s x s ee n s n n wo Se
t 7
t
s ue e s
he
.

.

Pl ntf swaved t rrghtt a bir to a t sve y l t s
ai if i hei i o r tai n t hi r a e t
a i t ltga i n.
ge n he ii to
De piet sr publcpolcy i f
s t he tong
i i n avorofa bir ton
r ta i

,

apary may,by isc
t
t onduc ,wave
t i

a bir ton. S & H Contac o s I .v A. FJ
r tai
r t r , nc . J
# CoalCo.l . 906 F. 15 , 1 4 ( 1h Ci.
, nc,
2d 07 51 1 t r
-

1 (ii Mos sf ConeM e 1Hos t , 460 U . a 22- E C.Ernst Inc v.M anhatan
990) ctng e '
f
m
pial
S. t 23;
,
t
.

Consr Co. 55 F.2 2 8 2 9 ( t Ci.1 7 :, c r i gy
t. , 9 d 6 , 6 5h r 9 7 Ac o d n l

,

.

apa t t tçs t i ly i
ry ha iubsantal nvokes

t ltgai m ac ne y' be or as e tng is rghtt a bir ton
he ii ton
hi r ' f e s ri t i o r ta i

m a wai t rg . I To
y
ve hat iht d

de e m i wheher a pa t has waved is c r cua rghtt a bir t ,c t mus c
t r ne
t
ry
i
t onta t l i o r ta e ours
t onduc a
t

t - a te t d rt (h y d cd i, n e tett l yo tecru tne s t part hasact d
wo p r ts:t s, te ) e i e f u d r h oai f h ic msa e , he y
Fi
t
e
i onsse l wih t ar tato rght
nc itnty t he bir i n i ,

a d s c n , te lo t s ewh t e, yd n s , t t
n , e o d (h yl o k o e eh r b oig o ha

p ryh si s mewa p eu ie t eo h rp ry'Krisk v.SunTrustsan/ , Inc. 654 F. 1194,
at a n o
y rj d c d h t e a t ' n
o' ,
3d
.

1 0 ( 1h Ci. 01 )(n en l u tto so te )( leain i o i ia)( u tn Ia C
2 0 1 t r 2 1 itr a q o ai n mitd atrto s n rgn l q o ig v x

o p.v
r .

#.Br u o ,I c,2 6 F.d 1 0 ,1 5 ( 1h Ci 2002) Furhe,due t t sr fdeal
a n fAm. n . 8 3 3 9 31 1 t r ). t r
o he tong e r
.

polc f vorng ar tai , t pa t who a gueswavert ar ahe vy bur n ofpr
iy a i
bir ton he ry
r
i s s
be
a
de
oof'unde
r

t sts.I ( i St v.F. Huton t Co. 898 F 2 1 42 1 43( 1h Ci.1 9 $. W ih
hi e t d quotng one
F
t f
,
d 5 , 5 1t r 9 0
t
.

.

t sf de a polc i mi , It n t t m a tra ha .
hi e r l iy n nd ur o he te t nd
Co i rng t tt a iy oft cic sa es'i t s c e i i m y dee m i i t t
nsde i he tot lt
he r um t nc ' n hi as t s
tr naton ha
,

Pli if a t d i ons se l wih t rght t a bir ton The e i no doubt t t Pl ntf s
antfs c e nc it nty t he i
o r tai
r s
ha ai if
.

ts tnta l i
lubsa ily nvoke t ltga i mac ner 'pro t de ndi t rg t a bir ton
d he ii ton
hi y' i r o ma ng he i ht o r ta i

.

not d a
e bove,Pl ntf fl a Com pl nt a Am e d Com pl nt
ai if ied
ai , n
nde
ai

,

As

a M oton f rClr s Def ul,
i o e k'
a t

a enga d f ly i I
nd
ge u l n nkma ts moton pr tc . Pli if ha e n f ly pa tci t i
r'
i
aci e
antfs ve ve ' l ri paed n
u

dicove y by de i I a ts wines , Dr w Paa ,a d s r i l ma t( ) a d c me t
s r
posng nkm r' t s e
r s n e vng nk r 1
ou n

rq e t ()as o itrog tre ; nd( )arq s f ra miso ( e DE 8 a 6 .
e u s;2 d f n er ao is a 3 e uet o d sins S e
7t)
.

Ho ve ,Pl ntfs'M oton a gues t ti di notwa
we r ai if
i r
ha t d
i
ve is rghtt a bir ton, de pie
t i o r ta i
s t
wa tngoversx m ont a trc
ii
i
hs fe omm e ng t a ton t fl t sM oto be us t i
nci he ci o ie hi
i n, ca e he t e st
bani r o
a bir ton' we e notr
r tai ' r
emove t i t sCour ' J 6 201 Or rr s vi t c i e oflw
d mtl hi
ts une
2 de e ol ng he ho c
a
,
quesi a dim isng Count sx t ough ei toft i talCompli .
tons nd s s i
s i hr
gh
he nii
a nt

( e DE 6 a 2 1 )
Se
2 t , 0.

Specfcal Pli if a g t tt i ta Compl ntsf r gn lw cli s a r s f t
i ly, antf s r ue ha he nii l
ai ' o ei a am nd eque t or he
e r or nay r i of a ntng a r e ve pr cl d t m fo
xta di r elef
ppoi i
ec i r e ude he r
m i
nvoki t rght t
ng he i
o

a btain.( eDE 6 a 2 9 . Ifnd t tt sar enti wihoutm ertf t r sons Fis,
r i to Se
r
2 t , ) i ha hi gum
s t
i or wo ea
rt
.

t f egn lw ca ms we e i e wihi t s ope of t a bir ton c a e
he or i a li
r nde d t n he c
he r ta i l us , as t wer
hey
e
fa ii outof or r a i t 't Fr hie Agr men .
%rsng
eltng o' he anc s
ee t

( e DE 12 a j 2 .) Th s te
Se
- t 05 . u , h

a bir to pr son t tbot pa tesa ee t c r Pl i if
r tai n ovii ha h ri gr d o ove ed antfs
s Ha t
d he
'f egn 1 c am s
or i aw l i .

Pl ntfs Am e d Compl i c nge t s ope ort or oft
ai if '
nde
ant ha d he c
he y
h
e cai s howeve ,Pl i if
lm ,
r antfs
mi ha be n e il d t atfe h c oc 'wih r ga d t wa ve .Se Krns ,65 F
ght ve e ntte o tr s l k' t e r o i r e i k 4

3d a 1
t 202-

.

0 ( o dn ta wh n a plitf fls a a n e c mplitt a u e pe dy changes t
3 h l ig h t e
an if i n me d d o an h t n x de l
e
he
s pe of t ca e t defnda s d be r ived fom hi wave)
ha
he s , he e nt houl
ele
r
s i r. Second, compeli
lng

a bir ton woul notha pr c ude Pli if fom r e vi e t bl r le ,asnot ng i t
r tai
d
ve e l d a ntfs r ec i ng quia e e if
hi n he
Fr nc s Agr mentpr l
a hie
ee
ecudest ar ta orfom a r ng
he bir t r
wa di

e r or nar r le t Be ver t
xta di y e if o a , he

E a hiee.6 M or ve , Pl i if coul ha i
i nc s '
Fr
'
eo r antfs
d ve nvoke a bir ton e ry i t pr ee
d r ta i a l n he oc di

ngs

not t t ndi t c am sagans t orgi de e nt .7
wihsa ng he l i
i t he i nal f nda s
1 now t n t t fna ave r quie t
ur o he i lw i r e r men '
.

p eudc t l kma t tn d tr nig
rj ie o n r. ç ee mi n
l
wh t e t p ryo p snga btai nh sb e p eu ie , coursconsdert l ngt ofdely i
eh r he a t p o i r i to a e n rj dc d
r
t
i he e h
a n
5Pl i if M oton ar d i f vorofabr d i e r t ton oft Fr nc s Agr e e '
antfs' i gue n a
oa nt m e a i
he a hi e e m nts
a bir i pr so . ( eDE 6 a 5 6 .
r taton ovii n Se
6
2 t -)

ec in 0.( ) f h r n h s
S to 2 5 d o teF a c ieAg e me t r cu e teF a c io , butnott Fr nchiee
re n p eld s h rn hsr
he a s ,
fom s e ng e r di r r le t ough a bir ton.
r e ki xtaor na y ei f hr
r ta i
1AsPar sand S lvan wereofi r ordiect rsofI ( eartt 12 bir tonpr si woul
S eDE - ) tai ovi on
.
a
d
uli
fce s
r o
nkm
hear
ha be n a i bl t t cli sa i tt m .
ve e pplca e o he am gans he
,

( e DE 12a j2 .() DE 1
Se
- t 05 a ; )

de a ng a bir ton a t expe e i r d by t
m ndi r tai nd he
ns ncure
h
a pa t fom pa tcpai i t ltga i
t ry r
ri i tng n he ii ton
pr es .' Krn ,654 F.3 a 1 01(n en lq o ain o te )( u tn S t H Co r co s
oc s' isk
d t 2 itr a u tto s mitd q o ig f
nta tr ,

9 6F.d a 1 4 . tW l e acam i n tabta l a te t a a to i
0 2 t 51 ) t h n li s o r i be t h i n ci n
r
r
me

sco menc a a
m
ed nd

tm e yr que thasbe n m a ,
i l e s
e
de

meep rii aini ds o e yd e n tc us p eudc s fiin
r a t p to n ic v r o s o a e rj ie u fce t
c

t cons iut a w a ver' Be y v Pr ntalBac Sec I . 8 F. 1
o
tt e
i . ' noa . ude i - he
2d 437, 1 4 ( 1h Ci.
.
, nc , 05
4 0 1t r

1 8 ) Ahe c r f ly c n i eig b t Pa te 'a g me t I beleve t t I ar wil be
9 6.
r a eul o sd rn oh ris r u n ,
i
ha nkm t l

p eudc di Iweet c mp l h Pa t st abtaei r s o et Pli tfs u tm el M oton.
rj ie f r o o e t e ri o r i t n e p ns o anif' n i y i
e
r
Asdic s d above, t is si t sc s wer ar ta e whe Pli if tld t
s us e
he s ue n hi a e e bir bl
n a ntfs ze h
e i tal
nii
Compli . Si e t n, Pli if ha fl a Am e d Compl nt
ant
nc he
antf s ve ied n
nde
ai , a M oton f Clr s
i or e k'
De a t Res est I
f ul, pons o nkmar' motons a pa tc pa e i dic y
ts
i , nd rii t d n s over

.

Now,wih ti on t
t ral he

he
horzo SPli if wa t pr ong t pr ee ngs a s k de e m i ton by a abir t g
i n, antfs nt o ol
oc di
nd ee t r na i
n r ta or
.

Gr ni gs h ar q e two l beu j s t I k r, asi has s ntçtnsoft andsofdolar
a tn uc e u s ud n u t o n ma t t
pe ç
e
hous
l s
i pr ti lpr ce di a dico r 't tm a ha bee
n era o e ngs nd s ve y' ha y ve n

a de ha t de a be ma
voi d d he m nd en de

e rir L e DE 7 a 1 ) M o e ve, Pl ntfs'M oton i untm el based on isf l et abi
al . s e
e
4 t 0 . r o r ai if
i s i y
t aiur o de

b t e P era S he u ig Or e ( 25 is e b M a itae J dg Viu ac on M ar h 7,
y h rtil c d ln d r DE ) su d y gsrt u e t n
c
2 2 1 A ss c , fnd t I artw o l bep eu ie i Iweet g a tti M o in Plitfs
01 .0
u h I i hat nkm
u d rj d c d f r o rn h s to ; anif
ha wai d t rghtt co pe a bir ton a am a trofl w .
ve ve he i o m l r tai s
te
a
Ac r ngl i i he e
co di y, t s r by
8on J nua y 31 ti i t s
a r , ral n hi
c e wass tf t t wee tilpe i be nni
as
e or he wo- k ra rod gi
10,
e
201 ( eDE 5) Cae rcali s tf Se e r5, 201 ( ei ) ng on Sept mber
2. Se
. lnda l s e or ptmbe
9The Elvent Cicui hasnot t tt pur e oft FA A 2. Se d..
e h r t
ed ha he pos
he
i t ç ele c
s o s ive ongesi i t
r
ton n he
c t a t pr depa te wih a at m a i m e hod f diput r s uton t twoul be
ours nd o ovi
ri s t n le tve t
or s e e ol i ha
d
s e e a l s c ty t n ltga i .' 800t v H u Pub I . 902 F. 9
pe di r nd e s os l ha ii ton '
h . me
nc,
2d 25, 932( 1hCi.
1 . I Iwer t say t sm aterand compelar taton .,
990) f
1t r
e o t hi
t
bir i t diput resol i pr ssw oul
b
e
uton oce
d
, he s
epr onge and t Pari swoul a guabl i
ol d
he te
d r
y ncurmor c t t f u ta i t over r hi
e oss hus r sr tng he
a c ng
,
.

VToeo teF
up s fh AA.
r
h

ePrti Sc dulng Or r( 25)r quie t Pa te t fl a1prti moin
eral he i de DE
e r s he ris o ie 1 eral to

me or ndaof1 w be or J y 1 201
m a
sa
nd
a
f e ul 6, 2. Pl ntfs M oton wa fl on J y 24
ai if ' i
s ied
ul , 201
2.
7

O RDERED AND ADJUDGED t tPl i if 'M oto t St y Pr e ngsa Compe
ha antfs
i n o a oce di
nd
l

Az i ain ( 6 )i DENI
bt to DE 2 s
r
ED

.

DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe sa W es Pam B c
n
r t
t l
h, F o ia t s
lrd ,hi

Se e be ,201 .
ptm r
2

ALD M . I
M DDLEBROOKS
UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI J
CT UDGE
Co e t
pis o:

Co e ofRec d
uns l
or

8

# d yo
a f