International Brotherhood of Teamsters, v. Amerijet International, Inc.

Filing 38

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 31 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 3/15/2013. (tkn)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORJ
CT
DA
M i miDi son
a
vii
Cas Num be 1 60654- V- O RENO
e
r: 2CI M
W TERNATI
ONAL BROTHERHOOD
TEAM STERS,

OF

Pl i if
antf,
VS.

A M ER UET W TERN A TI A L,l C .
ON
N ,

Def nt
enda .
/

ORDER GRANTI I PART AND DENYI PART M OTI TO DI I
NG N
NG
ON
SM SS

THI CAUSEc meb f r teCo r u nDee d n Ameie I tr ain lIc ' Mo in
S
a eo e h u t po fn a t rjt ne n to a,n .s to
t Sti Cou s1 1, I1a t Dimi sCount 1 V,a Vloft Fis Amende Compl nt
o rke nt , 1 and 1 nd o s s
s V, nd
he r t
d
ai

( E.No.31) fld on Nove ber20.201 Pl ntf l enai Br her
D.
, ie
m
2. ai if ntr tonal ot hood ofTe tr
amses
C%BT' s bmitdisfrt me dc ant
l ' u te t is a nde ompli onNove r6, 2s e ngc imainof r ta
)
mbe 201 e ki onfr to abirl

a r sa da od r e u rn Ameie' c mp in ewiht s a r .Ameie i tr fldte
wad n n r e rq iig r ts o la c t ho e wads
j
r tn u n i h
j
e
pr e m o i t dim is r si t Cour t dimis a lsx c nt oft I S n
es nt ton o s s , eque tng he
t o s s l i ou s he BT' mende
d

c mpan. F rtef lo n ra o s teCo r g a t Ameie' moin i pat n d n e i i
o li t o h ol wi g e s n ,h u t rn s r ts to n r a d e is t n
j
p r.Th Co r g a t Ameie' mo int srk Comt 1 I, n I1 st Co r h sp e i u l
a t e u t rn s r ts to o ti e t s ,1 a d 1 a he u t a rv o sy
j

rld ta i lc ss b e tma trj rs ito o e te . Th Co r lk wie g a sAmeie'
ue h t t a k u j c te u idcin v r h m
e u t i e s rnt
rjts
motont dimisCount V a t 1 f ist aleg as c fcvi a i oft m i m um pa a bir l
i o s s
I s he BT a l o l e pe ii olton he ni
y r ta

a r .Fial,h Co r d ne Ame i tsmoi nt dimisCo nsV a dVIfn n ise dta
wad n ly te u t e is r e ' to o s s u t n ,idig n ta h t
j
t l has s tcinty sa ed c am s al gi vi ai of t r pe tve a bir a r .
he BT
ufi e l t t l i
le ng oltons
he es ci r tal wa ds
Ac or ngl t l s lfl a a nded c
c di y,he BT hal ie n me
ompli no lt rt Apri 9. 3.
ant a e han
l 201

1 FACTUAL BACK GROUND
.

Plitf I i alb ru in c riidf rp r o e o teRal yLa o Ac ($ 'a
an if BT s a o no etfe o u p s s f h iwa b r t ç
RLA' s
)

t ee cu i erp e e tt o tepi t a fih e gn e so Dee d n Ame i t
h x lsv e rs n ai f h l s nd lg t n ie r f fn a t r e
ve
o
j
Itr ai n l Ameie is l i ac r oa dc mmo arc n e s b e t ot RLA.F lo n a
n en to a. r t tef s ag n o n i a i r u j c t he
j
o lwig
srkebyt l i Augus a Se e r2009, hepa tese e e it s pa ae c l c i
ti
he BT n
t nd pt mbe
t
ri nt r d n o e r t ole tve
ba gani ag ee t c rngpiot a fi e ne r r pe tvel Thepa te r tfe e h
r i ng r men s ove i
l s nd lght ngi e s es c i y.
ri s ai d ac
a e m e o Se e r 1 2009.
gr e nt n pt mbe 3,
On Aprll 201 t I fld a c
i 2, 2, he BT ie
ompl i i t sCour t c pe a bir to and
ant n hi
t o om l r tai n
e or e a bir to awar unde t RlA.I pa tc ar t 1 a lged sx c am sarsng outof
nf c r tai n
ds
r he , n ri ul , he BT le
i li
ii

t g iva pr e r co ane i t ba ga ni a e m e s t e ofwhi a epe tne t
he re nce oc du es nti d n he r i ng gr e nt ,hr e
ch r ri nt o
t pr e m oton.Cou I oft c
he es nt i
nt V he ompl i a e s d a a bir ton awar r s vi adipu e
ant ddr s e n r ta i
d e ol ng s t

ove mi mum pa gua a e f piot a ti e ne r . CountV c mce ne anAprl2011
r ni
y r ntes or l s nd lght ngi e s
c r d
i

abtaina r r q ii Ame i toc nt u i p irp o e u eo a iigfiht n ie r
r irto wa d e urng rj t o i e t ro r c d r f dvsn lg e gn es
e
n s
i adv eofar ai n f plnne $ r G'fi ht . Fi ly,Coun V1deatwih aNove be
n anc
ot to or a d t o- ' lg s nal
Ze
t
l t
m r

2 1ab tain a r rg r i t ep si o c mp n n lg o fih si Ameie '
01 r irto wad e adng h o t f o o e t e s f lg t n
ng
r ts
j
s heduls
c
e.

Ameie flda iiil to t d s s alsx c u t o M a 2 , 01 , c ti
r t i n nta mo in o imis l i o ns n y 4 2 2 whih h s
j e
Cour gr nt i ise ie y o Oc o r1 201 Ofr e
t a ed n t ntr t n t be 7, 2.
elvanc he e,t Cour dim is Co s
e r he
t s s ed unt

I V, n Vld tt j rs ito a c n e n t t h I c u dn talg a yhn mo eta
V, a d u o u idcin l o c r s ha t e BT o l o l e n tig r h n
e
hy t tc lvi a i oft a bir ton awa dsa wast s e ng t Sc im t a r a
po hei a oltons he r ta i
r nd
hus e ki o tonfr he wa ds s

amatro c u s . 1 t1 d o e msesv Ame q t n ' I c, .1 - 0 5 - Vte f o re' n 'Bh fT a tr . r e 1 t1 n .No 2 6 6 4 C1
'
,
M ORENO, 01 U.. s.
2 2 S DitLEXI 1 2 4, t* 7( D. a Oc . 7 201 ) T Co r
S 49 6 a 2 S. Fl. t 1 , 2 . he u t
t r f epe m itd t 1 t r s m i isc pl ntale ng s ii ,c r t vi atonsoft
he e or r te he BT o e ub t t om ai lgi pecfc onc ee ol i
he

BT he ie
a r so rs dimis l o lc o s j c matr u idcin.I a * 6.The l t n fld an
wad r ik s s a f r a k f ube t te j rs ito d t 2

ame d co a n on Nove
nde mpli t
mber6,201 r a s tngisal ga i i Count l V,a Vl
2 e s eri t le tons n
s V, nd

wi mo ep riua i a dr q sigt tteCo r o d rAme i tt c mpywiht e
t r a t lrt n e uetn ha h u t r e
h
c y
rj o o l t h
e
r s ci a r .
e pe tve wa dsl
4. Cou IV
nt

a

TheI Sca msi CountI se fom t bar i ng a e m e s gua ante t c e
BT' li n
V t m r he gani gr e nt ' r e o r w
me be sofam i m um ofsxt hotr ofpa pe r trdut pe i Prort ar trdut pe i
m r
ni
i y ls
y r ose
y rod. i o ose
y rod,

Ameie d tr n steduyd ysf re c ce me e a d is e aduyr se.Du t t e
r t eemi e h t a o a h rw mb r n su s t o tr e o h
j
I Ssrk fo Au u t2 t Se tmb r1 2 0 Ame i t i n tis ead t r trfrte
BT' ti e r m g s 7 o p e e 3, 0 9, rj dd o s u u y ose o h
e
r trdut pe i ofSe e be 7 t Ocob 4,2009 de pie t f tt ts ec e membe s
ose
y rod
ptm r o t er
s t he ac ha om r w
r

i fr dAmeie dui gtesrk ta te weea albet wo k.W h nAmeie
n ome
r t rn h ti e h th y r v ia l o r
j
e
r t
j
s e ntyi s d pay hec f t r t du yperod,i di noti udet sxt hour
ubs que l s ue
c ks or he oser t
i t d
ncl he i p
mi mum pa gua a e The 1 t n c le d t sf l r flng greva est e nt ly
ni
y r nt e.
BT he ha lnge hi aiu e, ii
i nc hat ve ua l
1 dt a bir to
e o r tai n.

OnNo e e 5 201 ,h a btao f u dta Ameie h dvo ae teb rann
v mb r , 0 t e r i t r o n h t r t a iltd h a g iig
r
j
a e m e san or r i t makewhol t ec e m e be swho ha i caed t i
gr e nt d de ed t o
e hos r w m r
d ndi t he r

a lbiiy t fy durng t cont t r t rdut pe i Specfc ly, sa e t
vaia lt o l
i he
esed ose y rod.
ii a l he tt d hat

()l ioswh h l bd i p iie e d rn teCo tse RDP s al ep i
a1 p lt o ed idng rvlg s u ig h ne td
h l b ad
t 60- urm i m um gua a e s tf t i CBA Se ton 5. 1, ubi tt t
he ho
ni
r nt e e orh n
c i B. s ec o he

e e to sstf rhi CBA Se to 5. ( e c l a dls a ywa e p i te
xc p in e o t n
cin P Absn e, n e s n g s ad h m
1 Thel ' a e de co pl ntas r s re isal tonsi Count l 1 , d IIç ha d s el t
BT s m n d m ai lo ease td t legai n
s , 1 an I ç
unc nge ol y o
pr er eisrgh t a al' P1' Fis Am .
es v t i t o ppe . .s rt
'
Compl4 n. 8n. 9 n. l a tont isc lngest Count l V,
. 1, 2, 3. n ddii o t hale
o
s V,

a dVlAmeie n w se si ispe e t to t srk Co ns1 l, n lla rd n a t n rF d rl l o
n , r t o ek n t rsn moin o tie u t ,l a d l s e u d n u de e ea Rue f
j
CiiP o e u e1 9 sn eteCo r ds se teec u t frlc o s betmatr uidcini i Oco r1 ,
vl r c d r 24 ic h u t imisd h s o ns o ak f u jc te j rs ito n t tbe 7
s
2 2o d r S el t1 o e msesv Ame d t n ' 2 2U. Dit L S 1 9 6 a # 4 5 23 Aste
01 r e. e n 'Bhd fT a tr . r e 1 tl 01 S. s. EXI 4 2 4, t 1 -1 , . h
,
I n tdi isrsonet temoint ds s,t< o sn t s tec u tsc t rvsto rc n ie isp ir
BT oe n t ep s o h t o imis i ' e o a k h o r (il o e ii r e o sd r t ro
o
d
r i ' t ec s Pl' Res t M ot t D im is 1 Cons que l t Cour srkesCoun s1 I,a II
ulng'on hos ount. .s p.o
.o s s .
e nty,he
t ti
t , l nd l

p ru n t i p e iu ds sa o tecamsfrlc o s be t te j rs ito .
u sa to t rvo s imisl fh li o a k f u j c matr u idcin
s

b ( r elwihrs c t teCo tse RDP.
y Amei t t epe t o h ne td
j
l a yi Se ton 5. t r s l beno r srci n i
n ppl ng c i P, he e hal
e tito mpos o t m e ns
ed n he a

bywhihapioti caedhi avalbiiyt ty(. ,a I opti rcor e l
c
l ndi t s ia lt o l eg. n PD -n e d, mai
m e s esortl phonec ls
s ag
ee
al uppore bybilngr c d co imaton oft cal
td
li e or nfr i
he l,

ec..Onc apiotha pr s ntd e de ofs hnotc ofavalbiiy,
t)
e l s e e e vi nce uc ie
ia lt
( r eqwi h v t eb r e o p o i gt a apltwa n ta albl t fyo
Amei t l a e h u d n f r v n h t io s o v ia e o l n
j
l
a ypat ua d ycame An f i r o g r elt pr d c l rc r f r
n ri lr a li d. y al e f Amei t o o u e PD e o ds o
c
u
j
t eCo tse RDP (rohe rc r o pl t v i bii t a ( rjt k p i
h n etd
o t r e o ds f io a al lt h t Ameie) e t n
a y
t eo dnayc u s o b i e s s al ra ta a v rei frn ea t t
h r i r o re f usn s) h l warn n d e s n ee c s o he
c e toft er or .
ont n
hos ec ds
P1' Compl Ex.6,a 17.
.s
.
t

Th 1 n w alg st t r e h svo ae t so d ro afw o c so b rf sn
e BT o le e ha Amei t a iltd hi r e n e c a ins y e u ig
j
t c
o ompe a ec e membe sde piet u on' i cai t t ari t tt c e m e be s
ns t r w
r s t he ni s ndi ton o he ilne ha he r w m r
had be n a l et fydurng t c ntsedr t rdut pe i To bepr ie t I sa e
e vaiabl o l
i he o e t ose y rod.
ec s , he BT tt s

t a is n a e it Amei t he teis a c o t a r if r n t arieta ih d
h t t e t n mal o rj a r h su n e f he wad n o mig he il h t t a
e
n
no pa dPiot Brt Bec a Fr Ha te a k not t t ndi t i a ia lt durng t
t i l s it lh nd nnk rlm r
wihsa ng her va lbiiy i he

c ne tdpeid.P1' Fis Am. mp . u t V, 2 .F rh r r ,h 1 camsta b t
o tse ro . rt Co l Co n 1 ! 2 u temo e te BT li h t oh
s
Bec a dHa t makh dc ntce Ame i tvae id rn t ec n e tdp ro o
lh n rl r a o a td
e
rj i mal u ig h o tse e id n
e

S pe e 1 s 0 9t idiaetera alblt.l Comt V, ! 1 , .La tteI s n a
e tmb r 5 2 0 o n c t h i v i i y d l I ! 8 20 s,h BT e t n
a i
e it Ameie o M a 3 2 1wi al t fe ly e wh h db e a albef rwo k
mal o r t n y , 01 t i o mpo e s o a e n v i l o r
j
h s
a
d rn t c ne tdp ro I Co n 1 !2 Tod t,h 1 alg sta Ameie h s
u ig he o tse eid. d u t V, 4. ae te BT le e h t r t a
j
r f sdt p ya yo t ee ly e a di tu s e a o d rc mp lngAmeie t c mpl
e u e o a n f h mpo e s n t h s e ks n r e o el
i
r to o y
j
wiht a btaor sa r
t he r ir t ' wa d.
#. CountPr

l Co n V,h 1 ag e ta Ame ie h sfie t c mpl wiha abta a r
n u t te BT r u s h t r t a ald o o y t n r i l wad
j
r
or i t ailnet pr dea ncenotc t fi engi er ofZe o- fi s Pro t t
derng he ri o ovi dva
i e o lght ne s
r G lght . i r o he
2009 srke FlghtEngi e sM iha land Lui Roc t pa ti Zer G fi si e d t
ti , i
ne r c e
s a ook r n o- lght nt nde o

smu aez r - rvt st ai n .Afe teRo a patcp tdi teu i n' srk , rjt
i lt eo g a iy iu to s tr h c s riiae n h n o s tie Ame i
e
de e t m t opporuniy t ty on Zer G fi si s t ofa a ee tbe wee t uni
ni d he he
t t ol
o- lght n pie n gr men t n he on

a t ari pr bii dic i i ton a ns e oye sf pa tcpai i t srke.The
nd he ilne ohi tng s rm na i gai t mpl e or rii tng n he ti
1 t n tld gre nc andpr e t a bir ton.
BT he ie iva es
oce ded o r ta i
The a bir t r ac d hi de son on Aprl1 2011 Des t fndi t tt ewa û
r ta or e he s cii
i 2,
. pie i ng ha her s i
no
q ntfabl e de e ofdic i i t y pr ctcei s hedulng orr prs l i t non- s i
ua ii e vi nc
s rm naor a i n c
i
e ias n he
a sgnme
nt

o Zer G fiht'a t f conta ua vi a i and c r s
f o lg s' nd hus i
no
r ct l olton
ore pondi y no rg t t
ngl
iht o he
monea y r medy s
tr e
ought'P1' Com pl Ex.7,a 11 1 t a bir t ne rhees a r d a
,' .s
.
t , 3,he r taor ve t l s wa de
r dy do avoi t pot nta f ra m ia id f i e s' I a 1
eme t
t
d he e il o ny s pple a nz s . d t 3.Ba i hi de son on a
'
sng s cii
n

ef r t t e d a yifrnc 't a Ame i t a d srmi ae t ea btao t ndrce t
fo to t me y n n ee e'h t rj h d ic i n td,h r i tr he ie td he
r
e
r
ari t contnue ispr - ti pr c ie ofa sng ti e nee si a nc ofar aton f
ilne o
i t e srke a tc
dvii lght ngi r n dva e
ot i or

pa n dZe o G fihs I a 8 Ho v r sn eteis a c o tea r , r e h sfie
ln e r - lg t. d t . we e, ic h su n e f h wad Ame i t a ald
j
t notf t Roc sofo
o iy he
a
pporunii t bi on Ze o- ti ht. The1 ac or ngl s ksa o de
t tes o d
r G lg s
BT c di y ee n r r

rq ii Ame i tt b t is ea v n enoieo pn n dZeo G fiht t t Ro a a dalw
e urng r e o oh su d a c t f ln e r - lg s o he c s n l
j
c
o
t t bi on t e ti s
hem o d hos lght .
C. Cou V1
nt

Fnal,h I c ne d i Co n Vl h t r e h svoltda abi aina r
i l te BT o tn s n u t t a Ame i t a i ae n r t to wad
y
j
r
r quii t ailnet pos co pone lgsoffi ht on t i m ont y s heduls Se ton
e rng he ri o t m
nt e
lg s her
hl c
e . ci

8D)1 oft c lci bar i ngag e me ssae t tiher tr dors hed e tmeof
( () he ole tve gani r e nt tts ha t ose e
t
c uld i
dut pe i wili udet s he edtm eoft rc
y rods l ncl he c dul i
hei omponentl , dhea ng,a r r f
egs dea
di ic a t
r postoni r s r e, r i ng,g ound s hool smul t tai ng,sai , oc tmes ti
e ii ng, e e v tani r
c , i aor r ni t tons bl k i ,rp
nlmbe s r tpe i ,da of,orot ra sgne dute .'Pl' Compl Ex.1, t27. W he
l r , es rods ys f
he s i d is' .s
.
a
n

Ameie fi dt p s r seswi c mp n n lg ,h 1 fldg iv n e ta p o e d dt
r t al o o t o tr t o o e t e s te BT ie re a c s h t r c e e o
j
e
h

a bir ton.
r ta i

I hi dec so i s d o Nove be l 2011 t a bir t t i o a c
n s ii n s ue n
m r 5,
, he r taor ook nt c ountt pli
he an

ln u g o t ea r e nsrq ii gt ep e e c o ç o o e tlg 'i Ameie' s h d ls
a g a e f h g e me t e urn h r sn e f ç mp n n e s'n
c
r ts c e ue .
j
Se P1' Com pl Ex.8,a 1 Howe r healono e t tt lng
e .s
.
t 2.
ve ,
s t d ha he a uageoft pr sonswa
he ovii
s

b r d die ty fom apr - gr e e c
orowe r c l r
e a e m nt ompa ha
ny ndbook i e f ctfom 200 t 2009. Se /
n fe r
4o
et
f

Un e t th n b o , r e ddn t s c mp n n lg o fn l o tr d s iet ie t a
d r ha a d o k Ame i t i o po t o o e t e s n ia r se s e p t he d ni l
j
c
lngua Seei Addii ly,sncec
a
ge.
d
tona l i
ompone l gsar notfna ie byt tm et tt
nt e
e
i lz d
he i ha he

sh d lsaep td tea btao wa c nc r e wihtefa a ii o rqurn Ame i tt
c e ue r ose ,h r i tr s o en d t h e s b ly f e iig rj o
r
t
e
pos c
t ompone lgsi a nc gi n t difculy i de e m i ng e c l whatfe g woul be
nt e n dva e ve he fi t n t r ni xa ty
r i ht
d
s pple f s pmentf a gi n l a i on an gi n day.Seejî a 11 Ye ,uponr vi
u id or hi
or ny ve oc ton
y ve
t t . t
e ew

o ter c r ,h a btao as d tr n dta f ie( r e)efcu tsc a g si ti
f h e o d te r i tr lo eemie h ti l Amei t fe tae h n e n hs
r
wh
j
pose m o hl s dul fom tm et tm e t pose publcs he ei a oxi e y 9
td nt y che e r i o i , he t d
i c dul s ppr matl 0%
a c a e ' 1 a 1 -1
c ur t .' d. t 6 7.

Asar s lo te efn ig ,h abtao c n ld dt a Ame i t s
e ut f h s idn s te r i tr o cu e h t r e mu t
r
j
ls t sheduldtmeoface me rs( l sandPFEs co
it he c
e i
rw mbe ' Piot
) mpone lgsa
nt e s
rq ie b S cin 8D)1, t t a c pe u esa d n t a pe tepre u rd y e t ( ( ) wi he c e td nd rtn i g h t r h e
o
h
c r c pr tc fom 2004onta t aci e r
2009,apr c iewel known t t pa tesa t tm e
a tc
l
o he ri t he i

t e a re u o t icu ino tes b e tln u g a pat ft i CBAS
h y g e d p n he n lso f h u j c a g a e s r o her
,
sh d lsc a g (ijfo tmet -i o c rb s du o ( rj t n e s
c e u e h n e sc r m i -o t c u a e p n Ame i q e d .
me
e
I a 1 .Th a btao te isr ce Ameie t tncu et es h d ldtmeo t er
d t 7 e r i tr h n n tu td r t o s ld h c e ue i f h i
r
j
i
c mp n n lg o te28 d yr trds h d l . . wi t u d rtn igta ( r el
o o e t e s n h -a ose e c e ue . , t he n esa dn h t Amei t
h
j
rs r e t erg tt c a g s hs h d l a ars lo E r e)d tr n db ie sn e s'
e e v s h ih o h n e uc c e ue s e ut f Amei t eemie usn s e d .
j
'
1 a 1.
d. t 8

Th 1 n w camsta Ameie h srf s dt p s c mp n n lg a rqur db te
e BT o li h t rjt a eu e o o t o o e t e s s e ie y h
a r Ass c fce de oft sf iur t c
wa d.
pe ii vi nce hi a l e o ompl t I f us son t c eofPiotFr nk
y, he BT oc e
he as
l n

P lco wh e i dAmeie o De e e 1 , 01 t iq iewh n teariewo l b gn
aa is o mal
e
r t n c mb r 9 2 1 o n ur e h iln ud e i
j
po tn tec mpo e t e s Amei tr s o d do De e e 20 2 1b sai t a iwo l
sig h o n n lg . r e e p n e n c mb r , 01 y tt h tt ud
j
ng
noti udea c
ncl
ny ompone l gsi r t r e ptf t e s c fcl a i t tha ale dy
nt e n ose s xce or hr e pe ii oc tons ha d r a

b e s h d lda t etmet er se wa p bih d S n et st , rj t a n t ose
e n c e u e t h i h o tr s u ls e . i c hi i Ame i h s o p td
me
e
c
ompo n l on Paac ossr t rf mos ti .Theuni t r o er quesst tt Cour
ne t egs
l i ' ose or t rps
on he ef r e t ha he
t

o d rAmeie t p s tec mp n n lg i ismo tl she ue .
re
r t o o t h o o e t e s n t nh y c d ls
j
I . DI
I SCUSSI
ON
CountIV

I t p e e t to Ame i t r u st theCo r s o l d s s Co n I frlc o
n he rs n moin, r e ag e ha t u t h ud imis u t V o a k f
j
s be tmatr u idcinu d rFe ea Rueo Cii P o e u e1 ( )1 a dfrfiuet sae
u j c te j rs ito n e d r l l f vl r c d r 2 b ( ) n o al r o tt
acam f r eifu d rRue 1 ()6 .l e s n e Ameie p e e stesmeag me t o b t
li o r l n e l 2 b () n se c , r t r snt h a r u n f r oh
e
j

b sso ds sa.At h o te, r e h g ih step rin o t ea btao ' d cso t a
a e f imis l t e us t Amei t ihl t h o t f h r i trs e iin h t
j
g
o
r
sae t tlhe es lbe no r src i i
t ts ha i r hal
t
e titon mpos d on t me nsby whih a pio i c t d hi
e
he a
c
l t ndi a e s

a alblt t fy' ndt a Co n eapio h sp e e tde ie eo s c noieo a alb l y
v ia ii o l'a h tl l c lt a rs ne vd nc f u h tc f v ia ii ,
y
l
t

( r ejwi h v tebu d no pr vn ta ap lt sn t v ia l t tyo a yp riu a
Ame i t l a e h r e f o ig h t io wa o a albe o l n n a t lr
j
l
c
d ycame . P1' Co lEx 6 a 1 .Amei t o tn sta ti ln u g r q ie ta a
a li d' . mp . . , t 7
' s
r e c n e d h t h s a g a e e urs h t n
j
elgi epa t pr de e de et heors hadpr vi l i c t d a ava lbiiy t fy i
i bl ry ovi vi nc hat
he
e ousy ndi a e n ia lt o l n
o dert qua iyf t pa nt
r o lf or he yme .
l lg oft sr quie nt t ari mai ai t tt I ha o y al gedone
n i ht hi e r me , he ilne nt ns ha he BT s nl le

s e ii vilto o teabta a r I p riu a, r e frtc n e t teI Salg to
p cfc oain f h r i l wad. n a t lr Amei t is o tss h BT' l ain
r
c
j
e
t a i s n a e i t Ame i trp rigt a Pi t Bec a dHa t makh dc na td
h t t e t n malo
r e e o t h t l s lh n rl r a o tce
j
n
o
e
Amei tv ae id rngt ec n etdp ro t i dc t t i a ia ii Ofei t se i
r e i mal u i h o tse e id o n iae her valblt frng hi mal
j
y.
,
d tdOco e 2 , 01 , ss p o tAmei t o sa mit a tee i s r e a % vd n e'o
ae t b r 7 2 1 a u p r, r e d e d t h t h mal e v s s l ie c 'f r
j
e

pum os soft a r f Belh asi i ntfeshi by nn a i udesasa a tc e t
e
he wa d or c
t de ii m
me nd ncl
n ta hm n

Bec so e it Ameie idc tn h sa ia ii S eDe .sM o .oDimisFis Am.
lh' wn mal o
r t n iai g i valblt e f' tt s s rt
j
y.
Compl Ex. Ho ve , hee a la nopoi m e i Ha te a k.I t ad,i r e st a he
. 2. we r t m i t
nt ntons rlm r nse t ef r o not r

e o e n me Hign wihwho Ameie h se e u e ar la ea t a ycamsa ans t e
mply e a d g is t
m
r t a x c td ee s s o n li g i t h
j
ailne.SeeDef' M ot t Dim isFis Am .Compl 1 n.
ri
.s
.o s s rt
. 0 6.

Ameie n tso yo eoh rp i tnt ec mplitwh r t e1 alg st a in tfe
r t o e nl n te o n i h o an ee h BT l e h tt o i d
j
e
i
t ari ofe i bl e o s t M a 3,2011e a lc ai ng als ofe o swho we e
he ilne lgi e mpl yee : he y
m i ont ni
it mplyee
r

a lbl t wor d i t c esedpei SeeP1' Fis Am.Compl CountI !24.
vaia e o k urng he ont t rod.
.s rt
.
V,

Ofei gt a e ii s p o t fismo ina welAme i t te s stefc t a t ee i
frn h t maln u p r o t to s l, r e sr se h a t h t h mal
j
pr de no hi m o et n a ls ofna a con a ti or ai n. Se De .sM o .o Dim is
ovi s t ng r ha it
mes nd t c nf m to
e f' t t s s

Orgn lCo . C, tc 1 Co s q e ty Ameie a g e ta tee id e n t
iia mplEx. Ata h. 6. n e u nl, r t r u s h t h mal o s o
j
c tt eç vi nc ' e oye spr di notc oft i a ia lt t t ari as
onsiut ç de e'of mpl e ovi ng ie her va lbiiy o he ilne
e
al ge y r quie by t a bir la r
le dl e r d he r ta wa d.

Ame i ttee o ec n ld sta tel h so l s fiin l alg davoaino t
rj h r f r o cu e h t h BT a ny u fce ty le e ilt f he
e
o

a r a t Bec I a c r a c wi t su esa dng Ame i tfldan tc wi t i Co r
wa d s o lh. n c o d n e t hi nd rtn i , r e ie oie t hs u t
h
j
h
onJ ua y 7, 3 i c tng t ti ha pa d Bec smi mum gua a e a t c i r
an r 201 ndia i ha t d i lh' ni
r nt e nd hus onsde ed

Co n I t b mo t S eDe .sNoieo M o te s3 Ameie no r q ssta t eCo r
u t V o e o . e f' tc f on s . r t w e ue t h t h u t
j
ds s Co n I f rlc o s b e t te j rs ito a df rfit et saeacam a tel
imis u t V o a k f u j c matr u idcin n o alr o tt li s h BT
l
hasf ie t al gea s c fcvi a i oft abir t ' dec son.
a ld o le ny pe ii olton he r ta ors ii

l rs ns ,h I ag e t t r e i efcieyakigteCo r t a o tt o
n epo e t e BT r u s ha Amei t s fe tv l s n h u to d p is wn
j
i e r t to oft a bir lawar a s e t tw oul be i pr r a t s s a The I i t n
nt p e a i n he r t a
d, t p ha
d
m ope t hi t ge.
BT n ur

o fr iso itr eaino tea r ta i c mmu iae t Ameie vae i i J n
fe s t wn neprtto f h wad h t t o nc td o
r t i maln u e
j
2011.I t te i,t l saedt ti beleve t t6 1t a r r quie wa a f of
n ha ma l he BT t t ha t i d ha 1 he wa d e r d s ny onn
a1

c
omm unia i fom c e me be s a t tf t ewho di i f c ty durng t diputd
c ton r
r w m r , nd ha or hos
d n a tl
i he s e
pa pe i t e o rkne t y wer a lbl t ty,s by de i ton t y woul qualf f
y rod,he mplye
w he
e vaia e o l o
fnii he
d
iy or

teg a a te' Pl' Fis Am. mp . u tl !25 Cingt esr ngp e e e to j d ca
h u rne . . rt Co l Co n V, . t h to r c d n f u iil
' s
i
de e e t t de i i ofa bir t s t I a g st tt Cour s d c im t awa d.
f r nce o he c sons r taor , he BT r ue ha he
t houl onfr he r

Sic i camst a i s p idAmeie wiht ei e tt a dc n a tif r t n o e ly e
n e t li h tt u pl
e
r t t h d niy n o tc n o mai f mp o e s
j
o
e i bl f rt m i mum pa gua a e ,i mait nst ti hasalege avi a i oft a r
lgi e o he ni
y r nt e t n ai ha t
l d olton he wa d.
Atam i mum ,howe ,t I i it t tt Cour s dr ma a diput ove t
ni
ver he BT nsss ha he
t houl e nd ny s es r he
i e t ton oft a r t t a bir t f c a i a i
mplmen a i
he wa d o he r taor or l rfc ton.
Si et sCour pr vi usy die t dt I t de
nc hi
t e o l r c e he BT o monsr t i isame
ta e n t
nded c
ompli t t
ant ha
i wasi f ts e ng m or t n c im a i oft awa d as a m a t r ofc s ,t Co tw il
t
n ac e ki
e ha onfr ton he
r
te
our e he ur l

d a wihtemoint d s s f rlc o s b e tmatr u idcinfrt f tc so s b e t
e l t h to o imis o a k f u j c te j rs ito is. s a k n u j c
At
matr u idcinb s do Ru e1 ( )1 . . o i t f r - fca atc a d fcu l
te j rs ito a e n l 2 b ( ) . c me n wo o ms a il ta ks n a ta
atc . Nor unasv Se s NB,LLC,720F.Supp. 1 3,1 4 ( . Fl 201 .l a
ta ks' k
'
. ahor e
2d 31 31 M D. a. 0) n

fca atc , c u t r l lo st l e i gh )plitf h ss fiin l alg daba i o
a il ta k a o r meey o k o ç e f te an if a u fce ty le e
s
ss f
s be t te j rs cin a dt alg to si hsc mplitaetk n a tu f rt ep r o e
u j c malr u idito , n he le ain n i o an r a e s r e o h u p s s
oft moi ' fawr nc v Dunbar 91 F. 1 1 ( t Ci.1 .I c r s,a
he ton.
'
e e.
, 9 2d 525, 529 11h r 990) n ontat

fcu lu idcin l t c u d rRu e1 ( )1 o c r wh ntemoi nt dimisc aln e
a t a j rs ito a a t k n e l 2 b ( ) c u s e h to o s s h le g s
a
Sh e itn eo s be tmatr u idcini fc,re p cieo t ep e dig . 1 .(uoig
û e x se c f u jc te j rs ito n a t irs e tv f h la n s' d q tn
t
'
Me hac v Chyse Cr tCor ,61 F. 507,511(t Ci.1980:.Sucha atckdiputs
nc a . r lr edi p. 3 2d
5h r
n ta s e

teç c u a y(ah rt ntes fi in y o t j rs ito l a t a s re b t epan ifa d
h s c r c rt e ha h u tce c ) f he u id cina f cs s e td y h litf n
a
p o frs mae il o e d n ir q aiyi s p o t fgh c aln e. V ln i v Hop. la
r fe ll tras f vie tay u lt n u p r o t e h l g l' ae tn . s Bel
e
'
Vit 25 F. 358,363( s Ci. ) l tnty, naparymount afcua a tck,a
sa, 4 3d
1t r 2001 . mpora l whe
t
s a t l ta
t srctc ti feet i pe nty wei f ct,a i y pr ee asi ne rc d unde
t ti our s r o nde nde l
di
gh a s nd ma oc d t ve oul
r

1 ( )6 o Fe R. V. 5 .' mpb lv Pa a i I v Gr , LC, . :0 c 1 9 - P,
2 b ( ) r d. Ci P. 6' Ca el . r dgm n . p.L No 5 1 -v- 1 6 TM
'
2011U. Dit LEXI 1 48 a * ( D. a. c.29,2011 ( i M o rs v a wl
S. s.
S 5 29, t 4 N. Al De
) quotng r ion .dvl y
Cor ,3 F. 920,925( 1hCi. ).
p. 23 3d
1 t r 2003)

Nowih tn igAme i tsag me t t tec nrr ,h prs n j rs ito a atc i
t t sa dn
rj ' r u n s o h o tay te e e t u idcin l ta k s
e
o afcu l ah rt nfca n t r .Asd s u sd, r e c n et tea c r c o an mb r
f a t a rt e ha a il al e
z
ic se Ame i t o tss h c u a y f u e
j
oft I Sf cua aleg tonsi CountI a pr f r m ae il ofe de ir qua iy,nn ey
he BT' a t l l a i n
V nd ofe s tra s vi nta y lt m l
t e a l,i s
he m is n uppor. TheCour woul t or na iy ha t a lt t c i rma tr
t
t
d hus di rl ve he biiy o onsde te s

o tiet pe dn st d tr n wh te i h ss b e tma tr u idcin o e ti d s u e
usd he la ig o eemie eh r t a u jc te j rs ito v r h s ip t.
Howe r m a tr ar dif r ntwhe af t at c alo i i t t mert oft
ve , te s e fe e
n acual ta k s mplcaes he is he

u d ryn c us o a to .l s c ac s ,l j ep o e c u s o a to f rt dsrc c u t .
n elig a e f ci n n u h a e Sth r p r o re f cin o he itit o r . .
g

i t fn t a j rs ito e it a d d a wihteo j cina ad rc atc o t emeiso te
s o id h tu id ci n x ss n e l t h b e to s ie t ta k n h rt f h
panifsc s . fa e c , 9F.da 1 2 ( u t Wila o v T c e , 4 F.d40 41
litf a e' wr n e 91 2 t 5 9 q oi lims n . u k r 6 5 2 4, 5
'
ng
(t Ci. 9 1) Th d fn a ti t e ço c dt p o e du d rRul 1 ( (). . rRul 5 .
5h r 1 8 ). e e e d n s h n i r e o r c e n e e 2 b)6 . o e 6 .
f
.

b t o wh c pa eg e trsrcinso t dsrc c u tsd s rto . I . q o ig
oh f ih lc ra e tito n he itit o r' ic ei n' d ( u tn
'

Wi ims n 6 5F.da 41 )
la o , 4 2 t 5.
l

Hee Ame i ts u idcin l ta k i ie tia l itrwie wihtemeiso t e
r , rj 'j rs ito a atc s n x rc by ne t n d t h rt f h
e
I Scam.S e iial Ame i ts e st d mo srt ta t eCo r lc sj rs ito b
BT' li p cfc l
y, rj e k o e n tae h t h u ta k u idcin y
e
dipr vi t I Sal gai t tt a ri vi atd t a bir t ' a d. Thi i pr ciey
s o ng he BT' le tons ha he ilne ol e he r ta ors war
s s e sl

t ee s n eo t eI Scam i Co n 1 Ac o d n l,h Co r fn sta j rs ito e it
h se c f h BT' li n u t V. c r i gy t e u t id h t u idcin x ss
a dd aswi Ame i tso j cina adie tatc o t eme is Ameie te eo emus
n el t
h
r e ' be to s rc ta k n h rt. rjt h r f r t
j
pr e unde et rRul 1 b)6)orRul 56.
oce d
r ihe e 2( (
e
Nor ly,hec c bewe nanayzngt moi unde et rRul 1 b)6)orRul 56
mal t hoie t e l i he ton
r ihe e 2( (
e
t l de
t l pend o whe he t dit i tc tc i r d m a t r out i t pl a ngs' Gar i v.
wi
n
t r he s r c our ons de e
te s s de he e di .
'
ca

Co n a e , l ( As o s, D.s P. ,1 4F.d 1 5 ,1 6 n.1( 1hCi. 9 7 .
pe h v r Belf s c.M ' A. 0 3 2 6 2 6 1 1 t r 1 9 )
,
Ac or ngl çhediti co tge r l mus co r am oto t dim isi o am o i f
c di y, s
t srct ur ne aly
t nve t
i n o s s nt
ton or

s mmayj d me ti i c n ie smaeil o tiet ec mpan . Da v T y o , 0 F.d
u r u g n f t o sd r tras u sd h o lit' y . a lr 4 0 3
'
1 1 -76( 1hCi.
272, 275
1 t r 2005) Ho ve,t Elve hCicuiha hel t tçadoc nt
. we r he e nt r t s d ha $ ume
a tc t amoton t dim ism a bec i e byt c twihoutc
ta hed o
i o s s y
onsder d he our t
onve tng t m oto
ri he i n

it o f rs mmayj d me to l i t atc e d c me i: 1 c nr l otep an ips
n o ne o u r u g n ny f he ta h d o u nt s () e ta t h litf
cam;a ( undiputd.'Hor ly v Fel ,304F. 11 11 ( lh Ci.2002)
li nd 2) s e ' se . dt
3d 25, 34 1 t r
.
tl s e i t sc extm e nst tt aut ntciy oft docume i notcha lnge ' I
çundiputd' n hi ont
a ha he he i t
he
nt s
le d. d
'
Re r ngce r iy, ou t ha f
ga di
ntalt c rs ve ound a tc doc e st b ç ental' r t
ta hed um nt o e i r 'whe e hey
c

ar a t ve yhe r oft pl ntf scli .l Bamer v Pu t HomeCor ,t El nt Cicui
e t he r a t he ai if a m n
t . le
p. he eve h r t
f
ound t t dititc t ope l c i r d pu c s a e m e satac d t amoton t
hat he src our pr ry onsde e r ha e gr e nt l he o
i o
d s isaco pl ntalegi vi atonsoff de als c ii l w.Se Bame tv PuleHome
im s
m ai l ng ol i
e r e urtes a
e
r . t

Cop.4 5F. p' 2 6 2 8( 1hCi. 01 ) Astec u t o e ,t ih u c n i eigte
r , 4 Ap x 5 , 6 1 t r 2 1. h o r n td çwqt o t o sd rn h
l
a r e nt ,i woul be i
g e me s t
d mpos i ef t DititCour t e l t pr pe l how muc contol
sbl or he src
t o va uae o ry
h
r
Pl i if e r ie ove t i i sm e s whi h t r outt bea c c a is i t sc e. l
antfs xe cs d r her nve t nt, c u ns
o
nli l s ue n hi as ' d
'
a 267. Addiimal t sCou tha he dt tt a tc ntofas l conta i a br a h of
t
tc ly, hi
r s l ha he ta hme
aes
r ct n
ec
c r c a ton di notr quie t Cour t c
onta t c i d
e r he
t o onve tt m oton t dimi se n t
r he i o s s ve hough t
he
de e nt ha ofe e t conta t ar ue t tisf m -e e ton clus r quie dim is l
f nda s d f r d he
r ct o g ha t onl s l c i a e e r d s s a .
Se Gon alz r Wat r k& t/y I . No.09e
z e . e mar
z/ nc ,
60265- V- ORENO,201 U. Dit LEXI
CI M
0 S. s,
S

31 a * ( D. a. a .3 201 .Bec us t plitf hadrfre t t s esc rc
039, t 7 S. Fl M r 0, 0)
a e he anif
eerd o he al onta t

th o g o t i (o lit, t eCo r fu t a t ec nr lyr q rme t a b e me.S e
s r u h u h s c mpanl' h u t o nd h t h e tai e uie n h d e n t e
t
'
t
i
d.

I t i c s ,heCo r te t Ameie' moina a 1 ( )6 moi nt d s s d s ie
n hs a e t
u tr as r ts t s 2 b ( ) to o imis e pt
j
o

t f c t ti i co i rng t pr f r d e a l. TheI r f r t t eema l t oughoutis
he a t ha t s nsde i he ofe e m is
BT e e s o hes
is hr
t

alg to i Co n I a p o fta inoiidAmeie o s e ii e o e swh we eei il
l ains n u t V s r o h t t tfe
e
r t f p cfc mply e o r lgbe
j
frt pa g a ee Se P1' Fis Am .
o he y uarnt . e .s rt ComplCountI !!22, Mor r i woul be
.
V,
24. eove,t d

i o sbet d tr n it eI h ds fiin l n tfe Ameie o eiil e o e s
mp s il o ee mie f h BT a u fce ty oiid rjt f lgb e mply e
wihou c i rngt ee a l.Asar ul, heCour fndst tt e l a e c nta t t
t t onsde i hes m is
es t t
t i ha he mais r e r l o he
I Sc am i Coun I .SeeBame t 445 F.App' a 267.And snc net rpa t quesi
BT' l i n
tV
r,
x t
i e ihe ry
tons

t ea t nii o tee i ,h Co r c n ie sAmeie' moin a a1 ( )6 mo int
h uhe tct f h mal te u t o sd r
y
s
r ts to s 2 b ( ) to o
j
dim is SeeHor ly,30 F. a 11
s s.
se
4 3d t 34.
Unde Rul 8,apl ntf m us pr dea i ho ta pl i satm e oft cli s
r e
ai if t ovi
t r nd an t e nt he a m howi
s
ng

t a t epe d ri e tte t r l f' F d R. v P. ()2 .W h nr l go amo int d s s
h t h la e s n i d o ei . e . Ci. 8 a( ) e ui n
l
e'
n
to o imis
u d rRul 1 ( )6 , c u t s v e t ec mpliti t elg tmo tfv rb et t panif
n e e 2 b ( ) a o r mu t iw h o an n h ih s a o a l o he litf

a da s metev r ct o welpe d dfcu lalg to s pe k rv U S De 'o at tr
n su h e a iy f l- la e a ta le ain .S a e . . p t fHe l f
h
Hu nS r s Ctsf rDie s Co to d Pr v n in 6 3F.d 1 71 1 7 ( 1hCi. 0 .
ma e v . r .o s a e nr l r e e to , 2 3 3 , 3 9 1 t r 201 )
Howe r t st tdoesnota y t l ga c l i ,a s h conc uso û tbe
ve , hi ene
ppl o e l onc usons nd uc
l i ns s
mus

s p o tdb fcu lalg to s' As c ot . q a, 5 U. 6 2, 7 ( 0 9 .Th u hap o e
u p re y a t a le ai n . h rj v I b l5 6 S. 6 6 9 2 0 ) o g r p r
'
c
ompl ntl
ai s notne d de a ld f c ua al gai y i m us c ai t or t n l l a
does
e t ie a t l le tons' t t ont n t e ha abe s nd
'
m
c l i ,a af mul i r c tton oft ee e sofa c us ofaci n wilno do.'Be l
oncusons nd or a c e ia i
he lm nt
a e
to l t ' l

At n i Cop. .T mby, 5 U. 5 4 5 5( 0 ) At mii m, pan if s p e e t
l tc r v wo l 5 0 S. 4 , 5 20 7 . a n mu a litf mu t rs n
a
é nough f c st sae ac am t r le t ti pl i eon isf c ' I a 570.
'
e
a t o t t l i o ei f ha s ausbl
t a e. d t
'
tA cl i ha f c a pl us biiy w he t pl i ifpl a f c ua c en t ta l st
ç a m s a i l a i lt
n he a ntf e ds a t l ont t ha low he
c tt dr w t r a ona e i e enc t tt de e
our o a he e s bl nf r e ha he f ndan i la e f t m i c
t s i bl or he s onduc a l ged.
t le '
'

I al 556 U. a 678.Thi sa r i t ta n t a t obabiiyr r m e , buti a ksf
qb ,
S. t
s t nda d s ç ki o pr
no
lt equie nt' t s or
m or t as rpos i lt t tade e
e han hee
sbiiy ha
f ndantha a t d unl u l ' I l ot wor ,t
s ce
awf ly.' d n her ds he

compli mus co an t nough f c t r s ar as bl e c ai t tdic r wilr ve
a nt t nt i s
e
a t o aie e ona e xpe t ton ha s ove y l e al
e de e'oft r uie e e
vi nc ' he eq r d l ment Twombl 550 U. a 55 S
.
y,
S. t 6. f
And, coure, awelplad
of
s
l- e ed

c mplitma p o e de e i isrk sas v yj d et t cu l o fo t os fcsi
o an y r c e v n f t ti e a v u g ha a t a pr o f h e a t s
i o bl a çha ar c r i veyrmoea unlkel '' d ( i Sc e v.
mprba e, nd t t e ovey s r e t nd i y.'I quotng heu r Rhode ,
s

41 U. 2 2 2 6( 9 4
6 S. 3 , 3 1 7 :.

Dept t I Sc ne to s t eCo r g a t Ameie' moint d s s Co n I
s ie he BT' o tn in ,h u t r ns r ts to o imis u t V.
j
To be n,heCour not st tt cli sr r ng Pio Be c ha bee r nder d m oo i lg
gi t
t e ha he am ega di
l t lh ve n e e
t n iht

o Amei tspa me to h smii gu r ne .Se De . No ieo M o t e s3 l a dto
f rj ' y n f i nmum aa te e f' tc f on s . n d i n,
e
s
i

t eOco e 2 2 1e i b le teI Scam t a inoiidAmeie o P lt rlmak'
h tb r 7, 01 mal ei s h BT' li h t t tfe
r t f io Ha t r s
j
e
ei i lt a i doe notm e i n hi na ea a lbuti t adr f r t a e o nn e Hi i
lg biiy s t s
nto s m t l
nse e e s o n mpl yee m d gg ns

whos ca m i no l nge a is SeeDe .sM ot t Dim isFis Am .Compl 1 n. Ex.
e li s o r t s ue.
f'
.o s s rt
. 0 6, 2.

Sn editi t e1w i ti Cic it a t e t ee hiisc n rd c t eg nea a c n ls r
ic t l s h a n h s r ut h t wh n h x bt o ta it h e r l nd o cu o y
g
a lga i oft pl di t e bisgove n,'t Ocobe 27, 1e alm us co r .
le tons he ea ng,he xhi t
r '' he t r 201 m i
t ntol

Cr n h w v fitr 5 6F.d 1 3, 2 2( 1h Ci. 0 9 ( u t Gr fnI d s, n . . r i,
e s a . se , 5 3 28 1 9 1 t r 2 0 ) q oi f l n u .I c v Ivn
ng
4 6F.d 1 8 1 0 ( 1hCi. 0 7 Thsr l a pise nt e hbt ta aeatc e t a
9 3 1 9, 2 6 1 t r 2 0 :. i ue p l ve o x iis h t r ta h d o
e
motont dimisbuta e i om or t d by r f r nc
i o s s
r nc
ae
e e e e.SeeCuc nota v.CVS Pha mac I ,
i t
r y, nc.No.

8:2-v- 94- 33AEP,201 U. Dit LEXI 1
1 c 11 T2 S. s.
S 60993,a * 0( . Fl No 9,201 .
t 9-1 M D. a. v.
2)
Thi l a t I SM a 3, 11e alc ani t na e a c a ti or ai of
s e ves he BT' y 20 m i ont i ng he m s nd ont c nf m ton
e pl eswho ar a l e y elgbl f t mi mum pa g r nt The I c endst t i
m oye
e leg dl i i e or he ni
y ua a ee.
BT ont
ha ,n
lghtoft diput d i e pr t tonsoft a r t Cour s d r m a t c e t a bir ton.
i
he s e nt r e a i
he wa d, he
t houl e nd he as o r ta i
l i tuet tc t i t El ve h Cic tha a tm esr m a d diput sove t
t s r ha ours n he e nt r ui ve t i
e nde s e
r he
i e pr tton ofa r t t a bir t f r ol i a i pa tc a whe ea a d' gr nt
nt r ea i
wa ds o he r taor or es uton, nd n riul r r n war s a
ofba k pa r m ansn g us See eg.Al num Brikt Gl s Wo ke sI 1 Uni v WWW
c y e i mbi uo . , . , umi
c f as
r r nt
on .

Pl mbn Potr Co p.9 F.d 1 4 ,1 4 ( 1hCi.1 9 )(I t ep risc n o a r eo
u ig t y r , 91 2 5 5 5 9 1 t r 9 3 &f h a t n n t ge n
e
t
e
t amountofba kpa ... henor c s ofa i i t tea t a r a ambi
he
c y, t
mal our e cton s o r t he wa d s
guousor

i omplt a rma t diput t t orgna abirt t clrf t a r ' Coc col
nc ee nd e nd he s e o he ii l r taor o aiy he wad.
); a- a

BotigCo v 1 1Bh . fl mse s Ch ufr,Wa e o s me t Hepe s Lo a UninNo
tl
n . . nt d o ka tr , a fe s r h u e n f l r, c l o .
991,506F. pp.2d 1 1 ( D.Al 2007)(e
Su
052, 056 S. a.
rcommendi rma lnc eswheet
ng e nd s as
i
r he
fna iltr ofa a r a ea g usa une ore e).Howe ,wher ac tfnds
i nca ems n wad r mbiuo nd nf c abl'
ver
e our i
t ta a r i no a bi
ha n wa d s t m guous r ma i nota oprat Se Unie St l Pa r& For s r
, e nd s
ppr i e. e t d ee, pe
e ty,

Ru b r Mf ,En r , le I d s t S r .Wo k r 1 t UninAFL- O- CIv S r b e, g. e v Alid n u . t e v r es n 1 o
CI CL . muht
St Cont ne Cop.479F.App' 250,25 ( 1hCi. 2)( lni t r ma ac et
one ai r r ,
x
4 1 t r 201 deci ng o e nd as o

t embirtrwh r t ec u t o n t eabi ao ' a r o b c p yt bet mbg o s.
h
tao ee h o r f u d h r t t rs wa d f a k a o ma iu u )
r
l t sca e,t Cour fndst tt awa d i nota guousa t deci st r m a
n hi s he
t i ha he r s
mbi
nd hus lne o e nd
t c e t t a bir t . I hi a d, he a bir t f
he as o he r ta or n s war t r ta or ound t ta lpiot who he d bi ng
ha l l s
l ddi

p ii g sd rngt ec n etdp ro we ee tte t t emi i l p yg aa te s b e t o
rvl e u i h o tse e id r n ild o h nmlm a u rn e , u j c t
e
exc ptonss tf t i Se ton 5. oft ba gani a e m e st dea wih e oye
e i e orh n c i P he r i ng gr e nt hat l t mpl e
a enc s P1' Compl Ex.6, t1 I dee mi ngwhe he anempl yeet qualfe f t
bs e . .s
.
a 7. n tr ni
t r
o
hus
ii s or he

mii m p yg rne b r frn et S cin 5P,h abtao e plctysae t a Ame i t
nmu a uaa te y eee c o e to . te r irtr x iil tts h t r e
j
wil a et eb r e o d s r vn api tsa sre a albit do n eap lt a p e e td
l h v h u d n f ip o ig l ' se td v i l y ç l c io h s r sn e
o
a i g
e ie c o s c noieo a alb l y' I . e h ssa d d .Th sAme i tsb r e i n t
vd n e f u h tc f v ia ii . d (mp a i d e ) u
t'
r e' ud n s o
j
tig rdu tl ne ly ep e e t ç v d n e' ftef c t a h o s eprvie Ame i t f
rg ee ni a mpo e r s ns s i e c 'o h a t h t e r h o d d
e
rj o
e
notc i wha e rf m ,ofhi o he a ia lt t wor durngt con esed pe i
ie,n
t ve or
s r r va lbiiy o k i he t t
rod.
Be aus t I S M a 3, 1 em a lof e s no s e de e ofa no i pr de t
c e he BT' y 201
i fr
uch vi nc
ny tce ovi d o

Ameie b a yo tee ly e l td, u ise dmeeyc nan als o n me a dc na t
rjt y n f h mpo e s i e b t n ta r l o tis it f a s n o tc
s
i onnai n,i c r dit t I Sa lga i t tt e lconsiut d s fcintno i t
nf
to t onta c s he BT' le ton ha he mai
tt e ufi e
tce o

Ameie o eiil e o e s Asar s l,h e i e ii mu t o en o rteI S
r t f lgb e mply e .
j
e ut te mal xhbt s g v r ve h BT'
pladi Se Cuci t 201 U . Dit LEXI 1
e ng. e
nota, 2 S. s.
S 60993, t* 0.Cons quenty,t Cour
a 9-1
e
l he
t
fndst tt I Scai r a di t M a 3,2011e ala s doesnotc tt e a a lga i
i ha he BT' l m eg r ng he y
m i lo
onsiut n le ton
ofas ii vi a i oft a r
pecfc olton he wa d.W ih no f rhe a lga i ofditnc vi a i oft
t
u t r le tons
si t oltons he

a r ,h Co r t eeo ega t Ameie' mo int d s s Co n I a t eI fist sae
wad te u th rf r rn s r ts to o imis u t V s h BT al o tt
j
e
nough f t t sat a cai t r le t ti plusbl on isf c Se Twombl 55 U . a 57
ac s o t e l m o ei f ha s a i e t a e. e
y, 0 S. t 0.
#. CountP
'

Co tayt isc ne to srg r igCo n I Ameie d e no a g et a t el h s
n rr o t o tn in e adn u t V, r t o s t r u h t h BT a
j
fie t s f e tyalg Ameie' n n c mp in ewi t eZeo- abi a a r i Co n
ald o u t n l le e
ki
r ts o -o la c t h r G r t l wad n u t
j
h
r
V.l se d, rjts ie o t eabtao ' d cso t a r arme yçoa odt p tn il
n ta Ameie ez s n h r irt rs e iin o wad e d f v i he oe ta
t

f ra ymia pidfin s'd s iefn n t a Ameie h dn tvoltdteb r anig
o n s p l ar e s' e pt idig h t r t a o i ae h ag i n
e
j
a e m e t Se Pl' Compl Ex.7, t1 The ari now mai ai t tt sad ison byt
gr e n . e .s
.
a 3.
ilne
nt ns ha hi m s i
he
a bir t sgnii t tt a r doesnotdr ise s nc fom t bar i ngagr e e ,t
r ta or i fes ha he wa d
aw t s e e r he gani
e m nt hus

r n eigtea r u e f re be Asar s l, r e r q et t eCo r t d s s Co n V
e d rn h wad n n o c a l.
e ut Amei t e u ss h u to imis u t
j
f rfi r t saeacam frr l fu d rRue 1 ( ( )
o al e o tt li o ei n e l 2b)6 .
u
e

TheI i tr i ssst a Ame ie' o jcinsaei fc a e f r t id c a
BT n u n n it h t r ts be to r n a t n fo to n u e
j
j d me to t epe dn .I a an sr se t d fr n et t e ea c u t mus s o fr
u g n n h la igs t g i te s s he ee e c ha f d rl o rs t h w o
a bir de i i and c endst tt a bir t ' de son he e c tt esaplusbl
r tal c sons
ont
ha he r taor s cii
r onsiut
a i e
i e pr t ton oft ba gani ag e me .M or ove ,t I r as e t ispostont tt
ntr e a i
he r i ng r e nt
e r he BT e s rs t
ii ha he
Cou ts ul r mandt de son t t a bir t ri i dee mi t tt a r i a g
r ho d e
he cii o he r ta o f t tr nes ha he wa d s mbi uous
.
Asme i d,apli ifne onl al gee
ntone
antf ed y le nough f t t sat a cai f r i t ti
acs o t e l m or elef ha s

fcalyplusbl i or rt s vi a 1 b)6 moi t dimis Twombl 550U. a 57
a i l a i e n de o ur ve 2( ( ) ton o s s.
y,
S. t 0.
He e, he l ha pr s nt s f c e f c sdem ons r tng di tnc vi a i oft a bir t '
r t BT s e e ed uf i i nt a t
ta i
s i t ol tons he r t a or s

Zeo G a r , p itta Ameie d e n tc n et Na l ,h I a srst a Ame i th s
r - wad a o n h t r t o s o o ts. mey t e BT se t h t r e a
j
j
f ld t no iy FlghtEngi e sM iha landLui Roc ofopporuniist bi on Ze o- fi ht .
aie o tf i
ne r c e
s a
t te o d
r G lg s

Rah r Amei tc alng st ef n a na e f re blt o teabtao ' a r Thi cam
te , r e h l e h u d me tl n o c a iiy f h r irtrs wad. s li
j
e
t tt a r i une o ce bl ,a t s d be va a e , i t mir ri
ha he wa d s nf r a e nd hus houl
c t d s he ro mageoft I S
he BT'

p i cp lcam t th Co r s o l c nfnnt a r a drq r Ame i tt c mpy.Atte
rn ia li ha te u t h ud o i he wad n e uie
re o o l
j
h
m o i t dim issa ,t I Sf ily plusbl a lga i ofabr c oft a r a e
ton o s s t ge he BT' aca l a i e le tons
ea h he wa d r
ad uaef t cai t s v ve.The is o e or e biiy i am a trf t Co tt decde
eq t or he l m o ur i
s ue f nf c a lt s
te or he ur o i

a altrsa e TheCo r a c r i l d n e Ameie' mo int ds s Co n V.
t ae tg .
u t c o dngy e is r ts to o imis u t
j
Count V1

Ame i tp e s sisfn lo jcina an tCo n V1o iso itr rtto o te
rj rmie t i a b e to g is u t n t wn n ep eain f h
e
c mp n n lgabta a r .I p riulr Ameie beiv sta t a r o l rq ie
o o e t e r i l wa d n a t a, rjt le e h t he wad ny e ur s
r
c
i l i ofc
ncuson ompo n l t tha bee s he e a t tme ofar tr spublc ton. The
ne t egs ha d n c dul d t he i
ose '
ia i
a ri c
ilne ommuni aedt si e r t tont t I vi e a lc r ponde efom De mbe 20
c t hi nt p e ai o he BT a m i ores
nc r
ce r
t De e be 22,2011 altl ove amont a trt a bir t is hi de ii . Ameie n w
o cm r
, ite r
h fe he r taor s ued s c son
r to
j

c e t ti ha comple wihi t boundsofisundert ndi oft a bir t ' d ii ,
ontnds ha t s
i d t n he
t
sa ng he r ta ors ecson
posi t el st twe es he e a t tmet tar t rwa publs . Fort sr s
tng hos eg ha r c dul d t he i ha ose s
ihtd
hi ea on,

Ame i tu g steCo r t ds s Co n VI o lc o s be t te ju s dint e Rue
rj r e h u to imis u t f r a k f u j c malr tidi o md r l
e
1 ( )1 o frf i r t saeacam f rrle u d rRu e1 ( )6 .
2 b ( ) r o al e o tt li o eif n e l 2 b ( )
u
F rh r Ameie ponso tha tel ddn t o t s t eari esu d rtn i ga a y
u te, r t it u t th BT i o c ne t h iln ' n esa d n t n
j
t d rn tesx mo t ta teabtao rti djzidcin o e ds u e a iigo t ft
i u ig h i nhs h t h r i tr eane t s ito v r ip ts rsn u o he
me
r
r
i e n aino t ea r Ame i ttusrq e t t a t I b e t p e fo c ne tn
mplme tto f h wad.
r e h e u ss h the BT e so p d r m o tsi g
j

Ame i tsitr rtto .
r e' n ep eai n
j
Th 1 i r s n eman an t t rjti s e i ds sa p r l ba e o iso
e BT n epo s iti s ha Ame i s e kng imis l u ey s d n t wn
e

i e pr tton oft a r a i e pr t ton t tt I diput s Though t 1 a guest t
nt r ea i
he wa d, n nt r e a i ha he BT s e .
he BT r
ha

tea r i efi ce ri isrq ie n ta Ameie p s a1c mpo n lg o e ly e
h wa d t l s la n t e u rme th t r t o t 1 o ne t e s n mp o e
s
j
r sess b e t oc a g sb sdo b ie sn e s t eu inr q sst a teCo r rma dte
o tr u j c t h n e a e n usn s e d , h no e uet h t h u t e n h
c et t a bir t ri i fndst a r t bea guous Addii ly,t 1 c am st tt
as o he r ta o f t i he wa d o
mbi
.
tonal he BT l i ha he

is eo wh t e iha tmeyo jce t Ameie' itr rtto i is l amatrf r
su f eh r t s i l be td o r ts n ep eain s tef te o
j
a bir ton.
r tai

AswihCo n l t i Co r wil e l t Ame i ts u idcina o j cinfrt As
t u t V,h s u t ld a wi
h rj 'j rs ito l b e to is.
e
ds u sd, ta k o s be t te j rs ito aeete f ca o fcu li n t e No k n s
ic se atc s n u j c matr u id cin r i r a il r a t a n aur . r u a ,
h

7 0F. p 2 a 1 4.l Co n VIAme ie p e e t afca a tc a i ç c e t gh I s
2 Su p. d t 31 n u t , r t r sn s a il ta k s t f c p s t e BT')
j
a
veso o j rs ito al-i nfc n fcsa tu a d a d e s st ers fiin y' ah rt a
ri n f u idcin ly sg i a t a t s r e n d rse h i u fce c 'rte h n
ds u igtera c r c .V lni 25 F.da 3 3 ld e , r e d e n t o ts t
ip tn h i c u a y ae t 4 3 t 6 . n e d Amei t o s o c n e the
n,
j
ve a iy oft I Salegai i Coun VIasi di i CountI bu i t a as e t t tt
r ct
he BT' l tons n
t
t d n
V, t nse d s rs ha he

Co r lc j rs ci nb c u et eI h sfie t alg avilto o t ea r a Ameie
u ta ks u idito e a s h BT a ald o le e oain f h wad s rjt
itr rt i.Co s q e ty t eCo r wil n yl o t d e i ( eI h ss fiinl alg da
nep es t n e u n l,h u t lo l o k o i e f t BTI a u fce t l e
s
h
y e
b sso s be tma tr u idcin, ndt ealg to i ( s c mplita etke a tu f rte
a i f u j c te j rs ito a h l ains n i ) o an r a n s r e o h
e
t
Pur e oft m oton. fawr nce 91 F. a 1
pos s he
i '
'
e , 9 2d t 529.

Asapr lm i r ma t ,t Cour fndst tt ar ta orsa r i s ce i et
ei na y ter he
t i ha he bir t ' wa d s us ptbl o

mut eitr rtto s Co sse twi Ame i tsitr r tto , h abtao d e o d rta
li n ep eai n . n itn t
pl
h
rj ' nep eain t e r irt r o s r e h t
e
t a a d s d be r ad i r f r nc t t pr ag ee en pr c i ofnotpos i c pone
he w r houl
e n e e e e o he e- r m t a tce
tng om
nt
l gs d pie l ng ge t t c r r i t com pa ha
e es t a ua o he ont a y n he
ny ndbook. See Pl' Com pl Ex.8, t 1
.s
.
a 7.

Thi p a tc wa d et t raiyt ttnma yc s s ( r eld dno k o wi a y
s r cie s u o he e lt ha,i n a e , Ame i t i t n w t n
i
j
h
r s bl de e ofc r a nt w ha f i s orr esw oul fy on a gi n da on wha
ea ona e gr e
e ti y
t lght
out
d l
ny ve y,
t

equpm e , wih whatc pone lgsa i wha or r untlt e ni be or t fi s
i nt and t
om
nt e nd n
t de , i he ve ng f e he lght

d p rld . I a 1 .Ame i tte eo eo fr ara o a eitmrtto wh r t earie
e ate l' d t 5
'
rj h r f r fes e s n bl ne eain ee h il
e
n
woul onl pos t e c
d y t hos ompone lgst ta eale s heduld, and t known wih c rant
nt e ha r r ady c
e
hus
t e ti y,
a t tmet r tri publs d.
t he i he ose s
ihe
Neve t e s t l s isan e lyr a ona e at r tve i e pr a i r quii
rhels , he BT ubm t
qua l e s bl le na i ntr etton e rng

Ameie t po ta1c mp n n lgss b e tt c n e i s h d lsb s do t arie sn e s
r t o s 1 o o e t e u j c o ha g s n c e u e a e n he il ' e d .
j
n
S ha u d rtn i i i a c r a c wihtembi ao ' h li t a Ameie i l ie tdt
uc n n esa dng s n c o d n e t h
t t rs odng h t r t s ç rce o
r
j
d
i l t s he e tm eoft rc pone l gson t 28- y r tr s he e a deaied
ncude he c dul d i
hei om
nt e
he da ose ed c dul s t l

a dsuse . . wi t eu d rtndn t a g r el e ev s h rg tt c a g s c
nd ic s d . , t h n e sa ig h t Amei t r s r e t e ih o h n e u h
h
j
s h d l a ar s t fg r eld tr ne b sn s ne ds' Thec nsr cini frh r
c e ue s eulo Ame i t eemi d u ie s e .
j
'
o tu to s u te
rif re b t abtao ' rc g iint a t ieg rjt ef cu t sc ng si ti p td
en o c d y he r irtrs e o nto h tç l Ame iel fe tae ha e n h s ose
wh
mont y s he efo tmet tm e,hepose publcs he ei a o ma ey 90% a c a e.''
hl c dul r m i o i t
td
i c dul s ppr xi t l
c ur t
1 a 1 1.
d. t 6- 7
Be us t pa tespr e c lci ye plusbl i e pr t tonsoft a r , t
ca e he ri es nt onfi tng t a i e nt r e ai
he wa d he

Co r a t i sa ed ne Ameie' moint ds s Co n VIfrlc o s b e tmatr
u t t h s t g e is rjts to o imis u t o a k f u j c te
j rs ito l isr ln o teI So ii a c mpan ,hi Co r wa c n tn dt th
u idcin. n t uig n h BT' rgn l o lit t s u t s o c r e ha te
uni wasm e ey s e ngconfr ai oft a bir la r a am at rofc s a t coul
on
r l e ki
im ton he r ta wa d s
te
our e nd hus
d

notalgealvea acua diput bet e t pa tes Se Ame fetI ',201 U. Dit
le
i nd t l s e we n he ri . e r ntl 2 S. s.
LEXI 1
S 49264, t*27. Ac e i t I Spr e a lga i a tue, t Cour fndst tt
a
c ptng he BT' es nt le tons s r he
t i ha he
uni hasa s ge t Co tsconc r by a lgi a ditnc vi a i ofisi e r tton oft
on
s ua d he ur '
en
le ng si t olton t ntm ea i
he
a bir la r i t f ofiscai r r ng PiotPalci . Acc di y, he Cour de e
r ta wa d n he onn t l m ega di
l
a os
or ngl t
t ni s

Ameie' 1 ( ( ) to
r ts 2b)1 moin.
j
Sn eAmei t t a n al o fr tesmea g me t nis1 ( )6 moin,h Co r
ic
r e fmd me tl fes h a r u n i t 2 b ( ) to t e u t
j
y
lke s de e t a ri ' ale nai ba i f dimis l Vi wi t c
i wie ni s he ilne s tr tve ss or s s a . e ng he ompl i i t lg
ant n he i ht

m os f vo a et t I a a s i t ve a iy oft uni sf cua alegai , see
t a r bl o ht BT nd s um ng he r ct
he on' a t l l tons

S a e , 2 F.da 1 7 t e1 h sa e uaeysae acam t a Ameie viltdte
pe k r 6 3 3 t 3 9,h BT a d q tl ttd li h t r t oae h
j
a r ast l co eve i.TheCour s l r ol t mate oft pa te 'va yi
wa d he BT nc i s t
t ha l es ve he tr he ri s r ng
i e rt tonsa a lt sa ast is i i t t e s nta m e isoft I Scai . A t
ntm e a i
t aer t ge he s ue mplcaes he s e i l rt he BT' l m
t stme,hel ha pr s n ed s fce f cua alegai nsi Co tVlt s vi am otont
hi i t BT s e e t ufi int a t l l to n un
o ur ve
i o
dl r s .
s nl s

1 1 CONCLUSI
1.
ON
Fo t a
r he bover s ,ti
ea ons i s
ADJUDGED t t
ha

()Dee a tAmeie ltr ain llc' M oint SrkeCo n s1 l, nd1Ia dt
1 fnd n
rjt n en to a,n .s to o ti u t , l a l n o
DimisCount I V, ndV1oft Fis Ame dCompli ( E. 31 ,iedon
s s
s V, a
he rt nde
ant D. No. ) fl
Nove be 20.201 i GRANTED I PART a DENI I PART.
m r
2, s
N
nd
ED N

( )Th Co r g a t Ameie' moint srk Co n s1 l, n l1 nd rRue1 9 a
2 e u t r n s rjts to o tie u t ,I a d l u e l 2( s
t sCo r ha ar a yd s s e t ec u t frlc o s b e t te j rs ito
hi u t s le d imis d h o n s o a k f u j c matr u idcin.
( )Th Co r ga t Ameie' mo int d s s Co n I a t eI h sfie t sae
3 e u t r ns r ts to o imis u t V s h BT a ald o tt
j
acli a lgi aco r t vi ai n oft a bir la d.
am le ng
nc ee olto
he r ta war

( )Th Co r d nisAmeie' moint ds s Co nsV a dVl Th I h s
4 e ut e e
r ts to o imis u t n . e BT a
j

s fc e ty a lgedvi a i oft r s tvea bir la ds
ufi i n l le
oltons he e pec i r ta war .

()Th 1 s alîea n n e c mpan n ltrt a Aprl9 2 1 .
5 e BT h l fl n mt d d o lit o ae h n i . 0 3

DON E AND ORDERED i Cha r a M im i Fl i t s
n
mbe s t a , orda, hi

da ofM a c 201
y
r h, 3.

FEDE
A. O
M
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRI J D GE
CT U
Co e pr de t
pi s ovi d o:

Com s lofRec d
t e
or