International Brotherhood of Teamsters, v. Amerijet International, Inc.
Filing
53
ORDER Denying Motion for Summary Judgment Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 12/4/2013. (bnt)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
Cas Num be 1 60654- V- ORENO
e
r: 2CI M
I
NTERNATI
ONAL BROTHERHOOD
TEA M STER S,
0F
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.
AM ERIET W TERNATI
J
ONAL,f ,
NC.
D e e nt
f nda .
/
ORDER DENYI DEFENDANT AM ERI
NG
JET I
NTERNATI
ONAL.I '
NC.S
M O TI N FO R SU M M A R Y JUD G M EN T
O
THI CAUS c mebeo eteCo r u o De e d n Ame i tItr ain l n . M oin
S
Ea
f r h u t p n fn a t r e n en to a I c' to
j
s
f SummayJ
or
r udgmen ( E.No.42) fldonJul 22. 3.Purua t Fed.R. v.P.56and
t D.
, ie
y 201
s nt o
Ci
Lo a Rue5 1 i i ADJ
c l l 6.,t s UDGED t a Dee d n Ame i tsM oi nf rS mma yJ g n i
h t fn a t rj ' to o u r ud me t s
e
DENI ast Co 1 Thi Cour fndst t he ei nodiput ofm a e i f c ast Ar ta orJ y
ED o unt . s
t i ha t r s
s e
t ral a t o bir t a
God ti 'j rs ito t a r ashe ui grme ywihnte1 r - ' r irto .Thi Co r
lsen s u idci n o wad c d ln e d t i h % o G'abtai n s u t
Ze
REM ANDS Count1 t Ar ta orDe sCa gnaf f t rclrfcai Thi Cour fndst t
1 o bir t
nni mpa
or urhe a ii ton. s
t i ha
t ei mpo e tL g' r taind cso i s b e t omu t eg o fi itr rtto , n a
h û
co n n e 'abi to e iin s u j c t li o d at n ep eains a d s
r
pl
h
ii i r p rf r hsCo r t p s iso u g n a t teb s itr r tto o tea r ,h
t s mp o e o t i u to a s t wnj d me t s o h e t nep eain f h wa d t e
Cour r m a t m a trt Ar tat Ca gna.
t e nds he te o bir or mpa
Pr e alBac ound
oc dur
kgr
Pl ntf l e natonalBr he hood of Tea t r i a lbor or ni a i t tr pr s nt
ai if ntr i
ot r
ms e s s a
ga z ton ha e e e s
s p rt b r anig u isofAmeie ltn ain l(l r e' ' plt a d fih e gn e s
e aae ag i n nt
r t n e zto a t i t' s ios n lg t n ie r .
j
Ame j l
Amei ti ac mmo arc rirta i s be toted te o teRalo dLa o Ac ($ '4
r e s o n i a re h t s u jc t h uis f h ir a b r t $
j
RLA' 5
)
U. C. 1 , t e ( 98 ) Th RL p o i safa wokço r s lto o d s u e b t e ar
S. j 51 e s q.1 6 . e A r vde rme r ' r e o uin f ip ts ewe n i
f
c rir a dt er mpo e sha ûr wl o t f re a c s o o t fh i tm rtto o a p iain
ares n h ie ly e t tg o ) u o giv n e , r u o t e ne eain r p lc to
ofa e ment c e ni r t o pay, u e ,o wor ng condii .' f
gr e
s onc r ng aes f
r l s r ki
tons'' #.
On Aug t27,2009,afe f y r ofba g ni wihoutr a ng a ag ee nt t
us
tr our ea s
r ai ng t
e chi n r me , he
ltmain lBr t eh o o Te mse siiitdasrk a an tAmeie. Se tmb r8 2 0
ne to a o h r o d f a tr ntae tie g is
r tOn p e e , 0 9,
j
t I e nai l Br he hood
he ntr tona ot r
o Te mse s a d Ame i tra h d t c le tv b r anig
f a tr n
r e e c e wo olcie ag i n
j
a r e nt r s i t t c
g e me s e ponsve o he once nsofpiot andfi hte nee s r s ctvel Thei tnta ton
r
l s
lg ngi r , e pe i y.
nsa ci
a os when t I e a i
r e
he nt m tonalBr he hood ofTe m ser br
ot r
a t s oughta sxi countc pli a i t
om a nt ga ns
Ameie se igrle o av reyof s u e aiigo t fh g iv n ep o e u e o t p ris
r t e kn eif n ait dip ts rsn u o te re a c r c d rs fhe a t '
j
e
c le tv b r aniga re n s Th Co r prvo syd s s e f u o t esxc u t. r e
olci e ag i n g e me t. e u t e iu l imis d o r f h i o n s Ame i t
j
n w mo e f rs mmayj d me t ntermanngt c u t, r s nl stf rha Comt 1a d
o
v s o u r u g n o h e ii wo o ns p e e ty e o t s l s n
1 o Plitf Ame i tsS c ndAme d dCo an .nt e eCo n s l en t na Br teho d
1 f anif r e ' e o
j
n e mplit l h s u t,ntr ai l oh r o
o
ofTe m se ss kse or e e oft a bir ton a ds r f r e t bewe n t pa te ast
a tr ee nf c m nt wo r ta i war , e e r d o t e he ri s he
û r G' a d (
i o- ' war Count1 a t l
ze
) nd he l
compone Leg'a r ( unt1) Bot a r c r
nt ' wa d Co 1. h wa ds oncen
Ameie' ma a e n rg tt sh d l a da sg wok.
r ts n g me t ih o c e u e n sin r
j
I.
I
Lega St
l andar
d
i a horze whe e t r i no ge ne i s of m aera f c .
s ut i d
r he e s
nui s ue
t il a t
S mma y j d me t
u r ug n
F dR. V. 5 () Th p rys e igs mmayj d me t e r teiiil r e o d mo tai
e . Ci P. 6 c . e a t e kn u r u g n b a s h n t bud n f e nsrtng
a
t a e e ofa ge ne is ofma e i lf c .Adi e v S.L Kr s d:Co. 398 U. 1 1
he bs nc
nui s ue
t ra a t ck s . I
es
,
S. 44, 57
( 9 0 . e p ry o p sn te mo in f rs mmayj d me tma n tsmpl rs u n mee
1 7 ) Th a t p o i g h to o u r u g n y o i y e t po r
I
aleg tonso deni soft pladi ; henon- o ngpa t mus e t ih t e s i elment
l ai
r
al he e ngs t
m vi
ry
t sabls he s ental e
s
ofisc eon whih i wilbea t bur n ofpr a til Ce otx Cor v Cate t 477 U, 31
t as
c t l r he de
oof t ra . l e
p. . r t,
S. 7
( 9 6 ; as s t Elc l du .Co v Ze ihRa i Cop.47 U. 5 4 ( 9 6 . en mn v n
1 8 ) M tu hi e . n s . . nt d o r , 5 S. 7 1 8 ) Th o o a t
a
t
m us pr e m or t a s ntla ofevi ncei s
t es nt e han ci il
de
n uppor oft nonmova fsposton.
t he
nt
ii Ande s v.
r on
4
.
7
t
fie t Lo b I c, 7 U. 2 2 2 4( 9 6 .
b r b y, n .4 7 S. 4 , 5 1 8 )
y
Th sa d r o r ve f raa btaina r i h g A d src c u tlols n t it h a
e tn a d f e iw o r i to wad s ih. itit o r t e ) o sto e r
r
d
'
1
.
cli soff c ua orl le r by a a bir t asa a la ec t si r viwi de sonsof
am
a t l ega ror n r taor n ppe lt our doe n e e ng cii
(
lwe c u t.Pa r r e sUn o v M ic , n .4 4U. 2 , 8( 98 ) Fu temo e t d itit
o r o rs' pe wo k r in . s o I c, 8 S. 9 3 1 7 . rh r r ,û lsrc
'
g
)
.
,
(
J
c u t h a igglbtaina p aswil o r -x miet emeiso f cu l eemi ai n o te
o rs e rn ar irto p e l ln t ee a n h rt r a ta d tr n to s f h
undel ngabirtona r 'Gr Am.I .Co.v. o 733F. 2d 1 1 ( . Fl
ryi r tai wa d.' eat
ns
M ye,
Supp. 298, 301 M D. a.
'
201 .An a birr a ca i oussandad al a abirton a r t sa ta slng a a
0)
r ta y nd prci t r lows n r tai wad o tnd i l o s
l
.
;
7
r s bl bassa asf t de ii ' Whiev Coc
eaona e i ppe r or he cson. t . a-col Co.5 F. 848,856( 1hCi.
'
a , 42 3d
1t r
:
2008)Anabir tona r i t prs i l e ildt deee ea e o c me . e e. ,
. r tai wad s hus e umptvey ntte o frnc nd nf r e ntSe , g.
'
!
ê
333 1 t r 2007 .Howeve,a
)
r n
Ros ns g v M o gan St e drCo. I . 494 F. 1 28,1 ( 1h Ci.
e wei . r
anly
, nc,
3d 3
,
a r m a notbe enf r e t
wa d y
ocd l
when ..t ar ta de son does notl aw is e s nc fo t
. he bir l cii
dr t s e e r m he
q
c l c i ba ga ni a e m e .'st l ke sv En eprs làc / CarCor , U . 593, 96
ole tve r i ng g e nt'' eewor r . t r ie F c &
p.363 S. 5
@
,
E
)
,
'
y
(9 ( .
j 6)
)
@
l
11
1.
Anal i
yss
9
A.
Ar tatonAwar 1 t Zer G Awar (
bir i
d : he od CountJ
)
.
)
I Co lo isSe ond Am e d Compli ,he l t r tona Br he hood ofTea se s
n unt f t c
nde
a nt t n e na i l ot r
m tr
s e t e or ar dy s tf t i wha t pa te ha c ld t
e ks o nf ce eme e orh n
t he ri s ve ale he e
r
/
7
)
.
l
te ei nod s u eo mae ilfcsrg r igt ea btao ' j rs it n t a r ashe ui g
h r s ip t f tra a t e a dn h r i t rs u idci o wa d c d ln
r
o
q
r me bewe n t pa te , nd aco ts l no o he wier vi w a abir tona a d, hi Co t
e dy t e he ri s a
ur ha l t t r s e e n r tai w r t s ur
DENI Slmm a y J
ES z r udgmen ast Co 1
t o unt .
f
i Undiput FacsPe tnentt t Ze o- Awa d
.
s ed t ri
o he r G
r
Amei t p r tstih ssmuaigz r ga i a c r igt ac n rc wihZeoGrvt
r e o eae lg t i ltn eo r vt c o dn o o ta t t r a iy
j
y
(
1
y
)
i
r
Co rto Be i n i u 20 9 Ame i t mp o e ft zeo- Pr fsin l ih En i es
moain. g l g nl ne 0 , r e e ly d ol r G o e so a Flg t gne r:
mi
j
r
t
E
(
E
s r
s a nd c el a. o une i
t
He t rFue es Tom a Se na,Lui Roc ,a M i ha Roc Fr m J untlAugus of2009 co
nt ,
i
a p o i tl t mo ts-tea sg me to Ze oG wo kb Ameie wa d n b t s p rt
p r xmaey wo nh h sin n f r - r y r t s o e y wo e aae
j
)
r ai nsa o t f Ze o- qualfe Pr es i
ot to m ng he our r G
ii d of sonalFlghtEngi e s one f NASA Ze oi
ne r ,
or
r G
l
fi t a onef c me cilZe o- fi s Ea h oft f i vi l wasgi n r hl t
lgh s nd
or om r a r G lght . c
he our ndi dua s
ve oug y he
)
s me a mto fi tm e,e urng e ch te t r uiie hour t r mai qualfe f NASA
a
mot f lght i
ns i a l w he eq st
so e n
ii d or
:
)
as i
sgnme . swa donei an i pa i ofa s t tali r a ei NA SA ti s
nt Thi s
n tci ton
ubsan i nc e s n
lght .
'
(
.
7
on Augus 27,2009,t I e ai lBr t hood ofTea se si taed a srke a i t
t
he nt m tona o her
m tr niit
ti gans
!
.
i
Ame i tOnSe tmb r8 2 0 teItr ain l oh r o o Te msesa dAmeie ra h d
rj .
e
p e e , 0 9,h n en to a Br teho d f a tr n
r tec e
j
t c l ci bar i nga e nt c rngpiot a fi hte nee s r peci l and sgned
wo ole tve gani gr eme s ove i l s nd lg ngi r , es tvey,
i
aLetr f r e n p e ni Ameie fo rtlai a ans e o e sf rh iiv v me t
te o Ag e me t rve tng r tr m eaitng g i t mply e o tern ole n
j
'
q
(
C
)
i t srke. srkee d on Se embe 1 2009whe piot a fi ht ne r r tfe t i
n he ti The ti nde
pt
r 3,
n l s nd lg engi e s aii d her
)
è
c rs
ore pondi c l c i ba gani a r e e s.
ng ole tve r i ng g e m nt
L
ï
.
t
Fr Aug t27,
om
us
2009, n t wor so gebe n, i t srke sr t ned t wor
whe he k t ppa
ga untl he ti r e ur o
k
2
J
.
b
ona
bout t be 1 2009, t
Oc o r ,
HecorFue e wa t onl oneoft f l Ze o- qualfe Pr e sona
nt s s he y
he otr r G
ii d of s i l
)
.
)
Flg Engi e sa ia ef as i nm e t Ze o- fi s a hewast onl oneoft f t t
i ht
ne r va lbl or sg nt o r G lght, s
he y
he our ha
C
di notpa tcpat i t srke W he t srke s r t ne t wor t c l tve ba gai ng
d
rii e n he ti .
n he ti r eur d o
k, he oleci
r ni
a r e ns e p e sy r sr e t Ame i t t rg t t s h d l a a sg wo k.Ha n
g e me t x r sl e e v d o
rj he ih o c e u e nd sin r
e
vig
L
d s o tn e te f u - es n r tto b n c si d rn t e srk ,Ame ie ee td t b gn
ic n iu d h o rp ro o ai n y e e st u ig h tie
y
rj t lce o e i
'
a sgni t Ze o- wo k t Pr e sona FlghtEngi e sbas on s ni iy. nt , hem os
s i ng he r G r o of s i l i
ne r
ed
e ort Fue es t
t
sen
l
i rZe o- qualfe Pr e sona Flg Engi r r c ve t wor whe hewasav l bl and
o r G
ii d of s i l i ht
nee , e ei d he k
n
aia e,
Se nawa as i
r
s sgnedwih Fue e wasnota ia e.Lui Roc a M i elRoc di notr t n t
t
nt s
val bl
s a nd cha
a d
e ur o
)
(
.
)
wor i Oc o rof2009. nse t y we ehe d outf o wor untllt J r of201 duet
k n t be
I t ad, he
r l
rm
k i a e anua y
0
o
)
.
'
,
t
i tga i i o alegai ofm ic
nvesi tons nt l tons
s onduc .ThusFue esa Se na s r d wor butdue t a
t
nt nd r ha e
k,
o
(
L
'
s
r
de r as i t qua iyofZe o- wor a tci t d fo wha ha be n pr di td i t s me of
c e e n he ntt
r G
k n i pa e r m
t d e e ce n he um r
2009,t r wasno Ze o- wor i J nuar orM a c o 201
he e
r G
kn a y
r h f 0.
)
)
'
W h nteRo a ddrtm , rj t i n t lc t rt r t afu - ro r tto f r r e h c s i eu Ame i dd o ee to eu n o o rpes n o ain o zeo
e
,
G wor a sg nt . onl we eneihe oft Roc squa i d f NASA as i
k s inme s Not y r t r he a
lûe or
sgnmen s a t y
t , s he
'
ha notwor d t r quiieZe o- fi so rt pror90 da pe i butm or ove ,hes l
d
ke he e st r G lght ve he i
y rod,
e r t ma l
.
'
.
q
'
qua iy ofZe o- fi ht di notr quieexpa i oft num be ofqualfe Pr e sona Flg
ntt
r G lg s d
e r
nson he
r
i d of s i l i ht
t
l
j
En ie r. r e ddn t lc t r-r i teRo a a di o et c sso is u tme r r gn es Ame i t i o ee to etan h c s n mp s he o t n t c so rze o G,
j
.
1
whih by c r twasr ponsbl f t expe e a s i t d wih tani Thust Roca we e
c
ontac
es i e or he
ns s s oc a e t r i ng.
he
s r
'
n ticu e i Zeo G a sg me t f lo n terb ltdrt r t Ameie i J n ayof 01
o n ld d n r - sin n s o lwig h i eae eu n o rjt n a u r 2 0.
k
t
t
t
i. Ze o- Gre nc sa Ar ta i n
i The r G iva e nd bir to
(
On Odobe 26,2009,t l t m a i
r
he n e tonal Br her
ot hood of Tea t s fld t ç r p'
mser ie wo i ou '
g
J
C
q
.
i
'
gre nc , one o be l of t f m e
iva es
n haf
he our mber of t Pr es i
s
he of sonal Flg Eng ne r g oup,
i ht
i e r
t
compl ni t :
ai ng hat
q
.
(
i
Al ta ne c e
l r i d r wme be swho haves c a qualfca i ,ie. o- a e notbe ngtown
m r
pe i l ii tons . Zer G, r
i l
1
.
)
i a co da e wih t NA SA r quie t oftyi 3 pa a i fi swihi 90 da .
n c r nc t he
e r men s l ng 0 r bolc lght t n
ys
(
)
'
@
L
.
(
The e c ewm e be sw ilnotbe c r ntw ih N A SA .
s r
m r l
ur e
t
'
E
E
Th rme ys u h wa t çimme aeytyal p ca q ai dce mbes ob c re t
e e d o g t so t j ditl l ls e il u l
l
se r wme r t e ur n
(
wi NAS rq ie n sa p r h i s e ilri n 'Se Ar irto De iino God ti ( E.
t
h
A e ur me t s e t er p ca tanig. e btain cso f lsen D.
'
)
'
(
;
I
48- )a 2.
1 t
The Chi Piotdenid t gre
ef l
e he ivanc s i a or nc wih t tr ts e oft m ulise
e n cc da e t he is tp
he
t-t p
.
J
)
'
gre nc pr s i t c lci bagani a e me s i t ei no (ole tvebagani
iva e oces n he ole tve r i ng gre nt,ç her s c lci r i ng
as
)
a re n) e u rme tomananZeo G s h d l o c re y' J a 3. rh giv n e wee
g e me trq ie n t iti r - c e ue r u rnc .f . t Aûe t e re a c s r
'
è
as nida ubs que t psi hepr es , nda nc dt heSyse Boa d, c a oc d,
lode e ts e ntse nt oc s a dva e ot
tm
r whihde dl ke
1
è
t l ena i na Br t r
he nt r to l ohe hood ofTea tr a nc t g iva st a bir ton.I hi de ii
mse s dva ed he re nce o r tai n s c son,
)
t
Ar taorJ y Gol t i c ude t tt r wasno cla e de t s
bir t a
dse n oncl d ha he e
e r vi nce o uppor t contnton t t
t he
e i ha
.
.
'
l
i
Ameie so p d a sg i g a y g iv ns t Zeo- a iy fih si rtlain f rt eru i n
r t tp e sin n n re a t o r Grvt lg t n eaito o h i n o
j
i
i
aci te , ndde e t gre nc wihr s c t a vi a i oft pa tescole tveba gani
tvii s a
ni d he iva e t e pe t o ny olton he ri
lci
r i ng
)
!
è
j
a e mentort Let rofAg e m e t I a 1
gr e
he te
r e n . d t 2.
)
'
è
Uli tl ho v r Ar i ao God ti d cd dt a Ame i tsZe o G wo k s h d l
tmaey, we e , bt tr l sen e i e h t r e, r - r c e u e
r
j
)
ough t beat r d.
to
le e Expli ngt tal rilr dy'wa ç e r dt a dt pot i f a y
ani ha ç ta eme ' s E quie o voi he ental or n
pa
r
,
t
)
mia p idfin s,, ed rce t a Ameie mo iyi s h d ln prcie i s c,awa s a
sp le ar e s,h ie td h t r t df t c e u ig a tc s n u 1
j
s
yo s
t e il Lui an M i hae Roc t beas i d t Ze o- fyi 1 a 1
o ntte s d c l a o
sgne o r G l ng. d. t 3.
(
.
l
t
)
!
.
i
.
ii Enf ce
i. or mentoft Ar ta i Awa d
he bir ton
r
A fd rl o rma dei t v c t o rma da abtaina r o l itea r tal
e ea c ut y cde o a ae re n n ri to wad ny fh wad E is
r
f
t c n o o c nfn is l, o matr wihn t es o e o t e S se Bo r o Adusme ts
o o f nn, r o i e tef t te s t i h c p f h y tm ad f j t n '
g
)
j rs cin'ctn Pa s n v Co t Ailn s I c, 5Fe . p' 7 9, 01( 1hCi. 0 7 .
u idito , iig ro s . n ' ri e, n .21 d Ap x 9 8 1 t r2 0 ) An
'
l
a bir t ' a hort i cr um s rbe by t a bir to a e nt whe he a a bir t has
r taors ut iy s ic c i d
he r tai n gr eme ;
t r n r ta or
e e d dt e eb u d i a is efr u iile o uin. g l Wigl Ope a o s' rho s ,n .
xc e e h s o n s s n su o j dca r s l to Pigy g y r tr Wa e u e I c
7
.
J
v Pi y Wi y Ope at r ' e
. ggl ggl
r o s War hous I p.Tr kDrie sUni Loc No. 6l1F. 58 584
e nde
uc
vr
on, al J,
2d 0,
( t Ci.1 8 ) s e a s Ce ta a ,l c,Fo tDo ge I wa v fo a No.81 ,I t Un o o
5h r 9 0 ; e lo nr l b n . r d , o . c l
6 n ' in f
l
I
Elcrc , doa dMac ieWo k r o
e tialRa i n
hn r e s fAme ia 8 7F.d 1 0 1 1 ( t Ci.1 8 )Cç hee
rc , 2 2 21 , 2 7 8h r 9 7 W r
E
a abi ao g e b y n hsc nr cu la t rt t d cd is e n tp o ry b f r hm,hs
n r t t r o s e o d i o ta ta uhoiy o e ie su s o r pel eo e i i
r
.
)
(
t
a r f ist dr w is e s nc fom t ag ee nta mus be va t d,de pie t us lgr t
wa d al o a t s e e r he r me nd
t
cae
s t he ua ea
.
j
t
i
'
oa
s o a on
def e e gi n t abirt ' a r .) Howe r abir t rs have br d power t f shi
ernc ve o r taors wads' .
ve , r ta o
)
E
t
a oprat r m e e o s
ppr i e e di s n ubmitd is s
te s ue .
!
:
:
Thi Cour i notc l t be a a l t c ton a bir ton de sons An a bir ton
s
ts
aled o
n ppelae our
r ta i
cii .
r tai
r
:
C
a r i pr s
wa d s e umptvey e il d t def r nc a e or e e .See eg. Ro e wei v M or
i l ntte o e e e nd nf c m nt , . , s ns g . gan
Sa ly & Co,I c,4 4 F.d 1 2 ,1 3 ( 1h Ci. 0 ) tf f dea poiy o stln lb r
tne
. n . 9 3 3 8 3 3 1 t r 20 7 .ç he e rl lc f etig a o
-
;
diput sbya bir to woul beunde mi di c t hadt fnal a on t me isoft a r .
s e
r tai n
d
r ne f ours
he i s y he rt he wa ds'
'
l
J
,
(
i
l
Ent r ie Fàce,363 U . a 596.J c a r viw ofa a r i ûi r
eprs
/
S. t
udii l e e
n wa d s lcicums rbe 'asa bir t s
c i d, r ta or
1 ono a t s u ir a st til o rs ees b e u n a pelt rv e i ra iya ia et t
d t c a j no v ri ra c u t wh r u sq e t p lae e iw s e d l valbl o he
y
l sn pat '' tCh re , C v S h re b r e , 4 F.d 8 6 8 ( 1hCi. 01 ) Aste
o ig ry. Ca a tr LL . c u tn e g r 6 6 3 3 , 43 1 t r 2 l. h
'
C
Supr m e Cour o e ve i Entr ie J c / ç twast a bir t ' consr ton whi h was
e
t bs r d n e prs c c , ç
l
he r ta ors
tuci
c
l
m onsr c i
he ontac, he rs
ba gane f ;a s f ra t a bir orsde sonc
r i d or nd o a s he r tat ' cii once sc tu ton oft c r tt cou t
,
C
ha no busne so rulnghi be us t ri e r tto oft co r c i dif e fom hi.'
ve
i s ve r i
m ca e hei nt p e ai n he nta t s fer nt r
s'
J
.
l
'
.
?
363 U. a 599.
S. t
i
Ana r spr s
wa d' e umptonofe or ea lt hol tu e ni t r viwi c t i f t al
i
nf c biiy ds r e ve f he e e ng our fnds ac u
'
y
.
l
l ga e r ordia e swih t a bir orsi e pr tton oft pa tes conta t ç a et
e l ror
s gr e t he r tat ' ntr e ai
he ri ' r c .t us he
Bec
L
or
.
t
)
pa teshave c r ced t have dipu ess tl d b a a bir t c e by t m r t rt n by a
ri
onta t o
s t e te y n r taor hos n
he ahe ha
)
'
2
j g ,t shea btao y ve o t fcsa do t eme nn o tec nrc t a t e h v a re
ud e ii t r i t rs iw fhe a t n f h a ig fh o ta t h t h y a e g e d
r
'
t a c p . Untdpa r r es1 t Un o v M ic , n .48 U. 29 3 ( 98 )(L ic ' ; e
o c e t' ie pe wo k r n 1 in . s o I c, 4 S. , 8 1 7 Q s o' s e
'
M
j
)
'
,
j
1
as r R. a eCo v fo a Uno 7 9 1 t Un o o b rWo k r , U. 7 7(98 )t s
lo l Gr c . . c l in 5 , n 1 i n fRu be r es 461 S. 5 1 3 .f
r
A.
l ast a bir ori e a gua yc tui ora yi t c r c a a tngwihi t s ope
ong he r tat s ven r bl onsr ng ppl ng he onta t nd c i
t n he c
'
ofhi aut iy,ha acou t sc nce hec
s hort t t
r i onvi d omm it d s rouse r doesnots fc t o rur hi
te e i
ror
ufi e o ve t n s
E
.
7
)
dec son. M ic 484U . a 38.t a bir t ' r ul m a bewr
ii ' s o,
'
S. t ç r ta ors es t y
An
ong;i maya aruns
t
ppe
uppored;
t
f
1
j
.
ima a p a p o l e s ne ;t ya p a f oih. tt yn t s be toc u tn efr n e'
t y p e r o ryra o d ima p e r o ls Ye ima o be u j c t o ritree c .
'
.
t
!
(
'
!
.
)
'
y
)
j
'
t
Det Ai Lie v Ai LiePiosAso .8 F.d6 5 67 ( 1h Ci. 98 )
l r n s . r n l t s c, 61 2 6 , 0 1 t r 1 8 .
a
t
t
,
a os fom t e s nceoft pa te c lc i ba gani a e m e .He r le on pas pr c ies
r e r he s e
he ri s' ole tve r i ng gr e nt
e id
t a tc
.
He e t sCo tde e st t a bir t ' a r Ar ta orGol t i ss hed i r m e
r , hi ur f r o he r taor s wa d. bir t
dse n' c ulng e dy
t
a d ta iin ln to so abi a fin s , rwi gu o Ameie' patp a tc swi r s d t
n rd t a oi n f r t l ar e s d a n p n
o
r
r ts s rcie t epe o
j
h
C
.
1
Ze o- ti bi ng i t c tu ton ofa e t bl a r f bot pari i ar taton. s
r G lght ddi n he onsr c i
n quia e wa d or h tes n bir i Thi
)
è
'
4
ti o raci n;i i wels tl dt tabir t sm a us e rnscads i l ngt pa t
mpr pe to t s l- ete ha r ta or y e xti i i , ncudi he s
W aS no
pr c i oft pa tes ba g ni hit y, nd r e ntlgi lton,t t ext ntt i i pr i
a tce he ri , r ai ng sor a elva e sai o he e hat t s obatve
,
'
q
.
oft çs ns oft a ee e ' a ii of a t coledi ba ga ni a e m e pe m is'
he se e
he gr m nt' nd tns ar s he l ve r i ng gr e nt r t .
'
i
.
fo ee sv Ea tr Ai Lie , n w6 1F.d 1 2,1 0 ( 1hCi.1 8 )( i to so te ) s e
v ls . se n r n s I c, 8 2 27 28 1 t r 9 2 ct i n mitd ; e
a
alo M a Le gueBa ebalPlye sAs ' v.Gar e 53 U. 504,509( ) Ast Supr
s jor a
s l a r sn
vy, 2 S.
2001 . he eme
'
Co r n tdi Untds e l r esv Wa ro d Guf vga inCo,t ei d sra c mmo lw
u t oe n ie tewo k r . r ir r lNa i t
o .th n u til o n a
t
J
.
-
)
i
i
t pr c i soft i tyandt s - i e l apa t t c l tveba gani a e m e
he a tce he ndusr
he hop s qualy r of he oleci
r i ng gr e nt
at hnote e s di i. 363US 57 58182( 960)
lhoug
xprs e n t'
'
4, - 1 .
W h n t p risv ln ai s b e tte tv st abtain,o e p ry s o l n tb
e wo a t ou trl u j c h ms le o r irto n a t h ud o e
e
y
E
l
è
.
al we t r -ii t t is pr e e me el be aus t dec son r nde e wa unf vo a e.
lo d o e ltgae he s ues es ntd r y c e he ii e r d s a r bl
t
Ameie akst i Co r t r - iht e i e c i isfv ra dt rc n ie t ed s ueo is
r t s h s u to e weg he v d n e n t a o n o e o sd r h ip t n t
j
.
t
f
(
me is pr ciel wha t Supr m e Cou thas ca i d cours not t do i r vi ng l bo
rt, e s y
t he
e
r
utone
t
o
n e ewi a r
J
a bir ton a r .M i o,484 U . a 38.l t a t vac t a a bir ton a r t r le t t
r ta i wa ds sc
S. t
nse d, o a e n r ta i wa d, he ei f ha
!
)
t
Ameie se s Ame i tç trf t e eyra o a l b ssu o whc teabtao ma h v
r t e k , re %
j
j mus e ue v r e s n be a i p n ih h r i tr y a e
r
a td'Os a S la i, n . . e mse sLo a Uno J #, 7F.d 1 61 1 6 ( 1h Ci. 9 6 .
ce . r m y v na l c v T a tr c l in 2 8 3 2 , 2 4 1 t r 1 9 )
'
Co s q e tyteb r e fc db Ameie i hg a di o et t r e ha fie t me t t
n e u n l h u d n a e y r t s ih n s n ha Amei t s ald o e wih
j
j
r pe tt t sa r Ar ta orGol ti wa notr srded t t f cor r oft coleci
es c o hi wa d. bir t
dse n s
e ti
o he our ne s he l tve
.
g
j
i
7
,
J
'
(
ba ga n ng a r e nti hi de ii hewa pe f c l fe t co i rpa tpr c i andta tona
r i i g e me n s cson;
s r e ty r e o nsde s a tce
r dii l
:
no i of f i es i or r t c t e t i e of t pa tes By notng t s pi i
tons
am s n de o onsnz he nt nt
he ri .
i he us e ous
L
J
;
t
cru tn e sro n i Ameie'ma a eil e iin a du odngtegiva c d siete
ic msa c s uru dng r ts n g rad eso s n ph li h re n e ept h
j
.
'
ia e u c o tee ie eo d srmi ain, btao Godsend dn t a Ameie c ne ds
n d q a y f h vd nc f ici n to Ar irtr l ti i o , s r t o tn ,
j
t
t
'
f
aba n hi dut t i t p r tt pa te a e
ndo s y o n e e he ris' gr ement.He smpl r c a i emr a i a odds
s
i y ea hed n nt etton t
j
'
'
t
wi ta o Ameie a disv e o i l n g me t ih s'
t h t f r t n t iw f t ' a e n rg t.
h
j
s ma
'
Th r i n q eto o maeil a t st Ar i ao God ti ' e rieo j rs it ni
e e s o u sin f tra f c a o bt t r lsen s xecs f u idci n
r
o
'
à
7
(
t
:
.
rn ei gt ea r Ath h at fh Zeo G a r l s btao God ti sb le ta Ameie
e d rn h wad. te e ro te r - wa d i Ar i tr lsen' eifh t r t
e
r
j
ha nota r as bl wihi ism a ge e rght i c
d
ded e ona y t n t na m nt i s n hangi ispa t a tc ade e m i ton
ng t s pr c ie, t r na i
wihi t dic e i a a hort ofal bora bir t . ic 484U. a 39. bir t Gol t n'
t n he s r ton nd ut iy
a
r ta orM s o,
S. t Ar taor dsei s
j
'
a r fc s do fin s a an n ici n tr bdp o e s fn igAme i t a ama a e n
wad o u e n ar e s nd o d srmiao y i r c s ,i dn
r e h d n g me t
j
,
rg t s he e,buti ha t do s i s h a wa t ti woul no dic i i t aga ns t
i ht o c dul
t d o
o n uc
y ha t
d t s rm na e i t he
è
?
g i va s An a bir i de son i a r d sgnii a de e e ,a he e,he ei no dipu eof
re nt .
r taton cii s wa de i fc nt f r nce nd r t r s
s t
(
'
ma e i lf c s o y a at mptbyt De e
t ra a t , nl n te
he f ndan t r ltga eam a trde de by anar tat .
t o e-ii t
te ci d
bir or
)
J
B.
Ar taton Awar l:Theç
bir i
dl
çcompone Le 'Ar tatonAward(
nt gs' bir i
Count1)
1
)
)
Count1 conc r t a r i a s c
1
e ns he wa d n e ond,s pa a e a bir ton de son,r f r d t by t
e r t r ta i
cii e ere o
he
i
û
t
' bir ton. eagan, t ra f c sa enoti diput ast t s
' ta i Onc
i ma e i l a t r
n s e o hi
pa te a t Com pone Le a
ri s s he
nt gs r
.
.
Cou ; a he ,hepa tesc e thei e pr a i oft a bir tonawa d. sdiput , c we t
nt r t r t ri ont s t ntr etton he r ta i
r Thi s e whi h n
J
(
t
be or Ar taorDe sCa gna i a bir ton,c
f e bir t
nni mpa
n r tai once ne s hed i r t r .Thepa tesha
r d c ulng ose s
ri
d
ag e di ac l ci bar i ngag ee e tt tce ti d yr t r f pio sa pr es i lfi ht
r e n ole tve ga ni
r m n ha ran ut ose s or l t nd of sona lg
e ne r woul i udet s hed e tme oft rc
ngi e s
d ncl he c uld i
hei ompone lgs- Com pone l 'mea ng
nt e
c
nt egs
ni
!
'
r
j
t de al r ga di t sa tng a e ngdesi tonsofag ve ti pro t t sa tofe ch28he t is e r ng he t ri nd ndi
tnai
i n rN i r o he t r a
(
C
:
)
da bi perod.I a bir ton,t I e natona Br he hood ofTe m se sal ge t tt pa te '
d i n r ta i he nt r i l ot r
n t r le d ha he ri s
y
y
)
l
r
a re n ma d tst a al o tr r te tc mp n n lg ,b tt t r e wa po tn r se s
g e me t n ae h t l r se s el c o o e t e s u ha Amei t s sig o tr
j
t
.
.
wi u lsi t c mp n n lg o tih st beto o e e c bi pei d l t r , rj t
t t it he o o e t e s f lg t o l wn v r a h d ro . n u n Ame ie
ho
ng
t
'
a s re t tt pli l ua oft c l ci bar i ng a e
s e td ha he an ang ge he ole tve gani gr ementdi notr quie t tt
d
e r ha he
.
c
ompone l gsofea h ti be lsed i t fna r t r
nt e
c lght it n he i l ose .
(
l
i
l pe tne pat Se ton 8D)1 oft coleci bagani a ee ntrads
n ri nt r, ci ( ( ) he l tve r i ng gr me e :
,
7
2
,
è
)
a.Rose e Dutes - The r tr d or s heduld tme of dut perods wili ude t
trd
i
ose e
c
e i
y i
l ncl he
)
s he ed tme of t r compone l ,de dhea ng,ar r f r s ii ng,r e v
c dul i
hei
nt egs a
di
ic a t e postoni es r e,
)
tani a ot r ltddute .Se Ar tai De ii o Ca g ( E. 2)a 2.
ri ng nd her eae is e birton cson f mpa na D. 48- t
è
@
Thel ngua ofAr taorCn gna' a r c l st f l ng:
a
ge
bir t
mpa s wa d onc ude he olowi
)
?
i
t
l
U pon ca e ulr e oft r or e de e i t sca e,i i a r ntt tby posi a
r f eviw
he ec d vi nc n hi s t s ppa e ha
tng
mo t l pu l s h d l,( r elh sa fil go di e a t isd si to f rt a
n hy bi c e ue Amei t a ary o d a s o t etnains o h t
c
j
)
.
2
.
mo t .nt i r g r i wa d tn n dt a wh l ( r ezef cu tsc a g si ti
nh.l hs e ad,t s ee ni e h t ie Amei t fe tae h n e n h s
.
j
:
'
pose m on hl s he efom tm et tme,hepose
td
t y c dul r i o i t
t dpublcs he ei a oxi t l 90%
i c dul s ppr ma ey
)
;
a ur t .. c di y,t sAr taor s esno r as why t Company c nnotls t
cc a e.. or ngl hi bir t e
Ac
e on
he
a
it he
!
J
,
)
t
s h d e tmeo ace me rsc mp n n lg a rq ie b Se to 8 D)1, t te
c t uld i f r w mbe' o o e te s s e u rd y cin ( ( )wih h
a c pt d unde sa ng t tpe t pr - onta tpr c i fom 2004ce e
rt ndi ha r he e c r c a tce r
2009,apr tc we l
aci e l
k o t tep risa tetmet ya re u n teicu inoftes b e tln ua ea
n wn o h a te t h i he g e d po h n lso h u j c a g g s
p r o terCBAS s h d e c a e fo tmet-i o c rb sd u o g rjt'
at f h i
, c e uls h ng r m i -o tme c u a e p n Ame i ls
e
ne ds .
e ..
Gi n t f eg ngunde sandi , fnd a c udet tt Com pa i r s
ve he or oi
r t ngs 1 i nd oncl ha he
ny s e ponsbl
ie
...
t ls c mpo e tlg pe s ci n 8 d ()i t er trt te e tn n td a d d suse
o it o n n e s r e to ( )I n h ose o h x e t o e n ic s d
a o e S eAr tainDe ii no Ca g ( E. 8 2 a 1 - 7
b v . e bi to cso f mpa na D. 4 - ) t 6 1 .
r
'hs wadi s c pi et mulpl itr rtto . rjt fe sh thiln u g drcs
F ia r s us e t o t e n ep eainsAmeie o fr ta t s a g a e ie t
bl
i
t ari t pos onl t e c
he ilne o
t y hos omponentl t ta e ale dy s he e a t kno wih
egs ha r r a c dul ds nd hus wn t
c rait a t tm e t r t ri publs
e t n y, t he i he ose s
ihed.The 1 s
BT ubmis a e l r s bl aler tve
t n qualy ea ona e t nai
itr rtto h we r o frn t a t sln u g rq ie Ameie t po ta1c mpo e tlg
n ep eain, o ve , fe ig h t hi a g a e e ur s r t o s 1 o n n e s
j
s be tt c a g si s h d lsbae o teari esn e .
u jc o h n e n c e u e s d n h iln ' e ds
Thi Cour woul be i
s
t
d
mpnz ntt de e mi whih oft s t i e r t tons s ul
de o t r ne
c
he e wo nt m e a i
ho d
pr va lJ c a r e ofa bir tonawar i l m ongt na r s kno t t lw. I 'As n
e i. udii l eviw
r ta i
ds s t
a
he rowe t wn o he a ' ntl s'
'
o c nss r s c Wo k r v V n z l n ntr a in l Ava in S. , 78F.u p 2 4,
fMa hiit&Ae opa e r e s . e e o a al e n co a de ico , A.6 s p . 6
266( D. a.1 ) Thi Couris lhasar a o eve ha heS wadi s c ptbl t muli e
S. FI 988 . s ttef le dy bs r dt tt t r s us e i e o tpl
a
i eprttons'Or Grntngi Pa ta De ngi PatM otont Dimis( E.38 a 1 As
ntr eai .' der a i n r nd nyi n r i o s s D. ) t 7.
t Fis Cic tnotdk ri Piot As ' v PanAme i Aiwa Cor , F. 25( s Ci.
he rt rui e nAilne l s sn .
rcan r ys p.405 3d 1t r
20 ) ûg he e a atmpt t
05, iwl r n te
o
l nf c a a a d g ne a e or r vea s a di put r qui i
e or e' n w r e r t s
e l
s e e r ng
i e r tton oft a r s s peora ia i t diput mus be r f red t a r co ne
nt p ea i
he wa d' co
pplc ton, hat s e
t e e r o e nve d
boa dofa bir tonf dee na i ' Be a et sa bir ton a r i t a bi uoust e or ,
r
r ta i or t nni ton. c us hi r ta i wa d s oo m g
'
o nf ce
t sCou tr mandsi t Ar taorCa pa f ca is a i
hi
r e
t o bir t
m gna or lrtc ton.
l
V.
Conc uson
l i
Dee d n Ame i tsM oinf rS mma yJ d me tsDENI a t Cou t . eei n
fn a t r e ' to o u r u g n i
j
ED s o n 1Th r s o
d s u eo maeila tr g r igt abtao 'j rs i o oa r ashe u igrme yb t e
ip t f tra f cs e ad n he r i t rs u iddint wad c d ln e d ewe n
r
t pa te ,a acour s lnotot r s r viw a a bir ton a r Bec us t ç o pone
he ri s nd
t hal
he wie e e n r tai wa d. a e he f m
nt
Le ' abtai n d cso i s b e tt mutpe g o fih it mr tto s h we e , h sCo r
g' r irto e iin s u j c o lil o d at ne eain , o v r t i u t
REM ANDS Count1 t Ar taorDe sCa pa f f rhe c a ii a i
1 o bir t
nni m gna or u t r l rfc ton.
DN A D REE iCabsti ili,i1d oDc b, 1.
OE N ODRDnhmea a ,odts a feme2 3
r M m Frah y e r0
FED
UN E
Copi spr de t
e ovi d o:
Couns ofRe d
el
cor
O
O
ATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?