International Brotherhood of Teamsters, v. Amerijet International, Inc.

Filing 76

ORDER granting 67 Motion to Compel. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/31/2015. (whl)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SO UT H ERN D I
STR I O F FL O RI A
CT
D
N o.1 CV .
2- 6065 M O REN O
4W TERNATI
ONAL BROTHERHOOD of
TEA M STERS,

Pl nf i
aitf
VS.

AM ERI ET I
J NTERNATI
ONAL,I C.
N ,

De ndant
fe
.

ORDER GR ANTI M OTI TO COM PEL ARBI ATI
NG
ON
TR
ON
Thi c us c m ebef et Cour o r m a fom t Elve h Cicui Cour ofAppe s
s a e a
or he
t n e nd r he e nt r t
t
al.
TheCour ofAppeasr vered a or rfom t sCou tdim isng t l e natona Br her
t
l e s n de r hi
r s s i he nt r i l ot hood

o Te mse ' s i t c mp lteabi ain o t s t o g iv n e f rlc o s b e tmatr
f a trs u t o o e h r t to f wo es f re a c s o a k f u j c te
r
j rs it n. l a u p b ih d o i o ,te Co r ofAp e l r ld t a ti Co r h ss be t
u id ci n n n u ls e pnin h u t
o
p as u e h t h s u t a u j c
ma trj rs ito t c mp labi ain b t e teTe mse sa d Ame i t b td dn tr a h
te u idcin o o e r t to ewe n h a tr n
r
r e, u i o e c
j
t m e is of t ca e bec us a m oto was notpr ry bef e t c t Thi Cour now
he rt
he s
a e
in
ope l
or he our.
s
t
c i r t Te m se ' m oton t c
onsde s he a t rs
i o ompe ar tai a f l ng t sr ng s si n of
l bir ton nd, olowi he to ugge to
t Cou tofAppea s gr s t Te m s e ' m oton t co pel
he
r
l , ant he a t r s i o m .
l r ar t Count I of t Te m s e ' c pl i , t Cou t of Appea s he d t t t
n eg d o
he a t r s om a nt he
r
l l ha he
Te m s e s C ed undi put f c s s fci ntt s
a tr t
pl
s ed a t uf i e o how a r g t ha ar t a i of t Se ofN i
i ht o ve bir ton he t
ne
de dl ke g i va s c pc l d by t di t i t c ta a m a t r of l . 604 F.A pp' 8 ,
a oc d r e nce om le
he s rc our s
te
aw '
'
x 41

8 ( 1hCi. 5 .Acc di y,hegre nce i Countlaedie tdt abirton.
49 1 t r 201 )
or ngl t iva s n
r rce o r tai

-

1
-

The Cour ofAppe swa notase i i i isdie tvesf Count 1 a 11 i vi
t
al s
xplct n t r c i or
s 1 nd 1, nvol ng
t Por of Span g ivanc s but ofer d s fce g da f r t Cour t c l t t
he
t
i re
e,
f e ufi int ui nce o he
t o oncude ha
a bir ton oft e greva esi as a opra e. The Cour ofAppe l fr thel t ta or r
r ta i
hes i nc s lo ppr it
t
a s is d ha n de

c
ompeli a bir ton woul notbe a e r e rt i a i a i oft RalLa Ac be us
lng r ta i
d
n xtatrioral pplc ton he i bor t ca e
t sltga i i vescoleci ba ga ni a ee t t twe e e c e i t Unied Stt s
hi ii ton nvol
l tve r i ng gr men s ha r xe ut d n he t
ae

b t e t d me tc e tte . 1 .a 8 2. Ame ie' p i ia a g me ti o p sto t t e
ewe n wo o si niis d t 5
r ts rncp l r u n n p o iin o h
j
Tea trs m o i i t te i t Cour c l co pe a bir ton,t c l c i ba gani
mse ' ton s ha ven f he
t ou d m l r ta i he ole tve r i ng
a e nt- by t i e es t nls- do nota y t t gre nce i Count 1 a 11 W hie
gr eme s
her xpr s e l-ppl o he i va s n
s 1 nd 1.
l

tee ma b me i i Ameie ' a g me t h Co r o Ap asd cd d ta Ameie i
h r y e rt n
rjts r u n ,t e u t f pe l e i e h t
r ts
j
m a ng t sar m e i t w r f t . l i now t r e of t a bie t de enni w he her
ki hi gu nt n he ong or l t s
m
he ol
he r t r o t ne
t
t e c l tve bar i ng agr e e s a y t t a i ve e pl es a w he he t e
hos olec i
ga ni
e m nt ppl o he ggre d m oye nd
t r hos

e oye a e e il t r i on t m e is oft rcli . 1 a 854. As s h,t Co t
mpl es r ntted o elef
he rt
hei a ms d. t
uc he ur
gr nt t Te m se ' moton t c
a s he a t rs i o ompelt a bir i n ofgre
he r tato
ivanc i Count 1 a 11
es n
s 1 nd 1 .

C

DoxE AxD ORDERED i cha r a M im i Fl i t s
n
mbe s t a , orda, hi

Z a o Auut2015.
d y f g s,

'
'

FE
A.
NO
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor

-

2-