Pulley et al v. JPMORGAN CHASE BANK, N.A. et al

Filing 69

ORDER granting 66 Motion Preliminary Approval of Class Action Settlement, Certification of Settlement Class, and Approval of Class Notice. Fairness Hearing set for 11/22/2013 at 09:00 AM in Fort Lauderdale Division before Judge James I. Cohn. Signed by Judge James I. Cohn on 6/26/2013. (ams)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA

f)H1t PULLEY,
) O,.
. 'P
:
#
DEBRA P J
ILLEY,
1l: ,
ttt .
zt* *bA bAvl a d S
l?
l
s, n USAN DAVI
S,

CW I ACTI NO.1 c 60936-l
L
ON
2- vJC

'

,': .v vd nl a do b hafo t msl sa da1
4;f i i. l n n i l fhe eve n 1
t.è
i.
è
t
n y
. *
.
.
.

k4yyë o h- sm ia l st t d,
t$ t ? t
l
i
h
*
i l ry iua e
-'

$
,(!...
:! ...
.rj(
)l r
yè
..
)

pjj j y
antgs

?

V.

J ORGAN CHASE 9ANK.N. a
PM
A. nd

CHASE BAN K USA , . ;CI ASE
N A. I
I
NSURAN CE AGENCY ; P M ORGAN
J
W SI RAN CE AGENCY ;
J
ASSURANT,m C.
;
AM ERI
CAN SECURI I
TY NSURANCE
COO ANY;a VOYAGER I
nd
NDE> I
TY
I
NSURANCE COM PAN Y.

De e nt .
f nda s

ORDER GRANTI PLAI FFS'M OTI FO R PRELI I
NG
NTI
ON
M NARY APPROVAL OF
cLAss Acn oN SEW LEM ENT,CERTI CATI N O F SEW LEG NT CLASS,
FI
O
ANl APPROVAL OF CLASS NOTI
l
CE
Upon c i r ton ofPl i i 'M oton f Ce tf a i ofSe te e Cl s
onsde a i
antfs
i or rik ton
tlm nt % ,
Pr lm i r Appr lofCl s Ac i Se te e , Appr va ofCl s Nouc i i he e
e i na y
ova
a s ton tlm nt and
o l
as
e, t s r by
ORDERED and ADJUDGED m f l ws
s olo :

1
.

Pr l n u Appr v l eç t lto a dS tlme Ag e me t'( e e e ,
ei a
mi
o a .n t i ain n ete nt re n ' h r o r
s pu

tet ete n Ape me f)e tr dit b a da n t ePlitFsP lpM ly De
h G tlme t e n ' ne e n o y n mo g h an i hii
s
e, m

Puly, eo Da i, n Sl Da i (TlitFs' o b h l o t ms l e a dt eSet me t
l J r me vs a d l
e
on vs ç ani ', n e af f he ev s n h tl n
l
e
Cl s( fnedbeow) a D M o ga Cha eBan N. ,Chas I ur eAgenc hc.a J
as de
l , nd
r n s
k, A.
e ns anc
y, , nd P

Mo g nI u a c Ag n y, .t e estln d f n a t a eteX h s De e d n f' i
r a ns rn e e c hc (h s etig ee d n s r h
a e fn n t ) s
a ove on apr i i r ba i a f i, e% ona e a a qua e.n eSe te e Ap ee nt
ppr d
elm na y ss s ar r
bl , nd de t
tlm nt
me

01 31 - 2 61 7 3 Vl
0 21 6 1

wa negota e a n msl ngt ove s ve a m ont a pr de s t ilmone a y a
s
it d t r -e h r e r l
hs nd ovi s ubsanta
t r nd

ij n iv rle .
nu c e eif
2.

n epr e pl n f did buton ofmone a y r left t Se te e Cls
opos d a or s
i
t r e i o he tlm nt a s

m e r i a ove on apr lmi r b% i a f i,r ms bl a a quat n eCo t
mbe s s ppr d
e i na y
s s a r e ona e, nd de e.
ur
a n st He erCl msœ oup 1 5M a ke Stee ,Suie 1
ppoi t he m
ai
51
r t
t t 700, ldel w PA 1 02 as
Phia phi
91
t Se te e tAdmi s t .
he tlm n
nia or
3.

Condii lCe e i ofSetl m e Cl s.TheCour make t f l ng
tona re aton
te nt as
t
s he olowi

d t mi tonsm t c ri a i oft Se te ntCl s :
e er na i
s o e tsc ton he tl me
as
a.

n eCo r c n to lyc ri st ef lo n Cl C% eS tlme t
u t o di nal e t h ol wig %s
i
se
ete n

C1s', o p r s so s tlme to l, n e Fe . Ci P. 3 a a d( )3 :
a s' fr u po e f et n ny u d r d R. v. 2 () n b 4 )
)
e
Al pe s nsi t Unie St t st tha orhad ar i nda
l r o n he t d a e ha ve
esde l
morga l n orlneofc e ts r c d byt Cha e De e n s
t ge oa
i
r di e vie
he
s f ndn t
a s c e by pr pe t on whih wi d i ur ncewa lnde nd e ur d
o ry
c n ns a
se r
plce a a tmebe we n J nua y 1 2008 a M a ch 4,201
a d t ny i
t e a r ,
nd r
3.

S e i al e cu e 9o t eS tlme tCls ae ()t e
p c/c ly x l d d m h et n a s r ; a h
e
De e nt a t i r pec boa d mçmbe s die or ,a
f ndn s nd her es ive r
r , r ct s nd

ofke s a ()bor we swh s widln rpa e is rn e
f r; nd b ro r o e n e de- lc d n n s c
polc wascu c l i ise iet s t ta pr um sc l c e
iy
eled n t ntr y o ha ny emi
ole t d
we ef lyr fmde t t bo r r
r ul e t d o he rowe .

b
.

n eS tlme tCl si s n meo t t on e o a1me esi
ete n % s o u r us ha j id r f 1 mb r s

i aci a e n e e a equesi of1 orf tcommon t t m e be soft e Se te e
mpr tc bl . r r
tons aw
ac
o he m r
h tlm nt
Cl s n ecli soft Se teme Cl sr pr e a i sa et ca oft cl m soft
as .
nm
he tl nt % e es nt tve r ypi l he si
he
Sete e Cl s.n e Se te tCl s Re e e a i a Se te e Cl sCol e wilf il
tlm nt %
tl men m s pr s nttves nd tlm nt as
mn l l ary
a ade t l pr e tt i t r t oft Cl s.
nd qua ey ot c he n e ess he as

c.

n eCou ta nt t Pl ntFs- Phii M ly,De a Puley,J r e
r ppoi s he ai i
lp
e
br
l e om

Da s a Slu n Davi - asSe te e Cl sr pr s nt i ,who s lr pr s ntt Se te e
vi, nd l
s
tlm nt as e e e atves
hal e e e he tlm nt
Cl s f pur e ofi e ntng t Se te e Ar ee nt n eCour a nt t 1 w Gr
a s or pos s mpl me i he tlm nt
me .
t ppoi s he a
m
ofM e e t & Nn i asSete e Cl sCouns l
r dih
rne
tlm nt as
e.
01 31 1 61 71 V1
0 2-2 6 3

d.

l t e Setl m e Agr e e tr na e pur l t ist r sf any
fh
te nt e m nt e mi t s smnt o t e m or

r a on, hi c Gonalc ë f ton oft Se te e tCl sf s tl me pur e s l be
e s t s ondi
e ka i
he tl m n % or e te nt pos s hal
vn >t d au oma ialy, t sa i s lr er t issa usi e at y be or t e c i
r e t tc l and hi cton hal ev t o t tt mm di el f e he xe uton

o teS tlme t e n .I ta e e t teP riss al enna1o tero j c n ,
f h et n Are me t n h t v n ,h a t h lr#i 1 f h i be éo s
e
e
a gume s a de e esw11 r pe tt cas c tfc ton.
r
nt , nd f ns
t1 es c o l s eri a i

4.

Es abls entoft Se te e Fund.A Se te e Ft s lbe e t bls d
t ihm
he tl m nt
tlm nt md hal
sa ihe

i tea u to $ 7 00 0 wh c wi fmd:a a1 tc a dAd nikaieCo t,n ld n
n h mo n f 4,5 ,0 , ih l t () 1Noie n mi s tv ss i cu i g
l
tec s o No ie ( )a1 a e ? t S tlme tCl sM e e s ()teCa eCo u in
h o t f tc ; b 1p m n o e t n %
e
mb r; c h s nzb to
es f n , wa d d o o n e
Awa d ,fa y t PlitFs a d( )Ato y iFeesand Expens , i a y a r e t c n A l
r s i n ,o ani ; n d tme s

f Pli i a t Se te e Cl s .TheSe te e Fund wilbepl c i an a cot
or antfs nd he tlm nt m s
tlm nt
l
a ed n
c mt

amiitrdb tej tlme t mi s trp rl n t a a e n a cpa l t te
d nsee y h et n Ad nikao u sl to n ve me t c e tbe o h
e
n
PlitFsa dt eCh Dee a t, t atidpat sn n il n tto t b j itys lce
ani n h %e fnd n s w11 hr ry s ca i eiuin o e on l ee td
1
b t eSetn Pa t s ihnt it ( 0 c lnd rd y o P ei n r Ap r v l ft s
y h tl g ri .W t i hry 3 ) ae a a s f r lmi ay p o a o hi
i
e
Se te e , f nt wilwieta f rt s off milo s n hundr 11)t l nd
tlm nt De endn s l r r ns e he um
our li n eve
ed 1tr holm

d las( 47 00 00 )U. d lasit a itrs- e rn bs ka c u t e i ae b te
o lr $ ,5 ,0 .0 S. o lr n o n n ee tb s ig n c o n d sr td y h
Se teme Adm i s t .An i er s t ta r on t Se te e Ft be or t Sete
tl nt
nika or y nt e t ha cc u:s he tlm nt md f e he tl-

me tFmdi d srb td s al er lie b t Set me tF n Pro t t Efe t Dae(s
n t s iti ue h lb enn d y he tl n u d. ir o he ci t a
e
ve
etbih di teS t e n Ave me t, 1 f n si t eSete n Ac ou t hal ei e td
sa ls e n h e t me t e n) a1 u d n h tlme t c n s l b nv se
l
a r i t d i s tt r Unie Stt sAg y orTr as y Se urte ofadur i t
nd envese n hor-e m
t d a e enc
e ur c ii s
aton o
ma urt oft vemont orls fom t daeofpur has
t iy wel
hs e s r he t
c e.
5.

I t Se teme Avee e i t r naed f a r on a pr ded t r i t
f he tl nt
m nt s e mi t or ny eu
s ovi he en, he

baanc r m ani i t Se te e Fund wilber f nd t t Chas Def ndn swihi 1
l e e i ng n he tlm nt
l
e u ed o he
e e nt t n 0
da .Net ra Pli i no Cl sCo elora Se teme Cl sM e be wilha a
ys ihe ny a ntl r as uns
ny tl nt %
m r l ve ny

-

01 2- 2 61 3Vl
031 1 671

3-

oblga i t r pa t Chas Def nda sf a a
i ton o e y he
e e nt or ny mount t tha bee pai ori = e unde
s ha ve n d nc d
r
t t r oft Se e e Apee tbe or i i t r na e
he e ms he ë m nt
men f e t s e mi t d.
6.

Reeas s I 5nsl a ove t Se te e Ap ee
l e . f ly ppr d, he tlm nt
mentwilr e eDef ndn
l el%
e n?

go ,a
m mongot rt ngs a1cli ,c r s o de ndst tr a e co e a iefom ,or
he hi , 1 n ms ha ge , r ma
ha elt , nc a rs r

perai i a wa t Chas Def ndant'plce ntofwi i um nc durng t Cl sPe i as
t n n ny y o
e e
s a me
nd ns
e i he as rod,
p ovi d f i Pa agr 1 oft Se te ntAg e m e
r de or n r aph 0 he tl me
e nt
NodcePl n. TheCour a ove t Cl s Notc al e d asEe bi A t t
a
t ppr s he a s ie fn he
t o he
Se teme Ag e nt W ihi 30 da O e Pr lm i r Appr
tl nt
eme . t n
ys r e i na y
ovaloft Setl ment t e
he te
,h
Se te tAdmi s t s ldis mi t t Cls Notc n eCl s Notc s lbes ntt
tlmen
nilaor hal s e nne he a s ie.
a s ie hal
e o
e c Se te ntCl sM e ra hi orherl tknown addr s 0 d,i a l bl t hi orhe ls
a h tl me
as
mbe t s
ms
es
f vaia e, o s
r at
known e a la es . I t e i t nc whe e t Cl sNotc i r t m e asundelver bl t
m i ddr s n hos nsa es r he ms
ie s e u d
i a e, he
Sete tAdmi s t wilmakea1 r % ona eefbrst l a et Se te e Cl sM embe ,
tlmen
nikaor l
1e
bl l t o oc t he tlm nt as
r
i udi t ' gt c a tt Sete ntCl sM e rt l phoni ly. l a tont
ncl ng em o ont c he tl me
as
mbe e e
ca l n ddii o
dis na i t Cl sNotc t Se te ntAdmi sr t rwilesa ih a 1 800 t e
s emi tng he ms
ie, he tl me
nita o l t bls
elphone
numbe a l unc a webst t pr de i or ton a utt s tlm e a s tlm e -elt d
r nd a h
ie o ovi nf ma i bo he e te nt nd ete ntr a e
doc e s
um nt.
8.

Opdng Outoft Se tementCl s A Se te
he tl
as .
tl mentCl s M e be who wihe t
as m r
s so

optoutoft Se te e Cl sm us do s i wrtng.I or rt optout a Se te e Cl s
he tlm nt %
t o n ii
n de o
, tlm nt u
M e rm us c
mbe
t ompl t a s nd t t Se te e Adm i s t ar ques f re usont ti
e e nd e o he tlm nt
nikaor e t o xcl i ha s

pos- ke no lt rt1 t dae f r que t f e uson s tf rh i Pm r a 22 oft s
tmar d a e 1% he t or e s s or xcl i e o t n
ph
hi
Or , c s lbes tf t i t Cl sNotc a on t we ie. n er quek f e l i
der whi h hal
e orh n he as
ie nd he bst
e
or xc uson
mus s tf rh t Se te ntCl sM e
t e o t he tl me
as
mber name a a es ,mus bepe s ly sR e by t
s
nd ddr s
t
r ona l i d
he

Se te e Cl sM e r a mus c ni asa e e t ti caesa desr t beexcude
tlm nt u
mbe , nd
t onl n tt m nt ha ndi t
ie o
l d

-

01 31 -2 6 6 1 V1
0 21 1 73

4-

âom t Sete e Cl s i t sLii a
he tlm nt a s n hi tg ion,s h asçIhe e r que tt tIbee uded âom t
uc
t r by e s ha
xcl
he

pr e Se e ntCl si t Pule Cl sAci 'M a sorcl soptout s lno be
opos d ë me
as n he ly as tom' s
as
s hal t
al d.
lowe
9.

A Se te ntCl sM e rwho desr st optoutmus t e tm e yaë r
tlme
as
mbe
ie o
t ak i l
mafve

wrte a ton pur ln t Pa apa 8 oftlsOr r e n i t Se te e Cl sM e r
itn c i
slnt o r ph
li de , ve f he tlm nt as
mbe

d srn t o t u o t eCls ( )flso h sfld as p rt a to a an ta yo t eRee sd
e iig o p o t f h m s a ie r a e e aae ci n g i s n f h la e
P ro s(sd f di teS tlme tAg e me t, r( )i, rb c me , p ttv ca sme e
e s n a eme n h et n re n) o b s o e o s a u ai e ls mb r
e
i a ot rcls a ton fl d a ns a oft Re e e Pe s .
n ny he a s c i
e gai t ny he l % d r ons
1
0.

Exc ptf t eSetlm e Cl sM e be swho tm ey and pr ry fl a
e or hos
te nt %
m r
i l
ope l e

r s f e l i n,a lot rSe te ntCl sM e r wilbedee e t be Sete e Cls
eque t or xc uso 1 he tl me
as
mbe s l
m do
tlm nt a s

M e r f a1 pur esunde t Ar e m e ,a upon t Efe tveDa e wilbebound by
mbe s or 1 pos
r he
e nt nd
he c i
t, l
istr s i l gt Reea e.
t e m , ncue
he l s
11
.

I t numbe ofSete e Cl s M e r who pr m ry and tme y e r ie
f he
r
tlm nt m s mbe s
o l
i l xe cs

ter i h t o to t fteS t e n Cl se c e ssxpec n ( %)o tettl u e o
h i rg to p u o h e t me t % x e d i re t 6 f h oa n mb r f
l
Sete tCl sM e r ,heSe ti Pa te si ae a ar e t tDef nds ss lha t
tlmen as
mbe s t
tlng ris tpult nd
e ha
e nt hal ve he
rghtt t r naet sAv e m e wil tpe t o s nci
i o e mi t hi
e nt tmu naly r a ton.

1 . Comme t o Ob e to sb S tlme Cls M e r .An S tlme t
2
n s r j ei n y e te nt a s mbe s y e t n
e

Cls Me e wh d e n t p o t ft Set me t yo j c t t eS tlme t
m s mb r o o s o o t u o he tl n ma be t o h ete n .
e
1 . An Set me tCls M e e wh wihe t o j c S t eSet me t s d s
3
y tl n a s mb r o s s o b e t o h tl n mu t o o
e
e
i wrtn .n ewrte o j cinmus b p s- r da dsldn ltrt R ted t f r
n iig
itn b e to
. e o tmake n e o ae I h ae o
t
I
o j c nsi Paa ph2 o ti Or e , ih s al estf rh i teCls Noiea d o t e
be io n r pa 2 f h s d r whc h lb e o t n h a s tc n n h
wy ie, i mus i l t c pton oftlscu e be sr e be sl wih t Co< and
bst and t t nc ude he a i
li
, i d,
ed t he

maldt a1 f h p rist ti c s a f l ws ( )Cls Co n e, il Na ie M ee ih
i o 1 o t e a t o hs a e s ol : 1 a s u s lKrsma rn , rdt
e
e
o

01 31 - 2 61 7 3V1
0 21 6 1

& Naie 1 S uhBr a S e S t 9 , ia ep i PA 1 1 ( )Co n e f rCh s
rn , 00 o t o d ke t ui 05 Ph ld l hw
e
91 0; 2 u s l o a e
Bn Robe tM . oc n M or n,Le s& Boc usLLP,200 Sout Bica Boul r Suie
nkz
r Br hi
ga
wi
ki
h s yne
eva d, t

5 0 , n , lrd 3 3 - 33 9 n ( )Co n e frAs u a tFmn G. r J r e BM
3 0 Mimi Fo ia 31 12 9 a d 3 u s l o s rn , k Bu q o d n
LLP,1 n omasJ
025
eFer o Ste t NW ,Suie400Eœ t W m hi on DC 20007s n re,
t
s , s ngt
5208.

1
4. n erq e n st m sr av ldwrte o j cins al estf rhi t eCls
e e me t o se t ai itn b e to h l b e o t n h a s
Noiea do t S tlme t e st, n s alicu e ()tens , d r s ,ee ho
tc n n he e t n W b ie a d h l n ld : a h me a d e s tlp ne
e

n mb ro t ePes n o j c ig a d i rp e e tdb c u A l o Msh rc u A l ( ) r o o
u e f h lo be t n ,f e r s ne y o n e, f / e o n e; b p o f f
n
owne s p ofapr ry on wM c wi i ur cewaslnde pl a, durng t e c % spe i by
rhi
ope t
h nd ns an
e r nr d i h l
e
rod

Cl eBn ko isp e e e s r, u sd ais o a lae ; c teb ssf rt o j cin; n ()
mA n r t rd c s o s s b iire , r m its () h a i o he be to a d d
a sae e ofwhe he he s i e t a ara t Fi Appr lH- rng, i e w11 or
t tm nt
t r /he ntnds o ppe t he nal
ova
i ei r t1

wih u c u s l An Set me tCls M e e whofist o jc t t eS tlme t nt e
t o t o n e. y tl n a s mb r
e
al o be t o h ete n i h
m mme des rbe i t Cl s Notc a consse w11 t sPa v a s lbe de m e t have
r c i d n he a s ie nd
it nt t1 bi r ph hal
e do

wav da ys c o j ci n s l n t ep r te t o j c t a ytr o a p o a o te
ie n u h be to , hal o b emitd o be t o n e ms r p r v l f h
Se te e a t Fi Appr
tlm nt t he nal
ovalHe rng,a s l bef ecos d fom s e ng a r vi w oft
a i nd hal or l e r
e ki ny e e
he
Se te ntort t r oft Ar ee tby a
tl me
he e ms he
men
ppea oro he m e ns
l t r a .

1 . S be t oa p o a o t eCo r, n S tlme tCls M e rwhos bnisa
5
u j c t p r v l f h u ta y et n m s mbe
e
ul t
t l wrte o jcinma a e r i pes no b c u s la t eFia Ap r v l s igh l
i y itn be to y pp a ,n ro r y o n e, t h n l p o a He rn ed
me
byt Cour, o s
he
tt how c e whyt pr e Se te e Ag ee nts dnotbea ove a
aus
he opos d tlm nt
me houl
ppr d s

fi, d q ae a drao a l, r vd dta t eo j ci gS tlme Cls M e e :()Gls
ar a e u t, n e n be p o ie h t h be tn e t nt a s mb r a e
e
w11 t Clr oft Cour a no i ofi e i t a
t1 he e k he
t tce nt nton o ppea a t Fi lAppr
r t he ns
ovalHe rng byt
si
he

d t t a i stf rhi t eCls No ieCNo ieOfItn inToAp e l a d( )s r e t
ae h t s e o t n h a s tc
tc
n e to
p mr ; n b e v s he
Roi OfI e in ToAppe rona1co eldesgn t i t Cl sNotc n eNotc of
tce ntnto
a
1 uns
i aed n he as ie.
ie
I e i t Appe rm us i udeco esofa pa r ,e bis orot re de t tt
ntnton o
a
t ncl
pi
ny m s xhi t,
he vi nce ha he

-

01 31 -2 6 67 3Vl
0 21 1 1

6-

o j cigS tlme tCls Me e wi p e e tt t eCo r i c n e to w1 1h Fis
b e tn ete n a s mb r l r sn o h u tn o n cin t te n l
l
1
Ap r v l nig.An atme wh itn st rp ee a o j c g Sete n Cls
p o a He rn
y to y o n e d o e r snt n be e
tlme t a s
M e be a t FY Appr lHe rng mus do s a t Cl sM e be ' expe eandm us fl
m r t he
ova a i
t o t he ms m r s
ns
t e
anotc ofa
i e ppes
-ncea las t wee be or t Fi Appr
t e t wo
ks f e he nsl
ovalHen i Any Cl s
rng.
u
M e rwho doe not5l aNouc ofI e i To Appe i a or e w11 t de i a
mbe
s
e
e nt nton
ar n cc dsnc t1 he adlnes nd
ot rs ci atonss tf t i t Ap e m e and Cl sNotcewilbedee
he m sc i
e orh n he
e nt
%
i
l
med t havewave
o
i d

a yo j cinst teS tlme ta ds al t ee t ldt r iea ys c o j cin a teFin
n be t o h et n n h lno b ni e o as n u h b e to s t h n l
o
e
t
Appr
ovalHe rng.
ai

1
6.

Ator ys Fe and Expe es a Cas Cont i i Awar .Defndn s
t ne ' es
ns , nd
e
r buton
ds
e nt

apeeno t oppos an a ia i f t a r ofAto e 'Fe sa Expe e i t sAc i
to
e
pplc ton or he wa d
tm ys e nd
ns s n hi ton

n t oe c e at tl f$14 50 0( o i cu i ge p ns s,obep i fo t eSet me t
o t x e d oa o ,2 ,0 n t n ld n x e e ) t
ad r m h tl n
e
Fund.

Pl ntfsalo i end t s e Cas Co buton Awa dsof$1 000 f t M l y
ai if s nt o e k e ni i
r
0, or he e

Pli i and$5, frt Da sPl ntFsfom tl SetlmentFundf t i wor a
antFs
000 o he vi ai i r le te
or her k nd
% ssa e i t ltga i t bepad 9om t Se te ntFund. Def nda swilno oppos
it nc n he ii ton, o
i
he tl me
e nt l t
e
t er quess
hes e t .

1
8.

n egr torde aloralowa e ordialowa oft e Atom eys Fe a
an
ni
l nc
s l nce h t
' es nd

Expe e a Cas Co rbuton Awr dswilbeconsde e byt Cour s
ns s nd e nti i
l
i rd
he
t epo t l fom t
e y r he

Cour' c i r ton oft f m e s r ona e s ,a a
ts onsde a i
he ai s , e% bl ne s nd dequa y oft Sete
c
he tl ment a any
nd
or rorpr ee ngsr l tngt t a i a i f Atom e 'Fe and Expens sa Ca e
de
oc di e ai o he pplc tons or t ys es
e nd s
M a geme Awa ds ora a alfo a or r ltngt r t orr ve s lorm odi a
na
nt
r , ny ppe r m ny der ea i he e o e r a
fc ion

t e wilnoto rt t tr naeorc e t sAre me ,o G e ordelyt fnalt of
herot l
m ae o e mi t anc l hi
e nt r ct
a he i iy
J
ud- e a ovi t Agr e e andt Se teme .
nt ppr ng he e m nt
he tl nt

-

0 0 2-2 61 71 V1
1 31 1 6 3

7-

1
9.

n e Se te tAdmi s t s lbea horz d t pa fom t Se te ntFund
tlmen
nikaor hal
ut i e o y r he tl me

no i r lt d a a nika i c t a t y c edue.
tce e ae nd dmi s tve oss s he om

20.

On Jul 26,201 t SetlmentAdm i s t s l dis nae Cl sNofc
y
3, he te
nita or hal s emi t >
e.

21
.

On orbe or Sept m be 25,201 Pl ntFs c e s l5l w11 t Cour a
f e
e r
3, ai i ' ouns l hal e t1 he
t nd

s veon t pa te t i a plc ton f t a r ofAtom e 'Fee a Exm ns a r quess
er
he ris her p i a i or he wa d
t ys
s nd
es nd e t
f Ca eConi bu i Awa ds
or s
ton
r .

2 . Ono b f r Odo r2 , 01 ,S tlme tCl M e r s al ()s r eo t e
2
r eoe
be 5 2 3 et n %s mbes h l; a ev n h
e
p ris a rq ie b ti Or e, n r q e t f re cu in&o t i s tlme t a d( )5l
a t , s e urd y h s d r a y e u ss o x lso m h s et n ; n b e
e
e

wi t eCo r a d sr eo tepate , sr q ie b ti Or e, n o j cinst t i
t h u t n e v n h ris œ e urd y bs d r a y b e t o h s
h
o
s tl nt
e teme .
23.

On o be or No
r f e vem be 12,2013,Pli i c
r
antFs' ounK ls l 5l w11 t Cour a
e hal e t1 he
t nd

s r eon t pa te t rmoton f f a a ovaloft Se te e Ap ee e .
ev
he ris hei
i or m l ppr
he tlm nt
m nt
2
4.

On orbe or Nove be 1 201 Pl ntfs counK s l ca e t be fl w11
f e
m r 8, 3, ai i '
el ha l us o
ed t1

t Clr oft sCour, d s r ed upon c e f de e nt,e da t o de l r tomsoft
he e k hi
tan e v
ouns l or f nda s
vis r c a a i
he
pe s unde whos ge r ldie ton t N o i wa dis mi t s
ron
r
e ne a r c i he tce s s e naed, howi t tNotc wm
ng ha
ie s
dis mi t d i a c dmwew11 t sOr r
s e na e n c or
t1 hi de .
25.

Fl alFa r s H e ng.A he i i s heduld t behel bef e t Cour on
i ne : ari
arng s c
e o
d or he
t

No m be 22,201 a 9: a. . f t f l ng pum os :
ve r
3, t 00 m , or he olowi
es

()
a

t fnal d tr n wh t e t c riyt Set me tCls u d r
o i ly eemie eh r o e t he tl n a s n e
f
e

Fe . Ci P. 3 4 )
d R. v. 2 1)3 ;
(
b)

t fnal deer newhehe t Seteme Are me i fi,
o ly t mi
t r he tl nt e nt s ar

r % ona e and a qua e, s ul bea o d by t Cour;
e
bl,
de t and ho d
ppr ve
he
t

()
c

t c nsd rwheh rt a p o etea piaino S tlme tCl
o o ie
te o p r v h p lc to f ete n as
-

01 31 - 2 61 71 Vl
0 21 6 3

8-

Couns l f a awa d ofa t e 'f esand e ns ;
e or n
r
tom ys e
xpe es
f

()
d

t c n i e wheh rt a p o tea piaino S tlme tCl s
o o sd r te o p r ve h p lc to f ete n %

Couns lf ca ec
e or s onG buton a r f rSetlm e Cls Re es nt tve ;a
i wa ds o
te nt a s pr e a i s nd

()
e
26.

t r l u ns c oh rmatr a t eCo r ma d e a p o it .
o ue m u h te te s s h u t y e m p rprae

n e Co ta ho est Pa te t t kea 1nec s e a a opra e se t
ur ut dz he ris o a 1 e s
nd ppr it t ps o

i eme t Se te e Ap e m e .
mpl nt he tlm nt
e nt
A
4 DONE r Tu-c in CIaI 3in FrLuedlBoa Cut,li ti
dy and ORDERED I, rS otadra,rwr onyFod h
ao
x1.
e d
rw s

#

J
AW S COl
m
UNl
TE STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDG
Cc: Al CounK lofRec d
1
e
or

-

01 31 - 2 61 71 Vl
0 21 6 3

9-