Benjamin et al v. CitiMortgage, Inc. et al
Filing
18
ORDER granting 6 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 5/6/2013. (cbe)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
C as N um be 1 62291- I M O R EN O
e
r: 2C V-
M URATBENJ W M dVEON I
AM
EBENJ I
AM N,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
VS.
CI M ORTGAGE,l ,
TI
NC.
D e e nt
f nda .
FI
NAL ORDER OF DI I
SM SSAL AND ORDER
DEN Y I G A LL PEN DI G M O TI N S AS M O O T
N
N
O
THI CAUSEca beo et Co t nt defnda 'M oint Dimis( E.No. )
S
me fr he ur upo he e nts to o s s D.
6.
Orgi lybr hti sae c tasaone- t c
i na l oug n t t our
co mt ompli ta ii t de t Fl rdaDe e i a
a n rsng m r he o i
c ptve nd
UnfiBu ie sPrcie Ac ('
ar sn s a tc s t '
FDUTP ',h sa o iv le t b ro r , u a a Ve ne
A' ti din n ov s wo o rwe sM rt nd o i
)
Be jmi, ungCi Mo ta e l c (' tM o ta e', ihi t el a s r ie f rt ep anif'
na n s i t rg g ,n . ' i rg g ' wh c s h o n e vc r o h litfs
i
ci
)
ho emorga e l n.nii ly,he c
m
t g oa I tal t ompl i wasfl d a i tbot t l n s r i e a Cii nk,
ant
ie ga ns h he oa e v c r nd tba
N . Cii nk, . . no bee s r edwih pr es a wa dim is fom t ca eonAprl
A. tba N A has t n e v
t oc s nd s s s ed r he s
i 29,
201 Thesa ec t s is t pli if' is FDUTPA c
3.
t t our dim s ed he a ntfs fr t
ompl i . E. 1 2 a pp. ant D. No. - t 21 22.
Thepli if fl a n e d compl nt whi wass e nty r m ove by t de e nt
antfs ied n m nde
ai , ch
ubs que l e
d he f nda .
Acc di t t n
or ng o he mende c
d ompli t onAugus 2,
an,
t 2005t borower e utd afxedr t
he r
s xec e i
ae
not i f voroft l nde , tFi i M orga Com pa LLC, hi h he d ar c da e i e es
ena
he e r Cii nanc al t ge
ny
w c l e or bl nt r t
i t e s b e tp o ry The panif r sd d a t e s be tp o e t a t etme te a n e
n h u j c r pet.
li tfs e ie t h u j c r p ry t h i h me d d
c pl i w a fl d.The pl i if a l ge t t on Od obe 30, 201 he l nde r co ded a
om a nt s ie
a ntf s le ha
r
2,t e r e r
n
a sg
s i nmen oft morg e t t de e n .Acc di t t a nde compl i ,t pli tfs
t he
t ag o he f nda t
or ng o he me d
ant he a n if
ne rr evedanotc of r ns e ora sg ntc e i et rt owne s pof o hes r i ng
ve ec i
ie ta f r s inme onc m ng ihe he
r hi , rt e vci
rght t t l n.The pli if aleg t tt y s a ' btva i ton lte ' a or a ' bt
i s o, he oa
antfs l e ha he ent '
de
lda i e tr' nd/
'
de
ve ii a i lte 't t def nda t de e mi t i ntt oft l n s r c ra owne oft
rfc ton e tr' o he e nt o t r ne he de iy he oa e vie nd
r he
l n. pl i if f t raleg t t he s nta' lfedwrte r ques't t l ns r i r The
oa The antfs urhe l e ha t y e
qua ii
itn e t'o he oa e vce .
n
mende c pli saest tt defnda f ie t ac
d om a nt t t ha he e nt al d o knowldge, es
e
r pond, pr deac
or ovi
omplt
ee
a a uaer pons t t swrte c r ponde e. naly,t pli if ale t tt no ei
nd deq t es e o hi itn ores
nc Fi l he a ntfs l ge ha he t n
que ton hasbee et rpa d i f l byt borowe sa orat r pa t
si
n ihe i n u l he r r nd/
hid ry.
The n e d c pl i c a nss x c m t a l gi vi a i oft Tr t i Lendi A c
m nde om a nt ont i i ot s le ng ol tons he u h n
ng t
(' LA';vi ai oft FarDe Cole tonPrci sAct('
'
TI ' oltons he i bt lci a tce
)
'
FDCPA';vi ai oft Re l
' oltons he a
)
EsaeSet me t r cie Ac t' Es 'i i lto so FDuTpAi e l tg j g n i dq e
tt tl n p a tc s tft pA' v oain f
e
l
l
d crao ud me tr uit
tte.The def nda ha moved f dim is ofa1 sx c am s o ,i t at r tve,f r a mor
il
e nt s
or s s al
l i l i r n he le na i o
e
de i t s a e e .
fnie t t m nt
Le lSt r
ca anda d
On amotont dim is t Cour mus viw t c
i o s s ,he
t t e he ompl i i t lg m os f vor bl t t
ant n he i ht t a a e o he
panif Glv rv fi tGr u I c, 5 F.d 1 0 ,1 0 ( 1hCi. 0 6 .Thstn th we e ,
li tf. o e . get o p, n .4 9 3 3 4 3 8 1 t r2 0 ) i e e, o v r
d e n t p yt lg l o l ins S eAs h rj v I a,1 9 S. .1 3 ,1 4 ( 0 9 .ç hi
o s o a pl o e a c ncuso . e c c o t . qb l 2 Ct 9 7 9 9 2 0 ) ç l
W e
ac antatcke b aRul 1 b)6)motont dimisdoesnotnee dealdfcua algai ,
ompli ta d y
e 2( (
i o s s
d tie a t l le tons
ap an ifso l aint p o d t etr t ' fhstnilg n )t r l f rq ie mo et a
litf' bi to o r vie h go mds o i e t e me t o ei e u rs r h n
g
t
e
lbel a c usons a af muli r ct tonoft eeme sofac eofa ton wilnotdo.'
a s nd oncl i , nd or a c e iai
he l nt
aus
ci
l
'
Bel l i Cor v Twombl 1 S. .1 1 65(
lAtantc p. .
y, 27 Ct 955, 964- 2007)(iai omit .A c ai
cttons ted) ompl nt
mus ha S noughf cst saeacam t r le t ti plusbl onisf e'i idoesnott
t ve ç
e
a t o tt li o eifha s a i e t ac ';ft
d
nudgel
)
te)camsa r s t l fo c n eva l t pa i l, i mu tb d s se 'I . t1 7 .
h l li co s he i r m o c i be o lusbe (t s e imis d. d a 9 4
ne
)
'
2-
-
Count1 Tr t i Le ngAc
: u h n ndi
t
The Tnzh i Le ng Ac i a cons e pr t ton saut t t s eks t ' voi t
t n ndi
t s
um r o eci t t e ha e
o ' d he
a
uni or d us ofc e t't ough t ' ni uldi cosle ofc edi t nns't r e blng
nf me e
r di' hr
he '
mea ngf s l tr
r t e s he eby na i
'
c n u r t b c me i f r d a u te c s o ce i.1 U. C.j 1 01a .l a dto t
o s mes o e o n o me bo t h o t f r dt 5 S.
6 () n d iin o
e wei t FedealTrde Commison t e ore ispr vii ,1 U. C.j 1 c) a
mpo rng he
r a
si o nf c t o sons 5 S.
607( , nd
i i c i na la lt onpes whowif lyandkno ngl vi aet saut 1 U. C.
mposng rmi l ibiiy
rons
lul
wi y olt he tt e, 5 S. j
1 1,t TI c e t s a prva e c us of a ton f a m a a saut y da a f c rai
61 he LA r a e
i t a e
c i or c l nd t t or m ges or e t n
dicos evi ains 15U. C. 1 a . Kisige v Wel Fa goBank NA.888F.
s l ur olto ,
S. j 640() See s n r . ls r
, ,
Supp.
2 1 0 ,1 1( D. a Au 3 , 01 ) I p riua , 1 41g ()r a a f lo :
d 3 9 31 S. Fl. g. 0 2 2 .n atc lr j 6 ( )1 e ds s o lws
I a ton t ot rdic os esr uie by t ss ha e , lt rt n 30 da a trt
n ddii o he s l ur eq r d hi ubc pt r not a e ha
ys fe he
da eon whih am orgag l n i s d orot r s ta fr e oras i
t
c
t e oa s ol
he wie r nse r d
sgnedt at r pa t
o hid ry,
t cr diort ti t ne owne o a sgne oft de s l notf t boroweri wrtng
he e t ha s he w
r r s i e he bt ha l iy he r
n ii
ofs h tanse ,i udi
uc r fr ncl ng-
( t i ntt add e s tlpho ml roft new crdior
A) he de iy, r s ,ee ne mbe he
et;
( ted t o ta se ;
B) h ae f r n fr
( h w t ra h a a e to p ryha i g a t rt t a to b h l o t n w
C) o o e c n g n r a t v n uhoiy o c n e af f he e
ce t ;
r dior
( t l ato oft plcewheeta frofownes poft de i r c de a
D)he oc in he a
r rnse
rhi he bt s e or d; nd
( a yo h rrlv n if r to r g r igten w ce i r
E) n t e ee a t n o main e a dn h e r dt .
o
1 U. C. 1 0 ( )1 . u tl f h n nd dc mp an alg sta t epanif n v rrc ie
5 S. j 6 2 g ( ) Co n o t e me e o lit le e h t h litfs e e e ev d
no i eoft a sgnme ofowne s pof he rmorga l ismotont dim is t de e
tc he s i
nt
r hi t i
t ge.n t
i o s s ,he f ndan fr t
t is
a gue t scli i tme- re cii t TI S one ye r saut of lm ia i .Cii orga
r s hi am s i ba r d, tng he LA'
- a t t e i ttons tM t ge
cli st tt lm ia i pe i bega t r when t m o t gedocume swe ee c e D.
am ha he i t tons rod
n o un
he rga
nt r xe ut d. E.
No. a p.5.
6 t
Howe r t homeowner ' am i bas o t de enda ' aleg f itr t no iy
ve ,he
s cli s ed n he f nts l ed alle o tf
t m oft asi
he
he sgnmen oft morga asrquie byt saut 1 U. C. 1 e r uie t t
t he t ge e rd he tt e. 5 S. j 640() eq rs ha
a a ton bebr
n ci
ought' t n one ye rfom t dae oft oc r nc oft vi ai n. He e, he
' hi
wi
a r he t
he cure e he ol to ' r t
'
-
3-
vi a i i a lge t ha oc ure upont ta f roft m orgag on Ocobe 30,201 D.
olton s le d o ve c r d
he r ns e
he
t e
t r
2. E.
No 12a !6. ea n e c mplitwa t l tldba e o t ealg to sc nan dt een
. - t Th me d d o an s i y ie s d n h le ain o t ie h ri .
me
Thede e
f ndan ne cli st tt TI c
t xt am ha he LA ounti i qua eyale d, l i i t r we e
s nade t l l ge c am ng he e r
' dicl ur a tc 'o t a e d c
' s os es ta hed't he m nde ompli ta nos
no
a n nd
howi ofhow t edicos eswe e
ng
hos s l ur
r
i orec o i vi a i oft s a ut D . N o. a pp. 6. sa gum ent si pr rat hem oton
nc r t r n ol ton he t t e. E. 6 t 5- Thi r
i m ope t
i
t dim i s s a a i puzz i gi n t e s nc oft pl i i f ' m e
o s s t ge, nd s
lng ve he s e e he a ntf s a nded com pl i :t tgo
a nt ha
.
d s os r r l tng t t ta f rand a sgnme oft m orga we egi n.
icl u es e ai o he r nse
si
nt he
t ge r ve
Fi ly,hede e
na l t
f ndant g t t a al n s r c r i c nnotbehed la et r1 U. C.
ar ues ha , s oa e vie ,t n
l i bl mde 5 S.
j1 41g .ts r et a teTI do s tmp s la iiyo sr ie s b t n'rdi rs wh fil
6 ()I itu h th LA e no i o e iblt n e vc r , u o ' e t ll o al
c o
)oc mpl wi a yrqurme tmp e t e . s cin 1 3 o ti t l ln ls b e to ( o
t o y t n e ie n i os d md r . e to 6 5 f hs i e a d u s cin 9 r
h
.
t
()ofs ci 1 1' 5U. C.j 1 40( ;s ealoDavi v Gr n ntMorg.Fundi l .No.
g e ton 64 .1 S.
'
6 a) e s
s . ee poi
t
ng, nc,
10 -v 2 9 2 1W L 7 7 21a * ( D. . a . , 01 )( o igta 1 U. C. 1 9 4 1
:9 c - 71 , 01
0 2 t 3 N. Ga M r 1 2 1 n tn h t 5 S. j 6 2 9( )
'i isas c rsla lt t st tonsi whih t s ni e wasonc a a sgne orowne oft
'm t eni e ' ibiiy o iua i n c he e c
l
e n si e
r he
1= '
0 '
)
Thepl ntfsa knowl dget t def nda i al ns r i e . ame dc
ai if c
e hathe e nt s oa e v c r The nde ompl nt l o
ai a s
a lge i s r lpl e t tt l n s r i ri wor ng a t t r pa t de c l coron be l
le s n eve a ac s ha he oa e vce s ki s he hid- ry bt ole t
ha f
o a o e a d o h l e o t epanif' oea dmo ta e'D. No. - a !3 ; e as D.
f n wn r n / r o d r f h litfsn t n rg g . E. 12 t 0 s e lo E.
'
No 12a !4 . pan if ha efie t ce ryalg t t h d fn a t s h o e o t ed b
. - t 3 The litfs v ald o lal l e ha t e e e d n i t e wn r f h e t
e
is f Acc di y,TI doe notpr deac us ofac i a i tt de e
tel. or ngl LA
s
ovi
a e
ton ga ns he f ndan f t c
t or he onduc
t
alg d. e Kh nv T eBa ko w Yo kM eln, 1 6 2 - V, 01 W L 1 0 0 a *
le e S e a . h n fNe r lo No. 2- 01 8 CI 2 2
0 35 9 t 3
('e vc r h v n l blt f rvoain of LA u ls te aetec re t rf r r eso
' r ies a e o i ii o ilt s TI ne s h y r h ur n o o me own r f
s
a y
o
t 1 .) (
he 0> ' Emphai a
.
ss dded) Be us t pli if ha f l t ade tl alge t t
. ca e he antfs ve aied o quaey le ha
-
4-
Cii org ge i o roft l n a is Co loft a
tM ta s wne
he oa t s ue, unt
he mende c pl nti DI I
d om ai s SM SSED.
Co l :
unt I FDCPA Cli
am
l CountI,hepli tfsas e tha t y a ee ild t r i fa ns t def nda unde t
n
I t a n if s r t t he r ntte o ele gai t he e nt
r he
Far b Colcinpr cie Ac (TDCP ', 5U. C. 1 9 e s q. eFDCPA i ac ns me
iDe t l to a tc s tC
e
A' 1 S. j 6 2, t e Th
)
s o u r
pr t c i saut t tpr bisc ran a i de e i a unf i de c l c i pr c ies See
o e ton tt e ha ohi t e t i busve, c ptve, nd a r bt ole ton a tc .
i The FDCPA' prvaee oreme pr son,j 1
d.
S i t-nf c nt ovii
692k,a horz any a ive pes t
ut ies
ggre d ron o
r c rda a sfom l nydebtc lct who f ist c
e ove m ge r t
a
ole or
a l o ompl wihanypr son'oft FDCPA .
y t
ovii ' he
j1 9 k a. e Ma xv Ge eal v n eCop. 1 3S. . 1 6 1 71a n. ( b. 6, 01 ) The
6 2 ()S e r . n r Re e u r , 3 Ct 1 6 , 1 t 1 Fe 2 2 3 .
pli if alget thedef ntoa s ni er( )f l t a knowldget De Vai tonLetr
antfs le ha t
enda l n e c 1 aied o c
e he bt ldai te
sn b t eplitfswi ntetmepeid stf rh b t eF
e t y h an if t h i
hi
ro e o t y h DCPA; 2 fie t rs o dt s i
( ) ald o e p n o ad
lte ; n ( )fie t p o iea' 1a dc mpee'e p n et s i lte . E. .12a !2
etr a d 3 ald o r vd ' n o lt 'r s o s o ad etr D. No - t 6;
11
s eas 1 US j1 9 (etn f rhd b c l co 'o lg to su d rh F
e lo 5 C 6 2g stig o t t t ol trs b iain n e te DCPA u o rc i ig
e
p n e evn
c re p n e c fo ac ns mt i c n cinwi t ec lcin o a yd b)
o r s o d n e r m o u r n o ne to t h ol to f n e t.
h
e
l o d rt saeacam u d rteFDCP t ec mpan mu t le e( )ta t panif
n r e o tt li n e h
A,h o lit s alg 1 h the li tf
h sb e teo j c o c le to a t t aiigfo c n ume de t( )ha tedee d n i ad b
a e n h be t f olcin ci y rsn r m o s r b ;2 t th fn a t s e t
vi
c lcorasdei byt FDCPA;and( t tt dee ntha e age i ana toromison
ole t
tned he
3) ha he fnda s ng d n c
si
p o ie b tesau e Nawa v Ba ko
r btd y h ttt .
b . n fAme ia No. 2- 1 0 J3 TBS 2 2W L 2 7 5
rc , 1 CV- 3 -- 2 , 01
91 8 2,
a *12( . Fl J y1 201 . defnda move f dimis o Coun 1 ont g ou t t
t - M D. a. ul 7, 2)The e nt
s or s sal f
t 1 he r ndsha
t pli ifha f ie t al get s ond pr
he antf s a ld o le he ec
ong.
The FDCPA r m o s fom t de i ton of' btc lct ' a pe s whos aci t
e ve r he fnii
'
de ole or' ny r on
e tviy
c
once sade whih wasnoti de a ta t tm ei wasobt i d by s h pe s Se 1 U . C.
m
bt c
n f ul t he i t
ane
uc ron. e 5 S.
j 1 9 a6 ; s e as Re s
6 2 () e lo e e
J r n Ch s & Co, 6 6 F.u p.d 1 91 1 0
pMo ga
ae
. 8 sp z 2 , 38
-
5-
( D.1.0 9 (Un e t eFDCPA,c ns me ' ce i r , mo ta es r iig c mp n ,o a
S. Fa2 0 )' d r h
'
o u rs r dt s a rg g e vcn o a y r n
o
a sg ofade a enotc i r h btc l t s' l ast debtwasnoti de a ta t
s inee
bt r
onsde ed de olecor ,as ong he
n f ul t he
t i wa a sg e .) Be te v Ba k o
i t s sin d'; n ly . n fAme ia NA. 7 3 F.u p.d 1 6 ,1 71( D. a
me
'
rc , , 7 s p z 3 7 3 S. FI.
2 ltn ) He e t ep an if h v fi dt alg t t h s be t e t si d fula t etme
01 lsme . r,h litfs a e al o le e ha t e u j c d b wa n ea t t h i
e
i wa ta fre t ted fn a tl a sr ie . e eg. E.
t s rnserd o h ee d n o n e vc r Se , . D. No.12 a !6 Ac odigy e e
- t . c r n l, v n
t
hough t pli if a lge t tt de e
he antfs le ha he f ndanti adebtcolecor Cii orga doe notm e tt
s
l t , tM t ge s
e he
d fnio p o i e b teF A, ihr q ie t th s b e td b b i d futa t et i
ei t n r v d d y h DCP whc e urs ha te u j c e t e n e a l t h i t
i
me
wa a sg d t t de e
s s i ne o he f ndant Count1 i DI I
.
1 s SM SSED .
Cou 11 RESPA Cl m
nt 1 :
ai
Thepl ntfsne pur tt as e t cai unde t Rea Esat Setl mentPr c iesAct
ai if xt por o s r a l m
r he l t e te
a tc
( 2U. C.j2605)cli ngt t c
1 S.
, ami hathe onductalge i Count1 i as avi ai oft RESPA.
le d n
1 s lo olton he
Howe r t pli if,who a art ha sm pl c e a pase t a lga i r iedt r
ve ,he a ntfs
ppe o ve i y opi d nd t d he le tons a s mde
t FDCPA counti o Count 1, vef l dt plada ua orsat o y da ge l rt RESPA.
he
nt
11 ha aie o e ct l t ut r ma s mde he
I t a pl ntfsonc agana lgeacual ndi a bl da
nse d, ai if e i le
t a nt ngi e mage , c a ea' r t ndpr m ae
s whi h r ' ec a
di
oxi t
rs l'o 'heLo n S r ie' voain o t eFDCPA (il'D. No.12a !3 .
e ut f '
' t a e vc r ilto f h
s
sc . E.
'
- t 5
Thi i soppy,s t syl pla ng.TheCour wilnotdo t pl ntfs wor f t m .
ss l
ho gun-t e e di
t l
he ai if ' k or he
Se Fr zl v EM C M o t Cop.3 2Fe Ap ' 8 3 8 6( 1h Ci. 01 )( e c ra (ttn
e ai .
e
rg. r , 8 d. px 3 , 3 1 t r 2 0 p r u im) saig
t ta algai ofda ge i ane esay elme ofacam unde t RESPA) s (aloSee
ha n le ton
ma s s c sr e nt
li
r he
;e s
Byr v Nehat261F. 1 11 (11hCi.2001 (nwhiht c ts
ne . z ,
3d 075, 29 t r
) i c he our oughtt a dha ng
o voi vi
di ti t c t unde g t tm e- ons i pr es of ' e r a ng t pl di and di c r ng
s rc ours
r o he i c um ng oc s ' a r ngi he ea ngs
r
s e ni
whet rt pli ifhassae acai o cai ,orr i la whehe t defnda ' afimai
he he antf
ttd l m, r l msf elet nd t r he e nts fr tve
dee e aelgal s fcent'.Be aus t pl ntfshavefie t algedamag basdont
fns s r e ly ufii .) c e he ai if
'
ald o le
es e
he
-
6-
de e ntsaleg vi ai ofRESPA,s ii aly,CountlIi DI I
f nda ' l ed ol tons
pec fc l
I s SM SSED.
CountI :
V FDU TPA Cl m
ai
Fl i sUnf i a De e i Tr de Pr ci esAc de a est t'mf rordec ptvea s
orda'
ar nd c ptve a
a tc
t clr ha ' ai
t
e i ct
o p a t e i t ec n u to a yta eo c mme c 'a et a u . a Sa.j5 .0 ( ) ' e
r r ci s n h o d c f n r d r o r e' r mlwf l Fl. tt 012 4 1.'
c
Th
Fl i Supr
orda
eme Cou thasnot t t' ce i n oc lsi t e i a r pr s nt i om iso or
r
ed ha de pto ctr f her s e e e aton, s i n,
pr ci e t t i lkey t m il d t c ume ac i r a ona y i t cr um sa es t t
a tc ha s i l o sea he ons r tng e s bl n he ic t nc , o he
c n u r d ti n .'Zlt c v Pr mirS ls Gr u I c, 0 F.d 1 81 1 8 ( 1h Ci.
o s me' erme t'' onik . e e ae o p, n .48 3 2 , 2 4 1 t r
s
2007)( i PNR,I .v Be onPrp.Mgmt,nc.8 So. 773,777( a. ) Hee,t
quotng
nc . ac
o
.l , 42 2d
Fl 2003). r he
pl ntfsputf t c am salegi t thede enda s debt oleci n e f t consiutds ht ar
ai if
orh l i
l ng ha t
f nt' c l to fors
tt e uc mf i
orde ptve a t .
ce i c s
Tosaeacl m unde FDUTPA, pl ntf mus al e(1 ade e i o unf rpr tc i
tt ai
r
a ai if t leg ) c ptve r ai acie n
t c s ofta orc
he oure rde ommece ( ca ai a ( a t ldn ge . lnsI .v Bul 951
r ,2) us ton, nd 3) cua ma s Roli , nc . tand,
So.2d860,869( a. DCA 2006) I ismotont dimis t defnda aguest te ni a
F1 2d
. n t i o s s ,he e nt r
ha ve f
de e i orunf rpr c iehadbee pr pe l aleg t epr c iesa enoti t coureofta
c ptve
ai a tc
n o ry l ed, hos a tc r
n he
s
r de
or com m er
ce.
Thede e ntpoi so t tt 'r deorcommer e'r quieme i ofennotme i ca e
f nda
nt ut ha he ' a
t
c ' e r nt s t
tn ss
de i wih borowe s a lgi FDUTPA vi a i a ns morga s r i e s.Se Tr ntv.
alng t
r r le ng
oltons gai t
t ge e v c r
e e
Morga El toni Re sr i S .I .61 F.Supp. 135 1 ( . Fl 2007)(i ng
t ge ecr c gitaton ys, nc, 8
2d 6, 365 M D. a.
fndi
l n s r i e di not ' rie,s i i,pr de,ofe o diti e'an hi die ty t t
oa e v c r d
'
adve ts olct ovi
f r r srbut ' yt ng r cl o he
pli if) To borow fom Tr ntsa yss e n a s mi t fcsa pld e t ih t t
antfs.
r r
e ' nal i, ve s u ng he a t s e sabls hat he
de e nte ge i de ptve a s orunf i ta pr tc ,t 1 n s r i e ' a i do not
f nda nga d n ce i ct
ar r de ac ies he oa e v c rs ctons
quaiy as' ad orc
lf t e omm e c unde t Act Unde FDUTPA,' adeorc me c ' e ns
r
r e'
r he .
r
t
r
om r e m a ;
-
7-
( d e t i ,s lctn ,p o i ig of rn ,o d srb t ,wh t rb sl,r na,o
Al v ri ng oiiig r v dn , fe ig r iti ui
s
ng ehe y ae e tl r
ot m ie,ofa good o s r i ,ora pr t whe he t ngi e orit ngbl ora
he s
ny
r e vce
ny opery, t r a bl
n a i e, ny
ot ra tcl c modiy,ort ng ofva ue wher ve st t ' a o co me ce s l
he ri es om
t
hi
l ,
e r iuaed. Tr de r m r ' ha l
i l de t c
nc u he onduc of a ta o c me ce,ho ve de i t d,i l ng a
t
ny r de r om r
we r nom na e nc udi ny
non oftornotf rpr i pe s ora tviy.
pr i
-o - oft r on c i t
Fl. ttj5 .0 4 )I t i c s , si T e ttela s r ie ddn t'd e t e s lctp o ie
a S a. 012 3 8 .n h s a e a n r n ,h o n e vc r i o a v ri ,o ii, r vd ,
s
oferorditi t ' nyt ng t t pl i if . co di t t n
f
srbu e'a hi o he antf s Ac r ng o he mende compl i ,Cii o t ge
d
ant tM rga
me e yobt i d a lga i e e ti am o t genot fo at r pa t l nde a pr e d t t ke
rl
ane e l ntr s n
rga
e r m hid ry e r nd oce de o a
eforst e or t tr soft tmorga . n i t de e ntwe ealege t beac e t or
f t o nf ce he e m
ha
t ge Eve f he f nda
r l do
r dior
e na as i eof hede ,t a tvii donotme tFDUTPA' de i tonof'r deorc
ve n sgne t
bt is c i tes
e
S fnii
'a
t
omme ce.
r '
'
Se Tr , 8 F.Supp. a 1
e ent 61
zd t 365.
Be a et de e ntss r i ngoft m orgag di notf l wihi t pur e ofta o
c us he f nda ' e vci
he t e d
al t n he viw r de r
co me ce,hepli if '
m r t antfs CountI FDUTPA cli i DI I
V
a m s SM SSED.
Cot V:De l r t yRelef
mt
c a a or
i
l Coun V oft nme d c
n
t
he
nde ompl i , hepl i if a lget y ha al gii t quesi n
ant t
antfs le he ve e tma e
to
ast whot pr rl ns r i e i . saleg ton c r dit t fr tf c soft n e d
o
he ope oa e v c r s Thi l a i onta c s he is our ount he m nde
c
ompl nt whih pli y a knowl
ai , c a nl c
edget tt def nda i t l n s r i e . ,eg.D. 1 2a
ha he e nt s he oa e v c r See . E. - t
pp.12.The pl n if s e a de a ai a t t def ntsrghtt r evepa e fom t
aitfs e k
clr ton s o he enda ' i o ec i
ym nt r he
pl ntf;t rg t as e s f e a c t;a t rg t e o c t not a m orga The
ai if he i ht o s s e s nd oss nd he i ht o nf r e he e nd
t ge.
plitfscam t e aee tte t ad caao yj d me to t eba i o t erc nc r ta t e
an if li h y r nild o e lrtr u g n n h ss f h i o en h t h
pa te wilptr ueaf ecos ecli a i tt m .
ri s l zs
or l ur am gans he
Th f d rl ca ao yJ d me t ts' o a i e e d n s u c o fd r lu id ci n'
e e ea De lr tr u g n Ac i ' t n nd p n e t o re f e ea j rs ito ,
n
'
S hi ig v Ro e s 3 3 U. 6 6,6 7 ( 96 ) a d i ' r c d rlo l, Aen L# Is Co v
c l n . g r , 6 S. 6 7 1 0 , n s ' o e u a ny ' ta
l
p
n. . .
Hawo t, 0 U. 2 7 2 0( 93 ) TheFlrd De lrt r J dg n Ac, nt eohe h n i
rh 3 0 S. 2 , 4 1 7 .
o ia caao y u me t to h t r a d,s
-
8-
s b tni ea dr me a i n tr . r oIln Ca l, n . . mc s Ca lvso o h S t,
u sa tv n e diln au e Ma c sa d be I c v Co a t be iin fte ouh
Ac, 0 F. u p 2 1 5 ,1 6 ( . F a2 0 ) Asu n tepan if s e d caao yrle
5 9 S p . d 1 8 1 0 M D. l .0 7 . s mig h litfs e k e lr tr eif
pur ua t t sa ut t y a er quiedt s :
s nt o he tt e, he r e r o how
a bona fde,acual pr s ntpr tc lnee f rt de l r ton;t tt deca aton s d
i
t , ee
aci a
d o he c a a i ha he lr i houl
de lwih apr s nt as erai d ora c rai bl sa eoff c sorpr s ntcontove s ast a
a t
e e , c t ne
s e t na e t t
at
ee
r ry o
sa e off ct;t s
tt
a s hat ome i uniy,powe ,prviege or rghtoft co pl ni pa t i
mm t
r i l
i
he m ai ng ry s
de nde upon t f c sort 1w a i a e t t f t;t tt r i s e pe s o
pe nt
he a t
he a pplc bl o he acs ha he e s om
r on r
pe s who ha ,o r as bl m a have an a t l pr e ,a r e and a a nitc
rons
ve r e ona y y
c ua , es nt dve s
nt go si
itrs i t es j c matr et e i fc o lw;h ttea t g nitca a ves i tr s
ne et n h ube t te , ih r n a t r a ta h n a o si nd d re nee t
a ea1be or t c t pr rpr es o c a sr pr e a i a t tt r i s
r 1 f e he our by ope oc s r l s e es nt ton nd ha he elef oughti
s
notm e ey t gi ng ofl ga a ceby t c t ort a we t quesi pr po
r l he vi
e l dvi
he ours he ns r o
tons o unded
fom c i iy.
r urost
Fl.Sa . 8 . 1 Flrd c u t ' l no rn e,i t ef r o ad ca ao yj d me t wh t
a tt j 601 . o ia o rs ' l t e d r n h o m f e lrtr u g n, a
wi
a
mount t an a s yopi on att i tnceofpa te who s
so
dvior
ni
he nsa
ris
how m e el t pos i lt ofl ga
r y he sbiiy e l
ij r o teb sso ah poh tc lsaeo f cswhc h v n taie a d aeo yc n ige ,
n u y n h a i f y teia tt f a t ih a e o rsn n r nl o tn nt
u c ran,a d rs i t ef tr .Fl. p'o n . . a a teT u t f l s Co, 1 So2 4 9
n e ti (n ) etn h uu e' a De tfl s v Gu r n e r s Lf n . .8 2 .d 5 ,
'
c
460- ( a.1tDCA 2002)( iainsa itmal ai omitd)Agan, de lrtonbyt
61 Fl s
ctto nd ne quottons te . i a caai
he
Co ti dicei r Tr elr l s Co.v Emey,579So. 798 8 ( a.1tDCA 1 )
ur s s rtonay. av e s n .
. r
2d , 00 F1 s
991.
He e,t pl n if a a t ba et i cli f deca aor r i o s c ai t tt
r he aitfs ppe r o s her a m or lr t y elef n pe ul ton ha he
de e ntwilpur ueaf r l m ea ton a i tt m . t pli if ha nota lge t ts h
f nda
l s
o ecos c i gans he As he antfs ve
le d ha uc
a aci hasbe n br hti t Fl i sa e co t,i s m st tt s c am ' onl ba i i a
n ton
e oug n he orda tt urs t ee ha hi l i s y ss s
hy hei a s toff c sa i i fo algal eme notye s
pot tc l e
a t rsng r m e r dy
t ought Ac or ngl t Cour r f es
. c di y, he
t e us
t e ecs isds rto a dDENI tep an if' u t cam f rd caao yj d me t
o x rie t icein n
ES h litfs Co n V li o e lrt r u g n .
CountVI Oui Til
; et te
Fi ly,t Cour t r t t pl i if 'hr e par gr ph qui tte cai . n t ra
na l he
t u ns o he antfs t e - a a
et il l m I hei mende
d
c mpan,h an if alg , o cu o i ,h th s be t rg g i aco du nP an if'i e
o litteplitfs l e c n ls rl ta te u j c mo ta e s l u po litfstt
e
y
l
-
9-
t tes be t o et,a d ta te u eli Noeh sb e pad o teo lg to sa drg t
o h u jc pr p ry n h t h nd ryng t a e n i r h b iain n ih s
t r unde havebe extnguihe Unde Fl rda l acompl i t qui ttte t r alpr pe t
he e
r
en i s d.
r o i aw,
ant o e il o e
o ry
ag ns a ale c oudupon i s d notonl s ttei t pli ift t l nd i c r r y
ai t n lged l
t houl
y how il n he a ntf o he a n ontove s
b tas ta aco de ssb f r rle c nbern e e a an ti.Wo d ufv T yo , 1 S .d
u lo h t lu xit eo e eif a
e d r d g is t o rf . a lr 1 8 o2
8 2, 2 ( a 2dDCA 1 6 )( iigSa kv Fr y r 6 So2 2 7( a 1 5 ) Tb et v Olo ,
2 8 2 Fl.
9 0 ctn tr . a e , 7 .d 3 F1.9 3 ; ib ts . s n
91Fl.8 ( a.1 ; ndBr htv Bu - Co.91Fl 345( a.1
a 24 Fl 926) a ec . rNe , a. F1 926:.' nnotonl mus t
'
The
y the
ma trwhih c tt est aleg cl bes
te
c ons iut he l ed oud hown butf c smus beave r d whih gi t cai
at
t
re
c ve he l m
a r ntv i t a wel a t ewhih s
ppa e aldiy s l s hos
c how isi i t '1
t nvaldiy.'d.
Asnot byt de e
ed he f ndantt pl i if ha f ie t a lgef ct whih s t a e
, he antfs ve a ld o le a s c how he ppar nt
e se e ofa potntalcoud oftte.The pli if ha nots r e t pu pored owneroft
xit nc
e i l
il
a ntfs ve
e v d he r t
he
morga e,
t g whos i er s c dpotntalyc eaes hacoud, t pr s Onl t 1 s c r
e nt e t oul e i l r t uc l wih oces . y he oan eni e ,
whih CountVIc l t 'r se 'ha be n name as a de e nt Eve r adi t n nd
c
als he ' u te, s e
t
'
d
f nda . n e ng he me ed
compl nti t lg mos f a e t t pli if,i c
ai n he i ht t avor bl o he antfs t nnno bes i t tt de e ant e f t
t a d ha he f nd ' fors
s
t e or e t exitngm orga oblg i n o be l ofat r pary a e e
o nf c he si
t ge i ato n ha f
hid t r nough t c e t a coud
o rae l
u o t et l t tes b e t o e t. pan if'le ai n o s t f cinwiht mo ta ea d
p n h i e o h u j c pr p ry The litfsalg to s f ai a to t he rg g n
t
s
not c n ber s d a a afima i de e et an f tzef e os epr ee ngs butt y do no
e a
aie s n fr tve f ns o y u tr or cl ur oc di ,
he
t
s ppor an i pe ntca eofa ton.Acc di y, ca et pli if ha f ie t pr ry
u
t nde nde
us
ci
or ngl be us he antfs ve a ld o ope l
al gef c ss
le a t uppori ac am f quittte,Cou VIi DI I
t
ng l i or e il
nt s SM SSED.
Be us t Cour ha dim is t pl i if ' m e d c pli on i pe
ca e he
t s s s ed he antfs a nde om a nt nde ndentb es
as
ou lne a
ti d bove,t
i doesnot ea ht de e
r c he f ndan ' a gume t tt c ss dbedimis dba e
ts r
nt ha he ount houl
s se s d
on t pl ntfs f l e t c pl wih co r c ua '
he ai if 'aiur o om y t nta t l '
condii pr c dent' o flng s t
tons e e 't ii ui.
I i t r or
t s he ef e
-
1
0-
ADJ
UDGED t a t i Ca s i DI M I SED wi o t rj dc , t e c p ryb a igis
h th s u e s S S
t u p eu ie wi a h a t e rn t
h
h
o fe a c t,Fe R.Ci P. ()1( (i.Furhe , 1pe ngmoi a eDENI a
wn e s nd oss d. v. 41a( )A)i) t r a1 ndi
tons r
ED s
M OOT wih l a t r ne i appr it
t e ve o e w f
opra e.
DONE AN D ORDERED i Cha r a M i m i Fl i t s
n
mbe s t a , orda, hi
da ofM a 201
y
y, 3.
FED
CO A . OREN O
M
CHI UNI
EF
TED STATES DI
STRI
CT
J GE
UD
Co e pr vi d t
pis o de o:
Couns lofRe r
e
co d
-
11-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?