Benjamin et al v. CitiMortgage, Inc. et al

Filing 18

ORDER granting 6 Motion to Dismiss for Failure to State a Claim Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 5/6/2013. (cbe)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M im iDi son
a
vii
C as N um be 1 62291- I M O R EN O
e
r: 2C V-

M URATBENJ W M dVEON I
AM
EBENJ I
AM N,
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
VS.

CI M ORTGAGE,l ,
TI
NC.
D e e nt
f nda .

FI
NAL ORDER OF DI I
SM SSAL AND ORDER
DEN Y I G A LL PEN DI G M O TI N S AS M O O T
N
N
O

THI CAUSEca beo et Co t nt defnda 'M oint Dimis( E.No. )
S
me fr he ur upo he e nts to o s s D.
6.
Orgi lybr hti sae c tasaone- t c
i na l oug n t t our
co mt ompli ta ii t de t Fl rdaDe e i a
a n rsng m r he o i
c ptve nd

UnfiBu ie sPrcie Ac ('
ar sn s a tc s t '
FDUTP ',h sa o iv le t b ro r , u a a Ve ne
A' ti din n ov s wo o rwe sM rt nd o i
)
Be jmi, ungCi Mo ta e l c (' tM o ta e', ihi t el a s r ie f rt ep anif'
na n s i t rg g ,n . ' i rg g ' wh c s h o n e vc r o h litfs
i
ci
)
ho emorga e l n.nii ly,he c
m
t g oa I tal t ompl i wasfl d a i tbot t l n s r i e a Cii nk,
ant
ie ga ns h he oa e v c r nd tba
N . Cii nk, . . no bee s r edwih pr es a wa dim is fom t ca eonAprl
A. tba N A has t n e v
t oc s nd s s s ed r he s
i 29,
201 Thesa ec t s is t pli if' is FDUTPA c
3.
t t our dim s ed he a ntfs fr t
ompl i . E. 1 2 a pp. ant D. No. - t 21 22.
Thepli if fl a n e d compl nt whi wass e nty r m ove by t de e nt
antfs ied n m nde
ai , ch
ubs que l e
d he f nda .
Acc di t t n
or ng o he mende c
d ompli t onAugus 2,
an,
t 2005t borower e utd afxedr t
he r
s xec e i
ae
not i f voroft l nde , tFi i M orga Com pa LLC, hi h he d ar c da e i e es
ena
he e r Cii nanc al t ge
ny
w c l e or bl nt r t

i t e s b e tp o ry The panif r sd d a t e s be tp o e t a t etme te a n e
n h u j c r pet.
li tfs e ie t h u j c r p ry t h i h me d d
c pl i w a fl d.The pl i if a l ge t t on Od obe 30, 201 he l nde r co ded a
om a nt s ie
a ntf s le ha
r
2,t e r e r
n

a sg
s i nmen oft morg e t t de e n .Acc di t t a nde compl i ,t pli tfs
t he
t ag o he f nda t
or ng o he me d
ant he a n if

ne rr evedanotc of r ns e ora sg ntc e i et rt owne s pof o hes r i ng
ve ec i
ie ta f r s inme onc m ng ihe he
r hi , rt e vci
rght t t l n.The pli if aleg t tt y s a ' btva i ton lte ' a or a ' bt
i s o, he oa
antfs l e ha he ent '
de
lda i e tr' nd/
'
de
ve ii a i lte 't t def nda t de e mi t i ntt oft l n s r c ra owne oft
rfc ton e tr' o he e nt o t r ne he de iy he oa e vie nd
r he
l n. pl i if f t raleg t t he s nta' lfedwrte r ques't t l ns r i r The
oa The antfs urhe l e ha t y e
qua ii
itn e t'o he oa e vce .
n
mende c pli saest tt defnda f ie t ac
d om a nt t t ha he e nt al d o knowldge, es
e
r pond, pr deac
or ovi
omplt
ee
a a uaer pons t t swrte c r ponde e. naly,t pli if ale t tt no ei
nd deq t es e o hi itn ores
nc Fi l he a ntfs l ge ha he t n
que ton hasbee et rpa d i f l byt borowe sa orat r pa t
si
n ihe i n u l he r r nd/
hid ry.
The n e d c pl i c a nss x c m t a l gi vi a i oft Tr t i Lendi A c
m nde om a nt ont i i ot s le ng ol tons he u h n
ng t

(' LA';vi ai oft FarDe Cole tonPrci sAct('
'
TI ' oltons he i bt lci a tce
)
'
FDCPA';vi ai oft Re l
' oltons he a
)

EsaeSet me t r cie Ac t' Es 'i i lto so FDuTpAi e l tg j g n i dq e
tt tl n p a tc s tft pA' v oain f
e
l
l
d crao ud me tr uit
tte.The def nda ha moved f dim is ofa1 sx c am s o ,i t at r tve,f r a mor
il
e nt s
or s s al
l i l i r n he le na i o
e
de i t s a e e .
fnie t t m nt

Le lSt r
ca anda d
On amotont dim is t Cour mus viw t c
i o s s ,he
t t e he ompl i i t lg m os f vor bl t t
ant n he i ht t a a e o he

panif Glv rv fi tGr u I c, 5 F.d 1 0 ,1 0 ( 1hCi. 0 6 .Thstn th we e ,
li tf. o e . get o p, n .4 9 3 3 4 3 8 1 t r2 0 ) i e e, o v r

d e n t p yt lg l o l ins S eAs h rj v I a,1 9 S. .1 3 ,1 4 ( 0 9 .ç hi
o s o a pl o e a c ncuso . e c c o t . qb l 2 Ct 9 7 9 9 2 0 ) ç l
W e
ac antatcke b aRul 1 b)6)motont dimisdoesnotnee dealdfcua algai ,
ompli ta d y
e 2( (
i o s s
d tie a t l le tons

ap an ifso l aint p o d t etr t ' fhstnilg n )t r l f rq ie mo et a
litf' bi to o r vie h go mds o i e t e me t o ei e u rs r h n
g
t
e
lbel a c usons a af muli r ct tonoft eeme sofac eofa ton wilnotdo.'
a s nd oncl i , nd or a c e iai
he l nt
aus
ci
l
'

Bel l i Cor v Twombl 1 S. .1 1 65(
lAtantc p. .
y, 27 Ct 955, 964- 2007)(iai omit .A c ai
cttons ted) ompl nt
mus ha S noughf cst saeacam t r le t ti plusbl onisf e'i idoesnott
t ve ç
e
a t o tt li o eifha s a i e t ac ';ft
d
nudgel
)

te)camsa r s t l fo c n eva l t pa i l, i mu tb d s se 'I . t1 7 .
h l li co s he i r m o c i be o lusbe (t s e imis d. d a 9 4
ne
)
'
2-

-

Count1 Tr t i Le ngAc
: u h n ndi
t
The Tnzh i Le ng Ac i a cons e pr t ton saut t t s eks t ' voi t
t n ndi
t s
um r o eci t t e ha e
o ' d he
a

uni or d us ofc e t't ough t ' ni uldi cosle ofc edi t nns't r e blng
nf me e
r di' hr
he '
mea ngf s l tr
r t e s he eby na i
'

c n u r t b c me i f r d a u te c s o ce i.1 U. C.j 1 01a .l a dto t
o s mes o e o n o me bo t h o t f r dt 5 S.
6 () n d iin o
e wei t FedealTrde Commison t e ore ispr vii ,1 U. C.j 1 c) a
mpo rng he
r a
si o nf c t o sons 5 S.
607( , nd
i i c i na la lt onpes whowif lyandkno ngl vi aet saut 1 U. C.
mposng rmi l ibiiy
rons
lul
wi y olt he tt e, 5 S. j
1 1,t TI c e t s a prva e c us of a ton f a m a a saut y da a f c rai
61 he LA r a e
i t a e
c i or c l nd t t or m ges or e t n

dicos evi ains 15U. C. 1 a . Kisige v Wel Fa goBank NA.888F.
s l ur olto ,
S. j 640() See s n r . ls r
, ,
Supp.

2 1 0 ,1 1( D. a Au 3 , 01 ) I p riua , 1 41g ()r a a f lo :
d 3 9 31 S. Fl. g. 0 2 2 .n atc lr j 6 ( )1 e ds s o lws
I a ton t ot rdic os esr uie by t ss ha e , lt rt n 30 da a trt
n ddii o he s l ur eq r d hi ubc pt r not a e ha
ys fe he
da eon whih am orgag l n i s d orot r s ta fr e oras i
t
c
t e oa s ol
he wie r nse r d
sgnedt at r pa t
o hid ry,
t cr diort ti t ne owne o a sgne oft de s l notf t boroweri wrtng
he e t ha s he w
r r s i e he bt ha l iy he r
n ii
ofs h tanse ,i udi
uc r fr ncl ng-

( t i ntt add e s tlpho ml roft new crdior
A) he de iy, r s ,ee ne mbe he
et;
( ted t o ta se ;
B) h ae f r n fr
( h w t ra h a a e to p ryha i g a t rt t a to b h l o t n w
C) o o e c n g n r a t v n uhoiy o c n e af f he e
ce t ;
r dior

( t l ato oft plcewheeta frofownes poft de i r c de a
D)he oc in he a
r rnse
rhi he bt s e or d; nd
( a yo h rrlv n if r to r g r igten w ce i r
E) n t e ee a t n o main e a dn h e r dt .
o

1 U. C. 1 0 ( )1 . u tl f h n nd dc mp an alg sta t epanif n v rrc ie
5 S. j 6 2 g ( ) Co n o t e me e o lit le e h t h litfs e e e ev d
no i eoft a sgnme ofowne s pof he rmorga l ismotont dim is t de e
tc he s i
nt
r hi t i
t ge.n t
i o s s ,he f ndan fr t
t is
a gue t scli i tme- re cii t TI S one ye r saut of lm ia i .Cii orga
r s hi am s i ba r d, tng he LA'
- a t t e i ttons tM t ge
cli st tt lm ia i pe i bega t r when t m o t gedocume swe ee c e D.
am ha he i t tons rod
n o un
he rga
nt r xe ut d. E.
No. a p.5.
6 t
Howe r t homeowner ' am i bas o t de enda ' aleg f itr t no iy
ve ,he
s cli s ed n he f nts l ed alle o tf

t m oft asi
he
he sgnmen oft morga asrquie byt saut 1 U. C. 1 e r uie t t
t he t ge e rd he tt e. 5 S. j 640() eq rs ha
a a ton bebr
n ci
ought' t n one ye rfom t dae oft oc r nc oft vi ai n. He e, he
' hi
wi
a r he t
he cure e he ol to ' r t
'
-

3-

vi a i i a lge t ha oc ure upont ta f roft m orgag on Ocobe 30,201 D.
olton s le d o ve c r d
he r ns e
he
t e
t r
2. E.

No 12a !6. ea n e c mplitwa t l tldba e o t ealg to sc nan dt een
. - t Th me d d o an s i y ie s d n h le ain o t ie h ri .
me
Thede e
f ndan ne cli st tt TI c
t xt am ha he LA ounti i qua eyale d, l i i t r we e
s nade t l l ge c am ng he e r
' dicl ur a tc 'o t a e d c
' s os es ta hed't he m nde ompli ta nos
no
a n nd
howi ofhow t edicos eswe e
ng
hos s l ur
r
i orec o i vi a i oft s a ut D . N o. a pp. 6. sa gum ent si pr rat hem oton
nc r t r n ol ton he t t e. E. 6 t 5- Thi r
i m ope t
i
t dim i s s a a i puzz i gi n t e s nc oft pl i i f ' m e
o s s t ge, nd s
lng ve he s e e he a ntf s a nded com pl i :t tgo
a nt ha
.

d s os r r l tng t t ta f rand a sgnme oft m orga we egi n.
icl u es e ai o he r nse
si
nt he
t ge r ve

Fi ly,hede e
na l t
f ndant g t t a al n s r c r i c nnotbehed la et r1 U. C.
ar ues ha , s oa e vie ,t n
l i bl mde 5 S.

j1 41g .ts r et a teTI do s tmp s la iiyo sr ie s b t n'rdi rs wh fil
6 ()I itu h th LA e no i o e iblt n e vc r , u o ' e t ll o al
c o
)oc mpl wi a yrqurme tmp e t e . s cin 1 3 o ti t l ln ls b e to ( o
t o y t n e ie n i os d md r . e to 6 5 f hs i e a d u s cin 9 r
h
.
t
()ofs ci 1 1' 5U. C.j 1 40( ;s ealoDavi v Gr n ntMorg.Fundi l .No.
g e ton 64 .1 S.
'
6 a) e s
s . ee poi
t
ng, nc,

10 -v 2 9 2 1W L 7 7 21a * ( D. . a . , 01 )( o igta 1 U. C. 1 9 4 1
:9 c - 71 , 01
0 2 t 3 N. Ga M r 1 2 1 n tn h t 5 S. j 6 2 9( )
'i isas c rsla lt t st tonsi whih t s ni e wasonc a a sgne orowne oft
'm t eni e ' ibiiy o iua i n c he e c
l
e n si e
r he

1= '
0 '
)
Thepl ntfsa knowl dget t def nda i al ns r i e . ame dc
ai if c
e hathe e nt s oa e v c r The nde ompl nt l o
ai a s
a lge i s r lpl e t tt l n s r i ri wor ng a t t r pa t de c l coron be l
le s n eve a ac s ha he oa e vce s ki s he hid- ry bt ole t
ha f

o a o e a d o h l e o t epanif' oea dmo ta e'D. No. - a !3 ; e as D.
f n wn r n / r o d r f h litfsn t n rg g . E. 12 t 0 s e lo E.
'
No 12a !4 . pan if ha efie t ce ryalg t t h d fn a t s h o e o t ed b
. - t 3 The litfs v ald o lal l e ha t e e e d n i t e wn r f h e t
e
is f Acc di y,TI doe notpr deac us ofac i a i tt de e
tel. or ngl LA
s
ovi
a e
ton ga ns he f ndan f t c
t or he onduc
t

alg d. e Kh nv T eBa ko w Yo kM eln, 1 6 2 - V, 01 W L 1 0 0 a *
le e S e a . h n fNe r lo No. 2- 01 8 CI 2 2
0 35 9 t 3
('e vc r h v n l blt f rvoain of LA u ls te aetec re t rf r r eso
' r ies a e o i ii o ilt s TI ne s h y r h ur n o o me own r f
s
a y
o
t 1 .) (
he 0> ' Emphai a
.
ss dded) Be us t pli if ha f l t ade tl alge t t
. ca e he antfs ve aied o quaey le ha
-

4-

Cii org ge i o roft l n a is Co loft a
tM ta s wne
he oa t s ue, unt
he mende c pl nti DI I
d om ai s SM SSED.
Co l :
unt I FDCPA Cli
am

l CountI,hepli tfsas e tha t y a ee ild t r i fa ns t def nda unde t
n
I t a n if s r t t he r ntte o ele gai t he e nt
r he

Far b Colcinpr cie Ac (TDCP ', 5U. C. 1 9 e s q. eFDCPA i ac ns me
iDe t l to a tc s tC
e
A' 1 S. j 6 2, t e Th
)
s o u r
pr t c i saut t tpr bisc ran a i de e i a unf i de c l c i pr c ies See
o e ton tt e ha ohi t e t i busve, c ptve, nd a r bt ole ton a tc .

i The FDCPA' prvaee oreme pr son,j 1
d.
S i t-nf c nt ovii
692k,a horz any a ive pes t
ut ies
ggre d ron o
r c rda a sfom l nydebtc lct who f ist c
e ove m ge r t
a
ole or
a l o ompl wihanypr son'oft FDCPA .
y t
ovii ' he

j1 9 k a. e Ma xv Ge eal v n eCop. 1 3S. . 1 6 1 71a n. ( b. 6, 01 ) The
6 2 ()S e r . n r Re e u r , 3 Ct 1 6 , 1 t 1 Fe 2 2 3 .
pli if alget thedef ntoa s ni er( )f l t a knowldget De Vai tonLetr
antfs le ha t
enda l n e c 1 aied o c
e he bt ldai te

sn b t eplitfswi ntetmepeid stf rh b t eF
e t y h an if t h i
hi
ro e o t y h DCPA; 2 fie t rs o dt s i
( ) ald o e p n o ad
lte ; n ( )fie t p o iea' 1a dc mpee'e p n et s i lte . E. .12a !2
etr a d 3 ald o r vd ' n o lt 'r s o s o ad etr D. No - t 6;
11
s eas 1 US j1 9 (etn f rhd b c l co 'o lg to su d rh F
e lo 5 C 6 2g stig o t t t ol trs b iain n e te DCPA u o rc i ig
e
p n e evn

c re p n e c fo ac ns mt i c n cinwi t ec lcin o a yd b)
o r s o d n e r m o u r n o ne to t h ol to f n e t.
h
e
l o d rt saeacam u d rteFDCP t ec mpan mu t le e( )ta t panif
n r e o tt li n e h
A,h o lit s alg 1 h the li tf

h sb e teo j c o c le to a t t aiigfo c n ume de t( )ha tedee d n i ad b
a e n h be t f olcin ci y rsn r m o s r b ;2 t th fn a t s e t
vi
c lcorasdei byt FDCPA;and( t tt dee ntha e age i ana toromison
ole t
tned he
3) ha he fnda s ng d n c
si

p o ie b tesau e Nawa v Ba ko
r btd y h ttt .
b . n fAme ia No. 2- 1 0 J3 TBS 2 2W L 2 7 5
rc , 1 CV- 3 -- 2 , 01
91 8 2,
a *12( . Fl J y1 201 . defnda move f dimis o Coun 1 ont g ou t t
t - M D. a. ul 7, 2)The e nt
s or s sal f
t 1 he r ndsha
t pli ifha f ie t al get s ond pr
he antf s a ld o le he ec
ong.
The FDCPA r m o s fom t de i ton of' btc lct ' a pe s whos aci t
e ve r he fnii
'
de ole or' ny r on
e tviy

c
once sade whih wasnoti de a ta t tm ei wasobt i d by s h pe s Se 1 U . C.
m
bt c
n f ul t he i t
ane
uc ron. e 5 S.

j 1 9 a6 ; s e as Re s
6 2 () e lo e e

J r n Ch s & Co, 6 6 F.u p.d 1 91 1 0
pMo ga
ae
. 8 sp z 2 , 38
-

5-

( D.1.0 9 (Un e t eFDCPA,c ns me ' ce i r , mo ta es r iig c mp n ,o a
S. Fa2 0 )' d r h
'
o u rs r dt s a rg g e vcn o a y r n
o
a sg ofade a enotc i r h btc l t s' l ast debtwasnoti de a ta t
s inee
bt r
onsde ed de olecor ,as ong he
n f ul t he

t i wa a sg e .) Be te v Ba k o
i t s sin d'; n ly . n fAme ia NA. 7 3 F.u p.d 1 6 ,1 71( D. a
me
'
rc , , 7 s p z 3 7 3 S. FI.
2 ltn ) He e t ep an if h v fi dt alg t t h s be t e t si d fula t etme
01 lsme . r,h litfs a e al o le e ha t e u j c d b wa n ea t t h i
e
i wa ta fre t ted fn a tl a sr ie . e eg. E.
t s rnserd o h ee d n o n e vc r Se , . D. No.12 a !6 Ac odigy e e
- t . c r n l, v n
t
hough t pli if a lge t tt de e
he antfs le ha he f ndanti adebtcolecor Cii orga doe notm e tt
s
l t , tM t ge s
e he

d fnio p o i e b teF A, ihr q ie t th s b e td b b i d futa t et i
ei t n r v d d y h DCP whc e urs ha te u j c e t e n e a l t h i t
i
me
wa a sg d t t de e
s s i ne o he f ndant Count1 i DI I
.
1 s SM SSED .
Cou 11 RESPA Cl m
nt 1 :
ai

Thepl ntfsne pur tt as e t cai unde t Rea Esat Setl mentPr c iesAct
ai if xt por o s r a l m
r he l t e te
a tc

( 2U. C.j2605)cli ngt t c
1 S.
, ami hathe onductalge i Count1 i as avi ai oft RESPA.
le d n
1 s lo olton he
Howe r t pli if,who a art ha sm pl c e a pase t a lga i r iedt r
ve ,he a ntfs
ppe o ve i y opi d nd t d he le tons a s mde

t FDCPA counti o Count 1, vef l dt plada ua orsat o y da ge l rt RESPA.
he
nt
11 ha aie o e ct l t ut r ma s mde he
I t a pl ntfsonc agana lgeacual ndi a bl da
nse d, ai if e i le
t a nt ngi e mage , c a ea' r t ndpr m ae
s whi h r ' ec a
di
oxi t

rs l'o 'heLo n S r ie' voain o t eFDCPA (il'D. No.12a !3 .
e ut f '
' t a e vc r ilto f h
s
sc . E.
'
- t 5
Thi i soppy,s t syl pla ng.TheCour wilnotdo t pl ntfs wor f t m .
ss l
ho gun-t e e di
t l
he ai if ' k or he

Se Fr zl v EM C M o t Cop.3 2Fe Ap ' 8 3 8 6( 1h Ci. 01 )( e c ra (ttn
e ai .
e
rg. r , 8 d. px 3 , 3 1 t r 2 0 p r u im) saig
t ta algai ofda ge i ane esay elme ofacam unde t RESPA) s (aloSee
ha n le ton
ma s s c sr e nt
li
r he
;e s
Byr v Nehat261F. 1 11 (11hCi.2001 (nwhiht c ts
ne . z ,
3d 075, 29 t r
) i c he our oughtt a dha ng
o voi vi
di ti t c t unde g t tm e- ons i pr es of ' e r a ng t pl di and di c r ng
s rc ours
r o he i c um ng oc s ' a r ngi he ea ngs
r
s e ni

whet rt pli ifhassae acai o cai ,orr i la whehe t defnda ' afimai
he he antf
ttd l m, r l msf elet nd t r he e nts fr tve

dee e aelgal s fcent'.Be aus t pl ntfshavefie t algedamag basdont
fns s r e ly ufii .) c e he ai if
'
ald o le
es e
he
-

6-

de e ntsaleg vi ai ofRESPA,s ii aly,CountlIi DI I
f nda ' l ed ol tons
pec fc l
I s SM SSED.
CountI :
V FDU TPA Cl m
ai

Fl i sUnf i a De e i Tr de Pr ci esAc de a est t'mf rordec ptvea s
orda'
ar nd c ptve a
a tc
t clr ha ' ai
t
e i ct

o p a t e i t ec n u to a yta eo c mme c 'a et a u . a Sa.j5 .0 ( ) ' e
r r ci s n h o d c f n r d r o r e' r mlwf l Fl. tt 012 4 1.'
c
Th
Fl i Supr
orda
eme Cou thasnot t t' ce i n oc lsi t e i a r pr s nt i om iso or
r
ed ha de pto ctr f her s e e e aton, s i n,
pr ci e t t i lkey t m il d t c ume ac i r a ona y i t cr um sa es t t
a tc ha s i l o sea he ons r tng e s bl n he ic t nc , o he

c n u r d ti n .'Zlt c v Pr mirS ls Gr u I c, 0 F.d 1 81 1 8 ( 1h Ci.
o s me' erme t'' onik . e e ae o p, n .48 3 2 , 2 4 1 t r
s
2007)( i PNR,I .v Be onPrp.Mgmt,nc.8 So. 773,777( a. ) Hee,t
quotng
nc . ac
o
.l , 42 2d
Fl 2003). r he
pl ntfsputf t c am salegi t thede enda s debt oleci n e f t consiutds ht ar
ai if
orh l i
l ng ha t
f nt' c l to fors
tt e uc mf i
orde ptve a t .
ce i c s

Tosaeacl m unde FDUTPA, pl ntf mus al e(1 ade e i o unf rpr tc i
tt ai
r
a ai if t leg ) c ptve r ai acie n
t c s ofta orc
he oure rde ommece ( ca ai a ( a t ldn ge . lnsI .v Bul 951
r ,2) us ton, nd 3) cua ma s Roli , nc . tand,
So.2d860,869( a. DCA 2006) I ismotont dimis t defnda aguest te ni a
F1 2d
. n t i o s s ,he e nt r
ha ve f
de e i orunf rpr c iehadbee pr pe l aleg t epr c iesa enoti t coureofta
c ptve
ai a tc
n o ry l ed, hos a tc r
n he
s
r de
or com m er
ce.

Thede e ntpoi so t tt 'r deorcommer e'r quieme i ofennotme i ca e
f nda
nt ut ha he ' a
t
c ' e r nt s t
tn ss

de i wih borowe s a lgi FDUTPA vi a i a ns morga s r i e s.Se Tr ntv.
alng t
r r le ng
oltons gai t
t ge e v c r
e e

Morga El toni Re sr i S .I .61 F.Supp. 135 1 ( . Fl 2007)(i ng
t ge ecr c gitaton ys, nc, 8
2d 6, 365 M D. a.
fndi
l n s r i e di not ' rie,s i i,pr de,ofe o diti e'an hi die ty t t
oa e v c r d
'
adve ts olct ovi
f r r srbut ' yt ng r cl o he

pli if) To borow fom Tr ntsa yss e n a s mi t fcsa pld e t ih t t
antfs.
r r
e ' nal i, ve s u ng he a t s e sabls hat he
de e nte ge i de ptve a s orunf i ta pr tc ,t 1 n s r i e ' a i do not
f nda nga d n ce i ct
ar r de ac ies he oa e v c rs ctons
quaiy as' ad orc
lf t e omm e c unde t Act Unde FDUTPA,' adeorc me c ' e ns
r
r e'
r he .
r
t
r
om r e m a ;
-

7-

( d e t i ,s lctn ,p o i ig of rn ,o d srb t ,wh t rb sl,r na,o
Al v ri ng oiiig r v dn , fe ig r iti ui
s
ng ehe y ae e tl r
ot m ie,ofa good o s r i ,ora pr t whe he t ngi e orit ngbl ora
he s
ny
r e vce
ny opery, t r a bl
n a i e, ny
ot ra tcl c modiy,ort ng ofva ue wher ve st t ' a o co me ce s l
he ri es om
t
hi
l ,
e r iuaed. Tr de r m r ' ha l
i l de t c
nc u he onduc of a ta o c me ce,ho ve de i t d,i l ng a
t
ny r de r om r
we r nom na e nc udi ny
non oftornotf rpr i pe s ora tviy.
pr i
-o - oft r on c i t

Fl. ttj5 .0 4 )I t i c s , si T e ttela s r ie ddn t'd e t e s lctp o ie
a S a. 012 3 8 .n h s a e a n r n ,h o n e vc r i o a v ri ,o ii, r vd ,
s
oferorditi t ' nyt ng t t pl i if . co di t t n
f
srbu e'a hi o he antf s Ac r ng o he mende compl i ,Cii o t ge
d
ant tM rga
me e yobt i d a lga i e e ti am o t genot fo at r pa t l nde a pr e d t t ke
rl
ane e l ntr s n
rga
e r m hid ry e r nd oce de o a
eforst e or t tr soft tmorga . n i t de e ntwe ealege t beac e t or
f t o nf ce he e m
ha
t ge Eve f he f nda
r l do
r dior
e na as i eof hede ,t a tvii donotme tFDUTPA' de i tonof'r deorc
ve n sgne t
bt is c i tes
e
S fnii
'a
t
omme ce.
r '
'
Se Tr , 8 F.Supp. a 1
e ent 61
zd t 365.

Be a et de e ntss r i ngoft m orgag di notf l wihi t pur e ofta o
c us he f nda ' e vci
he t e d
al t n he viw r de r
co me ce,hepli if '
m r t antfs CountI FDUTPA cli i DI I
V
a m s SM SSED.
Cot V:De l r t yRelef
mt
c a a or
i
l Coun V oft nme d c
n
t
he
nde ompl i , hepl i if a lget y ha al gii t quesi n
ant t
antfs le he ve e tma e
to
ast whot pr rl ns r i e i . saleg ton c r dit t fr tf c soft n e d
o
he ope oa e v c r s Thi l a i onta c s he is our ount he m nde

c
ompl nt whih pli y a knowl
ai , c a nl c
edget tt def nda i t l n s r i e . ,eg.D. 1 2a
ha he e nt s he oa e v c r See . E. - t
pp.12.The pl n if s e a de a ai a t t def ntsrghtt r evepa e fom t
aitfs e k
clr ton s o he enda ' i o ec i
ym nt r he
pl ntf;t rg t as e s f e a c t;a t rg t e o c t not a m orga The
ai if he i ht o s s e s nd oss nd he i ht o nf r e he e nd
t ge.

plitfscam t e aee tte t ad caao yj d me to t eba i o t erc nc r ta t e
an if li h y r nild o e lrtr u g n n h ss f h i o en h t h
pa te wilptr ueaf ecos ecli a i tt m .
ri s l zs
or l ur am gans he

Th f d rl ca ao yJ d me t ts' o a i e e d n s u c o fd r lu id ci n'
e e ea De lr tr u g n Ac i ' t n nd p n e t o re f e ea j rs ito ,
n
'

S hi ig v Ro e s 3 3 U. 6 6,6 7 ( 96 ) a d i ' r c d rlo l, Aen L# Is Co v
c l n . g r , 6 S. 6 7 1 0 , n s ' o e u a ny ' ta
l
p
n. . .
Hawo t, 0 U. 2 7 2 0( 93 ) TheFlrd De lrt r J dg n Ac, nt eohe h n i
rh 3 0 S. 2 , 4 1 7 .
o ia caao y u me t to h t r a d,s
-

8-

s b tni ea dr me a i n tr . r oIln Ca l, n . . mc s Ca lvso o h S t,
u sa tv n e diln au e Ma c sa d be I c v Co a t be iin fte ouh
Ac, 0 F. u p 2 1 5 ,1 6 ( . F a2 0 ) Asu n tepan if s e d caao yrle
5 9 S p . d 1 8 1 0 M D. l .0 7 . s mig h litfs e k e lr tr eif
pur ua t t sa ut t y a er quiedt s :
s nt o he tt e, he r e r o how
a bona fde,acual pr s ntpr tc lnee f rt de l r ton;t tt deca aton s d
i
t , ee
aci a
d o he c a a i ha he lr i houl
de lwih apr s nt as erai d ora c rai bl sa eoff c sorpr s ntcontove s ast a
a t
e e , c t ne
s e t na e t t
at
ee
r ry o
sa e off ct;t s
tt
a s hat ome i uniy,powe ,prviege or rghtoft co pl ni pa t i
mm t
r i l
i
he m ai ng ry s
de nde upon t f c sort 1w a i a e t t f t;t tt r i s e pe s o
pe nt
he a t
he a pplc bl o he acs ha he e s om
r on r
pe s who ha ,o r as bl m a have an a t l pr e ,a r e and a a nitc
rons
ve r e ona y y
c ua , es nt dve s
nt go si

itrs i t es j c matr et e i fc o lw;h ttea t g nitca a ves i tr s
ne et n h ube t te , ih r n a t r a ta h n a o si nd d re nee t
a ea1be or t c t pr rpr es o c a sr pr e a i a t tt r i s
r 1 f e he our by ope oc s r l s e es nt ton nd ha he elef oughti
s
notm e ey t gi ng ofl ga a ceby t c t ort a we t quesi pr po
r l he vi
e l dvi
he ours he ns r o
tons o unded
fom c i iy.
r urost

Fl.Sa . 8 . 1 Flrd c u t ' l no rn e,i t ef r o ad ca ao yj d me t wh t
a tt j 601 . o ia o rs ' l t e d r n h o m f e lrtr u g n, a
wi
a
mount t an a s yopi on att i tnceofpa te who s
so
dvior
ni
he nsa
ris
how m e el t pos i lt ofl ga
r y he sbiiy e l

ij r o teb sso ah poh tc lsaeo f cswhc h v n taie a d aeo yc n ige ,
n u y n h a i f y teia tt f a t ih a e o rsn n r nl o tn nt

u c ran,a d rs i t ef tr .Fl. p'o n . . a a teT u t f l s Co, 1 So2 4 9
n e ti (n ) etn h uu e' a De tfl s v Gu r n e r s Lf n . .8 2 .d 5 ,
'
c
460- ( a.1tDCA 2002)( iainsa itmal ai omitd)Agan, de lrtonbyt
61 Fl s
ctto nd ne quottons te . i a caai
he
Co ti dicei r Tr elr l s Co.v Emey,579So. 798 8 ( a.1tDCA 1 )
ur s s rtonay. av e s n .
. r
2d , 00 F1 s
991.
He e,t pl n if a a t ba et i cli f deca aor r i o s c ai t tt
r he aitfs ppe r o s her a m or lr t y elef n pe ul ton ha he
de e ntwilpur ueaf r l m ea ton a i tt m . t pli if ha nota lge t ts h
f nda
l s
o ecos c i gans he As he antfs ve
le d ha uc

a aci hasbe n br hti t Fl i sa e co t,i s m st tt s c am ' onl ba i i a
n ton
e oug n he orda tt urs t ee ha hi l i s y ss s
hy hei a s toff c sa i i fo algal eme notye s
pot tc l e
a t rsng r m e r dy
t ought Ac or ngl t Cour r f es
. c di y, he
t e us

t e ecs isds rto a dDENI tep an if' u t cam f rd caao yj d me t
o x rie t icein n
ES h litfs Co n V li o e lrt r u g n .
CountVI Oui Til
; et te
Fi ly,t Cour t r t t pl i if 'hr e par gr ph qui tte cai . n t ra
na l he
t u ns o he antfs t e - a a
et il l m I hei mende
d

c mpan,h an if alg , o cu o i ,h th s be t rg g i aco du nP an if'i e
o litteplitfs l e c n ls rl ta te u j c mo ta e s l u po litfstt
e
y
l
-

9-

t tes be t o et,a d ta te u eli Noeh sb e pad o teo lg to sa drg t
o h u jc pr p ry n h t h nd ryng t a e n i r h b iain n ih s
t r unde havebe extnguihe Unde Fl rda l acompl i t qui ttte t r alpr pe t
he e
r
en i s d.
r o i aw,
ant o e il o e
o ry

ag ns a ale c oudupon i s d notonl s ttei t pli ift t l nd i c r r y
ai t n lged l
t houl
y how il n he a ntf o he a n ontove s

b tas ta aco de ssb f r rle c nbern e e a an ti.Wo d ufv T yo , 1 S .d
u lo h t lu xit eo e eif a
e d r d g is t o rf . a lr 1 8 o2
8 2, 2 ( a 2dDCA 1 6 )( iigSa kv Fr y r 6 So2 2 7( a 1 5 ) Tb et v Olo ,
2 8 2 Fl.
9 0 ctn tr . a e , 7 .d 3 F1.9 3 ; ib ts . s n
91Fl.8 ( a.1 ; ndBr htv Bu - Co.91Fl 345( a.1
a 24 Fl 926) a ec . rNe , a. F1 926:.' nnotonl mus t
'
The
y the
ma trwhih c tt est aleg cl bes
te
c ons iut he l ed oud hown butf c smus beave r d whih gi t cai
at
t
re
c ve he l m
a r ntv i t a wel a t ewhih s
ppa e aldiy s l s hos
c how isi i t '1
t nvaldiy.'d.
Asnot byt de e
ed he f ndantt pl i if ha f ie t a lgef ct whih s t a e
, he antfs ve a ld o le a s c how he ppar nt

e se e ofa potntalcoud oftte.The pli if ha nots r e t pu pored owneroft
xit nc
e i l
il
a ntfs ve
e v d he r t
he
morga e,
t g whos i er s c dpotntalyc eaes hacoud, t pr s Onl t 1 s c r
e nt e t oul e i l r t uc l wih oces . y he oan eni e ,

whih CountVIc l t 'r se 'ha be n name as a de e nt Eve r adi t n nd
c
als he ' u te, s e
t
'
d
f nda . n e ng he me ed
compl nti t lg mos f a e t t pli if,i c
ai n he i ht t avor bl o he antfs t nnno bes i t tt de e ant e f t
t a d ha he f nd ' fors
s
t e or e t exitngm orga oblg i n o be l ofat r pary a e e
o nf c he si
t ge i ato n ha f
hid t r nough t c e t a coud
o rae l

u o t et l t tes b e t o e t. pan if'le ai n o s t f cinwiht mo ta ea d
p n h i e o h u j c pr p ry The litfsalg to s f ai a to t he rg g n
t
s
not c n ber s d a a afima i de e et an f tzef e os epr ee ngs butt y do no
e a
aie s n fr tve f ns o y u tr or cl ur oc di ,
he
t
s ppor an i pe ntca eofa ton.Acc di y, ca et pli if ha f ie t pr ry
u
t nde nde
us
ci
or ngl be us he antfs ve a ld o ope l
al gef c ss
le a t uppori ac am f quittte,Cou VIi DI I
t
ng l i or e il
nt s SM SSED.
Be us t Cour ha dim is t pl i if ' m e d c pli on i pe
ca e he
t s s s ed he antfs a nde om a nt nde ndentb es
as
ou lne a
ti d bove,t
i doesnot ea ht de e
r c he f ndan ' a gume t tt c ss dbedimis dba e
ts r
nt ha he ount houl
s se s d
on t pl ntfs f l e t c pl wih co r c ua '
he ai if 'aiur o om y t nta t l '
condii pr c dent' o flng s t
tons e e 't ii ui.
I i t r or
t s he ef e
-

1
0-

ADJ
UDGED t a t i Ca s i DI M I SED wi o t rj dc , t e c p ryb a igis
h th s u e s S S
t u p eu ie wi a h a t e rn t
h
h
o fe a c t,Fe R.Ci P. ()1( (i.Furhe , 1pe ngmoi a eDENI a
wn e s nd oss d. v. 41a( )A)i) t r a1 ndi
tons r
ED s
M OOT wih l a t r ne i appr it
t e ve o e w f
opra e.
DONE AN D ORDERED i Cha r a M i m i Fl i t s
n
mbe s t a , orda, hi

da ofM a 201
y
y, 3.

FED
CO A . OREN O
M
CHI UNI
EF
TED STATES DI
STRI
CT
J GE
UD

Co e pr vi d t
pis o de o:

Couns lofRe r
e
co d

-

11-