Fastway Moving and Storage, Inc. v. Eguiguren Ugarte

Filing 23

Order Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendant's Motion to Dismiss and Denying Defendant's Motion to Strike the Plaintiff's Complaint. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/26/2013. (vds)

'

)
t
i
'

q
)
i
!

UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI C U RT FO R TH E
CT
SOU TH ERN D I I O FLOR I A
STR CT
D
M i iD i s o
am
vi i

Cas Num ber 1 60832- V- O RENO
e
: 3C M
FA STW A Y M OV I G AN D STO M GE,l C.
N
N ,

V S.

FR AN CI
SCO J SE EG UI UR EN U G ARTE,
O
G
D e e nt
f nda .
/
O R DER G R AN TI G I PA R T AN D DEN Y I G I PAR T D EFEN D AN T ' M O TI N TO
N N
N N
S
O
DI I AN D DEN Y I G D EFEN D AN T' M O TI N T O STR I E TH E PLA I TI S
SM SS
N
S
K
N FF'
C O M PLA I
N

THI CAUSE ca bef r t Cour upon Def nda ' M oton t Dim isorSti t
S
me o e he
t
nts
i o s s
rke he

Pli ifsCompli ( E.No.7 ,ie onM a 21 20 3.
antf
ant D.
) fld
THE COURT hasc i r t moton a t e tne pori oft r co d, nd beng
onsde ed he i nd he ri nt tons he e r a
i
ot r i e f l a s i t pr m i es i i
he w s uly dvi ed n he e s , t s

ADJUDGED t tt M oto t Dim isi DEN ED I PART a GRANTED I PART
ha he
in o s s s
N
nd
N
wih l a t ame t Compli t Pli ifs la e d t Compl ntt clrf t c us sof
t e ve o
nd he
a n . antf hal m
he
ai o a iy he a e

a to e ttigt P an ift ij n tv rle b n l e t a Au us 8. 01 Th M oin t
ci n n i n he litf o nu cie eif y o a r h n g t 2 3. e t o
l
o
St i i D EN I .
r ke s
ED
1 BA CK G RO U D
.

Pl ntf, s wa M ovi a St a l , o ' c
ai ifFa t y
ng nd or ge,nc.am ng ompa fl s ta i t f nda ,
ny, ed ui gans De e nt
Fr ncic J eEgui ze Uga t isf me e pl e. e e
a s o os
gtr n
re, t or r m oye
f ndanti a l d t ha i ta e a
s lege o ve niit d n

unlwf ta froft prmay busne sdoman n e (at ymovi com)a y fom t
a ul rnse
he i r
i s
i
fswa
ng.
wa r he

(

'

'
j
.
!

9
#

i
;

(

c
ompa a i o t ha ofa t r pa t hosi co pa
ny nd nt he nds
hid- ry tng
ny. Pl ntf a s a lgesDe e nt
ai if l o le
f nda
i onne c i nt t tt c pa was g ng ou of b i s s ol or w ihhe d com pa ke ,
nf
d le s ha he om ny
oi
t
nes ; t e
t l
ny ys

ve ce(r c tr ,docume s e o er or ,a pa s ds( ma ngpa me f a y
hil tu k) ies
nt, mplye ec ds nd swor de ndi y nt or n

rtr o te ei ms; e Plitf scin c n a t, m ly e , n oh r o reayif r t n
eu n fh s t )usd an if le t o tcse o e s a d te pr p itr n o mai
e
o
f hi own pe s lga n;a fl afa e ar l e ton be foft c
or s
r ona i nd ied r udul nt mua por
hal he ompa wih t
ny t he

Flrd S c ea yofS ae TheCo an s t si f rc u t: l ij ci er l f ru n t
o ia e rtr
tt.
mplit omd n o o n s () nun tv ei pu s a t o
e
Dee ntsalge vi ai ofCha e 817. Fl i Stt e ,(1 t tousi erfrnc (1)
fnda ' le d olton
ptr 155, ord auts 1) ori nt eee e,11

ij n t erle rg r i gt ewe ied man , n (V c n eso
n u ci eif e ad n h bst o is a d l o v rin.
v
De e ntfl d a moton t dim is ort srk . As t Count1 De e nta g st t
f nda ie
i o s s
o ti
o
, f nda r ue ha
Cha e 81 1 Fl r da St t es doesnotc ea e a pr v t ,c vi ca e ofa ton and t tPl ntf
pt r 7. 55, o i
a ut ,
r t
i e i l us
ci
ha ai i f

i notpa toft saut si e d pr e t d c a s Ast Count l,11 a 1 De e nta g s
s
r he t t e' nt nde ot c e l s .
s 1 1, nd V, f nda r ue
Pl ntf sa lga i do no s fcinty sat ac us ofaci n upon whih r i c n be g a e
ai if le tons
t ufi e l t e a e
to
c elef a
r nt d.
l .STAN D AR D O F
I

t s vi a m o i t dim is pl i if
% ur ve
To
ton o s s , antfs

VI W
E

us do m or t n m e ey sa e lga
t
e ha
rl tt e l

co l i s i t adpl i if m us E le s e s ii f c ua ba i f rt ec us onsorf c
nc us ons ' ns e
'
a ntf s
t s l ge om pec t a t l s s o hos oncl i
a
ae

dimis oft i cli . Jac so v Bel h Teec .372F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.
s sal her ams' k n . lsout l om ,
'
3d 250, 263 1 t r 2004)
.
W he r lngon amotont dimis acour m us vi t e c
n ui
i o s s,
t t ew
ompl i i t lg m os f vor bl t
ant n he i ht t a a e o
t pli ifa a ce t pl ntf swe lpl de f t a t e Se StJos ph'Ho p.I . . p.
he a ntf nd c pt he ai if l- ea d acs nl. e . e s s , nc v Hos

Cop. fAm. 7 5 F.d 9 ,9 3 ( 1h Ci.1 8 ) Thi tn t h we r d e no a pyt lg l
r o
, 9 2 48 5 1 t r 9 6 .
e e, o ve, o s t p l o e a
co us ons Se As of v I ,1 S.Ct 1
ncl i . e hcr . t . qbal 29
. 937, 949 (
2009) M or r dl hie lga
.
eove, twl l e l
co us ons c n pr de t f n ewor of a c pl nt t y m us be s
ncl i
a
ovi he r m
k
om a , he
t
uppored b f c ua
t y at l

alg to s'I a 1 5 .Th s 'qa t a alg to smu t ee o g t r iearg torle a o e
l ain . d t 9 0 o e ' cu l le ain
e
'
l
b n u h o as ih t eif b v
-

2-

t

)
E

(

'

'
)
)
ë
!
@
:

q

l
(

h pec a i e
he s
i ha 1 he
ai ' le tons r r ' l l
s
t e s ultve lvelon t as umpton t ta loft c mpl nt al ga i a e tue.' BelAt.

Cop.v Twombl 550U. 544,545 ( ) I s t t c ai mus no me ey algea
r .
y,
S.
2007 . n hor he ompl nt t t r l le
m ic
s onduc , m us de onsr t t tt plade i e i e t r le .SeeI ,1 S. . t1
tbut t m tae ha he e r s ntt d o ei f
qbal 29 Ct a 950.

11 COUNT I(
1.
VIOLATI OF 817. ,FLORI STATUTES)
ON
15
DA
I Count1 Pl i ifalege t tDe e ntsc uc i ma ng i pr rflngswih t
n
, antf l s ha f nda ' on t n ki m ope ii
t he

Flrd S c eayo S aeviltsCh pe 8 7.5 , o d S au e , n rq e t a ij n to t
o i a e r tr f tt oae a tr 1 1 5 Flr a ttts a d e u ss n n u cin o
r tf t a lge mic
eciy he le d s onduc a co r c t r c d.Pl ntf a lgest ti i t vi tm ofal ed
t nd r e t he e or
a if le ha t s he ci
leg
crmi a tviy and t tc r ton oft Def nda ' le d m itlngswoul s r t publc
i nal c i t
ha oreci
he e nts lge
sii
d e ve he
i
i t r ti s uc as i e ala,fa ha be n comm itd upon t Fl i Depm m e ofStt
n e es na m h , ntr i r ud s e
t
he orda
nt
a e.

Co n l o s o saeacam f rij n tv rle s an if o s o ie tf a t e lig
u t d e n t tt li o nu cie eif Plitf d e n td n iy n md ryn
ca e ofa ton e ilng Pl i ift t sr m e I Pl i tf sRe pons t D e e ntsM oto t
us
c i ntti
a ntf o hi e dy. n a if
s
e o f nda '
in o

Dimis Pli ifsa e i i nots ki da a sf vi l to oft saut ,e t
s s , antf t t s t s
ee ng m ge or ai n he t t e ven hough Coun I
t
i e ildûvi a i ofCha e 81 1 Fl i St t e . I isRe pons , ai ifsa e i ç s
s ntte t olton
pt r 7. 55, orda aut ' n t s
'
e Pl ntf t t s td
doe

n ts e a yhn oh rta ij n tv rle a d ta litf s e st o n lw'ijmcie
o e k n tig te h n n u cie eif' n h t an if e k t mmo a 'nt tv
c
rle rltn t De e d n ' mic nd t Ho v r t caao yj d me t a dijmcin ae
eif eaig o fn a ts s o uc. we e, $ lr tr u g n s n nt to s r
d
eq t bl r m e es notc us ofa ton. pli tf mus r vai on a underyi cai i or rt
uia e e di ,
a es c i A a n if t e l n
l ng l m n de o
bee il t et rf m ofr i . Fengol Bu r o. - 0539- V,
ntted o ihe or
elef' i dv. dne , 08 8
'
C1 2008W L 461
0031 *
,2

( D. a. t 1 zoo8lctngBuc Ame ianAilne I , F. 29, n. ( tCi. ).
S. Fl Oc . 0,
tii
kv. rc ri s nc.476 3d 33 3 1s r2007 )

( n mo ino s if ret e ap ei n r o p r n n ijmcinmu t ba e u nac u eo
W y to r ut o ih r r l ay r ema e tn t to s be s d po a s f
mi
a ton, uc a a c tt i lvi aton, t es s ,ora nui a e. r i no s h t ng asa s t
c i s h s ons iutona ol i a r pa s
s nc The e s
uc hi
ui

f ra ta iin lij nci n i te a src.Fo a ta i o a ij n to t b e e t o eial
o r dto a nu to n h b ta t r r dt n l nu cin o e v n he rtc l
y
a l bl , pl i ifm us be a et a tc a e a ba i f r e i ft tw oul w ihs a s nzi unde
vaia e a a ntf
t bl o ri ul t
s s o le ha
d t t nd c tny
r
-

3-

'

'
q
q
E

F dR. VP. 2b () f izet saeacaml'WDl -l . tdstts myCopso gn es
e . Ci. 1 ()6 (alr o tt li . l
t
' l
Uni ae Ar
e
r fEn ie r ,
4 4F.d1 1 ,1 2 ( 1hCi. oo lctn Klyv UntdHe lh o p, n . 7 F.d1 9 , 0 7
2 3 1 7 1 7 1 t rz st i g a . i
i
a tgr u I c 3 6 3 0 2 1 9
( 1hCi.0 4) P an if s n ndteCo lit o d niyac us o a to t e Flrd o
1 t r2 0 ). litf mu t me h mp an t e tf a e f cin md r o ia r
fd r la gvn rs t t scam f rij n tv r l f
e ea 1w iig ie o hi li o n u ci e ei .
e
Ac r ngl Countloft Compl i i DI I SED wih l a t n e
co di y,
he
ant s SM
t e ve o m nd.

I COUNT 1 (
V.
1 TORTI
OUSI ERFERENCE)
Topr vai o acl m oft tousi e f r nc wih busne sr a i hi t rFl i lw ,
e l n ai
ori nt re e e t
i s eltons p mde orda a

apli ifmus etbls f ee nt:()t e se fabusnes r ai hi notne esaiy
antf t sa ih our lme s 1 he xitnce
i s eltons p,
c s rl

e i e c db a e fr e bl c n rc;2 k o e g o t r lto s i o t ep r o t d fn a t
v d n e y n n oc a e o ta t( ) n wld e fh eain hp n h a t fhe ee d n;
( ) nitni n l ndu j siiditree c wihterl ins i b t ed fn a ta () ma e
3 a n e to a a n u tfe n efrn e t h e o h p y h e e d n ; nd 4 da g
t t pli ifa ar ul oft br a h oft r l tons .Pikigt v Unie r i s 11 F.
o he antf s es t he e c
he e ai hi
l n on . t dAilne , 2 3d

1 3 ,1 4 ( 1h Ci. 9 7 (i n 7 Ha rsY u g t s o .v Ma q et Elcr nis 9 F.d
5 2 5 0 1 t r 1 9 )ct g r r i o n f s c . r u te e to c , 31 2
i
81 , 2 - 6( 1h Ci.1 91.To t u itree c wi ac nr c a dtriusitree ewi
6 8 5 2 1 t r 9 ) ri s ne frn e t o ta t n o t n efrnc t
o
o
h
a busne sr l tons p a e ba ialy t s m eca e of c i f The o y m aeraldif r nc
i s e ai hi r sc l he a
us
ton. #.
nl t i fe e e
a
ppea st be t ti one t r i a c r cta i t ot rt r i onl a bus nes r a i hi I
r o ha n
he e s onta nd n he h he e s y
i s el tons p. d.

l Co I, ai ifa lgesDe e ntha busn s r ltons ps bot c r cua a by
n unt I Pl ntf le
f nda
s i s ea i hi , h onta t l nd
vit ofPl ntf stest t c
rue
ai if i o he omm uniy. Pl i ifaleg Def nda ,wih knowl dge oft
t
antf
es e nt t
e
he
r ai ns ps i e i l i e f r d wih t r l tons s ca i t Pl ntf dn a s Ea le
elto hi , ntntonaly nt re e t he e ai hi , usng he ai if m ge . rir
i t Compl i , hePl ntf a lgesDe e
n he
ant t
ai if le
f ndanti tae a unaut i e ta f roft prm a y
nii t n
horz d r ns e
he i r
bus nes dom a n na ea a f om Pl ntf , nf m ed c i t t com pa w a goi out bus ne s
i s
i m w yr
ai i f i or
le s he
ny s ng of i s ,

us dPl ntf sci c acsf pe s na g n, ndund rookot ra tonsam e a unde mi ng
e ai if lent ont t or r o l ai a
t
he c i i d t
r ni
orde toyi Pl i if s bus nes ope a i .
s r ng a ntf
i s r tons
-

4-

t

)

.

è

'

)
;
.
)
y
!

#
è

l
(

Conta y t De e ntsas e ton, he eal ga i sa enotl l pl t ' Pli ifha s t
r r o f nda ' s ri t s le to r
t er ae.' a ntf s e
boi
f t s tcint f cua aleg tons t sa e a cli f r t tous i ere e
orh ufi e a t l l a i
o tt
am
ori
nt f r nce wih a busnes
t
i s
r ai ns p a orc r c .
elto hi nd/ onta t
Ac or ngl Pl ntf sM oton t Dimisi D
c di y, ai if
i o s s s

I a t Count1 oft Compl i .
ED s o
1 he
ant

V.COUNT II(
l TEM POM RY AND I
NJUNCTI E RELI W EBSI DOM AI
EFTE
NS)

To saea cam f rtmpo ay ij n t e rle a pan ifmu talg ( )a s b tn il
tt li o e rr nu ci eif litf s le e 1 u sa ta
v
lk l o dof u c s o t emeis ( ) s bsa ta tr a o irp rbl ij r it ij n to wee
iei o s c e s n h rt;2 a u tnilh e t f re aa e nu y fhe n u ci n r
h

n tg a td ( )t t h tr ae e ij r t t epan i so t ihsteh r a ij n to ma
o r ne ; 3 ha t e h e tn d n u y o h litf uweg h a m n nu cin y
c us ted fn a t a d( ta g a t teij n to o l n t is r et p bl itr s.S e
a e h ee d n; n 4)h t rni h n u cin u d o d se v he u i n ee t e
ng
c
eg. e Stau sandCo. Sunrs I enatonalTr n ,nc.51F. 982, ( 1hCi.1 )
. L vi r s
v. ie ntr i
adi I ,
3d
985 1 t r 995 .

I Co n 11Plitf se sa ij n to r ltn t tealg dwr ng u mia p o rain
n u t 1, an if e k n n u cin eaig o h l e o f l sp r p it
e
o
ofwe ie dom an nnme be ongi t t Pli if P ai ifalege t Def nda unlwf l
bst
i
s l ng o he antf.
ntf l s he
e nt a uly
ta f re isdomai nn t at r pa t hosi s r e t r by s ve el hanni t Pl n if
r nse r d t
n me o hid ry tng e vi , he e e r y
ng he aitf.
Pl i ifa l ge he ha no a qua e r m e a l , na uc asonl t i m e a e ta f roft
a ntf le s
s
de t e dy t aw i s h
y he m di t r ns e
he

d mann meb c t Plitf c na e t ut eij r .A dto al , an ifalg sa ij n t n
o i a a k o an if a v r ftl n u y
r
i n ly Plitf le e n nu ci
i
o
woul s r t publci e es a De e nti m ir pr e i Pl i ifsbusnes t t publc.
d e ve he
i nt r t s f nda s s e e ntng antf
i s o he
i
Con r r t D e e
t a y o f ndan ' a s ton,Pl ntf does no ne t a l ge w he t dom a n na esw e e
t s s eri
ai if
t
o le
n he
i m
r

al ge yt a uly ta f red o how t y wer a qui d.Pl i ifma notha a c st t s
le dl mlwf l r nse r r
he
e c r
antf y
ve c es o he e
f c sw ihouta o
at t
n pport iy f r di c r
tm t o s ove y.

Plitf s le ain d n t aif h frt lme te u rdf rnun tv r l fs bsa ta
anif alg to s o o s tsyt e see rq ie o ij cie ei :u tnil
e
lkelhood ofs ce s on t m e is A lhough Pl i i f le s a s t ntallke i
i i
uc s
he rt . t
a ntf l ge ubsa i i lhood ofs c s
uc es

on t me isasPli ifi t al ge s e l wf o
he rt
a ntf s he le d ol a ul
-

5
-

roft dom an na e,Pl i iff l t
he
i m
a ntf ais o

)

l

i

l

'

T
(
'
è
(

(
r
.
'
E
F

)
)
E

l
)

i e iyt ca e ofaci n upon whih hei lkel t s c e Asi coun 1 Pl i ifdoesno
d ntf he us
to
c
s i y o ce d
n
t , antf
t
.

ie tf a t e lig c us ofa to e t ln Plit t ter me yofij n tv r l f S e
d niy n md ryn a e ci n ni i g an i o h e d
t
nu cie ei . e
e
Fengol 2008W L 461
i d,
0031a W Al
t zk abama, F. a 1 Pl i ifm us a
424 3d t 27. antf
t mendt Compli
he
ant

t ie tf tec u eo a to u d rFlrd o fd r l w gvngrs t t scam f rij n t e
o d n iy h a s f cin n e o ia r e ea l ii ie o hi li o n u ci
v
r i .
elef

Ac or ngl Cot lIi DI I
c di y, mt I s SM SSED wih la t a e
t e v o m nd.

VI COUNT I (
.
V CONV RSI
ON)
Tosaeacli f conveson, pl ntf mus a e t t ( )heha arghtt t pr ry;
tt am or
ri a ai if t l ge ha : 1
s i o he ope t
( heha a a olt rg t t i
2)
s n bs ue iht o he mmedit posesi ft pr ry;()hema adema f
ae s son he ope t 3
de
nd or
posesi oft pr t a ( t dee nt ongf l a sl dc r orowne s pove t
s son he opery; nd 4)he fnda wr u y stme ontol
rhi rhe
pr ry. As ntum Cor v. Te r m ar Nor h Am e a I . N o. 1
ope t
ce i
p.
re k
t
rl , nc ,
0-2090&- V , 2011 W L
CI

1
233256,*3( D. a. ac 30,2011.
S. Fl M rh
)
I Count I Pl ntf a lge t t Def nda e m a nty de i d i of is pr ry,
n
V, ai if le s ha
e nt r ne l prve t
t ope t

icu ig b tn tl tdt isitr e d man n me e s v hce (r c )trs c so rlss
n ldn u o i e o t n en t o i n , y , e il tu k ie , u t me it,
mi
pa s ds a c a t .Pl ntf a lgest sde i t n i i onsse wih Pli ifss ea
s wor , nd ont c s ai if le hi prva i s nc it nt t antf ol nd
e usve owne s p ove t na e pr ry a c iut s a il lt f a c
xcl i
rhi
r he m d ope t nd ons t e n lega he t nd onveri n of
so
Pli ifspr t
antf
opery.
Cont a y t D e e nts a s r i t s alega o a e not ç l r pl t ' Pl ntf has
r l o f nda ' s e ton, he e l t ns r
t e a e.' ai if
boi

al ge s fce f c ua al ga i t sa eacli f onve son.
le d ufi int a t l le tons o t t
am or
ri
A c or ngl De enda ' M o i t D i m i s i EN I ast CountI oft Com pl nt
c di y, f
nt s ton o s s s
ED
o
V
he
ai .
V I .M O TI N TO S R I E
I
O
K

Be us t Co tdoe nottnd a oft ma t i Pli ifsCompl i t ber dundan ,
ca e he ur
s
s ny he ter n antf
ant o e
t
I

6-

-

y

'

t
'

t
.
)
)
'
j
l
)

i ae i , i pe tne , s andaous De e ntsM o i t Sti i DENI
mm tral m ri nt or c
l , f nda '
on o rke s
ED.

og m

DONE AN D ORDERED i Cha be sa M i mi Fl i t W p da ofJ y,201
n m r t a , orda, hi
y ul
3.

FE E
O A. O
M
UN TED STA T DI
STRI J D GE
CT U

Copi spr ded t
e ovi o:
Couns lofRe r
e
co d

I

I
I

1

)
)

.

-

7-

.

.

(