Ocean Cay, LTD v. Alebamon Marine Services, L.L.C. et al

Filing 17

ORDER denying 5 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 12/17/2014. (whl)

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Ca eN u be : 1 61 CI M ORENO
s m r 4- 775- V-

OCEAN CAY LTD.
,
Pli if
antf,

ALEBAM ON M ARI SERVI
NE
CES,LLC,a
nd
M A TT GREEN ,
De e nt.
f nda s
/
O R DER D ENY I G D EFEN DA N T' M O TI N TO D I I
N
S
O
SM SS

THI CAUSE c
S
amebe or t Cour upon De e ntAl ba on M a i Se vce , LLC'
f e he
t
f nda
e m
rne r i s
S

moi nt d s s Plit fOc a Ca LTD' Co litfrlc o p ro lu idcin.
to o imis ani e n y
f
S mp an o a k f es na j rs ito
THE COURT has c i e t m o i a t pe tne pori of t r or , a
onsder d he ton nd he ri nt tons he ec d nd
be ng ot m i e f l advi e i t pr m i e ,i i
i
ht s uly
s d n he e s s t s

ADJUDGED t tt moton i DENI .Ass tf t bel Fl i ' l a m saut
ha he
i s
ED
e orh ow, orda s ong- r t t e

c n e sj rs ito o ti Co r t e tran Oc a Ca scamsa an tAlb mo ,s e Fl.
o f r u idcin n h s u t o ne ti e n y' li g i s e n n e a

S a. 4 .9 , n t Co r' e rieo j rs ito d e n to fn t eDu P o e sClu eo
tt j 8 1 3 a d he u ts xecs f u id cin o s o fe d h e r c s a s f
t Co tt i U. Cons . m e XI
he nsiuton. S.
t a nd. V.

I t s Cas Oc a Ca ( Ba min c
n hi e, e n y a ha a ompa alge t tAlba
ny) le s ha e mon (n Alba
a a ma
c
ompa br a hed a maii c r c f t pur has ofadec bage. Alba beive
ny) e c
rtme onta t or he c e
k r
e mon le s

t a t sCo r d e n th v j rs ito t e tran a a to a ans i b c u e 1 tePa t s
h t hi u t o s o a e u idcin o n e ti n cin g i t t e a s : ) h ri
e
a enotFl i rsde s 2)t diput i ve t s l ofave s l t i t Bahmnast t
r
orda e i nt; he s e nvol s he ae
sel ocaed n he
ha
wa t bedei rd i Louiina;a 3)t
so
lvee n
sa nd hough t c r ti l saFl i f u s lci
he ontac ncude
orda orm ee ton
e a e, Ocea Ca Sc e l d' t cl us by r e lng t ba ge afe t s t a a ton f l
l us
n y % anc le ' he a e
es li he r
t r hi r ns c i el

t oug Oc a Ca r s
hr h. e n y e ponds t t i a ton t t Pari s f u s l ton clus - t s
ha- n ddii o he te ' or m eec i
a e hi

Co r h sj rs ito t e tran i camsb c u e p y n o t e c nr c wa t b ma e
u t a uidcin o n e ti t li e a s a me t n h o ta t s o e d
s
i o a Fl i ba ac ount Fort f rhc i r s ns t Cour a e t tt l to of
nt
orda nk c .
he o t om ng ea o , he
t gr es ha he ocai n

p y n a dt ef r m s lcinca s c nfr j rs ito o teCo r.
a me t n h o u ee to lu e o es u id cin n h u t
Th Co r ma e e cs p ro a j rs cint t ee tn a t rz db Flrd 1w a d
e u t y x r ie es n l u idito o h xe t uho ie y o ia a n
t t e e alowe by t Consiuton. See St
o he xt nt l d
he
tt i
ubbs v Wyndham Nas au Re or trCr t
.
s
s t î ysal

Pal Casi 447F. 1
ace
no,
3d 357,1 ( 1hCi.2006) W ih r pec t Flrdal Oc n Ca
360 1 t r
. t es t o o i aw, ea y

drcst eCo r t Flrd ' ln am sau e b wh c t Co r ma e e cs j rs ito o e
ie t h u to o i as o g-r ttt , y ih he u t y x r ie u id cin v r
a a o f rd b ra hn a c n rc i t i sat b fiig t p ro m a t rq ie b te
n din o i le c ig o ta t n hs tt y al o e f r cs e ur d y h
l
n
c nrc t b p ro me i t ssae' eFl.S a.j4 1 3 1( ) Ac o dn t t eFlrd
o ta t o e e fr d n hi tt.
'Se a tt 8.9 ( )g . c r ig o h o ia
DititCo r o Ap e l,Sfalr t pa ac nrcu ld b wh r pa me ti d et b ma e
src u t f p as t j i e o y o ta ta e t ee y n s u o e d
g u
i Fl i i s fce t s tsy Fl i ' l a pr son t t r e s t co r c ua a t
n orda s ufi int o a if orda s ong- nn ovii ha ef r o nta t l c s
deq r d't be per onne i Fl i .' Gl
r uie o
f
d n or da ' obalSat lie Comm uni i n Co.v Sudlne 8 So.
e lt
cato
.
i , 49

2d466,468( a Dit Ct App.2003) Hee,Oce Ca alege t tAlba fie t makea
F1. s. .
. r
an y l s ha e mon ald o
pa e i t a Fl i ba ac ount t r by s ts yi Fl i sl a m s a ut
ym nt n o
or da nk c
, he e a i f ng orda' ong- r t t e.

Th Co r n x c nsd r wheh r te e e cs o j rs it n d fe dg) ta iin l
e u t e t o ie s te h x rie f u idci s fn s r dto a
o o
n to so fi p a a d s bsa ta j sie'i c nrve to o t e Du Pr c s Clu e S e
o in f ar ly n u tnil u tc ' n o ta ni n f h e o e s a s . e
I e natonalShoeCo.v Was ngt 326U. 31 31 ( 945 ( ttonsomitd) Whiet
ntr i
. hi on,
S. 0, 6 1 ) quoai
te . l he
Pate 'fr m s eci caus (tndi ao )doe notstsy Fl i sl am sat e,se
ris o u el ton l e sa ng lne s
aif orda' ong-r t ut e

Alx n e Pr u f o Co Wo l He d u re sv T a r 8 7F.d91 9 0 ( 1hCi.1 8 )t e
e a d r o do t . rd a q a tr . h ye , 7 2 2, 2 1 t r 9 9 ,h
f um s l to cl us doe s ts y t Due Pr es pr oft Cour ' 'na ys s
or
e ec i n a e s a i f he
oc s ong he
tsa l i :

( e a e t e p ro a j rs ito r q ie n i a wav be rg t t r ae a
Blc us h es n l u id cin e urme t s
ia l ih , hee r
va i t of l l ar a m e s by w hi h a ltgant m a gi e e s or i ple
re y
ega r nge nt
c
ii
y ve xpr s
m id

c n e tt tep ro l u id ci noft c u t F re mpl,p riulry i t e
o s n o h e s na j rs ito
he o r. o xa e a t al n h
c
-

2-

c me cil c e , pa te feq nty si a e i a nce t s i t i
om r a ont xt ris r ue l tpult n dva
o ubm t her

c n rv risf rr s l to wi n apa t ua j rs ito W hee s c f r mo to e se o e o ui n t
hi
ri lr u idcin.
c
r u h ou
s l ton pr sonsha bee obt i t ough fe l neg it d a ee
eeci
ovii
ve n aned hr
r e y ota e gr ment a
s nd

aen tu e s n bl a d u j s,here oc me t e n t fe d d ep o e s
r o nra o a e n nu t t i nfr e n do s o o fn u r c s .
Bu ge Kig Cor
r r n
p.

Rud e c , 471 U. 462, 473 n.4 ( 985) (nenal ciai a
z wiz
S.
1 1
itr
ttons nd

quot i omit .ThePate 'f m s lci clus i t es i yvai a e ore bl
atons ted)
ris onz ee ton a e s s umptvel ld nd nf c a e
pr
unl st pl n ifm a a çtong s
es he aitf kes sr
howi t te or e e woul be unf i orunr as bl
ng' ha nf c m nt
d
ar
e ona e

unde t cic tnc . Kr nke v Ke z rI 1Hot sLt ,5 F. 1 1 1( 1h Ci.
r he rumsa es' e l . r ne nt
'
el d. 79 3d 279, 28 1 t r
2009)(uotng Car v Cr s Li s I .v Shut,499U. 585,593 ( 991) I or rt
q i
nial uie ne , nc . e
S.
-95 1 ). n de o
ove co et pr s pton ofva i t Al ba on mus dom or t n de onsr t t tOc n Ca
r m he e um i
ldiy, e m
t
e ha m ta e ha ea y
woul no ot r s s ts y Fl i s l a m saut ;Alba
d t he wie a if orda' ong- r t t e e mon mus pr ve t tisf
t o ha t onna i
ton
wa i e by fa orove r a hi ort te o c m e oft caus woul con r ve publc
s nduc d
r ud
r e c ng, ha nf r e nt he l e
d ta ne
i
polc Seei The Cour i una r ofcr umsanc t tt twoul c s doubton t vai t
i y.
d.
t s wa e ic t es ha ha
d at
he ldiy
oft Pari 'f um s l to clus l Be a eAl m on feey s l c e t sf um t r s ve
he tes or
eeci n a e. c us eba
r l e e t d hi or o e ol

a1d s ue aii fo isc n rc wi Oc a Ca ,t Co r' e rie o j rs ito d e
l ip ts rsng r m t o ta t t e n y he u ts xecs f u idcin o s
h

n t fe dta iin l oinso f i pa a ds b tn il u tc .
o o fn rdto a n to f ar ly n u sa ta j sie

1Albnmon' a glme t Oc n Ca i a le 't contac does notafe tt vai t of
e
s r l nt hat ea
y k nce ld' he
c
r t
f c he ldiy
t f r m s l c i c a e. Thi Co tha he d t t f u s e ton c a es a e s ver bl a
he o u e e ton l us
s ur s l ha or m el c i l us r e a e nd

rman i ef c u o b e c S eS h v Ba k r L@ d Ca .Co, .1 - 1 4 - V, 01
e i n fe t p n ra h. e ac s . n es
r s .No 18 3 4 CI 2 2
W L 1 0 0 3 a * ( D. a M a 2 , 01 )(( f r m s lcin ca s o rtsa as p rt
9 0 3 , t 2 S. Fl. y 4 2 2 :A) o u ee t lu e peae s e aae
ç
o
c r c t ti s ve a e f om t ag e m e i whi h i i c a ne and i e or a e a l
ont a t ha s e r bl r he r e nt n
c t s ont i d
s nf ce bl , s ong

ast f m s lci caus is fwasno i l i t c rc be us offa ') Tohol
he onz ee ton l e tel
t ncuded n he onta t ca e rud. .
'
d

o her s w oul nuliy f um s l cton cl us upon c r c ua di put - pr i el w he t r
t wi e
d lf or
ee i
a es
ont a t l s e
ec s y
n hei
t r s woul t ke ef e t
em
da
fc.
3-

#

/

DONEANDORDE Di ChmbraMimiFoiatv- dyo Dee e,04
RE n a est a , lrd,h a f cmbr2 1.
i
.

:7
!

,
.

.' ,.. .'''
7
! ' ', .''
J

,.
v.

-

.

-.- - ;:.
;u
..
.-

.

-

4

.

--

.. e
.- -

1.''*
.,**
.'

.A.7
.-

FEW I A.M ORENO
CO
UQ TED STATESDI CT J
STRI UDGE
Copispr de t
e ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d

-

4-