Rhein et al v. Kevelson et al

Filing 18

ORDER denying 17 Motion for Sanctions. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 12/10/2014. (ar2)

U NITED STATES D I
STRI C OURT
CT
SOUTHERN D ISTRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
Cas N o. 61830- V- TZ
e
14CI SEI
LI RH EI and
SA
N
SAM M Y RH EI ,
N

Pl ntfs
ai if ,
RO CH ELLE KEVELSON ,
TI
KVAH LYO N S,and

J
OYCE GENAUER,
Def
endant
s.

/

O RDER D ENYI D EFENDANTS'M OTI FOR SANCTI
NG
ON
ONS
Thi c r
s ase evol s ar
ve ound an i r t e i
nt ac abl nhert nc diput i s at c t
ia e s e n t e our

bet
ween Defnda sand t rsit J Sugar who i Pl ntf LiaRhen' m ot
e nt
hei ser udy
,
s ai if s
i s her
.

Pl ntfsar notpary t t s at c tltgaton, butt y c ns nt d t j n c ran
ai if e
t o he t e- our ii i
he o e e o oi e t i
s tl m e agr m ent and ar bound t r .
e te nt ee
s
e
he eby

Beor s pa s d a y l leSt r ( f nda s m o he a LiaRhen'
f e he s e wa , del e n Dee nt' t r nd s
is

gr ndmot r ta f re $ 5 ,0 t a a c untj ntyhed byJ Suga a Lia
a
he ) r nse r d 3 00 0 o n c o oi l l
udy
r nd s
Rhe n.On M a 6,201 t s at c tdec ar t tans e voi a or ed t f
i
y
4, he t e our
l ed hat r f r d nd der he unds

r ur d t t es at D e enda ss equenty s Pl ntfsa l t t eat ni t s
et ne o he t e. f
nt ubs
l ent ai if eter hr e ng o ue
f ar ur oft ef
or et n
hos unds and Pl ntfsfl t sac i f a decl aton t
,
ai if ied hi ton or
ar i hat

Def nda sw er tm e- r f om brngi s h al s t On N ovem ber26,2014,t
e nt
e i bar ed r
i ng uc aw ui.
he
Cour gr ed Def ndant 'm oton t di m i s es enta l on gr
t ant
e
s
i o s s , s i ly
oundst t s c ew as
hat hi as
aleady be or t s at c t ( 1 q
r
f e he t e our . DE- 5.

I xplc y,Def
ne i abl
endant have now r fl t rm oton t dim i s sm pl w ih
s
e-ied hei
i o s s, i y t
a ne tt e:as a 'm oton f s
w il
' i or anctons ''hemo i n ma snoa tmptt j tf
i . 'l
'
to ke
te
o usiy

s tons- i sm pl dr t l
anc i
t i y ops he egals andar f s tonsi o a al os- or f t
d or anc i
nt n m tw d-or
w or c
d opy- s e f om t m oton t dim i s ( mpa eDee nt' oto f r
pa t r
he
i o s s . Co r f nda s m in o

s nci ( 1 1wih De e nt' o i n t dim is( 6 .Co e di no e n
a tons DE- 7 t fnda s m to o s s DE- J) uns l d t ve
updat t m oton t i ca e t t Cour had a r ady dim i s t cas i f t
e he
i o ndi t hat he
t
le
s s ed he e- n ac ,
t m oton s ilas f t Com pl ntt be di m is .
he
i tl ks or he
ai o
s s ed

Att N ovem ber2 2 4 hea i t l w yer w er r i
he
5, 01
rng, he a
s
e em nded t t y ha a
hat he ve

dut t do m or t sm pl t ans at t rci nt 'w or ti tnc si o l es .
y o
e han i y r l e hei le s
s ns i t nt egal e
Pari ul l i t c e ofa f m iy diput ,l yer need fr tand f em os t be
tc ary n he ont xt
a l s e aw s
is
or
to

bo h ofie so t c ur a c un eo st t i cint, j tad c t s I bot
t fc r f he o t nd o s lr o he r l s not us vo a e .n h
e
capactest y ar r ponsbl f ke ng ltgaton f us on r ol ng and a di
ii he e es
i e or epi ii i oc ed
es vi
voi ng
c lc w ihi t s rtofRul 1. hiei i cl t t e i no l l tbet ee t
onfi t t n he pii
e W l t s ear hat her s ove os w n he

pa te ,as nci mo i n t tdo snot ve a t mptt jitf s nci nsdo sno
ri s a tons to ha e
e n te
o tsiy a to
e t
f clt t t 'us,s e ,a i x nsvede e mi to o e r a to a
a iiae he ' t pe dy nd ne pe i t r nai n f ve y ci n nd
j
pr eedi ' Fed.R.Ci P.1.
oc ng.'
v.

Fo t r a onssa e i t Or rGr nt M oton t Dim isg 1 ) t
r he e s t t d n he de a i
ng i o s s DE- 5, he
Cour w ilnote er ai any f t flngsi t sm ater The ef e i i
t l
nt t n
ur her ii n hi
t . r or t s
ORDERED t t
ha

Dee nt '' o i f Sa to ' ( 1 1i DENI
fnda s ' ton or nci ns' DE- 7 s
M
ED.
DONE AND ORDERED i M i iFl i ,t s /$ da ofDec
n am , orda hi
ember 2014.
,
N

R

PA TRI A A.SEI
CI
TZ

UN I STATESDI CT J
TED
STRI UDGE