Herazo et al v. Whole Foods Market, Inc.

Filing 45

ORDER Granting in Part Motion to Dismiss 29 and ORDER Staying and Placing Case in Civil Suspense File. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 7/23/2015. (mmd)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT FO R TH E
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
Cas N um be 14e
r: 61909- V - O REN O
CI M
M A m o HEn zo

Y AN ERI A LM ON TE ,
S

DE E EC AR &KE R AB,
NIL H X
NAN AS I
Pli if ,
antfs
VS.

W H OLE FO OD S M A RK ET,l C.
N ,

De e nt
f nda .
/

ORDER GRANTI I PART M OTI N TO DI I AND ORDER STAYI AND
NG N
O
SM SS
NG
PLA CI CA SE I C I I SU SPEN SE FI
NG
N V L
LE
Pli if m ant i t tDef ntW hol FoodsM a ke ,I us de ptvel be sont i
antfs i an ha
enda
e
r t nc. ed ce i a l
her
home t cpr ucs
opa hi od t.Due t t e dec ptve lbel,Pli if fl at e c
o hes
e i a s a ntfs ied hr e- ountc
ompli tf
a n or

t u t n ih n , i lto o teF o iaDe e tvea dUnfiTr d Prcie Ac, n n gie t
mj s e rc me tav oain fh lrd c p i n
ar a e a tc s ta d e lg n
m ir pr s ntton.Fede a 1w m a t s t t De enda i ude l l on t i homeo t c
se e e ai
rl a
nda e ha
f nt ncl
abe s
her
pahi
pr
oduc spr di t i i c tonsf rus - t s a ed pur e oft 1 w i t ac e unior iy
t ovi ng he r ndi a i
o e he t t
pos
he a s o hi ve f m t

i rgultonsove nonprs rptondr . U. C.j3791 TheFooda Dr gAdmi srtoni
n e ai
r
e ci i ugs 21 S.
.
.
nd u
nitai s
c r edwih ove sghto rlbei ofhomeo t cpr t .I viw o t sr ult y s he ,
ha g
t
r i ve a lng
pahi oduc s n e f hi eg a or c me

t eCo r a tisfo a j iaigti c s u e t ep i r j rs ito a i le r e to
h u tbsan r m dudc tn h s a e nd rh rma y u idcin nd mp idp e mp in
d crn s Th Co r as fnd Pli t f lc sa dngt s f rij ci er l f n t er n u t
o tie . e u t lo i s ani s a k tn i o ue o nun tv ei a d h iu j s
f
e
en i hm en c a m c nnots v ve ast r i a a qua e l lr m e
rc
t li a
ur i
he e s n de t ega e dy.

THI CAUSEc mebeor heCourupont Dee ntsM oi oDimis( E. 29)
S
a
f et
t
he fnda ' tont s s D. No. .

TH E COU RT ha co i r d t m o i a t pe tne po tonsoft r c d, nd be ng
s ns de e he ton nd he r i nt r i
he e or a
i

ot r s f l a s d i t pr m ie ,i i
he wie uly dvie n he e s s t s
Al t G> t t hem oto sGM NTED i r a hec ei STAYED pe ngr viw
M m m ha t
i ni
npa t ndt as s
ndi e e
b t Food a Dr g A dm i s r ton. I i a s
y he
nd u
nit a i l t s l o

ADJUDGED t tt Clr oft s Co ts l m a k t s c us a c os d f saitc
ha he e k
hi ur ha l r hi a e s l e or t tsial

p po e a dp a et ematrnacvl us ns fl . Co r s lrti u id ci na dt c s
u s s n lc h te i i is pe e ie The u thal eanj rs ito n he a e
s l ber sor d t t aci doc tupo m o i ofapa t i cic sa sc nge s t tt s
ha l e t e o he tve ke
n ton
ry f r um t nce ha
o ha hi

a to ma p o e dt fna ds sto Th so d r hal o p eudc t erg t o t epate t ti
cin y r c e o i l ipo iin. i r e s ln t rj ie h i hs f h ris o h s
ltg ton.Pl n if SHALL no iyt Cour by Oc obe 30,
ii a i
aitfs
tf he
t
t r 2015a e r 3mont t r afe of
nd ve y
hs he e tr
t c rntsausoft pr e ng a whe t sa on i r d t pr ee
he ure t t
he oc edi s nd
n hi di s ea y o oc d.
I i AD JU DG ED t ta1 ot rpe ng m oto ar D EN I a m oot
ts
ha 1 he ndi
i ns e
ED s
.
1 B ackeround
.

Pl ntf s fl t s pur t d cl s a ton a i tD e e ntW hol Foods M a ket l ,a
ai i f ied hi
por e as c i ga ns f nda
e
r , nc.

c
ompa ha s l s ve al
nyt t els e r homeo t cpr t unde her$365BeW el'br ndt r i vem e c
pahi oduc s
rt i 1
1' a o ele
dial
s
ympt s Pl ntfs cli t t De enda ' pr t do not dei r t be is pr s t
om . ai if am ha
f nts oduc s
lve he neft omied o
co um e s The na ed Pl i if ,M a i H e a Y a r s A l ont D e e e Cha ,a K e n
ns r .
m
a ntf s
ro r zo, ne i m e, ni l
nm nd na

Ras biptr ha e pr t a W hol Foods Spec fc l t y pur has d E
a lc s d oduc s t
e
.
ii aly, he
c e ç
cough Ea ef Ki ,
s or ds'
'
Sco h Ea e f A duls ' $ 1 Eas 'a SAr ca M ont na 30C' - none of w hi h t y c a m
ç ug
s or
t, T u
'
e' nd l ni
a
'
c he l i

l t
Alhough t Cour i a t ni f om t s m a t rpe ng a nc r e ,t Cour does
he
t s bs ai ng r hi te ndi ge y evi w he
t

fn t a Plitfslc sa igt s e ij n tv r le a dt ecam f ru j s e c me ti
id h t anif a k tndn o e k nu cie eif n h li o n u t mi h n s
nott na e gi n t e i a ade t r m e a l w . Shoul t a nc de lne t
e bl ve her s n qua e e dy t a
d he ge y c i o
a i sr tvel r viw t sm a tr t Pli if r m ani cai sar f monemy dnma
dm nita i y e e hi te , he antfs' e i ng l m e or
t
ges
unde t Fl r da D e e i a U nf i Tr de Pr c i sA c a ne i ntm i r pr e a i
r he o i
c ptve nd
ar a
a tce t nd glge
s e es nt ton.

delve e t pr m ie be f . Pl i if cli t y r i on De e ntsde ptve a f le
i r d he o s d ne hs antfs am he eled
f nda ' ce i nd a s
lbelng i ptr ha i t eho eo t cpr
a i n lc sng hes m pahi oduc s
t.

Th tr ec u t o li tsf r nus e c me t avo aino t eFlrd De e tv a d
e h e -o n c mpan i o u j t mi h n , ilto f h o ia c p ie n
Unf i Tr dePr di sAd,a neglge mir pr entton.De enda ha m o d t dimison
ar a
a ce
nd
i nt se es a i
f nt s ve o s s

va i g ounds
rous r
.
II. LezalSt
andard

$ s vi a moton t dimi s pl i if m us do m or t n me ey sae lga
ç ur ve
To
i o s s , antfs
t
e ha
r l tt e l
c l i ns'i t a antfsm us d l es es ik f c ua ba i f hos c usonso f c
onc uso , nse dpli if
'
tç eg om pec t a t l ss ort e oncl i r a e
al

dimis loft i cai . Jac s v Bel hTee
s sa her l ms' k on . lsout lcomm.372F. 1 1 ( t Ci.
'
,
3d 250, 263 11h r2004)
.
W he r i on amotont dim is aco t us viw t c pl nti t lg m os f vor bl t
n ulng
i o s s , ur m t e he om ai n he i ht t a a e o
t pl i ifa a e t pl n ifswe lpl de f t astue.SeeStJosph'Hos , nc v. p.
he antf nd cc pt he aitf
l- ea d acs r
. e s p.I . Hos

Cop.o ,7 5 F.d 9 , 5 ( 1h Ci.1 6 . Th stn t h we e , oe n ta py t lg l
r fAm. 9 2 48 9 3 1 t r 98 ) i e e, o v r d s o p l o e a
c n lso . S eAs c otv I b l 1 9 S.Ct 1 3 1 4 ( 0 9 . M o e v r i wl i lg l
o cu ins e h rj . q a , 2
. 9 7, 9 9 2 0 )
ro e , s hl e a
g e
c usons c n pr de t fa e k of a c
oncl i
a ovi he r m wor
ompli t t m us be s
a n , hey
t
uppore by f c ua
td
at l

ale tons'I a 1
lgai .' d t 950.Thos 'fa t alegai mus bee
e ' j cual l tons t nought rieargh t rle a ve
l
o as i t o eif bo
t s cul tve l velo t as um pton t ta 1oft com pl i ' alega i a e t u ' Be l t.
he pe a i e
n he s
i ha 1
he
a nts l t ons r r e.
' lA l

Cor v.Twombl 550 U. 5 5 (
p.
y,
S. 44, 45 2007) l s tt c ai mus notme ey algea
. n hor, he ompl nt t
r l le
mic
s onduc , m us de onsr t t tt pl de i e ildt r i .SeeI ,1 S. . t1 0.
t but t m ta e ha he ea r s ntte o elef
qbal 29 Cta 95
1 LeealA nal i
11.
yss

The m o i t di m i spr s nt a m yrad ofa gum e s i l ng w he he t Def nda '
ton o s s e e s
i
r
nt nc udi
t r he
e nt s

o fr o j d me toten me P an if mo th ic s , eh r an if ha esa dn t p ru
fes fu g n t h a d litfs o t er a e wh te plitfs v tn ig o u s e

ij ncierle, eh rPlitfs u j te c n cam c nsa i t efc o a a e u t
nu tv eif wh t e an if ' nus mihme t li a tnd n h a e f n d q ae

lg l e d a wh t e t sCo r s o l a san fo a j dc tn ti c s u d rteF o ia
e a rme y, nd eh r hi u t h ud b ti r m du iaig h s a e n e h l rd
De e tv a dUn ar a Prcie Ac' s f h r o pr vso t ep i r j rs ito d crn ,
c pi e n fi Trde a tc s ts ae ab r o iin,h rma y u id ci n o tie
orpr nc pl s ofi ple pr m pton.
i i e
m i d ee i

A. f /o h O fr o d me t
f #c fte fe : flu g n
TheElve hCic tnsti v Buc ane r, t n t rhi, F. 698( 1hCi. 4)
e nt r uii en . c es L d.parnes p 772 3d
1 t r201
a r s e t is ofwhehera de e ntm a m ootac a sa ton t o h anunac ptd ofe of
dd e s d he s ue
t
f nda
y
l s c i hr ug
ce e f r

j d me tu d rF d rlRul ofCi i Pr c d r 68 eo fr of u g n p o d d c mplt
u g n n e e ea e
vl o e u e .Th fes j d me t r vie o ee
r i t t nn e pl i if ,butnott c a sm e be s a wer pr de pr ort t pl ntf s'
elef o he m d a ntf s
o ls
m r , nd
e ovi d i o he ai if

tlngofam o i t ce tf acas .Gi nt cicl sa si St n,heElvent Cic tf
ii
ton o riy l s ve he r tm t nce n ei t
e h r ui oundt t
ha

t eo fr o j d me tddn t o t ec s .I , 7 F.da 7 0.
h fes f u g n i o mo t h a e d 7 2 3 t 0
I isr pl bre ,Def nda c
n t e y if
e nt once d t tSti i dipostveofisa g ntt tt ofe s
de ha e n s s ii
t r ume ha he f r

o j g n mo to t h Plitfs cams Ac odigy teCo r d ne t emo int ds s
f ud me t o u t e an if' li . c r n l,h u t e is h to o imis

o t sis ea dfn st eo f r o j g n ddn t o t en me Plitfs cams
n hi su n i d h fe s f ud me t i o mo t h a d an if' li .
#. Un tEnrihme ( ntJ
jus
c nt Cou )

$ti blc etr1w ta çh t e r o t us e rc me ti e utb ei n t r a d i,
d s a klte a h t t e h o y f mj t n ih n s q ia l n al e n s
I
z
t r f e nota ia ew he e t ei a a qua e l ga r m e ''I r . anaged Car L ii ,1
he e or ,
va l bl
r her s n de t e l e dy.' n e.M
e tg. 85

F.Supp. 1 0,1 ( D. a.
2d 31 337 S. Fl 2002)( i We trv Ro Carbbe Cr s s Lt ,1 F.
quotng bse . yal i an uie, d. 24
Su 2d 1 7,1 ( D.Fl 2000)( i t tunde Fl i lw,ç nt me ui da ge
pp. 31 326 S. a.
notng ha
r orda a t um r t ma s
qua

c n t ea r e wh na e f r e bec nrc e it.l.ç nu j t n ih n cam c ne it
a no b wad d e n n o c a l o ta t x ss' ) d nus e rc me t li a x s
' A.
onl i t s j c matroft cli i notcovee byavai ande o c abl c r c. I Thee
y fhe ub e t te hat am s
rd
ld
nfr e e onta t' d r
'

-

4-

i a ade t r m ed a 1 w when m one a y da a s a e a ia e vi a a t r tve c ai . e
s n qua e e y t a
t r m ge r va l bl a n le na i l m Bul

v Ga daCLSout as,I .No.1 21 C1 201 W L 3501 *3( D. a J y 1 201 .
. r
he t nc,
4- 898- V, 4
546, S. Fl. ul 4, 4)
Pl i if have nota l ge t e i a e e scon r ctnorha t y alege t r i a l c
a ntf s
le d her s n xpr s
ta
ve he l d he e s a k
ofa a qua e l lr m e D e e nta guest a qua e l galr m e i t s c e sem s f om
n de t ega e dy. f nda r
he de t e
e dy n hi as t
r

t e e sc r tbewee t pa tesf rt r t i pur has oft homeo t cpr t -t
he xpr s ontac t n he ri o he e al c e he
pahi oduc s he
f c s ofwhih a e pl i t c
at
c r ed n he ompl i a unde le t Fl i De e i a Unf i Tr de
ant nd
ri he orda c ptve nd
ar a

P a tc sAc cam,whc i a cam f rmo tr d ma e a ij ncier l f Be a et e
rcie t li
ih s li o neay n g s nd nu tv ei . c us h
e
c pl ntpr desf c ua alega i s
om ai ovi a t l l tons uppori a ade t r m ed of1 w a a c us ofa ton
tng n qua e e y a nd a e c i

t rc u t trme y t eDee a t r u sf rd s s a o t et u te rc me tcam .
o e o p ha e d ,h fnd n ag e o imis l f h mj s n ih n li
Plitfsa g et a t e s o l b alwe t pla te u j te c me tcam i t e
anif r u h t h y h u d e lo d o e d h nus mi h n li n h
atm aie Anu j s e c me tcam c n o l b p e i t atr aiei o eo mo eo t
l t .
e v
n u t mi h n li a ny e ld n he len tv f n r r f he

p risc ne t h e itn eo v ldt o a e p e sc n rc g venngt s be to t ed s u e
a t o ts t e x se c r aiiy f n x r s o ta t o r i he u jc f h ip t.
e
I Re.M anage Car Lii ,1 F.Supp.2d a 1 38;M ar o e l v De s heBankNat Tr s
n .
d
e tg. 85
t 337t r la . utc
. ut

Co , 31F. u p. d 1 8 1 2 ( D. a 2 3 . he a a r e n i arv da b wo d o i
.9
S p 2 21 , 2 8 S. Fl. 01 ) W n n g e me t s ri e t y r s r n
m i i t c r c i s i t be S xpr s . I r St
tng, he onta t s ad o
ç e s' n e andar Jur I tuctons - r d:Bus
e
'
d y nsr i -contact
.

Ca e , 1 So 3 2 4 3 ( a 2 3 .j o isv P e n .4 0F. u p. 2 , 2 6( D. l.
s s 1 6 . d 8 , 08 Fl. 01 ) npr ha . /z rf c, 9 S p 1 28 1 3 S. Fa
2007)(or n, .,hec toundt pur ha eofac e tr -e ngdr s t e t etbls
J da J)t our f
he c s
holseolrduci ug ufkinto sa ih

terq iiec nta t a rlto s pa dds se tet u t n ih n cam. Pr hisc u t
h e u st o rcu l eai n hi n imis d h mj s e rc me t li The o a o r
wrt :d j t mi h n éa n t x s wh r p y n ha b e ma ef rheb n ft o fre .'
oe C us e c me t c n o e it ee a me t s e n d o t e ei c n er d'
un
'
1 ( i N G. .Tr lAs oc v Celbrt Cr s s I . 764So.2d67 675(
d. quotng L ave s . . e iy uie , nc,
2, 2000:. Hee,
r
t Cour tndst Pl i if 'pur has oft hom eo t cpr
he
ti
he a ntf s
c e he
pa hi oduc s w hi h i noti diput ,f m s
t, c s
n s e or

-

5-

teb sso a e p e sc nr c a dds se teu j s e rc me tcam.
h a i f n x r s o ta t n imiss h nu t n ih n li
C. o i aDe e iean Unai T a ePr tc sAc Cl ml
Flrd cptv d f r r d acie t ai
As ot esau o ycam f rij n t er l fDee da tc aln e tePlitfs sa d n
t h tttr li o nu ci ei , fn n h le g s h anif' tn i g
v e
unde Ari e11 Pli if'c ai i c tst tt pr t weeworhls .Se Luan v
r tcl 1. antfs ompl nt ndiae ha he oducs r
t es e j .

De n e so ll e 5 4U. 5 5 5 4(é s e po u et i e a c n u td e n tnis l s o
# d r fWi f , 0 S. 5 , 6 s t x s r o l g l o d c o s o i tef h w
d
pa
l
ap e e tc s o c nr v ry rg r i ij n tv rle . i u a c mp n e b a y c n iun ,
rs n a e r o to e s e adng n u cie eif . f n c o a id y n o tn ig
.
p e e ta v reefcs'' ctngCi o o An ee v L n , 61U. 9 ,1 2 ( 98 ) q oig
rs n d e s fe t.'tii t fL s g ls . yo s 4
l
y
S. 5 0 1 3 , u tn
O 'he v Liteon,41 U. 488, 96( 974) .I t c extofc umerpr eci cams
S a . tlt
4 S. 495- 1 ) n he ont
ons
ot ton li
c le ngpr tlbei t cour hasa idt fu sa ngma m. t v Anheu e halngi oduc a lng,he t pple he jan tndi
xi Mary .
sr

Bu c Co, LC, F. u p. d 1 3 ,1 5 ( D. a 2 4 (i-eei n lk lh o o ij r i
s h .L 43 S p 3 3 3 3 8 S. Fl. 01 ) tl r s o iei o d f nu y n
-h
t f t e i a pl i ifhasno i e e ti pu c s ng t pr
he u ur f a ntf
nt r s n r ha i he oductati s aga n be aus i doesno
s ue i c e t
t

wor o doe not fr asa ried.'( i Mas v. ur 'I aton,I .No.1 CVk r s pero m dve ts ' quotng on Nat es nnov i nc,
)
2-

3 9BTM (
01
DHB) 2 3W L 1 6 9 7( D. lM a 1 , 01 :.I Ma t t ec u t mp a ie
, 01
9 9 5 S. Ca. y 3 2 3 n ry,h o r e h sz d
2 Fl i D e eptve a U nf i Tr de Pr c i s A c sa esasf l s
The or da c i nd
ar a
a tce
t tt
olow :

I a a ton br
n ny c i
oughtby ape s whoha s f r d al sasar ul
r on
s ufe e os
es t
ofa vi ai n oft spa t s h pe s m a r c
ol to
hi r, uc r on y e overa t lda a s
c ua m ge ,
pl at ne s f s a c tcoss as pr ded i s 50121
us tor y' ee nd our
t
ovi
n . . 05.
Howe r dama ,f s o c t a e not r co r e unde t s
ve ,
ges ee , r oss r
e ve abl
r hi
s c i a i ta r t lr who ha ,i good f t e ged i t
e ton gans
eaie
s n
aih, nga
n he
di s m i ton of cai s of a manuf c ur r or whol alr wihout
s e na i
lm
at e
es e t
act knowldget ti vi a e t spa t
ual
e
ha t olt d hi r.

j5 . 12 , l. tt (mp ssa d d .Asar tie o t es b e th me p t i me iie t e
0121 () F a S a. e ha i d e )
ealr f h u j c o o ahc d cn ,h
s a ut e a t ar quie e t tDef nda vi at d t a tw ih ac ua know l dge.Theco pl n
t t e ngr f s e r m nt ha
e nt ol e he c t t l
e
m ai t
lc a a lga i t tDe e ntha a t lknowl
a ks n le ton ha f nda
d c ua
edge i wa vi ai t a t I viw oft
t s ol tng he c . n e
he
Cour' a t ntonof hi c eonot rgr
ts bse i
t s as
he ounds t Cour de i t gr nt antfslavet a e
,he
t clnes o a Pl i if e o m nd
t scl i t i or a et tale i The Co t ne rhel s , est tt c a m i notpr ry
hi a m o nc por t ha l gaton.
ur , ve t e s not ha he l i s
ope l
pld unde t saut
e
r he t t e.
-

6-

t twheet c antonl c ansalgai ofpas ij y,hos ale tonsdonots
ha
r he ompli
y onti le tons
t nur t e lgai
uppor
t

afndn o sa dngwh r ij nci er l fi s ug t 1 .43F. u p. da 1 5 Si lry,h
i i g f tn i
e e n u tv ei s o h . d ,
e
S p 3 t 3 9. mia l t e
a n e c mpan heed t i p s ij r rg z i tep o u t a eig.l c n an a alg to
me d d o lit r eal a tn u y e adng h r d c lb l t o tis n l ain
s
n
e
t t but f r t m i l di l be i Pl ntf s w oul not ha plr ha e t hom e t c
ha
o he s ea ng a lng, ai i f
d
ve zc s d he
opa hi

medi ton.I alo de c i t pr
ca i
t s s rbes he oduct a ç t e s' The onl l ca deduci fom t s
s s i hl s .
wor
'
y ogi l
ton r he e
a lgai nsi t tt Pl i if wilnotbepu c i t homeo t c me c ton i t f ur
le to s ha he antfs l
r hasng he
pahi dia i n he ut e.

Co sse t t h p icpls n n itdi ua ,h Co r ds se tecam f rn u cierle
n itn wi e rn i e e u cae nf j n t e u t imis sh li o ij n tv eif
ht
frlc ofsa ngpurua tt Fedea Rul ofCi lPr edur 1 b)1 .
o a k tndi
s n o
rl e
vi oc e 2( ( )

D. se t n u d rt eS f Ha b r I idPr e i nan PrmayJu idito Do tie
Ab tni n e h ae r o , mple e mpto d i r rs cin crn s
o
D e e ntW hol Foodss e t ha t Cour a t n f om hemi pl ntf s c a m sba e
f nda
e
e ks o ve he
t bsai r
ngz ai i f ' l i
sd

o tesf h r o ,mp idp e mp in, n p i r u id cind crne .Th u d ryn p e s
n h a e ab ri le r e to a d rmayj rs ito o ti s e n e lig rmie
fr ti ag me tse fo te F d rlF o Dr g a d Co mei Ac,21 U. C.j 3 ,
o h s r u n tms r m h e ea o d, u n s tc t
S. j 01
3 ( )1, c ma d tsta h me p t cme iieb te tda t r g 'u e fd rla The
21g ( )whih n ae h t o o ahi dcn e rae s d u s' nd r e e a lw.
d
Ac ge r l pr bismil di lbei
t nealy ohi t sea ng a lng.21U. C. 331(ç f l nga t a t ca i
S. j
$The olowi cs nd he usng
t rofaepr bie ( (j i r ucin o dei r f i r ton i o i ertt c
hee r ohi td:a) the ntod to r lvey or ntoduci nt nt sae ommece
r
ofan f d ug, vi ,o c pr torc mei t ti ... s a
y ood, r de ce tba co oduc, os tc ha s mibrnded.l; ealo21U. C.
' se s
S.

j3 ()( eii S s rn e ' oicu emila i glb ln o a v rii g ; U. C.j3 2
21n d fnng ç b a d d't n ld se d n a eig r d e tsn l 21 S.
mi
5
(il çMibrndedDnz a De c s).A rgult y she r quiess le sofho opahi
tted s s a
gs nd vie '
e aor c me e r elr
me t c
pr t t i l S ndi tonsf rUs ' orS ie to f Us ' on t rpr t a r quied by
oduc s o nc ude ç ca i o e' r r c i ns or e' hei oduc s s e r
l

fd r lsaue S e 21 U. C.j 3 2 9( ) 21 C. R.j 2 . ( ) 016 ()4 ( r vdng
e ea tt t. e
S.
5 ( 1;
F. j 0161b ,2 .6 c () p o ii
r gult y s he f r f ma tng a co e r quie nt f ove -he countr dr pr uc
e a or c me o or ti nd nt nt e r me s or rt e ug od t

-

7-

lbei ;
a lng)Compla Polc Gui j400. ( ovi ngt U. Fooda Dr gAdmi srton'
ince iy de
400 pr di he S.
nd u
nitai s
c tonsunde whihhomeo t cdr ma bemakee .Selr aealor rdt i l
ondii
r c
pahi ugs y
r td) les r s equie o ncude
a t a e e of I ntt 'f t i pr
t t m nt
st
de iy' or he r oduc s t t pr de a ç cc la e s a e ent of t ge r l
t ha ovi n ç tr t t t m
a
he ne a

phama ol ca c tgor is oft dnz o t prnci li e acint)oft d ug.nt c e
r c ogi l ae yte ) he g r he i pa ntnded to s he r I he as
ofa ove -he c erdnl t ti am i ur a t t noe tbls dnn e t sr quieme s l
n rt - ount
g ha s xt e nd ha has sa ihe m ,hi e r nt hal
bedee t bes ts idby apr i nta c piuoussa e e oft ge a pha
med o a ife
om ne nd ons c
tt m nt he ner l nnac og c l
ol i a

a to t)o t e mitr o o isp i cp litn e a to t) ..' S e 21 C. R.j 2 . ,
cin s f h xu e r f t rn ia n e d d cin s. . e
'
F.
0161
*
Compla ePolc Gui j400.
inc iy de
400.

1 S f Ha b r
. ae ro
Ati s i hem o i o di m i si whe he heFl i Dec ptve a Unf i Tr dePr c i es
s ue nt
tont s s s t rt
orda
e i nd
ar a
a tc

Ac' s ehaborpr sonprcl sla lt TheAc e iil pr l sla lt f Can a t
ts af r
ovii e ude ibiiy.
t xplcty ecude ibiiy or i l c
g

o p a tc r q ie o s cfc l p r te b fd r lo sae lw. j 5 . 2 1 ,Fl.Sa .
r rcie e ur d r pe iial emi d y e ea r tt a ' 0121 ( ) a tt;
y
t
'
Pr as 490 F.Supp.2d a 1234. A n a t how e r does no nee t vi a e a s cii l e or
ohi ,
t
c,
ve ,
t d o ol t
pe t c '
ul

r gulton t be c i r de e i Pr as 490 F.Supp. a 1
e ai o
onsde ed c ptve. ohi ,
2d t 233. Ther e nti r f
elva nquiy or
t Co ti whe he W hol Foods ast m ovi pa t has s n t ta s cii f de a or sa e
he ur s
t r
e
, he
ng r y,
how ha pe fc e r l t t

lw a fr ai l a horze it e
a fim tvey ut i d t o ngag i t c
e n he onduc alege i t c
t l d n he ompl i , whe he W hol
ant not t r
e
Foodsvi ae as cii r eorr gulton.I , F.
ol td pe fc ul
e a i d 490 Supp. a 1
2d t 234. f lwihi t pur i
To al t n he vew
of t s f ha bor t Pr as c twr e t tt def nda had t s
he a e r , he ohi our ot ha he e nt
o how t Food a Dnz
he
nd
g

Ad i sr ton vi we a a oved t m il di adve tsng.I
m nita i
e d nd ppr
he sea ng
rii d
I t sca e W hol Foodshasge r ly s
n hi s ,
e
ne al hown t i i r quie t pr de lbel on is
hat t s e r d o ovi a s t
hom e t c pr uc s a t pr
opa hi od t nd he oduc s I c tons f U s .W hol Foods how e r has notm e
t ' ndi a i
or e
e
,
ve ,
t

-

8-

isbur nt s t tt Food a Dr gAdmi sr ton s ii aly a ho iedt l be sa is
t de o how ha he
nd u
nita i pecfc l ut rz he a l t s ue

i t sc s (x i t A t rug D o teFrtAme d dCo lit.TheCo r,h rf r , n n t
n hi a e e hbi h o h f h is
s
n e mp an)
u tt ee o e c n o
pr um e t tt Food a D r g Adm i sr ton vi w e a a ove t hom eo t c pr
es
ha he
nd u
ni t a i
e d nd ppr d he
pa hi oduc
t

l l a deci st a yFl i ss f har rpr son a e t ts
abes nd lne o ppl orda' a e bo ovii bs nt ha howi fom Def nt
ng r
enda .
J.Prmar Jurs c i
i y iditon

Th p i r jlidcind crn a pl s eeac s i l ae afd r l g nc ' e p rie
e rmay t s ito o tie p i wh r a e mpi ts e ea a e y s x e ts
r
e
c
wi arg ltdp o u t i dSttsv rl c R. Co, 5 U. 5 , 4( 95 )( ligt a
t e uae r d c.Unt a e .' Pa . R. .3 2 S. 9 6 1 6 hodn h t
h
e
F
p i r u idcind crn a p isd e v re f re n o (1cam rq ie t ers lto o
rma yj rs ito o tie p le wh ne e n o c me t f a li e u rs h e oui n f
is whih,unde a r gul t y s he ha be n plce wihi t s cilc pe e e ofa
s ues c
r e aor c me, ve e a d t n he pe a om t nc
n

a nitai body.) S-hedocrnee blsaco tt tkea tgeofa a nc se rie,
dmi srtve
'. t'
' f
ti na e
ur o a dvana
n ge y' xpets

p oe t teitg i o t er g aoy s h me a p o tsu f r t. Gr ehed v Yu aa
rtcs h n e rt f h e ultr c e , nd r moe nio mi ' e n l . c tn
y
y'
Foods L. ,1 F. pp.3d 1 ,1 ( D. a. 4)( i Fl su I v. r ,783So.
, P. 8 Su
371 375 S. Fl 201 quotng o- n, nc. Kik
2d
1 1 ( a. ).Theprmayj iditon docrnei adicrtonaydocrnet tal
029, 037 F1 2001)
i r urs ci
ti s s ei r ti ha lows

ç o ls osa p o e d n so t ds s ac mp an wi u p eu iepe dn t er s lto o a
d u' t ty r c e i g r o imis o lit t t rj d c n ig h e ou in f n
c t
ho
is wihi t s cilc
s ue t n he pe a ompe e ofa a nita i a nc ' Gar ionv Whol Food M ar et
t nce n dmi sr tve ge y.
' rs .
e
s
k

Gr u I .No.1 - 5 2 - 2 4 W L 2 51 9 ,* ( D. l J e2 2 4 . I t i c s ,
o p, nc,
3 0 2 2 CV, 01
4 2 0 2 N. Ca. un , 01 ) n hs a e
Defnda W hol Foodsr que t t Cour de e t sm a trt t Food a Dr Admi sr ton.
e nt
e
e ss he
t f r hi te o he
nd ug
nita i
Pl ntfsr yon Gar io v.ö' eFoo
ai if el
rs n
hol
dsM ar e ou I .so.1 CVk tGr p, nc,
3- 05222, 4W L
201

2 29 ( D.Ca.J n 2 2 4 t ag e t prmay j rs ito d crn d e n tr q r
451 0 N.
l u e , 01 ) o r u he i r u idcin o tie o s o e uie
a t nton. l Gar i on,t c tde i t a t i be aus t Food a D r A dm i s r ton
bs e i
n
r s he our clned o bs a n c e he
nd ug
nit a i
ha r pe t dl dec i d t a
d e a e y lne o doptf m alr gul tons r ga di t m ea ng oft w or çna tr .'
or
e ai
e r ng he
ni
he
d d ttal'

-

9-

1 .a * Iwr t :sj e ei noce rn iaint Ag n yitn t rviit i d cso a ytme
d , t 2. t o e tth r s la id c to he e c n e ds o e sth s e iin n i
g
s o Th r i,h r f r,n Se ou in o (h jis e p n i b f r t eAg n y t wh c t e
o n. e e s te eo e o r s lto f te su ' e dng e o e h e c o ih h
Co t oul defr'I ( tngCl kv Ti War Cabl 523F. 111 111 ( hCi. :.
ur c d e.' d quoi ar . me ner e,
3d 0, 4 9t r2008
Theunde l ngf t ofGar s ho ve ,a e dif r ntt n t epr s nthe e. n Gar s t
ryi acs
rion, we r r fe e ha hos e e
r I
rion, he

pl i if we e c le ng f lbescai i t f
antfs r ha lngi ood a l l m ng he oodswe ei t a . He e t Pl ntfsa e
r ç ur l' r , he ai if r
na
'
c lngi t l ca i f Us t t t Food a Dnz Adm i sr ton ma es f
hale ng he ndi tons or e ha he
nd
g
nita i
ndat or
hom e pahi me cne.l Gar ion,hec t pecfcal oundt Age yhadr pe t dl de i
o t c di i n rs t our s ii lyf
he nc
e a e y clned
t a pta de i ton f çna ur . I t sca e t e i no i c t on t tt Agenc i de i ng
o do
fnii or l t al' n hi s , her s ndi a i ha he
'
y s clni

t ove s e t i c tonsf us t ta e a i s
o r e he ndia i or e ha r t s ue.

Co rsc n ie fu fco s e a pligt d crn o p i r j rs ito ( )hen e
u t o sd r o r a tr wh n p yn he o tie f rmay u id ci n:1 t e d
t rs lea is t a ( )h sb e plc db Co g e swihnt j rs ito o a a miitaie
o e ov n sue h t 2 a e n a e y n r s t i he u idcin f n d n srtv
b d h vn rg ltr a t o i ( )p ru n t asau et a s b e t a id ty o a tvt t a
o y a ig e u ao y u h rt 3 u s a t o ttt h t u j cs n n usr r cii o
y
y
c e nsve rgult y s he t t( r rs e rie orunior t i a nitaton.
omprhe i e aor c me ha 4) equie xpe ts
f miy n dmi sr i

Gr e/c# 1 F. u p. da 1 7 Th F o a dDr Ad n srto h shen c sa ye p re c
e n / , 8 S p 3 t 3 6. e o d n ug miitai n a t e e s r x ein e
a e r iei e a i l be i ofhom eo t cm edi a i and i i w ihi heA ge y' pur i w
nd xpe ts nr gul tng a lng
pa hi
c ton
t s t nt
nc s v e
t dec de whe he t l be s a e com pla w ih f de a 1 w a t c pr he i r a or
o
i
t r he a l r
i nt t e r l a nd he om e ns ve egul t y
s m e i ha de s
che t s vi ed.

TheCo r i a r t a t e( rma yj rs ito d crnei n td sg e t sc r e pet
u ts wae h t h t i r u idcin o ti s o e in d o e u e x r
p
a c fom a
dvie r gencese r tmeacou ti pr s nt wih a is c
i ve y i
r s e e ed t n s ue onceva y wihi t a nc s
i bl t n he ge y'
a bi.'I r H or z Or
m t' n e
i on gani M ik Pl s DH A O m e
c l u
ga-3 M kt ( Sal s Pr tc Lii , 955
g. f
e ac i e tg.

F. pp. 1 1, 349( D. a. 3 .l hi c e, ve , ve hee e i r ult ys he
su zd 31 1 S. Fl 201 ) nt s as howe r gi nt xtnsve eg aor c me

-

10-

t o r eeho e t c dnz m r ke i a t ques i pr e t ove t l be si t sc s , he
o ve s
m opa hi
g
tng nd he
tons es n ed r he a l n hi a e t

Co r fn sa se to a p o raeu d rhe rmay u idcind crne S n o Ph r e tc l
u ti d b tni n p r p it n e t p i r j rs ito o ti . a d z a mac u ias
Cop. Rihar s vih, nc, F. 222, 2( Ci.l t di t tt is ofwhehe
r v. c d on- c I .902 2d
23 3d r ggolhol ng ha he sue
t r
a i r dinti pr ry l beed C c i ' Cna tve'
n ng e e s ope l a l t tve'or t c i 'unde t Food and Dr Adm i sr ton'
a
i
r he
ug
nita i s

sa r i notpr pel de i dbyadititcour)
tndads s
o ry cde
src
t.

Ha igf u dt ed crn o p i r u idcina pl s t ec u t a ds rto ete t
vn o n h o tie f rmayj rs ito p i ,h o r h s icein i r o
e
h
sa t ec s a drti u idcino t ds s tec s wi u p eu c i tePa t swo l n t
ty h a e n eanj rs ito r o imis h a e t t rj die fh ri u d o
ho
e
beunfil dia t ed. Retrv.Co pe , U. 258, ( 993) Pendi t r erlt
ary sdvanag See ie
o r 5Q7 S. 269 1 .
ng he efra o

teF o a Dr gAd nitain t Co r sa st sc s t a oi a yp eu iet tepat s
h o d nd u mi srto ,he u t ty hi a e o v d n rj dc o h ri .
e
Gr ehed 1 F. u p. da 1 7 .
e n l, 8 S p 3 t 3 7
J I idpr mpton
. mple ee i
l i pr e i a i çwhenc
mpled e mpton pples d
ompla ewihbot saea f der l1w i i
inc t h t t nd e a a s mpos i e.
sbl
. .

or w he t s a e l w it nds a a obs a e t t a com pls en a exe uton of t f l
n he t t a s a
s n t cl o he c
i hm t nd
c i
he ul

p p o e a do jcie o Co g e s' Ca t ciisCa l,nc v Crs 4 7U. 6 , 9 ( 9 4 ;
u s s n be tv s f n rs .' pi te be I . . i 6 S. 91 6 9 1 8 )
' al
p,
M il v.War rLambe tCo. 581F.Supp.2d 772,790 ( D.Te 2008)( i cli wee
ls
ne r ,
E.
x.
notng ams r
pr e e be a e def nda scoul eiheri r tt i pr
e mpt d c us
e nt
d t s ke her oduct i compla wih t FDA
ma
sn
ince t he
r quiem e s or t y c n r f a n f om m a ke i t i pr uc s i or r t co pl w ih t
e r nt , he a e r i r
r tng he r od t n de o m y t he

r uie nt (nda dt la lt i e byPli ifslws t The ca dobot ' (ii
eq rme s a voi he ibiiy) mpos d
antf a ui. y nnot
h.) ctng
'
Rigelv Me r c I .552U. 31 324(
e . dtoni, nc,
S. 2, 2008).
)
D e e nta gue t twhen Cong es e c edt d a i l nior iy f rN onpr c i i
f nda z s ha
r s na t he t tona U f m t o
N
es r pton

Dr ' pr so 21 U. C. j 379r i s ug t ac e unior t i rgultons o
ugs' oviin,
S.
, t o ht o hive f miy n e ai
ver

non es rpton dr - notj talopahi dr . I a g sPl ntfs s ts e ngt cha t
pr ci i ugs
us l t c ugs t r ue ai if' ui e ki o nge he
l belng r quie e s of D e e nts hom eo t c m edi a i c lc s w ih f de alpolc a
a i e r m nt
f nda '
pa hi
c ton onf i t t e r
i y nd

s d be i i y pr e e Not t t ng t Cour' tndi t tPli if l c sandi
houl
mpledl e mpt d. wihsandi he
ts i ng ha antf s a k t ng

t b ig a cam f rij nci rle,te Co r a dto al fn ta alwig te cam f r
o rn
li o nu t eif h u t d iin l ids h t lo n h li o
ve
y
ij n tv r l ft g f r r wo l u d nnie t p r o e f rwhih Co g e se a td t e
nu cie ei o o o wad ud n e n he u p s o
e
c n r s n ce h
t f r t ovii a t r t Fooda Dnl Ad i sr ton' a lt oc ryou isove sg
mio miypr son nd hwa the
nd g m nita i s biiyt a r t t r i ht
ofmar tng ofhom e t cpr t .
kei
opahi oduc s

DON E AND ORDERED i cha be sa M i mi Fl i t s
n
m r t a , orda, hi

gœ
'
A

Jdyo Jl 2015.
a fuy
,

.
.

.'
.
g

X

FED

-

Ct A. ORENO
i

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Couns ofRe or
el
c d