Maluff v. SAMS EAST, INC.

Filing 61

ORDER. Plaintiff's Motion to Strike Expert Witness Testimony of Nicole Bonaparte (D.E. 35) is GRANTED. Defendant's Motion to Limit the Testimony of Plaintiff's Treating Physician (Dr. Kingsley Chin) (D.E. 42) is GRANTED in part and DENIED in part. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 11/9/2017. (da00)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iD i s on
a
vi i
Cas N um ber 17- 264- V - O R EN O
e
: 60
CI M
REI LD O D A M A S M A LU FF,
NA
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
VS.

SA M ' EA ST,l C.
S
N ,
D e e nt
f nda .
/

THI CAUSE c me b f r te Co r u n ( )Plitf' M oin t S rk Ex e t
S
a
eo e h
u t po 1 an ifs to o tie p r
W ine s Tetmo ofNi e Bo pa t ( E.35) fld on Sept
t s si ny
col na re D.
, ie
embe 22.2017 a (
r
, nd 2)
Dee ntsM otont Li tt Te tmonyofPli ipsTratngPhyscin( .Ki ly Chi
fnda ' i o mi he si
antf e i
i a Dr ngse
n)
( E.42) fl on Sept
D.
,ied
ember25.2017.
THE COURT ha c i r t m otons t r s
s onsde ed he
i , he e pons s t r ple , t pe tne
e , he e i s he ri nt
pori oft r c d, beng ot r s f ly a s d i t pr m ies i i
tons he e or and i he wie ' l dvie n he e s , t s
u
A DJU D G ED a f l s
s olow :
Pl i tf M oton t St i Expe t W ine s Tes i ony of
a n ifs
i o r ke
r
t s
tm

Niol Bona re( E.35 i GRANTED.
c e
pa t D. ) s
(i
i)

Dee ntsM oton t Li tt Tesi
fnda '
i o mi he tmony ofPl ntf
ai ifs
Trai Physca ( . Ki ly Chi ( E. 42) i
e tng
iin Dr ngse
n) D.
s
G M NTED i par a DEN I i par .
n
t nd
ED n
t

()Dee ntsM oi i GRANTED t t e e i
a fnda ' ton s
o he xtnt t
s e t pr ve D r Chi f om of e i hi opi on
e ks o e nt . n r
f r ng s ni

a u tec u eo Pli tf sij re .
bo t h a s f anif n u is
( Dee
b) fndants Moton i DENI t t e e i
'
i s
ED o he xtnt t
se t e l
e ks o xc ude D r Chi s t tm ony a
. n' es i
bout t
he
r s bl ne sofPl i tf sm e ca bil .
ea ona e s
a n if
di l l s
1

DI
SCU SSI N
O

Thsi apes n lij r c s a iig fo a i ie ta a S m ' Clb so e Plitf
i s ro a nu y a e rsn r m n ncd n t a s u tr . anif

Mau falg st ta e ly eofDee d n Sn sEa t lc ne lg nl p h dap l t a k
l f l e ha n mpo e
e
f n a t m' s, n . gi e ty us e al j c
e
l de wih me c ndie i o M auf ba k whie he sood ne t hi s
oa d t
r ha s nt
l fs c
l
t
xt o s hoppi c r.The
ng a t

icd n alg dy c us d Mau f sro s lwe b c ij re ta ulmaey rq ie hm t
n i e t le e l a e
lf ei u o r a k nu is h t t tl e ur d i o
i
unde go l
r umba s nef i s g y.
r pi uson ur er
A. Pl ntf ' M ot on t St i Exper W ine sTes i onv ofN i ol B onapar e
ai i fs
i o r ke
t t s
tm
c e
t
Sa ' Eas r t i d N i e Bona t t pr de e
m s
t e a ne
col
pare o ovi xper opi ons a t s i on o
t ni
nd e tm y n

me c l codi and bilng. Bona re' t tmony i pur re y i
di a
ng
li
pa t s esi
s po tdl mpora i o a t a
tnt û udi nd
t
e uae t c ng a bilng pr c ies of Pli tf' te tng he t r pr der a t
val t he odi nd li
a tc
a n ifs r a i
alhca e ovi s nd he

c t r a ras bl c ge f t s c r rd. ( .sRes 3. Sa sc e
usoma y nd e ona e har s or he eni es endee ' Def' p. ) m' ontnds
'
t t Bonapa t s C e tm o as a bilng a c ng expe t on r s bl s of m e ca
ha
re' ' s i ny
t
li
nd odi
r
ea ona ene s
di l

r mbure nt i cii lt Sa s Eas' def e' a dgl udi s h tsi
ei s me s rtca o m' ts ens ' nd kexcl ng uc e tmony woul
d

e ic rt o eo teo yd ma e d fnssa albet Sa ' Ea t'(d4
vs eae n f h nl a g s ee e v ia l o m s s. 1 .
'
M a uf cha l nge t r i lt a r l va e of Bona r e' t s i ony.H i r l va
l f le s he elabiiy nd e e nc
pa t s e tm
s e e nce

or e udi
pa t s e tm
t
a g e a one pr vi s tc e gr
r um nt l
o des ufi i nt ounds f pr cl ng Bona re' tsi ony.Alhough

Bonapa t may be qualfe t opi on whet rPli if ste tng physcinsdoubl- le f
re
ii d o ne
he a ntf r a i
ia
e bild or

a c ran p o e u e o ic re t c a g d f ra c ran ij r s e c r ts a t Plitf s
e ti r c d r r n o r cl h r e o e ti nu y, h amo pe k o anif
y
ij re o tea p o rae e so c rante t n s
nu is r h p r p itn s f e ti rame t.
S m' Eatd s ue t a c n l so , oi t a u d rFlrd lw,ça plitf b ast e
a s s ip ts h t o cu in n t h t n e o i a a k ) anif e r h
ng
l
bur n ofpr ngt ras na e sofhi me c le ns . Col aHop.( m Beac s
de
ovi he e o blnes
s dia xpe es' umbi s Pal
'
he)
Lt P'hi v.Has on,33 So. 1 1 ( a 4t DCA 201 .l r i he viy on t Flrda
d. s p
s
3d 48, 50 F1. h
0) t eles a l
he oi
Cou t of A ppe s de i i n i St e Far M ut Aut I s Co. v Bowln whi h hel t t a
r
al ' c s o n at
m
. o. n .
.
i g, c
d ha

pes n lij r panift s d mo srt ta hi o he me ia e p ns sae ra o a l a d
ro a nu y litf s t e n tae h t s r r d c l x e e r e s n be n
mu
ne esay. 81So.3d 538,540 ( a.Dit Ct App.201 .Acc di t Sa sEat Bowlng
c sr '
'
Fl s. .
2)
or ng o m' s,
i

c
ompel t s Cour t pe mi Bona re' t tmony a
s hi
to r t
pa t s esi
boutt c ng and bilng pr c ies of
he odi
li
a tc
M al fsheat r pr de si or rt r butM auf e de oft rr as na e s1
uf
lhca e ovi r n de o e
l fs vi nce hei e o blnes .

Ho v r te Elv nh Cic i ar a y rjce t tag me ti Ca tla o v T r t
we e , h e e t rut le d ee td ha r u n n seln s . a ge
Cop. whc i ov d a ao o s p ro a ij r cams b s d o De e d n ' alg d
r , ih nv le n lg u e s n l nu y li a e n fn a ts le e
ne ie e.568F.App' 886 ( 1hCi.201 .Des t Bowln ' hol ng,t El nt Cic t
glg nc
x
1 t r 4) pie
ig s di he eve h rui
he d t tJ
l ha udge Kahle W ila sdi nota e he dic e i by e udi sm ia bilng a
t e n lim d
bus r s r ton
xcl ng i lr li nd
c ng tsi
odi e tmony fom Ni e Bona re t s
r
col
pa t he ame e pe twine s J a 88 The Cour c le
x r t s . J t 6.
t a ld

Bowln ima e ily dif r t'be us t de enda ale
ig ç t ra l fe en ' ca e he f nt lged t t t Pli tf f brc t o
ha he a n if a i aed r

e g eae hs ij re , wh ra Ca tla o iv le me ey
xa g rtd i n u is
ee s seln s n ov d rl

c nlc o e te
o tit v r h

r as bl ne sofc r f m e ca s r i e ,a s e t ha be de i r 'I
e ona e s
ha ges or di l e v c s s um d o ve en lve ed. d
'
G i n t El ve h Cicui' hol ng,J
ve he e nt r t s di udge W ila s s r tonal f r s rki Bona r e'
li m ' a i e o t i ng
pa t s
t s i o i i t c i She e a ne i ope c t
e tm ny s nsnz tve.
xpl i d n n our :

I i fc g pa tlhasa hi t ofe ,Ii gi i woul be
f n a t Bona re
nyt ng o fr ma ne t
d
i s
n ome r buta or i
e tl
mpea hm e contxt of how da a a e
c nt
e
m ges r
be ng ca c a ed by a tea i hos t l She ha not ng t do wih
i
l ul t
r tng pia .
s hi o
t

t ij is l a muc a t moton wa die td t t t i wil
he nure . n s h s he i
s rce o ha, t l
be gr nt d.
a e

g n p re s e k t t eis eo ho t ec r e a ec d dwh n
Bo a a t) p a s o h su f w h hag s r o e e
t y a er i
he r embur e by t i ur nc c
sd
he ns a e ompa es She c n t l us
ni .
a el
whehe s ehi f e mpl wasdoubl bil ort c d a
t r om t ng, or xa e,
e led hey ode
br n 1 g a o
oke e s ppos d t a compound fa t e.She c n' s y or
e o
r cur
a t a

s e k t tefc t t h swa asv r ij r , h y n e e t d X
p a o h a t ha t i s e e e nu y t e e d d o o

num be oft ngs t st e t e wasi pora ,a he e' m y bil
r hi , hi r a m nt
m t nt nd r s
l.

g o c n b ig i a d trt s y i Ite td X p ro Iwo l
Yl u a rn n oco o a f rae
esn
ud
ha done t s a t c r woul ha be n t s a t s i
ve
hi nd he ha ge
d ve e hi, nd hi s
wha i c t
t s usomarl c r ed f t spa tc arpr dur You c n
iy ha g or hi riul oce e.
a
have M s Bona re sa ng by. But unl s s ehi
.
pa t tndi
es om t ng
exta di r c e up dur ng t c s of t Pl ntf s c s I
r or na y om s
i he our e
he ai if a e
a not goi t a l t t t tm o f om M s Bo pa t Ri
m
ng o low ha es i ny r
. na r e. ght

1Th ma o i opi o i Bo ig e plie t a <g hieM s Pa h do no h v t n c sa y
e j rt nin n wln x an d h t twj l . c a es t a e he e e s r
y
medialbackgr
c
ound t r
o enderan opi on on whet t medi ca e alege y pr ded t M r Bow lng
ni
her he
cal r l dl ovi o .
i
was r as
e onabl s doeshave t r sie skiland tai ng t r nderan opi on on whet t bil
e, he
he equi t l
r ni o e
ni
her he ls
s it by hi medi pr der acc ael r l t car document i t m edi r or oft e
ubm ted
s
cal ovi s ur t y etect he e
ed n he
cal ec ds hos
s epr der ' 81So.3d at54 l
am ovi s.'
.

now s hasno pl c i t sc e.A s Is i you c n c l a doc or
he
a e n hi as
a d,
a al
t
t ge i t tt s i ony.
o t n ha e tm

T a s r to Or lAr me ta 3 ,Ca tl n sv T r tCop. No.1 - 2 67CV,2 1 W L
r n c l f a gu n t -4 sel o . a ge r ,
p
a
16 4 03
1
20801 a *1( . . a. a 25, 3 .
85, t SD Fl J n. 201 )2
Asi Caselanos Bona reha no pl e i t sc e.Hert tmony woul nota ss t
n
tl s
pa t s
ac n hi as
esi
d
s it he

t re of f c ...t unde sa t e de e or t dee m i a f c i is ' Unie St e v
i ir a t
t
o
r tnd he vi nc
o tr ne a t n s ue.
' t d at s .

Fr zir 387 F. 1
a e,
3d 244,1260 ( t Ci.2004) Theefr t s Cour GRANTS Pl ntf s
11h r
. r oe, hi
t
ai if
M o i t Sti Expe tW ines Te tmony ofNi ol Bo pa t.
ton o rke
r t s si
c e na re

B. Sam ' Eas ' M oton t Li i t Te tmonv of Pl ntf Tr i Phvscan (
s
ts
i o m t he s i
ai irs eatn:
i i Dr.
Ki ly Chi
nzse
n)
A teai physcin ma ofe e r opi o ba e on per o lknowl
r tng
ia
y f r xpe t ni ns s d
s na
edge obt i
aned
durng t c r a te t ntoft Pli ifi he s
i he a e nd r a me
he antf f ubmisa e tdicl ur na r tve r quie
t n xper s os e ra i e r d

u d rFe ea Rue o Cii P o e u e 2 ()2 ( . e ie v Wyeh l c, 80 - 8 4 Tn e d rl l f vl r c d r 6 a( )C) f vn . t n . No. :9 CV- 5 33
AEP,201 W L 2612579,a *1 ( . Fl J 25,201 ) Thi 26( ( ( dicos emus
0
t M D. a. une
0 . s a)2)C) s l ur
t

s mmaiete s b e tmatr fcs a d o i o st whih t p y iin i e e td t tsiy
u rz h u j c te, a t, n pnin o c he h sca s xp ce o etf .
Howe r lg her a doct ' opi on e e be
ve, iwj e
ors ni xtnds yond t fcs dicl ed durng cae a
he a t s os
i
r nd
te t e oft patenta t docori s c al r ti d t de l opi on t tmony,he or
r am nt he i nd he t s pe i ly ea ne o veop ni esi

s e i s be tt t e p o iinso Rue 2 ()2 ( , whih rq ie a mo e f lo wrte
h s u j c o h r vso f l 6 a ()B)' c e u rs
'
r u s me i n
t
e r rpo tBr v BetFoods 1 F. D. 5,388( D. a.1 .
xpe t e r. own . s
, 69 R. 38
N. Al 996)
Dr Chi M auf ste tng physcin s te hi 26()2)C)dicos edesrbi
. n
l f rai
i a ubmitd s a( ( s l ur ci ng
t f c sa o ni he plns t a es i hi t si ony.M auf c e t tt dic os d
he a t nd pi ons
a o ddr s n s e tm
l f ont nds ha he s l e
opi onst r de i d t ough teament'a t û . n i notpr di opi onsba e on
ni s e rve hr
we
r t ' nd hat $ Chi s
Dr
ovi ng ni
sd

i onnai obane fom ot rs c . ( .sRe p.4. Spe fcal Dr Chi plnstsiy
nf ton ti d r
he oures' Pl' s ) cii ly, . n a etf
'
a
boutt f l i
he olow ng:
2Judge W ilams i notal i srki t t tmony ofN i e Bonapare--/ : Cour gr nt
li
s
one n ti ng he es i
col
t â/
t a ed
Pl ntf s moton t s rke exper t tm ony of N i e Bonapa e i a 201 cas i vi lcl m s of
ai if'
i o ti
t esi
col
rt n
6 e nvol ng s ai

n glg nc a prmie la ii frpes alij isrs tngfo asi a fI. Ro r v Fisa
e ie e nd e ss iblt o ron nure euli rm lp nd al' ges . et
y
'
Re t r ntGr p. I c,No.1 - 07 CW ,201 WL 7 405 ,a #1( D.Fl J l 1 2 6) rpo t
sau a
ou , n .
524 36
5 40 t S. a. uy , 01 , e r
a rc
nd e omme ato ado e No.l - 407 CW , 6W L 76 78 ( D.Fl. ul 8 201 )
nd in ptd,
5 2 3- 201
44 9 S. a J y , 6 .
4

()
i

Ca s to
u ain

(i
i)

Ther s e sofPlitf medialbil
eaonablnes
anifs c ls

(i) Dr Chi sc r a dte t n o tePlitf
ii
. n' ae n rame t f h an if
Pl i if s f ur ca e a t e t e
a ntf ut e r nd r a m nt

(
v)

Thec tofPli ifsmedialc r
os
antf'
c ae
Pl ntf f ur c r a
ai i fs ut e a e nd tea m e , pe m a ncy or
r t nt
r ne
Pl ntf' r ti tonslm iatons
ai ifs esrci /i t i

Sa sEa tdipue Dr Chi sa ii td t tmony r gadi t frtt t cs ()
m' s s ts . n' ntcpae esi
e r ng he is wo opi : i
c uston;a (i t ra ona e s ofPli ifs me c lbil.l c e t tDr Chi s
a ai nd i) he e s blne s
antf
dia ls t ontnds ha . n'

te t n o M au fdd n trq r hm t d tr n t tc u e te P an ifs ij re o
rame t f lf i o e uie i o ee mie ç
wha a s d h litf nu is r
whehe t Pli ifsmedialbil weeras bl '( f' Re .2.
t r he antf
c ls r e ona e. De .s pl )
'
M oton t Li tTe tm on on Caus i
i o mi si y
aton
Cours r c nie t tr ol i oft s e de ir is s ofe de nd he viy on t
t e og z ha es uton he e vi nta y s ue t n pe
a l
he
pa tc a f c s He e, Sa ' Eas not s t t Dr Chi s S e ca r or pe t i ng t t
riulr a t . r
m s
t e ha
. n' t di l ec ds rani o he
m

Pl ntf te t nta caedo no conan aca ai opi o prort J 7,201 .... (#.
ai ips rame nd r
t ti
us ton nin i o une
6 'f )
'

l r s o s , au fo fr ac n l o y a s rin ta d a te tn p y iin wo l b o lt e
n ep n e M l f fes o cus r se t h t i j r ai g h sca ud e f it
o
l
l
v let hso h rp te ti t p ysca o l te tdt i daeij re ,b tso pe s o t
au o i r e ain f he h iin ny r ae he mme it n u is u tp d h r

o tl n tep te twh tc u e t eij r .. . ( . Rep. )Mau f ho v r p o d sn
f el g h ain a a s d h nu y .' P1' s 4. lf, we e, r vie o
i
' s
s
uppor f t s sae e ,f ii t ct e
t or hi t tm nt alng o ie ven one c e whe e t Cour pe m itd a teai
as
r he
t r te
r tng

p y iint o n o c u ain wih u p o u igaRu e2 ()2 ( rpo t
h sca o pie n a s to t o t r d cn
l 6 a( )B) e r.
I d,t El ve h Cic t s emi y pr e s f ditit cours t srke a teai
ndee he e nt r ui e ngl ef r or src
t o ti
r tng

physcan' c ain tsi
ii s aus to e tmony i t phy i an fie t s taRul 26()2)B)r por a
f he sci ald o ubmi
e a( ( e t nd

tefcss g eth ddn tn e t k o t eij r sc u et p e c ieac u s o te t n .n
h a t u g s e i o e d o n w h nu y' a s o r s rb o re f r ame t l
W is v Tas r 1 ' I . t El ve h Cicui af i d t ti c ts de s on t e ude a
l on . e ntI nc , he e nt r t fnne he ral our ' ci i o xcl
,

teai physcin' c us ton t si ony be aus t physcin di notne d t know wha c e
r tng
i a s a a i e tm
c e he
ia d
e o
t aus d

t pl ntf bac facur i or t te t ij y.303F.App' 708,71 (11h Ci.2008)
he ai ifs k r t es n der o rat he nur
x
2 t r
.

And t El nt Cic t i Unie St e v He r on hel t t t ditit c tere by
he eve h r ui n
td ats . nde s
d ha he src our r d
al ng t tea i physcin t opi on c us ton whe e t physci s team e di not
lowi he r tng
i a o ne
a ai
r he
i an' r t nt d

rq iead tr n to o h w teplitf wa ij r d 4 9F.d 1 3 1 0 ( 1hCi. 05 .
e ur ee miain f o h an if s nu e . 0 3 29 , 3 0 1 t r 20 )
Be a e Dr Chi di nots ta Rul 26()2)B)r por,a t f t s s he
c us . n d
ubmi
e a ( ( e t nd he acs ugget

n i rc n i ee n rr le o t c u eo M au fsij re t p e ci te t n,ti Co r
et o sd rd o eid n he a s f lf n u is o r srbe r ame t h s u t
he
GRANTS i partSa ' Eas' M oton t Li i t Tesi
n
m s ts i o m t he tmony ofPl ntf ' Tr atng Physcin
ai ifs e i
ia

t p e ld Dr Chnfo o frn h so ii na o t h c u eo M au fsij re .
o rcu e . i r m fe ig i pn o b u t e a s f lf n u is

2 M o int Li tTe t n o t eRe s n b e s o ant f'M e ia Bis
. to o mi si y n h a o a lnes fpl i l s dc l l
mo
f
l
Sam ' Ea tco e t tt Cour s d ba Dr Chi fom sai hi opi o aboutt
s s nt nds ha he
t houl r . n r t tng s ni n
he

ra o a ln s o Plitf' me ia b l . wih c u ain S m ' Ea tc n e d t a d atn
e s n b e e s f an ifs d c l il As t a s to , a s s o tn s h t t l o
s
g
tme durng t c s of Pl ntf s te t e di Dr Chi dee mi t r as blnes of
i
i he our e
ai if r am nt d . n tr ne he e ona e s

Pl ntf me c bil i or rt te tt Plitf. ( f' Re .7. He e howe ,Sa s
ai ips dial ls n de o r a he anif' De.s pl ) r ,
'
ver m'
f ist pr de a s
al o ovi ny uppor f t ssa e e lkey be aus Coursc it nty a lw te tng
t or hi t t m nt i l c e
t ons se l lo r a i

p ysca st o ie o te ra o a e e so aPlitf' me ia b ls S eT a s rpto T il
h iin o pn n h e s n bln s f anifs dc l il. e r n c i f ra
Pr e digs at27 3,Col man v.Home De U S. ,I . No.1: 5- 21 UU,201
oc e n
2-7
e
pot
A. nc,
1 CV- 5556

W L 45 20,a *1( D. a.M a.23,201 ( E.1 )( . ngseyChi tsiyi a t
431 t S. Fl r
6) D. 05 Dr Ki l
n etf ng bout he
t c lprceofas cfcme c pr e e) s ealo Hal' Camp,I v De e ,394 So.2
ypia i
pe ii dial oc dur ; e s
ls
nc. . ck r
d

1 41( a Dit Ct Ap 1 81 (r ai gp y iintsi e a t a u t blsa dt erc u a
0 F1, s. . p. 9 ) te tn h sca ett d s o mo n of il n h i a s l
i
c ci t teame r ndee ;S.Pac R.R.v Mont v 3 F. 50,5 3 (t Ci.1 )
onne ton o r t nt e rd)
.
. alo, 97 2d
2-5 5h r 968

(ee t c ne to t a p an ifd d n tp o d s fiin p o ft ft r a o be e s o
rj ci o tn in h t litf i o r vie u fce t r o i he e s na ln s f
ng
o
me c l bil i ured f t s r i e of doct s who we e c ld i o c ula in by t
di a ls nc r or he e v c s
or
r ale nt ons t to
he
teai physc a ' be us She te i physcin t tfed t tt c r s of t c ule
r tng
ii n,' ca e t r atng
t
i a esii ha he ha ge
he ons t d
docor we e r s bl a t r wase denc t the wasf m ii rwih t s r i st had
t s r ea ona e, nd he e
vi e ha
a la t he e vce hey

pef med',
ror '
)

6

A c r ngl t s Cour D ENI S i par Sa ' Ea ts M oton t Li i t Tes i ony of
co di y, hi
t
E n
t m s s'
i o m t he tm

Pli ifsTr tng Physca i or rt pe tDr Chi st si ony a
antf
eai
i in n de o nni . n' e tm
boutt r s blnes of
he ea ona e s
Pl i if sm e c bil .
a ntf
di al ls
CO N C LU SI N
O

Bas on t f eg ng,i i he e
ed he or oi t s r by
O RD ER ED A ND A DJUD G ED a f l w s:
s olo

() ExpetW ines TetmonyofNi eBona re( E.35 i
i
r t s si
col
pa t D. ) s
G R AN TED .

(i Dee nts Moton t Li tt Tesi
i)
fnda '
i o mi he tmony of Pli ifs
antf
Trai Physca ( . Ki ly Chi ( E. 42) i
e tng
iin Dr ngse
n) D.
s
G R ANT ED i par a DEN I i par .
n
t nd
ED n
t

( Dee ntsM oto i GRANTED t t extnti
a) fnda '
in s
o he e t
s e t pr ve Dr Chi fom ofe i hi opi on
e ks o e nt . n r
f rng s ni

a o ttec u eo Plitf sij re .
b u h a s f anif nu is
( Dee n ' M oi i DENI t t extnt i
b) fnda ts ton s
ED o he e t
s e t e ude Dr Chi s t si ony a
e ks o xcl
. n' e tm
bout t
he
r a ona ene sofPl ntf' m e ca bil .
e s bl s
ai ifs di l ls

V ks
p.
D ON E AN D O RDER ED i Cha be s a M i m i Fl i ,t s
n
m r t a , or da hi

W
FEDERI A.
C

ofN ove be 201
m r 7.

W

NO

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

Copi f r s d t
es u nihe o:
Couns lofRe d
e
cor