Spence v. Monowara Kabir Corporation et al

Filing 10

ORDER granting 9 Motion for Default Judgment in favor of Garfield Spence against Monowara Kabir Corporation, Raja's Family Investments, Inc.. Closing Case. Signed by Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/8/2018. See attached document for full details. (da00)

U NI D STATES D I
TE
STRI C O U RT
CT
SO U TH E RN D I
STRI O F FLO R I A
CT
D

CASE NO. 1 CV- 96- ORENO/SEL
: 8- 6O5 M
TZER
GA RFI
ELD SPE N CE ,

Pl nt f ,
ai if
VS .

M O N OW A RA K AB I C O RPO R ATI N ,
R
O

d/ a KW I STOP FOOD STORE a
b/
K
nd

M JA ' FAM I I ESTM E NTS , I C .
S
LY NV
N ,

De endant
f
s.

D EFA ULT JU D G M ENT A GA INST D EFE ND AN TS

TH I CAU SE i be ore t Cour u pon Pl nt f ' V e i i M ot on f Fi
S
s f
he
t
ai ifs r fed
i or nal

Def t Judgm ent agai
aul
nst Def
endant M ONOW ARA IABI CO RPO RU I N
s
I R
O

d/ a KW I STOP FOOD STORE a RAJA' FAM I Y I
b/
K
nd
S
L NVESTM ENTS, I C .
N
( E.9)fl d Jul 25,201 Pl i iffld t s ac i n on M ar h 20, 2018. O n
D.
ie
y
8. a ntf ie hi to
c
M ay 2, 2018, t Cl k ent ed Def t agai t Def
he er
er
aul
ns
endant , M O NO W A RA
s

KABI CORPORATI d/ a KW I STOP FOOD STORE and RAJA' FAMI Y
R
ON b/
K
S
L
I
NVESTM E NTS , I . due t t r f l r t pr
NC
o hei aiu e o oper y an s er or ot w i e
l
w
her s
pr
oper y pl
l ead t t Com pl nt I E.8 . The e o e i i he e y
o he
ai . D. )
r fr ,t s r b
O R D ER E D and A DJU D GE D as f l s:
olow
Pl nt f ' Ver f ed M ot on f Fi D e aul Judgm ent agai D e endant
i ifs
ii
i or nal f t
nst f
s

M ONOW AM IABI CORPOM TI d/
I R
ON b/a KW I STOP FOOD STORE a
K
nd
RAJA ' FA M I I ESTM ENTS , I . is G M N TE D . Judgm ent i hereby
S
LY NV
NC
s
1

ent ed i f
er
n avor of Pl nt f G ARFI LD
ai if
E

SPEN C E agai s D ef
n t
endant
s

M ONOW ARA IABI CORPORATI d/b/a KW I STOP FOOD STORE a
I R
ON
K
nd
RAJA ' FA M I I ESTM ENTS, I
S
LY NV
NC. The Cour her ENJOI Def
t
by
NS
endant ,
s

MONOW ARA KABI CORPOM TI d/ a KW I STOP FOOD STORE and
R
ON b/
K
RAJA' FAM I I ESTM ENTS, I , f om contnui i s di i i or
S
LY W
NC. r
i ng t
scrm nat y

pr tc s a ORDERS De e nt M ONOW ARA KABI CORPORATI d/ a
ac i e , nd
f nda s
R
ON b/
KW I STO P FO O D STO RE and RAJA ' FAM I I ESTM EN TS , I C . t al
K
S
LY NV
N
o ter

Kw i St l
k op ocat at 2300 SW 4t Ave
ed
h
nue, For Lauder e,FL 33315 (t
t
dal
dhe
d

Fa ii/' t c
c lt ) o ompl wih 42 U. C.j 1 1 1 c se asf lo
y t
S.
2 8 , f q. p l ws:
AC CESSI LE ELEM ENT S
B

a.

D ef ndant RAJA ' FAM I I
e
,
S
LY NVE STM ENTS , I C . shal m odiy t
N ,
l
f he
acc
ess ai e t t access bl par ng s
sl o he
i e
ki
pace w hi i not l vel du e
ch s
e
t t pr nce of a ram p i t access ai e, so t e access ai l i
o he ese
n he
sl
h
se s
i com plance w i h Sect on 502 .4 oft 20 10 A DA AG st
n
i
t
i
he
andar
ds.

b.

D ef
endant, M JA' FAM I I
S
LY NVE STM ENTS , I C . s l m odiy t
N , hal
f he

access bl par ng s
i e
ki
pace w hi i not l vel due t t pr ence of
ch s
e
o he es
ram p si fares i t accessi e par ng space, so t acces bl
de l
n he
bl
ki
he
si e

parki space i i com plance w i h Sect on 502 .4 of t 20 10
ng
s n
i
t
i
he
A DA AG s andar
t
ds.
D ef
endant, R AJA ' FAM I I ESTM ENTS , I . shal m odiy the
S
LY NV
NC ,
l
f

access ail adj
se acent t t accessbl parcng s
o he
i e
li paces havi a
ng
s r ace sl
u f
ope i excess of 1: s t acc
n
48, o he
ess ai l i i com plance
se s n
i
w i h Sec i 502. oft 20 10 A D AAG st
t
t on
4
he
andar and ar not l ve .
ds
e
e l
2

d.

D ef
endant, R AJA ' FAM I I ESTM E NTS , I ,shal m odiy t
S
LY NV
NC.
l
f he

r p l
nm
eadi f om t acc i e par ng space t t access bl
ng r
he
ess bl
ki
o he
i e
ent ances w i h a sl
r
t
ope exceedi
ng 1:
12, so t
he rnm p i
s
com planc w i h Sect on 405. oft 2010 AD M G st
i e t
i
2
he
andar .
ds
e.

D ef
endant RAJA' FAM I I
,
S
LY NVESTM ENTS, I ,shal m odiy t
NC.
l
f he
rnm p si fares w hi have a sl
de l
ch
ope i excess of 1:10, so the ram p
n

si f ar ar i com plance w i h Sect on 406 .3 of the 20 10
de l es e n
i
t
i
A DM G stm adards.

D ef
endant M O NO W A M
,

KABI C O RPO R ATI N ., shal m odiy the
R
O
l
f

i eror of t Faciiy whi h has sal and se i
nt i
he
lt
c
es
rv ces count
ers
l ng any por i of t count t
acki
ton
he
er hat has a m axi um hei of
m
ght

36 (hit si i
t ry- x) nches fom t fnihed foor,s t count i i
r
he i s
l
o he
er s n
com plance w i h Sec i 904. of t 2010 AD M G s andar , a1
i
t
t on
4
he
t
ds 1

portons of t sal and ser ce count e
i
he es
vi
er xceed 36 (hit si
t ry- x)
i
nches i hei f om t f ni d foor
n
ght r
he i she l .
g.

D ef
endant M O N OW A M
,

K ABI C O RPO RATI N , shal m odiy t
R
O
l
f he

door l ng t t res r
eadi
o he
t oom ar of t Faciiy w hi l
ea
he
lt
ch acks a
pr
oper m i m um m aneuver ng cl
ni
i
earance,so t door l
he
eadi t t
ng o he
r r
est oom i i com plance w i h Sect on 404. .4 of t 20 1 AD M G
s n
i
t
i
2
he
0
st
andar
ds.

3

R ESTR O O M S
a.

D ef
endant M O NO W AM
,

IA BI CO RPO M TI N , shal m odiy t
I R
O
l
f he

r r
est oom si w i h i
nk
t nadequ at knee and t cl ance, so t
e
oe ear
he

r r
est oom si i i com plance wih Secton 306 of t 2010
nk s n
i
t
i
he
ADM G st
andar
ds.
b.

D ef
endant, M O NO W ARA K ABI CO R PO M TI N , shal m odiy t
R
O
l
f he

l v o i s a o snks i t r s r m s whi h ha e po e pi s
a at re nd/ r i
n he e too
c ve x s d pe
and s f
ur aces and ar noti
e
nsul ed or confgur t pr ec agai t
at
i ed o ot t
ns
cont , so t si i i com plance w i h Sect on 606 . 5 of t
act
he nk s n
i
t
i
he
20 10 A DA AG st
andards.
C.

D ef
endant, M O NO W AM

I BI CO R PO M TI N , shal m odiy t e
G R
O
l
f h

cont ol on t f
r s
he aucet r
s equi e pi
r nchi and t ni of t w r s s,
ng
ur ng
he i t
so t f
he aucets are i com plance w ih Secti 309. 4 of t 2010
n
i
t
on
he

AD M G st
andards.
d.

D ef
endant M O NO W AM
,

K AB I CO RPO M TI N , shal m odiy t
R
O
l
f he

m i or i t bat oom s e
rr n he
hr
xceedi t m axi um hei ht per i t ,
ng he
m
g
m t ed
so the m i ror i com plance w ih Sect on 603 .3 of t 20 1 AD M G
r
n
i
t
i
he
0

st
andar
ds.
D ef
endant M O NO W A M
,

K AB I C O RPO M TI N , shal m odiy t
R
O
l
f he

r r s havi gr bars ad acentt t com m ode,so t gr
estoom
ng ab
j
o he
he ab
bars are i com plance w i Sect on 604 .5 of the 20 10 AD M G
n
i
th
i

st
andards as t r
he ear bar i t s
s oo hort
.

4

Def
endant M ONOW AM
,

IABI CORPORATI N, s l m odiy t
I R
O
hal
f he

hand oper ed fush cont olwhi h i not l
at l
r
c s
ocat on t o
ed
he
pen s de
i
of t access bl st l so t fus cont ol i i com plance wih
he
i e al,
he l h
r s n
i
t

Sec i 604. oft 2010 ADM G s andar .
ton
6
he
t
ds
g.

D ef
endant M O N O W ARA KABI CO R PO RATI N s l m odiy t
,
R
O
f he
, hal

i
nadequat cl
e ear t ni space i t r r
ur ng
n he est oom

,

s t
o he cl
ear

t ni s
ur ng pace i t r r
n he est oom i i com planc wih Secton
s n
i e
t
i
603. 1 of t 2010 AD M G s andar .
2.
he
t
ds
D ef
endant M O NO W AR A K AB I CO R PO M TI N , shal m odiy t
,
R
O
l
f he

door har
dwar oft bat oom e r
e
he
hr
nt ance whi has oper e par s
ch
abl
t
w hi requi e t ght gr
ch
r i
aspi , pi
ng nchi or t i i of t w r st so
ng
w st ng
he i ,

t r t oom door har
he es r
dwar i i com plance wih Secton 309.4 of
e s n
i
t
i
t 2010 A DM G s andar .
he
t
ds
D ef
endant M O N O W AM
,

KABI CO RPO RATI N , s l m odiy t
R
O
hal
f he

door of t r t
he es room w hi l
ch acks a proper m i m um m aneuve ng
ni
ri

cl ance, so t door t t r t oom i i com plance wih
ear
he
o he es r
s n
i
t
Secton 404. 4 oft 2010 ADM G s andar .
i
2.
he
t
ds
A1 r er
1 ef ences t '
o '
ADAAG st
andar ' s l r er t ADA Accessi lt
ds' hal ef o
bii

y

Gui lnes f Buidi
dei
or
l ngs and Faciii (
ltes ADAAG) as am ended t ough
hr
Septem ber 20 lO.

The above- ef enced al er i
r er
t at ons and m odii i
f cat ons s l be com pl ed i
hal
et n
a1 r pe s by D ecem ber 3 1 20 18. I t al er i
1 es ct
f he t at ons and m odii i
f cat ons are
,
not com pl t i a1 res t by D ecem ber 31, 20 18, t
e ed n 1
pec s
hen D ef
endant ,
s
5

M O NO W AM

KAB I C O R PO RATI N
R
O
,

RAJA ' FAM I I ESTM E NTS
S
LY NV

,

D/ A KW I STOP FOOD STORE a
B/
K
nd

I ,shal be s j t r onabl s tons
NC.
l ub ect o eas
e anc i

t com pelcom plance wih t s Judgm
o
i
t hi

ent Sai sanctons m ay i ude butnot
.
d
i
ncl

be lm i ed t per di
i t
o
em fnes a
i

nd/or t cl ng of t pre i untl s d
he osi
he m ses
i ai

m odii i ar c pl ed.
fcatons e om et
Accor ngl i i he
di y, t s reby ORDERRD AND AD
Ver f ed M ot on f Fi
ii
i
or nal Def t Judgm ent
aul

KABI CORPO RATI ,
R
ON

agai s D e endant , M O N O W AR A
n t f
s

D/B/ KW I STOP FOOD STORE and RAJA' FAM I Y
A
K
S
L

I E STM ENTS , I . ( E.91 i GZANTED
W
NC D.
,s
The C ourt

JUD G E D t
hat Pl nt f
ai ifs

.

r t ns j idi ton of t a v s yld ac i n t perm i
e ai urs c i
he bo e- t e
to o
t

Pl nt f
i if

seek at or s f
t ney' ees and cost and t
s
o as e D ef
sur
endant
s,
M O N OW A RA KABI CO R PO R ATI N
R
O , D/ A KW I STOP
B/
K
FO O D STO RE and
RAJA ' FAM I
S
LY I
NVE STM ENTS , I , subseque
NC.
nt com plance wih t s
i
t hi
Judgm ent and t Am er cans w i h D i
he
i
t
s lt es Act
abii i
.

DO NE AND SI
GNED i Chnm ber at M i i Fl i t s
n
s
nm , or da hi
,
2018.

FE
U

C opi f r shed t
es u ni
o:
Counselof r
ecor
d

6

/.
day ofAugus
t

RI
. M
REN O
D STATES D ISTR I JU D G E
CT