USA, et al v. South Florida Water, et al

Filing 2412

ORDER granting 2384 Motion to Adopt/Join; adopting 2397 Report and Recommendations; granting 2401 Motion to Adopt/Join. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 8/19/2013. (tkn)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO URT FO R THE
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI A
CT
D
M i m iDi s on
a
vi i
C as Num be 88- 886- I M O R EN O
e
r: 1
C VUN I
TED STA TES O F A M ERI ,
CA
Pl i if
a ntf ,

SO UTH FLOR I A W A TER M AN A GEM EN T
D
DI
STRI etal,
CT, .
D e e nt .
f nda s

O R DER A DO PTI G R EPO RT S O F TH E SPEC I M A ST ER
N
AL
TH I CA U SE ca e be or t Cour upon t U nie St t s M oton t A doptM ar h 1
S
m
f e he
t
he t d a e '
i o
c ,

201 Re toft Spe ilM atr( E.No.2384) fld on De ember28.201 a t St e
2 por he ca se D.
, ie
c
2 nd he at
Pa te 'Motont AdoptRe omme tonsConti di t Re t t Spe al a tr( ac
ris
i o
c
ndai
ane n he por of he ci M se M rh
29, 3)Supplme i t Specal trsMa c 1 201 Re r ( E. 2401)fl onAprl
201
e ntng he i Mase ' r h , 2 po tD. No.
ied
i
23.2013.

On M a ch 1 201 t Spec alM a t r i s d a Re r es a i hi r als i de dlne f
r , 2, he
i
s e s ue
po t t bls ng e i tc a i s or

opeai ofsor trte t ntae (
rton t mwae rame ras STA)r ere t asComparment B a C.Thepa tes
,ef rd o
t s nd
ri
r que t d t Cour hol t m a t ri a ya t e gei s tl e di c s onsont M a m um
e s e he
t d he t e n be nce o nga n e tem nt s us i
he xi

AnnualDic r Li t(1
s hage mi $
MADL'. TheCour hel t matri abe euntlNove rl
'
)
t d he te n yanc i
mbe 2,
201 a o M a c 25, 3 hea d o a a gum e on t Unied St t ' oton t A dopt he M a c
2 nd n r h 201
r rl r
nt he t
a es M i o
t
rh
1 201 Re tof t Spe i M aser A tt he r ng,t Cour r ques e t Spe a M as e
, 2 por
he
c al
t .
he a i he
te
t d he
ci l
tr
s ppl m e hi i ta R e t a hefl d hi s e en al por on M a ch 29, 3.N ow , o e
u e nt s nii l por , nd s e s uppl m t Re t
r
201
bef r
t Cour,a et m otonst ado bo h r t . ot bl t pa tesa e i a ee e f t m os
he
t r wo
i o pt t epors N a y, he r i r n gr m nt or he
t

pa tha t Cou ts d a fnn t Re t oft Spe a M ase .
r t t he r houl fi he pors he cil t r
Sum m a y oft M a ch 1 201 Re t t Spe a M as e
r
he r . 2 por of he ci l
tr

Thi Cour i tucedt Spe a M ase on M a c 31 201 t r comm e dea i sf t
s
t nsr t he cil t r
rh , 0 o e
nd dlne or he
c
ompltonofsor t te t e a e r f redt asCompa t e sB a C. TheM a ch 1 201
ei
t mwaer r am nt r as e e r o
rm nt nd
r , 2

Re r o te S e ilMa tre tbih sd a ln sfrt e c mpein o t e p o e t lse i
po t f h p ca se sa ls e e d ie o h o lt f h rj cs itd n
o
A ppe x A t t J y 5,
ndi
o he ul 2006 Re t l hi Re t t Spe a M as e r om m e
por . n s por , he ci l
t r ec
nds:

( )TheCour deemi t tJ y31, 2i ar lsi daebywhiht Dititmus be
1
t tr ne ha ul 201 s eaitc t
c he src
t
te tng wat ri Com pa t e B a t no t l a s he n t ow w a ofCo pa t e
rai
e n
rm nt nd he r he ' nd out r l
n
ys
m rm nt

C, u j c t rc ito p r t n e e t d sh r ete tdwae a ln a tefiu eo
s be t o e ep f e mis e d d o ic a g rae tr s o g s h alr r
i biiy of t r ul t r a nci s t i s pe t i tm e t m e t t s r c m e d
na lt
he eg a o y ge e o s ue nnis n i o e hi e om nde
de i i notr l t d t an ac sorf iur t ac by t D it i t
adlne s
ea e o y t
a l e o t he s r c .

( Asf t ce r fo wa ofCompa t ntC,heSpe a M aserr omme t tt
2) or he ntallw y
rme t
cil t ec
nds ha he
Cour die tt Spe a M a trt is af l up Re ta Rec me ton oncet
t r c he cil se o s ue olowpor nd
om nda i
he
r s uton oft c t a r s ceis sa s i t w ih t c nta fow wa a efnai d
e ol i
he ulur l e our s ue s oc aed t he e r l l
y r i lze
a a c t c i pl n a s he e ha be n a ove by a 1s a hol r .
nd onsnz ton a nd c dul ve e ppr d
1 t ke de s

Sum m ar oft M a c 29.201 Re toft Spec alM a t r
y he r h
3 por
he
i
se

A ltl overaye rl tr t SpecalM ase s e
ite
a ae ,he
i
t r upplmentd hi Re t Hea s t tt
e s por.
dvies ha he
N o t Buidou ofCom parm e B a t norhe n a s her tow w a ofCo pa t e C a e
rh l t
t nt nd he t r nd out n l
ys
m rm nt r

f ly ope a i l Se tng ade dlnef c plton oft s a e i no m oot
ul
r tona . ti
a i or om e i
he e r as s w
.
TheSout BuidoutofCompm men B a t ce r tow wa ofCompa t e C r quie
h l
t nd he ntall
y
rm nt e r
ve t ton gr t whi h i a i i t d i t 201 w e s s
ge a i
ow h, c s ntc pa e n he
3 t ea on. l t Cour dee s a dea i
f he
t m
dlne

a opra e t Spe i lM ase r co mendst Cour s ta de dlne ofOc o r1,201 f t
ppr it , he c a
tr e m
he
te
a i
t be
3, or he
Sout BuidoutofCom pa t en B t be f l ope a i .
h l
rm t o ' y r tonal
ul

Obi to t t Re rs
eci ns o he po t
The pa te al a e t Cour s d a
ri s l gr e he
t houl doptt Re t oft Spe a M a t r The U nie
he por s he ci l s e .
td

St t a t M icos eTrbeofl a ofFl i so ypoi tofco e i i af not i t
aes nd he c uke i
ndins
orda' nl n
nt nton s oot e n he
St t Pm i s M oto t Adoptt M a c 29, 3 Re t Tha f not r ie a est a gum ent
ae
e ' in o
he r h
201
por . t oot e e t r t he r
s
m a by t St t Pa tes i t r M oton Se ng D e l r ton of Com pla e wih t Cour '
de
he a e r i n hei
i
eki
caai
i nc t he
ts
Se e be 30, 2 Or ra W ihdr
pt m r 201 de nd t awal Re e enc t Spe a M a t r The Cour wila es
of f r e o ci l s e .
t l ddr s
t s i s i a s pa a e or ron t tm o i
hi s ue n e r t de
ha ton.
TH E COU RT hasco i r d t m otons t r pons s a t pe tne por i oft
nsde e he
i , he es
e , nd he ri nt tons he
r c d,a be ng ot wi e f l a s d i t pr m i es i i
e or nd i
her s uly dvi e n he e s , t s
A DJU D G ED t tt m o i a e GR AN TED a t Cou tA FFI S t Repor oft
ha he tons r
nd he
r
RM he
t he

Spe a M a trdae M a ch 1 201 a t Supplmen a Re t t M a c 29, 3.TheCour
cil se td r , 2 nd he
e t l por daed r h 201
t
fnds i moott s ta dea i f t Norh BuidoutofCompa t e B a t no t r a
i t
o e
dlne or he
t
l
rm nt nd he rhe n nd
s he n fow w a ofCom pa t e C .The Cour s t adea i ofO c obe 1 201 f t Sout
out r l
ys
r m nt
tes
dlne
t r . 3, or he
h
Buidou ofCom pa t e B t be f l ope a i l
l t
r m nt o
uly r tona .

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha
n
mber a M im i Fl i ,t s
s t a , orda hi

da ofAugus ,
y
t 2013.

FE
CO A .M
N
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J DG E
CT U
Copi pr de t
es ovi d o:
Speci M as erJol Bar t
al t
m
ket
Couns ofRe or
el
c d