Patton v. Dept. of Corrections

Filing 30

ORDER denying without prejudice 28 Motion for Issuance of CJA 30 Voucher for Purposes of Preparation of and Representation During Application for Executive Clemency. Signed by Judge James I. Cohn on 6/14/2012. (awe)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI COU RT FO R TH E
CT
SOU TH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
FO RT LAU DERDA LE DI SI
VI ON

Cas No.05e
22228- V- HN
CI CO
R O BER T PA TTO N ,

Pe ii r
ttone ,
VS
,

K EN N ETH S.TU CK ER ,Se r t y,
c e ar
Fl i Depa t e ofCorec i ,
orda
rm nt
r tonsl

Res
ponde .
nt
/
O R D ER

THI CAUSE i be or heCour onpeii nersM oto orl s eofCJ 30Vouc r
S
s f et
t
tto '
i nf s uanc
A
he
f Pum os sofPr pa a i ofa Re e e ato DurngApplc i f Exec i Cl m e y.
or
e
e r ton nd pr s nt i n
i
iaton or
utve e nc

(i oi n' g 2 Ja dRepo ei Op sto t M oinf rIs a c o aCJ Vo c r
' to ' DE 8 n s ns n po i n o t o su n e f A u he
M
)
i
o
g 29 . OnAu u t31 2 0 ,h Co r d ne M rPatn' p tto f r i o h b a c r u .
DE )
g s , 0 6 te u t e id . to s eiin o m t f a e s o p s
( 1 ) OnAu u t2 2 0 ,h Elve t Cic iCo r o Ap asd n e a a p iainf ra
DE 6 .
g s , 0 7 te e nh r ut u t f pe l e id n p lc to o
Cet aeo Ap e lb ly.DE25 . Al s f y a sltr Mr Pat na pe r t b s e ig
ri t f p aa ii (
fc
t
1 mo t i e r ae, . to p a s o e e kn
ve
e c i ce e y fo t Gover of t St t of Fl i a woul lke t f de a
xe utve lm nc r m he
nor he ae
orda nd
d i he e r l
gove nmen t a i hi co e andpr dec
r
t o ppo nt m uns l
ovi ompe a i f rs hpr ee ngs TheCour
ns ton o uc oc di .
t
ha c r ulyr vi we t M oton a i ot r s f lya s di t pr mi e .Fort r s
s a ef l e e d he i nd s he wie ul dvie n he e s s
he ea ons
t tf l t M oton i denid.
ha olow, he
i s
e

Peii hasr que td t t Cour G r c t is nc ofaCJ 30Vouc rt Todd
ttoner
e se hat he
tt e t he s ua e
di
Ahe o
1Kenneh S.Tuc ri now t pr pe r s
t
ke s
he o r e ponde i t spr e ng. Tuc s ul
nt n hi oce di
ker ho d,
t e or ,ça t tca l 'bes tt e asapa t unde Fe r Rul ofCi lPr ed e
her f e iu oma i ly' ubsiut d
ry
r de al e
vi oc ur

2 ( )1 . eClr i dr ce t do k t ndc a g t ed sg ainof h Re po e t
5 d ( ) Th ek s ie td o c e a h n e h e in to t e s nd n .

G. he f
Sc r orpur esofr pr e i
pos
e es ntngpe ii ri sa eclm e ypr edi ,na c da ewih
ttone n tt e nc oce ngs i c or nc t

1 U. C. 3 9 a dHa bs nv Bel5 6U. 1 0( 0 9 . (DE 2 )a 4 .I s p r o h s
8 S. j 5 9 n r io . l, 5 S. 8 2 0 )' I 8 t ) n u po t f i
'
M o i Pe ii rha pr de t Cour wiht doc
ton, ttone s ovi d he
t t wo umen s The et doc e ss t t
t . s wo um nt how ha
Peii
ttoner r quese a wa gr e c ta nt c
e t d nd s antd our- ppoi ed ouns l t r pr e hi du i hi
e o e es nt m rng s

e c i ce nc pr e ngs (DE 28- ,28- ) Howe r Peii rltrsae i t
xe utve lme y oc edi . g
1 21.
ve, ttone ae tts n he
M o i t tt ap nt e wa vac t don M a 1 201 Pe ii rdi no pr det Co t
ton ha he poi m nt s a e
y 6, 2. ttone d t ovi he ur
wih a doc nt ton s
t ny ume a i howi t a nt ntwa va a e
ng he ppoi me
s c t d.Furher e, hef t bass
t mor t acual i

f r h r le rq e tdi ta 'it s h u d rin d' u desa dngta t eP bl Dee d rs
o t e eif e u se s h tf l i t e n esg e s n rtn i h t h u i fn e '
l
c
Ofi eofe e t unde sg snn t t sa ec ta ana l ecou elbu t Atom e
fc f r d he
r i ned' me o he tt our s vaiabl
ns t he t y

Ge ea ' Ofieo j ce t t u d rin d sa p it n , o tn igt a sae1w p e e td
n r ls fc b e td o he n e sg e ' p onme tc n e dn h t tt a rv ne
t a nt nt ca eunde sg dr pr e edPe ii ri hi sa eposc ci ltga i
he ppoi me be us
r i ne e es nt
ttone n s tt
t onvi ton ii ton

whl sil ne ly eo CCRC- o t ' (DE 28 a 3 .Pei o r r vd steCo r wihn
ie tla mpo e f
S uh. I
'
) t ) tt ne p o ie h u t t o
i
f t ri or i r g di t d s ii n o hi r ques f rc e e y c
urhe nf maton e ar ng he iposto f s e t o l m nc ouns li t sae
e n he t t

c u to h rt a t s yt tt eAtone Ge e a' Ofieo j ce .Ac o dn l,heCo r i
o r, t e h n o a ha h tr y n rls fc be td c r igy t u t s
una r i Pe ii ri unr pr s nt da t ssa ofhi c e
wa e f ttone s e e e e t hi t ge
s l menc pr ee ngsori hei smpl
y oc di
f si y

no r pr s nt byM r Sc r Ass ch, heM oton i nots
t e e e ed
. he .
u t
i s
upporedby af ct b i s fcint
t
a ual ass ufi e
t a y hi r
o nal ze s eque t l a one gr ntr le .
s , et l , a e i f

Peii ri c r tha Har s hedt tj a horz f r l a ntdc el
ttone s orec t t bion l ha 3599 ut ies edealy-ppoi e ouns
t r pr e t i cle si sat clm e ypr ee ngsa enttest m t c pe a i f t
o e es nt her int n t e e nc oc di nd il he o om ns ton or hat

r pr e ai Howev , bion i f c ua l ditnguiha efom Pe ii r i t tt Stt
e es nt ton.
er Har s s a t ly si s bl r
ttone , n ha he a e
of Tenne s e doe notpr de f r c r- ppoi e c ns lt r pr e i ge ci nt i
se
s
ovi o ou ta ntd ou e o e es nt ndi nt le s n
ce e ypr e i . The Stt o Fl rdadoe .
lm nc oc ed ngs
ae f oi
s

W hen die ta la epr e ngspr ec ed b apublc de e ron be fofa
r c ppe lt oc edi
os ut y
i f nde
hal n

a c s da dc a ln igaj d me to c n ito a d s ne c o d ahtr n t
c u e n h le gn u g n f o vcin n e tn e f e t emiae
i an a fr a e ofs h c ci a s nt nc whe he by t Fl i Supr m e
n
fim nc
uc onvi ton nd e e e, t r he orda
e
Co torby t Unie Stt s Supr m eCo torb e r to ofa dea i f
ur
he t d ae
e
ur
y xpiai n
ny dlne or
flng s h a ali a sa e orf de a c t t publc de ende s lnotf t
ii uc ppe n t t
e r l our, he
i f r hal iy he
a cus d of hi or he rght pur ua t Rul 3.
c e
s
r i s s nt o
e 850,Fl rda Ruls of Crmi l
oi
e
i na
Pr dur ,i l ng a tme lm ispe tne t r t a s l a s s h peron
oce e ncudi ny i i t ri nt he eo, nd ha l dvie uc
s
t tr pr e a i i a c lt r lpr e ngsi t r ponsbiiy oft c pial
ha e es nt ton n ny ola e a oc edi s he es i lt
he a t
colatr r gi co ms l Thepublcde ende s lt n f war alorgi fl s
l e al e onal t e .
i f r hal he or d l i nal ie
on t ma t t t ca t lc lt r lr gi lc
he ter o he pia ola e a e ona ouns l r t ni s h c e f rhi
e , e ai ng uc opi s o s
orhe fls a ma be de ied.Howe r t ti c ts al r t n t powe t
r ie s y
sr
ve , he ral our h l eai he
ro

a po n t e b i df n e o o h ra tr e n t mply db tec pi c l e a
p i th pu lc ee d r r t e to n y o e o e y h a t ol r l
al at
r g o alc n e t rpr s nts c pe s n i pr c e n f rr le b e e u ie
e in ou s l o e e e u h r o n o e digs o ei y x c tv
f
clme ypur uantt s .2740and 27530
e nc
s
o s .
. 3.

Se F A. T 2 .( )a(mp ssa d d . Th r f r,i i u ieyt a Pei o rwo l b
e L S AT. 7 15 ()e hai d e )
ee o e t s nl l h t t ine ud e
k
t
entte t f r lyf dc e nc co ele n i hi M o i ha bee s fce l pl be a e
ild o ede a l unde l me y uns , ve f s ton d n ufi inty ed, c us

Ha bs ne rsl f u dt tfu s cin()2 p o ie f rc u s l ny wh nasaep tto e
r io xp e sy o n ha S b e to a( ) r vd s o o n e o l e tt eiin r
s
i u a l t o t i a e uaerp e e tto . Ha bs n 5 6U. a 1 8 (mph ssa d d ; e as
s n be o ban d q t e r sn ai n' r io ; 5 S. t 4 8 e a i d e )s e lo
'
Iikv Bel 6 6F3 2 9 2 ( t Ci. 01 )ç d ciet o lg t t f d rlg ven n t
rc . l, 3 .d 8 , 91 6h. r 2 1(we e ln o biae he e ea o r me t o
:
p yf rc u e i saepr c e ig wh r tesaeis l h sa s me ta o lg to ' s eas
a o o ns ln tt o e dn s ee h tt tef a su d h t b iain. e lo
);
Be v Ba ly 3 F d Ap . 4 (t Ci. 0 )1 t v nit eS p e Co rweet o etr
y , g e 01 e . px 4 2 6h r2 08(ç e e f h u rme u t r o v ru n
Bu
o rh li gi Ha bs n,heis ea c ri e t t eCo r i t a c s i wh te j3 9 p o ie
u od n n r io t su s etf d o h u tn h t a e s eh r 5 9 r vd s
i

arg t of d rlyfn e c u e i saece n ypr c e i g wh ntesat h srf s do f ie
ih t e eal u d d o nsln tt lme c o e d n s e h t e a eu e r a ld
t pr vd c z â /ltmp a i i o iia) Snc P tto e i t be't o ti a e u t
o o ie // - . e h ss n rgn l. i e eiin r s t l' o b an d q ae
ne'
a
r pr e a i ptr ua t sa elw, s dnotqualf f f r lya nt d a c
e es nt ton ls nt o tt a he houl
iy or ede a l ppoi e nd ompe a e
ns t d
co e f ssa ecemenc oce di . Howe r snc t M otonl c s fcinti or ton
uns l orhi tt l
ypr e ngsz
ve , i e he i a ks ufi e nf ma i
2I c r a nl m a c nge t a ys si Pettone w a ç e't r ce ve a ua e
t e t i y y ha
he nal i f ii r s l ' o e i deq t
abl
clm e ycouns lunde Fl rda1 butt sae c t a isdic ei de e hi r ques f
e nc
e
r o i aw
he tt our, t t s r ton, ni d s e t or
t a nt nt Tha i nott c r nts na i be or t Cour.Atbes,t M o i a s rs
he ppoi me . t s
he ure ce ro f e he
t
t he ton s e t
t s a e cour de e Pe ii rt c
he t t
t ni d ttone he ouns lofhi choos ng. Thi i a e ie y dif r nti s
e
s
i
s s n nt r l f e e s ue.

t ra hame isd tr n to ,ti d ne wih u p eu ie
o ec
rt eemiain i s e id t o t rj d c .

DON
EANDOR RE iC a estotadra ,lr ahsYtdyo Jn,
DE D n hmbraF rLu edl Foi tik h a fue
e d
--

201
2.

JAM ES 1 COH N
.
U M T STA TES DI
STRI T
C
cc:couns ofr d
el ecor

GE