Polycarpe v. E & S Landscaping Service, Inc. et al

Filing 75

ORDER Denying 61 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 11/3/2011. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O U RT
C
SO UTH ERN D I
STRI T O F FLO R I A
C
D
M i iD i s on
am
vi i

Ca eNo.07- 223- J
s
23
CV- LK
RESI S POLY CA RPE a
A
nd
REYN OLD SU LLY
a a1 ohe ssm iary st t d,
nd 1 t r i l l iua e

Pli tf s
a n if,

E & S LANDSCAPI SERVI I
NG
CE, NC.
a ERN ST M A YA RD ,
nd
De e nt.
f nda s
/
ORDER DENYI DEFENDANTS'M OTI FOR SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
ON
THI M ATTER C e be or t Cour uponDe enda s' oto f Su ma yl
S
Om S f e he
t
f nt M i n or m r udgm e
nt

( # )fldSe tmb r7 2 1 Th ri , fn a t s e s mma yj d me t ag igta te
DE 61,ie pe e , 01 . een Dee d n s e k u r u g n , r un h th
Pl ntfsha f ie t pr ent uf e e de ei s ppo t ft i mpai ove tmeandr tlat y
ai if ve a ld o es s fcint vi nc n u r o hert d ri
ea i or

dic r cai unde t Fai La Stnda dsAc (TLSA',t t ei i ufii e de e
sha ge l ms r he r bor a r
t(
' hather s ns fcent vi nc
)
ofda es a t tPl ntfs a undoc e edwor r , a notbrngs tunde t FLSA.
mag , nd ha ai if, s
um nt
ke s m y
i ui
r he
The
Cou t sf l bre edi t m at rlUpo c r f consde a i oft r or a t pladi ,he
r i uly if n he te .
n a eul
i r ton he ec d nd he e ngs t
Co tfndsi m us de De e nt 'M o i f Summ a y J
ur i t t ny f nda s ton or
r udgm e .
nt
1 Le St
. gal andar
d

li welstldt a s mmayj d me t sa p o raewh r t epe dn sa ds p o t g
t s l-ete h t u r u g n i p r p it ee h la ig n u p ri
n
matral esabls t tt r i noge neis a t a ma e i f c a t t movi pa t i
e i s t ih ha he e s
nui s ue s o ny t ral a t nd hat he
ng ry s

1Pl ntfsfldaRepo e( #65 onSe e r26, ,a Dee t fl a
ai if ie
s ns DE )
ptmbe 2011 nd fndans ied
Re y( #69)onOcobe 11 2011
pl DE
t r , .

e tte t j g n a amatro lw.Se Fe R. v. 5 ; l e Cop. .Car t, 7U.
nild o ud me t s te f a
e d. Ci P. 6 Ceotx r v tet47 S.
31 ,3 2 ( 9 6 .S mmay j g n ma as b p r p it wh r,a tra e u t tme f r
7 2 1 8 ) u r ud me t y lo ea p o rae e e fe d q ae i o
dic ver apa t f ist ma as w i s fcint oe tbls hee se eofa es e i eeme
s o y, ry al o ke ho ng ufi e t sa iht xitnc
n s ntal l nt
t t tpa t sca e a onwhi ht tpa t wilbe t bur nofpr a til Cel e 477U .
o ha ry' s , nd
c ha ry l ar he de
oof t ra . otx,
S.

a 3 2 3 W h ne au tn amoi nf rs
t 2 -2 . e v l aig
to o ummayj d me tlthee i e c of h n mn v n i
r u g n,ç l v d n e t e o o a t s
l

t b b l v d, n a1u tfa l ifrn e aet b d a i h sfv r'Se An e s nv fie t
o e ei e a d 1j siib e n ee c s r o e rwn n i a o . e d r o . b ry
e
'
Lobb I c.477U. 242,255( 986)
y n,
S.
1 .
lI A nal s
.
ysi

l t a
n he bove syld aci Pl i if ,f m e e oye ofa l nds a ng c
- t e ton, antfs or r mpl es
a c pi ompa s ek
ny, e

moneayda ge f unpai ove tmewa a rt i or dic r undert FLSA.Compl,
tr ma s or
d ri
ges nd ealat y s hage
he
(
.
DE /1.l t M oto f Summar J
/) n he in or
y udgme ,Defnda sagu t tt Pl ntfshavef l t
nt e nt r e ha he ai if
aied o
pr s nt uf i nt vi ncei s ppo t t i
e e s ic e e de n u r of herunpa dove tm ea r t laor s har cai sunde
i
ri nd e ai t ydic ge l m
r
t FLSA,t tt r i i ufi inte de e ofda
he
ha he e s ns fce vi nc
mage ,a t tPl ntfs a undoc e e
s nd ha ai if , s
um ntd
wor r ,may notbrng s tu rt FLSA .Fort f l wi r a ons De e nt M o i f r
ke s
i ui nde he
he olo ng e s , f nda s' ton o
Summ a yJ
r udgm e mus bede ed.
nt t
ni

Upon consder ton oft r co d,t Cour fndst Pl i if ha pr ded s scint
i ai
he e r he
t i hat antfs ve ovi
uf e
evi nc i s
de e n uppor oft i c am sa i s
t her l i nd n uppo t da
r of mage . ihr pec t t unpai ove tme
s W t es t o he
d ri
cai 2Pli if t sii dt tt r we ewee whe t y wor d ove 40hour , twe enotpai
l m, antfs e tfe ha he e r
ks n he
ke
r
s ye r
d

o tmewag .Aug.3 2011Pol apeDe , 1 -1 DE #64- J 3,2008SulyDe , t
veri
es (
0,
yc r
p.at 08 0,
69 une
l p.a

2Toe tbihacam f ru p i o ri , anif mu tp o iee i n et tl S eo
sa ls li o n ad vet Plitfs s r vd vde c ha:)t r
me
h
s wor dove tmewihoutc
he ke
ri
t
ompe ai ' nd2)t tt e oye çkne ors dha
nston'a
ha he mpl r ç w houl ve
k o o t o e t wo k.Al nv ## o b Ed cf rBibCk@.4 5F.d 1 0 ,1 4 5
n wn f he v ri
me r ' l . . fpu . u . o b
' e
, 9 3 3 6 31 -1
( t Ci. )
11h r2007 .
2

56 ,DE #64- )Pli if as t tfedt tt Dee nt di note oyas tm f ke pi
-58
1. antfs lo esii ha he fnda s d
mpl yse or e ng
ar or ofhour wor a i tu t d t f e n nott doc
ec d
s ked nd nsr c e he or me
o umen t hour wor d by t
t he
s ke
he

ln s a esa v ro sj b st s ( y21 2 0 Er s M a adDe , t41 4 DE / 4 1 ; u e3
a d c p r t aiu o ie .Ma , 0 8 n t y r p.a - 2, / - 0 J n ,
6
2008PolcapeDe ,a 36,DE #64- .De piet lck ofdocu nt e de ofPli if'
y r
p. t
4) s t he a
me my vi nce
antfs
al ge ove tm e t rt si ony pr dess fc e e de e i s
le d ri , hei e tm
ovi
ufi i nt vi nc n uppor oft unpad ove tme
t he
i
ri

cam be a s t Dee a t aealg dno t h v k p rc r . e ,eg.Ale v Bd o b
li c u e he fnd n s r le e t o a e e t e o ds S e . , ln . fpu .
Edu .o BibCny, 9 F.d 1 0 ,1 l 1 7 8( 1h Ci. 0 )(e e sngg a t sl r
cf r b /.4 5 3 3 6 3 4, 31 -1 1 t r 2 07 rv ri r n of t
mmay
j d me tnd fn a ' f v d s ieç anif 'a ko d c me tto a dia ii t saewi
u g n i ee d nts a or e p t ' i tfs lc f o u nain n n blt o tt t
Pl
y
h
pr c son t numbe ofunc
e i i he
r
ompe ae hou st y wo ke a t d o whih t two k wa
ns td r he
r d nd he ays n
c ha r
s

pefnne 'wher t a cu a yofdee tsrc d- epi pr e eswasque tone .W ih
ro d'
e he c r c
fndan ' e or ke ng oc dur
si d) t
r s tt t r a it y dic r e cli , bot Pl ntfst tfed t tt y we e fr d a tr t y
e pec o he etla or s ha g am 3 h ai if esi
ha he
r ie fe he

c ane t as ni o a notbengpadf t i ove tmehour.(une3,
ompli d o upe s r bout
i i or her ri
sJ
2008SulyDe ,
l p.

a 41 42 DE # 4 1 Au . 0 201 Poy apeDe .a 1 8 DE # 4 6 . kn t se i e c i lg t
t - , 6 - ; g 3 , 1 lc r
p , t 1 , 6 - )Ta ig hi v d n e n ih
m os f a et t Pl ntfs t Cour fndst r i s fc e evi nc i s ppo tofbot t
t avor bl o he ai if , he
t i he e s ufi i nt de e n u r
h he
unpa d ove tm ea r tla or dic r cai t rt FLSA .
i
ri nd ea it y s ha ge l ms mde he

l a d to teCo r fn sta teElv n hCic id cso i Pa e v Qu lt 1 nS.8 6
n d iin,h u ti d h th e e t rut e iin n tl , a i n , 4
y
F. 700( 1hCi.988)hasf e os dDefnda s agume t undoc ntdwor r ma
2d
1 t r1 , orcl e e nt' r nthat
ume e ke s ynot
brngaca m unde heFLSA.npatlt El ve h Cic thedt tundoc nt /leg wor r
i
li
rt
I
e ,he e nt r ui l ha
ume ed il al ke s
quaii d a S mpl es' i bl t brng ac am undert FLSA . J.De e
lfe s ç oye 'elgi e o i
e
li
he
f
f ndan sur t sCo t
t ge hi ur

3Toesabls aprmaf i ca eofrt ito Pl ntfsmus pr dee de et t 1
t ih i ace s ealain, ai if t ovi vi nc ha: )
t ye ge i saut iyprtce co tore esi 2)t ys frdadves e oyme
he nga d n tt orl oe td nduc xpr son; he ufee
re mpl nt
a tons bsque tt s haci t and3 t tt r wasaca allrkbewee t prt td
ci u e n o uc tviy;
) ha hee
us il t n he oece
c
onduc o expr s i n a t a r ee oyme a ton. itev.Unie Tec ,1 F. 956,
tr
e so nd he dve s mpl
nt c i f tl
td h. 03 3d

959( 1hCi.1 .
1 t r 997)

t dse adt eh dn i Pae b s do teUn td S ae S prmeCo r d cso i Hof n
o irg r h olig n tl a e n h ie tts u e
u t e iin n fma
Pl tcCompounds l .v NLRB,535U. 1 (
asi
, nc .
S. 37 2002) whih hed t tilgalwor r aenot
, c l ha le
ke s r
e tte t r i undert Na i lLa Rea i Ac .Onl a f w m o hs ago,t El ve h
n ild o elef
he tona bor ltons t
y e
nt
he e nt

Cic i rj ce ti v r ag me tS eGad me v N d D I v Cop.43 F d Ap x 8 ( 1h
rut ee td h s e y r u n . e la s . r n . r , 2 e . p' 01 1 t
Ci. 01 )( odngPae i si v l bidn p e e e t s- fma Pl si Co u d , n ..
r 2 1 h li tl s tl ai n ig rc d n po tHof n a t mpo n s I c)
l d
c
As tl o tn e t b v l bn igp e e e tnti Cic i,h Co r d n e s mma y u g n
Pae c ni u s o e ai idn rc d n i h s rutte u t e is u r j d me t
d
ont sgr und a we l
hi o
s l.
Ac r ngl ha ngc i e t pa te 'flngsa bei ot r s ad s d,i i he e
co di y, vi onsder d he ri s i nd ng he wie vie t s r by

ORDERED,
ADJUDGED, DECREED t t fndant M otonf Summar udgme (
and
ha Dee
s' i or
yl
nt DE
#61 be a t s i hee DENI
) , nd he ame s rby,
ED.
DO NE a O RDERED i Cha
nd
n mber atheJ mesLa enc Ki Fe r lJ tceBuidi
s t a
wr e ng de a usi
l ng
a Unie St t Cou t e i M i mi Fl i on t s3r da ofNovembe ,2011
nd t d aes rhous n a , orda hi d y
r
.

k

s LAW RE
NCE KI
NG
.S.
DI T CT COURT
S RI
SOUTHE D I TRI OFF ORI
RN S CT
DA
CC:

Co n ef rPli t s
u s lo ant
Jas SaulR e er
on
m
Re e & Ge g - e r
m r
or es pi r e
Ne W ord Towe
w
l
r
1 N Bi c yne Boul va d
00
sa
e r
Suie 28
t 00
M i i FL 33132
am ,
305- 6- 00
41 50
Fa 41 5005
x: 6-

Emalje r rpatr e .o
i:rme @ g ton ysc m
4

M athe St e W eber
t w anl y
Reme & Ge gespire
r
or - e r
1 N . s a Boul va d
00 Bic yne
e r
Suie 28
t 00
M i mi FL 331
a ,
32
305- 6- 000
41 5
Fax:[phone]

Emal mw@r p to n ysc m
i:
g atr e .o
Co ns l o De nd n s
u ef r fe a t
C hri K l ppi
s e n
Gl s rBo e h & Klppi
ase r t
e n
8 W es Br a d Boul va d
751
t ow r
e r
Suie 1
t 05
Pl nt ton,FL 333
a ai
24
95 424- 933
41
Fa 954- 4- 405
x:
47 7

Emal ga o @a l o
i: lb r o . m
c
Bar y G .Fe ngol
r
i d
8751W .Br r Boul va d
owa d
e r
Pl ntton,FL 33324
a ai
954424- 933
1
Fa 954- 7405
x:
474-

Emal b za a ooc m
i: a lw@y h .o
K ri opher W aler Zi ak
st
t
nchi
G l s er Bor t & K l ppi
a s , e h,
e n
8751W . owa d Bl Suie 1
Br r vd. t 05
Plnt ton,FL 33324
a ai
95 424- 933
41

Emal k 6 4 g i.o
i: wz z @ mal m
c