Vincenzo et al v. Carnival Corporation

Filing 32

ORDER granting 17 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 4/24/12. (dge)

UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT FOR THE
CT
SO U THERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
M i iD i son
am
vi i
C as N um be 09e
r: 20234- V - O R EN O
CI M
A N TO I ETTE V I CEN Z O
N
N
VI
NCEN ZO ,

and J HN
O

Pl ntfs
ai if,

CARNI
VAL CORPORATI
ON a M I I
nd
AM DA DE CO UN TY ,
De e nt .
f nda s
O R D ER G M N TI G M O TI N TO D I I
N
O
SM SS
TH I CA U SE c m e be or t Cour upon D e e ntM i m i Dade Count sM oton t
S
a
f e he
t
f nda
a y'
i o

DimisfrLa ko Su j c M atrJ rs it n ( E. . 7 .Plitf Anon t Vi e z
s s o c f be t te u idci D. No 1 ) anif t iet nc n o
o
e
s f r d af la t Po1 ofM i mia br
ufe e al t he 4
n nd oughts ta i tCa ni lCo por to puruantt
ui gans r va r ai n s
o

M aii a dAd r l uidito a da an tM imiDa eCo nt pu s a t os p e na
rt n miat rs cin n g is a - d u y ru n t u plme tl
me
yj
j iditonove c
urs ci
r ommonlw ne i nc Dee ntM imiDa Count aguest tt r i
a glge e. fnda
a - de
yr
ha hee s

lc o a miat u idcin b c us t eij r t o pa ea trt Pli tfsh dp r n nl
a k f d rlyj rs it e a e h n u y o k lc fe he anif a ema e ty
o
depa t t s p a we e movi t oug t por ofM im i The Cour ag ee t i lc
red he hi nd r
ng hr h he t
a .
t r s hat t a ks

s j tmatrj iditono rt smatra t rf et moi t dimisi g a e
ubec te urs ci ve hi te nd heeor he ton o s s s r ntd.
FAC TU AL BA C K G R O U N D

Pl i if a e r s dent ofPa m Bea h,Fl i . U pon c pl tng a f day cr s on t
a ntf s r e i s
l
c
orda
om e i
our
ui e he

ve s Ca i all a nai Ant nete Vi nz Srppe a f lwhie se ng down alr
s el m v m gi ton, oi t nce o l i d nd el
t
l t ppi
a ge
se ' l e tng t C ta e oft r i lD . Cons quenty, antfstl d a Ame
t p'whie xii he t
por r a e m na '
'
e
l Pl i if i e n
nded

Com pl i a l gi ne i nc by Car va Cop or ton a M i iD ade Count
a nt le ng glge e
ni l
a i nd am y.
M O TI N TO D I I STA N DA R D
O
SM SS
$To survi a m oton t di m is,pl ntfs m us do m or t m er y s at l
$
ve
i o s s ai if
t
e han
el t e egal
concl ons,'i t pl ntfs m us talege s e s fc f ualbasi f t
usi ' nsead ai if
ts l
om pecii act
s or hose concl i or
usons

fc dimis oft i cams' Jac - v Bel t Teec
a e s sal her li .' kb . lsouh l omm.372F.d 1 0,1 ( 1hCi.
on
,
3 25 263 1 t r
2004) W he r i o amoi t dimis aco tmus viw t c ai i t lghtmos
.
n ulng n
ton o s s, ur t e he ompl ntn he i
t
f abl t t pl ntf and acceptt pl ntf s wel- eaded f s ast ue. See St Jose s
avor e o he ai if
he ai if
lpl
act
r
. ph'

Hop.I .v Hop.Cor o ,795F. 948,953( 1hCi.1 6) Thi tne, ve,doe
s , nc . s
p. fAm.
2d
1 t r 98 . s e thowe r s
n a yt lgalc l i .Se As r? v I ,l S.Ct 1 1 49(
ot ppl o e oncusons e hc o . qbal 29
. 937, 9 2009) Morove,
. e r
iwj l lg c l i ca pr detefa wokofacompli ,t ymus b s
i hie e al oncusons n ovi h rme r
l
ant he
t e uppore by
td
fcua ale tons' l a 1
a t l lgai . d t 950. Thos 'fa t al ai mus b e ght r iearghtt
'
e ' jcual leg tons t e nou o as i o
g
r le a
e i f bove t s c a i l velo t a s pton t ta loft c pl i ' ale tonsa e tue.
he pe ul tve e
n he s um i ha 1 he om a nts l ga i
r r '
'

Bel l Cor v.Twombl 550U. 5 545( ) l s r,t c antmus notmeey
lAt. p.
y,
S. 44,
2007 . n ho t he ompli
t
rl
alege a m iconduct butm us dem onstat t t pl
l
s
,
t
r e hat he eader i entted t r i See I , 129 S.
s il o elef
qbal
Ct at 1
. 950.

I t ec s o amoint ds s f rlc o s be t te j rs ito ,s eb r e t
n h ae f t o imis o a k f u j c matr u idci n çh u d n o
o
t
etbls t e se eofs j c f eals j tmatrj iditonrsswiht pa t brngi t
sa ih he xitnc ube t ed r ubec te urs ci et t he ry i ng he
cli ' Swe tPe Marne L/ v Al a i ,I .41 F. 1 42,1 n. ( 1hCi.2005 .
am.
' e a i , t . uM rne nc, l 3d 2 248 2 1 t r
@
)

TheElve hCic thasr e t tamoto t dimisfrlc ofs j tmatrj iditoni a
e nt rui
uld ha
in o s s o a k ubec te urs ci s
f alatack t Sr r t courtm er y ..l and s i t pl ntf hassufi enty aleged a
aci t hat çequies he
el . ook
ee f he ai i f
fci l l

ba i f s be tmatrj iditon. St k v Oran Re 1He t ar S .524F. 1
ss or u jc te urs ci ' aly . l do g
'
alhc e ys,
3d 229,
1 33(1 t Ci. )
232- 1h r 2008 .

2-

-

D I U SSI N
SC
O
The U nie St t s Cons iuton au horze f de alc t t he r t l Cas ofad ialy
td ae
tt i
t i s e r our s o a ' l es
a
m rt

a maii J iditon. U. Cons.a4 11 j2, .l.
nd rtme urs ci ' S. t l. 1, c1 Howe r ifdealc t ha a
'
ve,de r ours ve n

id p n e t b iaint e u et a te d n t xc e teso eo ter u idcin'
n e e d n o lg to o ns r h t h y o o e e d h c p f h ij rs ito .
'
Hendes v Shise i U. ,1 1S.Ct ll 1 ( 2) W heeapli ifi okes
ron . n k,
S. 3
. 97, 202 201 . r antf nv

a miat u idcino e atr cam, eS s s tsyt c n to of o hlc to a d
d rlyj rs ito v r o t li h é t aif he o di ns b t o ai n n
mu
i
c
onne ton w ih m artm e a tviy. Gr r v Gr atLake D r dge t Doc ,Co. etal,51
ci
t
ii
c i t ' ube t . e
'
s e
:
t
k
,
. 3

U. 527,53 11 S. .1 43( 995) Thel ai t tdic r ' he t t toc re o
S.
4, 5 Ct 0 1 .
oc ton es s ens s
whet r he or cur d n

na ia l wae o wh te ij r s fee o ln wa c u e b av se o n via l wae '
vg be tr r eh r n uy u frd n a d s a s d y e s l n a g be tn'
I ( tng46U. C.
d. Cii
S. App.j7 )
40 .Thec
onneci is us sat pa tt tt deemi
ton s ue e wo- r es o tr ne

j rs ito a s fce c , e urng()wh t rt icd n ha ap tnilydsu iei a t
u idcin l ufiin y rq ii 1 ehe he n ie t s o e tal ir pt mp c
v
onmaii c
rtme ommec a ( whehe Shege r c a troft a tviygi ngrs t t
re; nd 2) t rç
t neal harce he ci t vi ie o he
i de s
nci nt howsas tnta r ai hi t maii a tviy.'d.( i Sis v Rub 491
ubsa il eltons p o rtme ci t '1 quotng s on . y,
U. 358 364,11 S.Ct289 ( 990)
S. ,
0
. 2 1 .

Th Plitfsalg tefl a dr s ligij r t o pa ewh l ç xtn tep r ae a
e anif l e h al n e utn n u y o k lc ie s iig h o t r a t
e
e
t r na D.'Si e t Pl i if c e t y we enoto t boa orna ga ewa e ,i m us
e mi l ' nc he antfs onc de he
r
n he t
vi bl t r t t

bedeemi di t ij ywasca e byt vese.çNfaii 1 ...or naiyte t a
tr ne f he n ur
us d he s l k jrtme aw
l
di rl ras n
çppu tna e'at c d t aves eli na ga e wa e sa pa toft ves elis l 'I a 535,
a re nc ta he o
s n vi bl t r s r he s t ef' d t .
s e al o Vi t r Car i r I v fJw,404 U . 20 2 1 2 11 92 S. . 18 30 L. 2d 383
e s coy
r e , nc. .
S. 2, 0- ,
Ct 4 ,
Ed.

( 971.Theque tont nbe
1 )
si he comeswheherornott por a e attr nalD i a a re ce
t
he t z a e mi
s n ppu tnan
oft Ca i ll a na i
he m va m gi ton.Aspr ousyr a one i t Sout r Diti to Fl rda û
evi l e s d n he
he n src f o i , s
an
a tnanc i an s ciialy i ntfa eie t ti de tne f us a d as c fc ly
ppure
e s y pe fc l de ii bl t m ha s si d or e boar pe ii a l

i tf a e ves ela i es e i lt t ves elsna g ton, oper ton,ormi son.'Gon al zv.
den ii bl
s nd s s nta o he s ' vi a i
ai
si '
z e

M/ siyPanama,1 F.Su zd 1 1 ( D. a.2000) Eve viwi Pl ntfs
vDe tn
02
pp. 352, 356 S. Fl
. n e ng ai if'
cai si t mos f vo a e lghta f de t m,t i ta e a t na D'c l be
l m n he
t a r bl i for d he he f
por r a t enni l ' amot
c i r d f us a r t Car va I a nai n, c n i beconsde ed e s nta t t
onsde e or e boa d he ni l m gi to nor a t
i r s e i l o he

v se' na iain o eain, rmiso .Sic t el c to c n to f rs hj rs ito i
e s ls vg to , p rto o sin n e h o ain o di n o uc u id ci n s
i
n tstsid Plitfsaeu bet s c sf l ivo ea miat j rs ito f rat r cam.I
o aife , an if r na l o uc e sul n k d rly u id cin o o t li t
y
i n tn c sayt a d e st eij r ' c r cint maimea tvt
s o e es r o d r s h n u y s ome to o rt ci i
i
y.
Pl i if a g t t c u s tc tpr desa c r t r r m e t tt y fl s t
a ntf s r ue hat he r i e i ke ovi
ontac ual equie nt ha he ie ui
a i tCa ni lCor a i i f der lco ta s h f m s l c i i va i a e o c a e.
ga ns r va
por ton n e a ur nd uc onz e e ton s ld nd nf r e bl
Pl i if pr vi d t i c ui e tc ta e de oft s c r ta i s
a ntf s o de he r r s i ke s vi nce hi ontac nd n uppor oft i a g e
t he r r um nt
t tve i pr r The c pl t l ua i t tc t a not by bot pa tes s a e :
ha nue s ope .
om e e ang ge n he i ke , s ed
h ri , tt s

Exc pta pr de i Clus 1 d)bel i i a e dbya bewe t Gues
e s ovi d n a e 2(
ow,t s gre
nd t en he
t
a Ca ni t al diput sa ma tr wha s ra ii unde ,i c
nd r val hat l s e nd te s toeve rsng
r n onne ton
ci
w ih ori i ntt t sCont a to t G ue ts c u s i udi t a lt a fom
t
nc de o hi
r c r he
s ' r i e, ncl ng r ve o nd r
t ve s ,s l be ltga ed,i a a l be or t Unied St t Di t i tCour f
he s el ha l ii t f t l, f e he t
a es s rc
t or
t So he n D i ti tofFl i i M i i o a t t e l w s t i w hi t
he ut r s r c
or da n am , r s o hos a uis n
ch he

Fe ea Co rso teUni d S ae lc s be t te j rs cin b f r ac u t
d r l u t f h t tts a k u jc matr u idito , e oe o r
e
l caed i M im iDa Count Fl i ,U. A. ot exc uso oft Coursof
o t n a - de
y, orda S. t he l i n he
t
a ot r c y,s a e orc r
ny he ount t t
ount y.

Plitfsaec re t h tti ln u g i v l Sn et sfd r l o r lc ss b e t te
anif r o rc t a h s a g a e s ai ic hi e ea c u ta k u j c matr
d.
j rs ito ,h rman e o tec nrc p o ie t a Plitfsmu ties i i M imiDa e
u id ci n t e e id r f h o ta t r vd s h t an if s tl ut n n - d
Count Fl r da.
y, o i

Pli if aeuna et esa ih a r lyj iditonove Cani Comortonor
antfs r bl o tbls dmiat urs ci
r r val
ai
MimiDa Count Thee oe,rla eo 28U. C.j13 i or rt e e s e ntl
a - de
y. rf r einc n
S.
67 n de o xtnd upplme a

j rs ito o e asaelw t r cam i mo t a n s be tmatr'rs ito e ss
u idcin v r tt a o t li s o, s o u jc te J idcin xit.
u

-

4-

C O N C LU SI N
O

ADJUDGED t tt Motont Dimisf rLac ofSubec M at J iditoni
ha he i o s s o k
j t ter urs ci s
G RAN TED ast bot Def nda Ca ni Cor a i a M i m i Dade Count A l o he
o h
e nt r val por ton nd a y. 1 t r
pe ng m o i a e D EN I a m oot The Pl ntf sar f e t s i t s a e c t of
ndi
tons r
ED s
.
ai i f e r e o ue n he t t our s
M i m i Da Count
a - de
y.

lldy ofApril,2012.
m
a

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r a M im i Fl i ,t s
n
mbe s t a , orda hi

.
'

'

) ..
: .
.
v

.
.

.

)'
:
'
'

.
.

,.

CO A . O REN O
M
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STR I J D GE
CT U
Copi pr ded t
es ovi
o:
Couns lofRe or
e
c d

-

5-