Jude Gillespie et al v. Kaplan University et al
Filing
433
ORDER denying 399 Motion to Abate and 405 Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 12/9/2013. (tpl)
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTHERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO . 20756- V - TZ/ M ONTON
09C1 SEI Sl
UN I
TED STATES OF AM ERI
CA,
e r lJ
x e. UDE GI
LLESPI
E,
Pl ntf,
ai if
K APLAN UN I ERSI ,e al,
V
TY t .
D e e n s.
f nda t
ORDER DENYI M OTI N TO ABATE AND M O TION FOR RECONSI
NG
O
DEM TI
ON
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on Rea orsM oton t Aba eEntyofFi l
S
s f e he
t
lt '
i o
t
r
na
J m e st Alow M a sr t ' Or rt Be Efe t t a Aced Upon a M oto f r
udg nt o l
gita e s de o
f c uaed nd t
nd
in o
Ex dtdBrei ga dCo sd rto g 3 9 a Reao J d Gils i' Rul 5 ( )Mo in
pe ie ifn n n ieain DE-9 ) nd lt r u e le pe s e 9 e to
t Re i rOr ron Summ ay J
o consde de
r udgmen a Ale orAm e J m e Ent r d The e
t nd t r
nd udg nt e e
r on
( 4 5 .Bohmoi n se t s t sd t eCo r' tn lud me te trda trteg a t of
DE- 0 ) t to s e k o e a i e h u ts s a j g n n ee fe h rni
ng
s mmayj d me t nfv ro Dee d n s TheCo r g a tdDee da t as mmayj d me t
u r u g n i a o f f n a t.
u t rn e fn ns u r u g n
a trfndi t tRelt c d note tbls a eeme ofhi c am ,na ey,s i ntr Bot o
fe i ng ha
a or oul
sa ih n l nt
s li
m l ce e . h f
Reao ' moin s e t h v t Co r re a n iss mmayj d me td cso .Ho v r
lt rs to s e k o a e he u te x mie t u r u g n e ii n we e ,
Reat hasnotm e hi bu de t esa ih t ne f r onsde a i Cons que l bot
l or
t s r n o t bls he ed or ec i r ton.
e nty, h
mo i nsa edeni
to r
ed.
Th M oton t Abat
e
i o
e
Reao frtmo e t a aee tyo t etna j d me t c u ete ewa o ttn i g
ltr is v s o b t nr f h i l u g n be a s h r s u sa d n
dic r a t tm et Cour en e ed isOr rGr tng Summ a y J m e .Re aoras e t
s ove y t he i he
t t r t de an i
r udg nt l t s rs
t t t unpr
ha he
oduce doc e s t t M agita eJ eha or r Def ndan st pr e,
d um nt ,hat he
sr t udg d de ed e
t o oduc
mi ha co a ne e de e e t bls ngDef nda s s i ntra t tt Cour s d ha
ght ve nt i d vi nc sa ihi
e nt ' c e e nd ha he
t houl ve
watdt a d e st es mmayj dg n moi su tl he Dee a t h dp o uc dte
ie o d rs h u r u me t ton n ia r fnd ns a r d e h
doc e s a or r d by t M ag sr t Ju e.
um nt, s de e
he
itae dg
Att tm et Or rGr ntng Summ a y J m e wase e e t sc eha be n
he i he de a i
r udg nt
nt r d, hi as d e
pe ng f ne ry tvea ahafye r , asg t
ndi or a l s nd
l a s l inikanta oun oftme, hei s ha be n f l
m t i t s ues d e uly
j ie f rt y as a db t pat s moinsf rs mmayj dg n ha b e fldtr e
on d o wo e r, n oh ri ' t o u r u me t d e n ie h e
e
o
mont e rir Thus ds oveyha be n ongoi f ye r att tmet s
hs a le .
, ic r d e
ng or as he i he ummayj
r udgme
nt
m otonswe edecded. W hiet Cou twa awa eoft outtndi dic y,no pary
i
r
i
l he
r s r
he sa ng s ovel
t
a s d i t tt dic ywasormi htha be r l va t t pe ng m otons Ha
dvi e t ha he s over
g
ve en e e nt o he ndi
i . d
hef tt dic r wa r lva ,Relt s d have butm a no a t
el he s ove y s ee nt aor houl
,
de
tempt wha s ve t
s t oe r o
no iy t Cour t tt ou sa ngdicove yha a be rng o t motonsf s
tf he
t ha he tt ndi
s r d ny a i n he i
or umm a y
r
j d me t Un e Fe e a Ru eo Cii Pr c d r 5 ( ) Reao c udha es u h t d fr
u g n . d r d r l l f vl o e u e 6 d , ltr o l v o g t o ee
r i on t pe ng motonsu i a trt dic er ha be n pr
ulng he ndi
i
ntl fe he s ov y d e oduce Re a o di nots e
d. l t r d
ek
s h r i . See ng s h r i now a
uc elef
ki uc elef
ppea st benot ng mor t n anate a as c bie
r o
hi
e ha
t mpt t e ond t
a t a e.
t he ppl
Furhe ,t doc nt s
t r he ume s oughtby Relt rwe epr
a o r oduc d t t Cour f a i c r
e o he
t or n n ame a
r viw .A r vi oft doc e st tt M a sr t J
e e
e ew he um nt ha he gitae udge o de e pr
r r d oduce de onsr t
d m taes
t tt ydono c an an i o m ai r l ntt t s i e i s Thus e i De e nt
ha he
t ont i y nf r ton eeva o he centr s ue.
, ven f f nda s
l hiet c e numbe , CVW l he as
r 09- 20756,i c t t tt smate wa fl i 2009,t
ndi aes ha hi
t r s ied n
he
c ewa orgi l fld i t M i eDititofFl i i M ar h 2008a lt rta f redt
as s i naly ie n he ddl src
orda n
c
nd a e r nse r o
t sd src ,r s tng i t 2009 c enumbe .
hi itit e uli n he
as
r
ha pr
d oduce t docume s t ywo d ha hadnoefd ont e tyofs
d he
nt,he ul ve
fe
he nr ummayj
r udgme .
ntz
Fi ly, aorsr lanc onCowanv JC. nne Co.790F. 1 ( lhCi.l ,
nal Relt ' ei e
. Pe y ,
2d 529 1 t r 986)
i mipa e I Co n teElve t Cic irves dag a to s mmayj g n tn igt a
s s lc d. n wa ,h e nh r ut e re rn f u r ud me t i dn h t
t r c d be o et tilc tesa ihe t exitnc ofge ne is sofma e i f c .I a
he e or f r he ra our t bls d he se e
nui s ue
t ral a t d t
1 3 .W h l t Co nc u t lon tdt a tee tyofs mmayj dg n wa p e tr
52
ie he wa o r as oe h t h nr u r u me t s rmau e
be us t r wa outt ndi dic r t c talo no e t tt pl i ift pr pe l
ca e he e s sa ng s ove y,he our s t d ha he antf l
had o ry
br ghtt t diti c tsateni t tt dic r r pons fom ( oft dee t)
ou o he srct our' t ton ha he s ove y es e r one he fndans
wa silouttnd ng. 1 Assaeda
s tl sa i ' d.
'
tt bove Re aori t i t n ca edi no do t s
, l t n he nsa t s d t hi .
Cons que l t M oto t Aba ei de e
e nty, he
in o
t s nid.
T eM oi f rRe o sdea in
h t o c n i r to
on
Relt rha a s fld amoton f r consde ai pur ua t Fe r lRul o Ci l
a o s lo ie
i or e i r ton s nt o de a
e f vi
Pr e e59( .Reaorase t t tt Cour' Juy1 201 Or rGrntngSummay
oc dur e) lt s rs ha he
ts l 6, 3 de a i
r
J
udgme conti d mi a e nsonsoff c a l w a t tf c st twer tr d
nt a ne s ppr he i
a t nd a nd ha a t ha
e e me
iundiput 'i t Or wer diputd ba e on t evi nces bmit byt pa te . Asa
d s ed' n he der e s e s d
he de
u ted he ris
r ul,Re aora gue t tt is ofs int rs ul nothavebe n de i d asam at roflw
es t lt r s ha he s ue ce e ho d
e c de
te
a
b ts o l h veb e s b te t aj r .Reao as ag e t th Co r s o l no h v
u h ud a e n u mitd o u y ltr lo r u s ha te u t h u d t a e
ga tdDee a t' to f rs
r ne fnd n s mo in o ummayj g n wih u a d e sngReao ' Mo inf r
r ud me t t o t d r si lt rs to o
Pa ta Summ a y J m e a Daube tmotons.Be a eneihe oft e a gume shave
ril
r udg nt nd
r
i
c us t r hes r
nt
me i,hemoton f r co i r ton i de e
rt t
i or e nsde ai s ni d.
2n or rf Rel ort unde san t Cour' co l i r r ng t doc e s r t r
1 de or at o
r t d he
ts neuson ega di he um nt, ahe
t flngt docume si t publcr c d(lhoughs ha ale dybe fl ,t Cour
han ii he
nt n he i e or at
ome ve ra en ied) he
t
i or rng De e
s de i
f ndant t pr e t doc e sM a sr eJ
s o oduc he um nt gitat udge Si
mont n o de e pr e
o r r d oduc d
i he J y1 2013Or rg 3 .Deenda t s lpr ucet doc nt t Reaorby
n r ul 2,
de DE-94) f ns hal od he ume s o lt
D e m be 20, 3.
ce r 201
Fis, ltrtk sis ewihf u fcst a t es mmayj d me o d rf u dwe e
rtReao a e su t o r a t h t h u r u g nt r e o n r
u ds ue ( ) h tdn oo ee e tl Ro sta h rp lce mih n tc mp r wi fd r l
n ip td: 1 t a รง l n v r od s h t e o iis g t o o o t t e ea
l
h
lwi'2) t tRos wasupt daeo e oyme tlw is s,ncl ngt Reha lt inAc;
a '( ha s
o t n mpl n a sue i udi he
biiato t
( )t tt
3 ha ' t dKa a souti c e t tKa a wasnoti vi ai oft l des t
OCR ol pln' sde ouns lha pln
n olton he aw, pie
t OCR fndi i' ( t tGayKer r asgne ofaPPA a is waslveyonboadwih
he
i ngs'and 4) ha r be, i r
t sue, k r
r t
me tngt eg ha ltto Acjrquieme s' Reat aguest tt s f t f me t
ei hos Re biiain t e r nt. l or r
'
ha he e acs or d he
b sso t Co tsfn i st t ()t eewa n e ie c t id c t t t p a kn w o
a i f he ur' idng ha: 1 h r s o vd n e o n iae ha Ka ln e r
s ul ha kno i wa no i compla ewiht Re biiai Ac,( t r wasno
ho d ve wn t s t n
inc t he ha ltton t 2) hee
e denc t i c et tKa a e oye sl ke t s lsan expeinc t dot i o , nd
vi e o ndiat ha pln mpl e ac d he kil d
re e o herj bs a
()Ros ha radSeci 50 a wa f mii wih i a isi eme i rgulto .
3 s de
ton 4 nd s a lar t t nd t mpl ntng e ains
Relt rsa gum e s,
ao ' r
nt howe r a e t s m epr vi l r iedby Relt i opposton t
ve , r he a
e ousy a s
a or n
ii o
De e d n s s mmayj d me t to
fn a t' u r u g n moi n.
Re onsde ato o a or rt sa e r r na y r med t bee oye s rngl '
c i r i n f n de k n xtao di r e y o
i
mpl d pa i y.'
Bu ge Kig Cor v As andEquiis I . 1 F.
r r n
p. . hl
te , nc, 81 Supp. 1 l ( D.Fl 2002)
2d 366, 370 S. a.
.
Th r aetr eg o n sfrr c n ieain:( ) nitr e i gc a g i c n r l n lw;()t e
e e r he r u d o e o sd r t
o l a n e v n n h n e n o tol g a 2 h
i
a alb lyo n w e ie c ; n ( )t n e t c re tce rer ro p e e tma ietij sie
v ia ii f e vd n e a d 3 he e d o o rc la ro r r v n n fs n u tc .
t
f a 1
J. t 369. I o dert de onsr t cea e r ,apl i ifm us dom or t n smpl r sa e
n r o m tae l r ror
antf
t
e ha i y e t t
prvi agume sBautsav Cr ieShlsCatrngdrSe vc I e n' .) ,350F.Supp.
e ous r
nt. it . us p
ei
r ie ntr l N M
,
2d
9 7 9 2( D. a 2 0 )
8 , 9 S. Fl. 0 3 .
l i a i ope us oft moton t r c i t as t Cour t r t nkwha t
t s n mpr r e he i o e onsder o k he
t o ehi
t he
Co t... le dyt
ur
ar a houghtt ough-i l orwr y .... Them oton t r onsde
hr
rghty
ongl
.
i o ec i r
wo d bea oprae wher ,f e
ul
ppr it
e or xampl t Cour ha pa e tym iunde sood apa t
e, he
t s tnl s
rt
ry,
orha m a ade ii out i t a r a i is spr e e t t Co tbyt pa te ,
s de
c son sde he dve s ral s ue es nt d o he ur
he ris
orhasm a an e r notofr s ni bu ofa e nson.
de
ror
ea o ng t ppr he i
4
Z. Mari I .v M/ c gei 8 F.Su 1 ,1 ( D. a.1 2)(iai o te
K. ne nc . vAr hi ts, 08
pp. 561 563 S. Fl 99 cttons mitd
a brc t omitd) Thus aE i f rco i rtonc nno beus dt r-ii t o1
nd a kes te . , t on or e nsdeai a t
mot
e o eltgae d
m at s r s a gumentorpr e e de et tco dha be n r iedprort t e r oft
ter , aie r
es nt vi nc ha ul ve e a s
i o he nty he
(h l ng d odel Th sp o i to icu e n w a g me t t a weep e i u l a albe bu
c al e r r. i r hbi n n ld s e r u n s h t r rv o sy v ia l, t
e
i
n t rs e . Wic o ev. e v eT o s I c,5 5F.d9 9, 5 ( 1h Ci. 0 9) itma
o p e s d' lh mb T e e o n , n . 5 3 4 9 7 1 t r 2 0 (n e l
'
q o ainsa ctto o te ) He e Reao h ssmpl r ie t es meag me t h
u tto nd i ins mi d . r , lt r a i y as d h a r u ns e
a
t
pr vi usy made.Relt hasnots
e o l
aor
hown t tt undiputd f t a ediput 34 Thus he ha
ha he
s e acs r s ed.'
,
s
no me hi bur n on am o i f rr onsde aton.
t t s de
ton o ec i r i
Se ond,Rea ora s t t ti wase r f t Cour t deny a mootRea orsM oton
c
lt s ers ha t
ror or he
to
s
lt '
i
f Pa talSum ma yJ
or ri
r udgm e a Daube tm otons Re aori conc ne t tt motonsa
nt nd
r
i . lt s
er d ha he i nd
t i e bism a nothavebe n r e d by t Cou ta t tt Cour m a ha i ope l
her xhi t y
e eviwe
he
r nd ha he
t y ve mpr ry
co i r d Def ndant'expe t.Ast t Dau r motons bec us t s i ntri s di not
nsde e
e
s
rs
o he
be t i , a e he c e e s ue d
r quie c i r ton ofexpe t i nc t Cour di notc i rs h e de ei r i on
e r onsde a i
r evde e, he
t d
onsde uc vi nc n ulng
t es mmayj d me tmoi n Nohn i t eOr rg a tn Dee d n s M o inf rSu r
h u r u g n to . t ig n h de rni g fn a t' to o mmay
3r un s e f tt tI one e rt l Ros t he polci m ihtnotc
'he diputd ac ha '
NO
ve o d
s hat r i es g
ompor wih
t t
fd rllw's o l p o a l h v r a d o e oh rt a Reao j s b f r h fldh sOCR
e ea a ' h ud r b by a e e d t n , te h n ltr u t e o e e ie i
No
c pli ,t d Ros t therpolcismi htnotco
om a nt ol
s ha
ie g
mpor wih f r llw . Howe , hi
t t ede a a '
'
ver t s
c nge i i m a e i lt t out om e b a e i doe nots
ha
s m t r a o he c
ec us t s
how t tRos w asawar t tt
ha
s
e ha he
polcesmi htnotcompl wih f de a 1w a t tm eKa a e e e i o t PPA a is
ii
g
y t e r l a t he i
pl n nt r d nt he
t s ue.
4 l t m ii e r t t f c t tCOCR t d Ka an' ou sdeco elt tKa a was
Re aor sntm es he a t ha '
ol pl s t i
uns ha pl n
no i vi a i oft lw,des t t OCR fndi . Re aora
t n olton he a
pie he
i ngs' l t ppea st i er e t st bea
'
r o nt pr t hi o
Coul fndi t tOCR di nottnd Kapln i v olto o t Re ltto Ac .I i nots h
' i ng ha
t
d
i
a n i a i n f he habiia i n t t s
uc
a fndi Fo t pur esoft M oton f Summar J
i ng. r he pos
he
i or
y udgme ,he Cour a s m e t
nt t
t s u d hat
Rea orc d e t bls t tOCR ha f d t tDef nda s polc e di notc
lt oul sa ih ha
d oun ha
e nt ' i i s d
ompl wiht
y t he
Re biia i Ac .Howe r t r c d e de ,a b t e tbls d t tDef nda s nonha lt ton t
ve ,he e or vi nce t es, sa ihe ha
e nt '
compla eamountd t neg i nc . The e wasnotas i il ofe de e t s
i nc
e o lge e
r
cntla vi nc o uppor a fndi
t i ng
t tDef nda sa t d wih dei r t i fe e eorr c es dir gar t sa r f af s
ha
e nt c e t lbe a e ndif r nc
e kl s se d, he t nda d or ale
c a m sac i
li
ton.
J m e ciest o r le o a ofDe e nt'e t Ast t M oton f Pa ta
udg nt t o, r ei s n, ny
f nda s xpers.
o he
i or ri l
Summ a y J m e ,Rea orsM oton f rPa talSumm a yJ
r udg nt lt '
i o ri
r udgm e f ed on t sng eis
nt ocus
he i l s ue
t tDe e nt ha notc ple wih s c i 504 oft Re biia i Ac .Reat ha not
ha f nda s d
om i d t e ton
he ha ltton t l or s
s
hown t tt compla e is ha be rngont s i n e i s o woul ha c nge t
ha he
inc s ue s a i
he c e t r s ue r
d ve ha d he
ou c
t ome.Thus Relt ha notme hi bur n f r onsde a i
, a or s
t s de or ec i r ton.
Acc di y,ti
or ngl i s
ORDERED t t
ha :
Re aor sM otont Abat Enty ofFi J
lt '
i o
e r
nal udgme st Alow M ag sr t ' Or r
nt o l
ita e s de
t BeEfecuae a ActdUpona M otonf Expe tdBrefnga Consdeai (
o
f t td nd e
nd i or
die i i nd
i rton DE3 i DENI
99) s
ED.
Reao J d Gils i' Ru e5 ()M oint Re o sd rOr e o S mmay
lt r u e le pe s l 9 e to o c n i e d r n u r
J d me t n Ale o Ame dJ d me t trdThee n g 4 5 i DENI
u g n a d tr r n u g n En ee
ro DE-0 ) s
ED.
ByD e e be 20,201 De e
cm r
3, f ndan ss lpr
t hal oducet Rea ort doc e t
o lt he um n s
Ma itaeJ dg S mo t no d rdp o u e i h rJ l 1 2 3Or e ( 3 4 .
gsrt u e i n o r ee r d c d n e uy 2, 01 d r DE-9 1
DONEadOR EDi MimiFoiati V dyo Dee e, 01.
n DER n a , lr ,hs
d
a f cmbr2 3
*
PATRI A A EI
CI
TZ
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
CC:
Al couns lo r or
l
e f ec d
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?