Jude Gillespie et al v. Kaplan University et al

Filing 547

ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR DISQUALIFICATION. Relator Jude Gillespie's Motion for Disqualification of District Court Pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 144 and 28 U.S.C. § 455 (DE 530 ) is DENIED. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 9/13/2016. (mc)

U NI
TED STATE S D I
STR I T CO UR T
C
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FL O RI A
CT
D
CASE NO.09 20756- V- TZ/
C1 SE1 TURN OFF

UN I
TED STA TES O F A M ER I ,
CA

e r lCARLOSURQUI DI etal,
x e.
LLA AZ, .
Pl i if ,
a ntf s

I
QAPLAN UNI
VERSI e al,
TY, t .

De e n s
f nda t .
/

ORDER DENYI M OTI FOR DI
NG
ON
SOUALI CATI
FI
ON
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on Relt JudeGil s e' M oton f
S
s f e he
t
a or
le pi s
i or

Diq lfc tonofDiti Cour Puruan t 28U. C.j1 a 28U. C.j455( 5301
s uaiiai
srct t s t o
S. 44 nd
S.
DE- .
Gils e,a pa e l dis tsi d wih m a oft Co tsr i i t sm at r s e t ha
le pi p r nty s a ife t ny he ur ' ulngs n hi te , e ks o ve
t unde sgnedr c eherel fom t sc e. Gil pi a a st r iet eea gument i fvor
he
ri
e us
s f r hi as
les e ppe r o a s hr r
sn a

ofdiquaiiain:( )hei dists dwih t Cour' r i onhi r en motons'2)moe
s lfc to 1 s saise t he
ts ulngs
s ec t i ,
(
r
t n 30 y r a t u r i d r pr e e t f
ha
ea s go he nde sgne e es ntd he onne pa e c
r r nt ompa ofDe e
ny
f ndan s The
t,

W a hi on Pos Co.a ( t l ri d a he hus ndhaveapes landpr e sona
s ngt
t ; nd 3) he mdesgne nd r ba
rona
ofsi l
r ltons p wih Sena o Bob Gr ha , heha fbr t roft f t roft c r tCEO a
ea i hi t
tr
a m t
l- o he
he ahe
he uren
nd
c r a ofThe W as ngt Pos .
haim n
hi on t

Fis,heCo r n t sta çu iil ul g ao eamo tn v rc n ttt av l b ssf r
rtt u t o e h t j dca r i s ln l s e e o si e ai a i o
n
u
d
abi sorpari iy m oton.... mos i ra y, he a epr rgr
a
talt
i
Al t nva ibl t y r ope oundsf a
or ppea , f r
l not o

rc al' Lieyv.Unie St e 51 U. 540,555( 994) Gil pi ha a ldt s
e us . tk
'
td ats, 0 S.
1 . les e s ppeae he ummay
r

j d me to d r whihwa afr d, ndi fe t a p a teCo r' o d rd n ighsRe e d
u g n r e, c s fime a s re o p e lh u ts r e e yn i n we
Rul 60M oton t Va at Sum ma y J
e
i o c e
r udgmen a t Re n Cas ora ot runf vo a e
t nd o ope
e ny he
a r bl

or r . H owe r a t Su em e Cour ha m ade c e r m e e dis ts a ton wih a cour '
de s
ve , s he pr
t s
l a , r s a if c i
t
ts
or r a e no a bas s f rr c a ordi q lfc ton.
de s r t
i o e us l
s ua ii a i

Furhe e under28U. C.j1 a a fda ti s
t nuor,
S.
44, ny fi vi n uppor ofrc alfldpurua t
t e us ie s nt o
t s s to m us be ttm el ' The unde sgned' pas r e e a i ofThe W as ngt Pos
hi ec i n
t si y.
'
ri
s t epr s nt ton
hi on
t

Co. nd herde ad l r l tons p wih Se orGr m ar publcknowldge, sl
a
c es ong e ai hi t nat
aha e
i
e
ea iy
dico r bl I Gil pi f tt teihe ,o bot oft e st tonsc ea ed a pot nta co lc
s ve a e. f les e el ha t r r h, hes iua i
r t
e i l nfi t

ofi e es,h s l ha r s d t s enye sa whe t sca ewa fr tfl nota tra
nt r t e hou d ve aie hem ev
ar go
n hi s s is ied,
fe n

u fvoa l s mmayj d me t e iina da fr n eb t Co r o Ap as
n a r be u r u g n d cso n fima c y he u t f pe l.
Fi l t unde sgne sr pr e a i ofThe W as ng on Pos Co. or t 30yea s
naly, he
r i d' e es nt ton
hi t
t m e han
r
a a he r l tons p wih SenaorGr ha a ebot s f rr move fom t i s i t s
go nd r e a i hi t
t
a m r
h o a e
d r he s ues n hi
m at rt t y do nO a ca
te hat he
t nd nnotbeconsde edt c eae a lc ofi
i r o r t ny a k mpari lt orbi .
taiy
as
Acc r ngl i i
o di y, t s
ORDERED t t Relt J deGils e' M oton f Diquaii aton ofDititCour
ha
a or u
le pi s i or s lfc i
src
t

Purua t 28U. C.j 1 a 28U. C.j455( 530qi DENI
s nt o
S.
44 nd
S.
DEs
ED.
VA

ooxna oRosuso i a ,- rd ,hszg-z- o e tmb rc)6.
nd
nvimisl ia ti - a rs pe e, (1
o
y
w
,

*

PA TRI A A .
CI
SE Z
UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
c
c:

A 1 cou elofr c d
l ns
e or