Bacon et al v. Stiefel Laboratories, Inc. et al

Filing 580

ORDER Denying Taxation of Costs for Electronic Database re 570 Supplement, filed by Greenspoon Marder PA Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 10/16/2012. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES D I
STRI T C O U RT
C
SO UTH ERN DI
STR I T O F FLO R I A
C
D
M I M ID I I O N
A
V SI
C A SE N O .09- 871 C I K l G
21 - V- N
TI OTH Y FI NERTY ,
M
N

Pl i if
antf,
STI
EFEL LA BO M TORI l C.
ES, N ,
e a.
t 1,
Def nda s
e nt .
/

ORDER DENYI TAU TI OF
NG
ON
C O STS FO R ELE CTR O N I DA TA BA SE
C
THI M ATTER c e bef e t Cour upon Gr ens
S
om s or he
t
e poon M a derP. .S BilofCoss
r
A ' l
t

( #5 ,fl Augus 8,201 I Supplme t IsRequett Rec rCossReae t t
DE 47) ied
t
2,md
e nt o t
s o ove t ltd o he
Crai a Us of an Elcr c Datbae Und 28 U. C. 1 4) ( #5 , tld
e ton nd e
e toni
a s
er
S. 9204 DE 70) ie
Se e r 1 201 The ei Gr ns
pt mbe 0, 2. r n, ee poon M a de ,a a sg e of Pl i irs f r r c el
r r n s i ne
antf o me ouns ,

r ie $8, 7. i coss t tDe e nta e t be t xe a as a gue t ti s d be
ect s 01 51 n t ha f nda gr ed o
a d nd lo r s ha t houl
p r te t tx Def nda sf t $73, 82 r a e t c e tng a mai ai ng a e e to c
e mitd o a
e nt or he
764. elt d o r a i nd nt ni n l cr ni
daa e t tPli ifsf m e co elus d t m a ge doc
t bas ha antf or r uns e o na
ument i r sed fom Defnda s
s t eque t r
e nt

it a
n he bove syl d aci Fo t r a onsdic s be o , heCour fndst tt m oton mus
- t e ton. r he e s
s us ed l w t
t i ha he
i
t
begr nt d a t t a e upon c t a de ed a t cossr l t dt t e e toni daa e.
a e s o he gr ed
oss nd ni s o t e a e o he l c r c t bas
1.BACKGROUND

Thi c e ha a lng a i ve pr edurlhitr The orgi lCompli ( #1
s as s o nd nvol d oc a soy.
i na
ant DE )
wa tld a a cls aci on J y 6,2009 and wasdimis d i pa t u Defnda s moton
s ie s a s ton
ul
s s e n r, pon e nt ' i

( # ) o J n a' 4,2 0 ( # 3 .Pli t fs Ame e Co an ( # 7 ,fld
DE 21, n a u l
y
01 . DE 4 ) ani
f
nd d mpli t DE 4 ) i
e

Fe r r 8,201 as wasdimisd i pa t ( /69) Deenda s t n ans r ( #75)
b uay
0, lo
s se n r. DE / . f nt he
weed DE
f oft s n count i t Am e d Co ait ,1 afe whi Pli if move f cas
our he eve
s n he
nde
mpl n s tr ch antfs
d or l s

cetfc ton. sCour deni cas cetfc ton ( #257)onJ y 21 2011a byNove r
riiai Thi
t ed l s riiai DE
ul ,
nd
mbe
oft tye , a1 Pli if ha be n dimis d e ptTi o hy Fime t 2The r m ani c am s
ha ar l a ntfs d e s s e xce
e i ng l i
m t
r ry.

weebiuc tds t a tefrt h s wo l iv leaj r tilo t es c rte fa d cam. e
r f rae o h t h is p a e u d n ov u y ra n h e u iis ru li Se
( # 9 ) Folwi a s v n d y til i M a 2 2 a j r f u d De e d n s S ifl
DE 3 0 . l ng e e - a ra n y 01 , u y o n
o
fn a t te e
La at i a Cha l Stef la e f r s cu iis fa a a r da a s t Fi ry of
bor ores nd
res i el ibl o e rte r ud nd wa ded m ge o nne t

$15 24 4.0 S e( #51 ) Fia j d me twa e trd J l 9 2 2 atrwhc Plitf'
,0 ,8 9 . e DE 5 . n l u g n s ne e uy , 01 , fe ih an ifs
at ne s
tor ys oughtt rc rtxa ecossunde 28U. C.j1
o e ove a bl t
r
S.
920.
W ha f l d wasç s resofcon r di t y a hi y c usng doc e sr ga di
t olowe
( ei
a
ta cor nd ghl onf i
um nt e r ng

Bil ofCoss'( #566 . si pa tse dfom t fc t tPli ifhadbe nr prs ntd
ls
t. DE
'
) Thi n r tmme r he a t ha antf
e e ee e
by Rude M c os (ç n')beor t f11 fl f ba upty a a sgne isasest
n cl ky $
Rude ' f e he 11, ied or nkr c nd s i d t s t o
1
Gr e poon M a de .The ea r Cr ens n M a de wa no i ve i t c s Howe ,i
e ns
r r
r he , le poo
r r s t nvol d n he a e.
ver n
t e ntt tPl i ifpr ie Gr e poo M a de hel a c gi le a ns Def nda a
he ve ha antf eval d, e ns n r r d har ng i n gai t e nt s

a a sgne ofPli ifsf me c elSe ( #532)
n si e antf or r ouns . e DE
.
To smplf t muliude of c usng flngs t Cour or r c
i iy he
tt
onf i ii , he
t de ed ouns l t c e
e o onf r

p ru n t Lo a Rul 7.() ( #5 6 . we k ltr o S p e r5 2 2 c u s lfld
u s a t o c l e 3 c. DE 6 ) Two e s ae , n e tmbe , 01 , o n e ie
a J nt No i of St t Re r ng Bil of Coss Fie by Pli if a Pl ntf For r
oi
tce
aus ga di
ls
t ld
antf nd ai ifs me

Co ns l ( # 6 ) Th j it n tc i dc td t a P an ifs f r r c u s l a d c rn
u e. DE 5 9 . e on oie n iae h t litf o me o n e n ure t
c
ouns la d De e nt'couns ha r s ved al butone is i t va i Bil ofCoss3
e n
f nda s
el d e ol
1
sue n he rous ls
t.
The s e r m ani i s wast t rc t i ure by Rude i c e tng and m ant i ng a
ol e i ng s ue
d he oss nc r d
whe
n n rai
i ani n

'count 1 3aleg ERI vi ato ;
s - l ed
SA ol ins Count4 ale s curte faud i vi a i oft Se iisExc ngeA c.
lged e iis r
n olton he curte
ha
t
2Tor fec t sc nge teCo re trda Or e a ndn tec s c pino No e e 7 2 1 ( / 6 .
e l t hi ha , h ut nee n d r me ig h ae a to n v mb r , 01 .DE / )
41

3Th co r a p o e tetx t no c ssb Panifsc re tc u e o S pe r1 , 01 ( #5 2.
e u t p r v d h a ai f o t y litf' u rn o nsl n e tmbe 1 2 2.DE 7 )
o
2

e ec r c da a e ar pr r y txabl a ç e s f exe iiai 'under 28 U. C. j
l t oni t bas e ope l a e s t e or
f
mplfc ton'
S.

1 2 ( . ( 5 9 !3 .
9 04)' DE 6 , )
'
Rud ha c eaed t elc r ni da a e t m a ge 76, doc e s c t i ng a
en d r t he e to c t bas o na
741 um nt on ani t

l s 1830, pa s.De Sa og,DE #570- ,!4) Tobuida popult t daa s Rude
eat , 477 ge ( c. ul
1 .
l nd
ae he tba e, n

hrd tmpoa yp r lg l a ds c eaiswh es l j bwa t ip td t a d c d d c me t
ie e r r aae as n e rtre os oe o s o n u aa n o e o u ns
b d t, a , il, o i, n k y r s Thec dn ma et ed c me t s ac a e 1 . t(!
y ae n me tte t p c a d e wo d .
o ig d h o u n s e rh bl. d a !
4- .The daa s ce i a mantna e was o re n by Henr Sa og,t n-n- e
7)
tba e raton nd i e nc
ves e
y ul he i hous
aai
ltg to d tb s a ls f rRu e 4I hi D ecl r ton, Sa lg a s rst tS ot e t n wi
i ain aa a e nay t o d n. n s
i
uo se t ha t lh r ha t
l
h
t s t of da a e m a ge e s t m ,a pr
hi ype
t bas
na m nt ys e
oduc i of t s m a t of ove 1 8 m ilon
ton
hi
gniude
r . li

pa woul ha be n m o e t unt na e t r alsialy us a woul ha r nde t r
ges
d ve e
r han e bl o e itc l e nd
d ve e r hei

p o u to vrual us ls . I a ( 6 .
r d cin it l ee s' d t ! )
y
'
I is s e e a bre now be or t s Coul Gr ns n M a de ,asan as i
n t upplm ntl i f
f e hi
t ee poo
r r
sgnee of

Ru n,a es es bot a a e t amountof$8, 7. f t xa e c t and t outt ng
de ddr s
h n gr ed o
01 51 or a bl oss
he sandi

is ofcossr ae t t eecr c daa s See( #569) Asa i ta matr t Cour
sue
t eltd o he l toni tba e.
DE
. n niil te ,he
t
a ove t $8, 7. t to of c t, pur ua t t si a e a e m e be we n
ppr s he 01 51 axa in
oss
s nt o he tpul t d gr e nt t e
Gr e poon M a de a Def nda s co e .
e ns
r r nd e nt ' uns l

The Cour now t ns t whehe Gr e poon M a de may r cove $73, 4. f c t
t
ur o
t r e ns
r r
e r
76 82 or oss
r lt d t t e e toni da a e.
ea e o he l cr c t bas
II.Dl
scUssl)
(N

Thep e ii pa t ma t c t agans t l i pa t a govene by 28U. C.j
r valng ry y ax oss i t he osng ry, s
r d
S.
1 Ta bl cossaeditnc fom at ne f s s eFe R.Ci Pr 5 d ,a aelmie
920. xa e t r si t r tor ys ee , e d.
v. o. 4() nd r i td
t t a t lc t of ltga i Cos s m a onl be t xe i t y t tw ihi one of s x c t gores
o he c ua os s ii ton. t y y
a d f he i t n
i ae i ,

4Gr e po M ader whih now e plysSa og i asi ia poston,doesnots kt r overf hi tm e. e
e ns on r , c
m o
ul n m lr ii
ee o ec
or s i Se

( # 7 , .)
DE 5 4 p 2 .

i udi c t fre mplfc ton a ma ngc e .28U. C.j 1 4) Thes aet out
ncl ng oss o xe iiai nd ki opis
S.
9204 . e r he er
lmisoftxa e c t.Mor ver Fedea Rul ofCi lPr edur 54( pr dest ditit
i t
a bl oss
eo ,
rl e
vi oc e d) ovi he src

c u twih $ po r t d c i t tx,a c ss t e ie e l rt d i j 1 2 . Cr w o d
o r t $ we o e l ( a s o t, h tms nl ae n 9 09 a f r
a
ne )
me
'
Fit g Co v JZ Gi b n , n . 4 2U.. 3 , 4 ( 9 7 9 e aloL gh nv Fie tn Tr d
tn . .
i
b o s I c, 8 S 4 7 4 2 1 8 ) s e s ou a . r so e ie r
Rubb r Co. 749 F. 1 9,1 (1 t Ci.1 5)((n t e r ie ofs
e
,
2d 51 526 1h r 98 ç he xe cs
1
ound dicei ti
s rton, ral
co t a ea co de gra ltt i as et ni txa ec t.).
urs r c r d e t aiude n c rai ng a bl oss'
l 2008, Co r s a nde t txtofSe i l 4)f t frttme t al f
n
ng e s me d he e
cton 9204 or he is i 5 o low or
t xi of ff s f e mplfc i a t c t of m a ng c e of any mat i st Thi
a ng
tee or xe iiaton nd he oss
ki opi s
eral., s
a ndmentwa ba e on t i e sng pr lnc ofel toni dic y i f r la tonsa
me
s sd
he ncr a i
evae e
ecr c s over n ede a c i
nd
a unde sa ng t tnotal l gal r l ntdocume s e sed i physca f m o y.Se LG
n
rt ndi ha
1 e ly eeva
nt xit n
i l or nl e

El tonisU S. ,I . v WhiloolCor ,No.08Cecr c
A. nc, . rp
p.
- 0242,2011W L 5008425 a *6n. ( D.
t
1 N.

11 Oc.20,201 ) Jar n r DATqlgr I , 08- 1 2,2011W L 48357 a *5( D.
1. t
1 ; di . ule o, nc.No. CV-46
42, t S.
Ca.Oc.1 2011.t-hi a ndme t j 1 204 orgi t wih a rc
l t 2, ) t s me
f
nt o 9 4) i naed t e omme to oft
ndain he
J di i Conf r nc Com m it e on Cour A dm i s r ton a Cas M a ge e . Race Ti e
u c al
ee e
te
t
ni ta i nd
e na m nt'
'
rs

Ame ia,I .v Hoose Racig rï:Cor ,67 F. 158 1 ( d Ci.201 .The c
rc nc .
ir n r p. 4 3d , 65 3 r 2)
ommite
te
c i r k t rt ls oft xa e c t s d be a nded t i ude e ns s a s a e
onsde ed s he he it a bl oss houl
whe
me
o ncl
xpe e s ocit d
wih ne courr
t w
toom t c ogis'butde e ned t ts c b e dt tmi wel go be
e hnol e '
t nni
ha u h r a h û ght l
yond t
he

itn e so eo t esaue'J dca Co frn eo t U. , po to h Pr c e igso h
n e d d c p f h tt t. u iil n ee c f he S.Re r ft e o e dn fte
'
J diilCof r n eo heUntdStts9 1 ( r 1 , 0 3 .
u ca n e e c ft
i ae - 0 Ma . 8 2 0 )
e
The e ha bee ge r l agr e e t t di t l c es -e. ta m it bl duplc t
r
s
n ne a
e m nt ha gia opi - - g. r ns ta e
i ae
ve sons s h asTI a PD F fl - a e t $ l tCe ur e val ntofm a ng c es' CSF
r i , uc
FF nd
ies r he t s nt y qui e
2
ki opi .
'

FlntParne s LLC v Reu nPat,I . 676 F.Su 2d 137 1 ( D.Ga.2009 r v' on
i
t r,
. tr
h nc,
pp,
6, 381 N.
)ed
ot rgr
he ounds 654 F. 1 ( Ci.2011 .Howe r t s ope ofd mplt to a
3d 353 Fed. r
)
ve , he c
s
exe ikain nd
5Thesau ewasena t i 1 . J 25,1 48,c.
ttt
ced n 948 une
9
646,62 Stt 955.
a.
4

c ss'nt edii l g i u la i ti cruta mo toh r.' r e t ug i i u d s ue
o t'i h gt a e s nce r n hs ic i nd s t es (El n ho h t s n ip td
a
lv
t teecr cdic r c t aea l eunde Se ton 1 4) t r i s ntl la hort
ha l toni sovey oss r vaiabl
r ci 9204 ,hee s ca ega ut iy

i t scrui a dititgi ng ltg sgui nc i s ki t e cossunde Rul 54( ( )
n hi ic t nd src vi iiant da e n ee ng hos t
r e d)1
and Se ton 1 4)'fG Elcr c ,2011W L 5008425 at*8.So c t have itr ee
ci 9204 .
'
e tonis
me ours
neprtd

S cin 1 2 b o dy. e eg. T ng c iv Ka JJ /cS i n 1/l 6 3F.d 1 8 1 21( t
e to 9 0 r a l Se , . , a iu h . n 'c apa , t , 3 3 21 , 2 9h
;
Ci. 1 (ç src coulsaefeet itr e t mea ngoft c tofc t re lse wihi
r 201 ) d tit ' r r o neprt he ni
Di
t
he as aego is itd t n
j 1 '.Ot r have r d i o t saut a muc nar rs ope.Se Grphi Pac agig
920.) hes
'
ea nt he tt e
h rowe c
e a c k n
l en. I .v C rrZumbi Co.No.3:0-v- -- 201 W L 291 4 ( . Fl.J y 1
ntr , nc . '
r
el ,
1 c 891J37, 2
253 M D. a ul 6,

2 2 (ee t a mo in t tx c ssf rp e rng ee to i c piso e h bt,wih d gtl
01 ) rjci
ng
to o a o t o rpa i lcr nc o e f x i i t i ia
s

e ha c me t,ta we e p oe td o s re sd rng a p tn ifi e n tilb c u e dh
n n e ns h t r rj ce n ce n u i
ae t n rng me t ra e a s t e
t
saut i t be i e ee ac or ng t ispli lnguage).Li mos cic t,t El nt
tt e s o ntmr td c di o t an a
' ke t ruis he eve h
Cic tha ye t a r s t s ope of e m plfc ton a t c t of ma ng co e i t
r ui s t o dd e s he c
xe ii a i nd he oss
ki
pis n he
di t la
gia ge.

The que ton i t sc e i eve m or s ii whehe t pr vaii pary may t t
si n hi as s n
e pecfc; t r he e lng t
ax he
c tr a e t a el toni daab ec e e s ey f t tpa t sbe ftorc
os elt d o n ecr c t as r atd ol l or ha ry' ne i
onve e e
ni nc .
W he a el toni da a e ha be buitf t pum os of r s
n n ecr c t bas s en l or he
e
e pondi t dicove y
ng o s r
r uess s
eq t , ome c t havedee d t tat xa e c t6H owe r ma mor c rsha de e
ours
me ha a bl os.
ve , ny
e ou t ve nid
s h r c r .7 (
uc e ove y '
Though t sa ut has bee br dene t alow f c ng ma e i s a
he tt e
n oa
d o l
or opyi
t ral s
6SeeCBTFIntParne s L v Reu nPah I c, 7 F. u p. d 1 7 ,1 81( D. . 00 )(( esr ie ae
i
t r , LC . tr t, n .6 6 S p 2 3 6 3 N. Ga 2 9 (
Th evc s r
c rai y ne es a yi t el toni a Thee mousbu de a e
e t nl c s r n he ecr c ge.
nor
r n nd xpens ofelcr cdicovey a ewelkno
e
e toni s r r
l wn.
Ta i oft ecosswile our ltga st exe cs rsr nti bur ni t opposngparywih t huge
xaton hes t l nc age ii nt o r ie e tai n de ng he
i
t t he

c s o u l tdd ma dsfree to i dso ey'; adi 2 1WL 4 3 7 2a * (g h r . . tid p ry
o t f ni e e n o lcrnc ic v r .) J r n, 01
mi
'
8 5 4 t 8 iwl ee . a hr- at
t

t hni a i e ge t pe f m duteslmie t t hni is r ae t t physc pr to ofi or ton,
ec cin s nga d o ror
i i td o ec cal sues eltd o he
ial oducin nf mai

rltdc ssaerc v r beu d rj1 2 ,.
eae ot r e o ea l n e 9 0.)
5
1Eols Te hnol e I v Ad b S sen , n .- F. u p. d-- 2 2W L4 25 6a * ( D. x sJ l 1
a c ogis nc . o e y tls I c,- S p 2 , 01
09 8 t 3 E. Te a uy 9,
2 1 )(eetn abi çne c s o $ miinfrd c me tc l cin, r c sig a dh sigl' sn t
0 2 rjcig l s x e s f 2 l o o o u n ol to p o esn , n o tn l'a o
li
l
e
rc v rbeu de j l2 ; e as Ra eTrs 6 4F.da 1 0(iigMa nv He klr& Ko hDee e Ic,
e o ea l n r 9 0)se lo c ie , 7 3 t 7 ctn n . c e
c fns,n .No.
10 -CV-61, 01 WL 1 9 5 0 a * ( D. . r28 2 1 ) l r Sce tfc Ata t,nc Seu iis
:8
12 1
5 9 8 , t 9 E. Va Ap . , 0 1.n e inii- lna l . c rte
,
Ligain, 101 CV-1 5 , 01 WL 2 71 6, t# ( D. . uy6 2 1;nr F s Me r Ers v
t to No. : i
902 l
6 29 a l N. Ga J l , 01 ) l e at moy ae .
S a so ,n .No 3 0 CV-0 1 2 0WL 5 9 9 , 4( D. X. v.l , 01 ),
p n in lc, . -1 48 , 01
0 3 45 * N. Te No 0 2 0)
.

5

o p s d t j tpa es i i n ts b o d a t c v r g n r lee to i d so ey c ss ta
p o e o us p r, t s o o r a s o o e e ea lcr n c ic v r o t h t
pr ce c pyi ors a ng ofma e il.' as Te hnolgisl r AdobeS t ms I . --F.
e de o ng c nni
t ra s'Eol
c o e nc. .
ys e , nc, -

Supp.2d -- 201 W L 4092586 a *3,( D.Texa J y 1 201 .The Thid Cicui was
-, 2
t
E.
s ul 9, 2)
r r t
pa tculrycrtc loft r i nal pe ti t xi ofs h c t :
ri a l iia
he ato e nnitng a ng uc oss

The de sons t t a l t xa i of al or e s i l al,elctoni dic r
cii
ha low a ton
l,
s entaly l e r c s ove y
c ula c r ,s h a t DititCour' r i i t s c e,a e untt r d
ons tnt ha ges uc s he src
t ulng n hi as r
s
e he e

fo t esau o ymo rn .S ci n 1 2 4 )d e n tsaeta alse t tla
r m h ttt r o ig e to 9 0 4 o s o tt h t 1 tps ha e d
u t t pr ton of c e of ma e i s a e t xa e I do not a horz
p o he oduc i
opis
t ral r a bl. t es
ut ie
t xai me ey bec us t y' t c ogy r quie t l c l e ts no
a ton r l
a e oda s e hnol
e r s ecmi a xperie t
or na iy pos e s d by t t pial l l pr e so l l does not s t
di rl
s se
he y c ega of s i na . t
ay hat

a tvii t tenc a c ts vi ma betxe Se i 1 4)a horz
ci tes ha ourge os a ngs y a d. cton 920( ut ies
a r ng o y t c tofm a ng c e .
wa di nl he os
ki opi s
Rac Tie ,674 F. a 1
e rs
3d t 69.

Si e t 2008 a
nc he
mend ntt Se i 19 ( ,no c t a rnty ha pemitd a
me o cton 204)
ours ppae l ve r te
pr va lng pary t r ove t e ns s t t Gr ens on M a dt s ks t tx. Rude a
e ii
t o ec r he xpe e ha
e po
r r ee o a
n, s
Pl ntf' f mer c ns l cr a e a m ai ane t eecr c datba e s ey f is own
ai ifs or
ou e , e t d nd
nti d he l toni
a s ol l or t
be fta notf t pu pos off c lt tngr s ns t dic r r
ne i nd
or he r e a iiai e po es o s ove y equess
t.
W hen c r e wih a f c ual sm ia m oton f c t ,a dititcoul i t Ease n
onfontd t a t ly i lr i or oss
src
' n he t r
t
Ditit of V igi a denid t moton be a e t m o t ha not de onsr t d t t is
src
r ni
e he
i
c us he van d
m ta e ha t
s r habl e e to cdatbas wasf a hi m o e t n t co ninc oft pa tes Felsv
ea c e l cr ni a e
or nyt ng r ha he nve e e he ri . l .

Vigni De .fT anp. 6 5F. p 2 7 0( D. . 0 )
r i a pto r s , 0 Su p. d 4 E. Va 20 9 .
Re r e s of whe he s amzng doc e s s d be vi
ga dl s
t r c i
um nt houl
ewed as c ng
opyi
ma e i l,t c tdoes not tnd t t t s caego y of txa e coss i udes
t ras he our
s ha hi t r
a bl
t ncl
de e n ' t hni sofpr ce sngr c ds e r c i da a a c
f nda ts ec que
o s i e or , xta tng t , nd onve tng fls
ri ie ,
whih s r ed t c e es a c bl doc
c e v o r at e r ha e umtn s r t rt mer l rpr
t , ahe han
e y e oduc pa r
e pe
doc e s i e e toni f m.By r usng t e nd t ta tonalnoton of
um nt n l cr c ùr
ef i o xpa he r dii
i
d opyi 't i l a bur oni a r of el ctoni d s
t
c
ng' o nc ude
ge ng r ay
e r c i cove y t c que t
r e hni s, he
co tr ognies t Su e Cour' pr e t tdititc t may de i t
ur ec z he pr me
t ec pt ha src ours
s
clne o

tx c t e
a oss numeae i j 1 bu c nno a d c t notenume aed unde j
rtd n 920, t a t war oss
rt
r
1 20.
9

6

1 a 743 ( tton omitd) Si fca l t Fel c ta tcultdt ditnci bewe n
d. t -44 ciai
te . gnii nty,he ls our ri ae he si ton t e
m a ng di t l c es and c eai a ne eecr c da a e.The f me ft wihi t xa e
ki
gia opi
r tng
w l toni t bas
or r is t n a bl

coss unde Se ton 1 4) he lter goe welbeyond saut y i e .As notd a
t
r ci 920( ;t at
s l
tt or ntnt
e bove,
Congr sco i r d a br de e
es nsde e
oa r xpanso whe a e ng t sa ut butex i il elctd f a
in
n m ndi he tt e
plcty e e or
na r w e ns on t tc r onl e m pltc ton a cos s ofc e - nott c e t o ofne ,
r o xpa i ha ove s y xe ii a i nd t
opi s
he r a i n
w

modii d,o enha ed di t lfl .
fe r
nc
gia ies
As c r y s por,Gr ns on M a de r le hea l on an o ni fom wihi t s
ontar up t ee po
r r ei s viy
pi on r
t n hi

ditit I Kl
src. n aman v.Fr e
e doms Wath,I . Cas No.07CVc nc, e
- 22433,2008 W L 41 l( D.
9488 S.

Fl Se .1 2008) t Honorbl Pa C. k afr aporin ofama srt srpo tt t
a. pt 2,
, he
a e ul Huc fimed
to
gitae' e r ha
saed: d t f c eai a ltga i da a e, ti e de e pr s nt ton, a co e a e
t t t s or r tng ii ton t bas ral vi nc e e ai
cos
nd pis r

rc a eund 28 U. C,j 1 4)whe ei i ne sa y duet t e r me c e t of
e overbl er
S.
920(
r t s ce sr
o he xte omplxiy
t c s a t o ga zai of m ilons of doc nt . The m a sr t a kno ldge t t
he a e nd he r ni ton
li
ume s'
'
gitae c w e d ha

dth s c ssaen te p e sy o tie b 2 U.. j l 2 , b tctd t a a o lu c s
' j e e o t r o x r sl u l d y 8 SC. 9 0' u ie o n n mao s ae
l
n
'
fom wihi a he cr tf s
r
t n not r icui or uppor.See i (ii foc e Mari I
t
d ctng khe d
tn daho Te s Co r
ch . . .
foc he Mari Adv e Envr
k ed
tn
anc d
ionme alS . I . CV- 31 E,2006 W L 209 5 (
nt yst nc, 98- 6587 D.

I a oJ l 2 , 0 6 )
d h uy 7 2 0 ).
The Cou tfnds t r to e i Klyman unpe s sve.Fis,J
r i
he ai nal n a
r ua i
r t udge Huc di no sa e
k d t tt
t t t c e ton of a el toni daa s woul al ys be a t a e c t ; i ed, he
ha he r a i
n ecr c tba e
d wa
u bl oss nde
s e e l de ed txi s h coss i Klyman be us She def nda s hie expe t a a
ubs qu nty ni a ng uc
t n a
ca e t
t
e nt r d
rs t
huge ho l c t't do wor t twoul ot r s S pe f m e by pa al al a a s ae
ury os' o
k ha
d he wie l
be ror d
r eg s nd s ocit

at ne a woul notbec
tor ys nd
d
ompe a ea c t unde 28U. C.j1 '2008W L 5111 a
ns bl s oss
r
S.
920.
'
293 t
* ( D.Fl.De 8,2008 .Se ond,i i uncea fo t f t ofKlyman t tpeofdat s
2 S. a c.
) c
t s l r rm he acs
a
he y
abae
t def nda s had b l or t t t J e Huc wo d a ove as txa e.Thid,t
he e nt
uit
he ype hat udg
k ul ppr
a bl
r he

Klyman opi ons di nottke i o c ierton t 2008 amend ntt Seci 1 4)
a
ni
d
a nt onsd ai he
me o ton 920( ;
i e t pa talafima e oft magita e r por,whih Gr e poon M a derr i she viy
nde d, he ri fr nc
he
sr t s e t c
e ns
r ele a l

o , se tr do emo t bf r Co r s n n e Se to 1 2 ( )
n wa nee n n h eo e nge s me d d cin 9 0 4 .
As f foc hee whi h a s was de i d bef e t 2008 a ndme , t Cour
or
k d,
c lo
c de
or he
me
nt he
t

rs tul diag e wih t opi on t tSe ton 1 4)al t prvalng pat t tx
epecf ly s r es t he ni ha ci 9204 lows he e ii ry o a
c t i it s d i e e tm e f c
oss f ç ave mm ns i
i
or ouns who ot wie woul have t sf t ough t
el
her s
d
o it hr
he
doc nt by ha ' 2006 W L 2095875 a *2.Thesa ut e e a i t xa e f e a c t i
ume s
nd.
'
t
tt e num r tng a bl e s nd os s s

n t b u ma nga at r e sj be se.
o a o t ki n to n y' o a ir
The ot r ca e cied by Gre poon Mar r se ( #570,pp.4-) ar fcual
he s s t
e ns
de, e DE
5 , e a t ly
i ppost None i ved t c e ton ofa eecr cdaa e f t conve e e oft pa t
na ie.
nvol he r a i
n l toni t bas or he
ni nc
he ry
s e ng t t x t c tnoran a t r t t t cos oft m por r em pl s w ho c d fl t
e ki o a he os
te npt o ax he t e
ay
oyee
ode ies o

ma t daaba es a c bl .
ke he t s e r ha e
M or ove ,i i t opi on oft s Cour t t a not d a
e r t s he ni
hi
t ha , s e bove,Congr ss a
es ' mend e of
m nt

Seci 1 204 di note nd t abl c t bey di t c ng t t ce i ofne
ton 9 4) d
xpa u e oss ond gial opyi o he raton
w,
modii d,ore nce di ialfl .A pr valngpa t m a t t c t ofmaki di t c es
fe
nha d gt ies
e ii
ry y ax he oss
ng gial opi ,

butSse i 1 4)doe notsae t talse t tla up t t pr i ofc e of
s cton 9204
s
tt ha l tps ha e d
o he oducton opis
m ae i l a e txa e.'Rac Tie 67 F.d a 1 A hol ng t t c r r woul be
tras r a bl '
e r s, 4 3 t 69.
di o he onta y
d
d et r d f o t sat or moornp' i ,an woul m uddy t ditnc i be we n t bl
d he e r m he t ut y
unt
i 'd d
d
he si ton t e axa e

c t,whih a e gene a l a l e t t pr va lng pary,a ato ne f e ,whih ge r ly
oss
c r
r ly vaiabl o he e ii
t nd t r ys e s
c ne a l
8

a enota ia eunde abs af - hitng a e m e orsat e.
r
va lbl
r ent ee s fi gr e nt t ut

8 eAlek PieieSe vc Co. .Wid r ess // 4 U. 2 (9 5) dsusigteAmeiar l fr
Se y s a p l r ie v len s bcey, 21 S. 40 1 7 ( ic sn h
n
rc ue o
at r e fe )
to n ys e s.
8

111.CONCLUSI
ON

Ac or ngl a trc e ulconsde a i a t Cour bei ot r s f l a s d,i i
c di y, fe ar f
i r ton nd he
t ng he wie uly dvie t s
he e ORDERED,ADJUDGED ,a DECREED t t Gr e poon M a de P. .' Bil of
r by
nd
ha e ns
r r A S l

Coss( #547)a Supplmen t IsRe s t Rec rCossReltd t t Crai and
t DE
nd
e t o t que t o ove
t ae o he e ton
Us of a Elcr c Daa e Unde 28 U. C. 1 4) ( #570) be,a ae hee
e
n e toni tbas
r
S. 9204 DE
nd r rby,
GRANTED i par and DENI i part Gr e poon M a de s l r c
n
t
ED n
. e ns
r r hal e overfom Def nda s
r
e nt

t ag e d upon a
he r e
mountof$801 51.The pori ofGr e poon M a de ' moton s e ng t
, 7.
ton
e ns
r rs i e ki o
t x t c t o c e tng a m ant i ngt e e toni datba ebe a i he e DENI .
a he oss f r ai nd i ani he l cr c a s , nd s x by,
ED
DONE r d ORDERED i Cha r at t J m e Lawr nc Ki Fe r l J tc
n
mbe s
he a s
e e ng de a us ie
Buidi a Unied St t Courhous M i mi Fl rda, hi 1 t da ofOc obe , 2.
l ng nd t
aes
t e, n , o i t s 6 h y
t r 201
t

W CA
O

ES LAW

X
NCE KI G
N

I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D
CT U
SOU TH ERN DI
STR I O F FLO R A
CT

Cc
:

Co ns l o Pl itp
u ef r an i

Bet A nn Elenberg K ri sky
hl
m
Rud M ccl ky Sm ih Sc t r& Rus e l
en
os
t huse
sl
200E Br wa d Boul va d
o r
e r
1 t Fl rPO Box 1
5 h oo
900
Fo4 La r e FL 33302- 900
1 ude dal,
1

Norm an S.Segal
l
Seg lGor c P.
al/ dih A.
801 Brc l A ve
i ke l nue
Suie 900
t
M i i FL 33131
am ,
M els Al
i sa agna
Rude M c os Sm ih Sc t r&;Rus e l
n cl ky
t huse
sl
701 Brc l A ve
i ke l nue

Suie 19
t 00
M i m i FL 331
a ,
31

Couns forDe
el
fendant
s
H iar e B a s
l i s
Gr e
e nber Tr ur g
g a i
1 Brc l Ave M im i FL 331
221 ikel nue a ,
31
M oni a Jane t C hapln
c
te
i
Gr e r Tr urg, A.
e nbe g a i P.
3 Ave oft Am e ias
33
nue he
rc
M im i FL 331 - 238
a ,
31 3
Li
ndsey C am p Edel ann
m
Gr e gTr urgLLP
e nber a i
3290N o t i Pa k a
rhsde r w y
Suie400
t
Ata a GA 30327
l nt ,
Pet N .H al
er
l
G r e r Tr urg,LLP
e nbe g a i
3290Norhsde Pa kway
t i
r
Suie 40
t 0
Ata a GA 30327
l nt ,
Todd D .W ozni
ak
Gr e r Tr i
e nbe g aurg
3290NorhsdePa kwa
t i
r y
TheFor m Suie400
u
t
Ata a,GA 30327
l nt

Debor Poore FizG er d
ah
t
al
W a t La a fSc oe r& Ca s n
lon nt f hr de
ro
11 E Br a d Boul r
0
ow r
eva d
Suie 2000
t
For Laude da e FL 33301
t
r l,

1
0