Moore v. Harris et al

Filing 159

ORDER denying 117 Supplemental Proposed Motion to Amend/Correct Complaint; adopting Report and Recommendations re 133 Report and Recommendations on 117 Supplemental Proposed Motion to Amend/Correct Complaint filed by Anthony L. Moore. Certificate of Appealability: No Ruling. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 2/3/2012. (ls)

UNI
TED STA TE S D I
STRI T C O U RT
C
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.0922754- V- TZ/ HI
Cl SEI W TE

ANTHONY L. OO RE,
M
Pl ntf ,
ai if
V.

W ALTER A.M C L,e aI,
NEI t .
Dee
f ndant .
s

ORDER AFFI I AND ADO PTI REPORT OF M AGI
RM NG
NG
STM TE JUDGE
THI M ATTER i be o et Cour upo t Re tofM a sr t J
S
s f r he
t n he por
gita e udge is d by t
s ue
he

Honorbl Parc A.W hie, tdSttsM a srt J
a e tik
t Unie ae gitae udge( 1 .I t Re tM a srt
DE- 33) n he por, gitae
J
udgeW hie r c me t tPl i if stsuppl me a Pr ed M oto t Am e Compli '
t e om nds ha antf i
e nt l opos
in o
nd
ant'

( I 7 b d nid b c u e t n n me t fi t sae a c u e o a to a d b c us o is
DE- 1 ) e e e e a s he me d n s al o tt a s f cin n e a e f t
untmelnes.Pli iffldhi ci lrg sc ant algi vi ai of42U. C.j1 3,
i i s antf ie s vi iht ompli , le ng oltons
S. 98 on
Se e r 1 2009. The pr e a e e s s k t a addii
pt mbe 5,
opos d m ndm nt ee o dd
tonalunna
med/
unknown
def nda s adefnda pr vi l dimi s byt Cour, ndne i nc cli sagans t new
e nt ,
e nt e ousy s s ed he
ta
glge e am
i t wo
de e nt .TheM a sr eJ
f nda s
gitat udges cii lynot t tPli ifhasnote anedwhyhei onl
pe fcal ed ha a ntf
xpl i
s y

n w s e i gt n mea dto a d f n a t W hi Plitfha fldObe ton t teRe o tDEo e k n o a d iin l ee d n s l an if s ie jci s o h p r (
e
1 , hasnota ese a oft is r s dbyt Re t i tad,heha smpl rieatd
361 he
ddr s d ny he sues aie
he por;nse
s i y etr e
hi ne c a m s a i tt pr
s w l i ga ns he opos d ne de enda s
e
w f
nt .

W hiege r ly,unde Fe r lRul ofCi lPr edur 15() l vet a nds ul be
l ne al
r de a e
vi oc e a, ea o me ho d

fe l gv n whe j tc s r q r s ad src c u t e dn tal w n n me twh r te eh s
rey ie
n usie o e uie , itit o r n e o lo me d n e e h r a
be nunduedely,ba f ih, lt r m otve orr peaedf iur t cur de i e
e
a
d at dia o y i , e t a l e o e fcindesbya e
m ndment
s

pr ousyalowe Br
evi l l d. yantv D upree,252 F. 1161, 1 63( 1hCi.
,
3d
1 1 t r 2001 .l t sca e Pl ntf
) n hi s , ai if
haspr vi l a e edt c pl ntandhasnote ane why hehaswat d s l t s k t
e ousy m nd he om ai
xpl i d
ie o ong o ee o
a e t c
m nd he ompl i a i a t namene de e nt . Furhe ,a t Re tno e t cl i s
ant gan nd o
w f nda s
t r s he por t d, he a m

a i tt pr e ne dee nt dono saec us ofa inunde j1
gans he opos d w fnda s
t tt a es cto
r 983 Fi ly,t sCourt
na l hi
.

fndst talowi t a ton ofne de e nt woul s t ntal dea t r ol i oft s
i ha l ng he ddii
w f nda s
d ubsa i ly ly he es uton hi
c e whi h ha pr es e quief , i udi t flng ofa nzi on a m o i n f s
as , c s ogr s d t ar ncl ng he ii
nd lng
to or umm a y
r

j d me t
u g n.
Ha ng ca e uly r e d,de nov , M agitae J
vi
r f l eviwe
o
sr t udge W hie' t oug Re qt
t s hor h por he

Ob e to s a dter c r i i h r b
j cin , n h e o d,t s ee y
O RD ERED t t
ha :

( ) Th a o e me to e Re o to M a itae J d e ( 1 3 i AF RMED a d
1 e b v - n in d p r f g sr t u g DE- 3 ) s FI
n
AD O PTED .

( ) anifsdu p e n a Pr p s dM oint Ame dCo lit'DE- l ) s
2 Pli tf' ç p lme tl o o e to o n mpan '( 1 7 i DENI
s
ED

.

s
D ox E and o lo Elso i M i m i Fl i , ti q V a o Fbur 2 1.
k t
n a , or da h s y -dy f era 02

PAT CI A . El Z
A
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
cc:

M ag sr t J
itae udgeW hie
t
A1 c ns ofr or #r s plry
1 ou el ec d/ o e /

2