Moore v. Harris et al

Filing 478

ORDER Adopting 401 and 457 Report and Recommendations. Defendant Nurse Chandilier is DISMISSED for lack of service; denying as moot 476 Motion for Referral to Volunteer Attorney Program. A1l pending motions not otherwise ruled upon are DENI ED as moot. Closing Case. Signed by Senior Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 6/15/2017. (pes) NOTICE: If there are sealed documents in this case, they may be unsealed after 1 year or as directed by Court Order, unless they have been designated to be permanently sealed. See Local Rule 5.4 and Administrative Order 2014-69.

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO U TH ER N DI
STRI T O F FLO R I
C
DA
CASE NO.0922754- V- TZ/ H l
Cl SEl W TE

ANTH ONY L.M OORE,
Pl ntf ,
ai i f
V.

W ALTER A.M C L,e aI,
NEI t .
De e
f ndant .
s
/

ORDER AFFI I AND ADOPTI REPO RTS OF M AGI
RM NG
NG
STRATE JUDGE.
DENYI M OTI FOR REFERRAL TO VOLUNTEER ATTORN EY PRO GRAM .
NG
ON
AND CLO SI CASE
NG
THI M A TTER i bef e t Cour upon t Re ta Rec m e tonsr Nur e
S
s or he
t
he por nd
om nda i
e: s

Ch n iirg 4 )a dt eS p lme tlRe o t n Re o nd to sr Nu s Ch n iir
a dle DE- 01 n h u p e n a p r a d c mme ai n e: re a dle
g 45 )is e b t Hon r beParc A. ht, tdS ae Ma itaeJ d e Plitf
DE- 7 su d y he o a l tik W i Unie tts gsrt u g . an if
e
h sfldo j cin (7 4 2 t t eS p e na Re r.Plitf ha as tld aM oinf r
a ie b e to s 1E- 7 1 o h u plme tl po t anif s lo le
to o

Reer lo Voune rAto n yPr g a g 47 ) Be a et eM as ash v b e u a et
fra t l te t r e o rm DE- 6 . c us h rh l a e e n n bl o
obt n s r ceo Def nda Nure Cha le ,t Re t a Re m m e tonsa e a fr e
ai e vi n
e nt s
ndiir he pors nd co
nda i
r fim d
a a pt d a Nur eCha l i dimis d fom t sa ton.Gi n t tNur eCha le i
nd do e nd
s
ndier s s s e r hi c i
ve ha
s
ndii r s
t onl r i ng De e nta s i bei dim is d,Pl i ifsM oto f Re e r t
he y ema ni
f nda nd he s ng s s e
antf '
i n or f ral o
V olnt e Ator y Pr r m i de e asm oo .
u e r t ne og a s nid'
t

Pl ntf tldt s42U. C.j1 a to a i tmuli edeenda s Ass outi
ai if ie hi
S. 983 cin gans tpl f nt. et n
mor deali t Re t Re mme to r NureCha le (
e ti n he por and co ndains e: s
ndiir R&R) aloft
, l he
De e nt ,e e N ure Cha le ,we es ve a we e uli e ydimi s d o s
f nda s xc pt s
ndiir r er d nd r tmatl s s e n umm a y
r

j d me t Nu s Ch n i e, o v r r mansu ev d.Ase pli e i t eR&R, fe
u g n . re a dl r h we e, e i nsr e
i
x an d n h
a tr

r nd fom t Elve h Cicui, heM ag sr t J e at mpt d t hep Pli ifl a eNur e
ema r he e nt r t t
itae udg te e o l antf oc t
s
Cha leri or rt e f t t s l c by or rng herf me empl ye t pr deNure
ndii n de o fecua e ewi e
de i
or r
o r o ovi
s
Cha le sl s known c a ti or ton.Thee oye ha none The M a sr e J
ndiir' a t
ont c nf ma i
mpl r d
.
gi tat udge
alo or r d he f
s de e r onnere oye t pr det t Cour,
mpl r o ovi o he
tunde s l als ofa lempl eswho
r ea , it 1
oye
we ee oye a DadeCore to l tt i a t tm eofPli ifsi i ntt r . The
r mpl d t
r c i nal nsiuton t he i
a ntf nc de he e
e o rwa una et do s bec us ofa c nge i s fwa e.l al s dic e f tt l t
mpl ye s bl o
o a e
ha
n o t r n a t t h for o ocae
Nur eCha ler t M a sr t J
s
ndii , he gitae udgeor r co- f nda Nur eCha ran' co e t
de ed de e nt s
mbe l i s uns l o
co a tCha
nt c
mberai t i r whe he Cha be l i had a y c t ti or ai n f rNur e
l n o nquie
t r m ran
n on ac nf m to o
s

Cha le .I tal cou elwa u bl t c a tCha li ( 449) Ba e ont s
ndiir niily, ns s na e o ontc mberan DE- . s d hee
e f t t R&R a Suppl mentlRe t ec
fors,he
nd
e
a por r omm e t tNur eCha le be dimi s d fom
nd ha
s
ndii r
s se r
t sm at r Afe i s nceoft Supplm e alRe t Cha rai sc
hi te . t r s ua
he
e nt
por, mbe l n' ouns fl d a
el ie n

Ame d dRe p ns t Or r( 4 8 ,nwh c s sae ta, he ma yrp ae atmp sa
n e s o e o de DE- 5 ) i ih he ttd h t a r n e e td te t t
c ac ,
ont t Chambe li emaiedcouns la sat t theha nots n orhe r fom Nur e
ran
l
e nd t ed ha
d
ee
ad r
s
Cha le sncet y we e e o d t t r
ndiir i he
r mplye oge he .

Pan ifh sfldo j cin t Ch mb ran' c u s lsi ta r s n e(7 4 9 a dt
litf a ie b e to s o a eli s o n e' niil e po s 1E- 5 1 n o
t Su pe na Re r ( 4 2 . Be a s o j cin t c u e ' r s ns aeno a
he p lme tl po t DE- 7 1 c u e be to s o o ns ls e po e r t n

a p o raers n ea db c us t o j cinsd n ta d e sc u e ' sae ns t e
p r p it epo s n e a e he be to o o d r s o nsls ttme t,h
o j cin aeo er e Plitf so j cin t t Su pe n a Re o t lod n ta d e s
b e to s r v ruld, an if be to s o he p lme tl p r as o o d rs
t c n e t o t eS p e na Re o ti ta , anifsae t t eh sb e s be to fle
he o tns f h u plme tl p r;nse d Pli tf tts ha h a e n u j c t as
dici i r r t a ar ul ofpur ui hi l lrg sa t tNur eCha be li i i
s plna y epors s es t
s ng s ega i ht nd ha
s
m ran s n
co e ptofCour . Fis ,ast Cour haspr ous y i o m e Pl ntf ,a vi a i ofhi
nt m
t r t he
t
evi l nf r d ai i f ny ol tons
s
r g sw hi oc ur ed a t t Se em be 2007 i de st tf
i ht
ch c r fer he pt
r
nci nt ha onne t bas soft s s tar
d he i
hi ui e
2

pr ry r s i a s pa ae s t Se ond, heCour c nno fnd Nur eCha be l i i c e
ope l aied n e r t ui. c
t
ta ti
s
m ran n ont mpt
be a eNur eCha be l n i noti vi ai ofa Cour or r Nur e Cha rai was
c us
s
m rai s
n ol ton ny
t de .
s
mbe l n

pr vi l dim is d fom t sc e a ha no i no ed a Cour or s Thus Pli ifs
e ousy s s e r hi as nd s t g r ny
t der .
, antf '

o j cin t t eS ppe n a Re r aeo er ld.
be t s o h u lme tl po t r v rue
o
Ha ng c r f l r vi we denov M agita eJ
vi a e uly e e d,
o,
sr t udgeW hie' R&R, t Suppl m ent
ts
he
e
al

Re o tPlitf so j ci n , n t r c r ,ti h rb
p r, an if be to s a d he e o d i s ee y
ORDERED t t
ha :

()TheRe r a Re omme tonsr NureCha le g 401 a t
1
po t nd c
ndai e: s
ndiir DE- 1 nd he
Supplme alRe ta Re ommendai r NureCha le (7 4571a eAFFI
e nt por nd c
tons e: s
ndiir 1Er
RMED a
nd
ADOPTED .De e
f ndantNur eCha le i DI I
s
ndiir s SM SSED f lck ofs r c .
or a
e vi e

( )Pli ifsObe o t Ato wyAn C. rn oi sRe p ns t Or e ( E- 9 i
2 ant
f
j din o tn
a Fa c l
n' s o e o d r 1 45 1 s
3
O VER RU LED .

( ) an ifsMo inf rObe to t M a itaeRe o t ndRe o n ain ( E- 5 1
3 Plitf
to o j ci n o g srt p r a
c mme d to 1 4 2
7
i
SOVERRULED .

( Pli ifsM otonf Reer t Vol e rAtor yPr r (7 476)i DENI
4) antf
i or fralo unte t ne ogam 1Es
ED
as m oot
.

( A1pendi motonsnototewier e u n aeDENI asmoot
5) l
ng i
h r s uld po r
ED
.

() Thsc s i CLOS
6 i ae s
ED.

.
>
Jv
-

DONEadORDERE iMimiFoiati / dyo Jn,07
n
D n a ,lrd,hs X a fu e2 1.
1

PA TRI I A .
A SE Z
UNI
TED STA T S D TRI J D GE
CT U

c
c:

M agita eJ
sr t udgeW hie
t
A1 c
1 ouns lofr or #r s plry
e
ec d/ / e /