Rinker et al v. Carnival Corporation et al

Filing 281

ORDER granting 261 Motion to Strike Affidavit of Dr. Gerald E. Stopcyznski. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 12/19/2011. (ls)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CASE NO.09- 5 CI SE1 SI ONTON
231 4- V- TZ/ M
SANDRA RW KER,
Pl i if
antf,

CARN I
VAL CORPOM TI e a1,
ON, t .
De e
f ndan s
t.
/
O R D ER G R ANTI G M O TI N TO STRI E A FFI VI O F D R .G EM LD E .
N
O
K
DA T
STO PC YZN SK I

THI CAUSE i beo et Co tonDee ntCa i lCoportonss( mi )
S
s fr he ur
fnda m va r ai ' Ca val

M oi nt S rkeAfi a i o Dr Ge adE. tpc n kig 2 1 i whih Canv l e k t
to o ti fd vt f . r l S o yz s DE-61 ,n c r ia s e s o
srke t Afi vi whi h i s
ti he fda t c s ubmit i s
ted n uppo tofPl n if sopposton t Ca i lsM o i
r
aitf
ii o m va ' ton
f Summar J
or
y udgm e .TheAfi vi c ansopi onsr r ng Def ntPat '
nt
fda t ont i
ni ega di
enda
els

quaii tons orl c t e , o s r a t s edocoro
ltcai , a k her of t e ve s he ol
t nboa d oneofCa i lss p.Suc
r
m va ' hi
h
opi onsa er lva tt Pli ifsne i nthii cli a Pli if sda m t tCa ni
ni
r ee n o antf
glge rng am nd antf
i ha r val
ne i n l r led on t m e ca opi on ofa unqualse doc or
glge ty e i
he di l ni
n
i d t .

Ca ni ls kst srke t Afi tbe a e i c ansopi onsnoti Dr
r va ee o ti he fdavi c us t ont i
ni
n .
St yz kispr vi l dicos e r r ta no dicl ed prort t dea i f
opc ns ' e ousy s l ed xpe t epor nd t s os
i o he dlne or

d sl sn e p r win se .Th s Can v l se t t a ii p eu ie b telt d s ls r o
ico i g x e t t e s s u , r i a a s rs h t t s rj dc d y h ae ico u e f
t e o ni be us t ca
hes pi ons ca e hey nnotobt i a e r r buta wines . l r s e,Pli if
an n xpe t e t l t s n e pons a ntf
a gue t tt o ni i t Afi vi a eba e on Pa e ' de ii t si
r s ha he pi ons n he fda t r s d
t ls poston e tmony.Thepa te
ri s
s l c e t J y de dlne f rdi c os e ofPl n if se r r po t .Pa e ' de ii occ r d
e e t d he ul a i o s l ur
ai tf xpe t e r s t ls poston ur e

onNove r1 2011.Ac r ng t Pl ntf, uc oft i or ai on whi h St yz kis
mbe 6,
co di o ai if m h he nf m ton
c opc ns '

Afi vi r i o y c me t lghta t de ii n. Howeve ,Pl ntf ha notexpl ne why
fda t eles nl a o i t he posto
r ai if s
ai d

Pa e ' de ii di notoc urea le i t sltg ton, es i ly gven t f c t thi tani
t ls poston d
c
rir n hi ii a i
pec al i he a t ha s r i ng
a quaii a i we ea is a woul r quiee r a yssl Pl ntf hasalo not
nd lfc tons r t s ue nd
d e r xpe t nal i. ai if
s
e aned why Dr St ys kisorg na r por doesnotno et thel c d s fcent
xpl i
. opc ns ' i i l e t
t ha
a ke ufi i

i or ai t opi o Pae ' quai a i
nf m ton o ne n t ls lfc tons.N o di t o i nalr po topi on Pa e '
r d he rgi e r ne
t ls
q lt a i ba e on t pe s me fl Pli ifr ceve fo Ca ni ma m on hsbe or
uaik tons s d
he r ol l ie antf e i d r m r val ny
t
f e
t e tr porswe e due.Thus i a
he xper e t r
, t ppea st tPl i ifs htt opi onsi t Afi vi
r ha antf oug he ni n he fda t
onl bec us Ca ni l sM oton f Sum m my J
y a e r va '
i or
udgm e poi e outt hol i Pl i if s
nt nt d
he es n a ntf '

evi nc z
de e.

Plitf as c ne d t a Canv l l s f r peu iei t eAf a i i p r te
anif lo o tn s h t r ia wil ufe no rj d c f h /d vt s emi d
t
t sa bec us Car valha t opporuniyt de eDr St yz kia trhefld t
o tnd a e ni
d he
t t o pos . opc ns fe
ie he
Afi vi. Pli ifas e t t tCa ni lc n r butDr St pc ns ' opi onswih t eofDr
fda t antf s rs ha r va a e
. o ys kis ni
t hos
.

Br dbe
a ny. Dr Br ry,ho e r i af twine sa a aCar va e oye i i hi
. adbe r w ve , s ac t s nd, s
ni l mpl e, t s s

poe ta ne lg n et a ne d t b r b td F rh r r , r i l l s fe prj d c
tn il gi e c h t e s o e e ute . u temo e Canva wil u fr eu ie
be a e, tt slt da e i c nnotob a n a e r r butalwines t addr st o ni i t
c us a hi ae t , t n
t i n xpe t e t t s o
es he pi ons n he
A f i vi. N orw ilt pa te ha an oppo t t t r i e D a
fda t
l he ri s ve
r uniy o a s uber c l nge a t D r
t hale s s o .
St z ki sopi on ora r butale r s nc t tm e f doi s pa s d i Oc obe 201l.
opcy ns '
ni
ny e t xpe t i e he i or ngs o s e n t r

Upo c i r ton,i i her by
n onsde a i t s e

l ' e ne i nc cl m s t tr s Pa e ' qua ii a i ha be n a pa toft sa i
'h glge e ai ha aie t l s ltc tons ve e
I
r
hi cton
s nc i w a fl i 2009. Ca ni lfl d is A ns e and Af m a i D e e e i D e m ber
i e t s ied n
r va ie t
w r
fr tve f ns s n ce
2010.

zl r i no e de e i t r c d t ti c t st tPli ifwasbl ked i he
'he e s
vi nc n he e or ha ndi a e ha a ntf
oc
n r
a tmpt a dic r r a d ng Paelsq lfc tons Thus i wo d a a t ti i Pl i ifs
te s t s ove y eg r i
t ' uaii a i .
, t ul ppe r ha t s antf
f iur t dii ntypurue he c am st tld t t lt flng oft Afi vi.
al e o lge l
s
r l i ha e o he ae ii
he fda t

ORDERED t tDef nda Ca ni lCor a i ' M oton t Sti Afi vi ofDr
ha
e nt r va
por tonss
i o rke tda t
.

Geal E.Stpc ns g 261 i GRANTED.
rd
o yz ki DE- ) s
P

DO NE A N D OR DERED i M i m i Fl i , ti
n a , orda hs
//
*

d yo Dee e, 0 1
a f cmb r2 1 .
<

PA TRI I
A
EI
T
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE

c
c:

A1 cou elofr c d
1 ns
e or