Rinker et al v. Carnival Corporation et al

Filing 289

ORDER denying 203 Motion to Strike ; granting 203 Motion in Limine. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 1/6/12. (tp)

UNI
TED STA TES DI
STR I T C O U R T
C
SO UTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLORI
CT
DA
CA SE NO.09- 5 Cl SE1 SI ONTON
231 4- V- TZ/ M
SA ND R A RW K ER ,

Pl n if
aitf,
CARNI
VAL CORPORATI e al
ON, t .
,
De e nt .
f nda s
/

ORDER GRANTI G I PART M OTI TO STRI ROBERT LESSNE AS AN
N N
ON
KE
EX PER T W I E SS
TN
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour o De e ntRama
S
s f e he
t n f nda
nbha Pa e ' M oton t Sti
i t ls
i o rke
Rober Les nea a Expe tW ine s ori t Ale na i M oto i Li net Exc ude
t s s n
r t s , n he t r tve, in n mi o l

Evd n e Te tmo y, n Co n sa Tra Re adngFuu eM e ia Exp n e ( 2 3 .
ie c , si n a d mme t t il g r i tr dc l e s s DE- 0 )
Dr Le s i Pl i ifse r i t fe dsofvoca i lr ha lt i e oy e ,
. s ne s antf xpe t n he i l
tona e biiaton, mpl m nt
e gonom is a e
r
c , nd conomi s A sPli ifse r,Dr Le s pr pa ed alf ca epl f
c.
antf xpe t . s ne e r
ie r an or
Pl i if i whih hes t ou t c t ofPl i ifsf t em e c lc r a ne .Pa e s eks
antf, n c
es t he oss
antf u ur di a a e nd eds t l e

t e udeRobe tLesnea a e r bec us ( )hef l t a ountf Pli ipsc nce
o xcl
r s s n xpet a e 1 aied o cc
or antf a r
dignossi hi lf e ca yc c ai and( hi rpor i no s poredbyr or
a i n s ie xpe tnc alultons
2) s e ts t up t
ec d
e d e a i e iey s c a i I t at r tve, t ls e t e udeLes ne fo
vi enc nd s ntr l pe ultve. n he le na i Pa e e ks o xcl
s rm
t siyi a
e tf ng boutPli tf f t em e ca ca enee a e
a n ifs uur di l r
ds nd xpens .
es

l t Elve h Cic te r t tmonyi ad si ei t()t e r i q lfe t
n he e nt rui, xpetesi
s misbl f $1 he xpe ts uaiid o
t tf c
esiy ompeentyr ar ngt matr hei e t a e s ( t mehodol bywhiht
t l eg di he te s ntnds o ddrs ; 2) he t
ogy
c he
e r r ac shi c l i i s fc e ty r la easde e mi d by t s r ofi r
xpe t e he s onc usons s ufi i n l ei bl
t r ne
he o t nquiy

ma t i Daube t a ( t tsi
ndaed n
r; nd 3) he etmonyasit t tiroffc,t oug t a i tonof
sss he re a t hr h he pplcai

s e tfc, e hni l o s ilze e rie, ounde sa t e de ort de e m i a f c i
cin ii t c ca , r peca i d xpe ts t
rt nd he vi nce o t r ne a t n

is e' Ci o u c lo av Ha c sCh mia s I . 1 8F.d5 , 6 ( 1hCi.1 9 )
su . t fT s ao s . r o e c l, nc, 5 3 48 5 2 1 t r 9 8
' y
(oonot omitd) Thepa t ofei t e r be r t bur oflyi t pr pe
f t e te .
ry frng he xpe t as he den a ng he o r

f u d to f ra miso o t ee etstsi n Hal .Uni dI s r n eCo o
o n ain o d sin f h xp r' e tmo y. lv t n u a c . fAme ia,
e
rc
3 7F.d 1 5 ,1 61( 1hCi. 0 4 .F rh r r ,h p ryo frn t ee p r d st eb r e
6 3 2 5 2 1 t r 2 0 ) u te mo e t e a t fe ig h x e ti h u d n
ha
o demonsr tng t tt t tm ony i çe e ntt t t s a ha a çogialy ad nc sa
f
ta i ha he esi
s r l va o he a k t nd' nd l c l va e
mae ila pe t ofisca e. BocaRat Communi Ho pial I v Te He t Car Cor ,
tra s c ' t s '
'
on
t s t , nc. . net alh
y
e p.

582F.d 1227,1 ( 1hCi. ) I a expe to ni doesnotha tai i s e i
3
232 1 t r 2009 . f n
r pi on
ve ( vald cintfc
c meci t t pe tne i r i s d bee l d bec us t r i no çi.'1 Thus
ol ton o he ri nt nquiy' t houl
xcude
a e he e s ft'' d.
,
Pl ntf be r t bur n ofe tbls ng t tDr Le s mee sa 1oft s r quie
ai if a s he de
sa ihi ha . s ne
t l he e e r ment i or r
s n de
t t tf a a e t
o esiy s n xper.
Pli tf ha no donet s Dr Le s sr por and hi de ii t tm ony i caet t
a n if s t
hi. . s ne' e t
s poston esi
ndi t ha
hi r po ti ba e on t lf e ctnc ofaheat 6 y rol wom a Ho ver t m e ca
s e r s s d he ie xpe a y
lhy 2 ea d
n. we , he di l

e de ,a wel asDr Les ne' r por, ndia est tPl n ifi no ahe lhy 62 y rol
vi nce s l
. s s e t i c t ha aitf s t at
ea d
wom a s i a 62ye ro1 woma wih sa t e col ca e ,ha wasdi gnos d i M a c
n; he s
a d
n t t ge hr e on nc r t t
a
e n rh
2011.Thus Dr Le s ' r po ta isc l inslc si'wih t f c soft sca e Asa
, . s ne s e r nd t oncuso a k s t' t he a t
f
hi s .
r s toft sl k offt whe que toned a hi deposto Dr Les net sii d t thi S
e ul hi ac
i, n si
t s
ii n, . s e tfe ha s t
number
s

wo l c a g 'i hi lf e p ca c p o e to wa wr n
ud h n e'f s ie x e tn y rj cin s o g.
l he r s e, antf a gue t tt r i no r co d e denc t tDr Les ne' lf
n r e pons Pl i if r s ha he e s e r vi e ha . s s ie

e p ca c p o e to i fa da dta Dee d n sh v n t r uc da y e ie c t a
x e tn y rj cin s lwe n h t fn a t a e o p od e n vd n e h t
Pli ifsc nce wile f c he lf e c a y.Ho ver t bur n i on Pl i ift s
a ntf ' a r l fe t r ie xpe t nc
we , he de s
antf o how t t
ha

he expe t e t t r quie e t ofDau ta Fe r Rul ofCi lPr e e702.Dr
r
r m e s he e r m n s
ber nd de al e
vi oc dur
.

Le s t tfe t thedi nott kePl i ifsca ri o ac ountwhe c c ai he lf
s ne esiid ha
d
a
antf
nce nt c
n alul tng r ie

e p ca c p o e to sb c us h wa no isr ce t b Plitf sat r e s no b c u ei
x e tn y rj cin e a e e s t n tu td o y anif to n y , t e a s t
woul ha no e f c on t c l ultons Cons que l Pli tf c nnotesa iht tDr
d ve
fe t he a c a i .
e nty, a n if n
t bls ha .
Les ne' c l i a t f tr me c lne dsa er i eort tt y wila ss t ti of
s s onc usons s o m te di a e r elabl
ha he l s it he rer
f c bec us a lofhi cacultonsa c l i a ebas d on t lf e ctncyofa he lhy
at a e 1
s l ai
nd onc usons r
e
he ie xpe a
at
wom a whih Pl ntf i no .
n, c ai if s t

Furhe mor Dr Le s slf c epln i l sva i doc or 'a nt nt , rous
t r e, . s ne' ie ar a ncude rous t s ppoi me s va i
t rpi ,a a at nda / i rf 1 hour pe da f t r tofPl n ifslf expe t nc '
he a es nd n te ntdrve or 6
s r y or he es
aitf ' ie
c a y.
Howeve , hi i t r por i caeswhe eorhow Dr Le s de opedt enumbe s At
r not ng n he e t ndi t
r
. s ne vel
hes
r.

hi de ii Dr Le s a te t thedi nots a wih Pl i ifsdoc or orPl ntf. He
s postons . s ne dmitd ha
d
pe k t antf'
t s
ai if

as ad te t ta1oft prj tdme ca c r a fe nc esi t ar smpl hi
lo mitd ha 1 he oece di l ae nd r que y tmaes e i y s
opi on.Thus t r i no e de et s
ni
, he e s
vi nc o uppor ma ofDr Le s se tm a e f f ur m e ca
t ny
. s ne' si t s or ut e di l
c r nee a d t i c t i Pl ntf slf ca epl n.U n rD aube tv M er e lDow
a e ds n he r oss n ai if ie r a
de
r . rl

Ph r c uias I c, 0 U. 5 9 5 2 9 ( 9 3 ,h Co r mu t se ster a o igo
a ma e t l, n .5 9 S. 7 , 9 - 3 1 9 )t e u t s a s s h e s nn r
c
mehodol unde l ng t e r ' t si
t
ogy
ryi he xpe ts e tmony. He e,Dr Le s ha notpr de a
r
. s ne s
ovi d ny

ra o igo meh doo yt s p o t i f tr me ia c r n e sp oe ton f rPlitf.l
e s nn r to lg o u p r hs uu e dc l ae e d r jci s o anif t
a p ast a hi etmae a en ti gmo et nh so i edxt S eCoo e r l Esa eo
p e r h t s si ts r oh n r ha i wn ps ii. e
k x e, tt f

T s irv S e f fMo r eCo ny Fl , 2 F.d 1 9 1 ( 1h Ci. 0 )(ttn ta a
e se . h r fç n o u t a.40 3 0 2, 0 1 t r 20 5 sai g h t
l ctcal t lf c r plni l ssvenf ur me ca ne ds:()me ca caewih
spe is ly,he ie ae a ncude e ut e di l e 1 di l r t
ane ol s sxtmeaye rf t rs ofPli ifslf ( me c c r wih aphysars sx
ur ogit i i
a or he e t antf ie; 2) dial ae t
itit i
tmesaye rf t rs ofhe lf ( ps hiti caef tmesayea f t r s ofhe lf
i
a or he e t r ie; 3) yc arc r our i
r or he e t r ie;
( hos t i tonse r tnye r f t rs ofPl ntf' lf ( physc a occ tona
4) pialzai vey e a s or he e t ai ifs ie; 5) ial nd upai l
t r pyt c amont f t r tofhe lf ( CNA atnda caedrve 1 hour ada f
he a wie
h or he es
r ie; 6)
te nt r/ i r 6 s y or
t ers o h rl e a d( )ase pc a e .Thelf c r plnp oe t t ec sso t e ef tr
h e t f e i ; n 7 le h mb r
f
ie ae a rj cs h o t f h s u ue
me c lne dst be $5, 3,79. wih apr e vaueo $ 390, 87.
di a e o
41 1 58, t
es nt l f 4, 502.

d src c ur ma e ld e p r tsi n whe isf cu l a i i n ta e uaeye pan d .
itit o t y xcu e x e te tmo y n t a ta b ss s o d q t l x lie )
Co eq nty, .Le s ma nott siyr ar ng Pli tf sf ur medialc ene .
ns ue l Dr s ne y
e tf eg di
a n if ut e
c ar eds
Acc di l i i
or ng y, t s
ORDERED THAT De e
f ndan Ra a
t m nbha Pa e ' M oton t Sti Rober Les neasa
i t ls
i o rke
t s
n
Expt'W ines ,o i t Ale nai ,M oton i Li net ExcudeEvi nee Tesi
l t s r n he t r tve
t
i n mi o l
de , tmony,a
nd

Comme sa Tra Regadi Fut eM edia Expe es( 203qi GRANTED i pata
nt t il r ng ur
c l ns DEs
n r nd
D EN I i pa t
ED n r :

The M o i n i Li i t Excl Evi nc Te tmony,a Com me sa Tra
to n m ne o
ude de e, s i
nd
nt t il
Re r ngFu ur M edialExpens i GRANTED.
ga di
t e
c
es s
2. The M oton i DEN I i a 1ot rr s c s
i s
ED n l he e pe t .

DONE AND ORDERED i M i , Fl i ,t s
n ami or da hi
-

GF
c

da ofJ
y anua y,201
r
2.

a

PATRI A A. EI
CI
TZ
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT UDGE
cc:

Al c
l ouns lofr cor
e
e d