Angoma v. United States of Amercia
Filing
36
ORDER AND OPINION DENYING LEAVE TO FILE SUCCESSIVE HABEAS PETITION AND DENYING CERTIFICATE OF APPEALABILITY denying 34 Motion for Leave to File ; granting 35 Motion to Amend/Correct. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 10/22/2014. (yha) Modified to convert to opinion on 10/22/2014 (yha). Modified text on 10/22/2014 (yha).
U NITED STATES D I
STRI C OURT
CT
SOUTHERN D I
STRI O F FLORIDA
CT
Cas N o.10- 42- V- TZ
e
220 C1 SEI
Cas N o.09e
20392- SEI
CR- TZ
LENI A N GOM A,
N
Pettoner
ii
,
UN I
TED STATES O F A M ERI
CA,
Res
pondent
.
O RDER D ENYI LEAVETO FI SUCCESSI H ABEASPETI ON
NG
LE
VE
TI
AND D ENYI CERTI CATEOF APPEALABI TY
NG
FI
LI
PettonerLeni A ngom a pl guit t pos es i ofc ai w ih i entt
ii
n
ed
ly o
s son
oc ne t nt
o
di ti e,w ai ng hi rghtt appeal Ashe ac
s rbut
vi
si
o
.
know l
edged i hi w rte pl
n s it n ea
agr entand agai i c t t s at or m axi um f t e c i esw as40 year .
eem
n n our , he t ut y
m
or hes rm
s
Bas d on t det r i i t he w asa car erof e r he w ass enc t 180
e
he e m naton hat
e
f nde ,
ent ed o
m ont a dow nw ar depar ur f om t applca egui i r
hsd
t er
he
i bl
delnes ange.H ehas a r
l eady
uns c s uly c l
uc es f l halenged t ss nt e onc and now s
hi e enc
e,
eeksl
eave t fl a s ond
o ie ec
habea petton,s ii ly t c l
s ii pecfca l o halenge hi c eer ofenderdes gnaton.
s ar - f
i i
Bec ehi s e e w asw ihi t s at or m a m um f hi c i es t Cour
aus s ent nc
t n he t ut y xi
or s r m , he
t
l c j idito t he rhi s c pe ii n. be a ehi camsa eba e o
a ks urs ci n o a s e ond tto And c us s l i r s d n
Al y p. td Stts 1 3S. . 1 1( 0 3 a De c mp p. tdStts 1 3S. .
l ne Uni ae, 3 Ct 2 5 2 1 ) nd s a s Unie a e, 3 Ct
e
e
2 6 (01 ) whih a er s c i l no r to ci l a ia eo c lae a r viw a
27 2 3 , c r e pe tvey t e r a tvey pplc bl n o lt r l e e nd
i r evantt t s c e he c d notpr le n i t sCour c d r h hi cl m .
r el
o hi as ,
oul
evai ve f hi
t oul eac s ai
A .BACKGROUN D
Undert gui lnes a 'c e ofende 'm us i r eva par have ' w o pror
he de i , 'ar er f
r'
t n el nt t
'
t
i
f l ny c nv ci nso .. c nto ld s t nc ofe e'U. S. j4 .( )( 1 .
eo o ito f . a o r le ubsa e fns . S. G. B11 a 20 4)A
'
' ontoled s t e ofe e' m us i r e ntpar be f ' he m anuf t e,i por,
' r l ubs anc f ns '
c
t n el va
t or '
t
ac ur m
t
expor,di ti i ordipens ng ofa cont oled s t nc ... t pos es i ofa
t s rbuton,
s
i
r l ubs a e or he s s on
c r l s t e ...w ih i e t m anuf t e,i por ,expor,di ti e or
ontoled ubs anc
t nt nt o
ac ur m
t
t srbut ,
dipe e. U.. G. 4 .( ( 0 4) Ango aha t prorc nvito :
s ns ' SS. j B12b) 2 1 .
'
m
s wo i o ci ns
1 F ' a ul a eo de i r ofc nna s' nd ' s s i wih i e t
) or ' wf s l r lve y a bi'a ' e son t nt nt o
unl
pos
s l o dei rc c i 'i vi l to o Fl . t t j8 3.3( )a ,r s ci l
el r lve o ane' n o a in f a S a . 9 1 1 () e pe tvey
t r de eeand s ondhid- gr
ec
degr e f oni ,i Cas N o. 4441 A i t
e el es n
e
99- - n he
Elve h J ca Cic ti a f Da Count Fl i ( 9 8.
e nt udii l r ui n nd or de
p orda.DE- - J
2 Foravi l ton of a S a . 8 3.3( )a () at r de e f l ny,n Ca eNo.
)
oai
Fl . t t j 9 1 1 ()2 , hid- gr e e o i s
F03- 226A i t El nt J calCic ti a f DadeCount Fl i
011
n he eve h udii r ui n nd or
y, orda.
( 9 9 s eas DE- 1 ( e c lo ta c i l)
DE-- ; e lo 1 8 pl a o l quy r ns rpt.
Angom a,t ough c
hr
ouns ,fr tc l
el is halenged t c eer ofenderdes gnaton i hi
he ar - f
i i n s
o e tonst t Pr -e e eI e tgai n Re r, i rt s ntncng. Cour
bjci o he e s ntnc nv si to po t pro o e e i The
t
r viwe t j me si bot c s sa t pla c loquy ta c i i Ca eNo. 3
e e d he udg nt n h a e nd he e o l
r ns rpt n s
F0 01 2 6 a de e m i d t tbot q lfe a ' o r l d s t nc ofe e . ( 9
1 2 A nd tr ne ha h uaiid s ' ntole ubsa e fns s' DE- c
'
1 JThi r s t d i as ntncng gui lne r ngesa tng a 1 8m o hs fom whih
2. s e ule n e e i
dei s a
t ri t 8
nt , r
c
t Cour de re do n a d t i s al o m o h s nt nc .DE- - 2a 5 2 - 6.
he
t pa t d w w r o mpo e 8 - nt e e e ( 9 1 t , 3 2 )
Angom a di notappeal ashe had w ai hi r ghtt do s l t
d
,
ved s i o
o. ns ead,he fl a
ied
ha
beaspe ii on J 21 2010 c l ngbot t l ul sofhi pl and t
tton une , , halengi
h he awf nes
s ea
he
de e m i ton a s ntncng t thewa ac r e o f nde . DE- .On J y 2 ,2 1 ,t s
tr na i t e e i ha
s a e r fe r ( 11 ul 5 0 1 hi
Co ta pt d M a ita eJ
ur do e
g sr t udgeWhiesRe tove r e hi o j ci , nd de e
t ' por, ruld s b e tons a
nid
hi pe ii n.DE- 2)TheCo tde e hi ac tfc t o a a a lt , c t
s tto ( 2 .
ur ni d m eriia e f ppe lbiiy whih he
Elve h Cic ta fr e ( 32 3 .
e nt r ui fim d. DE- , 31
O n Dec ber27,2013,Angom a fl t i a m oton,s ki l
em
ied he nst nt i ee ng eave t fl a
o ie
ne ha a peii ( 34JHea gue t thi c r e - fe rde i to wa not
w be s tton. DE- .
r s ha s a e r o fnde sgna i n s
c r e i t i cm e o s
ha g d n he ndit nt r ubmit d t aj y a pr ve be
te o ur nd o d yond ar a ona e
e s bl
do ,n vi lto ofAl y r Unie Stts 1 3S. . 1 1( 01 )( 1 f c st ti r a e
ubt i o ai n
l ne . td a e, 3 Ct 2 5 2 3 a 1 a t ha nc e s
e
ama t y mi mum s ntnc mus bes te t a f
nda or ni
e e e t ubmit d o nd ound tueby aj y)He
r
ur .
s eque l m oved t am e hi m oton t add an ar
ubs
nty
o
nd s
i o
gum entbas on De c mpsp.
ed
sa
Un tdStts 1 3S. . 2 6 (01 )(hem o fe c t go ia a oa h f dee mi ng
ie ae, 3 Ct 2 7 2 3 t
diid a e rc l ppr c or t r ni
i prorc c insj tf as nt ncnge nc me do snota y t pror
f i onvito usiy e e i nha e nt e
ppl o i
c nvito f vi a i as a ut wih a' i e i vii es to e e e s ) ( - )
o ci ns or oltng t t e t ' ngl, ndi sbl e f lm ntv .DE 35 .
s
B.D I
SCUSSI N
O
Be a eAng aha ar a uns c s f ly s
c us
om
s le dy uc e s u l oughtj2 5 r v e oft s m e
2 5 e i w he a
s ntnc hec le she e t sCour lc j iditon ov ra s c pe iin
e e e ha lnge r , hi
t a ks urs ci
e ny e ond tto
unls hec n i ke92 5 / ' a ngsca e' e tbls ng t thi e rirj2 5
e s a nvo
2 5s ' vi lus 'by sa ihi ha s a le 2 5
s
r edy w as 'nadequat ori f tve t t s t l iy ofhi det i ' 28 U . C.
em
'
i
e nefec i o e t he egalt
s enton.
'
S.
j2 5 4 l t Elve h Cic taf de a prs rc n brng as c nd pe ii n unde
2 5 $. n he e nt r ui, e r l ione a i
eo
tto
r
t s ngsc a e on t bassofa i er ni c
he avi
l us
he i
n nt ve ng hange i t 1 w onl i he m eet fve
n he a
yf
si
r r ent :
equiem s
()
1
t o houtt pe ii rss nt ncnp die ta a, nd fr tj2 5
hr ug
he ttone ' e e i
r c ppe la is 2 5
pr eedi El vent Cic tpr edenthad s ii ly and s
oc ng, e
h r ui ec
pecfca l
quar y
el
f e os t c ai r s i t new pe ii
or cl ed he l m aied n he
tton;
()
2
at rt peii rsfr tj2 5 pr c e g t Supr m eCo t
fe he ttone ' is 2 5 o e dl , he
e
ur
over r t bi ng pr edent
hzned hat ndi
ec
;
(
3)
t tSupr meCo tde ii n a i sr toa tvey on c la e a r viw;
ha
e
ur cso pple e r ci l
o lt r l e e
()
4
a ar s to t tS e eCour de ii n a yi r to c i l t
s e ul f ha upr m
t cso ppl ng e r a tvey, he
pettonersc r s nt nceexcee t s at or m a m um ;and
ii ' ur ent e e
ds he t ut y xi
(
5)
t s vi sca eofj2 5 e r a he hi ca m .
he a ng lus
2 54) e c s s li
S eBr a p. a d n FCC Coe n- e i m,7 8F.d 1 53 1 5 ( 1 h Ci. 0 3 ; e as
e y nt W r e ,
lma M d u 3 3 2 , 2 7 1 t r 2 1 ) se lo
Ja yp, r e ,FclM imi 7 7F.d 1 8 ,1 8 ( 1 h Ci. 0 4 ( ii Br a j
e nt Wa d n
- a , 5 3 2 3 2 5 1 t r 2 1 ) ctng y nt.
Angom a ca
nnots if t e r r ent .H i De c
ats y hes equi em s s s ampsc ai f l t fr tt o
l m ais he is w
pr
ongsbec us De c
a e s ampsdoesnotappl t t sca e atal,a s c d notha
y o hi s
l nd o oul
ve
ove t ned any cr ui pr edentt had f e os hi c ai .De c mpsonl applest
r ur
ic t ec
hat
or cl ed s l m
sa
y
i o
prorc
i onvi tonsbas on s at esw ih a ' i e,i vi i e se ofel e s'
ci
ed
t ut
t ' ngl ndi sbl t
s
em nt .
'
De c mp , 3 S. . t 28 1 F a S a . 8 3.3 t ba i f rbo h ofAng '
sa s 1 3 Ct a 2 2.But l . t t j 9 1 , he ss o t
oma s
pr ca ec
edi t onvi i ,i di sbl i doesnotalow a per on t ' el,m anuf t e,or
ctons s vi i e: t
l
s o' l
s
ac ur
delver orpos es w ih i entt s l,m anuf t e ordelver a c r l s t e.
i ,
s s t nt
o el
acur ,
i , ont oled ubs anc '
'
S unde S e a dv Un tdSt ts 5 4 U. 1 ( 0 ,as ntncng c tc n l k a t
o
r h p r . ie ae, 4 S. 3 20 5) e e i our a oo t he
pl agr em e a c t n ot doc ent t det m i w hi h oft e e e ent
ea e nt nd er ai her um s o er ne
c
hos l m s
Angom a vi a ed: m el w het he pl guit t sa e,m a ac r delver or
ol t na y,
her
ed ly o l
nuf m e, i y,
pos es i w ih i ent A ts nt i t sCour di e ty t : tr e ed t pl
s son t nt . e encng, hi
t d xac l hat i evi w
he ea
c l
oloquy i i Cas N o.F03n n
e
011226A i or t det r i t he had pl guit t
n der o e m ne hat
ed ly o
s l .DE- - 2a 54 6: )
ae ( 9 1 t :- 8.
H i Ale c ai f l t t r pr beca e ' le doesnotappl
s lyne l m ais he hid ong
us ' lyne
A
y
r to ci e yon c l t r lr viw . Ja yr. a d n FclM imi7 7F.d 1 8 ,1 8
e r a tv l
ola e a e e ' e nt W r e , - a , 5 3 2 3 2 5
'
( 1h Ci. 0 4) And hi whol cam f ist f urh pr ng be a e a he
1t r2 1 .
s
e l i al he o t o
c us , s
1
I det m i ng w het a prorconvi ton c tt esa pr cat ofens f a
n er ni
her
i
ci ons iut
edi e f e or
s nt i enhanc e undert A r ed Car erCrm i A c ort Se e i
e encng
em nt
he m
e
i nal t he nt nc ng
Gui i ,s e i c t c l onl att el m ent oft prorconvi ton,not
delnes ent ncng our s an ook y he e
s he i
ci
t f css r undi t c ci n. yo p Unie Stts 49 U . 57 ( 9 0 . h p r
he a t ur o ng he onvito Ta lr . td ae, 5 S. 5 1 9 ) S e a d
f td ae, 4 S. 3 2 0 ) r a e
' Unie Stts 5 4U . 1 ( 0 5 c e t d ana r w e c pto f rc c insba e on
J
.
r o x e i n o onvito
sd
'di sbl s at es' whih pr bi m a dif e ac i tess outi t aler i ,
' vii e t ut z' c
ohi t ny fer nt tvii et
n he t natve
s h t ac
uc hat onviton f vi atng t s at e w oul notceary i c e whih oft e
c i or ol i he t ut
d
l l ndi at
c
hos
pr bied actvii t de e nthad c m it l s h c es She r aut i d a
ohi t
i tes he f nda
om ted. n uc as , pa d horze
' odii d c egorca appr hz'w hih alow ed s encng cour st c ul a
'
m
fe at
i l
oac '
c l
ent i
t o ons t
s cfe s to j ca doc e si or rt de e m i whih oft eee e st
pe ii d e f udii l um nt n de o t r ne c
hos lm nt he
def
enda had vi at De c mpscl ii t She d di nota horze usng t e
nt
ol ed. s a
arfed hat par d
ut i
i hos
docum e st c
nt o onductaf e hee i i
r ew
lng nquiy i o t f t s r
r nt he ac s ur oundi t c
ng he onviton.
ci
-
4-
a knowl dge i hi wrte pla a r e nta i hi plac loq ( 9 45% 4- ;
c
e d n s it n e g e me nd n s e o l uy DE- 5
DE 1 2(9 c- 0 9 375 9,t sa ut y ma m um s ntnc f rt c i e hepld
- 5 0 - r2 3 2) :-1 1 he t t or xi
e e e o he rm s
e
guit ofc
ly omm itngw a 40ye r . U.. j8 ( ( )B)i)( 0 4 . sl o m o h
ti
s
a s 21 SC. 41b)1 ( (i 2 1 ) Hi 8 - nt
s e e i w e lw ihi t 40ent nc s l t n hat years at or m axi um .
t ut y
m
C.CERTI CATE OFA PPEALABI TY
FI
LI
To obt n a c tfca e ofappeal biiy,A ngom a m us m a 'a s t nta
ai er ii t
a lt
t ke ' ubs a i l
s wi oft de a o ac nsiutona rg . 2 U. C. 2 5 c( ) ' peiine
ho ng he nil f o tt i l i ht' 8 S. j 2 3()2 .' tto r
'
A
s tsi st ssa r by de o ta i t t urs so r a o c d dia e wih t
a ife hi t nda d
m nsr tng ha j it f e s n oul s gr e t he
dititc ur' r s uton o hi c tt i l l i ort turssc ul c ncudet
src o ts e ol i f s onsiutona cams ha j it o d o l he
is spr s nt d he ea ea q t t de e vee our ge ntt pr c e f t r'J ne
s ue e e e r r de ua e o s r nc a me o o e d urhe . o s
'
' s cy De tfcor, 0 F.d 1 4 ,1 4 (1hCi. 01 )Ango ha ma nos h
p e ', p'o r.6 7 3 3 6 3 9 1 t r 2 0 .
.
ma s de uc
s i bec e hi c ai i squar y f ecos undert Br
how ng aus s l m s
el or l ed
he yantt t
es .
D .CONCLUSI
ON
Ac di y,i i he eby
cor ngl t s r
ORD ERED t
hat
1
)
Ang asm o i n f la t a e hi m oton ( 3 i GRANTED.
om ' to or e ve o m nd s i DE-51 s
2
)
Ango asm oto f rla t fl ane ha a pe ii n ( 3 ) a
m '
i n o e ve o ie w be s tto DE- 4 , s
a nde ( 3 1 i DENI .
me d DE- 5 ,s
ED
3
)
A c tfc e ofa
er ii at
ppea abiiy i DEN I .
l lt s
ED
4)
Thi c e r ai CLO SED .Any pendi m otonsnotot w i r ed
s as em ns
ng
i
her se ul
upon ar DENI A S M O OT.
e
ED
D ON E AND O RD ERED i M i i Fl i t s MJ
n am , or da, hi
da ofOco r2014.
tbe,
j
.
x
'
'
'
*
PATRI A A .SEI
CI
TZ
UNI
TED STATES DI CT J
STRI UDGE
-
5-
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?