Alsobrook v. Alvarado et al

Filing 162

ORDER ON MOTIONS TO DISMISS. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 12/3/2013. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO. 1 221 3- K1
0- 8 CV- NG
CHRI
STOPHER URI ALSOBROOK,
AH

Pli tf ,
a n if

SGT.
ALVARADO,e a .
t l,
Def nda s
e nt .

ORDER ON M OTI
ONS TO DI I
SM SS
THI CAUSE c e be or t Cour upo Def nda sFau Ka r -l ri a M HM
S
om s f e he
t n
e nt t ma a l a rs nd

S lto s I c' M oi nt Dimis( 1 ) fldJ l 1 201 , fnd n sAl aa o, dia
ou in , n . to o s s DE 21 ,ie uy , 3 Dee a t v rd Me n ,
s
Cly,Crws a d Ha rs M oin t Dimis( 1 ) fld J l 1 2 3 a d De e d n
a
e ,n
ri' to o s s DE 27 , ie uy 7, 01 , n
fn a t

Gre ' Mo int Dimis( 1 4) fldNo e e 4, 3 l teMo ins Dee a t a g
e n s to o s s DE 5 , i
e v mb r 201 . n h to , fnd n s rue
t tCount la 1 s d be dim is d f rf l e t sa e a ca e ofaci or ale nai l
ha
s nd 1 houl
s s e o aiur o t t
us
ton, , tr tvey,

be us t y a eba r d by t He k docrne 1t tCount I ,VI,a V11s d bedimi s d
ca e he r re
he c
ti , ha
s V I nd I houl
s se
f f iur t sae a ca e ofa i t tCount I a VI s d be dim is d f f iur t
or a l e o t t
us
cton, ha
s V nd I houl
s s e or a l e o
e us admi sr tve r di s a fna l t tupon dim is lofCount 1 l,and 1 t t
xha t
nitai eme e , nd, i ly, ha
s sa
s ,1
V, ha
Co s V a VImus a s f l ast y a e de
unt
nd
t lo ai, he r pende tupon t e se oft c tt i
n
he xit nce he onsiutonal
t t co ane ofi Count 1 1 a I .The Cour,beng f l b i e on t m at r2fnds
ors mpli d n
s , 1 nd V
t i uly ref d
he te , i
1Hec v Humph e 51 U. 477( 99 .
k .
ry, 2 S.
1 4)
2 W ih r s t t D e e
t e pec o f ndan s H a r s a M HM Sol t ons l s M oton, t Cour ha a s
t
r i nd
u i , nc'
i
he
t s lo

c i r Pli ifsOpposto t Moton t Dimis( 1 ,whih wasfld on J y 1
onsdeed antf
iin o i o s s DE 26) c
ie
ul 2,
201 Dee ns Re y t Pl ntf Opposton ( 1 ,fl J y 22,201 a Pl ntf s
3, fnda t' pl o ai ifs
ii DE 29) ied ul
3, nd ai if
Sure y( 1 ) fldJ y29, 3. ihr pec t De e nt Al rdo,e J/' M oton,he
rpl DE 41, ie ul 201 W t es t o f nda s vaa t .s i t
1

t t De en s Hari a M HM Sol i , I s M oton s d be de e De e n s
ha
f dant
rs nd
utons nc'
i houl
ni d, f nda t
Al r do,e al' M oton s d be g an ed i pa t a De e ntGr n' M oton s d be
va a
t .s
i houl
r t n r, nd f nda
ee s
i houl

ga e
r ntd.
BA C K G R O UN D 3

OnMa 2 , 01 , an ifCh itp e Ura Alo r o (Alo r o 'fldh seg t
y 2 2 3 Plitf rso h r ih s bo k d s b o k' ie i ih t
)
c u t r Ame d dCo an (h d mpan ' ( 1 5 a ans De e d nt S r e n
o n Thi
d
n e mpli t te f
co lit) DE 0 ) g i t fn a s e g a t
'
Al aa o Seg a tM e ia Ofie Cly FauKa z - zi (s reHars),
v rd , r e n dn , fc r a , t ma aHars d s ri' MHM
Nu
Sol i ,l (t HM Sol i ' M ihae Cr ,Da dHars a Ca an Gre algi
utons nc.S
M
utons), c l ews vi ri, nd pti e n, le ng
ca esofaci under42U. C.j1 3rlt t avi ai ofAlobr sc tttonalrght
us
ton
S. 98 eaed o olton
s ook' onsiui i s
o J 6,
n une 2009,a whih tmeAlobr wasa i t a t So h Fl i Re e i Cen e ,
t c i
s ook
n mnac t he ut orda c pton
tr

a dwhihrs l di Alo r o s tiign me o ssro sij re . s b oo i a imaei
n
c e ut n s b o k usann u r u e iu nu is Alo r k s n n t n
e
t cusody oft Fl i De rm e ofCore i ;
he t
he orda pa t nt
r ctons Capti Gr n,Se ge Al r
a n ee
r ant va ado,
Ser a M e na a Ofi rCl a ee pl esoft Fl i De rm e ofCore i
ge nt di , nd fce ay r m oye
he orda pa t nt
r ctons
wo ki a t Sou h Fl i Re e i Cen e ; M HM So1tonsi a f egn cor a i whih
r ng t he t orda c pton
t r4
u i s or i
por ton, c

wa u rc r twih t Fl i a De rm e ofCo r tonst pr dehe lhc es r ce t
s nde ontac t he ord pa t nt
rec i o ovi
a t ar e vi s o
i t a De rm e ofCore tonsf iiis i udi t Sout Fl i Re epton Ce e ;
nmaes t pa t nt
r c i aclte , ncl ng he
h orda c i
ntr
NureHa rswasa empl ye ofM HM Sol i ns as i d t wor a t Sout Fl i
s ri
n
o e
uto , sgne o
k t he
h orda

Co r ha as c n ie e Plitf sOp sto t Dee d n s M oin t Dimis( 1 2 ,
u t s lo o sd rd an if po iin o fn a t' to o s s DE 4 )
whi wa fld on J y 30,201 a De enda s Re y t Pli ifs Opposton t M o i t
ch s ie
ul
3, nd f nt ' pl o antf
ii o ton o

Dimis ( 1 ,whih wa fld on Aug t8,201 W ih r pec t Dee tGr n'
s s DE 45) c s ie
us
3. t es t o fndan ee s
M oton,t Cour ha a s c i r d Def nda ' M e a um i Opposton t Gr n'
i he
t s lo onsde e
e nts mor nd
n
ii o ee s

M otont Dimis( 1 ,fldNove r20,201
i o s s DE 60) ie
mbe
3.

3The i or ton conti d i t ss c i co e fom Pli if 'Com pli ti t sa ton.On a
nf ma i
a ne n hi e ton m s r
antf s
a n n hi c i
moto t dim is t Cour a e s no c l or alega i a tue and vi wst m i t
i n o s s , he
t cc pt n- oncus y l tons s r
e he n he

l h mo tfvo a l t tePlitf. h rh v I b l 5 6U. 6 2 6 3 6 ( 0 9 .
i t s a rbe o h anifAs c o . q a , 5 S. 6 , 6 - 4 2 0 )
g

4 Se ge nt Al r do, Se ge nt M e na, Ofi e Cly, a Ca ai Gr en a e s d i t r
r a
va a
r a
di
fc r a nd pt n e
r ue n hei
i vi lc pa ii s
ndi dua a c te .

Re ep i n Ce e asa nure.5M ihae Cr wsi t Se ear oft Fl rdaDe rm e of
c to nt r
s,
pa t nt
c l e s he cr t y he o i
Core tons6Da d Ha rsi t f me war n oft Sou h Fl i Rec pton Ce t r?
r c i ; vi ri s he or r de
he t orda e i
ne .
On t mor ng ofJ 6,2009,Ser a Al r do wa on dut a t Sout Fl i
he ni
une
ge nt va a
s
y t he
h orda
Rec pton Ce e . s ook wasi ace lwih ace l t a t Sout FlrdaRe e i Centr
e i
ntr Alobr
n
l t
lma e t he
h oi
c pton
e.

Alob ook' c l ae t d Ser a Al r do t thedi notwa t bei a c lwih Alobr
s r s elm t ol
ge nt va a ha
d
nt o n el t s ook,
a t the woul be om evi e i hewasno s r t d fom Alobr
nd ha
d c
olnt f
t epa a e r
s ook. s ook as
Alobr
lo
r quese t bepl c i a c l s pa at fom hi ce l t Se ge ntAl r do di no s pa at
e td o
a ed n e l e r e r
s lma e. r a
va a
d te r e
Alobr fom hi c l ae.Sho ty t r fer Alob ook' c l t i taed afght whi h
s ook r
s elm t
rl he ea t , s r s elma e nii t
i , c

r s le i Alo r o s sanign meo ss ro sij re . s b o k a mitdt fg tn wih
e utd n s b o k u ti n u r u e iu n u is Alo r o d t o ih ig t
e
hi c lma e a ac r ng y,Alob o wasct i adici i r r por f fghtng a
s el t , nd, co di l s r ok
ied n s plna y e t or i i nd
s f r t l soft ry- ysgan tme.Ba e on t s f c s Cou 1sa e ac eofa i
ufe ed he os
hit da
i i
s d he e a t , nt tt s aus
cton
a i tSe g ntAl a f de i r ei fe e et a rs ofs rousha m .
gans r ea
var do or lbe at ndif r nc o ik e i
r
Ahers r lmi t s a whiet a tck wa silongoi Se gea M e na,Se gea
eve a nu e , nd l he ta
s tl
ng, r nt di
r nt

Alaa o a d Ofie Cly(o eh r t d re to sOfie s' c met Alo r o ' c l d o ,
v rd , n fc r a tg t e,he t r ci n fc r ' a o s b o k s el o r
co
)
a whi tm ehi c l ae sop d at c ng hi .Alobr as d t Corec i Ofi e st
t ch i
s elm t t pe ta ki
m
s ook ke he r tons fc r o

s pa a ehi fo hi c l a et sop t fght TheCore tonsOfi e sdi notm ovet
e r t m r m s elm t o t he i .
rci
fc r d
o
i e c de, a Alob ook r pe e hi r ques,t stme usngpr a t FThe Cor e tons
nt r e
rci
nd s r
e atd s e t hi i
i
of niy.

Ofi e st n soo by a wac d asAl r do' c l ae r s m e at ki hi a t fght
lc r he t d
nd the
va a s elm t e u d tac ng m nd he i
beg ane Ba e on t s f c s Cou 1 saesa c us ofaci a i tSe ge ntM e na
an w. s d he e a t , nt 1 t t
a e
ton ga ns r a
di ,
5x ur e Ha r s i s d i he i vi
s r i s ue n r ndi dualc pa iy.
a ct
6M i hae Cr w s i s d i hi of i i c pac t .
c l e s ue n s f c al a iy
7D avi H a r si s d i hi i vi lca ciy.
d r i s ue n s ndi dua pa t
8A l obr doe no c e tt va i t oft di ci i r r por e e e a i thi f rhi us
s ook s t ont s he ldiy he s plna y e t nt r d ga ns m o s e
of pr a and di r pec f l nguag w he a es i t Cor e tons O fi er , f w hi h he
of ne
s es tul a
e
n ddr s ng he
rci
f c s or c
s f r d t l sof s x y- ys ga n tm e.
uf e e he os
i t da
i i

Se ge ntAl r do, nd Ofi erCly f de i r t i fe e et ars ofs roushar .
r a
va a a
fc
a or lbe a e ndif r nc o ik e i
m

Thefghte nt ly e
i ve ua l nded,lavi Alobr k cove e wih bl a wih vi i e
e ng s oo
r d t ood nd t sbl
woundson hi fcea t bac ofhi he d.Se gea M edi t n or r Alob oo a hi
s a nd he k
s a
r nt
na he de ed s r k nd s
cel a et a l t m s vest be ha ufe t r h afa i t c l door Alobr ag e d,
lm t o low he el o
ndc f d h oug lp n he e l
. s ook r e
bu hi c lma er f e t a l hi e ft beha
t s e l t e us d o low ms l o
ndcufed.Ser a M edi r f e t r move
f
ge nt
na e us d o e
Alobr fom hi celun i bot i t swe eha ufed. ar ul,Alobr r m aned i
s ook r
s l tl h nma e r ndc f As es t s ook e i n
hi c l,u r a e f a t rt hour .Ba e on t s f c s Cou IIsa e aca e ofa ton
s el nte t d, or no he wo
s s d he e a t, nt I tt s us
ci
a i tSe ge M e naf de i r ei fe e t s rousm e ca nee
gans r ant di or lbe at ndif r nce o e i
di l ds.
Alobr a hi c lma ewe et n r m ove fom t i celby Ca an Gr en a
s ook nd s e l t r he e
d r her l
pt i e nd
e c td t t i imar whe eNu s Ha rswasas i
s ore o he nfr y, r r e r i
sgned t pr deca e t Alobr
o ovi
r o s ook.W hie
l
i t i im a y,Alobr k vomie a trbeng over ome wih na e a di zi s .
n he nfr r
s oo
t d fe i
c
t us a nd z ne s
No hels , nd de pie beng i t i im a y f t hour ,Nur eHani ne t rpe f med
net e s a
s t i n he nfr r or wo
s
s
s ihe ror
a di
ny agnosi tsso Alobr k t a s shi he ta anOrdi s cla ba
tc e t n s oo o s es s ad r um
d he e n, ndage ors ur
, ut e
a ofAlobr swounds. s Ha spr ded Alo oo wih f i of n a hewas
ny
s ook'
Nur e ni ovi
s br k t our bupr e nd
r t ned t hi c lby Ca a n Gr n.Fi day l tr onJu 11 2009,Alob ook vomie i
e ur o s el
pti ee ve s ae ,
ne ,
s r
td n
hi c l s
s el, udde yl tc c ous s a sr c hi hea ag ns hi bunk on hi wa t t
nl os ons i nes , nd tu k s d ai t s
s y o he
to , usng ane l c r i o hi f e a Bas on t s f ct,CountI satsa c us of
l or ca i
w a e aton n s or he d. ed he e a s
V te a e

a ton agans Nure Ha rsa M HM Sol i f delber t i fe encet s ro m e c l
ci
i t s ri nd
utons or i ae ndif r
o e ius di a
nee .
ds
M i ha Cr w s a Sec e a y oft Fl r da D e r m e ofCor e i , d i pl c an
c el e , s r t r
he o i
pa t nt
r ctons ha n a e
of i a polc nott s nis o t ai he lhc r pe s
fci l i y
o upe e r r n a t a e r onne fom prva e con r tng tr ss h
lr
i t
t ac i s m uc
a M HM Sol i . i e Cr w shasi pl c a of i i polcy whi h f r ds ordi c ag
s
utons M cha l e
n a e n f c al i
c o bi
s our es
4

c Te tonsofi er f o r movi i t sfom t i ce l unl sal i t si t c la e t
ol c i
tc s r m e
ng nma e r her ls es l nma e n he el gr e o
be, nd a e ha
a r , ndcufe e n i t f c ofme ca e r nces Davi Ha rs a W a de oft
f d, ve n he a e
di l me ge i .
d ri , s r n he
Sout Fl i Re e i Centr hasi plcea ofi alpolc whih f bi ordic ag
h orda c pton
e,
n a n fci
i y c or ds
s our es
c r c i ofi e sfom r movi i t sfo t i c l unl sa 1i t si t c lag e t
ore tons fc r r e
ng nma e r m her els es l nma e n he el r e o
hes a t , unt
be, a a e ha ufed,e n i t f eofm e ca e e g nces9Bas d on t e f c s Co V
nd r , ndc f ve n he ac
di l m r e i . e
sa e ac us ofa i f rpolc labiiy a i tM ihae Cr ws i hi ofi i ca ciyas
tt s a e cton o
i y i lt ga ns c l e , n s fcal pa t
Se r t r oft Fl i De rmen ofCore tons a Da d Ha s i hi i vi ua ca ciy.
c e a y he orda pa t t
r c i , nd vi ni , n s ndi d l pa t

CountVlsa e ac eofa ton f s pe vior la lt a i tD a d Ha rsf ran
tt s aus
c i or u r s y ibiiy gans vi ri o
a lge f iur t tan Ser a M edi Se ge ntAl r do,a Of erCl y,whih 1d t t i
le d a l e o r i
ge nt
na, r a
va a
nd ûc
a
c e o her
tona l
de i r t i fe e t r Alobr ok' c tt i lrg s.oAddii ly, CountVl
lbe a e ndif r nce owa ds s o s onsiutona iht l
I

sa e ac us ofaci a ns M HM Sol i nsf s r ior la lt ba e on a ale d
tt s a e
ton gai t
uto or upe v s y ibiiy, s d
n l ge
M HM Sol i polcy,whi h r s t d i af iur t tai a s r i ee oye , uc a
utons i
c e ule n al e o r n nd upe v s mpl es s h s

Nur eHa rs i pr
s ri, n operme c c r o e our i a o die tng e pl
dial a e, r nc ag ng nd/ r r c i m oyeesnott c
o onduc
t

c rand a n si tsswhihwo l rv a ij re t a a ee p n i t te t s c a ta mai
e ti ig o tc e t c ud e e l nu is h t r x e sve o ra, u h s r u tc

b an ij re . d,ial Co n VlIsae ac u eo a to a ans Ca ti Gre fr
ri nu is An fn l u t I tt s a s f cin g i t pan e n o
y,
delbe aei fe e t ars ofs rousha m f r ur ngPl ntf t hi ce lwih hi
i r t ndif r nce o ik e i
r or et ni
ai if o s l t s
11

c lmaewihwh m h ha j s f u h .
el t t o e d u t o g t

9 'he Com pl ntc a nst f l i conc us y a l ton:Sse gea M e na ha s a e t t
r
ai ont i he olow ng
l or lega i s r nt di
s t t d ha
he di notr m ove t Pl ntf f om hi ce l be us he was f r dde by of i a polc f om
d
e
he ai if r
s l ca e
o bi n
fci l i y r
ope ng a ce l doo ,eve i t c e ofm e ca ne s iy,w he one oft c l m a e i a ce l
ni
l
r
n n he as
di l ce s t
n
he e l t s n
l

r fs st alw hms l t b h n c fe '( 1 5 ! 8 )
eu e o lo i ef o e a d u fd. DE 0 , 2 .
'

1 The a lga i r r ng Da d Ha s s vior labiiy a f l e t tan ar saed,
0
le tons ega di
vi
ni ' uper s y i lt nd aiur o r i e t t

dl n i or tona belef'( 1 !91.
spo nf mai nd i .'DE 05, )
t

1 Thea lga i ofCoun VlIa e s r e a lr el c us y.
1
le tons
t 1 r pa s nd, a g y, oncl or
5

LE G A L STA N DA R D O N M O TI N TO D I I
O
SM SS

Def nda s M otont Dim isal st tCount 1 I,V, V1oft Compl ntf l
e nt ' i o s s lege ha
s , l and
he
ai ai
t me tf de a pla ng sa r and s d bedimis d,u
o e e r l e di tnda ds
houl
s s e nderRul 1 oft Fe a Ruls
e 2 he der l e
ofCi lPr e e, orf iur t sa eacli upon whih r i ca be gr nt d. d. Ci P.
vi oc dur f al e o tt
am
c elef n
a e Fe R. v.

1 Rul 8 r quiest ta c
2. e e r ha ompli i l aSs ta pl n sa e nt' monsr tngt tt
ant nc ude ihor nd ai t t me 'de
ta i ha he

cai nti e ildt r if FedR.Ci P.8. s vi aRul 1 b)6)moi ac ant
l ma s ntte o ele .
v. To ur ve
e 2( (
ton, ompli
mus i l Se
t ncude inoug f c st sa eac am t r left ti plusbl on isf e 'Be l l Cor
h a t o tt l i o e i ha s a i e t ac ,' l At. p.

v Twombl 550U. 5 570( 07 .$ cli ha fca plusbiiywhent pli ifplads
.
y
S. 44, 20 ) 1 am s a il a i lt
A
he antf e
f ct lc e t ta l t c tt dr w t r s bl i e e et tt de e nti la e
a ua ontnt ha lows he our o a he ea ona e nf r nc ha he f nda s i bl

frtemic n u talg d'As c o v I b l5 6 U.. 6 , 6 ( 0 9 . ac r lay
o h so d c le e . h rp . q a , 5 S 6 2 6 3 2 0 ) As o olz ,
'
a lgai abs n s
le tons e t uppori f c sa e no e il d t t spr s pton ofve a t 1 a 681
tng a t r t ntte o hi e um i
r ciy. d. t .

W he e ua i am oton t dimi s t Co tmus t kea1 oft wel- e f t lalegai
n val tng
i o s s , he ur
ta
l he lpld acua l tons
a tu 11 a 664.Howe r i hr a er cial oft elm e t ofaca eofaci s
s r e. t t
ve , s e dbar e t s he e n s
t
us
ton, uppore
td

by me ec l or satm e s do nots fce'I a 663.And,t Cour ' dut t ac ptt
r onc us y t e nt ,
ufi .' d t
he
ts y o ce he
f ct lal ga i i t compl i a tuedoe nOtr r i t i es cii f c ua dea l C n
a ua le tons n he
ant s r
s
equie t o gnor pe fc a t l tis t
i

fv ro g n r l rc n ls r alg to s'Gr hnI du .I c v lvn 4 6F.d 1 8 ,1 0 - 6
a o f e ea o o cu oy le ai n . f n s, n . .r i, 9 3 1 9 2 5 0
'
( 1h Ci.2007) TheCo tmus dimisac antt tdoesnotpr s ntapl i ecai
1t r
.
ur
t s s ompli ha
ee
ausbl l m
d
emonsr tng e il ntt r i .
ta i ntteme o elef
DI
SCU SSI N
O
A s not d a
e bove, D e e nt ' M otons s t f t a vare y of a g e s as t why
f nda s
i
e orh
it
r um nt
o
di m i s lo t va i Count oft Co pl ntoug t be di m i s The Cour s l a e s
s s a f he rous
s he m ai
ht o
s s ed.
t ha l ddr s

ea h i t n.For t r as ct d he ei t Cour fnds t tDe enda s Al a e al'
c n ur
he e ons ie r n, he
ti
ha f nt var do, t .s
6

M o i s d be gr nt d i pa t Def nda sHa a M HM Sol i ,l s M oton s d
ton houl
a e n r, e nt nis nd
utons nc'
i houl
be d e a Defnda Gr e sM oto s d begr nt d.
enid, nd e nt e n'
i n houl
a e
A. CountI

Dee nt pr e t ba e f whiht cam dimis ofCountli a o it i
fnda s esnt wo s s or c hey li s sal
s ppr prae:)
i i bardbyt He docrnea i)i fist saeacl m uponwhi rlefc n begrntd.
t s re
he ck ti nd i t al o tt ai
ch ei a
a e
Fo t r a onsct d he en,t Cour dia e s
r he e s
ie r i he
t s gr e .
i
.

TheH e Doc r ne
ck
ti

l t i t ntCompl i ,CountIsa e a c us ofa to a ns De e ntA l r do f r
n he nsa
ant
tts a e
ci n gai t f nda
va a o

dei rt i fe e e t a rs of srous ha m i vi ai of 42 U. C j1983.Upon
lbeae ndifr nc o ik
ei
r n olton
S.

c i rton ofaprvi ieai oft Compl nti t sa ton ( eAme d Complit
onsdeai
e ous trton he
ai n hi ci Se
nde
an ,
DI 1 ,t Cour deemi d t tPli ifsc us ofa ton agans Defnda sAl rdo a
! 8) he
t tr ne ha antf a e ci
i t e nt vaa nd
M e na f e ngeme i vi ain of42 U. C.51 wasbard by t He k docrne,
di or nda r nt n olto
S. 983
re
he c
ti
be us t a lga i c r dit d t fndi of a dici i r a ton a i t Pl n if f r
ca e he le tons onta c e he i ngs
s plna y c i ga ns aitf o

fg i ba e on t s
i htng s d
he ame i i nt f whih he s f r d a l sofgai tm e.Se Alob ook v
ncde , or c
ufe e os
ni
e s r
.

Alar No.1 221 2011W L 77291 at*1( D.Fl.Fe 28,2011;He kv Humphry,
v ado,
0- 83,
5,
S. a b.
) c .
e
51 U. 477,48 8 ( 4) ( ri a tons br ugh u r 42 U. C. j1 whe t
2 S.
6- 7 199 ba rng ci
o t nde
S.
983
n he
algai t e ne esaiy c lng t vai t ofac ci ;M uhammad v Cl e,540
le tons herof c srl hale e he ldiy
onviton)
. os

U. 7 9 7 4-5 ( 0 4 (x e dn He kb ï t c mpli s s e n j d me ta o d wi
S. 4 , 5 5 2 0 ) e tn ig c - a o o ant e kig u g n t d s t
h
dicplnayaci r s tngi l sofg tmece t) Towist sCour pr vi l fund:
si i r ton e uli n os ood-i rdis.
t hi
t e ousy o
( hee i no diput t tPli ifs frd dicplnay a ton r uli fom t
Tl r s
s e ha antf ufee s i i r ci es tng r he
e t i quesi na ey,a fghtbe wee Pl i ifa hi c l- t on J 6,
ven s n
ton: m l
i
t n antf nd s e lma e
une

2009.( 1 1.No i t e a diput rga di t r uli dicplnay
DE 5-) r s her ny s e e r ng he es tng s i i l

aci Pli ifs f r d t de i ton of3 da gan tme f fg i a f r
ton: antf ufe e he prva i
0 ys i i or i htng, nd o
6 da ofga n tme f dir pe tng ofi i s f I t a t is bef r t
0 ys
i i or ses c i
fcal. #. ns e d, he s ue o e he

Coul ...i whehe t Ame d Compl nt( 18 i iaest dici i r
'
t s t r he
nde
ai DE ) mplc t he s plnay
7

a to t ke a i tPl i if
ci n a n gans antf .
Al obr k, 2011 W L 77 5,
s oo
291

The Dicplna y Re t r fec s t f l ng i is
si i r
por el t he olowi n t

çstt m e tofFa t , whih wa putf war by De e ntM edi
t ae n
c s' c
'
s
or d
f nda
na:
he
i
r nt
On J
une 6,2009 l wa a sgne t c i e as t Hous ng Se gea . At
s s i d o onfnem nt

a po maey 0 5 g o rjIwa i t e o fc rsai n g tig b if d b (h )
p r xi tl 7 0 h u s
s n h fie tto etn ree y t e
M i ni Se ge ntwhe he he r a l ud noie and t dooron c lE21 was
d ght r a
n
ad o
s
he
el
09

p l l dn Aswea p o c e t ec l d o ls w i maeAlo r o .. tg tn
o u n ig.
p r a h d h tl o r a n t s b o k
i h ig
wi gi c l tl Boh imae wee o d r d t c a e tera to a d te
t h s el e . t n ts r r ec o e s h i cins n h y
h
ma
c
ompled.Shorl a trt y sare fg i a i f a oxi a ey 1 s onds
i
ty, fe he t td i htng ga n or ppr m t l 5 ec
,

t y weeagan oderd t c as a t c i l t Alobr and g s
he r i r e o e e nd hey ompled. nmae s ook
hi
c l t)d d n tr s me fg tn a an.Th y we e tk n o to t e c l a d
el e i o e u ih ig g i e r a e u f h el n
ma
es re t m e c lf a s s nt
co td o di a or s es me .

( 21- Di llnar Re t Log #402DE 1, scp i y por,
09028 .l t prvi Ame d Compli ,Count
2) n he e ous nde
ant

lalg d ta Plitf wa a in c n v ci o a a sul i hsj i c l a t a Dee d ns
l e h t anif s n n o e t it f n sa t n i al el nd h t fn a t
e
m
Alaa o a d M e ia wi e s d t ea s utb tto n a to t so i.( e DE l ,! 15 ;
v rd n
dn t se h sa l u o k o ci n o tp t S e
n
8 ! -)
Al ob ook,20l1W L 772915,a *1.
s r
t The Cou tr e t tt s al ga i di notc
r uld ha he e le tons d
ompor wih
t t
t r s uton of t dici i r aci t ke a i t Pli if pur uantt t t i i n ,a
he e ol i
he s plna y ton a n ga ns antf
s
o ha nc de t nd
Coun Iwast r f eS c k bare Alobr
t
he e or c - r d. s ook, 1W L 77291 a *1.
201
5, t
The Amende Com pli t whih wa dim is i pa ta des rbe a
d
an, c
s s s ed n r s c i d bove,wasdr td
afe

a fl d by Pl ntf pr e ngpr s Si e t ttme,Pli ifs c e pr bono c
nd ie
ai if oce di
o e. nc ha i
antf e ur d o
ouns a
el nd
fld t i t ntCompli .l t i t ntCompli ,Cou l sa e a c us of a ton agans
ie he nsa
ant n he nsa
ant
nt t t s a e
ci
i t

De e ntAl r f delbe ae i fer ncet ars o s rousha i vi a i o 42 U. C
f nda
va ado or i r t ndif e
o ik f e i
nu n olton f
S.

j 98 De e d n a g e t a t sc u eo a to i smia l Sc kbar d Fo t er a o sctd
1 3. f n a t r u s h t hi a s f ci n s i lry c - re . r h e s n i
e
he e n, he Cour di ag e s.
ri t
t s re

W ih rs c t Count1 Pli ifalge 1 t tPli ifsc l t soppe Dee nt
t epe t o
, antf le s: ) ha antf elmae t d fnda
Al r do a t d De e
va a nd ol f ndantAl a t the di notwa t be i ac lwih Pl i if a t t
var do ha
d
nt o n el t antfs nd ha
8

i Pli ifwa notr
f antf s emove fom t c l hewoul be omevi e ;2)t tPl ntf as d t be
d r he el
d c
olnt ha ai if ke o
spaatd fom hi cel t 3 DefndantAl r di not ng i r pons t t st ea of
e re r
s lmae; ) e
vaado d hi n es e o hi hr t
vi e e t r Pl ntf;4) t tPli ifs cel t s e nty i tae a fght whih
olnc owads ai if
ha antf' lmae ubs que l niitd i , c

Plitf pat iae i a dwhc r s le i Plitf s sann n meo s ro ij re 'a d
an if ri p td n n ih e utd n an if u ti ig u r us eius n u is n
c
,
5)t tt fghtwoul no ha oc ured i Deenda Al r do had noti e t s t ea
ha he i
d t ve c r f f nt va a
gnord hi hr t
t wa dsPli if
o r
antf .
De e
f ndan a s rs t t t e al ga i
t s e t ha hes le tons ne es a iy c tt e a c le
c s rl onsiut
ha lnge t t
o he

ds iln r a to tk np ru n t ti i ie t b c u ea a j dc to t t v r d vo ae
icp iay cin a e u s a t o h s ncd n, e a s n du iain ha Ala a o iltd
Plitf srg t t ud gv rs t ifr n e gi)ta t ene e st o fg tn ba k . . sa
an if ih s i l ie ie o n ee c sc h t h c si f i h ig c . wa
wo
y
r ul oft ofie s i ci '( 1 a 5) Thi agumen mis t mak. ai aebard
es t he fc r' na ton. DE 27 t . s r
'
t ses he r Cl ms r re
unde t Hec doc rne whe t y ne es a iy c le t valdiy ofa conviton,i udi
r he
k ti
n he c s rl halnge he i t
c i ncl ng

dicplna y aci r s tng i l s ofgai tm e,Hec ,511 U . a 48 8 M uhammad,540
s i i r tons e uli n os
ni
k
S. t 6- 7;
U. a 754- I t sca e Pl i ifsal tonsdo notr iet i e e e t tPl ntf di not
S. t
55. n hi s , antf' lega i
a s he nf r nc ha ai if d
tght ore t Pl ntf s d bee us fom fghtng, r t r t tDe e ntAl r do
i , ven hat ai if houl
xc ed r i i but a he , ha f nda
va a

wa d l eaeyid fee tt t f c t a afg t a dt ec n o tn s bsa ta rs o ij r
s ei rt l n ifrn o he a t h t i h , n h o c mia t u tnil ik f n u y
b
t Pli tf,wa i i t M or ove ,whie Pli tf s al a i i t r e f c st toc ured
o a n if s mm nen . e r
l a n if leg tons n e pos a t ha c r

beor t fcs desrbe i t Dici i r Re t t alegai do notconta c t
f e he a t c i d n he s plnay por, he l tons
rdit he

fn ig ofte Dicpia yRe r. Co r ( 1 7 ! 1 - )wi ( 21 1 Dicpln r
idn s h si l r po t1 mpa e DE 0 , ! 3 31 t DE - , s i ia y
n
2
h
Re r,Log# 402po t
090282,St e ntofFa t,s pr .Ac or ngl Countli notHe k- ïed,
atme
cs u a) c di y,
s
c baï
a t Cou ' m us co i r w he her t alega i a qua el s at a cl m de o t a i
nd he
l
t
t ns de
t
he l tons de t y t e
ai
m nsr tng
en il m e tt r i . e H e ,511 U . a 486tte n o elef Se
ck
S. t
87.

1 N ordoesPl ntf ' alega i t thi c l ae i ta e t fghtc r c t Dicplna y
2
ai ifs l ton ha s elm t niit d he i
ontadit he s i i r
Re t a t r por do no c an a i c ton ofwho sa td t t ht
por, s he e t es t ont i ny ndia i
t re he ig .
9

i.
i

Faiure t St e a C l m
l
o at
ai

( prs n ofs a ' S lbe a e i fe e e't a s t i lrs of s i ham t a
$ i o tcils dei r t ndif r nc o ubsanta ik
A
erous r o n
i t vi at t Ei h Ame e ,' a S ion ofi i s ha a dut .
mua e ol es he ght
ndm nt' nd s s
pr
fcal ve
y

t pr e t
o otc

prs r fom vi e a t ha ofot rprs ne s' Car e v.Galowa 352 F.d 1
ione s r
ol nce t he nds
he io r .
' tr
l y,
3 346,

1 ( 1h Ci.2003 ( i Far rv Br nan,511U. 8 828,833 ( 994:.Howe r
349 1 t r
) quotng me . en
S. 25,
1
ve ,

n te r ij r s fee b o e imae a te ha d ofa oh rta ltsit c nsiui n l
o vey nu y u fr d y n n t t h n s n t e rnsae n o o t to a
t
la l f prs ofi a s who a e r s
ibihy or ion fcil
r e ponsbl f t vitm ' s f t 1 a 8 And,
i e or he c i s a e y. d. t 34.

S e lg n fi r t p o e ta imaefo atc d e n t u tf l bii u de s cin 1 8 .
t gi e t al e o r tc n n t r m ta k o s o j siy i l y n r e to 9 3 .
n
u
a t
'Ca tr3 2 F.d a 1 0 ( u tngBr wn v Hu h s 8 4 F. 1 3 ,1 3 ( lh Ci.1 9 ).
' re 5 3 t 35 q oi o . g e , 9 2d 5 3 5 7 1 t r 9 0 )

. .

Thus t s vi a moton t dimis a ca e of a ton f delbe a e i fe e
, o ur ve
i o s s,
us
c i or i r t ndif r nce mus
t

ade t y pl d t e senc of$()a s tnta rs ofs ro ham;( t dee nt'
quael ea he xit e 11 ubsa il ik eius r 2) he fnda s
dei ae i fee t t trs an ( ca ai ' Se Hal v Tala a Cn/ ,50 F.
lbert ndifrnce o ha ik; d 3) us ton. e e . lpoos
'
y.
3d

1
579, 1 ( 1h Ci. 1 ;s alo Far r 511 U. a 834- (i ng i i ae
582 1 t r 995) ee s
me ,
S. t
38 tndi d bert
del

idfe e c ' rq ie t a t e d fn a twa i u jci l a r o te s b tn ilrs o
n ifrn e' e ur s h t h ee d n s d be tvey wa e f h u sa ta ik f
s
s rousham i or rt ha ha a Sufi e l cul bl saeofmi ' .
ei
r n de o ve d s fcinty pa e tt
nd''
)
As de c i a ve Pli if a s rs t thi c l ae t d Def nda Al r do t the
s rbed bo , antf s e t ha s elm t ol
e nt va a ha
woul be ome vi enti Pli tf wasnotr move fom t c l t tPli ifr que t t be
d c
ol f a n if
e
d r he el, ha antf e sed o
s pa a e fo hi c l ae,t tDef nda Al r do di not ng i r s
e r t d r m s elm t ha
e nt va a
d hi n e pons t t si o ton,
e o hi nf nna i

a d t a a fg te s e ,wh c r s td i s ro ij re t Plitf.Ac o dn l ,t Co r
n h t ih n u d ih e ul n eius nu is o anif c r ig y he u t
e
tnds t t Pli if ha ade t y pld f ct whih s
i
ha antf s
quael e a s
c ugge t t t Def nt Al r do was
s ha
enda
va a

s be t ey a r o a s b tn ilrs o s ro s ham t Pli if i rs ns t whc
u jci l wae f u sa ta ik f ei u r o antf, n epo e o ih
v
De e ntf ie t a t a a co di y,Def nti note tted t t r i r quese wih
f nda a ld o c , nd, c r ngl
enda s
n il o he elef e t d t

10

r pe tt Co t 1 Cf Cartr 35 F.d a 1 49- ( fimi ditit c ts dimis of
es c o un .
e , 2 3 t 3 50 afr ng src our' s sal
i t s s ton 1983 a ton f delbe ae i fer
mna e' eci
c i or i r t ndif ence whe e i a e wa a t ke by hi
r nm t
s tac d
s
c lma ebe a e i e ne t d prs ofi i st theif a ed'hi at cke ,ne rt d t
e l t c us nmat ver ol ion fcal ha
se r ' s ta r ve ol hem

t heha bee ' e ryt eae d,' ndne ra kedt beplc d i t otci c t '.
hat
d n d a l hr tne 'a
cl
ve s o
a e n i e tve usody'
pr
)
B . Count1
1

I CountI,Pl i ifsaesa c us ofa ton ag ns De e n s Al r do,M e na,a
n
I antf t t
a e
ci
ai t f nda t va a
di nd

Cly (h d re to sOfie s' f rd lb rt idfee c t sro sh r i vo ai n o 4
a t e s rcin fc r' o eieae n ifr n e o e iu am n ilto f 2
co
)
U. C. 9 3 Dee a t h vemo e t d s s Co n 1 f rlc o s b e tmatrj rs ito
S. j1 8 . fnd n s a
v d o imis u t 1 o a k f u j c te u idcin,
cai ng t s c us of a ton i bare by t Hec doc rne.Se Hec ,
l mi hi a e
ci s rd
he
k
ti
e
k

U . a 486S. t
87;
1
3

M uhammad,540 U. a 754- Fort r s nscie he en,heCour a e .
S. t
55.
he ea o
td r i t
t gr es

The g a me ofCount 1 i t t t Cor e tons Ofi r wines e Pl n iffghtng
r va n
1 s ha he
r ci
fce s t s d aitf i i
wih hi c lm ae a chos nott i e ce t so t fg .Pl i ifa s admist the us d
t s e l t nd
e
o ntr de o t p he i ht antf l o
t ha
e

pr a t whe a es i t Core tons Ofi r ,f whih he s f r d t l sofsxt da
of niy
n ddr sng he r c i
fce s or c
ufe e he os
i y- ys
gan tme pur ua t a dic plnar a ton.To wi,t Dici i r Repor' tSt t mentof
i i
s nt o
s i i y ci
t he s plna y
ts ' a e
Fa t , whi h wa putf wa d by De e ntM edi r dsa f l ws:
c s' c
'
s
or r
f nda
na, ea s olo

On J
une 6,2009 l wa as i ne t c i m e as t Housng Se gea t At
s sg d o onfne nt
he
i
r n.

a p o i tl 07 0 (o rq1wa i te of c rsain g tig b if d b (h )
p r xmaey 5 h u s
s n h t e tto etn re e y t e
i
M i ghtSe ge ntwhen we he r a l noie a t dooron c l E21 was
dni
r a
a d oud s nd he
el 09

pog ndi W he 1appr c d c lE21 i t Alo ook ...l
ul ng. n
oa he el 09 nmae s br
ooked a me
t
whie Iwas tyi t c nc hi a hi r
l
r ng o onvi e m nd s oomm ae t sop fg i a he
t o t i htng nd
sa e s n wha t f- a e you l ki a why do tyo f-i c e i her
tt d ma
t he -- r
oo ng t
n' u --ng om n e
a gets m e t '
nd
o
oo.

( 21- Dicplnar Re t Log# 402DE 1, s i i y por,
090283) Ast Cour hasprviusy notd,t r i
. he
t
e o l e hee s

' AsteCo r lc ss be tmatr u idcin o e Co n I,i i u n c s ay t a ay et a
3 h u t a k u jc t j rs ito v r u t 1 t s n e e s r o n lz h t
e
c am unde Rul 1 f f iur t sae a cai upon whih r le c n be g ant Se Es ns y v.
li
r e 2 or al e o t t l m
c e if a
r ed. e e o

Mc il 2007 W L 257342,a *1( 1h Ci.J n.31 2007)( fr ng dititc tslc of
M lan,
t 1t r a ,
afimi src our' a k
s j tmater urs ci ove Hec ba e cai .
ubec t j iditon r k- n'd l m)
11

no diput t t Pli if s f e dici i r ac i i co c i wih t s i i nt The
s e ha antf ufer d s plna y ton n nne ton t hi nc de .
qu ton, t r or i whe he t aleg i of Count 1 ne s arl cal i o que to t
esi he ef e, s
t r he l atons
1 ce s iy l nt
si n he
vai t oft dicplna y ac i t ke a i tPl i if Se Alobr k 2011W L 77291 a *1
ldiy he s i i r ton a n gans antf . e s oo
5, t ;
He ,51 U. a 486ck 2 S. t
87.
Co 1 c ai ,i e ala,t f l ng aleg i ns
unt 1 ont ns nt r i he olowi l ato :
37.The Pl i if des r t f r i er nton a fusr t d a t non e pons of
antf, pe ae o nt ve i nd r ta e t he r s
e
t of e s us d pr a t i t li t ofie st do s ehi t sopt fg .
he ûc r , e ofniy n e lng he fc r o
om t ng o t he i ht
43.Thi co does notca l it do t t valdiy of t dici i r r por
s unt
l n o ub he i t
he s plna y e t
ag ns Pli iff s
ai t antf or howi dir s c t c r tona ofi e s.The Pli tf ha
ng s e pe t o oreci l fc r
a n if s
no a does not diput he e t t whie t ofi e s sood pa sve y by and
t nd
s e r ha
l he fc r t
si l
wa c d t fg ,t Pli if e o pr ane a dir s c f l ngua t
t he he i ht he antf mplyed of
nd se pe tul a
ge o
t ofi e s Howe r r r es of t Pl ntf' i u nt us of ha s
he fc r .
ve , ega dl s
he ai ifs mpr de
e
rh
lnguag t ofi e swe e unde a oblg i t sop a fg t y kne t be
a
e, he fc r r
r n i aton o t
i ht he
w o

o c ri g a d t p e e tf te s ro ij r t t ePlitf,b tt y f i dt
c u rn n o r v n urh r eius n u y o h anif u he al o
e
do s
o,

( 1 ! 37,43) Nowihsa ng t slmiain,asi we e ofPli ifsalgai vi
DE 05, !
. t t tndi hi i tto
t r,
antf le tons a
pa ag aph 43,s pr t alega i ofCo t1 s r y c r dit a l s i pa tt sae e
r r
u a, he l tons
un 1 qua el onta c , t ea t n r, he t tm nt
off c s fom t dici i r a ton tke a ns Pli ifpur ua t t si i nt whih wa
a t r he s plna y c i a n gai t antf
s nt o hi ncde , c
s

s san d Co r ( 1 5 ! 37 wih ( 21 1 Dicpln r Re r,Lo # 4 2 0 0 8 ,
u ti e , mpa e DE 0 , ) t DE - , s l iay po t g 0 - 9 2 3
Sttme ofFacs su a) Ass h,t ealegai do notc
ae nt
t, pr . uc hes l tons
ompo twih t r s uton oft
r t he e ol i
he
J 6,20 dicplna y a ton t ke agans Pl i iff dir s ctng c r cto ofie s a
une
09 s i i r c i a n i t antf or s e pe i ore i ns fc r , nd
r c nii of Count1 a a c z bl ca e of a ton woul under i t vai t of t t
e og ton
1 s ogni a e us
ci
d
m ne he ldiy
ha

dic plnar ac i I ;s e alo He k 51 U. a 48 87.Cou 1,t r f e i He k- ïed,
s i i y ton. d e s c
2 S. t 6nt 1 he e or , s c ba ï

a d i p o e l ds s e f rlc o s be tmatrj rs ito S e i, s e as Es n o v
n s r p ry imis d o a k f u jc t u idcin. e d. e lo e s y .
e
.
Mè il 2007 W L 257342,a *1( 1h Ci.J n.31 2007)( tr ng dititc tslc of
M lan,
t 1t r a ,
afimi src our' a k

s be t te j rs it no rSe kb re cam)
u j c matr u idci ve c -ar d li .
o
1
2

C . Count IV and V I 1
s
l4

Cou I s a es a ca e ofac i a ns N ur e H a s a M HM Sol i f de i r t
nt V t t
us
ton gai t s
ni nd
utons or lbe a e

i feenc t s rousme c lne i vi ain of42 U. C.j1 a CountVl sae a
ndifr e o ei
dia eds n olto
S. 983 nd
1 tts
c us ofa tonagans MHM Sol i f s r s y la lt i vi ai of42U. C.j1
a e ci
it
utons or upevior ibiiy n olton
S. 983.

Dee d n sp e e tt b s sf rwhiht ycam d s sa o Co n sI a dVI i j siid: )
fn a t r s n wo a e o c he li imis l f u t V n I s u tfe i
Pli ifs cl ms a e bare f f iur t e us a nita i r dis i vi aton of t
a ntf' ai r
r d or a l e o xha t dmi sr tve eme e n ol i
he

Prs n Lii ton Reor Ac (i t a i)Pli ifha fie t sat a cai upon whih
io tgai
f m t $ A) nd i antf s ald o t e l m
PL1
c
r i fca be gr nt d.
ele n
a e
i
.

Faiure t Exhaus A dm i s i R em edi
l
o
t
ni tratve
es

The PLRA r quie i aest exha taval bl a nita i r m e e be or flng a
e r s nm t o
us
ia e dmi sr tve e di s f e ii

lws tunde 42 U. C.j1 3.42 U. C.jl e()($ a ton s lbe boug wih rs c
a ui
r
S.
98
S. 997 a f ci hal r ht t epe t
No
t pr s c tons unde s ton 1 ...by a prs r ...untls h ad i s r tve r m edi
o i on ondii
r ec i 983
i one
i uc m ni ta i e
es

a aea ia eaee used.).Thus a i t mus f lw gre ncepr e e a e us
s r valbl r xha t '
, n nmae t olo iva
oc dur s nd xha t

alrme isa alb eu d rta p o e ue bf r p ru n a a to u d rj 9 3 Se J h s n
l e de v i l n e h t r c d r eo e u s i g n cin n e 1 8 . e o n o
a
v Me
. adows 41 F. 11 ( lh Ci.2005) Howe r t t t decdi t is , ghe
, 8 3d 52 1 t r
.
ve , s hou
wi
i ng he sue t
Elve h Cic tha jr ogni dt tot rcou t ofa al ha c ude t a nitatve
e nt rui s ec ze ha he rs ppe s ve oncl d hat dmi sr i
r medis a e una l e whe e prs ofi a s do notr pond t a i a e' g i nc or
e
e r
vaiabl
r ion fcil
es
o n nm t s reva es

prve t flng ofgre nc s'Tiusv Kel 51 F.App' 864,866 ( 1h Ci.201 )(ii
e nt he ii
iva e . l . ly 0
'
x
1 t r 3 ctng
Br ,5 F. 1
yant 30 3d 368,1 n. ( 1h Ci.2008).
373 6 1 t r
) And,t Elve h Cic thasa o d t
he e nt rui
ppr ve he
r ol i of f t di put s s r oundi c a m s of f iur t e us a t m oton t di m i s
es uton
ac ual s e u r
ng l i
a l e o xha t t he
i o s s
sag Se J
t e. e ohns 4 1 F. a l1 Br ,530 F. a 1
on, 8 3d t 59; yant
3d t 368.
1 Def n s M oton t e t Count I a V 1 t t r a s t s lt Co t
4 enda t '
i ras
s V nd I oge he , nd o oo hal he ur.
13

A s a pr i i r m a t r t Cour not t t t i s of e
elm na y te , he
t es ha he s ue
xhaus i of a i s r tve
ton
dm nit a i

r medi i a a fr a i def ns ,t bur n ofwhi i bor by de e nt,a pl ntfsa e
e
es s n fim tve e e he de
ch s ne
f nda s nd ai if r
not r quied t de ons r t e us i n i t r com pl nt .Jone v Boc , 549 U , 1 21
e r o m t a e xha to n hei
ai s
s .
k
S. 99, 6

(
2007) I d i ng a moton t dimis f f lr t e us a nitai r dis t
. n ecdi
i o s s or aiue o xha t dmi srtve eme e , he
Elve hCic tf l at se pr e s Tu nerv Bur si 5 F. 1
e nt rui olows wo-tp oc s . r . n de, 41 3d 077,1 ( 1hCi.
082 1 t r
2008) û rt t c tl kst t fcualalgai i t deenda ' moton t dimisa
. d s, he our oo o he a t le tons n he f nts i o s s nd
Fi
t e i t pl ntf s r pons ,a i t c lc ,t kest pli if sve son oft f c s a
hos n he ai if es e nd f hey onfi t a
he antf
ri
he a t s
tue.I,i t t lg ,t de e nt i e ild t have t c
r f n ha i ht he f nda s ntte o
he ompli dim is d f r f iur t
ant s s e o a l e o

exha ta nitai rme e ,i mus bedimis d.Tur r 541F. a 1 ( tng Br ,
us dmi srtve e dis t t
s se
ne,
3d t 02 cii yant

5 0F.da 1 3 7 ) l t ec mpan i n ts be tt d s sa a tefrtse ,teCo r mu t
3 3 t 37 - 4 . f h o lit s o u j c o imis l t h is tp h u t s
m a s ii fndi t r ol t f c ua is s r a e t exhausi Br ,530 F. at
ke pec fc i ngs o es ve he a t l s ue elt d o
ton. yant
3d
1
373- 4,13
7
76.

Plitf fld h siiil o lito J l 2, 01 ( 1 ) Ac o dn l Plitf mu t
anif ie i nta c mpan n u y 2 0. DE 0 . c r igy, an if s
ha e use hi a nitai rme espro t t tdaef hi j1 aci t bes t ne
ve xha td s dmi srtve e di ir o ha t or s 983 ton o usai d.
John on,41 F. d a 11 D e e nt N ur e H a rs a M HM Sol t ons M oton ar ues t t
s
8 3 t 59. f nda s
s
r i nd
ui '
i
g
ha

Pli if ne r s m it a g i va
antf ve ub ted
re nce c e ni t c
onc r ng he onduct of Nur e Ha rs a M HM
s
ri nd
Sol i ,and s hi aci s d bedim is f f l e t e
utons
o s ton houl
s s ed or aiuz o xhaus.I hi Res e,Pl i if
t n s pons antf
l
a gue t t he tme y fld a i or m e c l g i va e as we l a a un i e y i onua
r s ha
i l ie n nf mal di a re nc ,
l s n tm l nf
s or hc ng,
ha he
m edi a greva e w he no r s
c l i nc
n
e pons t hi fr t greva e w a f t om i and t t t
e o s i s i nc
gre nc pr dur w a r nde ed una ia e t hi by t pr s ofi i s'f iur t r s nd
i va e oce e s e r
va l bl o m
he i on t c al a l e o e po

t hi gre nce .s( 1 .Baed ont algai ofPli ifsRe pons ,CountI i not
o s iva sl DE 26) s
he le tons
antf' s e
V s
' pl ntf al st thefld amedialgre
t ai if lege ha
5
ie
c ivanc on J 1 , 2009,whih i wihi t ffe
e
une 7
c s t n he iten14

s be tt ds sa a te frtse a d te Cou tmu tr s l e te fcu lis e r ltd t
u j c o imis l t h is tp, n h
r s e o v h a t a su s eae o
e us i
xha ton.

l t rRe y( 1 i s
n hei pl DE 29) n uppor oft M oton,De e nt ata h t s n, aie
t he i
f nda s tc he wor notrz d
(e a a i ofM a y Vi r t gre nce coo di t r of Fl i St t Prs ,i whih M s
lclr ton
r cke s, he i va
r na o
orda a e ions n
c
.

Vike s sats i e ala,t tPli ifne r fld a i or a or f m algreva esr r ng
c r t e , nt r i ha antf ve ie ny nf m l or
i nc ega di

t c
he onductofNureHa rsa MHM Sol i .( 1 1.Theonl e denc Pli ifofes
s ri nd
utons DE 29- )
y vi e antf fr
i s
n uppor oft e se e ofhi una we e m e c lgreva esa e t Pl ntf sown he r a
t he xit nc
s ns r d di a i nc r he ai if
asy

saeme s conti d i a he gre nce fl i Ocobe of 201 ( 1 3) ls
tt nt
ane n not r iva , ied n t r
0. DE 26- . sues
c e ni t r la lt ofPli ipshe r a satm e snot t t ndi Pli ifsevi nc
onc r ng he ei biiy
antf
a s y t e nt wihsa ng, a ntf
de e
i s fce t d s et de a a i ofM s Vike s bec us i de onsr t st tPl ntf di
s ufi int o iput he clr ton
. c r , a e t m ta e ha ai if d,
ata mi mum ,fl a m e ca -ea e g i nc i Ocoberof201 a M s Vike s'J y 22,
ni
ie
di lr lt d reva e n t
0, nd . c r ul
201 de l r ton sa e une voc l t t Pli if nev r fld a greva s r a e t t
3 c a ai tt s qui aly ha antf
e ie ny i nce elt d o he
c
onduc o Nur e Ha s o M HM Sol i ns As M s Vike s de l r ton i de
t f
s
ni r
uto .
. c r ' c a a i s monsr bl
ta y
i ore De e n sha f l t c ry t i bur n ofde
nc r d, f nda t ve aied o a r her de
monsrtng a f iur t e us,a
tai
a l e o xha t nd
Def nda sa eno e ild t t r le r se
e nt r t ntte o he e if eque t d.
l
I.

Faiure t St e a C l m
l
o at
ai

W ih r s c t Pl ntf ale d f l e t sa e a cai upon whih r i f c n be
t e pe t o ai ifs lge aiur o t t
lm
c ele a
gr nt d,Def nda s ar t tt a l ga i of t Com pl i c e ry s
a e
e nt gue ha he le tons he
a nt l a l how t tN ur e H a r s
ha
s
ri

te t Pl ntf whe he wasbr
r aed ai if n
oughtt t i ima y,s e by Nur e Ha rs a pr ded wih
o he nfr r e n
s
ri , nd ovi
t
da wi
y ndow pr de f flng s h gre nc ,f rwhi he di notr eve a r cept a f r
ovi d or ii uc i va es o
ch
d
ec i
e i , nd o

whihhene rcevedar s e,( 1 a 6) Pl ntf f t al st thefl as ond
c
ver e i
epons DE 26 t . ai if urher lege ha ied ec
g i va r ga di hi l c of team e by Nure Ha s on Augus 27 2009 whie he wa
re nce e r ng s a k
r t nt
s
ni
t ,
l
s
ho e a Suw a e Cor ec i l l tt i a t t he sm ia l di not r ei a r e pt o
us d t
ne
r tona nsiuton, nd ha
i l ry d
ec ve ec i r
r s ef hi s c
e pons or s e ond,un i ey gre nce.
tm l iva
1
5

f
our i of n bef e bei r t ne t hi cel. As De e
bupr e
or
ng e ur d o s l
f ndant put i, Pl ntf ' m e e
s
t ai ifs r
(ia r mentwih t t ofte menther c ve ca
ls g ee
t he ype r at
e ei d nnotb t ba i f a c am f delber t
e he ss or l i or i ae
i fe e e. f nda s'a gu e m is t m a k.
ndif r nc De e nt r m nt s es he r
Defnda sm ic tue t Compli i t rmoton.Pl ntf doesnotdiagr e wih
e nt s onsr he
a nt n hei
i
ai if
s e t
t c s ofte t e .Pli ifalege t tt team e her ceved wa s gr sy i de t
he our e r am nt antf l s ha he r t nt e i
s o os l na qua e
t ia
hat t mount d t no te t e a al TheCompli sa e ,i erala,t tPl i ifwa br
e o
r am nt t l.
ant tt s nt i ha antf s ought

t t i ima y wih ope wounds s lng on hi he d a f ce a c r wih bl
o he nfr r t
n
, weli
s a nd a , nd ove ed t ood.The
Compl ntgoes on t a lge t tPl i if vomie whie a tng te ment a afe bei
ai
o le ha antf
td
l waii r at
nd, tr ng
'r a e ' Pl ntf l f t i i ma y wih ope wounds s li on hi hea a f ce c r d
k e t d, ai if e t he ntr r t
t
'
n
, we lng
s d nd a , ove e

wih bl a wih f i ofn i hi poc t l t El nt Cic t a 51 a i i
t ood, nd t our bupr e n s ke. n he eve h rui, 983 cton s
vibl ev i c eswher a i t i dr a e 'by amedi lpr de whe e t tteam e was
a e en n as
e n nma e s d e t d'
t
ca ovi r r ha r t nt
s c s ya t a
o ur or s o mountt no te t ta al.
o
r a men t l Ancat v.Prs He t Se v . 769 F. 700,70
a
ion alh r s,
2d
4

( 1h Ci.1 .Ac or ngl t Cou tfnds t tDee nt ae no e ild t t r i
1 t r 985) c di y, he r i ha fnda s r t ntte o he elef
s twih r pec t Co sI a V1 .
ough t es t o unt V nd l
D. Count V and V I
s
Count V sat a c e of a ton a i t M i hae Cr s a D a d Ha s f polc
t es aus
c i ga ns
c l ew nd vi
ni or i y

la lt i vi ai of42 U. C.j1
ibiiy n olton
S. 983a CountV1sae a c us ofa ton a ns Davi
nd
tts a e ci gai t d
Ha rsf s vior la lt i vi ai of42 U. C.j1 Defnda s M oton a srst t
ri or uper s y ibiiy n olton
S. 983. e nt' i se t ha
Count V a V1mus be dimis d be a e t va i t oft eca e ofa ton de ndsupon
s nd
t
s s e c us he ldiy hos us s c i
pe
t exitnc oft consiuto lt t al ge i Count 1and l,whi Def nda sar ,a e
he se e he
tt i na ors le d n
s
1
ch, e nt gue r
S c k- r e A s t Cour ha de e m i d t Count 1 i notH e - n e t s a gum e m us
c ba r d.
he
t s t r ne hat
s
ck ba d, hi r
nt
t

f l Ac or ngl Def nda sa enote il t t r lefr uese wih r s c t Count V and
ai. c di y, e nt r
ntted o he ei eq t d t e pe t o
s

1
6

E . CountV l
II

Cou Vl1saesac eofaci a ns De e ntGr en f delbe ae i fe e t
nt 1 t t
aus
ton gai t f nda
e or i r t ndif r nce o

1rs ofsrousham i vi ai of42 U. C.j1 Defnda Gr e movest dimisf
1 ik ei
r n olton
S. 983. e nt e n
o s s or
f iur t sat acai upon whih r ifca be g a ed.The al tonsofCountV11a es r e
al e o t e l m
c ele n
r nt
lega i
1 r pa s

a d c n l s r As Plitf ha fie t pe d a e u t f cs d mo tai g e tt me tt
n o cu o y,
an if s ald o la d q ae a t e nsrtn nil n o
e
r i ,CountV I1m us be di m i s d.
elef
1
t
s se

CONCLUSI
ON
Acc di y,t Cour beng o he wie f l a s d,i i ORDERED,ADJUDGED.
or ngl he
t i t r s uly dvie t s
a d DECREED a f l
n
s olows:
Def nda s Fa u Kam a a l ar i a M H M Sol i , l s M o i t D im i s
e nt t
r -- rs nd
l
utons nc'
ton o s s

( 121 be a t s mei,hee DENI
DE ) , nd he a s rby
ED.
2.

Dee nt Al r do,Me na, a Crws a Hars M oi t Dimis(
fnda s va a
di Cly, e , nd ri' ton o s s DE
1 )be a t s mei, rbyGRANTED I PART.Co 1 i DI I
27 , nd he a s hee
N
unt 1 s SM SSED

wiho pr j diefrlc o s be t te j rs ito
t ut e u c o a k f u j c matr u idcin,
Defnda Gr e sMotont Dimis( 1 be, ndt smei, e
e nt e n'
i o s s DE 54) a he a s herby

GRANTED.CountV11i DI I
1 s SM SSED wihoutpreudie.
t
j c

4.

l Pli ifs elcs hes lr fl a a nde compl ntwihi t nt (
f antf o e t, hal e-ie n me d
ai t n we y 20)
daysoft dae oft sOr . fPli ifdoesnotfl an a e
he t hi der l antf
ie
m ndedcompl i ,
ant
De e nt s l ANSW ER t r
f nda s hal
he emai ng co soft Thid Am e d
ni
unt
he r
nde

Compli ( 107 wihi f t ( )daysoft dat oft sOr r
ant DE ) t n ory 40
he e hi de .
DONE and ORDERED i Cha r a t Ja
n
mbe s t he mes La e
wr nce Ki Fe a J tc
ng der l usi e

Buidi a Unie St t Co t us ,M i mi Fl i t s3r da ofDe mbe ,201
l ng nd t d aes urho e a , orda,hi d y
ce r
3.

ES LAW REN CE K I G
N
UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT
SOU TH ERN DI
STR I O F FL
CT

CC : M ag s r eJudgeChrsM .M c ie
it at
i
Ally
AI Couns ofR e d
l
el
cor

18

GE
I A
D