Jean et al v. T-N-T Farms, Inc. et al

Filing 124

ORDER denying 89 Motion for Partial Summary Judgment; denying as moot 93 Motion to Strike 89 Plaintiff's MOTION for Partial Summary Judgment. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 8/28/2012. (ls)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT
CT
SOUTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CASE NO.1 22467- V - TZ/ M ONTON
0Cl SEI S1
VERTI J
LE EAN , al,
et .
Pl i if ,
a ntf s
V S.

J
OHN C.
TORRESE,e al,
t .

De e nt
f nda s
/

ORDER DENYI M OTI FOR PARTI SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
ON
AL

Th smatri b f r t eCo r o Plitfs M o inf rPata S mmayJ d me t(
i te s eo e h u t n an if' to o ril u r u g n DE-

8 ) Plitfsb o g tti ca sa to o be afo be np c eswhowoke t fed a
9 . anif r u h h s l s ci n n h l f a ik r
r d he il s t
De e ant'f r durng t 2009 1 bea pi ng s as TheAm e
f nd s a m
i he
- 0 n cki e on.
nded Compl i al s
ant lege

voainso t Mi rn a dSe s n l rc tr l o k rP o e to Ac ( PA)a t eFar
ilto f he g a t n a o a Ag iul a W r e r tcin t AW
u
nd h i

La rS a d r Ac .Plitfss e s mmayj d me s ll a t tela ii o Dee d n s
bo tn ads t anif e k u r u g nt oey s o h iblt f fn a t
y
frf i r t c mpl wihttrc r k e igrq ie nso AW P 29U. C.j 1 21d ( )
o al e o o y t h e o d e pn e u rme t f
u
A,
S. j 8 ( )1
a 18 ()1 ,a f fiur t c ywiht wa saeme r quieme sofAW PA,
nd 31c( )1 nd or al e o ompl t he ge tt nt e r nt
29

U. C. j 1 2 ()2 a d 1 31c( )2Be a s ag n ieis eo maeil a te ssa t ti
S. j 8 1d ( ) n 8 ()2 . c u e e un su f tra fc xit s o h s
po ton ofPli if c am ,t M oton i de e
ri
antfs' l i he
i s ni d.

1 t j 1 1d)1 a j1 ()1 r uiee oye st kee a prs v r or
80h 82 ( ( ) nd 831c( ) eq r mpl r o p nd eer e ec ds
c n an n t ef lo n if r to ( t b sso whc wa e a ep i ( t n mb ro
o tii g h o lwig n o main: A) he a i n ih g s r ad;B) he u e f
pic wor uniseane i padonapic kbass ( t numbe ofhour wor d;( t
e e k t r d,f i
e ewor i; C) he
r
s ke D) he
ttlpa perode r ngs ( t s cfcs wihhel a t pur eofe c s wihhed;
oa y i ani ; E) he pe ii ums t d nd he pos a h um t l
a ( t ne pa
nd F) he t y.
2 t j 1 21d ()a d j1 31c( )r q iee ly r t S r viet e c s hwo k r
80h 8 ( )2 n 8 ()2 e ur mpo es o i o d o a h uc r e
p
f e c pa perod, n iemi dwrte sae ntoft i or to r quiedb paa a ( )
or a h y i a t ze itn ttme
he nf main e r y rgrph 1
o t ss b e to ' Th ie i paa rp ()aet o es to ti f t o e1 a o e
f hi u s cin. e tms n rg a h 1 r h s e u n oon t , b v .
'

Pli tfsa guet ti t a ofpr ry r c di t hour wor d by e h wor r as
a n if r
ha nse d
ope l e or ng he
s ke
ac
ke ,

r r d by AW PA , f nd t us af mul t cac a et ho swor ba e on t
equie
De e an s ed or a o lult he ur
ked s d he
a o ofbea pikedby t wor r l s
m unt
ns c
he ke . n uppor Pli if r l en iel on t A fi vi of
q antfs ey tr y he fda t

Ar n oGu d muz( 6 - ) i wh c h sae ta ç ce tddaabae e tr l o t e
ma d a a
DE- 3 2 ,n ih e tts h t 1 r ae t s d n iey n h
l
pr to s
oduc in hown f t w o ker' TheAfi tf rhe sa est t da awa c eae by
or he r .
'
fdavi u t r tt hat he t s r t d
c edii ea h bea pi rwih one hou ofwor f e yt bo sofbe pi ke Howe r
r tng c
n cke t
r
k or ver wo xe
ans c d.
ve ,
athi de ii Guda
s poston,
muzt tfed t theonl us d t sf mul tn ce t n c e , butnoti
esii ha
y e hi or a l rai as s'
i
'
n
a1ca e . DE- 1 1a 5 24- 2.Thus t ei a g nui i s ofma e i lf c ast whe he
l ss
I 7- t 4: 55:
,her s e ne s ue
t ra a t o
t r

Guada
muz vi ae t r cor ke pi r quie e sast a1me be soft cas .
ol td he e d e ng e r m nt
o l m r
he l s
Cons que l Pli tfsha no s
e nty, a n if ve t hown t tt y a ee ild t c a swi r le on t is of
ha he r ntte o l s de ei f he s ue

Dee a t ' al r t c mpywi t er c r k e n rq ie n so j 1 21d ( )a d
fnd ns fiu e o o l t h e o d e pig e ur me t f j 8 ( )1 n
h
1 31c( )
8 ()1 .
Pl ntf s c am sf vi a i oft wag saeme sr uie e sofAW PA a e
ai if ' l i or oltons he
e t t nt eq r m nt
r
de nde o t i r or ke pi c am sbe us i De e nt ke a m a er co dsandt
pe nt n her ec d e ng l i
ca e f f nda s pt cc t e r
hus
di notvi a et r c d kee ng r uie e t ,t n t wa sae e spr vi d t Pl i if
d
olt he e or
pi eq r m n s he he ge tt m nt o de o antfs

we ea c rt.Th r fr , e a s Plitfsaen te tte t s mmayj dg n o t er c r
r c u ae ee oe b c u e an if r o nild o u r u me t n h e od
k e igcams t y aen te t ldt s mma yj g n o tewa esae n cams
e pn li ,he r o ni e o u r ud me t n h g ttme t li .
t
Ac or ngl i i
c di y, t s
ORDERED t t
ha :

Pli if Motonf rPa ta SummayJ
antfs' i o ril
r udgme ( 891i DENI
nt DE- s
ED.

2

2. Def nda s M oton t Sti ort De Pli if 'M o i f Pa ta Summ ay
e nt ' i o rke o ny a ntf s ton or ril
l

J m e f rFa l et Compl W ih Loca Rul 7.C' Re r mentofaNum be e St tm e
udg nt o iur o
y t
l e 5 s quie
r d ae nt

o Un ip tdM aeil cs( 9 )i DENI a moo.
f ds ue tra Fa t DE-3 s
ED s t
DONE and ORDERED i M im i Fl i t s W #
n a , orda, hi
*

d yo Au ut2012.
a f g s,
ee

PA TR I A A . EI Z
CI
U NI
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U

cc:

Al Couns lofRec d
l
e
or