Mangravite v. University of Miami

Filing 32

ORDER Granting 22 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 12/9/2011. (jw)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M i iDi s on
am
vi i
Cas No.1 22895- JLK
e
0CVRON A LD M A N GR AV I
TE,

Pli if
antf ,

UN I ER SI OF M I M I
V
TY
A ,

De e
f ndan .
t
/

ORDER GR AN TI DEFENDANT' M OTI FOR SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
S
ON

THI M A TTER c esbe or t Cour uponDe e ntsM o i n f rSumm a yl m e
S
om
f e he
t
f nda ' to o
r udg nt

( / 2 ,ie Oco r , 1 Th r i Dee d n Uniest o Mimi e ks u r u g n
DE / )fld tbe 7 201 . een, fn a t v ri f n s e s mmayj d me t
2
y
on a1c s TheCour i f l bre e i t m at rl
1 ount.
t s uly i f d n he te .Upon c r f lc i r ton o t r co d a
a e u ons de ai f he e r nd
t pladi , heCour fndsi mus gr ntDe e ntsM oto
he e ngs t
ti t t a
f nda '
i n.
1 Background
.

l t a ve-t e aci n, ai ifRonal M a a t ,aco munia i pr es or s e
n he bo syld to Pl ntf
d ngr vie
m
c ton of s , e ks
d gesf t al d wr ul a oftntr byhi f m e e oy , f nda Uni r iy of
ama or he lege ongf denil e le
s or r mpl er De e nt ve st

M im i Spe tcal Pli ifM a a t cai t tDef nda Uni r iy ofM im iwr u l
a . cii ly, antf ngr vie l ms ha
e nt ve st
a
ongf ly
de e t nur ont ba i ofPli ifsag a wel asi vi ai oft tr ofhi e pl
nid e e he ss
antf ' e, s l n olton he e ms
s m oyme
nt

c rc a aleg pr s soft r madeon be l oft Uni riy.( c. Compl,DE
onta t nd l ed omie enue
haf he vest Se Am.
.
#1 ) Dee tUni st ofM i ha de e a1 cai a hasfldt si t tMoton f
9 . fndan veriy
ami s nid 1 l ms nd
ie hi nsan
i or

1Pli iffld aRe pons ( #28 on Ocobe 23,2011 a Deenda fl aRe y
antf ie
s e DE )
t r
, nd f nt ied pl
( #30)onNove r1 2011.
DE
mbe ,

S mmay J d me t An . DE # ;De sM o .Su
u r u g n .( s,
20 f' t mm.J,DE # 2 .Th f lo n fcsae
.
2 ) e o lwig a t r
undi put d.
s e z

Pl n ifRonal M a r viebe a ee oy asa a ssa pr e s i t Uni r iy'
aitf
d ng a t c m mpl ed n s it nt of s or n he ve st s
Sc
hoolofCom muni to i ar ulrt nur ta k poston e f tveJ nuar 1 2002.De e nt
cai n n eg a e e r c
ii feci a y ,
f nda

Uni r iy ofM i m ipr vi d Pl ntf M a a t wih a f r a f c t c r c si a i t
ve st
a
o de ai if ngr vie t o m l a uly onta t tpultng he
tr sofhi e oy e .
em
s mpl m nt

Thec r t sf rao - pr to
ontac wa o neyer obai no a poi m e fom J nua y1, 2t o
p nt nt r a r 200 hr ughM a
y
1 2002. i ta c r c wassgnedbybot Pl i ifM a a t a t n- ovos Lui Gl s r
5,
The niil onta t
i
h antf ngr vie nd he pr t s a e .
Thec r c pr dedt tPl n ifM a a t spr tona ype i wass he e t endo J
onta t ovi ha aitf ngr vie' oba i r rod
c duld o
n une
1 2008,wih fna de rmentlr viw f pr
,
t i l pa t a e e or omoton a t nur t bei taedby Nove be 15
i nd e e o niit
m r ,
2007. nM a 2002, nde c yea t r fe , antf M a a t e ut a he one ye rr ulr
I y
a a h r he ea tr Pl i if ngr vie xec ed not r - a eg a
tnu e ta k a nt e pr atona yc r c .Thec r c si or a e t Fa ulyM a l
e r r c ppoi m nt ob i r onta t
onta t nc por t d he c t
nua .
The 2001
-2002 Fa uly M a
c t
nual was i e f c a t tme t Pl i if M a a t
n fe t t he i hat antf
ngr vie
c
omm e edhi e oyme . Fac t a l e sf t t s t tvesa r andpr ce es
nc
s mpl
nt The ulyM nua s t orh he ubsan i t nda ds
o dur
ge r l e oy i de sonsa f c i r a nt
ne aly mpl ed n cii
fe tng e ppoi ment pr
, omoton, nd tnu e
i a e r.

AthetmePl ntf M a a t frtoi dt UnieriyofM imit De oft School
t i ai if ngrvie isj ne he v st
a ,he an he
o Comm unia i wasEdwa d Pfse . n 2005,De d Gr r pl e De n Pfse .
f
c ton
r itr l
a ogg e ac d a it r
I 20 Pli ifM a a t frt a i d f r t nur The Sc
n 07, a ntf
ngr vie is pple o e e.
hoolof Comm uni ton'
cai s
t nur d fc t m e a vot dt r omm e pr o i a t nur Twe pt m e r vo e f
e e a uly t nd e o ec
nd om ton nd e e. nt wo mbe s t d or
t nur ,a fvedi not ThePr vos vot d a i tpr
e e nd i
d .
o t e gans omoton a t nur a by lte da e Aprl
i nd e e nd, e tr t d
i
2Thef l wi f t a et ke fom Def ntUni r iy ofM im isStt me of
olo ng acs r a n r
enda
ve st
a ' a e nt

M aeilFa t ( /22) Pl ntf M a r t sr pons t rt ( #28) a t Pari 'J nt
tra cs DE / , ai if ngavie' es e heeo DE
, nd he tes oi
PrtilStp ai ( #31 .
era iulton DE )
2

2,2008,a s Pli ifM a a t oft dec so nott a r t ur Pli ifa ald t s
dvied a ntf
ngr vie he ii n
o wa d en e. antf ppe e hi
de son.
cii

On Nove r 1 2011 Pr sde Sha aa advied Pl ntf M ang avie t thewoul be
mbe 8,
, e i nt l l
s
ai if
r t ha
d
gr nt d ane r vi w f t a r o t nur i J nua y 2009.Uli a ey,on M a c 6 2009,t
a e
w e e or he wa d f e e n a r
tm t l
rh ,
he
Pr ta s Pl i ifM angr viet t di not e m mendt ntr Pli ifM a r t di not
ovos dvied antf
a t ha he d r co
e le. antf ng avie d
a pe l a hi e o e wiht Uni r iy ende i M a 2009.
p a , nd s mpl ym nt t he ve st
dn y

OnNove be 30, 0, ai if a a t lldaSe ndAm e
m r 201 Pl ntf M ngr vie ie
co
ndedCom pl nt3a s tng
ai s eri
cli s a i tDe e nt Uni r iy of M i mif ag dic i i ton i vi a i of t Age
am gans f nda
ve st
a or e s rm na i n olton
he

Dici n to i Emply n Ac (i
srmiain n
o me t t t
ADEA' , 9U. C. j6 e sq. Co n 1, b e c o te
' 2 S. j 21 t e ( u t )4 ra h f h
)
c nr cu l uyo g o fi a df id ai ( un 1)a dprmis r e tp e ( un 11.S c
o ta ta d t f o d at n ar e l Co t 1, n o so y so p l Co t1) ( e .
h
ng
Am. mpl,DE #1 . Pa te c ee al ttnmont ofdic r onOcobe 5,2011
Co .
9) The ris ompltd mos e
hs s ovey
t r
.
Beo et Cou tnow i De e ntsM otonf SummayJ
fr he r
s f nda ' i or
r udgme .DE #22)
nt(
.

3Pl ntf M ang a t fl dt i ta Compl n on Aug t1 201 a lgi t s m e
ai if
r vie ie he nii l
ait
us 0, 0, le ng he a

trecams ( /1. No e r1 , 01 ,h sCo r ds s e wi u p eudc t ecams
h e li . DE /) On v mbe 1 2 0 t i u t imis d t t rj ie h li
ho
f b e c oft c r cualdut ofgoodfiha fi de lngt mtI)a pr sor
or r a h he onta t
y
at nd ar ai cot l nd omis y
et
soppel( un 11,a pe mitdPl ntf Ma a t t fl a n ndedc ant Pli if
Co t 1) nd r te ai if ngr vie o ie n me
ompli . antf
M a g a iefldteFrt n e Co an o No e e 3 2 0.DE #1 )Th n, t t e
n rvt ie h is Ame d d mplit n v mb r 0, 01 (
4 . e wi h
h
co e ofDef ntUni st ofM im i Pl i ifM angr vie tl dt Sec Ame ed
ns nt
enda
veriy
a , antf
a t se he ond
nd

Compli on Ma 4, 1.DE #1 .
ant
y 201 (
9)
4On Ocobe 23, 1 a trt flng ofDef nda ' M oto f Sum mar J
t r 201 , fe he ii
e nts i n or
y udgme ,
nt
Pl n ifM a a t fld aunia e alStpulton f Dimi s lofCount1 i c tng t the
aitf ngr vie ie
lt r i a i or s s a
, ndia i ha

itn st p o e do ywi Comt 1 a d11 ( # 9 . fn a t i est o M imi
ne d o r c e nl t t s 1 n 1. DE 2 ) Dee d n Un v ri f n
h
y
o j ce t teds sa o Co mt1 ag i gt a atrt efl go amoi nf rs mmay
b e td o h imis l f t , ru n h t fe h ii f to o u r
n
j
udgme ,hepl ntf ma dimisacli onl wiht c e oft defnda o u nor r
ntt ai if y s s am y t he ons nt he e nt r po de
oft c t( #30,a 2 .Thi Cour ag e s Absntasi ai onbe foft Defnda o
he our.DE
t) s
t r e . e tpulton
hal he e nt r
am o i on be foft Pl i ifofe i ac
ton
hal he antf f rng ompeli r a on why t sCo s d dim is
lng e s
hi urt houl s s
Count1 Pli ifsuniae a si a i i i ufi e t dimi shi cli f a
, antf
l tr l tpulton s ns fcint o s s s am or ge
d s rmi ton- acl m t tDe e
ic i nai
ai ha f ndan Uni r iyofM im ihase nde f
t ve st
a
xpe d undst de e f
o f nd or
ove oney r FED. CI P. . co di y, hi Or ra es e t Pa tes a g e swih
r
ea .
R. V. 41 Ac r ngl t s de ddr s s he ri ' r um nt t
r s tt a1t e c sale d by Pl i ifi t Sec Ame
e pec o l hr e ount l ge
antf n he ond
nded Compli t
an.
3

I LegalSt
l.
andard

Sl r j d me tsa p o it wh r t epe dn sa ds p o t gmaeile tbiht a
l
mmay u g n i p r prae ee h la ig n u p ri tras sa l h t
n
s
t r i n g n neis ea t a ymae il a ta dt a t mo igp ryi e tte t u g n a
hee s o e ui su s o n tra fc n h the vn at s nild oj d me t s
ama tro lw.Se FED. CI P. Cel e Cor v.CJ/e/ 477U. 31 322( 986) t
te f a
e
R. v. 56; otx p.
r /,
S. 7,
1 .t
one

o te p icp lp r oss o t e s
f h rn ia u p e f h ummay j d me tr l i t ioae a d d s o e o fcu l
r u g n ue s o s lt n ip s f a t al
y
uns ppo td c am sordef ns s'Ceotx,47 U. a 3 -24.
u re l i
e e. l e
'
7 S. t 23
The m ovi pa t bea st b den ofpoi i t t pa tof t r c d t s
ng ry r he ur
ntng o he r
he e or hat hows t
he
a e ofage ne is ofma e i lf t eAdi e v SS Kr s (7 ,398 U. 1 1
bs nce
nui s ue
t ra ac .Se
ck s .
e s t Co.
S. 44, 57

(970) Ale v T on Foods I ,1 1F. 6 6 (11hCi.1 .Oncet movi pa t
1 ; ln . ys
, nc. 2 3d 42, 46 t r 997)
he
ng ry
e t bls t a e eofagen neis ofma e i f ct t b de s fst t nonm o ngpa t
sa ihes he bs nc
ui s ue
t ral a ,he ur n hit o he
vi
ry

t go be
o
yond t pladi a desgna e S pe fc f c ss
he e ngs nd i t l cii a t howi t tt ei age nei s f r
s
ng ha her s nui s ue o

til'Ceoe , 7U. a 3 4; e aloCh n lI c v IainAcie a o a, n .9 F.d
ra . l tx 47 S. t 2 s e s a e, n . . tla tv we r fFl.I c, 31 2
'
1 2,1 7( 1hCi.1 )( di t thenonmovi rymus ç omef r wihsgniia ,
47 47 1 t r 991 hol ng ha t
ngpat ts
c
onvad t i fc nt

po aiee ie c d mo tai tee se c o atibeis eo fc.)
r b t vd n e e nsrt h xitn e f ra l su f a t'.
v
ng
'
S u r u g n ma beia p o raee e wh r tepate a reo teb scf cs
s mmayj d me t y n p r p it v n ee h ris g e n h ai a t,
s
but s r ea
diag e bouthef c ualnf r nce t ts dbedr fom t s f t.'War orTombi ee
t a t i e e s ha houl
awn r he e acs' ri
gb

T a s Co,n . . VNa Fu g, 9 F. 1 9 , 2 6( 1hCi. 9 3 . amoinf rs mmay
r np. .I c v M/ n n 6 5 2d 2 4 1 9 1 t r 1 8 )On t o u r
o
j d me tt c u t s v e t e ie c a rs lea1n ee e i t lg mo t a o a l t
u g n ,he o r mu t iw he vd n e nd e ov 1ifrnc s n he iht s fv rb e o
t nonmo ngpa t Se An r onv fi ryLobb I , U. 242,255( 986 .Howe r a
he
vi ry. e des . be t
y, nc.477 S.
1 )
ve,
mer s i il o e de e i s
e cntla f vi nc n uppor oft nonm ovi pa t sposton i i ufi i t de e ta
t he
ng ry'
ii s ns fcent o f a

mo inf rs mmayj d me t Se i. t2 2 I t ee ie eo frdb ten n vigp ryi
to o u r u g n . e d a 5 . f h vd nc fee y h o mo n a t s
me eyc lr beo i n tsg fc n l p o aie s mma yj d me t sp o r S ei a 2 9 5
rl oo a l r s o iniia ty r b tv , u r u g n i r pe. e d. t 4 - 0.
4

111.A nal s
ysi

Pli ifM a a t af nne c muni tonpr e s att Uni r iyofM i mi s ks
antf ngr vie, o r om
ca i
of s or he ve st
a , ee
dn a s f wha he a lgest be a wr uld aloft nur pr s on dic i naor a
m ge or t
le
o
ongf eni
e e emied
s rmi t y nd
c ii us de sonma ng.Spec fc ly,Pl i if M a r t as e t cli a i t De enda
aprc o
cii
ki
ii a l antf
ng avie s rs a ms gans f nt

Uni riyofM imif ag dici nai (
ve st
a or e s rmi ton Count1, ea hoft c rcua d yofgood f t
) br c he onta t l ut
aih

a dfi d aigt u t1, n p o soyet p e ( u t 1) ( e . Co .DE #1 ) W i
n ar e l co n 1) a d r mis r so p lCo n 11. S c Am. mpl
n
,
9. t
h

t i tn moin, fn a t ie st o Mimi e k s mmayj dg n o a1 li , r un
he nsa t to Dee d n Unv riy f a s e s u r u me t n 1cams ag ig
a lck ofan die torcr um san i le de ofag dic i nai n,aswelast Uni r iy'
a
y rc
ic t ta vi nce
e s rmi to
l he ve st s
c
ompla ewiht wrte con r c ua sa r f tnur e l ton.
inc t he itn ta t l t nda ds or e e va ua i Uponc e ul
ar f consde a i
i r ton
oft unc nt se e de i t r c d, l ngwiht Pa te ' ea ngsa a g e s t Cour
he o e td vi nce n he e or a o
t he ris pl di nd r um nt ,he
t

fn sDee d n Unvest o M imi se t ldt s mmayj g n o a1 o n s
id fn a t i ri f a i n ie o u r ud me t n 1 c u t.
y
t
A.C ountI

ForCount1 Pl i ifM a a t as e t a cli ofag dic i na i i vi ai oft
, antf ngr vie s rs am
e s rmi ton n ol ton he

ADEA, le ngt thewa de e t r andutmaeytr nae be aus ofhi a ( c.
algi ha
s nid enue
li tl emi td c e s ge. Se Am.

Co l!2 DE #1 ) Th ADEA ma e iu lwf lo a e o e lod shag a yi dv d a
mp . 2,
9. e
k s t n a u fr n mply r d ic r e n n ii u l
t
orot r s dic i i t a ns a yi vi wihr s c t hi c
he wie s rm na e gai t n ndi dual t e pe t o s ompe ai t r s co tons
ns ton,e m , ndii ,

o p iie e o e ly n , e a s o s hidvd a ' a e'2 U.. j6 ()1. s c e d
r rvlg s f mp o me tb c u e f uc n iiu ls g . 9 SC. 23 a( )To u c e
'
wih a ADEA c am ,t bur i o t pl ntf t pr t tt def nda e pl rdi not
t n
l i he den s n he ai if o ove ha he e nt m oye d

a r tntr be a eofhi a Gr s v F#f Fi Se v .I . 1 S. .2343,2351 (
wad e le c us
s ge. o s .
n. r s, nc, 29 Ct
-52 2009)
;
s ealoHor v Unie
e s
n . tdpar e sev.I .433Fe App' 788 7 ( 1hCi. 1 (s Supr
c l r ,nc,
d
x , 93 1 t r201 ) &The eme
Cour hasr c ntycarfedt tapl ntf m us pr t t wa t ç -or c us f hea r e
t e e l l ii ha ai if t ove ha age s he butf ' a e ort dve s

e o ntaci i or rt prvalonadipaaeteame cl m unde t ADEA.)
mplyme ton n de o e i
s rt-r t nt ai
r he
'.
'

Toa v n ep s tes mmayj d me t tg ,h panif s o fret r ie t vd n e
d a c a th u r u g n sa e te li tf mu t fe i d rc e i e c
he
o ds rmi to o e tb iha i f cec s o a eds rmiainwi cr u tnil v d n e
f ici nain r sa ls prma a i a e f g ic i n to t ic msa ta e i e c .
h
Se Pac v S R . ys, 01F.d1 8 , 3 8( 1hCi. 9 3 ; e aloGr s , 2 S. . t 51n4
e e . . y S .7 2 3 3 1 8 1 t r 1 8 )s e s o s 1 9 Ct a 23 ..
Fo a s r s ' c me orde ano t c tt e die te de e ofagedi c i i ton,t
r upe vior s om nt
me r o onsiut r c vi nc
s rm na i he
c
omm e o a tonmus c usvey s bi t tc s îzadve s r ul i t wor ac See
nt r c i
t oncl i l how as ha au edtk
r e es t n he kpl e.

Clr v Co t ( Cl r ,I c,9 0 F.d 1 7 1 26 ( t Ci.1 9 ) A panifwh ofes
a k . as f a k n . 9 2 21 , 2 11h r 9 3 . lit
f o fr

cru tnil vd n emu t sa ls aprmaf cec s o a eds rmiain b f r t b r e
ic msa ta e ie c s e tbih i a i ae f g ici n t e o e he u d n
o
s fst t e pl rt oferalgii ae,
hit o he m oye o f e tm t nondic i i t yr as f t pl i ifst mi i
s rm na or e on or he antf ' er naton.

Ch pma v AIT a s , 29F.d 1 2 1 2 ( 1hCi. 0 )
a n . r np. 2 3 01 , 0 4 1 t r 20 0 .
W iht i t M otonf rSumm a yJ m e , enda Uni r iyofM i a gue t t
t he nsant i o
r udg ntDef nt ve st
nmi r s ha
Pli ifM a a t hasf l t pr dea die tors fcint r m santal de i s
antf ngr vie
aied o ovi ny r c
ufi e cicu t i evi nce n uppor
t
ofhi a dic i nato cai . ongwih t M oto f rSum ma yJ
s ge s rmi i n l m Al
t he
in o
r udgme ont ADEA cli ,
nt he
am
De e ntUni r iyofM im i es sa Stt mentofM a e i Facsand ct st e de on t
f nda
ve st
a pr ent
ae
t ral t
ie o vi nce he

r c r i tef r o d po i o of an ifM a g a ie De n Gr g a dDe nPfse .De .s
e o d,n h o m f e st ns Plitf n rvt , a o g, n a itr ( f'
i
Sae n o Fa t ! 2 - 6 DE / 2 DE # - 5 .l Repo s t Dee a ts M oin f r
ttme t f cs ! 2 2 , / 9
2
23 2 ) n s n e o fnd n ' to o
Summ a yJ
r udgme , antf M a av t doe notr f t anyofDe e
nt Pl i if ngr ie s
e ue
f ndan ' ar m e s diec t
ts gu nt , r t he

Co tt a y f c st tde
ur o n a t ha monsr t t r i a is f ti ,orde a ofDe e ntsas e td
ta e he e s n s ue or ral
ny ny
f nda ' s re

mae ilfcswihr s e tt teADEA cam. P1' S ae n o Fa t ! 2 - 6, # 8 . e
tra a t t e p c o h
li ( . ttme t f cs ! 2 2 DE 2 ) Th
s
Cou tmus now deer newhe he Pl ntf sf iur t c r ve tDef nda ' f t wilbe ft
r
t
t mi
t r ai if a l e o onto r
e nts acs l
aal

Plitf sADEA cam a t s mmayj d me tsa e Se S. F a L. 5 .( )(W 1 maeil
anif
li the u r u g n tg . e D. l. R. 6 1b ( 1 tra
f c s s tf t i t mova ' satm e fl and s ppore asr quied a
a t e orh n he
nts t e nt ied
u
td
e r bove wilb de m e
l e e d

6

a ted un e sc r red by t o
dmit
l s ontove t
he pposng pa t ssa e e , ovi d t tt Cour fnd t t
i
ry' tt m ntpr de ha he
t i s ha

t mova ' sae nti s ppo tdbye d nc i t r or '
he
nts ttme s u re
vie e n he ec d.).

iDie t ie c o
. r c Evd n e fAgeDic i nai n
s rmi to
l t a
n he bove syld a ton,Pli tf M a a t al ge t tDe n Gr us d lbe s s h
-t e ci
a n if ngr vie le s ha a ogg e a l , uc

a t o n e fc ly'( e . Co l! 1 , #1 ) Plit fM a g a i as alg sta o c
s i u g r a u t. S c Am. mp . 1 DE 9 . ani n r vt lo le e h t n e
y
'
f
e
hesoppe dyi hi g a harda ka hi ag be nmea r t tDea Gr sde e nort r
t d ng s r y i r nd s e c
ppa en ,ç n ogg' m a owa ds
Pli ifc nge 'a t ttDe n Gr alo ma s ve alc me sa
antf ha d' nd ha ç a ogg s de e r om nt boutPli ipsc ngeof
antf ha

a aa e'( c. Co . 1 DE /1 .
ppe rnc .' Se Am. mpl! 4, / 9)
l s ppo toft M oton f Su ma y J m e ,De e ntUni r iy ofM i ciesa
n u r
he
i or m r udg nt f nda
ve st
ami t
numberofca e i s
s s n uppo t isa gume t tt ea lgatonsar i ufi i ntt c tt ediec
r of t r
nt ha hes le i
e ns fc e o onsiut r t

e i e c o a eds rmiain. DE #2 a 1 -1 ) Fo e a e i Br d e v P e , n . te
vd n e f g ici n to (
2, t 3 4 . r x mpl,n a ly . hz r I c, h
Elve h Cicui he d t ta sa e ntby t hii m a erdurng a pr i i r i e viw t t
e nt r t l ha tt me
he rng nag
i
elm na y ntr e ha
pli if di not s nd lke a S prng chi n' di not consiu e diec evi nc of age
antf d
ou
i
t i
s
cke ' d
tt t r t de e
dicrmi to whe et hii ma ge r c
s i nai n
r he rng na r e omm e d pli ifpr r s i t i e vew pr es ,
nde antf og e s n he nt r i
oc s

whe e t hii m a ge wa no t uli a e de ii
r he rng na r s t he tm t c sonma r a whe e t r wasi ufi int
ke , nd
r he e
ns fc e
e d nc t tpl i ifwa not om otd be aus ofa biso be l oft hii mana r 2011
vi e e ha antf s pr
e c e ny a n haf he rng
ge .

W L 39628 a *2( t Ci.Se .9,2011.
24, t 11h r pt
)
He e, nGr g' c
r Dea og s omm e sa aci ar a ogo t t ei Sri /y. ket hii
nt nd tons e nal us o hos n t e Li he rng
m a ge i Br e De Gr g r c
na r n adly, an og e omm e d Pl i if M a a t f t r durng t
nde
antf
ngr vie or enu e i he

2007
-2008a ade cy rde piet 20 ons t Pl ntf Ma a t' ol ra aa .De.s
c mi ea s t he 06 e of ai if ngr vies de ppe rnce ( f'
St e ntofFa t !22,DE /22;Gr De 80:6-81:9,DE /24) Furhe ,i hi de ii
atme
cs
/
ogg p. 1
1
/ . t r n s poston,

De n Gr g e pan d ta wh nheu e tetr S e o fc l 'a d Cu o fc ly'h wa
a o g x li e h t e
s d h ems d nir a ut ' n j nir a ut , e s
s
y
'
7

rfri t t eln t o tn r a dn t ot ep oe s r' g s ( f' S ae n o F cs 23 DE
eerng o h e gh f e u e n o t h r fso s a e .De . ttme t f a t ! ,
s
#22; Gr g De 82: 1 4: , DE /24) Fi ly,Dea Gr tsii d t t hi e nt l
og
p. 1 -8 21
/ . nal
n ogg e tte ha s ve ua
rco ndai a ns Pl ntf M a avie' tnue had not ng t do wih hi age.( .s
e mme ton gai t ai if ngr t s e r
hi o
t s
Def'

S ae n o Fa t !22 DE / 2 Gr g De 8 1 -811 , # 4 .
ttme t f cs , / ; o g p. 0:6 :9 DE 2 )
2
Gi nt s nt si o ofDe nGr ont r c d,heCour fndst theDe e nts
ve he wor e tm ny
a ogg he e or t
t i ha t
f nda '

f cualsaeme si de e eofPl ntf' ale tonsofdiec evi nceofa dic i i ton a e
a t t t nt n f ns
ai ifs lga i
r t de
ge s rm na i r

s p o tdb rc r e i n e t f' S ae n o Fa t !2 DE / 2 . c r i l Plitf s
u p re y e o d vde c . De s ttme t f cs 2, / ) Ac o dngy, an if
2
f iur t de t e f c sdee t m a te
al e o ny hes a t
ms he dmitd.

i. r u tn il ie c t Esa l haPrmaFa i Ca eo eDici nain
i Cic msa ta Evd n e o tb i
s
i
ce s fAg s rmi t
o
To e tb ih te tp c l i f cec s o a e ds rmiain,te panifmus o fr
sa ls h y ia prma a i a e f g ici n to h litf t fe
e ie c ta h û 1 wa a me e o t eprtce a e go p,( )wa s be td t a v re
vd n e h t e i ) s
(
mb r f h o e td g r u 2 s u j ce o d e s

e ly nta to ,( )wa q aiidt d t ej b, n ( )wa rplc d b o o h nvs l ta
mpo me cin 3 s u lfe o o h o a d 4 s e a e y r t e ie os
postont ayou ri vi al'Ch pman, F.d a 1
ii o
nge ndi du .' a
229 3 t 024. nt Sec Am e d Compl i ,
l he ond
nde
ant

Plitf M a g a ie wh wa 51a te t o hrng alg sta dep t çe evln )sr n
an if n rvt, o s t h i f ii , le e h t s ie d c i ig to g
me
r
r vi fom hi f c t pe r 'a t una mousa ova ofhi t nur a iato b t M oton
e ews r
s a uly e s' nd he ni
ppr l
s e e pplc i n y he
i
Pit r Fa ly,t l s qualfe i vi l,who we eunde t a of40, e eg ant tnur ,
c u e cu t wo e s
ii d ndi duas
r
r he ge
w r r ed e e

whl h wa n t ( e . Co l ! 5 1 ,1 , #1 ) Top o e dt til t r c r mu t
ie e s o. S c Am. mp . ! , 6 8 DE 9 . r c e o ra,he e o d s
co an ev de i s ppo tofPli ifM a a t sa lga i .
nt i i nce n u r
antf ngr vie' le tons

l t M otonf Su mar udg
n he i or m
yl mentDe e nt v r iyof i mi nc dest t ai if
, f nda uni e st M a co e ha Pl ntf

Ma g a iec netb ihta h wa ame e o t eprtce a eca sa dt a h wa s be td
n rvt a sa ls h t e s mb r f h oe td g ls n h t e s u j ce
t a reempl
o dve s
oymen a ton whe hewa de edtnur ( #22,a 1 . e ntUni st
t ci
n
s ni e e. DE
t 6) Defnda
veriy

o Mimi r u sn v rh ls ta Plit fM a r v t c n o e tbih a i a i c s o a e
f a a g e e e tee s h t ani ng a ie a n t sa ls prmaf ce a e f g
f
8

dic i nai n bec us o t d rh ofe de o Pli ifM a a t ss fce quaii a i
s rmi to
a e f he ea t
vi nce n antf ngr vie' ufi int lfc tons
f t nur a t ale d unde qua iia i ofsm ia l st t d i vi swho we eof e e
or e e nd he l ge
r lfc tons i lry-iua e ndi dual
r f rd

tn r .DE # 2, t1 -1 ) l s p r o t e ea g me t, fnd n Unv riyo M imi ie t
e u e ( 2 a 3 6 .n u po t f h s r u n s Dee a t ie st f a dr cs
teCo r t t es m tsi n ofDe n Gr g a dDe nPûse . DE # 2! 21 2 ) P an if
h u t o h wo e tmo y
a og n a
tr ( 2 J , 5 . litf
!
M a a t doe notconett s a sri offc.( #28!!21 25)
ngrvie s
ts hee se tons a t DE
, .
Fori tnc De n Gr g t sii d t tt Pr os di notr omm e d tnur be us ,
nsa e, a
og e tfe ha he ov t d
ec
nde e e ca e
afe a f lr viw o t dif e oc aso ,i was deer i t t Pl i ifM a r vie wa
tr ul e e n wo fer nt c i ns t
t m ned ha antf
ng a t s

unqualse f t r be us oft o rl we knes ofhi s hol tc r or ( ogg De
i d or enu e ca e he veal a s
s c asi ec d. Gr
p.
78:-79: De/55 . rhe, anPfse tsiidt tDi Kontxi, oft ceai pr e s s
9 9, / ) Fu t rDe itr e tfe ha a
a sone he r tve ofs or
a r tnur wa mor qualfe f t nur t n Pr es orM a a t and t Chrsi Lan
wa ded e e, s e
ii d or e e ha of s
ngr vie
hat itna e,
t ot rpr es ora r d tnur wa ata tona s hol rwho sm pl coul notbec
he he of s wa de e e, s r dii l c a
i y
d
ompar dt
e o

ace t epes n.Pfse De .1 4;6 2 ,1 6:-1 DE # )
rai ro ( itr p 1 1 - 2 1 8 3, 25 .
v
Upon c i r tonoft s nt tmony ct byDe e
onsde a i
he wor esi
ied
f ndant t f t a itdbyt
and he acs dm te
he
Pl ntf,t Cou tfndst tDe e a Uni r iy o M i ,a t m ovi pary,ha metis
ai if he
r i ha f nd nt ve st f nmi s he
ng t s
t

bur n t de
de o monsr e t abs nce o a ge ne is ofm ae ilf ctwih r pe tt t ADEA
tat he e
f
nui s ue
tra a
t es c o he
cli .Se Adi e ,398U. a 1 7. t r t Cour tndst tPl i ifM a a t ha f ie t
am
e ck s
S. t 5 Furhe , he
ts ha antf ngr vie s a ld o
g be
o yondt pla ngsa desgna eS pecfcf t s
he e di
nd i t t ii acs howi t tt r i age nei s f rti l'
s
ng ha he e s nui s ue o ra'
co r ng t ADEA c am .Se Cel e 477 U. a 32 Ac di y,t Coul fnds t t
nce ni he
li
e otx,
S. t 4. cor ngl he
' i
t
ha

Dee da tUniest o M imi se tte t s mmayj d me to t ADEA cam.
fn n v ri f a i nild o u r u g n n he
y
li
B.C ount1
1

Count1 ofPli ifM a avie' Se ond Ame d Compl i i acli f br ac ofa
1
a ntf ngr t s c
nde
ant s a m or e h

9

c nta t l yof
o r c ua dut goodf iha f i d alng. ai if a r t a g t t e nt veriy
at nd ar e i Pl ntf M ng avie r ues ha Def nda uni st
ofM i br ac d t i ple c na ofgood f t a f i de lng whe i al gedl f ie t
ami e he he m i d ove nt
aih nd ar a i
n t le y a ld o
a r t t t nur pl na a bir iya idahi rsa doff l of s or e e t Pl i if
dhe e o he e e a nd r tarl pple
ghe t ndar
ulpr e s r viw o antf
M a a t st nur a i ton,he e de i ngPl i ifof sr m o bl c r c e ca i
ngr vie' e e pplca i t r by prvi
antf hi e s na e onta mal xpe tton
t t heDe e nt ve st of i wo da yt lw e a s it pr e s rsanda dofr viw
ha t
f nda uni riy M nmi ul ppl he o r s oca e of s o t r
e e

a grnte euponco ei ofhet epln.DE#28, t13,1 )l t M oto f Su r
nd a tnur
mplton t enur a (
a
7 .n he in or mmay
J m e , e ntUni er iyofM im ia gue t tPl ntf M a a t c nnotpur u abr c
udg nt Def nda
v st
a r s ha ai if ngr vie a
s e ea h
ofaconta t ldu y ofgoo f ih a f i de i c am a e abr a ofa s ii c r c ua
r c ua t
d at nd ar alng l i bs nt e ch
pecfc onta t l

o lg to . DE # 2, t )
b iain ( 2 a 21 .
The tm pled c nantofg f t and f i de i i de i d t pr e t c r ctng
t i ove
i
ood aih
ar alng s sgne o otct he onta i

pa tes ras ee cai . Co v Cs l e modalI ,732 So. 1 1 ( a.Dit
ri ' e onabl xpe ttons' x . x ntr
'
, nc.
2d 092, 097 F1 s.
Ct App.1 .û brac oft i id c
.
999) W e h he mple ovena ofg fih a f rdeai i nota
nt ood at nd ai lng s
n
i pend tc eofa ton,buta tc st t pe f manc ofa s c fc c ntacua oblgai '
nde
en aus
ci
ta he o he ror
e
pe ii o r t l i ton.'

Ce tro Ai Ca go l c v Untdpa c l e v Co, 20F.d11 ,1 51( 1hCi. 0 ) $ Th
n u in r r , n . . ie r e S r . .4 3 46 1 1 t r20 5 .< e
(
Elv nhCic il a h l t a acam fr b e c o i le c v n n o g o fiha df id aig
e e t rut h s ed h t li o a r a h fmpid o e a t f o d at n ar e l
n
cn tbemai ai d unde Fl i a lw i t a enc ofabr a h ofa e es t r ofac r t'
nno
nt ne
r ord a n he bs e
ec
n xpr s e m
ontac .
'
I a 11
d t 52.

ta t l r a h de iid n antf
l t a
n he bove-t ed a ton, t onl a lge con r c ua b e c i ntfe i Pli if
syl c i he y le d
M a a t sCompl i i apr son i t Fa t M anua t t e f c t t a t tme oft
ngr vie'
ant s ovi i n he culy
l o he fe t ha , t he i
he

i ta a poi m e , wa e ild t be a s i wrtng by t Exe i Vie Pr sde an
nii l p nt nt he s ntte o
dvied n ii
he cutve c e i nt d
Pr tof t s t ntve sa r and pr edur s ge al e pl d i de sons a f tng
ovos
he ubsa i t nda ds
oc e ner ly m oye n cii
fec i

po in a d tn r . S c Am. mp.!29 DE #1 ) Plitf Ma g a iec n e d ta te
r mot n e u e ( e . Co l ,
o
9 . anif n r vt o tn s h t h
10

Pr vos ne rpr vi dhi w iht s t s tntvesa r a pr e esi m ii t r y
o t ve o de m t he e he ubsa i tnda ds nd oc dur n tng, he eb

rn ei gDee d n Unvest o M iminb e c o c nrc .M a g a ieAf. 2 DE # 8 4 .
e d rn f n a t i ri f a i r a h f o ta t ( n rv t f ! , 2 - )
y
l i unc ese howeve , t t De e nt Uni r iy of M i m idi i f c pr de Pli if
t s ont t d,
r ha
f nda
ve st
a
d n a t ovi
a ntf
M a a t wih t s t ntvesa r a pr dur f tnur i wrtng.
ngr vie t he ubsa i tnda ds nd oce es or e e n ii
Ass tf t i De e ntUni r iy ofM im isSt tm e ofM ae ilFa s a t tm eof
e orh n f nda
ve st
a ' ae nt
tra ct, t he i
hi i ta a nt e ,Pl ntf M ang avie waspr de wih a e oyme c r c t twa
s niil ppoi m nt ai if
r t
ovi d t n mpl
nt onta t ha s

sg
ined, be foft Uni r iy,byt pr tLui Gl e , c expr s l a i bol prnt
on hal he ve st
hen- ovos s as r whih
e sy nd n d i
a s d t Pli ifsrght a dute asaf ulyme be we es tf t i t Fac t M a .
dvie hat antf i s nd i s
ac t m r r e orh n he uly nual

( # 2!4; # !4) l i t ipue t a Plitf M a g a iewa p o i e wi ac p o
DE 2
DE 28 .t s mds td h t an if n rvt s r v d d t o y f
h
t eFa ul M a u l( a g a ieDe 2 6 2 DE # 2!4; # !4)I i as u d s u e t a
h c t n a.M n rvt p. 3:- 3; 2
y
DE 28 .ts lo n ip td h t
t Fa uly M a li t docu e t s sf t t s tntve sa r and pr dur st t
he c t
nua s he
m nt hat et orh he ubsa i tnda ds
oce e ha

g n rlyaee ly di d cso safcigtn r .DE # 2!4; #2 !4)
e e al r mp o e n e iin fe tn e u e ( 2
DE 8 .
Upon c r ulc i r to oft r co dand t pladngs t Cour fndsno e de ei
a ef onsde ai n he e r
he e i , he
t
vi nc n
t r co d ofa e es c r t du y,i l ngt dut t pr de Pli ifM a a t wih
he e r
ny xpr s ontacual t ncudi he y o ovi
antf ngr vie t
t s t ntve sa r a pr ed es f t nur i wrtng,t tha bee br a d b t
he ubsa i t nda ds nd oc ur or e e n ii ha s n e che y he
Uni r iys ast pe mi ac am f br a oft dut ofgoodf t a f i dealng. co di y,
ve st o o r t l i or e ch he y
aih nd ar i Ac r ngl

s mmayj d me i g a tdo Co n I.
u r u g nt s rn e n u t I
C .CountI I
I

Asa at m a i t t cai f rbr a h of hecon r c ua dut ofg f t a f rdeai
n le tve o he l m o e c t
ta t l y ood aih nd ai lng

s tf t i Cou I, ai ifM a av t ha as e tdac am f pr s or eso li Count11
e orh n
nt 1 Pl ntf ngr ie s s re l i or omi s y t ppe n
1.
ThebassofPli ifM a a t spr s or e t
i
antf ngr vie' omi s y soppelcli i t De n Pfse advie hi t
am s hat a i tr
sd m o
d ie hi own tnur pln t t onc a ove woul c tt e t r quieme sf tnu e an
ev s s
e e a ha , e ppr d,
d onsiut he e r nt or e r d
11

t a,fh c mpidwihto erq ie n s h wo dbeg a td tn r . S c Am. mpl !3 ,
h ti e o l
e t h s e u rme t, e ul r ne e u e ( e . Co ! 6
3 DE #1 ) l r i e o Dea Pfse ' rpr e ai ,Pli ifM angavieal est the
7,
9 . n elanc n n itrs e esnttons antf
r t leg ha

t a sdo 'v ro soh ro p ru te a o h ru ie ste . S c Am. mp ! 3 , #1 )
ç se n' a iu t e p o tniis t t e nv riis ( e . Co l ! 8 DE 9 .
p
Sl elme srquie t etbls pr sor et lla lt unde Fl i lw ae: 1
t- e nt e r d o sa ih omis y soppe ibiiy
-he
r orda a r ()
apr s ma byt pr s ;2)t c t pr s s dras ye c t i ea i
omie de he omior ( whih he omior houl e onabl xpe to nduc cton
o f be r nc ont pa toft p omie '( t ti f ti
r or a a e he r he r s e, 3) ha n ac nduce s hacinorf beaa e,
d uc to or rnc and

t a ()d j siec nb a od do l b e f re n o t eprmie' Iht Ho dn Co, LC v
h t4 i u tc a e v ie n y y n o c me t f h o s .'y ie l ig .L .
n
'
M a tnMa it Matral, n .4 3F d Ap x9 3, 47( 1hCi. 01 ) q o igI R. a ed
ri ret e i s I c, 2 e . p' 4 9 1 t r2 1 ( u tn ' Gr c r
a
I
r
Co. .Geo aSe v .I .5 So. 91 9 ( a 1 9). at es dmatrt lw i cea
v dat r s, nc, 47 2d 9, 24 F1. 98 )As hr hol te,he a s l r
t t' omi s y e t
ha i
pr s or soppeli nota ia e asa r m e when t pa tesha a wrte co r c
s
valbl
e dy
he ri
ve
itn nta t

a d e sn ter lv n is e .d ( iigAdv n e ft. ' . r r ZK Y c Sae , 3 S 2
d rsi g h ee a tsu s I ctn
a c ds kg s w Cop. . a ht ls 8 0 o. d
y
924,9 ( a Dit CtAp 2002).
28 F1. s. . p.
)
He e,i i unc e t d t tPl i ifM a r vie se o e wih De e ntUni r iy
r t s ont se ha antf ng a t ' mpl ym nt t f nda
ve st
ofM im iwa gove ned by a
a
s
r
nnualc r c s e c ofwhih e es l i om or t d t Fa t
onta t , a h
c xpr sy nc
a e he culy

M a u l( # 2! 2 1 DE# ! 2 1 ) Ii as u o tse t th Fa u t M a u l e f rh
n a.DE 2 ! , 3; 28 ! , 3 .ts lo nc ne td ha te c ly n a s t o t
bot t s t ntvea pr e a r quie e sf a hivi t nur and gove ne e r se of
h he ubsa i nd oc dur l e r m nt or c e ng e e
r d ve y t p

t tnuep o e s ( # 2!4 DE # 8 !4) Un e t s cru tn e , e eawrte c nr c
he e r r c s .DE 2 ; 2
. d rhe e ic msa c s wh r
itn o ta t
a es e t r l va is - i t sc s ,hepur ui o t ntr - t r m e of omis yesoppe
ddr s s he e e nt s ues n hi a e t
s t f e le he e dy pr s or t l
i una lbl,asa m at roflw,t co e tDe e ntUni r iy ofM i ' de son t de y
s vaia e
te
a o nt s f nda
ve st
amis cii o n
Pl n if a a t t nur Se F7ï:Hol ng Co.LLC, Fe App' a 947. r o e i lght
aitf M ngr vie e e. e 7/
di
,
423 d.
x t
The ef r ,n i
oft e s e e ofagover ng w rte co r ct lpr s on, he Cour f ndsi m us gr nt um m a y
he xit nc
ni
it n nta ua ovi i t
ti t t a s
r

j d me t nteis eo p o so yetp l
u g n o h su f r mis r so pe.
12

Ac or ngl ha ng c i r d t Pa te flngsa beng o he wie a s d,i i
c di y, vi onsde e he ris' ii
nd i t r s dvie t s
he e ORDERED,ADJUDGED,and DECREED a f l :
r by
s olows

Dee n ' M oi f SummayJ
fnda ts ton or
r udgmen ( #2 be a t s mei hee
t DE 2) , nd he a s rby,
GRANTED.

ThePr ti lCo e e e s hed e f De embe 9, 1 a 9: mm . t
era nf r nc c uld or c
r 201 t 00
and he
Trals he e f t t we k ti pe i ofFe uar 21 2011a ehe eby
i c duld or he wo- e ral rod
bl y ,
r r
CANCELED.

Th Clr s al
e ek h lCLOSE ti c s . eCo r rt is u id cint c nsd r
h s ae Th u t ean j rs ito o o ie
moto f cossa f e ,i a
i ns or t nd e s f ny.
4.

A1 pe ngm oto a e DENI asm oot
1 ndi
i ns r
ED
.

DONE and O RDERED i Chambe sa t J m e La e eKi Fe r lJ tc
n
r t he a s wr nc ng de a usi e
Buidi a Unied St t Co t e i M im i Fl i o t s9t day ofDec mbe ,2011.
l ng nd t
aes urhous n n , orda n hi h
e r

AMESLAW RE
NCE KI
NG
U . D I TRI COURT
S. S CT
SOUTHE D I TRI OF FLORI
RN S CT
DA

1
3

CC:

Cou s l rPli W
n efo ant
PaulB e nar K unz
r d
Ba r & A s oc a e
nde
s it s
444 BrckelAve.
i l
Suie300
t
M i m i FL 331
n ,
31
3 - 05 358 5800
Fa 305- 4- 93
x:
37 65

Emalp ul b n e vs .o
i: a @ a d r iac m
Co n e f rDee a
u s l o f nd nt
Eri D avi Is cof
c
d i f
li fRagaz & Koe gs r
scof
t
ni be g
1 Br c l Avenue
200 i ke l
Suie 1
t 900
M imi FL 331
n ,
31
305- 3
373- 232
Fa 305- 3233
x:
373-

Emal liof ilw.o
i: sc f@ ra c m
Teresa R agat
z
l iof Ra t & Koe gs r
sc f gaz
ni be g
1 Brc lAve
200 ikel
nue
Suie 1
t 900
M im i FL 3 31
a ,
31
305- 323
373- 2
Fa 373x:
3233

Emal Ra az ilw.o
i: g t@ ra c m
Susan Vi ni W arner
rgi a
I iof Ra t & Ko gs r
sc f gaz
eni be g
1 Brc lAve
200 ikel
nue
Suie 1
t 900
M i m i FL 33 1
a ,
31

Emal wa n r ilw.o
i: r e@ ra c m

1
4