Kardonick v. JP Morgan Chase & Co. et al

Filing 345

Letter to the Court by Margaret E. Wheeler (yha)

U N I D STATE S D I
TE
STR I T C O UR T
C
SO UTH ERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M I IDI SI N
AM
VI O

FI b
LED

D.C.

AU2 19 2 1
21
Cas N o.1: 0- ve
1 c 23235 H OEV ELER
/
DA V I I
D QARD ON I ,i vi l and o be l
CK ndi dualy
n ha f
ofalot r sm ia l st t d a t ge r lpublc
l he s i l ry iua e nd he ne a
i,

Pli if
antf,

STEVEN M. L MORE
CL
E
ARj
RKU
ST (
'
s.o.f s DI A ,T
o Q /. MI
-Mi

OBJECTI TO SETTLEM ENT
ON

J ORG AN CHA SE & CO . a CHA SE BAN K
PM
nd
U SA .N . .
A

De e nt .
f nda s
OBJECTO N TO SETTLEM ENT
1 1a am e
. m
mberoft scl sa tons a ltmel s it d acli f ' asr r .
hi as c i nd i y ubm te
am ol
m
equied
2. M y f l nam e i M a ga e W he l r and m y addr s i 57 He ma Ne r n Roa
ul
s r rt
ee,
e s s 2 r n re
d,
H u i on,Texa 75949. The l tf di isofmy s i ls cziy numbe a e 8948.
ntngt
s
as our g t
oc a e lrt
rr

Io j c t t i s tlme tf rs v r lra o s Fis,hed tni o o t ams'i t
b e t o hs et n o e ea e s n . rt t ei t n f t i ' n he
e
i
cl
s tl nti f rt b oad a enc
eteme s a oo r
nd ompas i , a s t i t defnii oft e ed
sng nd o oo s he i ton û as
Rel
Cli ' Bot oft e tr pur tt i l ca ms ofwhi,h t c a s me be s
a ms.
'
h
hes e ms por o ncude li
c he l s
m r
have no knowl dge e s. The s tl m e e n pum ors t r e e cl i s t t a e
e
xit
e te nt ve
t o el as a m ha r
c ea e or hi n. Thi i unc cona e. As a r sde of Te s Te lw
onc l d
dde
s s ons i bl
e i nt
xa , xas a

pr nt a c
eve s ompany fom obt i ng a r l s ofunknown or f tr cai s u rt
r
ani
eea e
utle l m nde he
Texa D e ptve Tr de Pr c i es A c . The s tlm e a tm pt t a co pls t t
s ce i
a
a tc
t
e te nt te s o c m ih ha

whihTe a lw p e e t a t eeo ei s o l b rj ce .
c x s a r v n s nd h rf r t h ud e ee td

4 'Ias o j c t t es tlme tb c u ei atmp st dv r stlme tf n st c ran
. lo b e t o h ete n e a s t te t o ie t et n u d o e ti
e
cl s r es atves, but i i u l rw hy t s c as m e be s des r e an m or t n
as epr ent i
t s nc ea
he e l s m r
ev y
e ha

t r tofus. The have noti red a l ale
he es
y
ncu r ny eg xpens , a t r i no i c ton
es nd he e s
ndi a i
t t t y ha done a hi m o e t n t r t oft c a s membe s I t cl s
ha he
ve
nyt ng r ha he es
he l s
r . f he as

r pr s nt i sa ee il t $2, e ch,s i ea h cls me r
e e e atve r ntted o 500 a o s c a s mbe .
5. l t e ntt e i a diput a
n he ve her s
s e boutt s tlm e a a hi r a e t i Sec i
he e te nt nd nyt ng elt d o t
ton
,

4A oft s tl nta e m e r quie me t r ol i i t sCoul i Fl i
he eteme gr e nt e r s
o es ve t n hi
' n orda
t

, even

t
hough Ir i i Texa . l lha a pr em wih t i plm e ai ore eu i of
esde n
s f ve
obl
t he m e nt ton
xe ton
t s tl ment ls d notha t s e a r dy i Fl i . 1 s d,w ih a ldue
he e te
, houl
ve o e k eme n orda
houl
t l

r pe t t s Cour,be a e t hol t de e tla e f br c ng t s tl nt
es ct o hi
t
bl o d he f ndan i bl or ea hi he eteme
a ee
gr menti Te . Anyt ng es i unf i.
n xas
hi le s ar

1f rhe o j c t t e stlme tb c u et ca slwy r 'fe c me srih o to
u t r b e t o h ete n e a s he ls a e s e s o tag t u f
t s tl me f e tbls d f t be i of t cls . Thes f e s d ha
he e te nt und sa ihe or he neft he a s
e e s houl ve
be n nego i e s r e y onc a s tlmentnu be wasr a d f t c a s The
e
tatd epa atl
e ete
m r
e che or he l s .
i er nglng of t c a s l
nt mi i
he l s awye s f es a t c a s s te e f
r ' e nd he l s etl m nt und gi t
ves he
a a a t t s tlm e wa notneg it a t r slngh' a t no i s aes
ppe r nce hat he ete nt s
otaed t i m e t ' s he tce t t .
a

Alo,t c t f notc t cas m e r and a i sr ton cosss d bebor e by
s he oss or ie o l s mbe s
dm nita i
t houl
n
t def nt s par t l snc t i m i c
he enda s e a e y i e he r s onduc c us d t s l ui. Suc c t s d
t a e hi aws t
h os s houl

notbe de t d f o t cl s m e
duc e r m he as
mber 's tl ntf . Alo toublng i t f ct
s e teme und
s r i s he a
t t t a ount of l er ' f es a e
ha he m
awy s e nd xpens s r quesed i not ava lbl on t e
e e t s
ia e
h
s tlm e we ie. Thus cls m e r ha no i ho lr of a c
ete nt bst
a s mbe s ve
dea w a ge
hunk oft
he
s
s tlmentt cls lwye s a e tki away fom cl s m e
e te
he a s a r r a ng
r
as
mber . Thi i or ai
s
s nf m ton

s d have be n dicos d t cls me be supfont I a
houl
e sl e o as m r
r . t ppea st ss te
r hi etl ments f r
ufe s
2

'

fom t s m e c t s and c o of de e i t t t cas l wy
r
he a
overnes
l ud
c pton ha he l s a
er a us t
s cc e he
def nda s ofundera ng wih r s tt t pa nt pr t c i pr uc s Fi l
e nt
tki
t e pec o he yme
o e ton od t . naly,

ca sc elsf s d be ba e on t ne s tlme a unt( trde i of
ls ouns ' ee houl
s d he t ete nt mo afe ducton
notce a admi srton c t) snc t ne s tlme a
i nd
nitai oss, i e he t ete nt mountr e e s t tue
eprs nt he r
ûû

val ' ai d f t cls .
ue'obt ne or he a s

I i a s toublng t t s tlm e a e ntpr vi t de e nt t uniae a
t s lo r i hat he e te nt gr eme
o des he f nda s he l tr l
rght t t m i t t s tl e agr e e i t Cot ' i pos
i
o er na e he e tem nt e m nt f he
ut m e
s a addii l
ny
tona

fna i loblga i on t . Si et Cour i c r d wih de e mi ng t f i e s
i nc a
i ton
hem
nc he
t s ha ge t t r ni he a m s
oft s tl ment t de e nt s d notbeabl t sm pl optoutoft a e nt
he e te
, he f nda s houl
eo i y he gr eme

i t Cour de e m i st a tonalfna aloblg i on t de e
f he
t t r ne hat ddii
i nci
i atons he f ndan sa e f r
t r ai.
8. The e i alo no r as bl ba i f i e pr tng t s tlm e
r s s
e ona e ss or nt r e i he ete nt

agr ent tnder
eem
l

Deawar lw . None oft r e ntl ws t a
l ea
he elva a uis ppea t have orgi t i t tsa e
ro
i naed n ha t t ,
and t r i no r s na e bass f i er e i t s tlm e a
he e s
ea o bl
i or nt pr tng he ete nt g
r m e unde
ee nt
r
Del r l .
awa e aw
9. Fi l and m os t oublng, i t f c t tt r i a ol el no si a i i t
naly,
tr i
s he a t ha he e s bs ut y
tpulton n he
s tem ent agr ent t t pr ven s t def nda s fom c i ng t i de e i
etl
eem
ha e t he e nt r
ontnui her c ptve

pr c i s I t a i a ar t l wye s obt i d a quik pa da and
a tce . nse d, t ppe s he a r
ane
c y y

e bl t
na ed he

de e
f ndant t c i on wih t i dec ptve busne spr tc s The onl l e s i
s o ontnue
t her e i
i s aci e .
y os r n

t s de a e t vi i s oft s me t cls m e be s Eve yone e s sa t
hi al r he ctm
he che - he a s m r .
r
le t nds o
be ftwhie t cls membe s wave a loft i cli f a pit nc . Thi s ul
ne i
l he a s
r i l
her a ms or ta e
s ho d

notbepe m itd by t sCour.
r te
hi
t

1 'Fo te er a o s lr s e tu l rqu s t tt e Co r rj c te p o o e s tlme t
0. r h s e s n , ep cf ly e et ha h
u t ee t h r p s d ete n

and s t pa te ba k t t ne i tngt bl f amor f i s tl nt
end he ris c o he gotai a e or
e ar e teme .
Da e:Aug t 1 2011
t
us 5,
.

Si er l
nc ey,

M a e E. he l
r t W e er
572 Her n Ne r n Roa
ma
re
d
Ht i on,Texa 75949
mtngt
s

(36)4229
3300

SERVI OF DOCUM ENTS
CE

ls ntt sdoc
e hi
umentby ce tfe mai t
riid l o:
Cl k oft Cour
er
he
t
Sout r DititofFl i
he n src
orda
400N o t M im iAve.
rb a
M i i Fl i 331
am , orda 28

Ca ney W iln sBa e Boz n & Pu lam , PLLC
r
lim
t s ema
li
11 1 Ar de Dr ve Suie 200
31 ca
i , t
Lite Roc Ar ns s7221
tl
k, ka a
2
Zac r Pa ks
ha y r
Covi on & Buri LLP
ngt
lng
1 Penns va a A ve N W
201
yl ni
nue
W a hi on,DC 20004
s ngt

M a e E.W he l r
r t
ee