Kardonick v. JP Morgan Chase & Co. et al

Filing 470

ORDER granting 452 Motion to Strike ; denying 452 Motion to Dismiss. Signed by Senior Judge William M. Hoeveler on 12/3/2012. (ch1)

I

j
1

1
'

*
.

.A
.

UNI S
TED TATE DI CTCOURT
STRI
SOU TH ERN DI RI OF FLO RI
S
CT
DA

1

c s x 1n.za2 g-clv -H osvsLyiR
ws o
.

-

)

J
t
'
k

l

j

DAW D KARD ON ICK ,JOH N DAW D ,a d
M I AEL CLEM I S,i vi
CH
N ndi dualy and n
l
behal ofa1 ot
f
1 hers s m iar y s t ed a d
i l l i uat
t generalpublc,
he
i
Pl nt fs,
ai if

JP M O RGA N CH ASE & CO .and
CH ASE BAN K U SA ,N . ,
A.
Def
endant
s.
/

@

ORDER GRANTI M OTI TO STRI
NG
ON
KE

$
1
I

j

Thi caus i bef t Cour af er r ew oft fl . Acc ng t t docket
s
e s ore he
t t
evi
he ie
ordi o he
,

1

I

a flng s
ii ubm it by Tre Granton Ju1 20, 2012,hasbeen doc ed i t s c e as
t ed
vor
ket n hi as
a t oton f Sum m ar Judgm ent' The li appearst be an at em ptby G r t
s i or
M
y
.
'
lng
o
t
ant o

i ta ean a to ( s e s mar j me ast t c a m st r i ag ns JP
nii t
c in and e k um
y ud nt o he l i he e n) ai t
M or
gan Chas & Co. Chas Bank,and A eri Bankers Lie Ass ance Com pany
e
,
e
can
f
ur

p

j

q
'

l

i

.

o Fl rda.Appa e l Gr nts e t br gne (rpe ha r ne d)cai sag ns
f oi
r nty a e ks o i
w o r ps e we l m
ai t

(

:
(

s ve al e ii s afe ha ng b en uns c s ul i hi o j c i ns t t s Co ts
e r ntte t r vi e
es f n s b e to o hi ur '
appr
ovaloft set l entr hed by t par i i t s c .
he t em
eac
he
tes n hi ase

:

,

(
!
j

On Se t ber29,2011,Gr fl an o ec i and an appealoft sCour'
p em
ant ie
bj ton
hi
ts

l

Orderent ed Sept ber 16,2011.The C ur ofAppeal di m i sed Gr ' appealon
er
em
t
s s s
ants

(
:

Apr l24, 2012,f f l e t pr
i
or aiur o osec e,as rantnegl t t fl an appelants br ef
ut
ec ed o ie
l ' i

f
i

wi hi t t m ealot ed.As Def
t n he i
l t
endant c r ecty not al appeal w er di m i ed by
s r l
e, l
s
e s ss

:

(

.

j

(
.

:
'

t
.

@
!

(

l
1

j

1

tecutoApeli Ma 21,n tics inwcoe Grant' filng is an
h or f pasn y 02ad s aes o lsd
s i

l
j

i pr
m operat em ptt r
t
o eopen t scase.
hi

.
)

)
j

.

Bsdntebv, i
eo h aoeis
t

ORDERED AN D ADJLJ ED t t M oton t St i be GM N TED Doc
DG
hat he
i o r ke
ket
.

1

Enr Nu e 41i srce fo ti rcr as im properly filed in this case.
ty mbr 5 s tikn rm h eod

l
(

( t r i l , t t ext t Gr ' s bm i i i const
Ale natvey o he ent hat ants
ss on s
rued asarequestf r i
or elef

l

,

f
rom t s Cour as t t s c e,t reque ti D ENI
hi
t
o hi as he
s
ED

)y
#
DONEANDORDER i MimiFl da,t s g day of
ED n a ori hi
.

,

= - 2012.
er

1
I

o l
i
WI
LLI

M H OEVELER
.

S NO UNT DSA E DSRC J D E
E IR IE T T S IT IT U G
c est
opi o:

c
ouns ofr ord
el ec

Tr
evor Gr , P. Bo 23 , nr e, xas7703
ant O. x 7 Co o Te
5

1

!
j

j

1

.

l
I

1

ë
E

.

:
!

(

)

)
r

.

)

)

(
.
t

'

t
)

è

'
(
'
l

)
!
y
.

1
'
7
.
:
l

j
'