Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 180

MOTION to Appear Pro Hac Vice, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filing for Benoit Quarmby. Filing Fee $ 75.00. Receipt # 28423. (ksa)

'
L
' AI
$ D
P
1
.

F1œ I G FEE
lN
to- -.
.

*

.
.
- . - - - -

.

.

Pr hcc
O l
vl
ce
St - M .t i e,Cl k
even
armor er
*< e-- ' - K e R *A
'
z Q
m-

UN I
TED STA TES DISTRI COU RT
CT
SO UTHERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA

CA SE N O . 1 1 CV : : 0- 23580- U
U
M OTOR OLA M O BI TY,l C.
LI
N ,

Pl ntf /Count r a m D e e nt
ai if
e cl i
f nda ,

FI by
LED

D.
C.

N2V 12 201
1
APPLE,I C .
N ,
D ef
endant/Count ai Pl ntf .
ercl m ai if

STEVEN M L MORE
ARI
CL
ERK U. DI T.
S S GT.
s.D. FL - MI MI
of A
A

M O TIO N TO A PPEA R PR 0 H A C I F,
X

CONSENT TO DESI
GNATI AND REQUEST TO
ON,
ELE CTR O N I ALLY R ECEI E N O TI S O F ELEC TR O N I FI NG
C
V
CE
C LI

l a or nc wih Loca Ruls4( oft Spe a RulsGover ng t Admison a
n cc da e t
l e b) he cil e
ni he
si nd
Pr c i e of Ator ys oft Unie St t s D i t i tCour f t So he n D i ti t ofFl i t
a tc
t ne
he
t d a e sr c
t or he ut r s rc
orda, he

undesgnedrs cf l movesf t a si ohacvc ofBe tQuambyoft lw 51,of
ri
e pe tuly
or he dmisonrr
ie
noi r
he a 44
1
Qui Emanue Ur r & Suli n, ,51M a s Ave , dFl , w Yor , w Yok
nn
l quha t
lva LLP
dion nue 22n oorNe
k Ne r
1 0, lpho ( 2)8 7000,orpur e ofappe rnc a c c e o be lofM oool
001 Tee ne: 21 49f
pos s
aa e s o-ounsl n haf
tr a

Mobiiy,nc.ç ot ol')i t a
lt l (d or a' n he bove-t edca eonl andpurua t Rul 28 oft CM/
M
syl s y,
s nt o e
he ECF
Admi sr tvePr dur ,oper tBe tQua
nitai oce est mi noi nnby,or eveee toni flngsi t sc s , nd
t ec i lcr c ii n hi a e a
i suppor t eof s at asf l s:
n
t her
t es olow

Benoi Qua mbyi notad tedt prci i t Sout r DititofFlrdaand
t r
s
mit o a tce n he hen src
oi
i a m e be i good s a ng oft St t ba ofN ew Yor a t U nie St t s D it i tCour
s
m rn
t ndi
he a e r
k nd he t d a e s rc
t
f t Sout
or he
hern D i t i ofN ew Yor
s rct
k.

CA SE N O. 1: 0- : 1 CV 23580- U
U
M ova ,
nt Edw a d M . uli , quie, ft 1 w fln of s i r a D a sM uli &
r
M lns Es r o he a in A tga r ga vi
lns
Gr s a P. . i am e be i good s a ng oft Fl i Ba a t Unie S a esD it i tCo t
os m n, A , s
m rn
t ndi
he orda r nd he t d t t
s rc ur
f t Sout r D i ti tofFl r da, a nt i a of i e i t s St t f t pr c i ofl , nd i
or he
he n s r c
o i m i a ns n f c n hi a e or he a tce aw a s
a hor zed t fl t
ut i o ie hrough t Courtsel r ctlng s t .M ovantcons st bedes gnat as
he
' ectoni i i ys em
ent o
i ed

a m em be of t Ba o t s Cour w ih w hom t Co t a o
r
he r f hi
t t
he ur nd ppos ng co el m a r a l
i
uns
y e diy
c m uni a e r ga di t co
om
c t e r ng he nduc oft c e,upon w hom f lngs s l be s r d, ho s l be
t he as
ii
ha l e ve w
ha l
r quied t e ec r c l fl al doc e sa t ngst t a betl d el c r c ly, nd who s l
e r o l toni aly ie l um nt nd hi ha m y ie e toni a l a
ha l
ber pons bl f tlng doc l e si c m pla wih t CM /
es
i e or i i
tm nt n o i nce t he
ECF A dm i s r tve Pr ed es Se
nit a i oc ur . e
Se t on 28 oft CM /
ci
he
ECF A d i s r tve Pr e e .
m ni t a i
oc dur s

I ac or ncewiht l a r e ofhi Cour, noiQua
n c da
t he oc l uls t s
tBe t nnby, sma pa me of
ha de y nt

t sCour' $75. a sin fe.A c riiai i a c danc wihRul 4( i atc heeo.
hi
ts 00 dmiso e
e tfc ton n c or e t e b) s ta hed rt
Be tQuamby, b a tlo h de i td c uns la purua t Se ton 28
noi
r , y nd lr ug sgnae o e nd s nt o ci
CM /
ECF A dm i sr tve Pr dur s her by r
ni ta i
oce e , e eque t t Co tt pr vi N otc of El c r c
s s he ur o o de
ie
e toni

Fiig t Be i Qu r y a e i a r s b nq r y g ine n e .o
ln s o not a mb , t mal dd e s e uamb @ un ma u l m
c
W HEREFORE,
EdwadM . uli move t sCour t e e a Or f Be tQuamby
r M lns
s hi
to ntr n der or noi r
t a a bef r t sCour on be l ofM ot r a, ora l pos r l tng t t pr e ngsi t
o ppe r o e hi
t
ha f
o ol f l pur es e a i o he oc edi n he

a -t e matra die tngt Clr t pr denotc ofeldrni tlngst Be tQun mby.
bovesyld te nd rci he ek o ovi
ie e o c ii o noi r
D a ed: N o m be 1 2011
t
ve r 0,

Res tuly s m it d,
pe f l
te

Edwa dM . uli ( a. rNo.8 920)
r M lns F1 Ba
63
e lisla td v sc m
muln o si a i.o
Do ga J Gila o( a Ba No 1 2 2
u ls . u in F1. r . 5 8 )
d i ino a td vsc m
cul @ si a i.o
a

A STI RR AGA D AV I M U LLI S & G RO SSM AN ,P. .
GA
S
N
A
701 Br ckel Avenue,16t Fl
i l
h oor
M i i Fl i 33131
am , orda

Te1:305 37 8 2/Fax:( )37 8
.( ) 2-28
305 2- 202
2
M TI
GARRAGA DAVI M ULLNS& GROSS
S
I
MAN,P.
A.

AS GARRA DAvl M IL I & Gl s l,EA.
TI
GA
s J LNS
k MAq
os

CA SE N O . 1: CV : 10- 23580- U
U

Cha l s K . e hoe n*
re
V r ve

Ch re v r o v n g i e n l o
a ls eh e e @ uM ma ue. m
c
D avi A .Per s
d
l on*

d vip rs n g n e n e.o
a d elo @ uin ma u lc m
Ant
hony Pas or
t *

a t n p so @ u in ma ue.o
nho v a t r un e n l m
c
QUI EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,LLP
50 Ca ior a St e t 22nd Fl
lf ni r e ,
oor
San Franci co,Calf ni 94111
s
ior a

Te. ( 5 8 5 6 0 /Fa ( 5 8 5 6 0
l:41 ) 7 - 6 0 x: 41 ) 7 - 7 0
Edw a d J. e a o*
r D Fr nc

e d fa c @ q i n ma u l o
d er n o u n e n e. m
c
Ra ond N . i r
ym
N m od*

rv i o @ c in ma u l o
a nmr d l n e n e. m
u
c
QUI EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,
LLP
51 M adi on A venue,22nd Fl
s
oor
N ew Yor N ew Y or 10010
k,
k

Tel:[phone]/Fax:( 2)8 71
.( 2) 4921 49- 00
Davi A .N el on*
d
s

d v n lo @ u in ma ue.o
a e e s n un e n l m
c
QUI EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,
LLP
500 W es M adi on St e t Suie 2450
t
s
re, t
Chi ago,Ilnoi 60661
c
li s

Te.( 2)7057400/Fax:( 2)7057401
1:31
31
M dm it dpr hac vi e
te o
c

Co n ef rPli W co n e cai Dee d n M oo oa
u s lo ant u tr l m- f n a t tr l

Sol i s I .and M ot ol M obiiy I
uton , nc
or a
lt nc.

3
AS GARRAGA DAVI M UL NS& GROS
TI
S
LI
SMAN,P.
A.

AS GARRA D A sM IL I & G R s x,IA .
TI
GA vl J LNS
osuA t

UN I
TED STATES D I
STRI CO UR T
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FLOR I A
CT
D
CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 2358 UU
0-

M OTOROLA M OBI TY, C.
LI m ,
Pl ntf /Count r ai D e e nt
ai if
e cl m f nda ,

A PPLE,l C.
N ,

De e nt/Count r a m Pl n if
f nda
e cli aitf.

CERTI CATI OF BENOI QUARM BY
FI
ON
T

Be tQuar
noi
mby, s ntt Rul 4( oft Speca Rul Goveni t Admiso
purua o e b) he
il es
r ng he
sin
a Pr tc ofAtor , r by ce tfest t
nd aci e
t neys he e
rii ha :
1have s udi d t Loc lRul oft Unied St t D i ti tCo tf t Sout r
t e he
a
es he t
a es sr c ur or he
he n

DititofFl i a
src
orda; nd,

( Ia ame e i g o sa d n o t eS aeBa o Ne Yo k a dTh Un td
2)
m
mb r n o d tn i g f h tt r f w r n e ie
St t D i t i tCour f t Sout n D i t i tofN e Yor
a es sr c
t or he
her s rc
w
k.
RF

. . . .
.w

BENOI QUARM BY
T

.

x

CA SE N O . 1: CV : 10- 23580- U
U
CER TIFICA TE O F SERV IC E

IH EREBY CERTI t tonN ove be 1 2011 atue a c r tc oft a
FY ha
m r 0,
, r nd or ec opy he bove a
nd
f r goi wass r d vi r ul rU . M a la El toni M a lupo Chr sophe R .. ce Coun e
o e ng
e ve a eg a S. i nd ec r c i n i t r J Pa ,
sl

f rDee d n, elGos a & M a g s LLP,1 9 Brc el e ue S t 1 0 , imiFlrd
o f n a tW i, th l
n e,
3 5 ik lAv n , ui 2 0 M a , o ia
e
331 a vi El c r c M ai upo Co elf D e da
31 nd a e t oni
l n uns or f nt

t Ser c Li tbel .
he vi e s ow

Edwad . uli ( a Ba No.863920)
r M lns Fl. r

SE RV ICE L I
ST
M ot ol ..? / ,I .v.
or a #f :#/.p nc Appl ,I .
t
e nc
Case N o. 1: 23580- v- U
: 10Ci U
U nie St t s D it i tCour ,Sout r D it i tofFl i
t d a e s rc
t
he n s rc
or da

Chr s o rR ..Pa e
i t phe J c

Sam uelF.Er t
ns #

c rso h rp c @ wel o
h it p e .a e i. m
c

sr t c vc m
ens@ o .o

e wad.o o i.o
d r s t @wel m
c

c a k t@ c v.o
h s et o c m

Edwa d Sot
r
o

Cl s i Sa
ui tne unde s Has t*
r
ke t
Ro r D .Fr *
be t
am

W ei,Got hal& M angesLLP
l
s
1 Br c l A ve
395 i ke l nue,Suie 1
t 200
M i m i Fl i 331
a , or da
31

rr m@ c v.o
fa o c m

Chr s M ari a
i
tni k*

c riik c v.o
ma t a @ o c m
n

Telpho ( )577- 00
e ne: 305
31
Fa i l ( )37 71
csmie: 305 4- 59

W i lw B.
ns o
Taub*

wtu @ c v.o
ab o c m
N at A .Gr
han
eenbl t
at*

Covi on & Burlng LLP
ngt
i
One Fr St eet
ont r
San Fr nc s o, iom i 94111 5 6
a i c Calf a
- 35

n t a c e n at i.o
ah n.re blt@wel m
c
JilJ.H o*
l

il. .z i.om
ilhol welc

Tee
lphone:( 5)5916000
41
Fac i l ( 5)5916091
smie: 41
-

Jacquelne T.H ar ow *
i
l

ic i.alw@wel o
a k eh ro
i. m
c
A l e M .Cappela*
m
l

Robe tT.H a l m *
r
sa

a nec p la wel o
n .a pel@ i. m
c

r a lm@ c v.o
h sa o c m

Covi on & Buri LLP
ngt
lng
333 Tw i D ol n Dr ve,Suie 700
n
phi i
t
Re ood Sho e ,Ca ior a 94065
dw
r s lf ni

Bran C.Chang*
i

b inc a @wel o
ra .h ng i. m
c
W e l Got ha & M ange ,LLP
i, s l
s
201 Redwood Shor Pa kw a
es r y
Re ood Shor ,Ca i o ni 94065- 4
dw
es lf r a
113

Tee
lphone:( 632650) 4700
F c i l:( 5 )6 2 48 0
a smi 6 0 3 - 0
e

Telphone:( 802e
650) 3000
Fa i l ( 802- 00
csmie: 650) 31
4
AS GARRAGA DAVI M ULLNS& GROS
TI
S
I
SMAN,P.
A.

AS GARRA DA sM t
TI
GA vl muxs& GR s q,IA.
osMAl I

CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 23580- U
U

Jenny C.W u*

M athew D .Pow er
t
s*

J n ywu wel o
e n . @ i. m
c

mat e p wes tns c i lwg o p.on
th w.o r@ e e rt a r u c l
y

W e l Got hal& M a esLLP
i, s
ng
767 Fi h A venue
ft
N e Yor N e Y or 1 3
w
k, w
k 015

St ve S. r ns
e n Che e ky*

se e c rns y tns giva r u c m
tv n.hee k @ e e rt lwg o p.o

Telphone:( 2)31 8000
e
21 0Fa smie:( 2)31 8007
c i l 21 0-

Te e iy La Gr LLP
ns grt w oup
201 Re ood Shor s Pa kwa Suie 401
dw
e r y, t
Re ood Shor s Ca i or a
dw
e , lf ni

M ar G .D avi
k
s*

Tee h n :( 5 )8 2 6 0
lp o e 6 0 0 - 0 0
Fac i l ( 802smie: 650) 6001

M akd vi@ welc m
r .a s i.o

W ei,Got hal& M a esLLP
l
s
ng
1300 Eye St ,N W ,Suie 900
reet
t
W as ngt D C 20005
hi on,

Telphone:( 68 7000
e
202) 2Fa i l ( 857- 40
csmie: 202) 09

M dm it dpr hac v c
te o
ie

5
AS GARRAGA DAVI M ULLI & GROSS
TI
S
NS
MAN,P.
A.

AS GARRA DA sM IL I & GR s x,lA.
TI
GA vl J LNS
osMA ?

UNI
TED STATES DI UCT COURT
STI
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
M OTOROLA M OBI TY , C.
LI m ,
Pl ntf /Count r a m D e e nt
ai if
e cl i
f nda ,
CA SE N O . 1 1 CV : : 0- 23580UU
A PPLE,I C .
N ,

De e nt1Count r l i Pl i if
f nda
e c am antf.

O R DER G M N TIN G M O TIO N TO A PPEA R

PRO HAC FTC' ,CONSENT TO DESI
F
GNATI AND REQUEST TO
ON
E LE CTR O N I AL LY R EC EI E N O TI ES O F ELE CTR O N I FI N G
C
V
C
C LI

THI CAUSE ha ng come be o e t Cour on t M oton t Appe rPr Hac Vi f
S
vi
f r he
t he
i o
a o
ce or

Be t Quamby,Cons ntt De i ton,a Re tt Elcr cal Re i Notc s of
noi
r
e o sgnai nd ques o e toni ly ceve ie
Elcr c Fii (he t oton' ,purua t t Spe ilRul Goveni t Admiso a
e toni lng t d i ' s nt o he ca es
M
)
r ng he
sin nd
Pr c ie ofAtor ysi t Unie St t sDititCour f t Sout n DititofFl i a
a tc
t ne n he t d a e src
t or he
her src
orda nd
Sec i 28 oft CM /
ton
he
ECF Admi sr tvePr ed e . Thi Cour ha ng consde edt m o i
nitai
oc ur s
s
t vi
i r he ton
a a 1ot rr l va f dor ,i i he e
nd l he e e nt a s t s r by:
O RD ERED AN D A D J D G ED t t
U
ha :

TheM otoni GRANTED.Benoi Quar ma a ra patcpaei t sa tonon
i s
t mby y ppea nd rii t n hi ci
be l ofM ot ol M obiiy, nc. nd M ot ol , nc.The Cl r s l pr deel c r c nottc ton
ha f
or a
lt I a
or a I
e k ha l ovi e t oni ii a i

o a1 lcr ni fl st Be otQu r y vae ia d e sbe g amby in ma u lc m.
f 1 ee to c ii o n i a mb , i mal d rs n u r @gun e n e.o
ng
D ON E AN D ORD ERED i Cha be s i M i m i Fl i , t s
n
m r , n a , or da on hi

da ofN ove be ,
y
m r

2011
.
H onor bl U r ul M .Ung o
a e s a
ar
Unie St t sDititJ
t d a e src udge

Co esf nihedt Al Couns ofRe or
pi ur s
o: l
el
c d