Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 189

MOTION to Appear Pro Hac Vice, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filing for Cathleen G. Garrigan. Filing Fee $ 75.00. Receipt # 29144. (ksa)

FLNG Jt
Il
t

PAI
D

X >i 9
vS

V a
Pohc
l
r
ce

'
N

l
z

St
even M,L i e, er
armor
k

U TDSA E DSRC C U T
NIE T TS IT IT O R

S UT R DIT ITO F ORD
O HE N S RC F L IA
CA SE N O . 1: CV: 10- 23580- U
U

M OTO ROLA M OBI TY ,l C.
LI
N ,
Pl i if/Count c ai D ef nt
a ntf
er l m
enda ,

FI by
LED

Q' l Q.
'
.
.

N2k 2! 2 1
91
s-EvuN v tAqI I
r
' MIM:

C E Kti I4 ,',
s R ? ) -(
L
lf )
T
r o ih = (
. fk.
) '
,
.

APPLE,l C.
N ,
Def ndan /Co e cl m Pl ntf .
e
t
unt r ai ai if

M O TI TO APPEAR #AO D C VICE
ON

CONS TO DESGNATI N? REQUV TTO
ENT
I
O AND
ELE CTR O N I LLY R ECE I E N O TI ES O F ELEC TR O N I FI N G
CA
V
C
C LI

l a cor ncewih Loc Rul 4( oft SpecalRul Goveni t Admison a
n c da
t
al es b) he
i
es
r ng he
si nd
Pr ctc ofAtor ysoft Unied Stt sDititCour f t Sout n Diti tofFl rda,t
a ie
t ne
he t
a e src
t or he
her src
o i he
unde s gne r pec f l m oves f t a i s on pr hac v ce of CA TH LEEN G .
r i d es tuly
or he dm s i
o
i

GARRI
GAN oft lw fr ofQui Ema lUr r & Suli n,LLP,50Caior aSte t
he a im
nn
nue quha t
lva
lf ni re,

22nd Fl , Sa Frncic Calf ni 94111 Telphone:( 5) 875oor n a s o, ior a
, e
41
6600,f pur e of
or poss
a rnce a c co elon be l ofMot ol M o lt l a M ot ol l (ole tvel
ppeaa
s o- uns
haf
or a biiy, nc. nd or a, nc. c lci y
i ot ol') i t above-t e ca e onl a puruan t Rul 28 of t CM/
i or a' n he
M
syld s
y, nd s t o e
he
ECF
A dm i s r tve Pr dur ,t pe m i Cat ee G .G ar i t r e ve e e t oni f lngs i t s
ni ta i
oce es o r t hl n
r gan o ec i l c r c ii
n hi

c e,a i s
as nd n uppor t e sat asf l :
t her of t es olows
1.

Ca hl e G.G ar i
t en
r gan,Es ,i nota it d t pr c i i t Sout r Diti
q- s
dm te o a tce n he
he n srct

ofFl i a i a m e be i g
orda nd s
m r n ood s a ng oft St t Barof Ca ior a a t U nie St t
t ndi
he a e
lf ni nd he
t d a es

Diti tCour f t Norher DititofCa ior a.
src
t or he t n src
lf ni

ASTI
GARRAGADAVI M UL NS& GROS
S
LI
SMAN,P.
A.

M o nt Edwa d M .M uli ,Es r of t l w fr of Asi r a M uli
va ,
r
lns quie, he a im
tga r ga
lns
D a i & Gr s an,P. . 701 Br c l A ve , 1 t Fl , M i m i Fl i 331 , Tel phone:
vs
os m
A,
i ke l
nue 6 h oor a , orda
31
e

( )372305
8282,i ame ri goodsa ng ofTheFlrdaBa a t Unie Stt Ditit
s
mbe n
tndi
o i r nd he td aes src
Cour f t So he n Di t i tofFl i m ai ai a of i e i t s St t f t pr c i e ofl w ,
t or he ut r s rc
orda, nt ns n f c n hi a e or he a tc
a

a i a horze t fl t ough t Cour ' elc r c flng s tm . M ova c e st be
nd s ut i d o ie hr
he
ts e toni ii yse
nt ons nt o
desg t d asa me be oft Ba oft sCour wih who t Cour a opposng c
i na e
m r he r hi
t t
m he
t nd
i ouns lm a
e y
r diy com m uni t r r ng t c
ea l
ca e ega di he onduc oft c e upo w hom flngs s lbe s r d,who
t he as , n
ii
hal
e ve
s l be r quie t el t o c l fl a 1doc e s a t ngs t tm a be t e e e t o ca l
ha l e r d o ec r ni aly ie l
um nt nd hi
ha
y
sl d l c r ni ly,

a who s l be r ponsbl f flng doc e s i c pla e wih t CM /
nd
hal
es i e or ii
um nt n om i nc
t he
ECF
A dm i sr tve Pr ed e . See Sec i 28 oft CM /
ni t a i
oc ur s
ton
he
ECF A dm i sr tve Pr dur .
ni ta i
oce es
l a cor nce w ih t l a r e oft s Cour ,C at e G .G arr gan hasm a
n c da
t he oc l ul s hi
t
hl en
i
de

pa ntoft sCour' $75. admison f A c rii to i a c da e wih Rul 4( i
yme
hi
ts 00
si ee. e tfcain n c or nc t e b) s
a t c he e o.
ta hed r t
Cat ee G . Gar i n, b a t oug desgna ed c
hl n
rga y nd hr h
i t ouns and pur ua t
el
s nt o
Sec i 28 CM /
ton
ECF Adm i s r tve Pr ce es he e r ques s t Cour t pr de N o i e of
ni t a i
o dur , r by e
t he
t o ovi
tc
El c r c
e t oni

Fii
lngs

Cahlen
t e

G.

Ga gan
ni

a
t

e al
m i

a es '
ddr s
.

c t le a aia q n e n e .o .
ahe n a c n@ uin ma u l m
c
W HEREFO RE,Edw a d M .M uli ,m ovest s Coul t e e a O r r f C at e G .
r
lns
hi
' o nt r n de or hl en
t
G arr gan,t a ar be or t s Cour on be f of M ot ol f al pur e r l tng t t
i
o ppe
f e hi
t
hal
or a, or l pos s e a i o he
pr ee ngs i t a
oc di
n he bove- t ed m a t r a diec i t Cl r t pr de notc ofel c r c
s yl
te nd r tng he e k o ovi
ie
e t oni

2
AS GAR A DAVI M ULLNS& GROSS
TI RAG
S
I
MAN, A.
P.

flngst C at ee G .G a i n.
ii o
hl n
rr ga

Da e N ove r29, 1
t d:
mbe
201

Re pe tply s . it d,
s c f .l m te

2

r
'

.
.

EdwadM . uli ( a.
r M lns F1 B o.863920)
e l @ atd vi.o
mulns sia sc m
i
DouglsJ Gi ino( a.BarNo.1
a . ula F1
5282)

d ila o@a td vi.o
gu in sia sc m

A STI RM GA D A VIS M U LLI S & G RO SSM AN ,P. .
GA
N
A
701 Brc l Avenue,16 h Fl
i ke l
t oor
M i m i Fl i 331
a , orda
31

Te.( )372- /Fa ( 3721:305
8282 x: 305) 8202
Char es K .V er
l
hoeven*

Ch reveh e n g ine n e.o
als r o ve @ un ma u l m
c
Da d A.Pe lon*
vi
rs

d v d elo @ q i n ma u lc m
a i p rs n u n e n e.o
D a d Ei e a
vi s m n*

d v d ie n u M e n e.o
a i esma @q i ma u l m
c
QUI EM ANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,LLP
50 Calf ni St e t 22nd Fl
ior a r e ,
oor
Sa Fr nci c Calf i 94111
n a s o, iom a

Te1:( 5 875- /Fa ( 5 875. 41 ) 6600 x: 4l ) 6700
Edw ar J.D eFr
d
anco*

e d fa c q in ma e.o
d e rn o@ un e nu l m
c
Ra ond N . i r
ym
N m od*

rv mr d@q n e An e .o
a ni o uin n a u l m
c
Be tQuamby*
noi r

b n u nn v q n e n e.o
e q a b @ uin ma u l m
c
QUI EM ANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,LLP

51 M a s A ve ,22nd Fl
di on
nue
oor
N e Y o k, ew Yor 1001
w r N
k
0

Tel:( 2)849- /Fa ( 2)8 71
. 21
7000 x: 21 49- 00
D a d A . e s n*
vi
N lo

d v n lo u n e n e .o
a e es n@q i n ma u l m
c
QUI EM ANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,LLP
500 W e tM a s Ste t Suie2450
s dion r e , t
Chi a llnoi 60661
c go, li s

Te.( 2)705l: 31
7400/Fa ( 2)705 7
x: 31
- 401
M dmit dpr hacvie
te o
c

Cou s l o Pl it co ne ca m- f n a t t r l
n e f r an W u tr li Dee d n Mo o oa
Sol i s I andM ot ol M obii I
uton nc.
or a
lt nc.
y
3
ASTI
GARRAGA DAVI M ULLI & GROSSMAN,P.
S
NS
A.

UNI
TED STA TES DI
STR I COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLOR I A
CT
D
CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 2358 U U
0M OTO ROLA M O BI TY ,l C .
LI
N ,
Pl ntf /Count r a m D e e
ai if
e cl i
f ndan ,
t

A PPLE,l C.
N ,

De enda /Count r l i Pli if
f nt
e c am antf .
C ER TI CA TI N O F CA TH LEEN G .GA R R I AN
FI
O
G

Cat ee G.Garrgan, s ntt Rul 4( oft Spe i RulsGoveni t
hl n
i purua o e b) he cal e
r ng he
Adm i s on a Pr c i e ofAtor
s i nd a tc
t neys he e ce tfe t t
, r by ri i s ha :

( ) lha sudi t Loc Rul oft Unie SttsDititCour f t So hen
1
ve t ed he al es he td ae src
t or he ut r
Di t i tofFl i ,
s rc
or da'
and,

(
2) Ia amemberi goodsa ngoft Stt Ba ofCalf ni a TheUnied
m
n
tndi
he ae r
ior a nd
t
St t D i t i tCour f rt N orher D it i ofCa ior a
a es s rc
t o he
t n s rct
lf ni .

CA TH LEEN

. A

CER TI CA TE O F SERV I
FI
CE
l HEREB Y CERTI t on N ovem ber 29,2011,a t ue and cor
FY hat
r
rect copy oft above
he

a f e ng wa s l d vi r a U. M ala El c r ni M ai upon Chrsophe R..Pa e,
nd or goi
s ewe a egulr S. i nd e to c
l
it r J c

Co n e f r Dee d n ,W el Gos a & M a g s LLP,1 9 Brc elAv n e S ie 1 0 ,
u s l o f n a t i, th l
n e,
3 5 ik l e u , ut 2 0
M i m i Fl i 331 and vi El c r c M a lupon Couns lf D e e nton t Se vi e Li t
a , orda
31
a e t oni
i
e or f nda
he r c s
be ow .
l

EdwadM .Muli ( a.Ba No.
r
lns F1 r 863920)
SER V I E LIST
C
M ot ol M obii I .v Appl ,I .
or a
lt nc .
y
e nc
Ca e N o. 1 1 2358 Ci UU
s
: : 00- vU nie St esD i ti tCour ,Sout r Di t i tofFl i
t d at
sr c
t
he n s rc
orda

Chr s o rR . Pa e
i t phe J. c

Sa ue F. ns *
m l Er t

c rso h rp c @wel o
h it p e .a e i. m
c

s r s@ c v.o
en t o c m

e wad.o o welc m
d r s t @ ivo

c a ket c v.o
h s t@ o c m

Edw a d Sot
r
o

Chr s i Sa
i tne under Has t
s ket*

W ei,Got hal& M a s LLP
l
s
nge
1 Brcke lA ve
395 i l
nue,Suie 1
t 200
M i m i Fl i 331
a , or da
31

Robe tD .Fr *
r
am

rrm@ c v.o
fa o c m

Chr sM a tni k*
i
ri a

Te . ( )577- 00/Fax: ( )37 71
1: 305
31
305 4- 59

c riik c v.o
ma t a @ o c m
n

N at A .Greenbl t
han
at*

wtu c v.o
a b@ o c m

W i ow B.Taub*
nsl

Covi on & Burlng LLP
ngt
i
O ne Fr Stee
ont r t
Sa Fr ncic Calf ni 9 11 5356
n a s o, ior a 41 -

n t n.r e b at welc m
aha ce n lt@ i.o
J l J Ho*
il .

il. @ welc m
il
ho i.o

J c i T. row*
a quelne Ha l

Te . ( 5 5 - 0 0/ x:( 5 5 - 0
1: 41 ) 916 0 Fa 41 ) 916 91

ic i.alw@wel o
a keh ro
i. m
c
Anne M .Ca la*
ppe l

Robe tT. asam ?
r H l

a n .a p la wel o
n ec p el@ i. m
c

r a lm@ c v.o
h sa o c m

b in.h nq welc m
ra c a @ i.o
Aru M e r
j n ha
ain. h a wel o
ru me r @ i. m
c

Te.( 6321: 650) 4700/Fax:( 0)63265
4800

Bran C.Chang*
i

Covi on & Burlng LLP
ngt
i
333 Twi D ol n D rve,Suie 700
n
phi i
t
Red
wood Shor ,Calf r a 94065
es io ni

W e l Got ha & M ange ,LLP
i, s l
s
201 Redwood Shor Par a
es kw y
Re ood Shor ,Calf ni 94065- 1
dw
es
i or a
1 34

Te1:( 802- /Fax: ( )80 31
. 650) 3000
650 2- 00

4
AS GARRAGADAVI M ULLI & GROSS
TI
S
NS
MAN, A.
P.

J nny C.W u*
e

M athew D .Pow er
t
s*

J n . @welc m
e nvwu i.o

mate po r@ tn e rt lwc o .o
th w. we s e s g iva r upc m

W e l G o s l& M a
i, t ha
nges LLP
767 Fi t A ve
fh
nue
Ne Yor Ne Yor 1
w
k, w
k 0153

St ven S.Che e ky*
e
r ns

se e c ee k e e rtlwg o pc m
tv n.h rns y@tns c i a r u .o
y
Azr H a m ehm edo c
a dzi
vi

Tee
lphone:( 2)31 8000
21 0Fa smie ( 2 31 - 0
c i l: 21 ) 0 8 07

a r @tns giy a r u .o
za e e rtlwg o pc m

Te e iy Law Gr LLP
ns grt
oup
201Re
dwood Sho e Par y,Suie401
r s kwa
t
R e ood Sho es Ca ior a
dw
r , lf ni

M ak G. a s
r
D vi *

M ak.a i@ wel o
r d v s i. m
c

Tee
lphone:( 802650) 6000
Fac i l ( 802smie: 650) 6001

W e l G ot hal& M a es LLP
i, s
ng
1 Eye Ste t NW ,Suie 900
300
r e,
t
W a hi on,D C 20005
s ngt

Telphone:( 682e
202) 7000
Fa i l ( 85 0940
csmie: 202) 7-

M dm it dpr hac v ce
te o
i

5
AS GARRAGADAVI M ULLI & GROS
TI
S
NS
SMAN,P,
A.

UNI
TED STA TES D I
STRI CO U RT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA

M OTOROLA M OBI TY,I ,
LI
NC.
Pl ntf /Count r a m D e e n ,
ai i f
ed i
f nda t
CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 2358 U U
0A PPLE,l C.
N ,
D e enda /Count r l i Pl i i f
f
nt
e c a m a ntf .

O R DER G R AN TI G M O TIO N TO A PPEA R
N

##O HAC FTCFICONSENT TO DESI
GNATI AND REQUEST TO
ON
E LECT R O N I A LLY R EC EI E N O TI ES O F EL ECTR O N IC FILI G
C
V
C
N

TH I CA U SE ha ng c e be or t C o to t M o i t Appe r Pr H ac Vi e f
S
vi om
f e he ur n he ton o
a o
c or
Ca hl en G .Ga r ga Cons ntt Des gna i and Reque tt El t oni a l Rec i N otc of
t e
r i n,
e o
i ton,
s o ec r c ly
e ve
i es

Elcr c Fii (he SM oi ),purua t t Spe ilRul Goveni t Admison a
e toni lng t t ton'
s nt o he ca es
r ng he
s i nd
Pr c i ofAtor ys i t Unied St t DititCo tf rt Sout r DititofFl i and
a tce
t ne n he t
aes src ur o he
he n src
orda
Se ton 28 oft CM /
ci
he
ECF A d i s r tve Pr edur s Thi C o ' ha ng c i r d t m oton
m ni t a i
oc
e . s ul vi ons de e he
t
i
a a1 o he r e ntf c or ,i i her by:
nd 1 t r el va a t s t s e
O RD ERED A N D AD J D GED t t
U
ha :
The M oton i G RAN TED . Ca hl en G . Gar i n m a a a a pa tci t i t s
i s
t e
rga
y ppe r nd r i pa e n hi
a ton on be f of M ot ol M obiiy, I . and M ot r a, l
ci
hal
or a
lt nc
o ol nc. The Cl r s l pr de
e k ha l ovi

e e toni notfca i of a1 elc r c flngs t Cahle G. Gari n, vi e l a es
lcr c
ii ton
l e toni ii
o t en
rga
a mai ddr s

c t le a g @ q i e n e .o
ah e ng air uM ma u l m.
c
DONE AND ORDERED i Chambe s i M im i Fl i o t s
n
r , n a , orda, n hi
52011.

Hono abl U r ul M .Ungar
r e s a
o
U nied St t D i t i tJ e
t
a es sr c udg
Copi s f ni he t
e ur s d o:
A l C o elofRec d
1 uns
or

da of
y