Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 239

ORDER Granting 232 Motion to File Under Seal Exhibits to Its Declarations In Support of Its Oppositions to Apple's Motion to Compel (DE 224 and 225) by Motorola Mobility, Inc.. Signed by Magistrate Judge Ted E. Bandstra on 2/14/2012. (See Order for full details) (nc)

#

UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI COU RT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA

Ca eNo.1 1 c 23580- S/
s
: 0- vRN TEB
M OTOROLA M OBI TY,I ,
LI
NC.
Pl i if
antf,

A PPLE I C .
N ,
Def nda .
e nt
APPLE I C .
N ,
Count r l m - a ntf ,
e c ai pl i if
V.

M OTOROLA,I C.
N and
M OTORO LA M OB I TY ,I C.
LI
N ,
Count c am - e nt .
er l i Def nda s

O R DE R G M N TI M O T O R O LA ' M O TI N T O FI U N D ER SEA L
NG
S
O
LE
EXHI TS TO I DECLARATI
BI
TS
ONS I SUPPORT OF 1
N
TS

OPPO SI ONS TO APPLE' M O TI
TI
S
ONS TO COM PEL ( 224 AND 225)
DE
THI CAUSE havi come b or t Cour on M ot ol Sol i ,I a M ot ol
S
ng
ef e he
t
or a utons nc. nd
or a

M o lt I ' (ole tvey d oor a' Moton t FieUnde Sea Exhi t t isDe aai
biiy, nc.s c lci l s t ol'
M
) i o l
r l bis o t clrtons

i S p o to isOp osto st Ap esMo inst Co e ( 2 4 a d 2 5 ,a te Co r
n u p r f t p iin o pl' to o mp l DE 2 n 2 ) nd h u t
ha ng c i r t a i a i a ot r i e bei dul a s d he ei i i ORD ERED
vi ons de ed he pplc ton, nd he w s
ng y dvi e
r n, t s
AN D A DJU D GED :

1
.

The M oto t Se li G RAN TED .
in o a s

Cas No.1 1 c 23580e
: 0- vRNS/
TEB
2.

Exhi tA at che t t De l a i ofDavi M .Elhu i Suppor ofM ot ol s
bi ta d o he car ton
d
i n
t
or a'

Opposton t Appl sM oto t Com pe Re pons st l eroga oresN os 7 a 1 Re r ng
ii o
e'
in o
l s
e o nt r t i
. nd 2 ga di

Pr t Em bodyi M o or a' As e td Paent;a Exhi t 1 4,6,a 7 at c d t t
oduc s
ng t ol s s re t s nd
bis ,
nd ta he o he
De l ai of Da d M .Elhu i Suppor of M ot ol s Opposto t Appl s M oton t
car ton
vi
i n
t
or a'
ii n o
e'
i o

CompelRes est l erogaore Reg r ng Se-f pBoxPae s( .1 22) s l befld
pons o nt r t is a di t-'
o
tnt Nos 9- , hal ie
un rs al
de e .
The Cl r s l m a nt i t a or e i d ex bis unde s alt ough t fnal
e k ha l i a n he f em ntone hi t
r e hr
he i

r s uton oft above c ptone a ton,i udi durng a pe i of a alt ken by any
e ol i
he
a i d c i ncl ng i ny rods
ppe a
pa t t t sca e,e eptasot r s or r d by t sCour orr quie by l
ry o hi s xc
he wie de e
hi
t e rd
aw.
The Cl k s l de toy t a or m e i d e bis upon fnalr ol i oft
er hal sr he f e ntone xhi t
i es uton he

a vec ptoned a ton,ncudi a1a
bo a i
c i i l ng 1 ppeas
l.

DONEAND ORDERED i Cha r i MimiFlrda o ti tv a o Fe ur
n mbes n a , oi , n hs h y f bray,
2012.

*

k
D. pm - - -

HON ORABLE TED E.BANDSTM
U nie St esM ag s r t J
t d at
i t a e udge

Copi t
es o:
A1 Couns lofRec d
1
e
or