Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 246

ORDER granting 225 Motion to Compel. Signed by Magistrate Judge Ted E. Bandstra on 2/24/2012. (yha)

UNI
TED STATES DI
STRI CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CASE NO .1123580- VCI SCOLA/
BANDSTRA
MOTO RO LA M OBI TY,I ,
LI NC.
Pl ntf,
ai if
V.

APPLE I ,
NC.
Def
endant
.
/

APPLE I ,
NC.
Count cl m Pl ntf,
er ai ai i
f
V.

MoTo Ro LA,I ,and
Nc.
MoTo Ro tA M OBI TY,I ,
LI
Nc.

Count cl m Def
er ai
endant
s.
/

O RDER
THI CAUSE cam ebef et
S
or hecoudon Def
endantand Count cl m Pl ntf Appl
er ai ai if
e
l ' M oton t Com pelResponsest l erogat i Nos.7 and 12 Regar ng Pr
nc.
s
i o
o nt r ores
di
oduct
s

Embod ngMot r a' As ededPa en s( E. fl onJan y31, 2. onr iw
yi
o ol s s
t t D. 225)i
ed
uar 201 Up eve
oft s m oton, he r
hi
i t esponse and r yt et t cour fl and appl e f ,ii her
epl her o, he
ti
e
i
cabl aw ts eby
O RDERED A ND ADJUDG ED t
hat Def
endantand Count cl m Pl ntf Appl
er ai ai if
e
I ' Moton t Com pelResponses t I erogat i Nos.7 and 12 i G RANTED,t
nc.
s
i o
o nt r ores
s
he

Cour ov r ig Mo or a' obec i s t er t Specfc l t Cour fnd t att
t erul
n
t ol s j ton h e o.
i al he
i y,
t i s h he
r
eques ed i or aton i l erogat y No.12 i r evantand/ I y t t I t t
t nf m i n nt r or
s el
or i
kel o he ead o he

g.
ogi nc.
nc.
di
scover ofadm i bl evi
y
ssi e dence. See e. ,LeaderTechnol es I v.Facebook l ,

20 W L 30211 ( De12009 (equin t dico e ofaIpr c sors vc s t a
09
58 D. .
) r r g he s lsur
i
l odu t
erie h t
em body any oft assered cl m s oft pat i sui and i ii i ofwhi cl m s
he
t
ai
he ent n t
dentfcaton
ch ai

t epr duc pr tc )Lie s t eCou ti st tn or tons
h o t acie. k wie,h
rfnd ha if ma i ough i It r t yNo.
tn n erogaor
7 i r evantand notovery br
s el
l oad. Accor ngl M ot ol shalsuppl entis answer t
di y, or a
l
em
t
so

t eit r ga or b pr vi n aln p ii ed if ma i wi i t ( 0 da so t e
hes nero t i y o dig l on- r l
es
v eg nor t
on t n en 1 ) y f h
h
dat oft s O r .
e hi der

DONE AND ORDERED i Chamber a Mi ,Fl iat szhV a o Febrar
n
s, t ami ord hi
y f u y,
2012.

-

e W X--- -

- -

Ted E.Bands r
ta
Unied St es M agitat Judge
t
at
sr e
Copi f ni
es ur shed t
o:
Honor e Robed N.Scol
abl
a
Counselofr d
ecor