Motorola Mobility, Inc. v. Apple, Inc.

Filing 250

MOTION to Appear Pro Hac Vice, Consent to Designation, and Request to Electronically Receive Notices of Electronic Filing for Graham Pechenik. Filing Fee $ 75.00. Receipt # 34916. (ksa)

l

.
' '.
. ' ...
..

FI I G FE
tk
A

pIAD

N

m -

FI by
LED

Po
r

v hc en MqLorjte cl k S UIEERNAE Dslc cu '
aev' ?// er TDS DISTRIl OF ' oD A
T mor
Tlr r
TH T TS CT t FLORIR
St

.
C.

le
c

.

l

CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 23580- S
RN

MA2 2 ? 2 1
92
STEVEN M . ARI
L MORE
CLERK t s Dl r cT.
)
s'

s. o / /. MI
o.f L - XMI

M OTOROLA M OBI TY,I ,
LI
NC.
Pl i i f/Count r l i Def nda ,
a ntf
e c am
e nt

A PPLE,l C.
N ,
Def
endant/Count cl m Pl nt f
er ai ai if.

M O TI N TO A PPEA R PR0 H A C FT
O
CF

CONS TTOD NAT ON, REQU TTO
EN
EW
I AND
V
EL ECTR O NI ALLY R EC G V E N O TI ES O F ELE CTR O N I FI N G
C
C
C LI

l ac or ewih Loc Rul 4( oft Speca RulsGoveni t Admison a
n c danc t
al es b) he
il e
r ng he
si nd
Pr tc ofAtor ysoft Unie St t sDititCour f t So he n DititofFl i t
aci e
t ne
he t d a e src
t or he ut r src
orda, he
unde sgne r pe tuly movesf t a iso o hacvi ofGRAHAM PECHENI oft
r i d es c f l
or he dm s i npr
ce
K
he

lw 514 of Qui Ema lUr r & Suli LLP,50 Caior a Stee,22dFl ,Sa
a 71
nn
nue quhat
lvan,
lf ni r t n oor n
Frncic Caior a 94111 Teephone:( 5)875a s o, lf ni
, l
41
6600,orpur e ofa rncea c c e
f
pos s ppeaa s o-ounsl
on be l ofM ot ol M obiiy,l (k ot ol' i t a
haf
or a
lt nc. t or a' n he bove-t edca eonl a purua t
M
)
syl s y, nd s nt o
Rul 28 of t CM /
e
he
ECF Adm i s r tve Pr dur , t pe m i G r ha Pe ni t r c ve
ni t a i
oce es o r t a m
che k, o e ei

e e toni flngsi t sca e a i s ppo tt e sa e a f l
l cr c ii n hi s , nd n u r her of tt s s olows:
Gr ha Pe heni i nota te t pr tc i t Sout r Diti tofFl i a a
a m c k s
dmit d o aci e n he
he n src
ord nd
i a m e be i good s a ng oft N e Y or Cour ofA ppe s
s
m rn
t ndi
he w
k
t
al .
M ova ,
nt Edw a d M . uli , quie, t 1 w fr of s i r a D a sM uli &
r
M lns Es r of he a im A tga r ga vi
lns

Gr s n, A.i amembe i good sa ng oft Fl i Ba a t UniedSt tsDiti t
os ma P. , s
rn
t ndi
he orda r nd he t ae src Cour
t

AS I
TGARRAGA DAVI M UL NS& GROSS
S
LI
MAN,P. .
A

CA SE N O . 1: 0- : l CV 23580-k S
1N

f rt Sout r Diti to Fl rda mai ai a ofi ei t sStt f t pr ctceofl a i
o he
he n src f o i , nt ns n fc n hi a e or he a i
aw, nd s
a hor z t f l t ough t Co tse ec r c flng s t m .M ova cons n st bedes gna ed a
ut i ed o ie hr
he ur ' l toni ii ys e
nt
et o
i t s
a m e be of t Ba of t s Cour w ih whom t Cour a oppos ng c
m r
he r
hi
t t
he
t nd
i ouns l m a r adiy
e
y e l
c m uni t r ar ng t c
om
ca e eg di he onduc oft ca e upon who flngs s lbe s r
t he s ,
m ii
hal
e ved,who s l be
ha l

r quie t e e toni lyfl a 1
e r d o l c r cal ie l docu e sa t ngst tma befldeecr c ly, d whos l
m nt nd hi ha y ie l tonia l an
hal
ber s
e ponsbl f flngdocume si c
i e or ii
nt n ompla ewiht CM J Ad i sr tv Pr e e .Se
inc t he
ECF m nitai e oc dur s e
Se ton 28 oft CM /
ci
he
ECF Adm i sr tvePr e es
nitai
oc dur .
l a cor nc w ih t l al ul soft sCour , a m Pe he k, m a pa e t
n c da e t he oc r e
hi
t Gr ha
c ni has de ym n

oft sCour' $75. ad si f A c rii to i a c danc wihRul 4( i atac dheeo.
hi
ts 00 mison ee. e tfcain n c or e t e b) s t he rt
4.

Gr ha Pe ni ,by a t ough de i t d c
a m che k,
nd hr
sgna e ouns la pur ua t Seci n 2B
e nd s nt o to

CM /
ECF Admi sr i Pr dur s he e r ue t t Cou tt pr de No i ofEl cr ni
nitatve oce e , r by eq ss he
r o ovi
tce
e to c

Fiig t Grha Pe he i a e i a d e s g a a e he i q ine u lc m
l s o a m c nk, t mal d r s rh mp c nk@ u n mr e.o
n
W H EREFORE, w a d M . uli m ovest sCour t e e a Or rf G r ha Pe he k
Ed r
M lns
hi
t o nt r n de or a m c ni
t a a be or t sCour on be fofM ot ol ,f al pur esr l tngt t pr e ngsi t
o ppe r f e hi
t
hal
or a or l pos e a i o he oc edi n he

above-t l d m at r a die tng t Cl k t pr de notc of elc r c flngs t Gr ham
sy e
te nd r c i he er o ovi
ie
e toni ii
o a
Pec ni
he k.
D a ed: M a c 7,201
t
rh
2

Res
pec

l
y

m it
te

Ed r M . i ( a a No 8 3 2 )
wad
ns Fl. r . 6 9 0
e li @ a td v sc m
mu l
ns sia i.o
DouglsJ Gi ino( a Ba No.15 2)
a . ula F1. r
28
d ila o@ atd vi.o
gu in sia sc m

ASTI
GARM GA DAVI M ULLI & GROSSM AN , A.
S
NS
P.
701 Brckel Avenue,16t Fl
i l
h oor
M i m i Fl i 331
a , orda
31

Te.( 0 )3 2 8 8 / x:( 0 )3 2 8 0
l: 3 5 7 - 2 2 Fa 3 5 7 - 2 2

2
M TG
IARRAGADAVI MULLmS& GROS MAN, A.
S
S
P.

CA SE N O . 1: CV : 10- 23580- S
RN

CharesK . e hoe n*
l
V r ve

Ch re v r e e @ q i e u lc m
a ls eho v n unn mr e.o

D a d A . rs
vi
Pe l on*

d v d elo @ q n e n e.o
a i p rs n uin ma u lc m
Da d Eie a
vi s m n*

d vies mr @ q in ma u lc m
a d ie
un e n e.o
QUI EM ANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,LLP
50 Calf ni Ste ,22nd Fl
ior a r et
oor
Sa Fr nc s Ca i or a 9 11
n a i co, lf ni 41

Tel:415 875- /Fax:( 5 875.( ) 6600
41 ) 6700
Edwa d J. Fr nc
r De a o*

e d fa c @ q i n ma u l o
d er n o u n e n e. m
c
Ra ond N . i r
ym
N m od*

ry i o / q in ma u l o
a nmr dl un e n e. m
c
Be tQua
noi nnby*
b n u r v g in ma u l o
e q amb @ un e n e . m
c
QUI EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,
LLP
51 M adi Avenue,22nd Fl
son
oor
N ew Yor N e Y o k 1 0
k, w r 001

Tel:[phone]/Fax:( 2)8 71
.( 2) 4921 49- 00
Davi A . e s
d N l on*

d v n lo @ q in ma u l o
a e es n un e n e . m
c
QUI EMANUEL URQUHART & SULLI
NN
VAN,
LLP
500 W es M adi on St e t Suie 2450
t
s
re, t
Chi
cago,llnoi 60661
li s

Te.( 2)705- /Fa ( 2)7057401
l: 31
7400 x: 31
M dm it dpr hac vi e
te o
c

Co n e f rPlit co n e cai Dee d n M oo oa
u s lo an W u tr l m- f n a t tr l
Sol i s I and M ot ol M obii I
uton , nc.
or a
lt nc.
y,

3
M TI
GARRAGA DAVI M UL NS& GROS
S LI
SMAN P.
A.

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STR I CO URT
CT
SOUTHERN DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA
CA SE N O . l: 0- 23580- S
: 1 CVRN
M O TO RO LA M OBI TY ,I C .,
LI
N

Pl i if/Count r am De e
antf
e cli
f ndant
,

A PPLE,I C.
N ,
D e e nt/Count r l m Pl i if
f nda
e c ai a ntf .
CER TI CA TI N O F G R AH A M PE CH EN I
FI
O
K

Gr
aham Pe he k,purua t Rul 4( oft SpecalRul Goveni t Ad si
c ni
s nt o e b) he
i
es
r ng he mison
a Pr e ofAtonwys he e c rii st t
nd adi e
t
, r by e tfe ha :
1ha s udi t Loc Rul oft U nied St t s Di t i Cour f t Sou he n
ve t ed he
al es he t
a e s rd
t or he t r
D it i ofFl i ,a
s rd
or da' nd,

la ame be i good sa ng
m
m rn
t ndi

t Ne Yor Cour ofAppeas
he w
k
t
l
l

G RA HA M PECH EN I
K

CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 2358 RN S
0-

C ER TI CA TE O F SER V I E
FI
C
l H ER EBY CER TI t t o M a c 7,201 a tue a c r t c py oft a
FY ha n
rh
2, r nd or ec o
he bove a
nd

f egoi wa s r edvi r gul rU . M a l ndEl toni M al
or ng s e v
a e a S. i a
ecr c iupon Cl sophe R.. e Coun e
ui t r J Pac ,
sl

f rDee da tW elGos a & M a g s LLP,1 9 Brc l Av n , ie1 0 , imiFlrd
o f n n , i, th l
n e,
3 5 ikel e ue Sut 2 0 M a , o ia
331 a vi Elc r cM alupon Couns f D
31 nd a e toni
i
el or

a

t
he

c Litbe o .
e s lw

EdwadM .Muli ( a. rNo.8639 )
r
lns F1 Ba
20
SER V I LI
CE ST
M ot ol M obii l .v Appl ,l .
or a
lt nc .
y,
e nc
Cas N o. 1 1 CV e
: : 0- 23580- S
RN
U nied St t D i ti tCour ,Sou he n D i ti tofFl i
t
a es sr c
t
t r sr c
orda
N a han A .Gr enbl t *
t
e at

Couns f Apnl ,l .
el or
e nc

n t a ge n at wel o
ah n.re blt@ i. m
c
Stve S.Che e ky*
e n
r ns

Chr s ophe R. . e
it
r J Pac

se e c rn k @ welc m
tv n.hee s y i.o

c rso e .a e wel o
h itph rp c @ i. m
c
W e l Gothal& M a esLLP
i, s
ng
1 Brcke lA ve
395 i l
nue,Suie 1
t 200
M i m i Fl i 331
a , or da
31

JilJ. o*
l H

Telpho ( 577- 00
e ne: 305) 31
Fa i l ( 374- 59
csmie: 305) 71

ic i.alw@ wel o
a keh ro
i. m
c

Sam uelF.Er t
ns *

M at w D . e s
the
Pow r *

s r s@ c v.o
en t o c m

mate p wes i.o
th m o r@wel m
c

Chrs i Sa
i tne under Has t *
s ke t

B ra C . ng*
i n Cha

c a ket c v.o
h s t@ o c m

b in.h n @ wel o
ra c a g i. m
c

il.o i.o
ilh @wel m
c

J c i T. al *
a quelne H row
A nne M .Ca l
ppela*

a nec p l @ welc m
n .a pel
a i.o

rrm@ c v.o
fa o c m

W e l G ot hal& M a es LLP
i, s
ng ,
201Re
dwood Shor Pa kwa
es r y
Redwood Shor ,Calf ni 94065- 13
es
ior a
1 4

c riik c v.o
ma t a @ o c m
n

Telpho ( 8 3000
e ne: 650) 02Fa i l ( 802- 00
csmie: 650) 31

RobertD .Fr *
am

Chr sM a tni k*
i
ri a
W i l w B . ub*
ns o
Ta

wtu @ c v.o
ab o cm

Covi on & Bur i LLP
ngt
lng
One Fr ntSt e t
o
re
Sa Fr nc s o,Calf ni 94111n a ic
ior a
5356

Ro r T.Hasa *
be t
lm

r sa c v.o
ha lm@ o c m

Covi o & Buri LLP
ngt n
lng
333 Tw i Dol n D rve,Suie 700
n
phi i
t
Re
dwood Shor s Ca ior a 94065
e , lf ni

Telpho ( 5 5916000
e ne: 41 ) Fa smie: ( 5)5916091
c i l 4l
-

Te.( )6321: 650
4700/Fa ( 632x: 650) 4800
4
M TI
GARRAGADAVI M UL NS& GROS
S LI
SMAN, A.
P.

CA SE N O . 1: 0- : 1 CV 2358 RN S
0-

Jel y C.W u*
m

J n . @ wel o
e nywu i. m
c

W e l G ot ha & M a
i, s l
ngesLLP
767 Fi t A ve
fh
nue
N ew Yor N ew Y or 10153
k,
k

Tee
lphone:( 2)31 8
21 0- 000
Fac i l ( 2)31 8
smie: 21 0- 007
M a k G .Da s
r
vi *

Ma kd v stwel o
r va io i. m
z c
W ei, ot hal& M a sLLP
lG s
nge
1 Eye St e t N W ,Suie 900
300
r e,
t
W as ngt D C 20005
hi on,

Telphone:( 68 7000
e
202) 2Fac i l ( 857smie: 202) 0940
M dm it
tedpr hac vi e
o
c

5
M TI
GARRAGA DAVI M ULLI & GROSS
S
NS
MAN,P.
A.

UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COU RT
CT
SOU TH ERN D I I OF FLO RI A
STR CT
D
M O TO RO LA M O BI TY ,I C .
LI
N ,

Pl i if/Countr ai De e nt
antf
e cl m f nda ,
CA SE N O . 1 1 CV : : 0- 23580- S
RN
A PPLE,l C.
N ,

D e e nt/Count r l i Pl i if
f nda
e c a m a ntf .

O R DER G M NTI G M O TI N TO A PPEA R
N
O

PRO HAC I EtCONSENT TO DESI
X
GNATI AND REQUEST TO
ON
ELECTRONI
CALLY RECEI NOTI
VE
CES OF ELECTRONI FI NG
C LI
TH I CA U SE ha ng c e be or t C o ' on t M oton t A ppea Pr H ac Vi e f
S
vi om
f e he ul
t
he
i o
r o
c or
G r ha Pe ni Cons nt t D e i ton,a Re s t El dr ni ly Rec i N o i s of
a m
che k,
e o s gna i
nd que t o e o ca l
e ve tce

Elctoni Fii (he S oin',purua t t Spe a Ruls Goveni t Admison a
e r c lng t t to '
M
) s nt o he cil e
r ng he
s i nd
Pr c i ofAtor ysi t Unied Stt sDititCour f t Sout n DititofFl i a
a tce
t ne n he t
a e src
t or he
her src
orda nd
Se ton 28 oft CM /
ci
he
ECF Admi sr tvePr dur s Thi Cour ha ng c i r t m o i n
nita i
oce e . s
t vi ons de ed he t o
a a 1o he r e n f t s i i he e
nd 1 t r el va t ac or , t s r by:
O RD ERED AN D A D J D GED t t
U
ha :

The M o i i GRANTED.Gr ha Pe he k ma a a a pa tc pa ei t sa ton on
ton s
a m c ni y ppe r nd rii t n hi c i
behal ofM ot aM obiiy,I a M ot ol , I The Cl r s l pr de e e t o cno ik a i
f
orol
lt nc. nd
or a nc.
e k ha l ovi l c r ni tt ton

ofa l l dr ni t lngst Gr ha Pe he k, vae ia d e s r a
l e e o c i i o a m c ni i mal d rs g G

p c e i@ q i e u l o
e h nk uM mr e. m.
e

DONE AND ORDERED i Cha r ,i M im i Fl rda,on t s
n
mbe s n a , o i
hi

da ofM a c ,
y
rh

201 .
2

Honor bl Robe tN .Sc a,J .
a e
r
ol r
Unie Stt sDiti J
t d a e srct udge
Copi sf ni he t A l Couns ofRec d
e ur s d o: l
el
or