Chase Home Finance LLC v. DePass

Filing 63

ORDER Denying 61 Motion for Reconsideration. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 1/17/2012. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES DISTR I C O URT
CT
SO U TH ERN DISTRICT O F FLO RI
DA
M I M ID I
A
VISI N
O
CA SE N O .102361 C l K ING
2- VM ARG ARET R .DEPA SS,

Pl ntf ,
ai if

UNUM d/ a FI
b/ RST UNU M LI I SU M N CE
FE N
COM PA NY ,a Re ser Tr
git ed adem ar a M ar tng
k nd
ke i
Br nd ofUN UM GROUP a isI SU RI G
a
nd t N
N
SUB SI ARI
DI ES,
D ef nda .
e nt
/

O R DER D ENY I G PLA I TI S A M ENDED M O TI N FO R
N
N FF'
O
R ECO N SI EM TI N
D
O
TH I CAU SE c esbef e t Cour upon Pl i ifM ar etR .Depas
S
om
or he
t
antf
gar
s'

Ame d M o in a M e o a um i S ppo to He M o i n f Re o i e a i n (
nde
to nd m r nd n u r f r to or c nsd r to DE
# ) Gl dDe e r2 20111 The en, a n ifs e r le fom t eCo tsOr e
61 , e c mbe 0,
. r i Pli tf e ks e if r h ur' d r
Gr ntngDe e n ' M o i f rSu ay J g e , ie No mbe 1 201 .(
a i
fnda ts ton o mm r ud m nt fld ve r , 1 DE

/5 .Pli tf pr vi usy s u tt i s mer me yby fln aMoton f
/ 7) an if e o l o gh h s a e d
ii g
i or
Re o i r to ( #5 )o Nove e 8, 011
c nsde ai n DE 8 n
mb r 2 .Ahe ac r f r viw oft r c r
r a e ul e e
he e o d,
t Co r d nidPl i ipsM o i n f rRe o i r to onDe e r1 201 .( #6 .
he u t e e antf
to o c nsde a in
c mbe , 1 DE 0)
Pl ntf now as t Courtt r ons dert m at ryeta n.H avi r vi w ed t
ai i f
ks he
o ec i he te
gai
ng e e
he

1 f nd n fl daRe pon e( / )o J nu r 6 2 2.No r pl wa tmey
De e a t ie
s s DE / n a a y , 01
62
e y si l
fl d. m a t ri t r or rpe f det r i ton.
ie The te s he ef e i or e m na i

conce nsr i ed by Pl ntf i t A m e d M otons he Cour fndsno l orf t l
r as
ai if n he
nde
i t
ti
egal ac ua
basst s
i o uppor r onsde a i
t ec i r ton.

A m oton f r onsi r i m a onl be gr ed f lm ied r ons.A m oton
i or ec de aton y y
ant or i t eas
i

t r ons deri onl a ia e when apary pr e st cour w ih e de ofan
o ec i s y va l bl
t es nt he
t t vi nce
i er ni c nge i cont oli l w ,t a l biiy ofnew e denc ort need t
nt ve ng ha
n
r lng a he vaia lt
vi e, he
o

c re tce re r ro ma f s ij tc .Eie r v ca nialCo p.No. 7- 058 CV,
o r c la ro r nie t n usie s nbe g . r v
r , 0 22 20 W L 29 02 a * ( D . a. ul 7, 008 ; e a s Z. M arne I c v. V
08
46 9 t 2 S. Fl J y 2 ) s e lo K. i , n . M/

Ar hi t , 08F. p 1 ,1 63( D. a.1 2) Su tMe c lCe e o
c gei 8
s
Su p. 561 5 S. Fl 99 ; mmi dia ntr f
Al ama I . . ly, 4 F. pp, d 1 5 1 5 ( . Al . 003 .l t it r ssof
ab , nc v Rie 28 Su 2 3 0, 35 M D. a 2 ) n he n e e t
fnalt a cons rva i ofs cer our ,r
i iy nd
e ton
car es ces econs der i ofa or ri an
i aton
n de s
e r or na y r edy w hi i t be em pl d s rngl Unied St e v.Baie 288 F.
xta di r em
ch s o
oye pa i y.
t
at s
ly,

Su p. d 1 ,1 67 ( . Fl 200 ) a fd, 9 F. 1 8 ( 1h Ci. 005 ; e alo
p 2 261 2 M D. a. 3 , f 41 3d 20 1 t r 2 ) J c s

S lmanv Hae 20 4W L 8 3 a * ( . Al 2 2)CdLltga t s oul n us
pel
. ly, 0
668 7 t 2 M D. a. 00 g ii n s h d ot e
moinst r c nsd ra ak ej r ra to t a a rer i ' .Furh r e a
to o e o ie s ne -ek e cin o n dves u1 '
ng.) temor,

moin frrc nsdeainc nno b us dt a a eag me t ara yrj ce byt
to o e o i rto a t e e o dv nc r u ns le d ee td he
c u t S eU.. AlAsesa Equlme to s SieBul n Cor ,e a.8 F.
o r. e S v. l s t nd p n fWe t d idig p. t l, 43
Su p. 77 385( D. 1.1 3) l i a i a pr pra eve cef rr ii a g n s
p 3 ,
N. 11 99 . t s n n p o it hi l o a sng r ume t

whih c l ha be nrie beo ej gme wa e trd,Do olCr tlPr ducs I c
c oud ve e as d fr ud nt s nee
k ysa o t, n .
v D . C.Co niato Co p. 1 F.d 1 27,1 ( t Ci.1 4)
. S.
mmu c ins r , 5 3 4 434 7 h r 99 .
Pl i i f how e r a i f l t pr s apr m a f e c e f r
a ntf ,
ve , ga n ais o e ent i aci as or econs der i
i aton.

2

Pl ntf doe no of e any new l orf ct e dence,norcan Pl i ifs
ai i f s t f r
egal a ual vi
a ntf how eihera
t
n

itr ni c ngei c nr lig1w o an e t c re tce rer ro ma fs ij sie.
neve ng ha n o toln a r e d o o rc la ro r nie tn u tc
Pl ntf i t a n as e t t tt sCour ds d notl a tm elne oft sl t
ai if nsead gai s r s ha hi
t 'houl
ook t i i ss hi as
a
ppea butl a t i s ofii elnes a a di ta i f om t tue f t i t s
l
ook t he s ue tm i s' s sr cton r he r ac s n hi

n he a
he ac s
c
s on s
c s . ( #61 a 3 .Onl a c
ae' DE , t ) y hange i t l w ,ort f t upon whi h a decii i
'

ba e wil u tf ar c n i r to o ap e o o de .Su s v Sa e Sa n &
s d, lj siy e o sdea i n f r vi us r r s man . l m, xo
Nile #. ,1 3 F. D . 9, 4 ( . Fl .1 4) Pl itf ha n ta s re a y
es n, W. 5 R. 68 69 M D. a 99 . an if s o s e td n
c
hange i t l w ori t f t upon w hi h t Cour ' decii w asbas butm e el
n he a
n he ac s
c he
ts
s on
ed,
r y
atempt t ge anot bie a t a e.
t
so t
her t t he ppl
A cc di y,a t f lconsde a i oft pl ngsand t sat oft ca e,i
or ngl fer ul
i r ton he eadi
he t us he s t
i her
s eby

O RD ER ED ,AD JU DG ED ,and DECR EED t tPl ntf Am ended M oton f
ha ai ifs
i or

Re onsd r to o t Co r' N o mbe 1 2 1Or e ( #61 i he e y DENI
c ie a i n f he u ts ve r , 01 d r DE ) s r b
ED.
Pl i ifm a notfl a f t rm otonsf r
antf y
ie ny urhe
i
or econsi r ton w ihoutl ve oft Cour,
de a i
t
ea
he
t
butm ay a
ppealt t El ve h Cic tCour ofAppeal i s desr
o he e nt r ui
t
s f o ied.
D ON E AND O RD ER ED i Cha be s atM i i M i iDade Count Fl i
n
m r,
am , am y, or da,
t s 1 hofJ
hi 7t
anua y,2012.
r
k

- T ES LAW RENCE KI
AM
N
S. I
D STRI J DGE
CT U

.

j

S
OUTHERN DI T CT FYLORI
S RI
,
DA
3

CC:

Pl i if
antf
M argare R .D e s
t
pas
P. .
O Box 835641
M i i FL 33283
am ,
PRO SE

Couns f Dqf
el or endant
K r s i Be h Pet
i tna t
t
PetFur a PL
t
m n,
2101N W Cor a e Boul va d
por t
e r
Suie 316
t
BocaR a on,FL 33431 7343
t
561 994- 1
- 431
Fax:[phone]

Emalk t@petur n.o
i: pet tf ma c m

4