Estrada et al v. Alexim Trading Corp.

Filing 73

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 64 Motion for Summary Judgment. Defendant's Motion is granted as to Count 1 for unpaid overtime. Defendant's Motion is Denied as to Count 2 for retaliation. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 11/7/11. (mg)

U NI
TED STATE S D I
STR I CO UR T
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO RI A
CT
D
CASE NO .1 23696- V - TZ/ M ON TON
0CI SEI SI
FELI VELEZ,
X
Pl i if
a ntf ,
VS.

ALEX I TM D I CO RP.
M
NG
,
De e nt
f nda

/
ORDER DENYI M OTI FO R SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
ON
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on t Def nda ' M oton f Summ a y J
S
s f e he
t he e nts
i or
r udgm e
nt

( 6 j Pan ifst c u tsc n a n dc mpli alg sacam f ru p i o e t i
DE- 8 . litf wo o n e o d me de o ant le e li o n ad v ri n
me
vi atonoft Fai Lab St r Act(
ol i
he r or andads
FLSA)a acai f r aiton i vi ai oft
nd l m or etlai n olton he

F A.Dee d n mo e f rs mmayj d me t nb t c u t a g igta Plitf i n
LS
f n a t v s o u l u g n o o h o n s r un h t anif s ot
c r d by t FLSA. Bec us Def ntf iedt r iet M ot Carire m pton i is
ove e
he
a e enda a l o a s he
or re xe i n t
pladi o d i dic r De e ntsm oton i de e a t Count1 Def ntsm oton
e ngs r urng s ove y, f nda '
i s ni d s o
. enda '
i
i de e a t Count1 be us Pli ifi c e byt r a iton pr sonsoft FLSA.
s ni d s o
1 ca e antf s over d he etla i
ovii
he
1. M at alFad s
eri

Defnda i a c z a ntt tpr de i e alc r ta poraton s r c t a fom
e nt s a go ge ha ovi s ntgr a go r ns t i e vies o nd r
a po ti t , wol ( 70- :2. Pl ntf wase oye byDee n asad i rofcag
ny r n he rd. DE- 2, ) ai if
mpl d
fnda t
rve
ro

tu ksfo De embe 13,2007t Aug t1 2008.( 67, 20. Ac or ngt Dee nt
r c rm c r
o us 4,
DE- p. ) c di o fnda ,
durng t tm ePl ntf wor d f De enda , f nda had fveca go tuc us t ta por
i he i
ai if ke or f nt De e nt
i
r r ks ed o r ns t

mecha s f delveyt nato la i e nai ldesi tons ( 70- a ! ) A1oft
r ndie or i r o ina nd ntr tona tnai . DE- 2 t 5. l he
tu ksha agos ve ceweg i exc sof1 001pounds (d a !6. Du i t r lvan
r c d r s hil ihtn es 0,
. 1 t ) rng he ee t

tme,Def nda o d one tuc t thad agr sve cl wei ofls t 1 001pounds
i
e nt wne
r k ha
os hi e ght e s hat 0,
,

whc wa n t e b c r ot c d i r.(d a ! . Ac o dn t Plitf, narg lrb ss
ih s o usd y ag nlk rves 1 t 7) c r ig o an ifo e ua ai
hedr s le t c t theetmaesweg dl st n 1 000pounds ( 67a 20.
ove malr nzks ha si t ihe es ha 0,
. DE- t )
W hiePli ifwor d f De e nthewa i t c e t punc i a outa t
l antf
ke or f nda
s nsnzt d o
h n nd
t he

begnni a e ofhi wor da ( 67a 20. Thepunc coc wa l atd i i
i ng nd nd
s k y. DE- t )
h l k s oc e nsde
Dee ntsf iii a wa onl a e sbl durngbusne shour .(d.at21. Pl ntf,
fnda ' acltes nd s y cc si e i
i s
s 1
) ai if
howe r s tm e dei r d ca go a rhour a was t e or una e t punch i a out
ve , ome i s lve e r he
s nd
,her f e, bl o
n nd

f t tmes ntonhi afe ho sdei re .(d)Pli ifc ane t Dee ta t
or he i pe
s tr ur lveis 1
antf ompli d o fndan bout he
l a i oft punc cock a t tt l a i n pr nt Pli iffom bengabl t r c d al
oc ton he
h l
nd ha he oc to eve ed antf r
i
e o e or l

ofhi hour wor d rs tngi Pl ntf notgetngpadf a1oft hou shewor (d)
s s ke euli n ai if
ti i or 1 he r
ked. 1
Pl ntf alo c
ai if s ompl i t thewa notbe ngpr pe l pad f rt ove tm et thewo ke
aned ha
s
i
o ry i o he ri ha
r d.

(d) A fw wee ltr Pli ifwa tr nae (d)Ac r i t Dee nt Pli ifwa
1
e
ks ae, antf s emi td. 1
co dng o fnda , antf s
t r nae bec us he diplye agg es i t r a t rdrve a wasr de a
e mi td a e
s a d r son owa ds no he i r nd
u nd

dse p cf l ohss pev s r.( 6 - a ! . Th r atr Plitf flds i.
ir s e tu t i u r io s DE- 4 1 t 5) ee fe , an if e ut
I . Sum m ar Judgm e St
I
y
nt andar
d

S mmayj d me tsa p o raewh n th pla i g . . h ta t eei nog n ie
u r u g n i p r p it e t e e d n s . s ow h t h r s e un
t

is ea t a ymaeil a ta dt th mo i gp ryi e tte t aj d me t samatro
su s o n tra fc n ha te v n a t s n i d o u g n a
l
t f
e
lm ' An e s nv fie t Lo b , n .47 U. 2 2 2 7( 9 6 ;
a ' d r o . b ry b y I c, 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) HCA He t S rs o .I c
al e v. fGa, n .
h
v Emplye sHe t I s Co. 2 F. 982,991(1 t Ci.2001 .Onc t movi pa t
. o r alh n . , 40 3d
1h r
)
e he
ng ry
de
monsr t st a enc ofa ge nei s ofm aera f c , henon- ovi pa t mus i
ta e he bs e
nui s ue
t il a t t
m ng ry
t'
come
f wa dwih tpe ii f c ss
or r t s cfc a t howi t tt r i a ge ne is f ti l'' M atus t Elc.
ng ha he e s nui s ue or ra .'
s hia e

I d s Co v Ze t Ra i Co p.4 5U. 57 5 7( 9 6 ( o igFe . Ci P, 6 e) The
n u . . . ni do r , 7 S. 4, 8 1 8 ) qu tn d R. v. 5 ().
h
2

Cour mus viw t r c d a a lf c ua i e e st r r i t lghtm os f vor bl t t
t t e he e or nd 1 a t l nf r nce he efom n he i
t a a e o he
non- ovi pa t a dec d whe he ûthee de pr s nt a s fci tdia ee
m ng ry nd i e
t r çt vi nce e e s ufi en s gr mentt
o

rq ies b sint aj r o wheh ri i s o e sd dt a o ep rymu t rvala amatr
e ur u miso o u y r te t s o n -ie h t n a t s p e i s te
o 1w.' Ale v T s nFo d , n . 1 F3 6 2 6 6( 1hCi. 9 )( oigAn ro 4 7
f a ' ln . y o o s I c, 21 .d 4 , 4 1 t r 1 97 qu t
'
n des n, 7
U. a 25152).
S. t - )

I o po igamo inf rs mma yj d me t ten n- vn p ryma n trl s ey
n p sn
to o u r u g n ,h o mo ig a t y o ey oll
o t pl di ,b mus s
n he ea ngs ut t how by a fda t ,de ii ,a wer t i e r t i ,a
f vis postons ns s o nt roga ores nd
a isonst ts cii f c sexitde onsr tng age neis f til Se Fe R.Ci P.
dm s i ha pe fc a t s m ta i
nui s ue or ra . e d.
v.

5 () () s eas Ceoe Cop.r Car t, 7 U. 31 , 2 ( 9 6 .A meeç cn i a' f
6 c ,e ; e lo ltx r . tet4 7 S. 7 3 4 1 8 )
r f itl 'o
s l
e de e s
vi nc uppori t opposngpa t sposton wilnots fc i t d,t r mus bea
tng he
i
ry' ii
l
uf e; nsea he e
t

s f in s o n ta t j r c u dr a o a l 5ndf rt a pat.An r o , 7U. . t 2;
u fce t h wig h the u y o l e s n by
o h t ry des n 47 S a 25
s ealo Wale v Da b 91 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( 1hCi. 9 0 .
e s
k r . ry 1 2 5 3 5 7 1 t r 1 9 )
1 1 D icus i
1 . s s on

1 De n a i No Enildt Su r Ju g n o Pl it ' Ov ri Cl m
. # d nts t t e o mma y d me t n an t s e tme ai
t

z

Dee a t v sf rsl r u g n o Plitf cam f run i ov ri b c u e
fnd n mo e o l
mmayj d me t n an ips li o pad e t e a s
me
Def ntas e t i i e mptfo t FLSA ' overi epr sonsundert M ot Ca re
enda
s rs t s xe
r m he
S
tm
ovii
he
or rir

Ex mpt n, U.. j21 ( )1. Pli t fe s n ilya srsta De e d n h swav dti
e i 29 SC. 3 b ( ) ani se tal se t h t fn a t a ie hs
o
f
de e ebec us Def ndantf ie t r s t a fr ai de ens i isa werori r pons t
f ns
a e e
a ld o aie he fim tve f e n t ns
n es e o
Pli ifsi erog t i s a r que t f a s i a De e ntne rs
antf nt r a ore l nd e ss or dmi sons nd f nda
ve oughtt n e is
o m nd t
1n r pons t t f l ng i e r t r De e
I es e o he olowi nt roga o y f ndan r ponded 1 / '
t es
$ A.'
N
I you cli t tPli ifi exe fom t ove tmepr sonsoft FarLa
f
am ha antf s mpt r he ri
ovii
he i bor
St nda dsAc o t tt FarLa St nda dsAc i i pplc et Pli ifor
a r
t r ha he i bor a r
t s na iabl o a ntf
Defnda t i n iy by saut y, eg a o y a c s l w ciai t s ii e m pton
e n , de tf
t t or r ult r nd a e a tton he pec fc xe i

a we ort s e e isdic y r pons s Pli iff t ra guest ti wol be s ve ey
ns r o upplm nt t s over es e . antf urhe r
ha t d
e rl

p eudc di De e d n i al we t riet ee mp ina t i sa eo tep o e dn sgv n
rj ie f fn a t s lo d o as h xe to t h s tg f h r c e ig ie
t tdi c r i cl ed a ti li s ti Fe u r
ha s ove y s os nd r a s e n br a y.

Gene a l f l r t pl a a afimatvedef ns wa ve t tde e e. atme v Roarng
r ly, aiu e o e d n fr i
e e i s ha f ns L i r .
i

To ,I .601F. 1 1 ( 1hCi. 1 .l Di v J rResaur Gr p,LLC,
yz nc,
3d 224, 239 1 t r 20 0) n az . agua t ant ou
627
F. 1 2,1 4 ( 1hCi. 01 ,hedee n f ldt pl di isa we t a FLSA
3d 21 21 1 t r 21 0) t fnda t aie o ea n t ns r o n
c
ompli t afima i de e eofa ad i sr tvee mpton.The de enda ne rmoved
ant he fr tve f ns
n m nita i xe i
f nt ve

t a e isa we a ne rr ie t e m p i durng dic r TheDi c tf undt t
o m nd t ns r nd ve as d he xe ton i s ove y.
az our o
ha
t swa ac a scc e ofwai ra f undt tt dititc thad e r by pe m itng t is
hi s l s i as
ve nd o
ha he src our
red
r ti he s ue
t be r s d a ti . I a 1 5. Si lry,i t sc e,De e ntdi notr iet M ot Ca r
o aie t ral d t 21
mia l n hi as
f nda d
as he
or nie
e m pto i isa we and a fr i de e es ne rmovedt n e isa wer a ne r
xe i n n t ns r
fimatve f ns , ve
o m nd t ns , nd ve
r s i dur ng di c r Cons que l Def nda c nnotr i e t e m pton f t fr ttm e
aied t i
s ove y.
e nty, e nt a
a s he xe i or he is i

a t es mmayj d me tsa e Ac o dn l, u r j d me ti d n e
t h u r u g n tg . c r igy s mmay u g n s e id.
B.Dek d ntsNo Enildt Su r J d me to Pl n f 'Rea ito Cl m
j n a i t t e o mmay u g n n ait fs tla in ai
t
Dee d n mo e frs mmayj d me t nPlitf rtlaincam b c u ePli if
fn a t v s o u r u g n o anirs eaito li e a s ant
f
i notc r d by t FLSA ' r t iton pr so .A cli f r t i i unde t FLSA
s
ove c
he
S eala i
ovi ins
am or ealaton
r he

rq ie as o n ta ( )tee ly ee g g d i a tvt p o e tdu d rteAc; 2 t
e urs h wig h t 1 h mpo e n a e n ciiy r tce n e h t ( ) he
e ly es b e u nt s fee a v rea to b tee l e ; n ( )ac uslc n e to
mpo e u s q e l u frd d e s cin y h mpoy r a d 3 a a o n cin
y
e itd b t e t e o e ' a tv t a dtea v rea to
xse ewe n he mply es ciiy n h d es cin.Wofv Co a coa Co, 0 F.
l . c - l .2 0 3d

upo whihy r l de ci t r s nt)youbeivet e mpto i a ia e
n c ou ey, s rbe he ea o s
le he xe in s pplc bl,
i c t a pa4ofyoura we t f t bas f cli i s h e mpton and
ndi ae s l
ns r he acual es or am ng uc xe i
des rbe t r or a doc e su whih you r l i r s
c i he ec ds nd um nt pon c
ey n e pondi t t s
ng o hi
i e r t y.
nt r oga or
4

1 1 43( 1hCi.2000) Defnda ague t tbe us Pli ifi notcovee byt
337, 342- 1 t r
. e nt r s ha ca e antf s
rd he
FLSA ,he ca te t bls t fr tel m entofa r t i ton cl m .
nno s a i h he is e
e ala i
ai

Thet r Se oye 'i de d by t FLSA a t ny i vi e pl
e m tmpl e' s sne
he
s ' ndi dual m oyedby an
a

e oy r' 29U. C.j203( () Ther aitons ci oft FLSA satst i i unl ul
mpl e .'
S.
e)1.
etlai e ton he
t e hatt s awf
$ o dic r ori a o he m a rdicrmi t a i ta e oye be us s h e o e
ç s ha ge n ny t r nne s i nae gans ny mpl e ca e uc mpl ye
t
ha fl a c
s ied ny ompl i ori tt e o c us d t bei tt ed a pr ee ng u rorr l e t
ant nsiutd r a e o ns iut ny oc di nde
eatd o

t scha er' 29U. C.j215.Thus on isfc t r aitonpr sonoft FLSA woul
hi pt .
'
S.
, t a e he etlai ovii
he
d
a yt Pli if Furhe e t e mptonr le onbyDefnda ,29U. C.j21 b ( )i
ppl o antf. t nnor,he xe i eid
e nt
S.
3() 1,s
anexe i t t m a m um hourr quie e soft Act nott ot rs tonsoft Ac .
mpton o he xi
e r m nt he ,
o he ec i
he t
Thus ba edon t l ngu oft sa u e, ai ife ged i a i t pr e t unde t Act, s
he a age he t t t Pl ntf nga
n ctviy ot ced
r he
co pli ng a
m a ni boutt l a i oft punc cl k andhi r s tng i biiy t pr ryr c d
he oc ton he
h oc
s e uli na lt o ope l e or
hi tm ea r ceve pr pe c pe ai De e ntsm o i n onl a es est fr telmen
s i nd e i
o r om ns ton. f nda ' to
y ddr s he i s e t
ofacai f r t la i Cons que l be a et r t la i pr son oft FLSA a ist
l m or e a iton.
e nty, c us he e a iton ovii
he
pple o

Pli if Dee ntsM otonmus bede e a t Pl ntf srt iton cam.
antf fnda '
i
t
nid s o ai if ealai li
Acc di y,ti he e
or ngl i s r by

ORDERED ta De e d n ' M oin frS mmayJ d me t DE- )i GM NTED i
h t fn a ts t o u r u g n ( 68 s
o
n
pa t D EN I i par :
r and
ED n t

1 Def ndantsM oton i gr nt d a t Cou 1f unpad ove tme.
. e
'
i s a e so
nt or
i
ri

2. De e ntsM oton i de e ast Co t2 f r t la i
f nda '
i s nid o un or e a iton.
DONE a ORDERED i M im i Fl i t s
nd
n a , orda, hi

? d yoç
a
*
'

,

2011
.

q
.

PA TR I A A .SEI
CI
TZ
UN I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J D GE
CT U
c
c:

Al Couns lofRec d
l
e
or