Estrada et al v. Alexim Trading Corp.

Filing 74

AMENDED ORDER DENYING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT re 73 Order on Motion for Summary Judgment,. Signed by Judge Patricia A. Seitz on 11/8/2011. (ra)

U NI
TED STATE S D I
STR I CO U R T
CT
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO RI
CT
DA
CA SE N O .1 23696- V - TZ/ M ON TON
0CI SEI Sl
FELI V ELEZ,
X

Pli if
antf,
VS.

A LEX I TR ADI G CORP.
M
N
,
D e e nt
f nda
/

AM ENDEDIO RDER DENYI M OTI FOR SUM M ARY JUDGM ENT
NG
ON
THI M ATTER i be or t Cour on t Def nda ' M oto f Summ a yJu
S
s f e he
t he e nts i n or
r dgment

( 6 1 Pli ifst c u tsc n a n e c mpan alg sacam f ru pado e t i
DE- 4 . antf' wo o n e o d me d d o lit l e li o n i v ri n
e
me
vi ainoft FarLaborStndadsAc (
olto he i
a r
t FLSA)a acam f r tlaton i vi ai oft
nd li or eai i n olton he

FLS Dee d n mo e f rs mmayj d me to b t c u t a g igta Plitf i n t
A. fn a t v s o u r u g n n oh o n s r un h t anif s o
c e byt FLSA .Be us De e ntf ie t r s t M ot Ca e e
over d he
ca e f nda al d o aie he
or ni r xempton i is
i nt
pla ngsordurng dic r Def ntsmoton i de e ast Count1 De e
e di
i
s ove y, enda '
i s nid o
. f ndantsmoto
'
in
i denid a t Count1 be a ePl ntf i c r by t r t lai pr s o oft FLSA.
s
e so
1 c us ai if s ove ed he e ai ton ovii ns he
1 M at alFact
.
eri
s

De e nti aca go a ntt tpr desi e a c r tans tton s r ce t a fom
f nda s r ge ha ovi ntgr l a go r pora i e vi s o nd r
a y po ti t word. ( 7 - , 2. Pli tf wa e o e b De e d n a ad ie o c r o
n r n he l DE- 0 2 ! ) anif s mply d y fn a t s rv r f ag

tuc fom De e r1 2007t Augus 1 2008.( 67, 20. Acc di t Defnda ,
r ks r
c mbe 3,
o
t 4,
DE- p. ) or ng o e nt
d i t tme Pl i ifwor d f Def nda ,Def nda ha fve c r o tuc us d t tans t
urng he i
antf
ke or e nt
e nt d i a g r ks e o r por

l hsOr e a nd t Co r' Or e De yn Mo inf rS mmayJ d me t( 7 q
' i d r me s he u ts d r n ig to o u r u g n DE- 3 ,
r
whih m it ke y saed a t e t tDe e
c sa nl t t t he nd ha f ndan ' M oton wa gr nt i par a denid i
ts
i
s a ed n t nd
e n
par.
t

mec ndief delv y t nai landi e nai ldetnatons.( 7 2at!5. A1 oft
rha s or iel o tona
ntr tona si i
DE- 0) 1 he

tu k h dag o sv h ceweg tn e c s o 1 ,01p u d .(d a ! ) Du igterlva t
rc s a r s e il ih i x e s f 00 o n s 1 . t 6. rn h ee n
tme,De e nto d onetuc t thada gr sve c ewei o l s t t1 001pounds
i
f nda wne
r k ha
os hi l
ght f e s ha 0,
,

whc wa n tu e b c r otu kd ie s (d a ! . Ac or igt Plitf, nar g lrb ss
ih s o sd y a g r c rv r. 1 t 7) c dn o an if o e ua a i
h dr es le tuc t thee tmaesweg dl st 1 000pounds ( 67a 20.
e ov malr r ks ha si t ihe es han 0,
. DE- t )
W hie Pli ifwor d f De e
l antf
ke or f ndan hewa i tuc e t pu h i a outa t
t
s nsr t d o nc n nd
t he

b gl n a e do hswo k d y ( 6 a 2 . Th p n hco kwa lc td isd
e i g nd n f i r a . DE- 7 t 0) e u c l c s o ae n ie
mi
Def ntsfciii andwasonl ac esi edurngbusnes hour.(d a 21) Pli if
enda ' a ltes
y c sbl i
i s s I t . antf,
howeve ,s m e i delver d c r a trhour a wa ,t r f r ,unabl t punc i a out
r o tmes i e a go fe
s nd s he e o e
eo
h n nd

f t tmes onhi afe hour dei res (d) Pli ifc ane t De e ntaboutt
or he i pent s tr s lvei . 1
antf ompli d o fnda
he
l tonoft punc coc andt tt l a i pr ve e Pl ntf fom bei a et r or al
ocai
he
h l k
ha he oc ton e ntd ai if r
ng bl o ec d l

ofhi hour wor rs tngi Plitf notgetngpadfra1oft hour hewor (d.
s s ked euli n anif
ti i o 1 he s
ked. 1 )
Pli ifalo c
a ntf s ompl i d t thewa notbengpr ry pad f t ove tm et thewor d.
ane ha
s
i
ope l i or he ri ha
ke

(d4 A fw we k ltr Plitf wa tr n td.(d) Ac o dngt Dee d ntPli tf wa
1
e e s ae, an if s emiae 1
c r i o fn a , anif s
t r i td be a ehediplyed a r s o t r a he drve a wasr a
e m nae c us
s a
gg es i n owa ds not r i r nd
ude nd

dse p cf l ohss p r io s ( 6 1a ! . Th r atr Plitf flds i.
ir s e tu t i u e vs r. DE-4- t 5) ee fe , an if i ut
e
l . Sum m ar Judgm e St
I
y
nt andar
d

S mmayj d me t sa p o raewhe th pla ig . . h t t h r i nog nun
u r u g n i p r p it
n t e e dn s . s ow ha t ee s e i e
t

is ea t a ymaeil a t n t t h mo n pat i e tte t aj d me t samatro
su s o n tra fc a d ha t e vig ry s n ild o u g n a
te f
lw. An ro v fiet Lo b , n .47 U. 2 2 2 7( 9 6 ;
a ' des n . b ry b y I c, 7 S. 4 , 4 1 8 ) HCA He t Se v.o .I c
'
al r s fGa, n .
h
v EmplyesHe t I .Co.240F. 982,991( 1hCi. 01 .Oncet movi pat
.
o r alh ns ,
3d
1 t r 20 )
he
ng ry
d m o tat t a e e ofage ne is e ofm a e i f c ,t non- ovi pa t m us S ome
e nsr es he bs nc
nui s u
t ral a t he
m ng ry
tt
c

f wa d wih çpe ii f t s wi t tt r i a ge ne is f ti l''M atu hia Elc
or r t s c fc acs ho ng ha he e s nui s ue or ra . '
ss t e.

l du . . . ni Ra oCop.4 5U. 5 4 58 ( 98 )( u tn Fe . Ci P. 6e ) Th
n s Co v Ze t di r , 7 S. 7 , 7 1 6 q o ig d R. v. 5 (). e
h
Co tmus vi w t r cor a a lf c ua i e e e t r r i t lghtm os f vor bl t t
ur
t e he e d nd 1 a t l nf r nc s he efom n he i
t a a e o he
non- o ng pa t a dec de whe he ishe e d e pr e s a s fc e di a e e t
m vi
ry nd i
t r ét vi enc es nt ufi i nt s gr em nt o

r q ies miso t aj r o wh t e i i s o -ie t t n p rymus p e al samatr
e u r ub sin o u y r eh r t s o nesd d ha o e at t rv ia
te
of1w.' Alenv T onFoods I . 1 F. 642,646( t Ci.1 L igAnde s 477
a '' l . ys
, nc, 21 3d
11h r 997) quotn
r on,

U. a 2 - 2
S. t 515 $.
I o po i amo inf rs mma yj dg n ,h n n mo n p ryma n t eys ll
n p sng
to o u r u me tt e o - vig a t y o r l oey
on t pla ngs butmus s
he e di ,
t how b afi vis de ii ,ans r t i e r t i ,a
y fda t , postons we s o ntr ogaores nd
a s i nst ts cii f c se s de
dmi so ha pe fc a t xit monsr i age ne is f rti l SeeFe R. v.
tatng
nui s ue o ra .
d. Ci P.

5 () () s ealoCeoe Cop. . tet47 U. 31 , 2 ( 98 ) A meet cnil'o
6 c ,e; e s l tx r v Car t, 7 S. 7 3 4 1 6 .
r ç i tl ' f
s
a
e denc s
vi e uppori t opposng pa t sposton wilno s fc i t d,t r m us bea
tng he
i
ry'
ii
l t ufi e; nsea he e
t

s fiin s wi t a t ej r c ul ra o a l fn f r h t ry An ro 47 U. a 2 2;
u fce t ho ng h t h u y o d e s n by i d o t a pa t. des n, 7 S. t 5
s eas Wale v Da b 91 F.d 1 7 ,1 7 ( 1hCi.1 9 )
e lo k r . r y, l 2 5 3 5 7 1 t r 9 0 .
1 D icussi
11. s
on

De n a ti No Enildt Su r J d me t Pl nz ' œ e tmeCl m
# d n s t t e o mmay u g n on ait s ri ai
t
Dee a t v sf rs mmayj d me t nPlitf' cam f ru p i o e t be a e
fnd n mo e o u r u g n o anifs li o n ad v ri c us
me
Def ntas e t i i e
enda s rs t s xemptfom t FLSA' ove tme pr sonsunde t M ot Ca re
r he
S ri
ovii
r he
or r ir

Exe i 29U. C.j21 b)1. Pli ifesental ase t t tDef ntha wai dt s
mpton,
S.
3( () antf s ily s rs ha enda s ve hi
d ens be aus De e ntf l d t r i et afima i de e ei isa we ori r s ns t
ef e c e f nda aie o a s he fr tve f ns n t ns r n e po e o

3

Pli ifsi erogaore za r ssf a iso andDef ntne rs
antf nt r t i s nd eque t or dm s i ns
enda
ve oughtt a
o mend is
t
a we ort s e tisdi c r r po es Pl ntf f t ra g st ti wol bes ve el
ns r o upplmen t s ove y es ns . ai if urhe r ue ha t d
e ry

p eu ie i Dee d n i alwe t r iet e e to a t i sa eo t ep o e dng gv n
rj dc d f fn a t s l d o as he x mp in t hs tg f h r c e i s ie
o
t td s ve y i cos d a ti i s ti Fe ua y.
ha ico r s l e nd ral s e n br r
Ge r l f iur t pl d a a fr a i de e ew ave t tdef ns fatme v.
ne aly, a l e o ea n f m tve f ns i s ha
e e. i r Roarn
ig

To ,I .601F. 1 1 ( 1hCi.201 .I Di v Ja Re t antGr p,LLC,6
yz nc,
3d 224, 239 1 t r 0) n az . guar saur
ou
27
F. 1 2,1 4( 1hCi.21 0 ,hedee ntf ld t pl di isa we t a FLSA
3d 21 21 1 t r 01 ) t fnda aie o ea n t ns r o n
co aitt a fr ai de ens ofa a nita i e m p i Thede e ntne rm o
mpl n he fim tve f e n dmi sr tve xe ton.
f nda
ve ved
t a nd isa wera ne rr s d t e m pton d i dic r TheDi c tf undt t
o me t ns
nd ve aie he xe i urng s ove y.
az our o
ha
t swasacls i ca eofwave a f undt tt dititc t d e r d byper ti t is
hi
a sc s
i r nd o
ha he src our ha re
mitng he s ue
t be r ie a ti l 1 a 1 5.Si lry,n t sca e,De e ntdi notr iet M ot Ca e
o as d t ra . d. t 21
mia l i hi s
f nda d
a s he
or ni r
e mpto i isa we and a fr ai de e es ne rmove t a
xe in n t ns r
f m tve f ns , ve
d o mend isa we , ne r
t ns r and ve
r ied i durng dic r Cons que l Def ntca
as t i
s ove y.
e nty, enda
nnotr iet e m pton f t fr ttm e
as he xe i or he is i

a t es mmayj d me tsa e Ac o dn l, u r j g n i d ne .
t h u r u g n tg . c r igy s mmay ud me t s e id
#.Dee d ntsNo En i e t S mma yJ d n o Pl it 'Reai in Cl m
f n a i t tt d o u r u gme t n an # s t l o ai
l
at
De e d n mo e f rs mmayj g n o Plitf srtl to cam be a ePlitf
fn a t v s o u r ud me t n an if eai in li c us anif
a
i notco r d byt FLSA' r t lai pr sons A ca m f r t la i undert FLSA
s
ve e
he
S e ai ton ovii . li or e a iton
he
2n r pons t t f l ng i erog or De e ntr s
I es e o he olowi nt r at y f nda e ponde $ A.
dç '
N/ '
I you cli t tPli ifi e mptfom t ove tmepr sonsoft FarLa
f
am ha antf s xe
r he ri
ovii
he i bor
St nda dsAc o t tt FarLaborSt nda dsAc i i pplc et Pli tf or
a r
t r ha he i
a r
t s na iabl o a n if
Def nda ,i ntf b sa ut r r gul t y a ca e 1 w c t ton t s cii exe pton
e nt de iy y t t o y, e a or nd s a ia i he pe fc m i

u whihyourl desrbet r as s youbele t e mptoni a ia e,
pon c
ey, ci he e ont)
ive he xe i s pplc bl
i c t a pa tofyotra we t f t bas sf c am i s h exe i a
ndi ae s r
t ns r he acual e or l i ng uc
mpton nd
de c i t r or and doc e s upon whi h you r l i r s
s rbe he ec ds
um nt
c
e y n e pondi t t s
ng o hi
i er
nt rogat y.
or

rquiesas ngt t( )t e o ee ge i a tviypr tce undert Ac;( t
e r howi ha 1 he mplye nga d n ci t oe td
he t 2) he
e o es e ntys frda rea tonbyt empl r a ( )aca a c ci
mplye ubsque l ufee dves ci
he
oye ; nd 3 us l onne ton

e itdbewe nt ee o e ' a tvt a dtea v rea to
xse t e h mply e s ciiy n h d es cin.Wofv Co a coa Co, 0 F.d
l . c - l .2 0 3
1 1 42- ( 1hCi.
337, 3 43 1 t r 2000) Dee taguest tbe us Pl n ifi notcovee byt
. fndan r
ha ca e aitf s
rd he
FLSA, c nnote t bls t frtee e ofar t la in cai .
he a
sa ih he is lm nt
e aito l m
Thetnn i m pl e'i de i byt FLSA a ç y i vi ua e pl yed b a
e ' oye ' s fned he
e
s d ndi d l m o
an
y n

e oye . 29U. C.j203()1 .Thert iton scinoft FLSA sat t ti i unlwf l
mpl r'
'
S.
e( )
ealai e to he
t es ha t s a u
do dic g ori a ot rma rdic i nae a i ta e o be us s h empl e
t s har e n ny he nne s rmi t ga ns ny mplyee ca e uc
t
oye
ha fld an c pli ori tt e orc us d t bei tt e a pr ee ngunde orr l e t
s ie y om a nt nsiut d a e o nsiut d ny oc di
r eatd o

t sc ptr' 29U. C.j21 Thus onisfcet r t itonpr sonoft FLSA woul
hi ha e .
'
S.
5.
, t a he ealai ovii
he
d
a yt Pli if Furhemor,t e mptonr i o byDee nt 29U. C.j21 ( ( ) i
ppl o antf. t r e he xe i eled n
fnda ,
S.
3b)1, s
a e mpton t t m a m um hourr quie e t oft Ac ,no t o he s ctonsoft Ac .
n xe i o he xi
e r m n s he t t o t r e i
he t
Thus bas o t l ngua oft saut Pl i ife ge i a tviypr t td undert Ac , ed n he a
ge he t t e, antf nga d n c i t o ece
he t
co pli ng a tt l a i oft punc c oc a hi r uli i biiyt pr ry r co d
m a ni bou he oc ton he
h l k nd s es tng na lt o ope l e r
hi tme a r cevepr pe c
s i nd e i
o r ompe ai De e ntsmoton onl addr s e t fr telm e
ns ton. f nda '
i
y
e s s he is e nt
ofa cl i f r t la i n.Co eque l b a e t r t lato pr s on oft FLSA a i t
a m or e a i to
ns
nty, ec us he e a i i n ovi i
he
pples o

Pli itDee ntsMotonmus bede e a t Pl ntf' r aitoncl m.
antfl fnda '
i
t
nid s o ai ifs etlai ai
A c r ngl i i he e
co di y, t s r by

ORDERED ta Dee d n ' M o inf rSu r J d me t( 6 )i DENI
h t fn a ts to o mmay u g n DE- 4 s
ED.

Do adOR E E iMi Fl i thi X dyoNoe e,01
xE n D R D n a orda, s
mi
a f vmbr21.
,

*

x

.

PA TRI A A .SEI
CI
TZ
UNI
TED STATES D I
STRI J G E
CT UD

c
c:

A1 Co elofRe d
1 uns
cor