Hartford Casualty Insurance Company v. Crum & Forster Specialty Insurance Company

Filing 218

ORDER Denying 217 Motion to Stay pending Appeal. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/13/2012. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRICT CO UR T
SO UTH ER N D I
STR I O F FLO R I A
CT
D
M I M IDI I O N
A
V SI

CA SE NO .1024590- V- N G
CI Kl
HA RTFORD ACCI
DENT AND I EM N I
ND
TY
COM PANY ,a f ei cor a i asequia e
or gn por ton,
t bl
s oge and r pary i i er ton behal of
ubr e
eal t n nt es
f
M il r& Sol on Gener Cont a or I ,
le
om
al
r ct s, nc.
Pl ntf ,
ai if

CRUM & FOR STER SPECI
ALTY I SURAN CE
N
COM PAN Y,a f ei cor a i
or gn por ton,

D ef nda .
e nt
/
HARTFORD A CCI EN T AN D I DEM NI
D
N
TY
COM PAN Y ,a f ei c or i a equiabl
or gn om aton, s
t e
s ogee a r lpa t i i e e ton behal of
ubr
nd ea ry n nt r s
f
M ilr& Sol on Ge r Contac or ,I ,
le
om
ne al
r t s nc.
Pl ntf,
ai if

W ESTCHESTER SU RPLU SLW ES I SUM N CE
N
COM PAN Y,a f ei cor a i
or gn por ton,

D ef nda .
e nt
/
OR DER DENY I PLA I TI S M O TI N TO STA Y PEN DI G APPEA L
NG
N FF'
O
N
TH I M A TTER com esbef e t Cour upon Pl ntf H a tor A cci nta
S
or he
t
ai if r f d
de nd

I de nt Co ny' (sl rf r ' M o in t S a Re o u i n ofDe e ntCr m &
n m iy mpa s û- to d' to o ty s l to
la
)
fnda u
Fo se S cilyI u a eCo n sts u & Fortr' M o i n f Ato n ys Fe s
rt r pe at ns r nc mpa y' t m
cr
se ' to or t r e ' e
)

a Cosso , t r tve M o i f rEx e i n ofTi t Re pon ( E. 7) fl d
nd t r Ale nai , ton o t nso
me o s d D. #21 , ie
A ugus 2,201 Fort f l i r s ,t Cour fndst Pl ntf M oton s d
t
2.
he olow ng ea ons he
t i hat ai ips
i houl
be de e a t tt t o pr vi M agita eJ
ni d nd ha he w
e ous
s r t udge' or r gr ntng a s a s d be
s de s a i
t y houl

va t
ca ed.

PRO C ED UR AL BA CK G R O UN D
Pl i i fHarf d' Compl ntf D eclr t y Dec ee agai tD ef ntCr &
a ntf
tor s
ai or
a a or
r
ns
enda
um

Fo se a Dee da tW esc se Su l Lie wa ds se wihp eu c b e ty
rtr nd fn n
the tr m us n s s imis d t rj die y nr

o t Cou tsSu r J gme tOr e so J e 1 201 ( E. s1 & 1 ) Fi l
f he r' mmay ud n d r n un 5, 2.D. # 94 95 . na
J gme sf re c De e a twe et r a tre t r d o J 21 201 ( E. 1
ud nt o a h f nd n r he e fe n e e n une , 2 D. #s 96

&1 ) wihrtninof urs cinf d tr nainoffe a c t.
98 , t ee to j idito or eemi to
e s nd oss
Pr ort t tm et teihe D e e ntfl d isM oton f Taxa i ofCos sa
i o he i ha t r f nda ie t
i or
ton
t nd
Fees Pl ntf Harf d fl N otce ofA ppeals ki r e oft Fi Or r of
, ai i f tor ied
i s
ee ng evi w
he nal de s

Di m is e e ed agai tt m by t Cour .The NotcesofAppealw e e fl J y 11,
s s al nt r
ns he
he
t
i
r ied ul

201 ( E. 1 9& 200 .
2.D. #s 9
)
Two days l e ,on Jul 13,201 Def
at r
y
2, endantCr & For t rfl isM oton t
um
s e ied t
i o

Ta Coss( E. 20 i t a u of$1 3 2. whihwa rfre t aM a itae
x t D. # 3) n he mo nt
4,2 42, c s e erd o
gsrt
J geo J y 1 201 ( E. 20 .Th ne tda onJ l 1 201 t M a srt
ud n ul 6, 2 D. # 4) e x y, uy 7, 2,he gitae
J
udge,s s e,ent r d a Or rSt yi D ef
ua pont
e e n de a ng
endantCr & For t r' M oton t Ta
um
se s
i o x

Co t, o rne a trc ncuso oft e c s ona pe l ( E. 207 . c nsde ai n
ss t e w fe o l i n h a e p a . D. # ) No o i r to
w a gi t t m ert oft m oton,norw asCr & For t rgi a opporuniy t
s ven o he
is he
i
um
s e ven n
t t o

-

2-

obe tt t sa TheM a srt J ge' s as eopi onsa ngr s lto ofc t
j c o he ty.
gitae ud s u pont ni tyi e ouin oss
w a appar l bas s mpl upon t gr
s
enty ed i y
he ound t tPl ntf had t ken a a
ha ai if
a
n ppeàlt t
o he
Elvent Cic tCour ofAppe sa t ,i t a lat cour s
e h r ui
t
al nd hat f he ppe l e
t houl r ver t
d e se he

j g nt oft c r fra r a o teis o fe a c t woul te ds p a .
ud me s he ou t o ny e s n,h sue f e s nd oss
d h n ia pe rl
Thi ofcour e de i D ef ndtntCr & For t r w ihouthea i orconsde a i of
s
s prves e t
um
se , t
rng
i r ton
t m e is isr ghtt r quiet Pl ntf t pos a s r edea bond unde t
he rt , t i o e r he ai if o t upe s
s
r he

pr viinsofFe R. v. 62 d i Pli ifwihe asa ofe c i f ra
o so
d. Ci P. ( ) f antf s d ty xe uton o ny
de er i ton ofenttem entt f a cos s.
t m na i
il
o ees nd t
Def
endantW esc t rSur usLi s'cons der i ofis a i ton f bilof
t hes e
pl
ne
i aton t pplca i or l

c ssi t a ntof$1 7 2. 6 ( E. 05 ,fl dJ l 1 201 wa as sa e b
o t n he mou
0, 2 . D. #2 ) ie u y 6, 2, s lo ty d y
3
enty ofa or roft M a s r eJ
r
n de
he gitat udge Gr ntng Pl ntf H a tor sM oton t St
a i
ai if r f d'
i o ay,

o Aug t1 201 ( E. 6 . st wa wi ut ai o c nsdeain o
n us , 2. D. #21 ) Thi oo s t he rng r o i rto f
ho

Dee n W e thetrse ilme t pr tcinf s msa j diae a d tr ne
fnda t sc se ' ntte nto oe to or u d u c td nd eemi d
t be due i afe c i r i ofism oton.
o
t t r onsde aton t
i
On J y 20,201 D ef
ul
2, endantCr & For t fl a M oton f A tor y' Fee
um
ser ied
i or t ne s s

a Nonnd
Taxabl Expe esand Coss s ki an a ountof$281603. i atona y'
e
ns
t, ee ng
m
, 00 n t e s

fe a a a un o $ 08 1 i e ns s( E.# ) whihwa r fre t t
e s nd n mo t f 32, 4.2 n xpe e D. 209, c s e erd o he
Ma itaeo J l 23 2 2( E./ 1 ) Th ne td y onJ y24, 2, antf
gsrt n uy , 01 D. / 0 . e x a , ul 201 Pli if
2

Thea fr a e r t f t El ve h Cic tofcvi a a sdurngt ls l m o h
fim nc ae or he e nt r ui
i l ppe l i he a t z- nt
pe i e e ds 84% .
rod xc e
-

3-

H a tor agai tl a M oton t St cons de a i ofD ef
rf d
n ied
i o ay
i r ton
endant se il m entt coss
' ntte
o t

a fe a t prvalngpat i t a vesyldc s ( E. 7)
nd e s s he e ii ry n he bo -t e ae.D. #21 .
Bef e t Cour now i D e e ntCr & For t r' M oton f Fee and
or he
t
s f nda
um
se s
i or s

Expe e ( E. 09) GldJ l 20, 01 a Plitf Hato d' M oint Sty
ns s D. #2 , e uy 2 2, nd an if rf r s to o a
Res uton ofD ef ntCr & For t ' M oton f Ator
ol i
enda
um
s er s
i or t neys'Feesand N on-axabl
t
e

Ex ns sa Co t ( E. 7)fldAu s 2, 2.
pe e nd ss D. #21 ' ie gu t 201
.
,
LEG A L A NA LY SI
S

The Fi lJ
na udgm e sent ed i t above-t ed c une voc y r er
nt er n he
syl ase qui abl es ve

j idito f rd tr nain o fe a c ss Thsi r ut ,c so r p a tc a i
urs cin o eemi to f e s nd o t. i s o i u tmay r cie nd s
ne
a m a t rt tm us beconsi r d s t a pary w ihi t appealan a r e decii
te ha
t
de e o hat ny t s ng o
dve s
s on
wilknow t a ountofs r edeasbond i wilhave t pos i or rt a y f and
l
he m
upe s
t l
o t n de o ppl or

obanasa o amo tr ud n f rfe a c t.Hee sa we ee e e p irt
ti ty f neayj gme t o e s nd oss r, tys r ntrd ro o
t de e m i i oft am ountt w hi bot Cr & For t ra W es ches e Sum l
he t r naton he
o
ch h um
s e nd
t tr
us

Li w ilbe e il aga ns Pl ntf a f whi h,i Pl ntf desr t havea say,i
nes l
ntted i t ai if nd or c f ai if ies o
t t
m us pos a bond guar nt ng per or anceofisoblgaton t pa t e s s att
t t
a eei
f m
t
i i o y hos um
he
concl i oft appeal
us on he
.

Pu s ntoRul 62.( o t Lo a Rue oft Unie SttsDititCou tfr
rua t e 1A) f he c l ls he td ae src
ro
t Sout r Dit i ofFl i
he
he n srct
or da:
R ULE 62. A PPEAL BO ND S;AU TO M A TI STA Y
1
C

( )Appe Bond,A s pe s d a bo sa ng e c i n of
a
al
u re e s nd tyi xe uto

amone udg nts lbei t a untof11 oft
yj me hal n he mo
0% he
-

4-

j dg n,oprvi sc iyf itr s, o t,a a y
u me tt o de e urt or nee tc ss nd n
awar ofda agesf del y. Upon isown m oton orupon
d
m
or a
t
i
applca i ofapary t Cour m a diec ot wi
i ton
t he
t y r t her se.

( Ext nson o Aut
b) e i f omatcSt y W he Notc o Appe
i a
n ie f
al
Fie I wihi t f u te (4)da pe i etbls e b
ld. f t n he o re n 1 ys rod sa ih d y
Fe r l eo Ci l o e ur 62() apat tlsa yofte
dea Rul f viPr c d e a, ry ie n
h
m otonscont
i
empl ed i Fe r Rul ofCi lPr
at n de al e
vi ocedur
e

( 2() o anotc ofa a,he unls ot r s or r db
6 b, r
ie ppe lt n e s hewie dee y
t Cour,a f t say s lexitf aperod nott exc
he
t urher t hal s or
i
o eed

t ry( 0)da fom t e tyoft j me o o de.The
hit 3 ys r he nr he udg nt r r r
pur e oft s a tonals a i t per i t flng ofa
pos
hi ddii
t y s o m t he ii
s r edeasbond,whi s l be fl by t end oft t ry
upe s
ch ha l ied
he
he hit

( )da peidp o d dh ri
30 y ro r vie een.
Add to ly Rul 6 d)oft Fe e a Ru eofCi lPr e ur ma aest
ii na l, e 2(
he d r l l
vi oc d e nd t he

Co tsa ova ofas pes d a b d frasa of u me whe apa t tke a
ur' ppr l
u re e s on o ty j dg nt n ry a s n
a
ppeal
.
RU LE 62.STA Y O F PR O CEEDI G S TO EN FO R CE A
N
JU DG M EN T

( )Aut matcSty;Exc pto f rI j tons
a
o i a
e ins o n unc i ,
R e ver ps and Pat A c
cei shi ,
ent countngs
i .

Exc pta s at d i t sr e,no e
e s t e n hi ul
xecuton m a i s on a
i
y s ue

j me tno ma pr c e ngsbetk nt e orei, ntl
udg n, r y o e di
a e o nf c tu i
1 da ha pa ed afe isent y.Butunl sst cour
4 ys ve ss
tr t r
e he
t
or r ot m i e,t f l i a enots a afe bei
de s he s he olow ng r
t yed t r ng
e e ed,e i a a ali t n;
nt r
ven f n ppe s ake

( )St y W ih Bond on an Appe l I a a a i t k n, h
d a
t
a . f n ppe l s a e t e
a
ppelantm ay obt n a s a by s s
l
ai t y
uper edea bond,e pti a
s
xce n n

a to de c i d i Ru e62 a( )o ( .Theb ma be
ci n s rbe n l ( ) 1 r 2)
ond y
gi upon ora t flng t notc ofa alora t
ven
fer ii he i e
ppe
fer

-

5-

obt ni t or alow i t a
ai ng he der l ng he ppeal The say t s efec
.
t ake f t
when t cour a ove t bond.
he
t ppr s he

Ru e6 a i st a y a a a eo de r q rngpa n . e v M er Tfc
l 2 pple o n ppe lbl r r e uii yme t Coh n . to. /
'

I s Co.33 Fe Ap x 375 378( d Ci. 09 ( ii Cl v l ndHai Cl c I .v
n . , 4 d. p' , 2 r 20 ) ctng e e a
r i , nc .
ni
Puk,1 4 F. 1 ,1 ( t Ci. 9 ). t pur s i t e u eûha t epr v lngpa t
l 0 3d 23 25 7h r1 97 ) Is po e s o ns r t t h e aii ry
t
w ilr ove i f l i t dec s on s d be afim ed,whie pr ec i t ot sde
l ec r n ul, f he i i houl
fr
l ot tng he her i

agai tt r s t paym entca
ns he ' k hat
i
nnotbe r coupe i t decii s d be r ver ed.' d.
e
d f he
s on houl
e s '1

Ce ti y, tilud ha tedicei ofsa i c nsd rtonofM oto f r
ranl a ra j ge s h srton tyng o ieai
ins o
Fe sa d Co t a e r ofaj dgme t r o i t ei tnc swhe et ea la e
e n ss nd nty
u
nt he e n n hos nsa e
r h ppe lt
i s i ba ed upon a s i ofdecii be w e Cicuis a ca e offr ti pr s on or
s ue s s
plt
s ons t en r t . s
is m e si
s d be sayed pendi a i m i nta l t de s on on a sm iarl i s I i not
houl
t
ng n m ne ppela e cii
i l egal s ue. t s
a a eoft s di c e i how e r f a dit i cour t de a non- eva lng pa t s
n bus
hi s r ton,
ve , or srct
t o ny
pr ii
ry'

moton f s ay wher t non- e lng pary ha notpos ed a s r e
i or t
e he
pr vaii
t s
t
upe s deasbond.
See

Aclu o v dav Maso, 0F.d 1 ,1 66(t Ci. 2)( di t ti wa no
v fNe a . t 67 3 046 0 9h r201 hol ng ha t s t

a a us o dsrto b t dsrc c u tudg t de asa oft e c inofa
n b e f icein y he itit o rj e o ny ty he xe uto
n
a a d ofator y' f eswher t non- e lng pary neiherappeal t awar of
w r
t ne s e
e he
pr vaii
t t
ed he
d
a t ne sf norposed a s r edeasbond i acc da w ih Fe Rul ofCi l
tor y' ees
t
upe s
n or nce t d. e
vi

Pr e ur 62 d )
oc d e ( ).
W ih t i t ntM oton f St Pl ntf H arf d hasnotba ed isr ques t t
t he ns a
i or ay, ai if tor
s t e
t o he
M agitat f a say on any oft dicr tonar f or ,nor i
s r e or t
he s e i y act s
, ndeed upon any f ct
a or
ot rt t ti fl aN otce ofAppeal o gr
he han ha t ied
i
.N
ounds orr onsf t exe cie of
eas
or he r s
-

6-

dicr i f t gr i oft sa have be m ade by Pl i if Pl ntf i as ng t
s eton or he antng he t y
en
a ntf
ai if s ki he

Cour t e r s a dicr i bas upon not ng m or t n t flng ofa Notce of
t o xe cie s eton ed
hi
e ha he ii
i
Appeal Thi i nots fci nt
. ss
ufi e .
I t d,Pl ntf r i upon unpubls or sofs a e er i t Sout n
ns ea
ai if eles
ihed der
t ys nt ed n he
her

Dit i ofFl i by ot rU . M agi ta esoft sD it i ,asw el asunpubls
srct
orda
he S.
sr t
hi srct
l
ihed
or r ofdit i cours i Okl
de s
srct
t n
ahom a a Ilnoi ,wher n de e m i ton off a coss
nd li s
ei t r na i
ees nd t
ha bee def r ed untluli a e deci i by t El nt Cicui Cour ofA ppe s on
s n er
i tm t
son
he eve h r t
t
al
Fi J
nal udgm e s See M orrs v YTB 1 ' I ,N os.08nt .
ion .
ntl nc.
.
565GPM ,08579GPM ,

1 - - , 0 WL 1 311 ( D. 1. y23 201 ) Gau irv Jo s No.
0 305 GPM 201
9 27 S. 11 Ma , 0 ; te . ne ,
C1 08 4 - 200 W L 29 3 ( . Okl Se . 20 ) Mo rsv Arz Be . .
V- - 45 C, 9
29 38 W D. a. pt 9, 09 ; r i . i. v Co
LLC, 0 60 07- 20 W L 5 449 ( D. a J l 26, 006 ; d rStyi
No. 3- 9 CV, 05
5 58 S. Fl . u . 2 ) Or e a ng

Moint Ta Coss Ha fo d(5:I s Co. .Ci o r ho ,
to o x t, r r 7 , n . v t fMa at n
,
y
ht i/c . d. c hsgov d c10 11 2 6 ( D. a J n. 201 (
tps/e fos us ou . / o / 51 0 439 2 S. Fl . a 4, 2) No.
I I 7 CI KI M CALI
O- OO7 - V- NG/
LEY, v ia eonPACER a D. #9 . Co r d s
a a lbl
t E. 6) The u t oe
notfnd pe s i any oft cas s cie by Pl ntf ,asnoneoft cas r l a sngl
i
r uas ve
he e t d
ai if
he es etect i e

i t ncew her t c tconsder w hy a dicr i y say s d be e e ed,a eac
ns a
e he our
i ed
s etonar t houl
nt r
nd h
ca e onl s a esasgr
s
y tt
oundsf a sa a one-ort lne e anaton t td...a a
or t y
wo-i xpl i ha ç n ppeal
ha bee fl ....'
s n ied
'
A ccor ngl t Cour GndsPl ntf M oton f St y ofcons de a i of
di y, he
t
ai ifs
i or a
i r ton

ator y' f a cos sprort t e f and cos shavi be cons der
t ne s ees nd t i o hos ees
t
ng en
i ed,

-

7-

d tr ne a j gme e tr dt beprmaur .I vi ae ted pr c s of1w
eemi d, nd ud nt nee o
e t e t olts h ue o e s a
r q rdun rtepr e r sofFe R. v. 6 d)frteposi ofs pes de s
e uie de h oc du e
d. Ci P. 2( o h tng u re a
bonds i t a
f he ppealng pary w ihesa s a
i
t s
t y.
A fe t M agi ta e J
tr he
sr t udge ha r ed upon t out t ndi M otonsf Feesa
s ul
he s a ng
i
or
nd

Coss,pur uantt t Or oft sCour ofRef enc Pl ntf m a t m ove f a
t
s
o he der hi
t
er e, ai if y hen
or

sa ofs c mo tr ud n,et rbypo tngabo i t a ntof1 0pec nta
ty u h neayj gme t i
he
si
nd n he mou
1 re s
r quied by t LocalRul ,orm ovi f a say pe ng appealofpa entoft
e r
he
es
ng or t
ndi
ym
he

j g n a r o fe a c t.
ud me t wad f e s nd oss
C O N CLU SIO N

I ul ngi aprs int tt u me t a dimis l byt sCo r, fe a
nd gi n e umpto ha hej dg ns nd s sas hi u tatr
t oughl ltgat and i ensvel bref a a gued c e by ver e renc l w yer
hor
y ii ed
nt i y i ed nd r
as
y xpe i ed a
s

ma berves d,sno s sce t j siyde i ngaprvaln pa t oft
y e re i t uf into u tf prvi
e iig ry he
de er i ton ofis e il e t f s a cos sand t pr e i ofa s r edeas
t m na i
t nttem nt o ee nd t
he ot cton
upe s
bond. A c di y,i i he e O R DERED ,A DJUD G ED and D EC REED asf l
cor ngl t s r by
olows:
1.

Pl ntf Harf d A cci nta I m niy Compa sM oton t St
ai i f tor
de nd nde t
ny'
i o ay
Res uton ofDef ntCr & For t Speci ly I ur nce Com pany'
ol i
enda
um
ser
a t ns a
s

M oton f rAto e 'Fe sa d Co t ( E. 7 be a t s m ei
i o t m ys e n ss D. #21 ) , nd he a s

he e DENI wiho pr j c t r -ieaM o in f rSty a d
r by
ED t ut e udi e o e fl
to o a n
Appr
ovalofa Super e
s deasBond,aferator
t t neys f a c t havebee
' ees nd os s
n
s by t M agita e J
et he
sr t udge a a oved by t sCour .
nd ppr
hi
t

-

8-

TheOr e Sty n De e a tCr & Fo se ' M o in t Ta Coss( E.
d r a i g f nd n um
rtr s to o x t D.
# 7 a t eOr rSty ngDe e a tW e the trsM o i n f rBil
20 ) nd h de a i
f nd n sc se ' to o l of

Co t ( E. 6 be a d t s mea eh r b VACATED.The
ss D. #21 ) , n he a r e e y
M agi tat Judge s lcons der a m ake a Re ta Recom m e i
sr e
hal
i , nd
por nd
ndaton

on t M oton t Ta Cos sand t M oton f BilofCos sr f r ed f
he
i o x
t
he
i or l
t e e r or

s c c nsde ai n b t sCou tsprorOr e s( E. 20 20 a 20 )
u h o i r to y hi r' i d r D. #s 3, 5 nd 9 .
3.

The M oton by Pl ntf Harf d Acci nta I
i
ai if tor
de nd ndem niy Com pa s
t
ny'
M oton f an A dtii l20 da t Res
i or
ltona
ys o pond t t r pectve m otonsby
o he es i
i
D ef nda sCr & For t a W e t t r Sum l Li M otonsf
e nt um
ser nd s ches e
us nes
i
or

Fe sa Coss( E. 7 b a t e s mei h r by GR ANTED.
e nd t D. #21 ) e nd h a s e e
Pl ntf s lha untlFrday,A ugus 31,201 w ihi w hi t r pond
ai if hal ve i i
t
2 t n
ch o es

t s i mo i ns De e ntCr m & Fo se wilha tn ( 0 da fo
o a d to . fnda u
r tr l ve e 1 ) ys r m
t dat oft Re pons t tl isRe y.
he e he s
e o i e t pl
D ON E A ND O RD ER ED i Cha ber a t J m esLawr
n
m s t he a
ence K i Fede al
ng
r

J tce Buidi and Unied St esCourhous M i m i Fl i ,t s 1 h da ofAugus ,
us i
l ng
t
at
t e, a , orda hi 3t y
t
201
2.

(

W

y.. ,
'
e
z,*
e
'

'

'

M ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
,
,
I
TED STATES D I
STRI
CT
GE
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF F RI
CT
DA

-

9-

Copi f ni hed t
es ur s
o:
M agit e Judge Chri M .M c ll y
s rat
s
A ie

Co e fo Ha lo d
uns l r rf r t
Mi
guelA ngelBri l Es
zue a, q.
Ta orVe P. .
yl
ga, A
2555 Ponce De Leon Boul r
eva d
Suie 220
t
Cor G a es, 33134
al bl FL

Emalmb iuea a lr e a.o
i: rz l@tyo v g c m
El ne W ihers
ai
t
poon,Es
q.
V e na,La r e,& Pi c t l,P. .
zi
w enc
s ieli A
121A l
hambr Pl a
a az
Suie 1604
t
Cor Gabl ,FL 33l
al
es
34

Emal e te s on vl a c
i: wih rpo @ plw,om
Ti ot Shane Tayl ,Es
m hy
or q.
Tayl V ega,P. .
or
A
1 1A l m br Pl za
2
ha a a
Suie 1604
t
Cor Gabl ,FL 331
al
es
34

Emalta lr a o v ga.o
i;tyo @tylr e c m
Co efo Cr m * Fo se :
uns l r u
r tr
H oly S.H ar y,Es
l
ve
q.
Thor on Da s& Fe n
nt
vi
i
Brc lBa Vi w Cent e
i kel y e
r
80 SW 8t Ste
h r et
Suie 2900
t
M i i FL 331
am ,
30

Emalhav y@t l w.o
i: r e dta c m

-

1
0-

Mi
chaelChar esG or
l
don,Es
q.
Thor on,Da s& Fe n,P. .
nt
vi
i A
80 SW 8t St e
h r et
Suic 2900
t
M i i FL 331
am ,
30

Emalg d
i: oron@tta c m
dl w.o
Cou s l rWe the tr
n efo sc se l
A aron B.Til y,Es
le
q.
Cozen O'
Connor
45 Br
oadwa
y
28 h Fl
t oor
Ne Y or NY 1
w
k,
0006

Emalaily@ c z n.om
i: tle o e c
Anaysa G alardo,Es
l
q.
Coz O'
en Connor
200 S B ica Boul d
s yne
evar
Suie 441
t
0
M i i FL 331
am ,
31

Emal a l r o@c e c m
i: gal d oz n.o
a
Br
yan P.Vezey,Es
q.
Cozen O'
Connor
1 M cKi y St e
221
nne r et
One Hous on Cent Suie 2900
t
er t
H ous on,TX 7701
t
0

Emalb z y@ c z n.om
i: ve e o e c
Jos
eph A .Zi i ki Es
em ans , q.
Coz O'
en Connor
1 M cKi y Stee
221
nne r t
One H ous on Ce erSuie 2900
t
nt
t
Houson,TX 7701
t
0

Emalj imins @ c e c m
i:ze a ki oz n,o

-

11-

Ri
chard M i
chaelDunn,Es
q.
Coze O'
n Connor
200 S Bica Boul d
s yne
evar
Suie441
t
0
M i i FL 331
am ,
31

Emalr un oz n.o
i: d n@c e c m

-

1
2-