Hartford Casualty Insurance Company v. Crum & Forster Specialty Insurance Company

Filing 223

ORDER Denying and Striking 220 Motion Post Judgment Discovery. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/16/2012. (jw)

UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRICT CO URT
SO UTH ER N D I
STR I O F FLO R I A
CT
D
M I M IDIVI
A
SION
CA SE NO .1024590- V- l
CI K NG
HA RTFORD ACCI
DENT AND I DEM NI
N
TY
COM PAN Y,a f ei c por i asequia e
or gn or aton,
t bl
s oge and r pary i i e es on be fof
ubr e
eal t n nt r t
hal
M il r& Sol on G e alContac or ,l ,
le
om
ner
r t s nc.
Pl ntf ,
ai if

CRUM & FO RSTER SPECI LTY I SUM N CE
A
N
COM PANY ,a f ei com or ton,
or gn
ai
Def nt
enda .
/

HARTFORD ACCI ENT A ND I EM NI
D
ND
TY
COM PANY ,a f ei cor a i asequiabl
or gn por ton,
t e
s ogee a r pa t i i er ton behal of
ubr
nd eal ry n nt es
f
M il & Sol on Gene alCont a or ,l ,
ler
om
r
r ct s nc.
Pl ntf ,
ai if

W ESTCHESTER SU RPLU S LI ES I SUM N CE
N
N
COM PANY ,a f ei cor aton,
or gn por i
D ef nda .
e nt

O R DER DEN YI A ND STRI I G
NG
K N
PLA I TIFF' M OTI N FO R PO STN
S
O
JUD G M ENT D I
SCO V ER Y
Pl ntf ate ptt add a ltga i di cove y el m e t t Cour '
ai i ps t m o
ii ton s
r e nt o he
ts

c sd r to ofpo tj dg n f e a c t i n ihe pemitd no a o it a t s
on i e a in
s-u me t e s nd oss s et r r te r ppr pra e t hi
sa eoft epr c e n i t a ve syld c s .Pos-ud ntmo i nsf f e a
tg h o e di gs n he bo -t e a e
t gme
j
to or e s nd

c t by pr lng pary,w her n a a
oss
evaii
t
ei n ppealhas been t n,m ay be accom pani by s h
ake
ed
uc
e a ton and ar e ast m ovantf el i a opra e f t Cour' cons der ton.
xpl na i
gum nt he
e s s ppr i t or he
ts
i ai
Shoul i be desr bl orhel ul t m ovi pary m a atach t a tm el m oton f f
dt
ia e
pf , he
ng t y t
o i y
i or ees
and c t s afi t orot rs i sons ofe
os s uch fdavis
he ubm s i
xper opi on by compet ntl
t ni
e awye s
r
tyi sm iarltga i ast t r s
r ng i l ii ton o he ea onablnes oft f .
e s he ees

Tot s t o osng p ry( antf he en)s ul r s ndwih isb if
hi,he pp i a t Pli if r i ho d e po
t t re

rg r nga yo j cin ima h vet t moin, c ompa e bys c atda t o
e adi n be to t y a o he to a c
nid u h fs vis r
ot l a hortest ti m a w ih t pr ent i udi opi onsofs e rs as
her egal ut ii ha t y s o es , ncl ng ni
uch xpe t
t y deem appr i e t t i s Folow i t s t m ovi pa t m a r y i t
he
oprat o he s ue. l ng hi , he
ng ry y epl f he
Cour s alows.
to l
The Cour t pr dst acons der i a de er i ton oft i s off
t hen ocee o
i aton nd t m na i
he s ue ees
a cossbas d upon t w rten s i sons,ori he ors s d s el t or
nd t
e
he it ubm s i
f
he houl o ec , al

ag me ta he rng.Thediceinho v r i ttlyve td i t p e i ngj get
r u n nd ai
srto we e ,s oal se n he r sdi ud o
r at a de er i t pr s w her by t si s i r ol l J tce Pow el'
egul e nd t m ne he oce s
e hi s ue s es ved. us i
ls

d cso i He ly v Ec e h t 461U . 4 ( 9 3) r s v st is r ie he en
e ii n n nse . k r ar,
S. 24 1 8 , e ole he s ue as d r i
w ih pr s on a cl iy:
t ecii nd art
1A r ques f a t ne s f ss
k e
t or tor y' ee houl notr s ti a s
d
e ul n econd

maorltg to l al ofc re ltga swil etete
j iiain. de l
y, ous , ii nt ls tl h
am ountofa f W he e s tl enti notpos i e,t f e
ee.
r e tem
s
s bl he e
1 Theau hort oft J
t iy he udge t r gult t mec ni soff ea i tonsi cea . Se
s o e a e he
ha c
e pplca i s l r e

I7/ v Ne Ha hr De . fEmply n , 5U.. 5 U. 4 ( 9 2 ) gho v
'7/ . w mps ie pto
1 :
o me t45 S 4 5 S. 45 1 8 ) Kni tn .
Wakn , 6F.d 7 (tCi.1 8 ) Br wnv Ci o l to, 1F.d 1 2 ( 1hCi. 98 )
tis 61 2 95 5b r 9 0 ; o . t fpamet 68 2 3 5 1 t r 1 2 ;
y
Zakamav MountSi Me Ce e ,906F.d645( 1bCi.1 .
l
.
nai d ntr
2
1 t r 990)
2

a i antbear t bur ofesabls ng entte e t an
pplc
s he den
t ihi
ilm nt o
awar and docum entng t a opra e hour expended a
d
i he ppr i t
s
nd
houry r es
l at .
* # # #

W e r phasze t t di ti cour ha di c e i i
eem
i hat he srct
t s s r ton n
de e m i ng t am ountofa f e awar '
t r ni he
e
d.'
l i t r or
t s he ef e,

O RDER ED ,AD JU DG ED ,and DECREED t t Pl ntf sM oton t
hat he ai if
i o

c nd t s-u me tdic eyo t svea Dee a t'moi f at ne sfes
o uc po tj dg n sov r n he e rl fnd ns tons or tor y' e
a c t ( E. 22 and 22 1 b a t es mea ehe e DENI a
nd oss D. #s 0
0- ) e nd h a r r by
ED nd
STRI KEN fom t r d.
C
r he ecor
DO N E AND O RD ER ED i Cham be sa t J m esLawr
n
r t he a
ence K i Feder
ng
al
J tce Buidi and U nied St t Courhous M i i Fl i t s 1 h da ofAugus ,
us i
l ng
t
a es
t e, am , or da, hi 6t y
t
201
2.

'

.

J ES LA W REN CE KI G
A
N
'
I
TED STATES DI
STRI J
CT U
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI OF FL
CT

M agi tat J
s r e udge ChrsM . c ll y
i
M A ie
A1c
1 ouns ofr d
el ecor

N.

E
DA