Hartford Casualty Insurance Company v. Crum & Forster Specialty Insurance Company

Filing 237

ORDER Determining Attorney Fees Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 11/15/2012. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES DI
STRICT CO U RT
SO UTH ERN DI
STRI O F FLO RI A
CT
D
M I IDIVI O N
AM
SI
CASE NO .1 24590- V - I
0CI K NG
HA RTFORD ACCI ENT A ND I EM NI
D
ND
TY
COM PAN Y ,a f ei cor a i asequia e
or gn por ton,
t bl
s ogee a r pary i i er ton behal of
ubr
nd eal t n nt es
f
M il r& Sol on G e r Cont ac or I ,
le
om
ne al
r t s, nc.
Pl i if
antf,

CRUM & FO RSTER SPECI LTY I SURAN CE
A
N
COM PANY ,a f ei c por ton,
or gn or a i
Def
endant
.
/
O R DER D ETERM I N G ATTOR NEY K FEES
NI

TH I M A TTER c esbef e t Courtupon D e e
S
om
or he
f ndantCr & For t
um
ser

Sp cal l s a c Co ny' (i um & Fortr' M o i f rAto ne sFe s
e i t n ur n e mpa s s
y
cr
se ' ton o t r y' e ,
)
Ex ns sa Coss p s ntt S. . a. c lRue 7. a a Fl . a . 7 79.
pe e nd t, urua o D Fl Lo a l 3( ) nd a Stt j 68. 1
1 PRO CED UR AL BA CK G R OU ND
.

Pl itf Ha tor Ac i nta l de t Compa y (sl rf d' c mme e t i
an if rf d cde nd n mniy
n i- tor ' o nc d h s
la
)
acton ast pur t e t bl s oge ofM il r& Sol on G e r Contact s,
i
he pored quia e ubr e
le
om
ne al
r or
l ,t r overa t ne s f s a e
nc. o ec
tor y' ee nd xpens st twer gener t by H a tor i de e ng
e ha
e
a ed
r f d n f ndi

1 Thema trha bee f l bre e wih t flng ofPl ntf Harf d Ac i a
te s n uly i f d t he ii
ai if tor cdent nd

l mniyCompa sRe pons tldAugus 31 201 ( E. a Cr & FortrsRe y
nde t
ny' s e ie
t , 2 D. 226) nd um
se ' pl
Memorndum fldSe e
a
ie ptmber24, 2( E. .
201 D. 233)

M ilr& Sol on i a s r t underyi l s ti vi t consr i oft
le
om
n epa a e,
l ng aw ui nvol ng he
tucton he

Ocea Gr nde Condom i um . Cr & For t rans ed and count cl m ed f
n a
ni
um
se
wer
er ai
or

de lrtr rle ( E. ) rua tt Fl Sa. 7 79, um & Fo se s r e
caaoy eif D. 41.Pu s n o a. ttj 68. Cr
rtr e v d
Ha tor wih ap opo a f s tlme tonDe e r1 2 1( E. 9- ) Aft
rf d t r s l or ete n
c mbe , 01 D. 20 1 . t r
ext ns ve bretng and or a gum e on t s ver M otonsf Sum m a y J
e i
ii
al r
nt he e al i
or
r udgm e by
nt
t r pec i pari durng M ay 201 t sCour gr ed Cr & For t ' M oton f
he es tve tes i
2, hi
t ant
um
s er s
i or
Sum m ar J
y udgm e Agai tH a tor on J 15,201 Thi w a f l ed by enty ofa
nt
ns r f d
une
2. s s olow
r

Fi a J dg nti f vo o Cr m & Fo se o J ne21 2 2 ( . 1 )
n l u me n a r f u
rt r n u
, 01 D E. 98 .
Th sVe iid M o i f rF e a Coss( E. 9)wa fld b Cr m & Fo se
i rfe
ton o e s nd t D. 20
s ie y u
r tr
on J y 20,201
ul
2.

Def
endantsM oton s ksr
'
i ee ecove yof$281603. asr as
r
, 00 e onabl at ne sfes
e tor y' e

pl n -a a ee pe s sa d c t f a a dii a $3 0 4.2 ( az rAf .D.
us on t x bl x n e n oss or n d ton l 2,8 1 Glt e f, E.

2 )
09 .
I DI
I. SCU SSI N
O

Fl i s Of e ofJudgm e St ut alows a pr vaii pary t s f t expense
orda' f r
nt at e l
e lng t o hit he
s

ofltgaint tepat t trj csara on beo fr FlrdaSttt j7 7 p o de
ii to o h ry ha ee t e s a l fe . o i aue 68.9 r vi s
i r evantpa t
n el
r:

$I any ci lacton f dam agesfl d i t cours oft s
$n
vi i or
ie n he
t
hi

sa e i ade e ntflsa o f rof u me twhih i n t
tt , f fnda ie n fe j dg n c s o
acc pt by t pl ntf w ihi 30 days,t def ndants l
e ed
he ai if t n
he e
hal

b e tte t r c r(t)r a o bl c ssa at r e sf e
e n ild o e ove is e s na e o t nd to n y' e s
fom t daeoftlng o t o f ri t j gme i o
r he t si f he fe f he ud nt s ne
. . .

-

2-

ofnola lt o t j g n o t i dbyt epli tf i a
ibiiy r he ud me t b ane
h a n if s t
l s 25 pe ce l st n s of er...'
ea t
r nt es ha uch f
'

Thi expe e s fi i des gned t encour s tem e ofdi put wihoutt
s
ns hitng s i
o
age etl nt
s es t
he
nec st ofha ng t r ortt cour r ol i
es iy
vi o es o
t es uton.

TheElv n h Cic tha c sse ty h dt tFlrdaStt t j768.9 i
e e t r ui s on it n l el ha o i au e
7 s
s t i l w i di r iy c esand i a i abl t c ai sbas d on sat l t tar
ubsantve a n ve st as
s pplc e o l m
e
t e aw ha e

tldi fd r lc r.S eMe c s v Ak r nS ntr t53 F. d 11 1 50( 1h
se n e ea ou t e n hie . ema e eht, 2 3 46, 1 l t
Ci. 00 ) Ho o thv Dimo
r 2 8 ; r wic . a ndAic a I du tis I .6 F. d 1 4,l 8( 1h
rrh n sre , nc, 45 3 25 25 l t
Ci. 01 ) J e v Uni d S c Ali e LLC,4 F. 1 06,1 09( 1h Ci. 07 .
r 2 1 ; on s . t pa e l ,
e
anc
94 3d 3
3 1 t r 20 )
Se Egwuat v.Bur i on CoatFact y War
e
u
lngt
or
ehous Cor ,No.8: 0- e p.
1 CV 996,2011W L

3 93 7, t* ( . . a. g. 201 )( a n ifIa ef t d e a ' r a o bl
7 45 a 2 M D Fl Au 25 1 pli tf ibl or he efnd nt e s na e
s
at ne ' e 'n u r d fo t edaeo t Pr p a f rSete e ' ; are v. me
tor ys f e ' c re r m h t f he o os l o tlm nt) Ch ls Ho
i
'
De , 0 61 07- V , 01 W ' 1 73 ,a #1( D. a M a c 1 2 1
potNo. 9- 9 CI 2 1 L 32 41 t S. Fl . r h 7, 01 )
( e e da te ildt r c vt at r e s f e fom pli tf ba e onpl itf f iu et
d f n n ntte o e o r to n y ' e s r
a n if s d
an ifs al r o

a c pts tlme o f rs r e und rFl rdaStt t j 7 79 .
c e ete nt fe e v d c o i au e 68. )

Ha to dtke alga poston i iso sto t t e a plc biiy o j 7 79
rf r a s e l ii n t ppo ii n o h p ia lt f 68.
c n e di t s tlme û. . si a i a dt r f r u nf r e bl b c u e: a t
o t n ng he ete nt $ . i nv ld n he e o e ne o c a e e a s ( ) hc

pr po a f rs tlme tf lsou sdet p viw ofj768.9 oft Fl i S a u e ; nd
o s l o ete n a l ti he ur e
7
he orda t t t s a
( )t p o a f rs tlme ti t o a g oust b e o c a e. Pli tf lg l
b he r pos l o ete n s o mbi u o e nf r e bl ' an ifs e a
'
a ysi i bas upon a i e r t i t tisorgi Com pl nti nota ci lac i f
nal s s ed
n nt m e aton ha t i nal
ai s
vi ton or

da g sa r q r dbyt Ofe ofJ dgme tS au e( E. 6) Ha tor a gu st t
ma e s e uie
he f r u
n t tt D. 22 . rf d r e ha
-

3-

t i tn c s i nomor ta a a to f rd caaoyj me .Plitf rle u
he nsa t a e s
e h n n cin o e lrtr udg nt anif eis pon
s a e cas wher Fl i courshave hel t tpa tcul pr eedi
tt
es
e orda
t
d ha r i ar oc ngs,s asf f t e
uch or eiur
a w ilr vocaton,w er notc vi ac i f da agesundert St t e.
nd l e
i
e
i l tons or m
he aut z

Dee n Cr & Fo se ctsNes v Ma ieGr p o m Be c / c, 7
fnda t um
rtr ie lon . rn ou fpal a h, n .67
So. d99 ( a DitCtAp 1 6 i o osto
2 8 Fl. s. . p. 99 ) n pp iin.
l Nel Fl i sFourh Dit i tCour ofAppeal f
n son. orda'
t sr c
t
s ound t tt O f e of
ha he f r

J dg ntSauec na yt ade lrtr j me . r ,heb e ofay c t
u me ttt a ppl o ca aoy udg ntThee t uy r
ah
appe e a deci on and a ar ofator sf i f
al d
si
w d
t ney' ees n avoroft yachtsbr rand s l
he
' oke
eler
arsng fom a br
ii r
each ofa pur has contac .The cour r as
c e
r t
t e oned t talhough t acton
ha t
he i

wa br u ta arqu s f de lrtr j dg n,her a is ewa a e c o dd p i
s o gh s e e t or caaoy u me tt e lsu s n s r we e ost
o lq dae d ma sa d t a ,he e o e Fl . a , 7 7 a ple
f iui t d a ge n h t t r f r , a Stt j 68.9 p id.
Ast sCourtexpl ned i isFi Sum m a y J
hi
ai
n t nal
r udgm ent3t i t cas i a
, he ns ant e s

c nta tdip ec tole byt etr ofade e ea r e n c nta t (heDe e e
o r c s ut on r ld h e ms
fns g e me t o r c4 t
fns
2 Fore mpl Ro adov Bi uc 8 So.2d 1l1 ( a. h DCA 2002)(i ngt t
xa e, s
. el h, 27
5 Fl 4t
fndi ha
f f t e a ton,a a i r m pr ee ng,i notaci la ton f da a be us ispu pos
oreiur c i s n n e
oc di s
vi c i or m ges ca e t r e

wa t dee miei e et i auni epiceofpr ry ;Milrv. yman, So. 111
s o tr n ntr ss n
qu e
opet) le Ha
766 2d 6
( a. hDCA 20 ( di t Fl i Stt ej768. i nota i bl t wilrvoc ton
Fl 4t
00) hol ng hat orda aut
79 s pplca e o l e ai
p o e dn s; n Na ' l d m. .fteS v Co s l I s S r s, 78S 2 4 4 4 ( a 4t
r c e ig ) a d tl n e Co o h . . n o . n . e v . 7 O. d 0 , 08 Fl. h
.
DCA 2001 (i ngt tFl i St ut j7 79di nota ywheet ralis i t ca e
) fndi ha orda at e 68. d
ppl
r he e sue n he s
wa i urnc c rgef anundel ngtr a ton)
s ns a e ovea or
ryi o t ci
3 ( E. 95a 1 .
D. #1 t 5)
4 Ha tor scli a i tCr & For t r lt t t consr ton ofaco
rf d' a ms gans um
ser ea e o he
tuci
ndomi um .
ni

M &S sr dast ge r c rcorf t prj tHa tor ass ey,is pa me a
eve he neal onta t or he oec. rf d, urt sued y nt nd
pe f
ronnanc bondsf t prj c onbe l ofM &S.Cr & Foseris dage a la lt
e
or he o e t
haf
um
rt s ue
nerl ibiiy
po iy t M &S f r2003. rHuri a W imai Oc obe of2005, &S wass d f r
lc o
o
Ahe
rc ne l n t r
M
ue o

c n tu to d fcsr ltd t tep oe t Hato drs o d du d ri b n , n r q e tdt a
o sr cin ee t eae o h rj c. rf r e p n e n e t o d a d e u se h t
s
-

4-

Age me t.nCou tlofisc mplit Ha tor ake t Cou tfriudg n a is
re n) l
n
t o an , rf d s d he r o j me t gan t
Cr & Fort and i Harf d' f vor..i t amountof$1478, 69 .. aswel as
um
ser
n tor s a
. n he
, 839. .,
l

pr-u gme i ee t' I co t1 ofisc mplitHato da ke t Cou tfr
ej d ntntrs.s n un 1 t o an, rfr s d he r o
'

ûu gme ta i tCr m & Fo se / rd ma si tea un of$ 9, 9. pl pe
j d n gans u
rtr l a ge n h mo t 73 41 85 us rj dg n itr s,e s n bl c t, nda yf te r le ta ti Co tde msprpe
u me t neetr a o a e oss a n urh r eif h t hs ur e
o r
a dj t' Th r fr,t Cou tfn t ttei tn c s i acvia to frd ma e ,t
n us.6 e eoe he r ids ha h nsa t a e s i l cin o a g s o
'
whi t O f e ofJ
ch he f r udgm entSt ut a i s.
at e pple
Harf d a s a gues t tCr & Foser scount r ai do nots a e a ci lacton
tor l o r
ha um
t '
e cl ms
tt
vi i

f da age ; Harf d ciesno aut iy s
or m s.
tor t
hort ugges i t underFl i l ,a def ndants
tng hat
orda aw
e
'

c un e camsc n r mo a a to fo t epu v e ofj7687
o tr li a e ve n ci n r m h r iw
.9.

Th èo tt rf ec ncud st t rfr sfiur t a c p Cr & Fortrs
e ur heeor o l e ha Hato d' al e o c e t um
se'
De ber 1 201lPr
cem
,
oposalf Se tem ent coupl w ih t uli at det m i ton by
or tl
,
ed t he tm e er na i
t Cour i f vorofCr & For t ri is Fi Judgm entofJ 21,201 t Fl
he
tn a
um
s e n t nal
une
2, hat a.

Stt j76 7 d e gov r t me isoft spo to oft eM o i n f Fe sa Coss
a. 8.9 o s e n he rt hi rin h
to or e nd t ,

Cr & Fort ri emniy a de e M & S. n 2007.c
um
se nd
f nd f nd
l
ouns f t pari entr ade e e
el or he tes e ed
f ns
ag e ntco r c ,wher by Cr & Fo se c e edt c
r eme
nta t
e
um
r t r ons nt o ouns f rHarf d' c i d
el o
tor s ontnue
de e e o M & S. a e m e tpr de f rce t n ltga i gui elnest twoul gove n
f ns f
The gr e n ovi d o rai ii ton d i ha
d
r
M &S' def e.
s ens

5 ( E.1a 6)
D. t .

6 ( E.1a 7)(
D. t empha i a )
ss dded .
7 ( E. a 5)
D. 226 t .
-

5-

Def ntCr & For t r i entted t r overisr onabl atom e sf esand coss
enda
um
s e s il o ec
t eas
e t y' e
t
i r f om D e ber 1 2011.
ncur ed r
cem
,
A. Loads ar A pplc i
t
i aton.

' orda hasadopt t f r ll s a appr h ast f
' i
Fl
ed he ede a ode t r
oac
he ounda i f se tng
ton or ti

r onabl f awar 'Egwuat v.Burln on CoatFact y W ar
eas
e ee
ds.
'
u
igt
or
ehou Cor ,N o.8: 0se p.
1

CV- 6, 011W L 37 45 a # 3( . Fl .
99 2
93 7, t M D. a Aug. 2 1 ( ii St nd d Gu a y
25 01 ) ctng a ar ar nt

l s Co. . a sr 55 So. d8 ( a 1 0).' d tnniet la tr t
n . v Qu n tom, 5 2 28 FI. 99 ) ' ee n he o dsa ,he
To
r ona e houry r t i m uli i by t am ountofhour r s
eas bl
l a e s tpled
he
s ea onabl e nded on t
y xpe
he

li to 'Pr e tv LfeIs Co v Wale , 8: - 3 ,2 1 W' 1 496 0, t#
igain. otcie
t
'
n . . . k r No. 09CV- 63 0 0 L 9 2 a
2 ( . Fl M a 1 2 1 )( ii Fl i Pate t Co n atonFu d v Rowe 47
M D. a. y 4, 0 0 ctng orda in ' mpe s i
s
n .
, 2
So. l 45,11 1( a.l 5 .' r a o bl ho l r t i t p e ii ma k tr t i
2d 1
5 F1 98 ) ' e s na e ury ae s he r va l
A
ng r e a e n
t r eva l c m uniy f sm ia s vi by I wye sofr onabl c
he el nt egal om
t or i l r er ces a r
eas
y ompar e
abl

s ls e ein e a drp ain.No ma v Hou igAut rt O / o nt r
kil, xp re c , n e utto ' r n . sn ho i /C/P fMo gomey,
'
y
.
8 6 F. 1 92,1 9 ( 1h Ci.1 8 .' d n eofr tsma b a uc t r ug d r c
3 2d 7 29 1 t r 98 ) ' e c
Evi
ae y e dd ed h o h ie t
e de ofc gesby lw yer unde s m ia cic s a
vi nce har
a
s
r i lr r um t ncesorby opi on e denc '1
ni vi e. d.
'
Cr & For t ata
um
s er t chesher n asExhi t' ' t A f i vi ofis f e r
ei
bi ' ' he fda t t ee xpe t
D ,
Phii G l zer Es M r G lt i a pa t rw ih t M i i Fl i l w fr M ar ow ,
lp at , q. . a zer s
rne t he am , orda a im
l
Conne l Abr s,Adl New m an & Le i ,P. . a f m e l a parne a H i m ih,
l. am
er.
w s A , nd or ry
t r t ghs t
St
raus and G l zer,P. .M r. l zerw asadm it t t Fl i Ba i 1
s
at
A
G at
ted o he orda r n 978,a f
nd or

t pas t ry yea s hi pr i ha bee devot al os excl i y t i ur nce r at
he t hit
r , s actce s n
ed m t
usvel o ns a
el ed

-

6-

l i ai n matr , n l ng i ur n ec ve a e l i a i ( fd vi ofPhii Glt e a !
i g to te s i cudi ns a c o r g i g ton. Afi a t
t
t
lp az r t (

Ass tf t i hi A f
e orh n s sdavi,t houry r t scha ged by Cr & For t ' counsel
t he
l ae
r
um
sers
a pa al si t scas a e r onabl and i lnew ih t cusom ar r t cha ged by
nd r egal n hi
e r eas
e
n i
t he t
y a es r

i ur nc d f ns lw tr i M imi Fl i a' (d. t 6)Mr Glt e f te o ne
ns a e e e e a sms n a , ord . I a !
. az r urh r pi s
t tt t alnumberofhour c ai ed by Thor on,Davi & Fei P. .i connecton
ha he ot
s lm
nt
s
n, A n
i

wiht de e eofCr & Fo se (o t p ro De e r1 2 1t o gh J ne21
t he fns
um
rt r f r he e id c mbe , 01 hr u u
,
2 1 )Sse tr l r a o bl i lg to t e t nsvelbo r q r dt c mplt t lga
0 2 s n iey e s na e n ih f he x e i a r e uie o o e e he e l
i

ts i ol d. (d. t ! a 6)
a ks nv ve ' I a T3 nd .
'
The Cour ac st exper opi on ofM r G l zeras a c r tand pr
t cept he
t ni
. at
or ec
oper
opi on upon whi t Cour ca r y i de e m i ng t i s pr ent by t s M oton.
ni
ch he
t n el n t r ni he s ues es ed
hi
i

Hator ha s csco j cinst Crm & Ha tod' M oinf rFe si a diin
rf d s pe i be to o u
rfr s to o e n d to
t isge rlo j cins Theeobe tonsflit t bai c tgo is ( )o j cins
o t nea b e to . s j ci al no wo sc ae re :B. be to
t fe , n ( )o j cinst no txa ec ss TheCou tsa aysso e c c tgoy
o e s a d C. be to o n-a bl o t.
r' n l i f a h ae r
f l s.
olow

8 Cr & Fort rnot t tt r t c ge by isat ne and pa algal i t
um
se es ha he aes har d t tor ys
r e s n he
pr e c s i 2011 201 a e sgnii nty l st t r t sc r d i 2007es nt a e n
- 2 r i tca l es han he a e ha ge n
2009 byt
he
at ne and p ae sa Ca lo Fi ds de e ec
tor ys
ar lgal t rt n el , f ns ouns f rHa tor a M ilr& Sol
el o rf d nd le
omon,
i t unde l ngl ws t I t sr a d, hehoury r t ofpa t r Parc aThom ps a
n he
ryi a ui. n hi eg r t
l aes
rne s tii
on nd
Ti hyTay or r d fom $265- 25.The houry r eofas o a eKa e Pe kewa a hi
mot
l , ange r
$3
l at
s cit s y a
s s gh
a $ an $260 an t houryr t ofpa alga Sor da Smih wa a hi as$1 $17
s 230 d
d he
l ae
r e l ai
t s s gh
65- 0.
-

7-

B. Ha tor sOb e tonst Cr & Fo se ' Fe s
r f d' j c i o um
r trs e .
1
.

Needl s di
e s scove y.
r

Thi di cover i udesr vi w oft andsofpa ofdocum ent a
s s
y ncl
e e
hous
ges
s nd

de sto .D , 226 Cr m & Fo se r s ndst tt d ume sa d de ii s
po iins ( E. ) u
rt r e po ha he oc nt n poston
w e eus t ditnguih t e e
r ed o s i s hos xpens r a ed t t def e oft underyi ltga i
es elt o he ens
he
l ng ii ton

a tos rltdt rparngt s j c c d num. um & Fo se as noe t t
nd h e eae o e ii he ube t on omii Cr
rtr lo ts ha
boh p risr le o m o toft c a ln dde ston i p e di . D . 2 )The
t a te ei d n s he h le ge po ii s n l a ngs ( E. 33
Cour fndst tt di c y r at d t t unde l ng ltgaton w asnotne es
t i ha he s over el e o he
ryi ii i
edl s.

The ef e,Cr & For t m a r overr s
r or um
ser y ec
ea onabl f esr at d t i tga i t
e e el e o nves i tng he
unde l ng Itgaton.
ryi ii i

2.

Th Cou tsutmat e cu i o u t Ha fo d' epe t
e r ' li e x lson fcr m t r r s x r
tsi n Jte n tba r c v r o h s e sr l e t teepe t
e tmo y l. o r e o ey fto ef e eatd o h x r.
î

Harf d a guest tCr & For t rm a notr
tor r
ha um
se y
ecove any oft bilng e res
r
he li nti
r at t Cr & For t ' expe tbec et e r w asexcl
el ed o um
ser s
r
aus he xpe t
uded by t Cour . Cr
he
tg um
& For t r pondst tt us ofisexper was diec l r a ed t is def e a t ti
ser es
ha he e t
t
r ty el t o t
ens nd o ral
pr pa a i l l addii Cr & For t a gue t tise r w asr ai d t r
e r ton.o n
ton, um
ser r s ha t xpe t
et ne o ebutt
he

evi
dence ofer by Harf d' expe t A lhough t Cour uli a el excl
f ed
tor s
r. t
he
t tm t y
uded Cr &
um
For t r sexpe t t sdi notm a t s a unr ona e e
se '
r , hi d
ke hi n eas bl xpens i Cr & For t '
e n um
ser s

9 ( E.226a 1 .
D.
t 4)
l ( E. at9)
0 D. 233
,
-

8-

pr pa aton ofisde ens when t e
e r i
t f e
he xpens w asi r by Cr ,a t r or t
e
ncur ed
um nd he ef e he
Cour fndst Cr & For t m a r overt e f sr a ed t ise
t i hat um
ser y ec
hos ee elt o t xper .
t

Fe sr l e t c ale gigt Cou tse lsono u &
e eatd o h ln n he r ' xcu i fcr m
For er' e pe .
st s x rt

Harf d alo a guest tCr & For t m a notr
tor s r
ha um
s er y
ecoverf t e f as oci t
or hos ees s a ed
w ih s eki r cons der i oft Cour' excl i ofCr & For t ' exper.Cr
t e ng e
i aton he
ts
uson
um
ser s
t um

& Fo se d sn tr s ndt Ha tod' o jcin. Co ti sHator sobe ton
rtr oe o epo o rf r s b e to The ur fnd rf d' jci
w el t
l aken t tCr & For t i note il t r
ha um
s er s
ntted o ecove f es f t hour i c e t
r e or he
s t hos o

s
pend s ki r onsder i oft Cour' decii i a amountof$4, 50.
ee ng ec i aton he
ts son n n
244.

4.

Fe sr ltdt wo kpef me b lgal s it t.
e eae o r ror d y e a ssans

Ha tor rie svea o j cinst Cl & Fortrslg la ssa ta dpaae l
rf d as s e r l be to o '
um
se ' e a sitn n r lga
fe . rfr o j cst t n e o h ur bildbylg la ssa t a paae l a
e s Ha to d be t o he umb r f o s le
e a sitns nd r lgas s

wel stert a whiht yweebild. Co tsa lssoft s obe to
la h ae t c he r le The ur' nay i hee j cins
f l s.
olow

N um be ofhour .
r
s
H arf d ar
tor guest tt bilng ent i as oci t w ih Cr & For t r' l
ha he li
res s a ed t um
s e s egal
as it si l r y f cl rcala s cr a i wor H a tor alo a gue t tt bilng
s sant s a gel or e i nd e et ral k. rf d s r s ha he li

a s at w ih t l as it nt a pa al scont i duplcatve,r
s oci ed t he egal ss a s nd r egal
an
i i edundant
,

e c s i , nn c s ay, n bl k bilnge ti s Ha to d' o j ci nsa eun e ri
x e sve u e e s r a d oc li n re . rf r s b e to r cla .l
11 SomeofHatod' obeci aege rlydie tdt r t o goupsof
rf r s j tons r neal rce owads ypes r r
bilngenres butdo no die t Cour t s ci cbilnge re Ot rob e tonsaedie td
li ti ,
t rcthe
t o pe t li ntis. he j ci r rce
l
t r s c fcbilngen res b a eco l or Some ofHa tor spr e r ductonsmay
owa ds pe ii li
ti , ut r ncus y.
rf d' opos d e i
-

9-

l t ad,Harf d a t che neary l50 unnumber pagesw ih enty- enty,boie pl e
ns e
tor ta s
l
ed
t
r by- r
l r at

obe ton i s l, n-tnd r f n .Cr & Fo se rs dsb sai t tn eof
j ci s n malno sa ad o t um
rtr epon y ttng ha on
t e e re a e i pr , fe a r vi ofCr & For t ' bilng ent i atrbut t
hes nti s r m oper A tr e ew
um
ser s li
res t i ed o

lg la ssa so paae l, n Ha tor sc repo n obe to ,h Cou tfnd
e a sitnt r rlgas a d rf d' or s ndig j cins te r i s
t ts eoft s enti ar exa pl ofbl k bilng.The Cour al o fndst som e
ha om
he c res e m es
oc li
t s i hat
e res l k s sci de ai t det r i w hehert y a e duplc i r dundant
nti ac uf ent t l o e m ne
t he r
i atve, e
,
exce si ,orunnec ar The ef e,t Cour wilr
s ve
ess y. r or he
t l educe t t alnum berofhour
he ot
s
bil by l a sit nt a par e s f whi Cr & For t m a r
led
egal s s a s nd al gal or ch um
ser y ecoverby 20% .
i.
i

The r e a w hi h Cr & For t rbil f w or pe f m ed by l
at t c um
s e led or k r or
egal
a sit sand par e s i r as
s s ant
al gal s e onabl
e.

Harf d a guest tt r t atwhi Cr & For t bil f w or pe f m ed
tor r
ha he a e
ch um
ser led or k r or

by l galas i t sand pa al ss d be r duced.The qualfcatonsofCr &
e
s sant
r egal houl
e
ii i
um
For t ' l as it sand par egal r
sers egal ss ant
al s angebe w e a Ba or s degr a t e y
t en
chel '
ee nd w nt
ye s ofe
ar
xperence,t an As oci e' degr and t o year ofe rence, i t M a l
i
o
s at s
ee
w
s xpe i
Pror o y ,
201 Cr & For t f l t i iy by na e t i vi
2, um
s er ais o dentf
m he ndi duall as i t orpar egal
egal s sant
al

bemuli e at mpt t r duc a sngl f e,e ns orc twihouti toduci as tntve y
tpl te s o e e i e e xpe e, os t
nr
ng ubsa i l

n w o j cin.t sd fiutt tlb c us Hato d' Re p n esmpl r fr t ExhbtA, D.
e be to I i ifc l o el e a e rfr s s o s i y ees o ii ( E.
226- ) whe pr e i t fna a ntt berduc d.Exhi tA i a 1 pa docu ntt
1, n esntng he i l mou o e e
bi s 48 ge
me hat
lsspr e r duc i onan hourby- ,lne by-i ba i i t e f m a .Harf d alo
it opos d e tons
- hour i - lne ss n abl or t
tor s
at c sisf e r' a tda tt t moton. et rdoc
ta he t ee xpe ts fs vi o he i N ihe
umen c a nsan e a ton ofhow
t ont i
xplna i
t fnalrductonsr ese we er ac d,nort wha e entr duc i overa Fore
he i e i equ t d r e he
o
t xt e tons
lp.
xampl
c,
H a tor r que t a r duc i f s c e a i lt s a a r duc i be us t l ala s s a a
rf d e s s e ton or e r t r a a ks nd e ton ca e he eg s i t nt nd
pa al ga e resprort M a 1 201 di no ls a s c fc l ga as i t ntorpar l al Ta n
r e l nt i i o y , 2 d t i t pe ii e l s s a
a eg . ke
t et r t et r tonsaonee e d t t a amountoflgala ssa and pa algalf es
og he , hes wo educi
l
xc e he ot l
e
s it nt
r e e

tatCr & Fort rr quessby ove $47000.
h um
se e t
r ,
-

10-

as oci ed wih eac bilng enty.The Cour ca
s at
t
h li
r
t nnotde e m i whi h i vi
t r ne
c ndi duall gal
e
as it ntorpar e peror ed t w or i ea bilng e r
ss a
al gal f m
he
k n ch li nty.
Harf d a gue t t asa r ul,t r e a whi h Cr & For t m a r
tor r s ha ,
es t he at t c um
s er y ecove
r
f es f t rl as it nt and par e ss d be t l e tr e am ong t m .And
e or hei egal ss a s
algal houl
he ow s at
he

be et eentisa eal bil a $85. Ha tor ar
caus hes rc r l led t 00, rf d guest t Cour mus s ec a
hat he
t t el t
ne .r ona er t
w eas bl a e.
H a tor s
rf d ugges st a r onabl r t f a l a sit orpa al w ih a
t hat eas
e a e or egal s s ant
r egal t n

As oci e' degr a t ye sofe incei $15. perhour Ther or Ha tor
s at s
ee nd wo ar
xpere
s
00
.
ef e, rf d
ar ,t r t ofeve y e r r at d t w or pe f m ed by a l galas it orpa al
gues he a e
r nty el e o
k r or
e
ss ant
r egal

s d ber duced t $1 00 perhour Cr & Fort r pondst $85. perhouri
houl
e
o 5.
. um
ser es
hat 00
s
r s
ea onabl f eac oft l as it sand pa al st ta
e or h he egal ss ant
r egal ha ppeari t bilng r cor ,
n he li e ds
r dl soft ri vi
egar es
hei ndi dualqualfca i .z
ii tonsl
Neiherpary ciesany l aut iy sugges i a r onabl r e f l
t
t t
egal hort
tng eas
e at or egal
as it nt orpar e s i M i i How e ,ar vi w ofcas f om ot l ge cii i
ss a s
al gal n am .
ver e e
es r
her ar
tes n

1 Cr & For t rma t e a tonalr pons s Fis,t ti c n pr de
2 um
se kes hr e ddii
es e . r t ha t a ovi
i or i de a lng whih i vi lgala ssa sa pa aega sa e a s a e wih e c
nf maton t ii
c ndi dual e
s it nt nd r l l r s ocit d t a h
i vi ltme e r Howe r i di no pr det ti onna i i t orgi r c dst ti
ndi dua i nty.
ve , t d t ovi ha nf
ton n he i nal e or ha t
s
ubmit d t t Cour a t Ha tor Norha i pr de t ti or a i t da e.Se
te o he
t nd o rf d.
s t ovi d ha nf m ton o t cond,t t
ha
Ha tor sf l et s
rf d' aiur o ubmi a a fdavi de a lng t r t ofisown par l l vi aesS. Fl
t n fi t t ii he aes t
aegas olt D. a.

L. 73 8 a dtee o en g tsHa to d so j cin . eCo r fn sta $ 50 p rh u i a
R. .( ) n h r f r e ae rf r ' b e to s Th u ti d h t 8 .0 e o r s
r as bl f e o ot rgr
e ona e e n he ounds a ne d notr c t sis .Fi ly, ha Ha tor spa a e l
, nd e
ea h hi s ue na l t t rf d' r l ga s

bildatart a hi as$1 00,ctngbil fom Ha tor sc el( E.209- .A rviw of
le
ae s gh
70. ii ls r
rf d' ouns , D.
8) e e
t bil,D. 209- doe i c t t tc rani vi sbilda art ofaound$1 0pe
he ls ( E. 8) s ndiae ha e ti ndi dual le t ae r
7 r
hour Thos i vi l a e ditng s ont bilngr or by a t rs ne t t i na e .
.
e ndi dua s r si uihed he li ec ds
se iks xt o her m s
Howev ,no e a ton i ma oft asers i t bilng r c ds.
er
xpl na i s de he t iks n he li e or Ther f e, heCour doe
e or t
t s
n ha e
ot ve nough i or ai t e ua et sa gum e .
nf m ton o val t hi r
nt
-

11-

Fl i 3s
ordal uggesst t$85. i ar ona er t The ef e,t Cour fndst t$85.
t ha
00 s eas bl ae. r or he
t i ha
00
perhouri a r onabl r t f a lt l as it sand pa al s f w hi h Cr &
s eas
e a e or l he egal s sant
r egal or c um
Fort s eksf
ser e
ees.
C. Non-raxabl C os s
e
t

H a tor ar
rf d guest Cr & For t m a notr
hat um
ser y
ecovera cossbe
ny t yond t e
hos

r c e a eu e 28U. C.j 1 0.Ha to dct sKe n y v Au o own r I s Co.
e ov r bl nd r
S.
92
rf r ie ar e . t - e s n .

( 8:6-v- 9 T- 4No. 0 c 005 5- 2 TGW , 0W L 3 62 0 ( . Fl 201 ), o s pp tt
201
0 42 M D, a. 0 ) t u or is
poston. l Kear y,t cour w asf ced w ih a m oton f f esand c t pur ua t t
ii
n
ne he
t
a
t
i or e
os s s nt o he

Ofe ofJ dg n Saut a atnd n obe to smia t tos i tei tntc s
fr u me t tt e nd tt a t jcins i lr o h e n h nsa a e.
The cour e ai t tf r coursonl per i r
t xpl ned ha ede al
t y m t ecove y ofnon-axabl cos sk her
r
t
e t i e
w
a s a ut S i ty'aut i i t do s ora c texplcil de ar t tt sa ut
t t e explcil
horzes t o
o,
our
i ty cl es ha he t t e

c e es a s t i rghtt cos s. The cour w e on t expl n t tneihe t
r at
ubs antve i o t '
'
t nt o
ai ha t r he

l nguage i t Of erofJ
a
n he f
udgm entSt t e norr evantFl i cas a goesf e
a ut
el
orda el w
ar nough t
o
cr t a s t ntve rghtt coss. Ther or t c tc ude t whie t O f e of
ea e ubs a i i o t
ef e, he our oncl d hat l he f r
J
udgm e St ut i s t i l w f Eri pur esast a t ne s f ,i i onl
nt at e s ubsantve a or e pos
o tor y' ees t s y

p o e r llw a t c ss I t a ,c t r man g r db 28U . C.j 1 0.
r c du a a s o o t . nse d oss e i ovene y
S.
92

l Se eg. z kiv Kik an ' St r s l . No. 07- 802- l223 e . Pyc yns . r l d s o e , nc , 6: cv- Or- KRS,2008 W L

5 64,a *3( . Fl 2008 (i ngr s bl art of$95. pe hourf apaal lwih
448 t M D. a. ) fndi ea ona e ae
00 r
or r ega t
ni y r ofexpe i ea $65. perhourf an a nita i a ssa who di ba i
ne ea s
renc nd
00
or dmi sr tve s it nt
d sc

paae wor ;Ke ne v Aut l nesI .Co.No.8: c 005 - 24rlgal k) ar y . o-N r ns ,
06-v- 95T- TGW , 3
71
F. zd 1 1 77( . Fl 201 (eti art of$65. pe hou f a e r l l
supp. 369, 376- M D. a. 0) s tng ae
00 r r or n nty-eve
pa alga f t dif e pa aeg swhos i tt a t r f equa ii tons t c tc d
r e l or wo fer nt r l al
e den iy, nd he e or
lfcai , he our oul

notdeemi .
tr ne)
-

12-

Cr m & Fo se r s dst a S. Fl . R. 3( )pe misapr v iig pa t t
u
r tr e pon h t D. a L. 7. a r t e a ln ry o
s kr
ee ecover ofnon-axa e expens and cos s.Cr & For t ri cor ec t t l
y
t bl
es
t
um
s e s r t hat he ocal
r e pe m i a pary t s k non-axa e coss,f exam pl wher aut i by s a ut or
ul r t
t o ee
t bl
t or
e
e horzed
tt e
as i
s anctons. Ther or Cr & For t i notentted t any non-axa e c t ,
ef e, um
s er s
il o
t bl os s

i udi t cossand f f is e tl ta e ns ,W es l and LexiN exi
ncl ng he t
ees or t xper,4 r vel xpe es
taw
s
s
r e ch c t ,and cos sf bac ound chec
es ar os s
t or kgr
ks.
1 1. C ON CLUSI N
1
O

Accor ngl i i O RD ER ED ,ADJUD G ED ,a D ECREED t :
di y, t s
nd
hat
Def ndant Cr & For t Speci t l ur
e
, um
s er
aly ns ance Com pany' Verted
s is
M oton f Ator y' Feesand Non- xa e Expe esand CossA ga ns
i or t ne s
Ta bl
ns
t
i t

Pli if ( 20 , , n t s mei h r b GRANTED i par a
antf, DE 9) be a d he a s e e y,
n t nd
D ENIED i par ,a
n
t nd

Def
endant Cr & For t Speci t l ur
, um
ser
aly ns ance Com pany,i her
s eby

e tte t $ 9,92.0 i f e p s ntt Fl rdaStt t j 7 . a d
n ild o 25 5 5 n e s urua o o i au e 6879 n
a ns H a tor Cas t l ur
gai t r f d
ualy ns ance Com pa
ny.

DO N E A ND O RD ER ED i Cham ber a t Ja esLa r
n
s t he m
w ence Ki Fede al
ng
r

1 Onl t $20, 83 Cr & Fort rs e t r c rr aed diec l t ' ii i t
4
y he
885.
um
se e ks o e ove elt r ty o t lzng he
ut
s r c ' ofise rsnott tme bild byCr & Fo se ' c
e vies' t xpe t
' he i
le
um
r t rs ouns lwhi t Cour ha
e
ch he
t s

pr vi l dicuse See( E.209a 6 .
e ousy s s d. D.
t)
-

13-

J tc Buidi and U nied St t Courhous M i i Fl i t s 1 hday of
usi e l ng
t
a es
t e, am , or da, hi 5t
N ovem ber 201
, 2.
K

. *
v
'
'

,

.
.

v.
f

'

*

m J M ES LA W REN CE K I G
'
N
.
'
'
I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J
CT UD
SOU THERN D I
STRI OF FLORI A
CT

,

..

-

-

Copi f nihed t
es ur s
o:

Co e f rHa lo d
uns l o rf r :
Mi
guelAngelBrzue a,Es
i l
q.
Tayl Ve P. .
or ga, A
2555 Ponc D eLeon Boul r
e
eva d
Suie 220
t
Cor G a es FL 331
al bl ,
34

Emalmb iuea tyl v g c m
i: rz l@ a or e a.o
El ne W iher
ai
t spoon,Es
q.
Vezi La r
na, w ence,& Picieli P. .
s t l, A
1 1A l
2 hambr Plza
a a
Suie 1604
t
Cor Gabl ,FL 331
al
es
34

Emal e te s on vl a c m
i: wih rpo @ plw.o
Ti ot Shane Tayl ,Esq.
m hy
or
Tayl Vega,P. .
or
A
1 A l m br Plza
21 ha a a
Suie 1
t 604
Cor G a es FL 331
al bl ,
34

Emalta lr a or e a.o
i:tyo @tyl v g c m

-

1
4-

-

Cou e fo Cr * For tr
ns l r um
se :
H oly S.H ar
l
vey,Esq.
Thor on Da s& Fei
nt
vi
n
Brckel Ba Vi w Ce r
i l y e
nte
80 SW 8 h St ee
t r t
Suie 2900
t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
30

Emalhav y@t l w.o
i: r e dta c m
Mi
chae C harl sG or
l
e
don,Es
q.
Thor on,Davi & Fei P. .
nt
s
n, A
80 SW 8t Stee
h r t
Suie2900
t
M i i FL 331
am ,
30

Emalgodo dta c m
i: r n@t l w.o
Coun e fo We the tr
s l r sc se :
Aar B.Til y,Es
on
le
q.
Coze O'
n Connor
45 Br
oadw a
y
28t Fl
h oor
New Y or N Y 1
k,
0006

Emal aily c z n.om
i: tl @ o e c
e
A nays G alar Es
a
l do, q.
Coze O'
n Connor
200 S Bica Boul d
s yne
evar
Suie441
t
0
M i i FL 33131
am ,

Emal a la d @ c z n.om
i: galr o o e c
Br
yan P.Veze Es
y, q.
Coze O'
n Connor
1 M cK i y Stee
221
nne r t
One Hous on Ce erSuie 2900
t
nt
t
H ous on,TX 7701
t
0

Emal b z y@ c e c m
i: ve e oz n.o

-

15-

Jos ph A .Zi i ki Es
e
em ans , q.
Cozen O'
Connor
1 M cKi y Stee
221
nne r t
One H ouson Ce e Suie 2900
t
nt r t
Hous on,TX 7701
t
0

Emalj imin ki c e c m
i:ze a s @ oz n.o
Ri
chard M i
chaelD unn,Es
q.
Coz O'
en Connor
200 S Bica Boul va d
s yne
e r
Suie441
t
0
M i i FL 33131
am ,

Emalr n c z n.o
i:du n@ o e c m

-

16-