Bacon v. Stiefel Laboratories, Inc. et al

Filing 126

OPINION RULING ON DEFENDANTS'OMNIBUS 84 Motion in Limine Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 5/2/2013. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES DISTRICT CO U RT
SO UTH ER N D I
STRI O F FLO R I
CT
DA
CA SE N O .11 20489- V - 1 G/ CA LI
CI K N M
LEY
J ES A . CON ,
AM
BA

Pl i if
a ntf ,

STI
EFEL LABOR ATORI I C.
ES, N ,
a Del a e c por i CH ARLES W .STI
aw r or aton,
EFEL,
BRENT D .STI
EFEL,TOD D STI
EFEL,
STEPHEN K ARA SI ,M I
CK
CHA EL CORNELI
US,
and M ATT S,PA TTU LLO,
Def
endant .
s
/

O PI I N R ULI O N D EFENDAN TS'OM NI
N O
NG
BUS M O TI N I LI I E '
O N M N
Def
endant 'Om ni M oton i Li i s ki e uson oft i r
s
bus
i n m ne ee ng xcl i
he ntoduc i by
ton

P an if f vi e e o e nng a h EC a ui, b u po td ete n s us i
'li tf o e d nc c nc r i ( )t e S lws t ( )p r re s tlme tdic sons
b t e t pa te , n ( )De e a s û tae cpln ng'i aca sce mpl ofa
ewe n he ri s a d c f nd nt' ç r t gi a ni 's ls i xa e n
s
a t m ptt getpr ti r i on bas c l e dentar m ate sw hi m a orm ay not
te
o
e ral ulngs
i aly vi i y
tr
ch y,
,
e ars dur ng t ti l and t adm is biiy ofwhi h w ildepend e i ey upon t
ver ie i he r a ,
he
s i lt
c l
ntr l
he
ma
nneri w hi i ars durng t ti and t m anne i w hi i i pr e e Thes
n
ch t i es i he ral
he
rn
ch t s es nt d.
e

a en tm atr i lmi .Thec ie i f raCo r d cso t e l ee de c (n lmi e
r o te s n i ne
rtra o
u t e ii n o xcud vi n e i i n )
m 1s be bas upon whe he ornott f uale de s
1t
ed
t r
he act vi nce oughtt be e ude i cl l
o
xcl d s eary
i
nadm i sbl on any pos i e gr
si e
sbl ound.

Pli ifrs
antf e ponde t t sM oi onAprl23, 3( E./11 .
d o hi ton
i 201 D. / 8)

Wihrs e tt teo j cint r frnc t t S lws t ima bece ry
t e p c o h be to o eee e o he EC a ui,t y lal
r evantasr t evi
el
ebutal dence. Pl ntf sat s i isr s
ai if t e n t e pons ve m em or ndum ofA pr l23,
i
a
i
he
o
ude
2 3 ( E. 1 8 t a i wilo y o frt a e d n ea r bu tl Fort Courtt excl
01 D. # 1 ) h t t l nl fe h t vi e c s e ta .

t sascl l i
hi
eary nadm is bl on a pos i e gr
si e
ny sbl ound w oul be i pr
d m operatt stm e.
hi i
l i s cl ,t ts tem e -el t dicus i be wee t pa tesar
t s o ear ha etl ntr a ed s sons t n he r i e
i dm is bl a ti ,t ti i a exe c s i f iiy f couns t se a l lm i or r
na s i e t ral ha t s n r i e n utlt or
el o ek n ' i ne de
n

dr ci lwy r no t d wha t yara ykno t yc nno d A smpl o j ci
ie tng a e s t o o t he le d
w he a t o. i e b e ton,
s o da y d atmp t brn i stlme tdsusinsa t til fr t j y,
h ul n bo y te t o ig n ete n ic so t he ra beo e he ur
w oul bes t nabl and coul be e iy deal w ih durng t ti .Pl i if sr s
d
usai e
d
as l
t t
i he ral a ntf e pons
e

( E. 1 8 ce ry r c gnie t sprn p l wh r Pli if sae t y h ven i e in
D. # 1 ) la l e o z s hi icia , e e antfs t t he a o ntnto
ofi r
ntoduci s h evi nce.
ng uc
de
I lm i cons de a i ofar ent and evi ncer atng t t D ef nda s
n i ne
i r ton
gum s
de
el i o he
e nt '
isr egi pl ng a sr t cpl ng docum ent 'i equaly m ipl
stat c anni nd ta egi anni
s' s
l s aced. One need

l kno f t rt n De e nt'me a du ( 6- 0-D. #8 t quikl dic r
oo
urhe ha f nda s mor n m pp. 1
E. 4) o c y s e n
t tt c pl xii s ofe des rbi t si s t t Court e ralr
ha he om e te
ven c i ng hi s ue o he
pr t i ender i nota
st
m a t rwhi s d be c i r i Im i Experenced ti couns ,and cerai y t
te
ch houl
onsde ed n i ne.
i
ral
el
t nl he
Cour,c e s on per psa hal a doze ways i whi t e m ater m i ber eva
t an nvii
ha
f
n
n
ch hes
t s ght el nt
durng t t i pr s aton ofe de
i he ral e ent i
vi nce. Counse wilha t f lopporuniy t m a
l l ve he ul
t t o ke

whae e obe tont ywiht ma -maeilt,rlva y wo kpr d t ec. ila
tv r j ci he s o ke traiy ee nc , r o uc, t - l nd
whe tee de ei s ug tt bep e e e
n,h vi nc s o h o r sntd.Ath t u t e(h til,heprdiaefr
ta j ncur te ra)t e c t o
2

t ir
he ntoducton oft e dence eihe w il orw ilnot ha been pr ry l d a is
i
he vi
t r l,
l , ve
ope l ai nd t
r e nce m a eralt e c.w ilbe cl ary a r t a1 t pari s. A te ptng t ge t s
el va
t i iy, t
l
e l ppa ent o 1 he te
t m i o t hi

m a t rr ol on an i Im i bas si sm pl t ate ptt i
te es ved
n i ne i s i y o t m o nduce t Cour t enga i
he
to
ge n

s c ltv c n e t ea t h t matrwilaie a dt weg a r s le
pe uaie o jcur s o ow he te l rs , n o ih nd e ov
adm i sbiiy off t diput m or a opr a el l tt t ti . l i t r or
s i lt
ac ual s es e ppr i t y ef o he ral t s he ef e,
ORDERED ,AD J GED a D ECREED t t D ef ndant Om ni M oton
UD
nd
hat he e
s'
bus
i

î Li n ( E. 4)fldM a c 2 ,2 3 b ,a t s me i he e y DENI
n mie D. #8 ie
r h 7 01 e nd he a s r b
ED.
DON E AND ORD ERED i cham be sa t Ja e La ence K i Fede alJ tc
n
r t he m s wr
ng
r us i e
Buidi a U nied St t Court e,M i i Fl i t s2n day ofM a 201
l ng nd
t
a es
hous
am , or da, hi d
y, 3.
<

J ES LA W REN CE KI G
AM
N
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI
C

Cou ef Pli W .
ns l or ant
Nor an S,Segal,Es
m
l q.
Sundeep K . uli Es
M lck, q.
SEGA LL GO RD I P. .
CH, A
801 Br c lAve
i kel
nue
9t Fl
h oor
M i i FL 331
am ,
31
A a on S.
r
Podhur t Es
s , q.
Pe e Pret Es
t r i o, q.
M at
thew W ei hal,Es
ns l q.
PODH URST ORSECK,P. .
A
25 W es Fl erSt e
t agl r et
Suie 800
t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
30

GE

Cou ef De nd :
ns l or fe ant
D a d A .Coulon,Es
vi
s
q.
Li e Cam p Edel a Es
nds y
m nn, q.
Gr nber Tr ur g,P. .
ee
g a i A
333 S. 2n Avenue
E. d
M i i FL 331
am ,
31

4