Cedano et al v. Alexim Trading Corp.
Filing
22
ORDER granting in part and denying in part 14 Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Chief Judge Federico A. Moreno on 10/27/2011. (mmz)
UN I
TED STATES DI
STRI COURT FOR THE
CT
SOU TH ERN D I
STRI O F FLO RI
CT
DA
M i m iD i son
a
vi i
Cas N um ber 11e
: 20600- I - O REN O
C V M
A M A DO CED AN O ,e a1,
t .
Pl ntf s
ai i f ,
ALEXI TM DI G CO RP.
M
N
,
D e e nt
f nda .
O R DER G R A NTI G I PA R T D EFEN DA N T'
N N
S
M O T I N FO R SUM M A RY JUDG M EN T
O
Pl ntfs we e ca go tuc drver f De e nt Alxi Tr di Cor a i a
ai if
r r r k i s or f nda , e m a ng
por ton, n
i t m ai lc r a nthe dqua tr d i M im i Fl i
n e tona a go ge
a
re e n a , orda.Pli if brng t s s tagans t r
antfs i hi ui i t hei
f me empl r al i t co sunde t Fai LaborStndadsAc CS
or r oye, legng wo unt
r he r
a r
t FLSA' :( )Unpad
' 1
)
i
ove tme; nd( rtlaor frng. is r s dbyt s c s r s ci y, r ( )whehe
ri a zleait y ii The sues aie
hee ount, e pe tvel ae: 1
t r
Pl i t f sa ee m ptfom t overi ep ovi i oft FLSA bec us t yar i i r 'a dei d
a n if r xe
r he
tm r sons he
a e he e i ve s' s tne
dr
byt Mot Care Ex i t t FLSA;a ( whehe Pli if c dbepr e t b te
he or rir empton o he
nd 2) t r antfs oul
otced y h
r t i ton pr sonsoft FLSA e i t y ar e m pt
e ala i
ovi i
he
ven f he e xe .
1.Fact Background
ual
A l xi 'r di Cor a i i a c r a tt s r c s t i e a i
e m F a ng
por ton s a go gen hat e vi e he nt m tonalt a i t y.
r de ndus r
Pl i if wor da t c drver f Def nda a dif e pe i bet e De e b r2006t ough
antfs ke s nlk i s or e nt t fer nt rods we n c m e
hr
Aprl201 Pli if s e c pe ai f alege ove tme hour wor d outi ofbusnes
i
0. antfs e k om ns ton or l d ri
s ke
sde
i s
hour . Pl i i f a gue t t s hour wentu om pe a ed bec us D e e
s a ntfs r
hat he e
s
nc
ns t
a e f ndantpup os f l ke
e uly pt
t tme ke pi ma hi i i af c lt t t onl opendurngbusnes hou s t pr ve i
he i - e ng c ne nsde a iiy ha was y
i
i s r ,hus e ntng
Pl ntfsfom e e i t ehour t y wor dout i ofbusne shour Pl i if bei ve t y
ai if r ntrng hos
s he
ke
sde
i s
s. antfs le d he
we ee il dt ove tmepa ca et De e ntha oc sonalypa dt m ove tmei t pas.
r ntte o ri
ybe us he f nda
d ca i l i he
ri n he t
De e nta guest tPl i if a enote ildt ove tmebe us t y a eexe pt r t FLSA
f nda r
ha antfs r
ntte o ri
ca e he r
m fom he
unde t M ot Ca e Exempton.
r he
or ni r
i
Pli if a s s e lqui t d da ges t y s f e whe De enda fr d t m i
a ntfs lo e k i da e
ma
he ufer d
n f nt ie he n
rt iton f as e tng t i FLSA rg s Pl ntfs alege t t t y we e fr d be aus t y
e ala i or s ri he r
i ht . ai if l
ha he
r ie c e he
c
ompl i dt De e nta
ane o f nda boutnot ngpai ove tmea r quie byt FLSA.Def nda a gue
bei
d ri s e r d he
e nt r s
t Pli if we efr df
hat a ntfs r ie ormibe vi ,ncudi anat r tont tonePl ntf ha wih a he
s ha or i l ng le cai ha
ai if d t not r
d i r Pl ntfsr pondt t f nda 'r s i apr tns andr ga di hes c fcale ca i
rve . ai if es
ha De e nts ea on s ee e,
e r ngt pe ii tr ton,
t tt ot rdrve wa net rfr d nordic plned.
ha he he i r s ihe ie
si i
I .St
I andar ofR e e
d
vi w
Su r j d me t sa to ie wh r t eei n g n i eis eo maei l a t Fe R.
mmay u g n i uh rz d ee h r s o e u n su f tra fc. d.
Ci . 5 () Th p rys e i s mmayj d me t e r teiiil u d no d mo srtn te
v P. 6 c. e at e kng u r u g n b as h nta b r e f e n taig h
a e eofage neis ofmaera f t Adik sv S.- A-ps' Co.398U. 1 1 7( 970)
bs nc
nui sue
t il ac. c e . I r 'dr ,
L
î
S. 44, 5 1 .
Th pat o p sn temo inf rs mmayj d me t yn tsmpyr s u o meealg to
e ry p o ig h to o u r u g n ma o i l e t p n r l ains
e
orde a soft pl di ; henon- ovi pa t mus esa iht e s nta elm e sofisc e
ni l he ea ngs t
m ng ry
t t bls he s e i l e nt
t as
onwhi i wilbe rt bur nofpr a ti . Cel e Cor v CJ/e/ 477U. 31 ( 98 ;
ch t l a he de
oof t ral otx p. . r /,
S. 7 1 6)
Matus t Elc I du Co.v Ze t Radi Cor ,475 U. 574 ( 986) Thenonmovan mus
s hia e . n s.
. nih
o p.
S.
1 .
t t
pr entmor t a si il ofe de e i s
es
e han cntla vi nc n uppor oft nonmova ' poston. A j y mus
t he
nts ii
ur
t
r s na y be a e t fnd f t nonm ova .
ea o bl
bl o i or he
nt Ande s v Lï l? Lobb l ,477 U . 242,254
r on . ht y
r
y, nc.
S.
-
2-
( 986)The Cour mus vi t evi ncea drw a1 r s bl i ee si t lg mos
1 .
t t ew he de
nd a l ea ona e nfrnce n he iht t
f vor bl t t nona a e o he
movi pa t I at25
ng ry. d.
5.
1 1 LeaalA nal i
1.
vs s
A.
CountOne:U npa d O ve tm e
i
ri
Pl n if aleget tpu s t t FLSA ,he a ee ildt pa m e f ove tmehour
aitfs l ha , r uant o he
t y r ntte o y nt or ri
s
t ywor d.De e
he
ke
f ndanta guest tPl ntfsa eno e ild t ove tm ebe aus t y a ee mpt
r
ha ai if r t ntte o ri
c e he r xe
fom t FLSA unde t M ot rCa e Ac .Pli if dia e t tt M ot Ca e Acta i s
r he
r he
o ni r t a ntfs s gr e ha he
or ni r
pple ,
a gui t t Pli if dr tuc t twei d ls t n t saut y a
r ng ha antfs ove r ks ha
ghe e s ha he t t or mountr quiedt ti ge
e r o rg r
t M ot Ca te Ac . rt r as sa e beow,t sCour tn t tPl i if a ee
he
or ri r t Fo he e ons tt d l hi
ti ds ha antfs r xemptfom
r
t FLSA be a et y ar drve sasdefne by t M ot Ca e Ac .
he
c us he e i r
i d he
or ni r t
The FLSA exe sfom is wage a hourr quie e s' ny e oye wih r s tt
mpt r t
nd
e r m nt '
a mpl e t e pec o
whom t Sec e a yofTr ns tton ha powe t esabls qua ii tonsa m a m um hour of
he r t r
a pora i
s
r o t ih lfca i nd xi
s
s r c purua t gheMot Care Acl'29U. C. 2l b)1.Unde t M otrCare Act
evie s nto t
or rir t.
'
S. j 3( ( )
r he o rir ,
teSe rtr o Tr n p rainh sj rs cino e ' mply e o . amoo c ni r' 4 U. C.
h ceay f a s o tto a u idito v r ' o e s f. tr a e . 9 S.
e
.
'
j31 b)1.TheMot Ca re Exe i t t FLSA wa rvie i Augus 2005,defni a
502( ( )
or rir mpton o he
s e sd n
t
i ng
' ot ca re ' as ' pe s pr di m ot ve cl t a pora i f com pens ton. 49 U . C .
' or ri r' a r on ovi ng
m
or hi e r ns t ton or
ai '
'
S.
1 02( 4) l t , '
31 1 . n um a '
commeri moorve ce'i dei a a'el- opeledort dve ce
cal t hil 's tned s ' fpr l
s
owe hil
us d on t hi
e
he ghwa i i ert t c
ys n nt sae omm e c t ta po tpas e r orpr t i t ve c e...
r e o r ns r
s nge s
opery, f he hil
ha agr sve c er tngorgr swei ofa las 1 001pounds whi he i gr tr'49U. C.
s os hil a i
os
ght t e t 0,
, c ver s eae .
'
S.
311 1( . ,hewei ofhetuc be a oneoft detni elme sofwhet radrve
32( )A)Thus t
ght t r ks c me
he i ng e nt
he i r
f lunde t e m pton ornot
el
r he xe i
.
Thi Ditithasale is a r i on t e e oft M ot Ca re Exe i i
s src
r ady s ued ulng
he xt nt he
or rir mpton n
He nan zv Brnk'l ,
r de . i s nc.2009W L 11
3406( D. a.
S. Fl 2009) l He nande J eMoor r e t t
.n r
z,udg
e uld ha
t Brnk' drve swe eexe p e t
he i s i r r
m t ven hough t d oveam i tee ofve cl m a up oftuc
hey r
xl t
hi es de
r ks
weghi bot ove and unde 1 0001pounds. nande 2009 W L 11
i ng h r
r 0,
Her
z,
3406 a #5. Brnk' te t
t
i sle
wa m a up of1 4 t u ks 95 ofwhi h weghe o r 1 001pounds 1 To decde whehe t
s de
0 rc s
c
i d ve 0,
. d.
i
t r he
Brnk' drve s we e e mpt or not J
i s i r
r xe
, udge M oo e was gui d by r a i is d by t
r
de
egul tons s ue
he
De rme ofLa .The er gultonsdicus e t applcai of1 M ot rCa re Exe pton
pa t nt
bor
s e ai
s s d he
i ton he
o r ir m i
one oy st tha am i ur ofdu i , om et twoul f lun rt e mpton a ot r t t
mpl ee ha d
xt e
tes s
ha
d al de he xe i nd he s ha
woul no .udgeM oor f
d tJ
e oundt gui ngprnci ebe ndt er gul i t be'ha whe m i d
he di i pl hi hos e atons o ' t n xe
t
aci tes oc r t M o or Ca rerAc f vor cove a of t e pl e durng t coure of
tvii
cu , he t
ri
t a s
r ge
he m oye
i he
s
e ly n i t a j b u e ster g lra d o g i d te o te e ly e h v o l ad
mpo me t n h t o , nls h e ua n n ong uis f h mpo e a e ny e
mi m use f c ont s e yofope ai ' l a * Anal zi fo t sprncpl J eM oor
ni
fe t he aft
r ton. d. t 5.
'
ogi ng r m hi i i e, udg
e
hed t tt Brnk' drve s ' ke on bot c
l ha he i s i r '
wor d
h omm e ci a non- omm e ci ve cesa t i
r al nd
c
r al hi l nd her
dute t r f es fcintyi pa t dt s eyofope a i ofcommer i m ot vehi e t brng
i s he e or ufi e l m c e he af t
r tons
cal or cls o i
t m wihi t s opeoft FLSA'mot c ni re
he t n he c
he
S or a e xempton./ a *6( tngColisv He iage
i ' #. t cii
'
ln . rt
Wi Celr ,L/ ,2008W L 5423550,*1 20( D.11 2008).
ne la s 2
9- N. 1.
)
The D it i Cour ofM as a
s rct
t
s chus t r e s m iary i an FLSA e pton ca e i vi
ets ul d i l l n
xem i
s nvol ng
FedEx drver. I Ti v Ade co USA,I . 2008 W L 428651 ( M a s 2008) Fe as
i s n dd . c
nc,
2 D. s .
, dEx lo
ope a e a m i te of r ks s e wei ng ove l 001poundsa ot r w e g ng unde t t
rtd
xed l et t uc , om
ghi
r 0,
nd he s i hi
r ha
amount TheCour s
.
t ubmit t tonepos i ea ia i oft M ot Ca rerAc t s hm i d
ted ha
sbl pplc ton he
or ri
t o uc xe
fe t woul be t gi t Se e a y ofTr ns t i a hort t r gul t t hour f dr v sof
le s
d o ve he cr t r
a poraton ut iy o e a e he
s or i er
t u ksove 1 001pounds a gi t Se e a y ofLabora hort t r gul e t hou sf i r
rc
r 0,
, nd ve he cr t r
ut iy o e at he r ordrve s
oftuc unde l 001pounds Ti 2008 W L 428651 a *3.Howeve , heCour r a one t t
r ks
r 0,
. dd,
2 t
rt
t e s d ha
-
4-
ti a piai nwa no a vs b e'wlt u s mes e ii i dc to t a Co g e sitn e s c
hs p lc to s t d ia l ' i t o p cfc n iai n h t n rs n e d d u h
g ho
abiur to ofr gult yr ponsbiii s'l TheCour a s f
f cai n e a or es i lte . d.
'
t lo oundt ts h abiur atonwoul
ha uc
f c i
d
' a a i vi
' ke n ndi dual e o e' dal wor t deer ni f c or as t t Se r t r of
m
mplye s iy
k he t mi ng a t
o he c e a y
Tr ns tton' r gult ya hort r t rt nt s cii c r c e itcoft e o r. l a
a pora i s e a or ut iy,a he ha he pe fed ha a t rsi he mplye ' d. t
'
* I t ad,t Cou thel t a mor pr tca a oa woul be t defne a emplye asa
4. nse he
r d hat
e aci l ppr ch
d
o i n
o r
'mot c ni r i i me t t defnii of(heM oorCare Act be us i us s1 001pound' or a e' f t es he i ton t
'
t rir ) ca e t e 0,
pl tu ksi i ert t c
us r c n nt sae omm e c e i i alo conducsot rope ai t tdo no m e tt t
r e, ven f t s
t he
r tons ha
t e ha
d fnio ' # TheCo r g a tdp ril u r u g n t Dee d nso t i is e r ln ta
ei t n./ .
i '
u t rne a t s mmayj d me to fn a t n hs su ,u ig h t
a
Fe wa t r or am o orca re ' t whos empl ye t Se r t r ofTr ns t i ha t
dEx s he ef e
t rir ' o
as
e
o es he c e a y
a poraton s he
powe t pr s i r quie
r o e crbe e r ment f maxi
s or
mum hour ofs vie'bec us Fe ' es'om me ci
s er c ' a e dEx ' c
us
r al
m ot v c e ' o ta por pr ry i i e s a e com m e c '1
or ehi l s t r ns t ope t n nt r t t
r e. d.
'
De e nts tee of tuc a e mi d;m os wei ove 1 001pounds but Def nda
f nda ' l t r ks r xe
t gh
r 0,
,
e nt
c e t tatlas onei unde l 0001pounds Folowi t r s ng l d outi He nande
onc des ha e t
s
r 0,
. l ng he ea oni ai
n r
z
a Ti Def nda ' m i dfee of r ksma Def nt mot c ni ra gi st Se etr
nd dd, e nts xe l t tuc
kes enda a or a e nd ve he cr a y
o Trns o tt nj rs it no e Dee d n ' e o e s If lws h t an if a ee e tr m
f a p rai u idci v r fn a ts mply e .tol t a Plitfs r x mp fo
o
o
o
t wag a hourr quie e soft FLSA undert M o orCa e Act The f
he
e nd
e r m nt
he
he t
ni r .
ocusoft M ot
he
or
Ca re Ac sam sa r a i t e a tvii t ti c t s f t ofope a i ofcommer i
rir t i t egultng hos ci tes ha mpa t he a e y
r tons
cal
ve cl i i ert t co mer e. To de t applcai oft Ac mer l be aus oneort
hi es n nt sae m
c
ny he
i ton he t ey c e
wo
tu wihi al r e te twe ghl s t t saut ya ountwoul bec r r t t pur e of
r cks t n a g l e i e s han he t t or m
d
onta y o he pos
t A c . m iart FedEx' m i d te oftucks t m i d n ur ofA l m Tr ng Cor a i s
he t Si l o
s xe l et r
, he xe at e
exi adi
por ton'
te tof tuc i s fc e t brng t m unde t r gul ton oft Se e ar ofTr ns t ton,
le
r ks s ufi i nt o i he
r he e a i
he cr t y
a pora i
pur uantt t M ot Car i A ct
s
o he
or r er .
-
5-
Ba e ont wel-ea oned de sonsdic sng t M ot CarirActse m ptons t s
sd
he lr s
cii
s us i he
or re
' xe i , hi
Cour fn t tDe e ntqualfesa am ot c ni whos e pl esa ee m ptfom t FLSA
t i ds ha f nda
ii s
or a er
e m oye r xe
r he
pr sonson wa a hour .Ac or ngl Pli if a e no e ild t ove tme wa sbe a e
ovii
ge nd
s c di y, a ntf s r t ntte o ri
ge c us
t y a ee
he r xemptfom t wagea hourpr vii oft FLSA, t Def nda ' M oton f
r he
nd
o sons he
and he e nts
i or
Sum m a y J m e i g ant on t s Count
r udg nt s r ed
hi
.
B.CountTwo:Ret i or Fii
alat y rng
Pli if a guet tt yar en ild t lqui t ddama be aus De e
antfs r ha he e tte o i da e
ges c e f ndantfr dt m i
ie he n
r t lai nf Pl ntfs c pl nt t the we eenttedt ove tmepa unde heFLSA, ndt t
e ai to or ai if ' om ai s ha t y r il o ri
y
rt
a ha
s h r t la or frng i i vi a i oft FLSA . Pl ntfs f t ra gue t te n i t y a e
uc e ait y ii s n olton he
ai if urhe r
ha ve f he r
e mptfom t wa a hourpr sonsoft FLSA,t r t i i pr e tonsoft FLSA
xe
r he ge nd
ovii
he
he ealaton ot c i
he
co i t appl t t
ntnue o
y o hem.De e nt i ore ty a g t ti Pli tf sa ee mptfom t wa
f nda s nc r c l r ue ha f a n if r xe
r he ge
and hourpr sonsoft FLSA,t y a e sm ia l e mptfom t r ala or pr son oft
ovii
he
he r i l ry xe
r he et it y ovii
he
FLSA. Defndan s f t ra gue t tPl i if c nnotdemonsr t t tt y e ged i a tviy
e
t urhe r
ha antfs a
ta e ha he nga
n ci t
pr t c e byt FLSA bec us Def nda ' conduc ne rvi atdt FLSA. sCour fndst
o e t d he
a e e nts
t ve ol e he
Thi
t i hat
t r t laor frng pr son oft FLSA a i st Pl i if eve i t y a ee mpt d fom t
he e ai t y ii
ovii
he
pple o antfs n f he r xe e r he
wa a hourpr sons oft s
ge nd
ovii
he ame Act a t tque tons ofm ae il fcte s r ga di
, nd ha
si
tra a xit e r ng
w he hert fr ngs we e r t i t y.
t he i i
r e ala or
The r a it y frng pr vii of t FLSA sa es t t 't s l be unl ul f a
etla or ii
o son
he
t t ha ' ha l
i
awf or ny
pe s .t di c r o i a ot m a r dic i i t a i ta e a oye be us s h
r on..o s ha ge r n ny her nne s rm na e ga ns n n pl e ca e uc
e oy ha fl a compl nt.unde orrl e t t sr t. 29U. C.j21 a( .I Wit
mpl ee s ied ny
ai .. r eatd o hi AcJ'
'
S.
5()3) n rz
v Ros Pac a ngComp.367F. 5 ( hCi.l ,heCour hedt 'ul i t wag and
. s k gi
,
2d 49 5t r 966)t
t l hat' nlke he e
l
-
6-
hourpr so ofSeci 6a 7oft (
oviins
tons nd
he FLSAI whih a yonl t a 'mpl e.. ge i
, c ppl y o n e oye .
enga d n
c mmec o i t ep o u to o g o s o c mmec ,t ep o e to o ( rtlao yp o iin
o re rn h r d cin f o d f r o re'h r tcins f t eait r r v so l
he
a y,wihoutqualfcai t 'nyempl e.Thepr bii of(hertlaor pr sonlae
ppl t
ii ton, o a
oye '
ohi tons t eait y ovii r
smia l unlm ie f t y a ediecedt 'ny pe s '
i lry i td, or he r r t o a
r on.Thust cla a unambi
he e r nd
guousl ua
ang ge
oft sat er ut t .viw t tet rt e o orhi e oye m us bee
he t ut ef es he.. e ha ihe he mplyee
s mpl r t ngage i a i tes
d n ctvii
c r d by t Ac ' wa a hourpr sonsi or rf t srcur aga ns di c i i t y
ove e
he ts ge nd
ovii
n de or he ti t es i t s rm na or
dic get be i
s har o nvoke 'Wit,367 F. a 550- . M or r c l J
d.' rz
2d t
511
e e enty, udgeJ da a s r l t t
or n lo ued ha
'th F Sp o bto o r tl to i bo d rta isc v rg o mi mu wa eo o e t
'j e LSA' r hiiin n eai in s ra e h n t o e a e f ni m g r v ri
l
a
me
wa vi ai .'Obr gon v JEP Famiy Entr,I ,71 F. zd 1 11 1 4 ( D.Fl.
ge oltons' e
.
l e . nc. 0 supp. 3 , 31 S. a
zol t tng Wit v ssPack gi C ,367 F. 549,550- ( h Ci.1 66).Theef e
olcii
rz .Ro
a ng X.
2d
551 5t r 9 ) r or,
Pli if 'exe pton fom t pr e i oft wa a hourpr sonsoft FLSA doe not
antfs
m i r he otctons he ge nd
ovii
he
s
pr c u t m fom brngi acl m unde t r alat y frng pr son oft FLSA .
e l de he r
i ng ai
r he et i or ii
ovii
he
To e t ih t i r t laor frng cai , a ntfsmus s
sabls he r e ai t y ii l m Pli if
t how t t y wer fr dbec us
hat he
e ie
a e
oft ra s ton ofsaut y rght,whehe ornotot rgr
hei s eri
t t or i s
t r
he ounds e se f r t dic r 29
xit d o he s ha ge.
U. C. 21 a)3) Ana s tonofsaut yrght wilsil c rdbyt FLSA e nwhe t
S. j 5( ( . seri
tt or i s l tlbe ovee
he
ve
n he
e pl eh amit ke butr as
m oye as
sa n, e onabl,be ift tt e oye i e gi i unl wf c
e le ha he mpl r s nga ng n a ul onduc .
t
Br nnanv Maxe 'Yamah I .51 F. 1 1 ( hCi. 975 .nBr nnan,heEi hCic t
e
.
ys
a,nc, 3 2d 79, 82 8t r 1 ) l e
t ght rui
f ndt thee oy wasnote gi i a
ou ha t mpl er
nga ng n nyvi a i of heFLSA, t t hee pl escoul
olton t
but ha t m oye
d
ha r as bl i e r e t empl r sc
ve e ona y ntm etd he
oye ' onduc asavi a i l a 1 8 TheCou t dt t
t
olton.d t 82- 3.
r hel ha
t Pl ntf m i aken,butl ul as i of t r FLSA rght consiut pr ect actviy
he ai ifs st
awf , serton
hei
i s
tt ed ot ed i t
l it i bi n pr ede i t scicui t ough Bonne v, Ci o ih r , 6lF.d I 0 ,1 0 ( 1h
w rz s ndig ec nt n hi r t hr
r
t fprc a d 6 2 2 6 2 9 1 t
y
ci.1 ) i whiht El ent Cic tadoptd a bi ng prce aI de sonsha down byt f
r 981, n c he ev h r ui
e s ndi e dent l cii
nded
he onner
Fit Cicuibef eO cobe l 1 l
fh r t or t r , 98 .
und t e FLSA.I
er h
d
I t i tntc e,Pl ntfsbe ive t A lxi Tr di Com or i n wa vi a i t
n he nsa as ai if le d hat e m a ng
ato
s oltng he
FLSA ' pr sonsf overi ea r c d ke pi b plci t tm e ke ng mac n i
S ovii or
tm nd e or e ng y a ng he i - epi
hi es ndoor
s
w he e t y wer una l e t Pl ntf s out i of bus ne s hour .Pl ntf s be i ve t t t
r he
e vaiabl o ai i f
s de
i s
s ai i f le d ha he
pur e ofke ng t e mac nesi
pos
epi hes
hi ndoor wa t a d pr ry ac ountng f a lofPl i if '
s s o voi ope l c i or l
antfs
wor nghour andt e or a d pa
ki
s
her f e voi ymentoft i ove tmewa .Pl ntfs ge nebe ift t
her ri
ges ai if ' nui
le ha
t ywe eentte t ove tmepa undert FLSA se e fom t f tt tt y ha bee pad
he r ild o ri
y
he
t mm d r he ac ha he d n i
ove tm e on oc s on,w he vert tm e e r m a hi doc ent d t ext a hour .Thes pror
ri
ca i
ne
he i - nty c ne um e he r
s
e i
i t nc ofove tmepa
nsa es
ri
ygavePli if t r s bl be ift the wer e ildt ove tm epa
antfs he ea ona e le ha t y e ntte o ri
y
unde t FLSA . Ev t
r he
en hough Pl i i f w e e i or e i t r be i f t t w e e e il d t
a ntf s r nc r ct n hei le hat hey r ntte o
ove tm e pa t rcom pl nt t m a ge ent
ri
y, hei
ai s o na m aboutove tm e pa c tt ed a i t pr e t d b
ri
y ons iut ctviy ot c e y
t FLSA .
he
Afe Pli if mades ve al ompli swiht rs r s r gar ngt e pl rsn
t r a ntfs
e r c
ant t hei upe vior e di he m oye ' on-
pa ntofov tm e A l m Tr ng Cor aton fr t .
yme
eri , exi adi
por i ied hem Genui is sofma e i f te s
ne s ue
t ral ac xit
r a di wh he t frng was i r t la i f Pli if 'as eri oft i FLSA rght ,or
eg r ng et r he ii
n e a iton or a ntfs s ton
her
i s
wheherDef nda ha ot ,l tmat r a onsf t frngs Def nda a guest toneoft
t
e nt d her egii e e s
or he ii . e nt r
ha
he
Pli if wa fr a trheha ave bal le cai wihanot rdrve .Pli if countra guet
antfs s ied fe
d r at r ton t
he i r a ntfs
e r hat
t o he drv i ve i t ale c tonwa neiherr prma dno fr a t tt e pl r
he t r i er nvol d n he tr a i
s t e i nde r ied, nd ha he m oye
di not
d havea t lk
c ua now l dgeast t or gi oft a t r a i Re e i t evi e i t lgh
e
o he i n he le c ton. vi w ng he denc n he i t
mos fvorbl t t nonmovi pat t sCour fndst taras bl j ycoul c udet t
t a a e o he
ng ry,hi
ti ha e ona e ur
d oncl ha
Pli if we e fr d i r t la i f t rc
antfs r ie n e a iton or hei ompli s a
a nt boutoveri e pa a t Def nda '
tm
y, nd hat e nts
pr f e r as f t fr ng a e p et xt .Acc di y,que tons ofm at r a f tr ai a
ofer d e ons or he i i r r e ual
or ngl
si
e i l ac em n nd
-
8-
t De e nts M oton f Sum m a y J
he f nda '
i or
r udgm e i de ed on t sCou .
nt s ni
hi
nt
I .C oncl on
V
usi
The De enda ha de onsr t d t t t r a e no m a e i l f c s i diput r r ng
f
nt s m t a e ha he e r
t r a a t n s e ega di
Pli tfs cls ii tonasdrve sunde t M ot Ca e Ac , nd t r f ePli if a ee
a n if ' a sfcai
i r
r he
or ni r t a he e or a ntfs r xempt
f om t ove tm e pr sons of t FLSA .Pl ntf s ha s
r
he
ri
ovi i
he
ai i f ve hown t t t y a e e il d t t
ha he r ntte o he
r t la or trng pr ec i oft FLSA des t t i exe pton f om t ove tm e pr s onsof
e ai t y i i
ot tons he
pie he r m i r he ri
ovi i
t tA c , nd m or ove , he e a e m a e i lf c si di put r ar ng w he he Pl i if w e e fr d i
ha t a
e rt r r
t r a a t n s e eg di
t r a ntf s r ie n
r t la i f as e tng t rFLSA rght . c or ngl i i ,
e a i ton or s r i hei
i s A c di y t s
ADJUDGED t tDef ntsM oi f Summay J
ha
enda ' ton or
r udgment( E.No.1 ,tl on
D.
4) ied
A ugus 5. i G RAN TED w ih r s c t C ou O ne oft Com pl nt butD EN I w ih r pec
t s
t e pe t o
nt
he
ai ,
ED t es t
t CountTwo.
o
#
.
.
DO NE AN D ORD ERED i Cha be s a M i i Fl i t
n
m r t am , orda, hi
FE
I
Co e pr vi d t
pi s o de o:
Co elofRe or
uns
c d
-
9-
S
da ofO c obe ,2011
y
t r
.
C
. O REN O
M
STA TES DI
STR I J GE
CT UD
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?