Henderson v. Astrue
Filing
31
FINAL JUDGMENT GRANTING DEFENDANT'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 9/19/2012. (jw)
U NI
TED STA TES D I
STRI T C O U RT
C
SO UTH ERN DI
STRICT OF FLORI
DA
M I M ID I I O N
A
V SI
CASE NO.11- 20683CVJLK
K ATHY HEN DERSON
o/ o 1 HEN D ER SON ,
b/ .
Pl ntf,
ai if
M I AEL J. STRUE
CH
A
Comm iso rofSocilSec iy,
s i ne
a
urt
Def nda .
e nt
FI
NAL JUDG M ENT GRANTI G
N
D EFEN DA N T ' M O TI N FO R SU M M A R Y JU D G M EN T
S
O
THI CAUSE co e be or t cour upon Pli tf' M o i f Summ a y
S
m s f e he
t
a n ifs ton or
r
J me ( #21 and Defnda ' M oton f Summay J
udg nt DE )
e nts i or
r udgment( /25)1The
DE / .
Cour ha afimeda ado e aJ 28,201 Re ta Rec
t s fr
nd ptd une
2 por nd omme i ($ '
ndatons ç
R&R'
)
b M a itae J d e Ba r Oab ra v sng ta De e d n i e tte t j d me ta a
y gsrt u g ry r e d ii h t fn a t s nild o u g n s
m at ro l w.Fort r s nsdic s d beow,t Cour fndst tDe e nts moton
te f a
he ea o
s us e l
he
t i ha f nda '
i
e
di y, antf s
fr s mmay j dg n agai t Pl i if must be grantd and,accor ngl Pli if'
o u r u me t ns antf
m oto m us bede e
in
t
nid.
L BACKGROUND
1 Hendes tt ama ' wa frtdi nos wih atntondefci hy rci t
.
ron dcli nt' s is ag ed t te i
l
i t pea tviy
diode (C
sr r C
ADHD' whe he was s ve i 2004.Si e t t tme,te t
'
)
n
e n, n
nc ha i
rament of 1
.
Hende s s A D HD ha not r quied hos t lz i n, e e d ps a rc c r or
r on'
s
e r
pia i ato
xt nde
ychi t i a e
1Pl ntf' M oton f Summar J me wasfld on Se e
ai ifs i or
y udg nt
ie
ptmber2,20ll OnNove
.
mebe 2,2011
r
,
Dee d n fldi ownMoinfrS mmayJ d me t n icu e i iaRepo s ( # 6 t
fn a t ie t
s
to o u r u g n a d n ld d n t s n e DE 2 ) o
Pli ifsm oto Pl ntf di notr pond orrpl
antf'
in. ai if d
es
e y,
i e v nton t oug a c ii sa lzai pr a and ' s i ele t la ltes a e no
nt r e i hr h rss tbii ton ogr m
' nt l cua biii r t
hi
sgniia l i r ' ( #29,p.2) Ho r whe no medi td a rc
i fc nty mpaied. DE
'
. weve , n t
cae s e omme d
nde
by hi physca ,1 He r o d be n i puli ,e sl dita t d,a on oc son,
s
i ins . nde s n d
has e m sve a iy sr c e nd,
ca i
a e sve.I He a s ha be n dignos wih dyshymi , oppostona defa e
ggr s i
d
lo s e a
ed t
t
a2
ii l inc
dior r3a 1a ni dior r a ashm a. d
s de , e r ng s de , nd t
I
I 2006, Pli if Ka hy He r on tl a c am f Supplm e al Sec iy
n
antf
t
nde s ied
l i or
e nt
urt
I ome on be l of he t n ni yea - d s n.Pl ntf cai wa de ed by t
nc
ha f
r he ne- rol o
ai ifs l m
s ni
he
SocalSec iy Adm i sr ton,t n by Adm i sr tve La J
i
urt
nita i he
nita i
w udge Ti hy M ahe ,a
mot
r nd
fnal by a a a s c
i ly
n ppe l ounci r vi ng J
l e ewi udge M a r Pl i ifnow u g t s Cour t
he . antf
r es hi
to
r re a e r
eve s s roneous J
udge M a rs de son detr i ng t t Pl ntf s n was not
he ' cii
e m ni ha ai ifs o
di a e as defne by t Soc a Se iy Ac a t r f r not e il t dia lt
s bld
i d
he
i l curt
t nd he e o e
ntted o s biiy
b ne isor alem a i l t r m a Pl i ifscai f rf t rev u i
e ft , t tve y, o e nd antf ' l m o urhe al aton.
I .LEGAL STANDARD
I
Ge eal,s mma yj d me ti a p o raewheetepla ig a d s p o t
n rly u r u g n s p r p it
r h e dn s n u p ri
ng
matras e t ih t t t r i no ge ne i s as t a ma e i l f a t t t
e i l sabls ha he e s
nui s ue
o ny t ra act nd ha he
mo igp ryi e tte t j d me ta amatro lw.Se Fe .R.Ci P. 6 Ceo e
vn a t s n ild o u g n s te f a
e d
v. 5 ; ltx
Cor r Catet 477 U. 31 322 ( 986) The movi pat b r t bur n of
p. . r t,
S. 7,
1 .
ng ry eas he de
poi i t t pa toft r c d t ts
ntng o he r
he e or ha hows t a e e ofa ge ne is of ma e i
he bs nc
nui s ue
t ral
f t s eAdik sv S.L Krs ( Co,398U. 1 1 ( 970) a trwhih t buden
ac, e c e . I es f .
S. 44, 57 1 , fe c he r
s fs t t nonmovi pa t t go be
hit o he
ng ry o
yond t pl di a desg t ts cii f c s
he ea ngs nd i nae spe fc a t
s
howi t t t e i a ge ne is f ti .' Cel e 477 U . a 32 s al
ng ha her s
nui s ue or ral'
otx,
S. t 4; ee so
2 fr o c rncd p eso mak db rg al lw mo d ,h u hn t ssv r a mao d p eso
A o m f ho i e r sin re y e ulry o o s to g o a e ee s j r e r sin.
Se A. A. .M e ca Encycopedi he :/ w.c . m. h. pu dheat / Hooolgl .
e D. M
di l
l a, /w n binl ni gov/ bme lh pM
6/
3M o ec
r ommonl s n i boys opposto defanc dior i apatm ofbe ort i diobedint
y ee n
,
iin i e s der s te
havi hat s s
e ,
hosie,a defa t r pe s i a t rt Se A. A. .M e c Encycopedi
tl nd int owad r ons n uho iy. e D. M
dial
l
a,
hlp:/
/www. binl ni gov/
nc . m. h. pubmedhe t
alipM Hooozso4/
.
2
2d 472,1 ( 1h Ci.1 )
477 1 t r 991
Ch n l I c v Ia inAcie a o Fl. I . 931 F. 1
a e, n . . tla tv we r f a, nc,
or d t gnii , oba i
( di t t t nonmovi pa t mus Scom e f w ar w ih si fcant pr tve
hol ng ha he
ng ry
tt
e d e de tai t e se e of a ti e is of fc.'.On a moton f
vienc monsrtng he xitnc
rabl sue
a t'
)
i or
s mmayj d me t t e c u t s ve t e e ie e a d r s le alifrnc si t e
u r u g n, h o r mu t iw h vd nc n e ov 1 n ee e n h
lg mos f vo abl t t nonmovi pary. SeeAnder on v fi ry Lobb I . 477
iht
t a r e o he
ng t
s . be t
y, nc ,
U. 2 2 25 ( 9 6 . ft e i e c o frd b teno mo igpa t i meey c lr be
S. 4 , 5 1 8 ) I he v d n e fee y h n vn ry s r l oo a l
o i n t infc n l p o aie s mmayj d me t sp o e . ei a 2 - 0
r s o sg iia ty r b tv , u r u g n i r p rSe d t 49 5 .
Th sc s i lc tsa a dto a c n ieain a te s mma yj d me tsa e
i a e mp iae n d iin l o sd r to t h u r u g n tg
b c u ei iv l e rv e o ad cso b a a mi srtv lw j d e($ '. ou h
e a s t n o v s e iw f e iin y n d nitaie a u g ( ' Th g
ALJ )
t c tr vi wst ALJSf c ua fndi wih def r nce t Cour g vesno de er nc
he our e e he
' a t l i ngs t
e e , he
ti
f e e
t hi lgalo ni .The Co tr viwst ALJ' de ii t s e t ti i s
o se
pi ons
ur e e he
S c son o e ha t s uppore by
td
s tntale d e a bas d on pr
ubsa i vi enc nd e
operl lsanda ds Elion v Bar
ega t r . ls . nhar,355 F.
t
3d
1 2,1 ( 1h Ci.2003)(ntr lciai omitd) The que ton t Cour mus
27 275 1 t r
i ena ttons te .
si he
t t
a we i whehe t A LJere i hi a i ton of1w t f t .
ns r s t r he
r d n s pplca i
a o ac s
1 DI
11. SCUSSI
ON
A c l unde t ag of 1 i dia e u r t Socil Se urt Actçi t
hid
r he e
8 s s bl d nde he
a c iy
if hat
i vi lhasa me c l de e mi bl physca orme a i ime ,whih r s t i
ndi dua
di aly t r na e
i l
nt l mpar nt
c e uls n
mar a s ve e f tona lm ia i ,a whih c n be e ced t r ul i deah or
ked nd e r unci l i ttons nd
c a
xpe t o es t n t
whih has lse orc n be e
c
a td
a
xpece t l s f a c i
td o a t or ontnuousperod ofnotl s t n 1
i
es ha 2
mo ts' 4 U. C.j 1 8 ca ( )C)i.A c id wh me t t a o e ciei wilb
nh . 2 S.
'
3 2 ()3( () h l o es he b v rtra l e
e ild t diabiiy i ur nc be is unl s t y enga i t ubsan i gai ul
ntte o s lt ns a e neft
e s he
ge n l t tal nf
s
a tviy. 42 U. C.j 1 ()3( (i.To e l t whet r a c l i dia ed as
ci t '
'
S.
382ca ()C)i)
vauae
he hid s s bl
d fn d b teSo ilS c rt Ac,a a miitaielw j dg u e atr ese a ay i
eie y h ca e u iy t n d n sr t a u e s s h e -tp n lss
v
3
p o ie byt eCo eofFe ea Re uain . e 2 C. R.j 41 .2 ()( ) Fis,he
r vd d h d
d r l g lto s S e 0 F.
69 4 a -d . rt t
ALJ de e m i s whehe t cli a i wor ng a wheher t t wor c tt es
t r ne
t r he am nt s
ki nd
t
ha
k onsiut
g if le o me t 20 C. R.j 41 .2 *) S c nd te ALJ d tr ne wh t e t e
an u mply n.
F.
69 4 . e o , h
ee mi s eh r h
cai ntsmedi li nne i sver 20C. R.j41 92 .Fi ly,t ALJl
l ma '
ca mpai nt s e e.
F.
6. 4/) nal he
ooks
t wh t e te i ar n t el) me ial e u ls,o fncin ly e u ls' t
o eh r h mp ime t d ts, dc l q a g) r u to al q all' he
me
y
lse i i ne t. 0 C. R. 41 .2 * . J d eGab rn tdi hsR&R, h st r
itd mpan n s 2 F. j 69 4( As u g r e oe n i
t i hid
se i pe f r d by a s pa ae i uiy i t sx cha a t rsi oft c l sf toni
tp s r o me
e r t nq r n o i
r c e itcs he hid' unc i ng:
$ )ac rnga usng i omai ( at ng a co ei ts ;()i eaci
ç quii nd i nfr ton; 2) tendi nd mpltng a ks 3 ntr tng
(1
a d r ltn wi oh r;( ) mo ig a o t a d ma iu ai obe t;( ) c rn f r
n eaig t te s 4 vn b u n
h
np lt
ng j cs 5 a ig o
o s l;a d ( )man anig he lh a p y ia welb ig. ( # 9 p 7 ( ing 2
ne ef n 6 iti n at nd h sc l l- en ' DE 2 , . ct 0
'
i
C. R.j41 926a( ( ).
F.
6. b)1)
he val t d r ha
ge
am nts xhi t tii
J e M a r e ua e m o e t n 300 pa s of Cl i a ' e bis dea lng,
udg
i e ala,te tng physcans not ,r cor of ps hol c esi an ac de i
ntr i r ai
ii ' es e ds
yc ogialt tng, d a m c
pe f manc a s hoolbe or J e M ah f
ror
e, nd c
havi . udg
er ound t tCli antha note ge i
ha am
d
nga d n
s t nta ganf a tviy and s f r d fo t e s ve alm e ca i im e s ADHD,
ubsa il i ul c i t
ufe e r m hr e e r
di l mpar nt :
a lani dior ,a oppostonaldefa dior r ( a DE # 1 1 p.22)
e r ng s der nd
ii
ince s de . R. t
5- ,
.
Howe r J
ve , udge M a rco ude t t1 Hende s smedi li im e sdi no m e t
he ncl d ha .
r on'
ca mpar nt d t e
o medialy e
r
c l qual t lse i im e t o a f nci l e va e unde t sx
he itd mpar n s r ' tona qui l nt
u
r he i
c r ctrsis of a c l s f toni I Thus J
ha a e itc
hid' unc i ng. d
, udge M ahe c ude t tCl mant
r oncl d ha ai
was notdia e unde t Soca Sec iy Ac a t r o e noten il t dia lt
s bld
r he
il urt
t nd he ef r
tted o s biiy
i u a e be tt . d
ns r nc nei s I
Plitf' moi n frs mma yj d me tldg sf u man atc so te d na
anifs to o u r u g n o e o r i t k n h e il
a
o b n ft: 1 J d eM a rsd cso ûsn ts p o tdb tes b tni l ih o t e
f e eis ( ) u g he ' e ii n i o u p re y h u sa ta weg t f h
i
4
evi nc '( #21 p.20) ( J M a rer i fii t dic ss ofPl nifs
de e' DE ,
; 2) udge he red n alng o s us ome
aitf'
s n' sholsi ts sors ( ) J
o s c atc et c e ; 3 udge M a e rd i dimisng o oft te tng
her re n s s i ne he rai
physcin' ase s nt;a ( J e Mahe lc a a quat undesa ng of
i a s ssme s nd 4) udg
r a ked n de e
rtndi
at i n de i tdior r
tento fci s de .
Co v rey De e d n ' moin fr s mma y j d me tag e t a Plitf s
n es l , fn a ts to o u r u g n r u s h t an if
a a i wihoutme i.l pa tc a ,De enda r ciest r c d be or J
ppe l s t
rt n riulr f nt e t he e or f e udge M a
her
de onsr tng t tCl i a ' m e c i ime wa notf tona l equi l ntt a
m tai ha am nts dial mpa r nt s
unc i ly
va e o
lse i nne be us Cli i l c d a ma ke lmia i i ac rng a usng
it d mpai nt ca e a mant a ke
r d i t ton n quii nd i
i onna i a i a tndi a c
nf
ton nd n te ng nd ompltng t ks ha a l st n m a ked lm iai i
e i as ; s es ha
r
i t ton n
c rng f hi el a mai ai ng hi he lh a we lbe ng;and ha no lm iaton i
a i or ms f nd
nt ni
s at nd l- i
d
i ti n
itrcig a d r ltng wi oh r o i ma p ltn o j cs ( # ,p 1 -1 )
n ea tn n eai
t t es r n niuaig b e t. DE 25 p. 3 7 .
h
De e nta gue t tt r co d pr de s t ntalevi nc u whi J
f nda r s ha he e r ovi s ubsa i
de e pon ch udge M a r
he
co d de de t tPl i ifs s wa notdiabl a de i by t Soc a Se urt Ad
ul ci ha antf on s
s ed s fned
he i l c iy
a d ta,h rf r , fn a ti e tt dt j dg n a amatro lw.
n h tt eeo e De e d n s nil o u me t s te f a
e
The Cou tfndsno obvi e r wih t ALJ Sf t fndi .M o eove ,t
r
ous ror t he
' acual i ngs
r r he
Cour fnds t t J e M a r appled pr pe l l sa r i e l tng Cl i a '
ti
ha udg
he
i
o r ega t nda ds n va ua i
am nts
elg biiy unde t sa u e.The quesi t i whe he J
i i lt
r he t t t
ton hen s
t r udge M a rs de a of
he ' nil
dia lt be ist Pl i ifss wa s
s biiy neft o antf on s uppore by s t nta e denc
td
ubsa il vi e.
J d eGab rsR&R n tsta S clama ts e t mia p e n tea p ia l
u g re'
oe h ts li n e ms o s p rhe d h p lc b e
l
sa r ofr vi ...bor outby hi r pe t d r f e est the s t nta weghtof
t nda d
e ew
ne
s e a e e er nc o t ubs a i l i
e d e.' ( #29,p.9) The sa r ofrviw i,i d,muc nar rt n
vienc '' DE
.
tndad e e s ndee
h rowe ha
Pli if s
antf uggess df e Co tm a not ...r wei t e denc or s tt e is own
t.t'
-h
ur y
e gh he vi e
ubsiut t
j d me f r t to t e ALJ rg r ls o wh te t e Co r fes i wo d h v
u g nt o ha f h
, e a de s f eh r h u t e l t ul a e
r ol d contit i t e de e dif r nty ha i r viwe t r c d a hea d t
es ve
lc s n he vi nc fe e l d t e e d he e or nd r he
tsi
etmonyi t frti tnc 'Pate s v Asr ,2011W L 837744,* ( D. a Fe
n he is nsa e. tr on . tue
'
2 S. Fl. b.
1 2011 ( tng Mie v Chatr 8 F. 1
0, ) cii
ls . e , 4 3d 397,1 ( 1h Ci.1 ) So lng a t
400 1 t r 996). o s he
r c d i ude s tnta e de e upon whih t ALJ c d have bas hi decson,
e or ncl s ubsa i l vi nc
c he
oul
ed s ii
t sCour i pr bie fom r ver i t tdecson.C n i t evi e pr ponde at
hi
t s ohi t d r e sng ha
ii t
Eve f he denc e
r es
a i tt Comm isone ' fndi ,we mus a fr i t dec son r ac d i s
ga ns he
s i rs i ngs
t fim f he ii e he s uppore
td
by s tnta e de e.'Elion v Bar t 355 F.d 1
ubsa il vi nc ' ls . nhar,
3 272, 1 ( 1h Ci.2003
275 1 t r
)
(n en l uoe a d ctto o te ) Plitf,nh rmo inf rs mmayj d me th s
itr a q ts n iain mi d . an if i e to o u r u g n, a
t
done not ng t dipr t abunda ofe de e s
hi o s ove he
nce vi nc uppori J e M ahe ' dec son.
tng udg
rs ii
By m e e y poi i t e de e t c d s
rl
ntng o vi nc hat oul uppor a c l i n c r r t t r ac d
t onc uso onta y o hat e he
by t A LJ i note
he
s
nough.
Pl i ifs o he at c on t ALJ' de ii t the e r i f lng t dic s
antf' t r ta ks
he
S cson ha
red n aii o s us
s
ome of Cli nts s hol si t s s or s a i dim isng one of t teai
a ma ' c a tc e t c e nd n s s i
he r tng
physc a sa s s nt ,a t the lc a ade t unde sandi ofat nton de i t
ii n' s es me s nd ha
a ked n qua e
r t ng te i
fci
dior r alo a e eiherwihoutme i,ir lvant or a t ve y las,i ufi e t
s de
s r t
t
rt r ee , , t he r e t ns fcint o
s t i a fndi t tt ALJe r d.
usan i ng ha he
re
1 1 C ONCLUS ON
1.
I
The r or i r plt wih e de e s
ec d s e e e t vi nc uppori J
tng udge M a r s de son t de
he ' cii o ny
Su e
pplment Sec iy I ome t Pl i ifss a J
al urt nc
o antf on, nd udge M ahe ' de i i was b e
rs c son
as d
o p o e lg lsa d r . ee oe Dee d n , n n tPli tf, se t ld t j d me t
n rp r e a tn ads Th r fr , fn a t a d o anif i ni e o u g n
t
as a m a t r of l , A c or ngl upon c r ul c i r ton of t r cor and bei
te
aw
c di y,
a ef ons de a i
he e d
ng
ot r ie f l a s d,i i O R D ER ED ,AD JU DG ED .a D EC REED t
he w s uly dvi e t s
nd
hat
6
1 D e enda ' M oto f Sum m a y J gme ( #25) be,a i hee
. f
nt s
i n or
r ud nt DE
nd s rby,
G R AN TED .
2. Pli ifs Moton f Su
antf
i or mmar J
y udgment ( #21 be,and i hee
DE
)
s rby,
D ENIED .
The Clr i die t t CLO SE t sca e.
e k s r ced o
hi s
DONE and ORDERED i c
n hambe sa t J mesLa e e Ki Fe r lJ tce
r t he a
wr nc ng de a usi
t e, ami orda, t hi 9t
y
Buidi a Unie Stt Courhous M i , Fl i da ed t s 1 h da of
l ng nd
t d a es
Se e r 201
ptmbe , 2.
/
V
V
*
'
b
.
'
'
.
J
A,-'
' '
.
'
5
g
ES LAW REN CE KI
NG
I S
TED TATES DI TRI J
S CT UDGE
SOUTHEM DI
STRI OF FLORI
CT
DA '
Cc:Cl r ofC ourt
ek
Coun efo Pl nt
s l r ai W
A dam Scot Nei
t denber
g
A da N ei nbe g,PA
m
de r
7067 D .W es Br a d Boul va d
t ow r
e r
Pl nt ton,FL 33317
a ai
Co eforDe nd nt
uns l
fe a
Chr s opher M ac arol
it
chi i
U S Ator y' O fi
t ne s fce
99 N E 4t Stee
h r t
M i i FL 331
am ,
32
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?