Carnival Corporation v. Operadora Aviomar S.A. de C.V. et al
Filing
46
ORDER Granting 38 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Jurisdiction Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 8/8/2012. (jw)
UN I
TED STA TES DI
STRICT C OU RT
SO UTH ERN D I
STR I O F FLO R I
CT
DA
M I IDI I O N
AM
V SI
CA SE NO .11 20687- J
CV- LK
CARN I
VAL CO RPORATI
ON
d/ a CARN I L CRU I LI ES,
b/
VA
SE N
Pl ntf ,
ai if
OPER AD ORA AV I AR S. .de C. .
OM
A
V,
D ef
endant
.
/
O RDER GR ANTI G M O TI N TO D I ISS FO R LA CK O F SUBJECT
N
O
SM
M ATTER JUR I C TION
SDI
TH I M A TTER com es bef e t Courtupon D ef
S
or he
endantOpe ador Avi arS. .
r a
om
A
d C. ' M oint Dimisf rLa k ofS j c M atrJ idcin ( /38 ,fld o
e V.S to o s s o c
ube t te urs ito DE / ) ie n
A prl 30,201 The Cour i f l bref on t m aterlUpon car ulcons de a i of
i
2.
t s uly i ed
he
t .
ef
i r ton
t Pari ar ent ,t Cour fndst ti m us dim i st above- t e ac i
he tes' gum s he
t i ha t t s s he
syl d ton.
L BACKGROUND
Thi i a br h of conta ac i bet ee Pl ntf Car val Com or i
s s
eac
r ct ton
w n ai if
ni
aton
(i r va' a d De e da Ope a o a Avi r S. d C. (s o r'.Pl itf
û ni l) n
ca
'
f n nt r d r
oma A. e V. û ma ' an if
Avi
)
Car va i a c por i or ni d pur ua t t l ws of Pana a,w ih is prnci
ni l s or aton ga ze
s nt o he a
m
t t i pal
plc ofb i s i M imi Fl rda ( Co . 3 DE #3 . fnda Avima i a
a e usne s n a , o i . Am. mpl ! ,
7) De e nt o r s
lPl ntf Car valfldaRes e( #42- )onM a 23,201 a Dee nt
ai if ni ie
pons DE
1
y
2, nd fnda
Avima fldaRe y( #44)o J 1 201
o r ie
pl DE
n une 5, 2.
f egn c mpa y wi isprn i l a eofbusne sl a e i Yuc t n, e c .(t a !
or i o n t t i cpa plc
h
i s oc t d n aa M xi o 11 t
4) On Fe r ay 28 2 1 Pli iffld a Co a n i t a ove syld a to a i t
.
b u r , 01 , antf ie
mpli t n he b -t e c in gans
D ef ntAvi arz s ng declr t y decr and da ages f D ef
enda
om , eeki
a a or
ee
m
or endant Avi ar s
om '
al
leged f l e t i
aiur o ndemniy Pl ntf Car valf m ai enance and cur pr de t an
f ai if ni or
nt
e ovi d o
e oy eo Plitf Cania whowa ij e d rnga ATV rd ofee b Dee a
mpl e f anif r v l
s nurd u i n
ie fr d y fnd nt
Avima i Ac pulo, e c ( mpl, #1 . Co a n ha snc b e a nd d
o r n a c M xio. Co .DE ) The mpli t s i e e n me e ,
a t A m e d Com pl nti now t oper i pl di
nd he
nde
ai s
he
atve ea ng.
A cc di t t A m ended Com pl nt Pl ntf Car vala D ef ntAvi a
or ng o he
ai , ai if ni nd
enda
om r
ent r
e ed i o a St ndar Shor Exc si l pe nt Contact Agr m e
nt
a d
e
ur on nde nde
r or
ee nt
(ç g e me ' o ç e l ng i e t c n r c ' o o a u Oc o r 7,20 4.(
$ r e nt' r ç ryi nd mniy o ta t' n r bo t t be
A
und
)
0 Am.
Co . 1 . r u n t t Ag e me , f nd n Av o rofe e s r e u so t
mpl! 6) Pu s a t o he r e nt De e a t i ma f r d ho e xc ri ns o
pas enger of Pl ntf Ca ni ls s ps. The Agr m e s ie t t D ef nda
s
s
ai if r va ' hi
ee nt peci d ha
e nt
equied o ndem niy
f
A vi ar w as r ponsbl f obt ni labiiy i ur
om
es
i e or ai ng i lt ns ance, and r r t i
Pl ntf Ca ni if al l s ,cl m s la ltes da ages,caus of a i l
ai if r val çor l os es ai , ibiii , m
es
cton, egalf ,
ees
a cos sand expe esw hi m ay a ie orbe cl i ed agai tCARN I
nd t
ns
ch
rs
am
ns
VAL r at d t i
el e o, n
c
onnec i w ih, as a cons que e of or ars ng f om t busnes or o r tons of
ton t
e nc
ii r
he
i s
pe a i
AVI AR. ( Compl!1 . Age me as p o d st ti d h l bego r d
OM ' Am.
'
. 6) The re nt lo r vie ha tç al
s
vene
t he ne al
ii
he
t
a es
by and consru i a dance w ih t G e r M artm e Law of t Unied St t
t ed n ccor
a d o t La oft S a eo Fl rda U. A . ( r e n ! 1 e , /3 1 .
n / r he ws he t t f o i , S. ' Ag e me t 4( ) DE / 7- )
'
2D e e ntA CE Am e i a I u anc Com pa wasvol a iy di m i s on M a c 28,
f nda
r c n ns r e
ny
unt r l s s ed
rh
201 prort t flngoft Ame dCompli .( #36)
2, i o he ii
he
nde
ant DE
.
2
On Fe ua y 29,2008,i A c co,M exi a em pl
br r
n apul
co, n
oyee of Pl ntf Ca ni l
ai if r va
s sane pes a ij res d i a ATV s r e urin o e a o rtd by
u ti d ron l nu i urng n
ho e xc so wn d nd peae
De e a tAvima .( Co .! 8) Sic t n,Pli tf Ca ni lha be n pa n
f nd n
o r Am. mpl . n e he a n if r va s e yig
m antnance and cur i e ss of$500, 00,t t e oyee i acc da wih
ie
e, n xce
000. o he mpl
n or nce t
fd rlmaii lw.(d.a ! 11.Se ge r l Lo ho e a Habo W okes
e ea rtme a 1 t
) e neal ngs r nd r r r r '
y
Co ns to Ac,3 U. C. j 901 e s q. U. C.j 301 4 (ç J ne Ac' .
mpe ai n t 3 S. A.
t e ;46 S.
0 çhe o s t'
t
)
Pur ua t t A gr em ent ai if Car val has t nder is def e t D ef nda
s nt o he
e
,Pl ntf
ni
e ed t
ens o
e nt
Avo ra s e ri ure nta i e t f rt ij re s ti d byPlitf
ima nd e ks emb s me nd nd mni o he nu is usane
y
anif
Ca n va ' e o e ( Co ,! 1 ) De e a tAvi r ha net e a c p e t
r i ls mplye . Am. mpl 8 . f nd n
oma s ih r c e t d he
d f n e n i d mnii d Pli if Ca nva . (#.. W i t i tn a to Pli if
e e s or n e fe antf r i l f ) t he nsa t c in, antf
h
Cani la s rs c ams a i t De e a Av o rf r Br a h of Con r c ( un 1;
r va s e t li gans f nd nt i ma o e c
ta t Co t )
Eq t b el de t ( nt1) Co rbu i n ( nt11;a De lr t r Rei f( n
uia l n mniy Cou 1; nti to Cou 1) nd ca a o y le Cou t
1 . Am. mpl) Be o et e Cou t i De e nt o rsM o i t Dimisf
V) ( Co .. f r h
r now s f nda Avima ' ton o s s or
La kofSu j c MatrJ rs ito ( oint Dimis DE #38 .
c
b e t te u idcin.M to o s s ,
)
I .D I
I SCUSSI
ON
l t a ov -tld a ton Plitf Cania le st tt sCo r ha s j c
n he b e sye ci , anif r v lalge ha hi u t s ube t
matrj rs cin pu s n t 28 U. C.jj 1 31 1 2 a d 1 33.M or s cfc l
te u idito rua t o
S.
3 , 33 , n 3
e pe iial
y,
Plitf Canv lalg st tt sCo r ha fdea q sinj rs ito un r28U. C.
anif r ia le e ha hi u t s e r l ueto u idcin de
S.
j 1 ,be a s Pli if Ca ni lha be n pa ng m an e nc a c r pu s ntt
331 c u e antf r va s e yi
i t na e nd u e rua o
f de a lw.( Co .! 1 DE #3 .I a dii n,Pli tf Cani lague t a t s
e r l a Am. mpl ,
7) n d to an if r va r s h t hi
Co t ha a miat j id ci n u e 28 U. C. j 1 3, b c us t u e l i
ur s d r ly urs ito nd r
S.
33 e a e he nd ryng
i m nii ton contacti a m a ii e contact pur ua t whi Pl ntf Ca ni lse ks
nde fca i
r s
rtm
r , s nt o
ch ai if r va e
Def ntAvi a s def ns a i
enda
om r'
e e nd ndem ni i of c ai s under t ge r m a ii e
icaton
lm
he ne al rtm
lws ofmantna e c e,a u e wo t ne s (d..Fi l Pli tf Cani la s rs
a
i e nc , ur nd ns a rhi s . 1 4 nal a n if r va s e t
y,
ta t r q rme t o di riyj idito u e 28U. C.j 1 2 aeme,be a e
h t he e uie ns f vest urs cin nd r
S.
33 r t c us
t am ount i contove s i above $75, 00 and Pl ntf Car val mai ans is
he
n
r ry s
000.
ai if ni
nti t
prnci pl of busnes i Fl i w hie D ef nda A vi a m ai ai is prnci l
i pal ace
i s n orda
l
e nt om r
nt ns t i pa
plc ofb i s i M e i o.1 a ! 2 .
a e usne s n x c (d. t )
W ih t i t ntM oton t D im i s D ef ntA vi arc l
t he ns a
i o s s , enda
om
halenges a1 ofPl ntf
1
ai i f
Ca ava' g o dsfrs j c matrj idito M oes csc l De e a tAvi r
n i ls r un o ube t te urs cin. r pe i al fnd n oma
y,
m a nt nst a lofPl ntf Car valscl m sa i e undercontact a oppos d t f a
i ai hat l
ai if ni ' ai r s
r ,s
e o eder l
1w o ge r lmaii lws s a n t i o j idito u ret r28U. C.j
a r nea rtme a , o s ot o nv ke urs cin nde ihe
S.
1 o 28U. C.j1 33,na dii ,Dee ntAvi rag est tc mplt di riy
331 r
S.
3 I d ton fnda
oma r u ha o ee vest
i l ki whe e Pl ntf Ca ni i i
s ac ng
r ai if r val s ncom or t i Pana a and D ef nt Avi ar
a ed n
m
enda
om
m ai ai is prnci lpl ofbusne i M e co.
nt ns t i pa ace
i ss n xi
A prnci t nt of f r l ci lpr dur i t t f al cours ar c t of
i pal ena
ede a vi oce e s ha eder
t e ours
lmie j rs iton.Se ge r l Mo rs n v Alsat I de Co , 2 F.d 1 5,
i td u idc i
e ne a l r io . lt e n m. . 28 3 25
y
1 0 . ( 1h Ci. 0 ( x l i ng t twihi t b un ofAri l 11 f d r lc rs
26 -61 1 t r 200 ) e p ani ha t n he o ds
tc e 1, e e a ou t
ma he ro yt ec s sfrwhih Con r s ha g a e j rs ito . hee a hee a
y a nl hos ae o
c
g e s s rntd u idcin) W r , s r,
cour fnds t a acton does m eett r quiem e s oft pl ntf a s t gr
ti
han n i
he e r nt
he ai i fs s ered ounds
frs j c matr urs ito i mus dimist a to
o ube t te j idcin,t t s s he cin.
4
A.TheCl msAs e t d a
ai
s re ndReifRe se
le que tdDoNot ie Und rFe e al w
Ars
e d r La
Pli ifCani lsfrta s re gou f s jc matrj rs ito i fdea
antf r va' is se td r nd or ube t te u idcin s e rl
33 g a ig e ea ou t rgi l uiditon ve tes ha
q si n.2 U. C.j 1 1(rntn fd rlc rso i na j rs ci o rmatr t t
ue to 8 S.
ars unde f al lw,te te ,a t Un t d S a e
ie
r eder a r ai s nd he ie t tsCon tt to .I t Ame de
siu in) n he
n d
Compl nt Pl ntf Ca ni l a s t cl m s f br ach of c r t equia e i m niy,
ai , ai i f r va s ers ai or e
ontac ,
t bl nde t
c nti to a d de lr t r r lela 1se ig fo t e lga rg s c e r d b t
o rbu in, n ca a o y e it 1 tmm n r m h e l iht onfre y he
u ryig i e fc to c nta t (
nde l n nd mnii ai n o r c. Am. Co .. As a ba i f f d r l q si n
mpl
)
ss or e e a ue to
j rs cin,t Ame de Complitsae t tr s ltono iscamsa ans Dee nt
u idito he
n d
an tts ha e oui f t li g i t fnda
A vi arne s r l i ves a a yss oft e pl
om
ces a iy nvol
n nal i
he m oyee' f r l bas m ai e nce
s ede aly- ed
nt na
a c r ca msa ans Plitf Cani l (d4 l c n r s,De e ntAvi ma a g s
nd u e li g i t an if r va . 1 .. n o ta t fnda
o r r ue ,
a t Cour agr ,t t Pl ntf Car vals cl m s, abs a i pe nt cl m s
nd he
t ees ha ai if
ni ' ai
ent ny nde nde
ai
under f al l w , r a e onl t t e or e of t underyi i
eder a
el t
y o he nf cem nt
he
l ng ndem nii i
fcaton
c n r c, whih doe notis l i ok a f d r l q e to ( o i n, a 7 ) Upon
o ta t
c
s
tef nv e e e a u si n. M to t -8 .
consde a i of t cl m s a s t and t r i r
i r ton
he ai s ered
he elef eque t i t A m ended Com pl i ,
s ed n he
a nt
t Cour fndst t at
he
ti
ha , lhough Pl ntf Cam i ' oblgaton t is empl e ars under
ai if
vals i i o t
oye i es
f de al lw , a r i a l e t Pl i if Car val i t i t m ate derves
e r a
ny elef vaiabl o a ntf
ni
n he nsant
tr
i
excl i y fom is contac ua r l i hi wih D ef nda A vi a .A cc di y, a
usvel r
t
r t l e atons p t
e nt om r
or ngl s
t Am ended Com pl ntdoesnotalege any c ai s a ii under t Consiuton,l ,
he
ai
l
l m rsng
he
tt i aws
or tea i of t Unied St es t Cour fnds t t Pl ntf Ca ni ' c ai s do not
r tes
he
t
at , he
ti
ha ai i f r vals l m
c mewih nt s j c matrof28U. C. 1 31
o
t i he ub e t te
S. j 3 .
5
B.TheAgr m e I N ota M arii e Cont
ee nt s
tm
ract
Pli if Ca i ls s c a s re g o nd f r s b e t matr j rs ito i
antf m va ' e ond s e td r u o u j c te u id ci n s
a r ly,a i a lge ha t Agr e nt i a ma ii c ta t 28 U. C. j 1 33
dmia t s t le st t he e me s
rtme on r c .
S.
3
(rntng fd rl c u t e l i j rs ci ov r a miat a maii c ss.
g a i e e a o rs xcusve u iditon e d r ly nd rtme a e )
W h t rac nta ti maii i n t ea s be tt afdea c r'j rs ci und r
ehe o r c s rtme n aur nd u j c o e r l ou ts u iditon e
28U. C.j 1 33 d pe so ûhenaur oft c nta t a t whehe i ha r fr nc t
S.
3 e nd n d
t t e he o r c, s o t r t s e e e e o
maii sr ieo maii ta a tons'Se Nor l S. Co.v Kib 5 U. 1
rtme e vc r rtme rnsci . e fok Ry.
'
. ry 43 S. 4,
2 ( 4 ( ii g N Pa .S. t v Hal Br he sMarne Ry.t Shl bul n Co ,2
4 200 ) ctn
c S. %. . l ot r
i
f p idig . 49
U. 11 ,1 4 ( 91 ) A ma ii c nta ti o t td ea e t a s p i isu ea s c
S. 9 2 1 9).
rtl o r c s ne ha d lts o hi n t s s u h,
ne
r
or t com m er or t na ga i on na ga e wat r ,or t tans t i by s or t
o
ce, o vi ton
vi bl
es
o r poraton
ea, o
m a ii e o nt'Se JA. , nc v M / a y Lu il , 3 F. 96 ( t Ci.1 2 .
rtme mplyme . e R.I . . VL d cle 96 2d 5 h r 99 )
'
For i t
nsance,a contac f She tans t i ofgoods by s ' even i a por i oft
r t or s r poraton
t
eas'
f
ton
he
ta pora i i on l nd, as wel as contac s f t r i of a s p a e ge aly
r ns tton s
a
l
r t or he epa r
hi r
ner l
a c ptda maii c nta t. rokS.Ry.Co. 5 U. a 24. c nta t c nta t
c e e s rtme o rcs Nof l
, 43 S. t By o r s, o r cs
t a e m e el i de al t m artm e ac i t s h a t e S ade on l
hat r
r y nci nt o
ii
tviy, uc s hos s
m
and, t be
o
pe f r d on lnd' ( . , t bu l a s p) a e t o a tnu t d t i k a miat
ro me
a ' eg. o id hi , r o te a e o nvo e d r ly
j rs cin.Se Sl c e v Ro Ca i e n Cr s s Lt ,5 9 F.d 251 2 (t Ci.
u idito e av h v . yal rbb a uie, d. 5 3
, 55 4h r
2 09 ( u igPe pl 'Fer Co o sonv Be r ,61U. 3 40 ( 8 );T rot
0 ) q otn o es ry . fBo t . es
S. 93, 2 1 57 ) he i
v Ba Drlig Cor ,78 F. 5 ,5 ( t Ci.1 8 ( ii g 1Be d c o Ad iat
. y iln
p. 3 2d 27 38 5 h r 9 6) c tn
ne i t n m r l
y
j 1 3(t e 1 5 )
8 7 h d. 98 ) .
6
Tur ng t t i t nt m ater Pl ntf Ca ni l ar s t t A gr e i a
ni o he ns a
t , ai i f r va gue hat he
eem nt s
m a ii e conta , beca e i concer t sa es of s e excur i tcke s t Pl ntf
rtm
r ct
us t
ns he l
hor
s on i t o ai if
Ca ni ' pas e s,who woul not ha t opporuniy t pur se t e tcke s or
r vals s nger
d
ve he
t t o cha hes i t
pa t i t i t e s r e uri nsb f rt i pa s geo Pli ifCani lss p. P1'
ri pa e n h ho e xc so ut o her s a n antf r va ' hi ( .s
c
Rep. a 3 4) I r s ns ,Dee da Avima agu st tat g t pupo eofte
s , t - . n epo e fn nt o r r e ha lhou h he r s
h
Agr m e i f Pl ntf Car valt s ltcke s f Shor Excur i t is gue t a
ee nt s or ai if ni o el i t or
e
sons o t
s s nd
f D ef ntAvi ar t a r nge and pr de s
or
enda
om
o ra
ovi uch Shor Excur i ,t of e i of
e
s ons he f rng
s h s e e ur ons i a m e e c
uc hor xc si
s
r onve e e,a not es enta t t pas enger ta
ni nc nd
s i l o he s
s' r vel
onPl itf Ca ni lss ps ( E' Re y, t3 . r s vet sis e t Co t o kst
an if r va ' hi . De s pl a ) To e ol hi s u , he ur l o o
t A gr m e ,whi h i atac t t Am e
he
ee nt
c s t hed o he
nded Com pl i .
ant
The A gr m e a is i a conta t pe m i D ef ntAvi ar a pr der of
ee nt t s ue s
r ct o r t enda
om , ovi
l nd- e exc s ons a pors ofcal, t s l s e excur i t t pa e r of
a bas d
ur i
t
t- - l o el hor
s ons o he ss nge s
Pl i if Car val The A gr m entw as execut by t V . of Oper i on be f of
a ntf
ni .
ee
ed
he P.
atons
hal
Def
endantA vi ar and by t V . of Cr s Ent t nm entand Pr am m i a t
om
he P.
uie erai
ogr
ng nd he
D iec or of Tour Ope a i on b haf o Pli tf Ca ni a . ( r e nt a 4 .Th
r t
r tons
e l f an if r v l Ag e me , t ) e
s rvi pr de pur ua t t Agr m e do notocc on t c ui s p a do not
e ces ovi d s nt o he
ee nt
ur
he r se hi nd
p sc ly a f c t c uie s p ( g. a r par.Fu t r t Ag e me td e no p po t
hy ia l fe t he r s hi e. , e i) rhe , he r e n o s t ur r
t i ur or guar ee t s et of t pa se s of t cr s s p whie aboa d t
o ns e
ant he af y
he s nger
he uie hi
l
r he
cr s s p.Upon car ulconsde a i oft t m s a c extoft A gr m e and t
ui e hi
ef
i r ton he er nd ont
he
ee nt
he
r evant a hort t Cour Gnds t t t A gr m ent be w ee Pl ntf Ca ni l a
el
ut iy, he
t
ha he
ee
t n ai if r va nd
D ef nda A vi ar i l ng t i
e nt
om , nc udi he ndem nii ton c a e c ai t ei i m er y
fca i l us ont ned her n, s
el
7
i de alt t m a ii e a i t of Pl ntf Car val ie. t ca
nci nt o he rtm ctviy
ai if ni , . , he niage of pas e
s nger .
s
A cc di y,t Cour tndst tt A gr m e doe notqualf as a m a ii e cont a
or ngl he
ts
ha he
ee nt s
iy
rtm
r ct
t i ok a miat s j c matr urs ito u r28U. C.j1 33.
o nv e d rly ube t te j idcin nde
S.
3
C.Compl t Di si I Lac ng
e e ver t s
y
ki
Pli ifCani lsrmann a sre g o nd f rs b e tmatrj rs ito i
antf r va' e iig setd r u o u j c te u idcin s
dv riy. U. C.j 1 32(00 ( rn igf d r lc u t o i na j idito ov rc s s
iest 28 S.
3 2 5) ga tn e ea o rs rgi lurs cin e a e
whe et a o nti c nto ry i o r$ 0 00 a t pa te a e di r e .Cou t
r he m u n o r ve s s ve 75,00. nd he ri s r ve s )
rs
ha l ng r q r d c mplt di r iy t i vo j1 32.S e Swe tPe Marne Lt v
ve o e uie o ee ve st o n ke 3 e
e a
i , d. .
APJ M a i ,I c ,41 F. 1 2,1 ( 1h Ci.20 ) Fo pu os s o d tr i ng
rne n . 1 3d 24 247 1 t r 05 . r m e f e em ni
di s t (a cor aton s lbe deem ed t be a cii n ofa St e by w hi h i hasbeen
ver iy, $ por i hal
o
tze
ny at
c t
ic mortd a d oft Stt wheei h sisp i i lpl e o busne s' j 1 3 c ()
n o ae n
he ae r t a t rncpa ac f i s. 3 2()1
'
( 00 )
2 5.
W ih t i t ntM oton t Di m is D ef
t he ns a
i o s s , endant Avi a ar
om r gues t di st i
hat ver iy s
l ki becaus bot Pl ntf Cam i and Def nda A vi ar a e ale cor a i
ac ng,
e h ai if
val
e nt om
r i n por tons
u de j 1 2()2) I s p r oft sagu n,De e a tAvi ra s rst tPli if
n r 33 a( .n u po t hi r me t fnd n oma se t ha antf
Ca ni lsd l ii e hi a boh aFlrd c r r to a af r i n c m o a in (n t i
r va ' ua ctz ns p s t
o i a o po a i n nd o e g o r to i h s
c s ,a Pa ma a c r r to )ne t s c e e d v r iy whe e t e o posng pa t i
ae
na nin o po ai n gae omplt i e st
r h p i ry s
as a f egn c r a in (n t s c s ,a M e c n c po ai n) Se ge e al V a v
lo or i o por to i hi a e
xia or r to . e n r l ak .
y
Emb ae - e a Br sl ia De Ae o tc ,SA. 30 F.Su p.2 1 33 1 3 ( D.
r rEmpr s a ier
r nau ia . , 3
p d 3 , 33 S.
Fl .20 )(çompl t dve st i lc n b c u e o Pli ifa d o De e nta e
a 03 t
c e e i riy s a kig e a s ne antf n ne fnda r
boh a in f rdie st p pos s'.
t le s o v r iy ur e '
)
8
I rs
n e pons Pl ntf Car va a gues t t alhough bot Pa tes ar f ei
e, ai if
ni l r
ha t
h ri
e or gn
cor a i ,Pl ntf Car vals conc r sat a a Fl i com or i due t is
por tons ai if ni '
ur ent t us s
orda
aton,
o t
p i i lplc o busne s i s fce t i kedi riyj rs cin.I s ppo tofis
rncpa a e f i s, s ufiint o nvo vest u idito n u r t
a gum ent Pl ntf Ca ni ur t Cour t r a unpubls
r
, ai if r val ges he
t o ead n
i hed3 El ve h Ci ui
e nt rc t
o i o Crs v Ca nialCop. 41 Fe App' 1 7,2 ( 1h Ci.201 ,f t
pnin, it . r v
r , 0 d.
x 9 00 1 t r 0) or he
pr
oposton t tPl ntf Car vali a ways a c tze ofFl i f pum os ofdi st
ii ha ai i f ni s l
ii n
orda or
es
ver iy.
( s ,a 4 .The Co tha r a t Crs o ni a fnd t a whie is hol ng i
Re p. t )
ur s e d he it pi on, nd i s h t l t di s
a i e t t i t m ater is ulina e concl i t t Ca ni i a Fl i
pplcabl o he ns ant
t , t ti t
uson, ha
r val s
orda
c por ton,i lm ied t t tf t oft tcas
or a i s i t o ha ac s ha e.
I Crit t El
n
s , he event Cicui anal d w het di st e s s be ween a
h r t
yze
her ver iy xi t t
n
i v d lpa t who i a ctz n ofa Stt a a f e g c r or ton (n t tc s ,as
ndii ua ry
s ii e
ae nd or i n o p a i i ha a e lo
Cani l, t isalge prn i l a eofbusne si t s meStt 41 Fe App' a
r va) wih t le d icpa pl c
i s n he a
ae. 0 d. x t
200.Uli a el t CrstCour hel t bec e a cor aton di a cii f di r iy
tm t y, he i
t d hat aus
por i çs tzen or ve st
j id ci n pu pos so t c nty whe e i i c re e a oft sa e whe e i ha is
urs ito r e f he ou r
r t s ha tr d nd he tt
r t st
prnci pl e of bus nes ,'compl t di st was l ki wher bot t i vi
i pal ac
i s'
e e ver iy
ac ng
e h he ndi dual
pl ntf and t f ei c por i wer cii
ai if
he or gn or aton
e tzens oft s m e St e.1 at200-01.Under
he a
at d.
t r i
he atonalofCrst di r iy lke s w oul be l ng w he e,as i t i t ntm a tr a
i , ve st i wi e
d
acki
r
n he ns a
te ,
cor a i w ih dua f ei and St t cii hi s anot f e gn cor aton.See
por ton t
l or gn
a e tzens p ues
her or i
por i
alo,e. ,Sl
s g. avchev,559 F. a 251
3d t .
3ç publs d o ni a enotc i r bi ngpr ce nt butt y ma be ct d a
i
un ihe pi ons r
onsde ed ndi
e de ,
he
y
ie s
pe s svea hort ' 11 h Ci. 36r ua i ut iy.' t r R. 2.
H e e t Cour fnds t tbas on t f t aleged i t Am ended Com pl nt
r , he
ti
ha
ed
he ac s l
n he
ai ,
Pl ntf Car va c i
ai i f
ni l ontnues t be bot a cii n of Fl i as w el as a f ei
o
h
tze
orda,
l
or gn
c m o a in.j 1 3 c ( ) Ac o dngl upo c nsde ai n ofPli tf Cani lssaus
o r to
3 2( ) 1 . c r i y, n o i r to
a n if r va ' tt
a f ei cor a i a D ef nda A vi a ' s a usasa f ei c por ton,t Cour
s or gn por ton nd
e nt om r s t t
or gn or a i he
t
fndst tcom pl e di r iy i l ki
i ha
et ve st s ac ng.
1 1 CONCLUSI
1.
ON
A cc di y,upon cons der i of t pl adi and bei dul a s i i
or ngl
i aton
he e ngs
ng y dvi ed, t s
her OR DERED,A DJUD G ED ,and DECR EED asf l s
eby
olow ;
1.
D ef nda Ope a a Avi ar S. .de C. .S M oton t D im i s f Lac
e nt
r dor
om
A
V '
i o s s or k
o Su jc M atr J rs ci ( #3 be a t sme i he e y,
f b e t te u iditon DE 8) , nd he a s rb
G R AN TED .
The a ve sye a to i he e y DI I
bo -t ld c in s r b SM SSED wiho pr j c t r t ut e udi e o e
fl i ac r wihpr pe j rs ito
ie n ou t t o r u id ci n.
The Cl k i diect t C LO SE t scas
er s r ed o
hi
e.
4.
A 1 pendi m otons a e her by DENI asm oot
l
ng
i
r
e
ED
D ON E AN D OR D ERED i Cham ber a t J m e La e Ki Fede alJ tc
n
s t he a s wr nce ng
r usi e
Buidi a Unie Stt Courhous M i mi Fl i ,t s 8t da ofAugus,201
l ng nd td aes
t e, a , orda hi h y
t
2.
z J
'
ES LAW REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STA TES D I U CT J
STI
SOU THERN DI
STRI OF F
CT
1
0
GE
DA
CC:
Co efo Pl i W
uns l r ant
C ur i Jay M as
ts
e
M as Lar ,Eve s e PA
e, a
r ol
SBS Tow e
r
2601 Sout Ba hor Drve
h ys e i
Suie 800
t
M i i FL 331
am ,
33
3053773770
Fax:305- 0080
377-
Emal c s @mltilc m
i: ma e era.o
R i d G r fens e n
char
eif t i
M as La a Eve s e,P. .
e r
r ol A
SB S Tower
2601 S.Ba hor D rve
ys e i
Suie 800
t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
33
3053773770
Fa 305x:
3770080
Emalrr ifnsen@ mltil o
i:g efe ti
era. m
c
Cou e fo De nd s
ns l r fe ant
R yan Charl M e
es ade
Qunt ios Preo W o & Bo e , A.
i ar , it , od
y r P.
9300 S.Dadelnd Bl
a
vd
4t Fl
h oor
M i m i FL 331
a ,
56
30567011
01
Fa 30567011
x:
61
Emalr a e q wblw.o
i:me d @ p a c m
V al i Shea
er e
Se
dgwi LLP
ck
2400 E Com m er alBoul va d
ci
e r
Suie 11
t 00
For Laude dal ,FL 33308
t
r e
9549582500
11
Fa 958- 1
x:
25 3
EmalVaei.he @ sdg c a c m
i: lres a e wiklw.o
Jos
eph K .Pow ers
Sedgw i k,LLP
c
1 Br Stee
25 oad r t
New Y or N Y 1
k,
0004
Emalj e h. we s sdg c a c m
i:osp po r@ e wiklw.o
1
2
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?