Cortina v. F.A.D. Detective & Security Services, Inc. et al

Filing 68

ORDER Granting 65 Motion for Summary Judgment. Signed by Senior Judge James Lawrence King on 5/18/2012. (jw)

U NI
TED STATES D I
STR I C O URT
CT
SO UTH ER N DISTRICT O F FLO RI
DA
M I I DI
AM
VISI N
O
CA SE N O .11 20732- V - l G
C1 K N
H ECTOR CORTI A ,
N

Pl ntf,
ai if

F. . . ETECTI &
AD D
VE
SECURI SERVI
TY
CES,I C.
N
a FM NCI
nd
SCO A LTAM I N O,
M
Def
endant
s.
/
O RD ER G M NTING SU M M AR Y JUD G M ENT
I FAV OR OF D EFEND ANTS
N

TH IS M ATTER i bef et Cour upon Def nda s'Re
s or he
t
e nt
newed M oton t D im i s
i o s s

f r c of b e t atrJ idito o ,nteAlen tveM oto f rS
o La k Su jc M te urs cin ri h tr ai , in o ummayJ me t
r udg n
( #65 , e Ap i 2 201 a n ifr s nd d( #6 o M a 1 , 2. TheCou t
DE ) ûl d rl 7, 2.Pli tf e po e DE 7) n y 3 201
r
i t r or f l bref d i t sm at r Upon ca ef consder ton oft uncont t f t
s he ef e uly i e n hi te .
r ul
i ai
he
es ed ac s
i t r cor a t ar ent se f t i t Pari bref ,t Cour tndst ti m us
n he e d nd he gum s t orh n he tes' i s he
ts
ha t
t

g a ts
rn ummayj gme ti fvo ofDefnd ns
r ud n n a r
e a t.
1 Backgr
.
ound

Thi i a a to b ou ht nde t FarLa rStnd r sAc , U. C. 201 e . e
s s n c in r g u r he i bo a a d t29 S. j , ts q.

($
$
FLSA' . Pli ifHe tr Cori ts 4na' a lge fnda s f ie t pa h m
' antf co
)
t l i ' le sDe e nt ald o y i
na co1 l
ove tm ew age and fr hi i r t laton f hi c
ri
s
ied m n e a i i or s ompl ni aboutD ef nda s'a i
ai ng
e nt ctons.

Prort hi t r i ton, ai ifw or asaSec iyG ua d f ef nt A . . e ectve
i o s e m na i pl ntf
ked
urt
r orD enda F. D D t i

& Se u i Se vc s I .(T. D.) a c mo a in t tpr vi s s c iy c ula y
c rt r ie , nc 1 A. ' , o r to ha o de e urt ons t nc
y
'
s r ces prva e det tves and s curt guar f c t er i M i iDade Count
e vi , i t
ec i ,
e iy
ds or usom s n am y,
Fl i D ef ntFr nci o A la iano, heDiec orofF. . .i a e pl
orda. enda
a sc t m r t
r t
A D , s n m oyerw ihi t
t n he

m ea ng oft FLSA .Pl ntf w asas i
ni
he
ai if
sgned t guar gr y s or ,i udi Pr i e
o
d ocer t es ncl ng esdent
Supe m a ke a LaM i Supe m a ketlI Febr r 2011 Pl ntf H ec orCori tl s t
r r t nd
a
r r . n
ua y
, ai if t
tna ied ui
i t El ve h J c alCicui Cour i a f M i m iDade Count Fl i s eki
n he e nt udi i
r t
t n nd or a y, or da, e ng
da age f D e e
m s or f ndant aleged vi a i oft overi e and r ala i pr s onsoft
s' l
ol tons he
tm
et iton ovii
he

FLS Z De e a t r mo dt ea ov -t l da to t t sCou t M a c 3, 1 (
A. f nd n s e ve h b e sy e ci n o hi
r on r h 201 . DE
O nM a c 1 2011, ai i ffl d a Am e
r h 6,
Pl ntf ie n
nded Compl nt t i udeas ond pl ntf
ai ,o ncl
ec
ai if
w ho ha snce be s ve ed f om t a
si
en e r r he bove- t e ac i
s yl d ton.

l taly, e
nii l Def ndant deni t tt yoweda oft $42, 50s
s ed ha he
ny he
187. oughtbyPl ntf
ai if
i overi e com pens ton,and deni t tt y t r i t Pl ntf f r t i or r ons
n
tm
ai
ed ha he e m na ed ai if or e alat y eas .

( .DE #7; o n Pr ti l i DE /4 .Dic ve yc o e o ve r23, 01 , n he
Ans,
J i t era Stp, / 0) s o r l s d nNo mbe 2 1 a dt
moi n pr ci epe i d e e No mbe 28, 01 .( he uln Or r DE #1 )
to a tc ro nd d ve r 2 1 Sc d ig de ,
7.
The on Fe uar 1 201 Def nt m oved t dim i st a
n,
br y 7, 2, enda s
o s s he bove- t ed ac i
syl
ton
upon t
ender of f lpa ent adm itng t t D ef nda s' r ds r
ul ym ,
ti ha
e nt ecor eveal t t Pl ntf
ed ha ai if

l ai ifr e st agrocer sor he guar asçM er
pl ntf ef r o
yt e
ded t cado La Ni ' Def
na.' endant ,however not
s
, e
t tt cor e name i (LaM i Supennar t'ast do nothave any cusom er by t nam e(M er
ha he r ct
s(
a
ke ,' hey
t
s he
d cado
LaN i ' The ditnc i i i atri t t sCour' anal s
na.'
si ton s mm e al o hi
ts ysi.

z an ifsCo antc nti d t c ns 1 Cou 1al ngf lr t pa ov ri wa s
plitf' mpli o ane wo ou t: ) nt , l
egi aiu e o y e tme ge ;
a 2)Cou t1, le n r tlaor frng.
nd
n l a lgig eait y ii
2

wor e , 8.4ho sof ve t
k d205 5 ur o ri
mebewe nAug t 2 8a
t e
us z8, 00 ndDe e e 3l 200 ( f '
c mb r , 9.De s

M o.t Dimis DE # .Ala r n Af.! 8 DE / - .I s mo ng De e a t
o s s,
47, tmia o f ,
/ 4) n o vi , f nd n s
47
c dedt t owedPl ntf a addii $7, 86t s if t ove tm er e,a
once hat hey
ai if n
tonal 606. o atsy he ri at nd

t n r d as m of$1 21 7 t i l delq d td da ge . De s M o.oDimis! 1
e de e u
5, 3.3, o ncu iui ae ma s ( f ' t s s 4,

DE # ) Pli ifrj ce t tnd rda nto t ba i t ti di no a c u f rt
47 . antf ee td he e ee mou n he ss ha t d t c o nt o he
num berofoveri ehour t tPl ntf ale hew or Pl ntf s eque l twages
tm
s ha ai if l ges
ked, ai ifs ubs
nt os
,

a dat r y' f e a c ss ( ' Re p.oDe s M o.oDimis DE #51 a 3 . tma ey,
n to ne s e s nd o t .P1s s t f ' t s s ,
, t ) Uli t l
w ihoutr hi t m e is t Cour de e D ef nda s M oton t D im ison t ba i
t
eac ng he rt , he
t ni d
e nt '
i o s s
he s s
t ti was untm el fl d gi n t t dea i t fl m otons e r m or t n t o
ha t
i y ie ve hat he dlne o ie
i
xpied
e ha w
m ont pror.
hs i 3

Att Aprl5,201 c e
he i
2 al ndarcal, he Cour dicus ed w ih t Pari t e denc
lt
t s s
t he tes he vi e
t bepr s ed a ti . I s be ea entt tpl ntf i endedt oferonl hi ow n
o
e ent t ra14 t oon cam ppar ha ai if nt
o f
y s

uns
uppor e t tm ony aspr ofhi cont i t hew or i e ssoft 2, 54
t d esi
oof
s
enton hat
ked n xce
he 058.
overi ehour doc e edand adm it by Def ndant On t tbas s t Cour ,
tm
s um nt
ted
e
s. ha
i ,he
t conss ent
it

w ih isr s
t t e ponsbiiyt nar ow t i s t tr m ai i diput afe t cl eofdi cove y,
i lt o r he s ues ha e n n s e tr he os
s r
de er i t onl Pl ntf sr ala i cl m w oul pr ed t ti .The f l i da
t m ned hat y ai if et i ton ai
d oce o r al
olow ng y,
Pl ntf m oved f clr fca i a gui t D ef
ai if
or a ii ton, r ng hat endant t
s' ender a ountdi notf l
ed m
d
uly

3OnM ac 30, 2,Def nt fldas c ne ryieni lM otont Dimis (
rh 201
enda s ie e ond, al d tca
i o s s .DE
#58.Agai t Cour de edt moi ont ba i t ti wasuntmel fld.DE #60)
)
n,he
t ni he ton he ss ha t
i y e (
.
4l a ton,a t cae rc l,De e nt 'c
n ddii t he lnda a l f nda s ouns or lym ove t wihdr w on t
el a l
d o t a
he
basst thi c intha nota c
i ha s le
s
nd nnno pa hi .
t y m
3

s tsyPlitf sc amsf ru pa d o ri d ma s ( #6 .
aif an if l i o n i ve t a ge .DE 2)
me
I cons der ton of t f egoi pr dur hit y,t Cour ent ed a Or r
n
i ai
he or ng oce al sor he
t er n de

Co tn ngTra .( #6 ) n isOr rCon i ui Tra ,heCo t a eldt etils t
n i ui i l DE 4 .I t de
tn ng ilt
ur c nc le h ra e
f Aprl10,201 a gave Pari an addii
or
i
2 nd
tes
tonalt ry da di w hi t fl a a a1
hit ys çn
ch o ie ny nd l

mo inst yma wiht fl die tda t s is s' ( # 4, t3 .Ast Cou t ou
to he y s o ie r ce t he e s ue . DE 6 a )
'
he r f nd
CountIha be r ol a t Pr Tralconf r
d en es ved t he e- i
e ence,t Cour e
he
t xpect d pari t tl
e
tes o s e

s mmayj g n b if o termani rtlai cam.Dee da sfldt i tnt
u r ud me t re s n h e i ng eaiton li
fn nt ie he nsa
Re we M oint Dimisf rLa kofSu j c M atrJ rs ci o,i teAlen tve
ne d to o s s o c
be t te u iditon r n h tr ai ,
M o i f rS
ton o umma yl g e o
r ud m nt nAprl 201 (
i27, 2. DE#65 . f nd n s M o i n, we r
) De e a t ' to ho ve ,

d dn a dr s t r t la in ca m.Pli iff ie t mo tmey f rs
i ot d e s he ea ito li antf a ld o ve i l o umma yj dg n
r u me t
on any is
s ues.
I .LegalSt
I
andard

Su r j g nti a pr pra e wh r t e pl a ngsa s p tng mae il
mmay ud me s p o it e e h e di nd u pori
tras
es a i h t tt r i no genui i s ast any m a eralf a t t m ovi pary i
t bls ha he e s
ne s ue o
t i act nd hat he
ng t s

e tte t u me ta amatroflw.Se FED. CI P. 6; l e Cor v Car t, 77
nild oj dg n s te a
e
R. V. 5 Ceotx p. . tet4

U. 31 3 ( 98 ) t oft p i i l mos so t s mmayj g n r l i t
S. 7, 22 1 6 .s
one he rncpa pu e f he u r ud me t ue s o
i ol e a dipos of f ualy uns
s at nd s e
act l
uppored c ai s or def e ' Cel e 477 U . at
t lm
ens s.' otx,
S.
323-24.

Them ovi pa t bea st bur n ofpoi i t t pa toft r d t s st
ng ry r he de
ntng o he r he ecor hat how he
a enc ofage nei s ofm a eralf .SeeAdikesv.S. . e & Co. 398U . 1
bs e
nui s ue
t i act
c
H Kr ss
,
S. 44,

4

1 7( 97 ) Ale v T onFo ds I c.1 F.d6 6 ( 1hCi. 9 ) On et mo n
5 1 0 ; ln . ys
o , n , 21 3 42, 46 1 t r 1 97 . c he vi g
pa t es a i he t a e of a genui isue ofm at ralf t t bur n s fs t t
ry t bls s he bs nce
ne s
e i ac , he de hit o he

nonm ovi
ngparyt go beyond t pl ngsa des gna eûs fc f t s i t tt e
t o
he eadi nd i t lpecii ac s how ng ha her
otx,
S.
ee s
, nc. t i
i a ge ne i s f t i .' Cel e 477 U . at 324;s alo Chanel I v,Ialan
s
nui s ue or ral'

Acie a o a.l c, 31F.d 1 2 1 ( 1hCi.1 1 (ol ngt tt no mo ng
tv we r fFl , n .9 2 47 , 477 1 t r 99 ) h di ha he n vi
parym us tcom e f ar w ih s gnii , oba i e de de onsr tng t exi t e
t
ti
om d t i fcant pr tve vi nce m
ta i he senc

ofatibl is eoff c .)
ra e s u
a t' .
'

d mmayj me ma beia prpraee e wh r tepate a reo t ba i
s
su r udg nt y n p o it v n e e h ris g e n he sc
f ct ,butdiagr about t f t i e ences t s d be dr
a s
s ee
he ac ual nf r
hat houl
awn f om t e f ct .'
r
hes a s'

Wa ro T l e Tr n p.Co,I c v M / Nan Fun 695F. 1 9 1 6 ( 1h Ci.
r ir ombkb e a s
. n. . V
g,
2d 2 4, 29 1 t r

1 3 . amoto frs mmayj g ntt c urmus ve t e de ea rs vea1
98 )On
in o u r ud me ,he o t t iw he vi nc nd e ol 1
i er
nf ences i t lghtm os f abl t t nonm ovi pa t See Ande son v.fi t
n he i
t avor e o he
ng ry.
r
bery

Lob y I .4 U. 2 25 ( 98 ) Ho ve , me es i tlaofe d n ei s po t
b nc, 77 S. 42, 5 1 6 . we r a r cn il vi e c n up r of

ten mo ngpa 'po iini i ufiin t d fa amoi frs
h on vi o s sto sns fce to ee t ton o ummayj dg n.Se
r u me t e
i a 252. I t evi nce ofer d by t nonm ovi pa y i m er y col a e or i not
d. t
f he de
f e
he
ng rt s
el
or bl
s

sg sc ntyprbai , u r j g nti prpe . e i a 2 -5
ini a l o tve s mmay ud me s o r S e d. t 49 0.
1 1 A nal i
1.
ys s

Plitf sCo a n c n anst oc un s 1 Cou t , le i f iur t pa ov ri
an if mpli t o t i w' o t : ) n 1 a lgng al e o y e t
me
wa e ; n 2 Cou l, le n r t lao yfrng. hieDe e a t ' o i na d e s so y
g s a d ) nt 1a lgig e ait r ii W l f nd n s M to d r s e nl
Count1 t Cour w ila yze bot c
, he
t l nal
h ount . Upon ca e ulcons der i oft r cor a
s
rf
i aton he e d nd

5

t pla i s teCou tfn i mus g a ts mmayj dg n i fvorofDee da t on
he e dng ,h
r ids t t rn u r u me t n a
fn ns
bot count .
h
s
a.

Count1:Recover ofO ver i e Com pens i
y
tm
aton

CountIofPl ntf Com pl ntalegesvi atonsoft FLSA ' overi epr s on.
ai ifs
ai l
ol i
he
S
tm
ovi i

Spe fc l Pl ntf c endst tt t ala
ciialy, ai if ont
ha he ot mountowed i $42, 50,pl lqui ed
s
187.
us i dat

d ma s ( mp1, #1 2, 2) Pur u n t t FLS a e o e who vi lt st
a ge . Co .DE - :1 . s a t o he A, n mpl y r
o ae he
ove tm epr s onsoft FLSA s lbe la e t t em pl
ri
ovii
he
hal
i bl o he
oyee af e ed i t am ountof
f ct n he
hi unpa d ove tm ecom pens i and i a addii
s
i
ri
aton
n n
tonale
qualam ounta lqui ed da ages
s i dat
m
.

29U. C. 21 De e a sc ndu tdaf l a c n i of A. ' pa olr c r , c
S. j 6. f nd nt o ce u l c ou tng F. D.S yr l e o ds whih
s e t t alam ountofhour w or by Cori a concl
how d he ot
s ked
tna, nd
uded t Cori i ow ed
hat tna s

$7. 86 t s tsy t overi r t r l t i F. . ' payr lr ds. Ala ia
606. o aif he
tme ae eteced n A D.S
ol ecor
tm r no

Afi vi,DE # - a !8 Li i ae da ge wo d b i t t a a un o d t
fda t
47 4, t . qu d td ma s ul rng he otl mo t we o
Cori t $15, 1 73.Def nt t r t ss t Cori who r us t pa nt
tna o
2 3.
enda s ende ed hi um o tna,
ef ed he yme
on t gr
he oundst tt t
ha he ender a ountdi nots i f Pl ntf cl m f unpa d ove tm e
ed m
d
ats y ai ifs ai or
i
ri

da a s DE /51 a 3 .
m ge .( / , t )
F. . ,s payr l acc i w a bas on uncontove ed e denc i udi
AD'
ol
ountng s
ed
r rt vi e, ncl ng
Cori s per onnel fl , une pl ent com pe a i f m s I f m s em pl e
tna'
s
ies
m oym
ns ton or , RS or ,
oye

i onnaton f m s ea ni r or , em pl
nf
i or , r ngs ec ds
oyee tm e s t , a phot opi c ks.
i
hee s nd
oc ed hec
e
ds l
AD '
ee
l
Ala r noAfi vi, / 4 a ! -7.Thes recor refectF. . .S complt payrol
tmia
fda t DE / , t 5
47-

r c r s 1 .a !1
e o d . d t 0.Cori h sno dipu e t ea c a y o De e a s r c r s
t a t s t d h c ur c f f nd nt ' e o d .
na

Furher or Cori has f ied t pr
t m e,
tna
a l o oduce any docum e s e de ng hi
nt vi nci
s

uns t it cai t thei acualy owe $42, 50 ormor i overi epay. Upon
ubsantaed l m ha s t l
d
187.
en
tm
quesi ngby t Cour a t
toni
he
t t hepr ti cal ndarc lCori scouns adm it t tCori
e-ral e
al, tna'
el
ted ha
tna

hasno doc e s not ,di i ,pa ol r ds I r ds or anyt ng ot rt n hi
um nt , es ares yr l ecor , RS ecor ,
hi
he ha s

vague r l cton, t s
ecole i
o uppor hi cl m s t t t r wer un- ecor hour wor d.
t s ai ha he e
e r ded
s
ke
Ther or F. , .s pa ol r or a e t s e e dence of Cor i s hour a
ef e, A D ' yr l ec ds r he ol vi
tna'
s nd
c
ompens i Def ndant alo fl on r d a de aied H it y ofPa e s Sum m ar
aton.
e
s s ied
ecor
t l
s or
ym nt
y

d p c igt a u ofo ri wa st bepad t Co t .( #58 5) AsDe e nt
e i tn he mo nt ve tme ge o
i o ri DE - .
na
fnda s
ha t nder t act am ountofdam ages t Cori a pr ent t Cour wih t
ve e ed he ual
o
tna nd es ed he
t t he

entr pa ol r or r atng t Cori t bur n ofpr s fst Cortnat pr t
ie yr l ec ds el i o
tna, he de
oof hit o
i o ove hat
heact l wor a addii
ualy
ked ny
tonalove tm ehour notr l t d i F. . ,spa ol r or ,
ri
s
etec e n A D ' yr l ec ds

Thi Cour e es l sat a t Aprl5, 2pr t i cal nda al t t ca e1
s
t xpr sy t ed t he
i 201 e-ral e rc l hat he s aw
i ve y cl r as t Pl ntf s bur n ofpr
s r ea
o ai if
de
oof. D e e
f ndant ha s it t com pl e
s ve ubm ted he
et
payr lr or s i t t a a ountofhour wor d by Cori I r s
ol ec ds how ng he ot l m
s ke
tna. n e pons Cor i
e, tna
m e el ofer hi own uns
r y f s s
uppored t tm ony t the w or un- ecor hour How ever
t es i
ha
ked r ded
s.
,
t ti note
ha s
nough. eM at hiaEl I
Se
sus t ec. ndus Co. ZenihRadi Cor ,475U . 574,
. v.
t
o p.
S.
586

( 98 )( di t tt e no mo ng pa t S tdo mo e t n smpl s w t tt r i
1 6 hol ng ha h n- vi ry û
mus
r ha i y ho ha he e s

smemea hy ia d bt st t maeilfcs'. s r ies mmayj gme , t
o
tp sc l ou a o he tra a t' To u vv u r ud ntCori
)
na
mus pr s n e de es wi 1 s fce t s g e me t r qu r s b s i nt aj r o
t e e t vi nc ho ng û ufi in dia r e nt o e ie u miso o u y r
a
w het r i i so on- i t one pary m us pr vai as a m a tr ofl .' l v.T
he t s
s ded hat
t
t e l
te
aw 'Alen
yson

7

Foo s I . 1 F.d 6 64 ( 1h Ci.1 97 ( otn And r on, 7 U. a 251 5 ) .
d , nc, 21 3 42, 6 1 t r 9 ) qu ig e s 47 S. t - 2 )
He e,no evi
r
dence ha been pr f r ot r t n Cori s ow n uns
s
of e ed he ha
tna'
uppored t tm ony.
t es i
The e i no r d evi
r s ecor
dence di putng Def
s i
endant r dsors i t Cori w or
s' ecor
how ng hat tna
ked

i e essoft 2, 54 ove tm ehour doc ent by Def
n xc
he 058.
ri
s um ed
endant Ther or t Cour
s.
ef e, he
t

fndsPl ntf f l t m e hi bur ofpr on Count1
i
ai if ais o et s den
oof
.
b.

Countl R e alaton
I: t i i

The e i a dearh ofevi nce on t r d r r ng Pl ntf s r t i i cl m .
r s
t
de
he ecor ega di
ai if e alaton ai
N eiherPl ntf nor Def
t
ai i f
endant bref t Cour on a i s r at d t t r alaton
s i ed he
t
ny s ues el e o he et i i
c ai .Ne rt es ,t Cour fnds i i appr i e t addr st r t i i cl m i t s
lm
ve hel s he
ti
ts
oprat o
es he e alaton ai n hi

Or e .Al g Dee a t ddno mo f s mmayj g n onPlitf rtlain
d r t h fnd ns i t ve or u r ud me t
hou
anifs eaito
cl m ,di ti c t a e wi y a
ai
srct our s r
del cknow l
edged t pos es t poy r t e e s n a y
o
s s he ve o nt r ur nA r

j dg n ss as nt s lnga t l sn pa t wa onn tc t ts ha t c mef r r
u me t u po e, o o s he o i g ry s o i e ha he d o o o wa d
w ih a1 of he e denc Ce ot x,477 U . a 326. Pl ntf onl e denc on t
t 1
r vi e. l e
S. t
ai ifs y vi e
he
r t i i c ai cons s sofPl i ifsSwor St t m e a Pl ntf Suppl ent Sw or
e alaton l m
it
antf
n a e nt nd ai ifs
em al
n
D ec a aton, nw hi Pl i ifsat t hew asfr d bec ehe c
lr i i
ch antf t es hat
ie
aus
ompl nedt D ef nda s
ai o
e nt

t ti wa ilga f rt m no t p yhi o ri .( #6 3, t2, .
ha t s le l o he t o a m ve tme DE 7- a 4)
SfheFLSA pr e si vi sf om r t i i f as e tng t rrght unde t
s'
ot ct ndi dual r
e alaton or s r i hei i s
r he

s a ut by m aki i unl w f f a e pl r $o di c ge or i any ot m anne
tt e
ng t a ul or n m oye t s har
n
her
r
dicrm i t a ns any empl e beca e s h e pl
s i na e gai t
oye
us uc m oyee has tl any com pl nt or
s ed
ai

i tt ed orca ed t be i tt ed a pr edi unde orr l t t t s c pt r orha
ns iut
us o
ns iut ny oce ng
r e a ed o hi ha e ,
s

8

t s ii or i aboutt t tf i a s h pr eedi ... ' Wi e v. We er Fl da
e tfed
s
o es iy n ny uc oc ng. ' ' gly
st n ori

Li ig I c ,20 K 331 31 a * ( . Fl De 7,20 )( uo i 29 U. C.j
ghtn n . 05
2 9, t 4 M D. a. c.
05 q tng
S.

21 ( )3).$ pr ver t la inun r heFLSA, pl itf mus s w t t( )s e ga e
5 a ( ) $ o ea ito de t
To
a an if t ho ha : 1 he n g d
i a tvi pr e td und rt e a t ( )s s e ue ty s f r d a ve s a to b t
n c i t otc e
y
e h c ; 2 he ubs q n l ufe e d r e c in y he

e o r a ( ac us lc ne tone se b t e t ee oy espr t c e a t t a d
mplye ; nd 3) a a on c i xit d ewe n h mpl e ' o e td ci y n
vi

t a v ree o me a ton.ff(ii Wolv Coc -coaCo.200F.d1 7,1 42 43
he d e s mply nt ci ' t ctng f . a l ,
'
3 33 3 ( 1h Ci. 0
1 t r 200 :.

Plitf fist ma aprmaf i c s f r tlai
anif al o ke i ace a e or eaiton.Att s
he ummayj dg n
r u me t
sage,Cor i nee m or t pr cut hi r t iton cl i t a s gned s a em e s yi
t
tna ds
e o ose e s e ala i
a m han i
t t nt a ng
he wastr i r t i i f com pl i sa
s ed n e alaton or
ant boutl k ofove tm epa Sone oft prnci
ac
ri
y. û
he i pal

p posso tes
ur e f h ummayj gme r ei t iolt a ds eoffcual uns ppo td
r ud nt ul s o s ae nd ipos a t l
y u re
cl m sordef ns .' Cel ex Cor , U . a 323-24.A r e oft r d s st t
ai
e es'
ot
p. 477 S. t
evi w
he ecor how ha
Pl ntf sr ala i c ai i aprm eexa pl ofaf t ly uns
ai if et i ton l m s i
m e
ac ua l
uppor e cl m t tc
t d ai ha annot

s vvet s
ur i he ummayj g nttg TheCo r fn t t antf' fiu et od e a r
r ud me sa e.
u tidsha Pli ifs alr opr uc , he
ove oneyea ofdi cove y,any evi nce ofr t it y frng i f alt Pl ntf scl i sof
r
r
s
r
de
e ala or i i s at o ai i f a m
r t i ton.
e ala i

I .Concl i
V
uson

A c di y,upon a r vi w oft r cor a t Courtbei ot wie advi ed,i
cor ngl
e e
he e d nd he
ng her s
s t
i her
s eby
OR DERED , DJUD GED and DECR EED a f l s
A
s olow :

9

De e a s M o i nf S
f nd nt ' to or umma yJ dg n ( #6 i he e yGRANTED.
r u me t DE 5) s r b

Th s c s i DI M I
i a e s S SSED wih pr j c . J rs c in i r s nrd f r a
t e udi e u idito s e e e o
de e m i ton off s a coss.
t r na i
ee nd t

The Cl r s lCL O SE t scas
e k hal
hi e.
A l ot rpendi m otonsa e DENI as m oot
1 he
ng
i
r
ED
.

Fi l ud me twilb e t r dby s pa aeo d ro t Co t
na j g n l e n e e
e r t r e f he ur.
DO N E AN D OR DERED i cha be satt Ja esLawr nceK i Feder Jus i e
n m r
he m
e
ng
al tc

Buidi and Unied St t Courhous M i i Fl i t s 18t da ofM a 201
l ng
t
a es
t e, am , orda, hi h y
y, 2,

J

ES LA W REN CE K I G
N
I
TED STA TES D I
STRI J
CT
SOUTHERN D I
STRI O F FL
CT

Co efo Pli W
uns l r ant
Law r
enceJos M c ui s
eph G nne s
1 SW 37t A ve
627
h
Suie 100
t
M i m i FL 331
a ,
45
305- 557
448Fa 305x:
4489559

Emallmpaa
i:j lw@nez r c m
te o.o
Coun e fo De nd
s l r fe ant
Tom John M anos
Tom JM a PA
nos
OneBrc lSquar 9t Fl
ikel
e h oor
801Brckel Ave
i l
nue
M i i FL 331
am ,
31
305- - 00
341 31

GE
I A
D

Fax:305- - 02
341 31

EmalTma s tmlwfr c
i: no @ j a im.om

11